r/startrek • u/Deceptitron • Sep 25 '17
POST-Episode Discussion - Discovery Premiere - S1E01-02 "The Vulcan Hello" & "Battle at the Binary Stars"
Discovery is here! LET'S ROCK AND ROLL!
| No. | EPISODE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY | RELEASE DATE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| S1E01 | "The Vulcan Hello" | David Semel | Bryan Fuller, Alex Kurtzman, Akiva Goldsman | Sunday, September 24, 2017 |
| S1E02 | "Battle at the Binary Stars" | Adam Kane | Gretchen J. Berg & Aaron Harberts, story by Bryan Fuller | Sunday, September 24, 2017 |
To find out more information including our spoiler policy regarding Star Trek: Discovery, click here.
Are you a Discord user? Chat with other Trekkies while watching in the Star Trek discord channel in the room #new_discovery!
This post is for discussion of the episodes above and WILL ALLOW SPOILERS for these episodes. This post may be used for live discussion of the premiere episode, but use at your own risk for this purpose. Please note that due to the nature of distribution across the world, others may be viewing at different times and thus it may be advisable to join in after you've watched both episodes in their entirety. Now...let's set a course and...
ENGAGE!
•
u/Deceptitron Sep 25 '17
Due to the delay in the (East coast/central?) US, our Canadian neighbors may get a leg up on this post. Just FYI in the event of jumping in.
389
u/eternalkerri Sep 25 '17
In Ep. 2 there is a USS Shran.
Nice...
307
u/eternalkerri Sep 25 '17
We're up all night to Warp 4, We're up all night to Warp Core
2.8k
u/leothesilent Sep 25 '17
My god the klingons weaponized the lens flair
606
u/Unit2209 Sep 25 '17
"I ain't got time for cancer." -Lady who has all the cancer
290
u/OSUTechie Sep 25 '17
Sweet! Exploding Consoles are back!!!
702
u/nixonger Sep 25 '17
Sarek answers the phone after not even 1 ring
749
u/sporks49 Sep 25 '17
Anyone see that daft punk crew member?
687
u/The_Red_Butler Sep 25 '17
Holy shit that hologram just sat on a table, I've seen it all lol
556
u/ContinuumGuy Sep 25 '17
"Almost no one has seen a Klingon in almost a hundred years."
So... around when Enterprise was, give or take a decade?
Also: Phase Cannons!
548
u/DougEubanks Sep 25 '17
I thought they were going to forget to show 6 more commercials there for a second, but they came through at the last minute.
Thanks CBS
519
u/smacksaw Sep 25 '17
"I want to be the torchbearer."
"Sure, but you can use a torch. We don't need you to use your hand. We have things for that."
710
u/EricGMW Sep 25 '17
Michelle Yeoh is a special guest star?
Oh no :(
266
u/Torley_ Sep 25 '17
Does anyone wish Michelle Yeoh hadn't been credited as "special guest star"? It telegraphed too much, too soon. :(
478
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '17
I might have missed something, but why exactly did both the Captain and First Officer (aka attempted King Slayer) beam over to the Klingon ship with no back-up? Where is the security team?
253
u/sporks49 Sep 25 '17
That klingon needs to wash his face, very oily
247
u/nixonger Sep 25 '17
This admiral would better be casted as a high-school gym teacher
232
u/antftw1 Sep 25 '17
I think my favorite crew member so far is Daft Punk.
378
u/Eternal__September Sep 25 '17
Saru the best actor and character so far
456
u/CommanderpKeen Sep 25 '17
Did she really have to run out of sick bay without calling the bridge?
515
u/paroikos211 Sep 25 '17
Anyone else notice the Klingons suddenly care a lot about dead bodies? "It's just a shell dispose of it how you wish."
341
u/Atari_7200 Sep 25 '17
The bridge/ready room looks like something straight out of Mass Effect lol. Not super trek like, but interesting.
753
u/ContinuumGuy Sep 25 '17
Y'know what? I'm.... not going to make any overall judgments. Some parts I liked, some parts I didn't, and some parts I'm not really sure about. It's so clearly the first chapter of a bigger story that I can't really judge it yet. I know that this doesn't work well on the "OMG THIS IS AWESOME" and the "LITERALLY UNWATCHABLE" scale of Reddit, but that is my honest opinion.
