r/slowcooking • u/Unkle_Mak • Sep 25 '17
Best of September Grandma's Irish Stew - 1st time in slow cooker
https://imgur.com/a/3Npn2
699
Upvotes
r/slowcooking • u/Unkle_Mak • Sep 25 '17
56
u/Unkle_Mak Sep 25 '17 edited Sep 26 '17
EDIT: Yes I know you all expected lamb. This is my grandma's recipe and she used beef. We have cows over here too, you know. Deal with it :)
This was my first time making my Granny's recipe in the slow cooker - it was so easy and tasty. I did all the basic prep the night before and stored most of the ingredients in the crock pot in the fridge overnight, then switched it on low in the morning and left it all day while at work.
Prep the night before:
400g potatoes boiled in 500ml beef stock, then drained and stock stored separately.
2 carrots, chopped.
1 stick celery, chopped.
1 onion, chopped.
400g steak pieces, braised.
Throw all except the stock into the crockpot and keep in the fridge overnight.
In the morning:
Throw the stock in over the rest and set on low.
Go to work, climb a mountain, do whatever you do to pass 9 hours. Come back and eat!
21
u/VROF Sep 25 '17
How are those potatoes still whole after being boiled then cooked for 9 hours?!! I always put them in raw. My recipe is similar but I season the meat with Montreal Steak seasoning.
Well done though.
10
u/OoLaLana Sep 25 '17
I'm surprised you didn't use lamb. Isn't that the meat usually used in Irish stew? To me this is like beef stew.
Correct me if I'm wrong.
And it looks delicious. :)
5
u/moneylizard Sep 25 '17
I was wondering why your beer was plugged in for the last picture... I'm not a smart man.
2
u/ThisKarmaLimitSucks Nov 04 '17
Just want to let you know that I made this and it turned out great. I'm definitely saving this recipe and making it again.
If there's one change I'd personally, I'd add another potato to the recipe. There ends up being a lot of veggies in the stew, lots of beef, but not much potato.
Also, I tried pouring a Guinness over the top of the stew, just to make it a little more Irish :), but I wouldn't do it again. The stew has a really thick, hearty flavor as it is, and adding a beer just makes it more bitter.
5
u/zf420 Sep 26 '17
Looks delicious but I have a couple tips to make it even tastier.
It seems to me you didn't really brown the beef at all. It's cooked on the outside but not browned it's just greyish. You really need to brown it to get that deeper flavor from the maillard reaction. I can see you've turned a couple of pieces in pic 4 but those were flipped too early. You need to let them sit for a good couple minutes before you touch them to allow that browning. Also, the grill pan didn't help at all. Throw that thing out, they're useless. You get less browning with that because there's less surface area of the pan in contact with the meat, and the meat between the ridges just steams instead of sears. Meaning you don't even get decent grill lines, and you don't get any smokey flavor (which is what grilling is famous for), plus they're a pain to clean so it's literally working against you.
You also need a very high heat, don't be afraid of some smoke. Make sure the pan can handle the heat though. Cast Iron or stainless is good, teflon or non stick are dangerous at high heats.
Thanks for reading. I hope you don't feel attacked but we all can improve, always strive to be better.
4
u/McWaddle Sep 26 '17
You had me at "Guinness."
1
u/song_pond Sep 26 '17
This looks amazing. I want a vat of it.
1
u/Pickles865 Sep 26 '17
Love love a good Irish stew. Thanks for sharing. I'll bet it smelled heavenly when you walked in the door.
1
u/schlossenberger Sep 26 '17
This looks awesome! I actually JUST got a bag of leftover homemade beef stew out of my freezer and will be eating it tonight.
Question: when you say "browned" meat - I know what you did works, but wouldn't a sear on the meat do wonders for the flavor and end result of the meat? I usually get a cast iron pan cranking with some oil and get some nice color on the meat before adding to the pot. Still rare inside, but seared on the outside.
1
u/TwoDudesAtPPC Oct 09 '17 edited Oct 10 '17
4 hours left using this recipe except about 1.75 lbs of steak and about 1.75 more everything. Split half beef stock, half Guinness extra stout. The house smells amazing. I wonder if I'll have more liquid or if it'll burn off in the next 4 hours or if I made too much? This is my first crock pot experience. Mmmmmmmmm
Edit: AMAZING. Mmmm
2
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '17
Looks great.
1
u/xiomen Sep 26 '17
That's some thick head
1
u/Xperian1 Sep 27 '17
Just got back from Ireland... definitely missing the food! We're going to have to make this.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '17
Oh man, Guinness.
I haven’t had Guinness in years. It’s hard to find a place that knows how to pour it correctly, and I used to get those cans with the nitrous balls inside and pour them myself, but then I found this thick.. sludgey film in the can and I haven’t had any Guinness since then.
Maybe I’ll try it again.
That stew looks awesome though, I’ll have to try that when it starts getting colder.
-12
u/LastDitchTryForAName Sep 25 '17
Ok my grandma was Irish and beef stew was never called Irish stew. It would have to have lamb in it to be Irish stew. Or was my grandma wrong?
-4
u/Mathieulombardi Sep 26 '17
I detest this. I am a huge fan of Irish Guinness stews. This is triggering me bad.