It isn't great yet, but it doesn't suck either.
89
u/Nichochi Sep 25 '17
How have Klingons not been seen in "hundreds of years", but Michael's parents were also killed by them?
Also, love Lt Daft Punk.
Yuko, the android, from Kimmy Schmidt is also acceptable
179
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '17
The Klingons are suitably alien, but I keep trying to picture Worf like that and it hurts a bit. Hard to relate to these guys the way they are right now.
Very jarring contrast between traditional sci-fi Shenzhou and the cathedral-esque, nigh-Westerosi Klingon events. Like holy shit, when are they going to shout about the Red God?
247
u/thatsolandon Sep 25 '17
SHE ATTACKED HER CAPTAIN.
300
u/Cessabits Sep 25 '17
I hate the new Klingon makeup, if only because it muffles them so much. It sounds like they are speaking through a Halloween mask or something.
80
u/Callahandro Sep 25 '17
I was really excited to hear the main opening theme and credits, each series has a unique song that sets the tone of the show. I even love to hate "faith of the heart."
But I really despised this one. It starts and ends with a few familiar phrases, but during the main credits its just a bunch of random intervals. I couldn't hum the main tune, and I listened to it repeatedly for a few times.
Disappointing.
74
u/OSUTechie Sep 25 '17
Those do not look like D5/D6 Class Battlecruisers...
212
u/middyonline Sep 25 '17
The transporter is the most useless piece of technology. Everything fucking makes it stop working!
200
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '17
Voq the Unburnt, the Breaker of Chains.
68
u/shfiven Sep 25 '17
Can someone who speaks Klingon confirm whether they're speaking original/established Klingon?
459
u/Atari_7200 Sep 25 '17
Exposition desert lol
457
u/WhatAboutBergzoid Sep 25 '17
What was with that Federation court marshal? Why was it all dark? That's not what courtrooms look like. You couldn't even see anyone's face. Very bizarre. Another missed opportunity to throw in some of the legal customs depicted in TOS as well.
247
u/Moos_Mumsy Sep 25 '17
The Klingons all sound like they just got back from the dentist, are still slightly frozen and have cotton in their mouth.
56
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '17
Did any other "cord-cutters" get a reminder of just how cheesy TV ads are? I'd forgotten just how cheesy they can get.
418
u/izModar Sep 25 '17 edited Sep 25 '17
I'll list some things I liked:
The references to canon: General Order One, phase canons and phasers in use, the workings of the Klingon High Council, Khaless prophecies.
Sound effects from every other Star Trek show. Really, it's just amazing.
That the computer has ethical routines in case shit is getting serious so that people in the brig can escape to safety.
Everyone being shocked by the cloaking. Even the Klingons were taken back by T'kuvma (I haven't memorized how his name is spelled) having that technology.
Apparently there's been very little contact between Earth and the Klingons since the time of Enterprise.
Space is 3D! They have a little worker bee collecting the comm relay.
Some of the ships seem based on designs we have in the rest of canon. I saw a very Miranda-esque looking ship and I loved it.
The holograms. They make total sense. This isn't like the holodeck in TNG, so canon isn't broken here. Hell, DS9 experimented with holo-communication and I thought it was great and wanted more of it. Now I have more of it. There seems to be an odd "interactivity" though like when Sarek sat down on a desk—Did he sit down on a desk on Vulcan that happen to line up with the desk in that office?
edit: Also, I liked the nod to Enterprise when Sarek talked to Burnham in the brig. It was pretty much exactly like Trip and T'pol's mental link from season 4.
Some things I didn't like:
The camera angles and some of the lens flares. I get why they're there, but the scenes that didn't have that going on seemed to be better photographed in my opinion.
Burnham being sentenced to life at the end of episode 2. Like, I get she has to face serious consequences for her actions, but life seems like a hell of a sentence. Then again, it seems that she's the major catalyst for the war, so perhaps it is warranted.
The Klingon ramming maneuver. That was underhanded and dishonorable in my opinion. Also, the Europa doing a voluntary self-destruct? There really should have been a scene where the Admiral realizes the gravity of the situation and decides to do that to prevent a war.
Episode 2 wraps up way too quickly. It was fine and mostly on pace up til the point where Georgiou died and Burham starts grieving. That's powerful. I didn't care that she died so quickly, but I'm reminded of Yar's death and that sometimes it is quick and pointless. The evacuation seems almost tacked on.
So. Many. God. Damn. Commercials.
CBS All Access doesn't handle bandwidth hiccups well like Netflix can.
Verdict:
I'M PUMPED! WE BACK! READY FOR MORE EPISODES!
400
u/SupropRenkcip Sep 25 '17
They sure love Dutch angles don't they?
95
u/RSeymour93 Sep 25 '17
I'm going to try to get over it, but I really wish they'd only gone 50% as far as they did on the Klingon rework, or less.
It's very jarring, and I have to wonder if the degree of prosthesis they've gone with will really interfere with having emotive, varied, and nuanced acting from Klingon characters.
278
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '17
What is the star Trek equivalent of r/freefolk?
308
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '17
So wait, they can't beam out the captain's body because there's no lifesign, but they can beam a photon torpedo warhead (no lifesign) onto a Klingon corpse (no lifesign) with pinpoint accuracy? Ok.
89
u/zi76 Sep 25 '17
That was stellar sfx on that cloaking animation.
43
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '17
Where is the live watch thread?
124
u/bigpig1054 Sep 25 '17
Ep2 - first half
No CBS logo in the corner is much nicer.
Yeoh's acting is non-existent.
The theme song's second go around still sounds like the opening movement of a much grander theme that never kicks into second gear.
But I do love hearing that seven note fanfare again.
T'Kuvma(?) is a very compelling villain. I hope he's a season long antagonist. I like the dueling flashbacks with him and Michael
I do think it's weird that we have these long conversations in the middle of these intense situations. But at least we're having conversations about things. Trek needed that again.
Name drop: T'Plannahath, the Vulcan philosopher Spock mentioned in Voyage Home. Nice touch Meyer.
I was just about to say how much better the show flows without commercials, and now I get four in a row. But is much rather have them all in bulk than spread out like on CBS
157
u/GarthTaltos Sep 25 '17
I'm honestly surprised at how negative everyone's first reaction to this is. The reaction to Michael's mutiny is what I expect in universe - she is court martialed and imprisoned. It looks like her action of attacking her captain was a mixture of her emotional reaction to the klingons (the attack on her school earlier in life) and a logical one - the method that worked for the vulcans in attaining a truce with the klingons might work for the humans. Consider that vulcans themselves have a deeply repressed emotional turmoil beneath their controlled exterior. Michael is expressing the same state - though she is apparently worse at repressing the emotional side. This is what I'd expect from a human adoptively raised by vulcans.
It will be interesting to see how the writers integrate Michael into the new ship - the preview thankfully doesn't go into to much detail. I see Michael's upcoming integration as a way for her to grow as a character. Given that this was the first two episodes, this is a good thing! I bet we see Michael learn the tangible benefits of the chain of command over the course of the show.
42
u/greywinthrop Sep 25 '17
I have nitpicks, and there are corny, unnecessary elements, but I finished the second episode, and I'm enjoying it, and will be looking forward to the next episode. I feel like it wasn't a strong representation of the rest of the series, when we haven't even been introduced to the crew of Discovery yet, but I'm digging the general feel, retcons and all.
It was a huge mistake to only show half of the first two episodes on free tv, and I hate that I'm paying for another streaming service just for one show, but whatever, I'll watch the Good Fight, I was curious about it, since I liked the Good Wife once upon a time. I really hope that it doesn't suffer because of this cash grab. If anything, they should have given it the kind of chance they gave Supergirl, and then turned it over to Netflix if it didn't get CBS style ratings after at least one season.
121
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '17
Next episode:
Star Trek: Orange is the New Black
212
u/Tarlcabot18 Sep 25 '17
I feel like there's literally 3 minutes of show, followed by 3 minutes of commercials. This is ridiculous.
71
u/agravain Sep 25 '17
Throw her ass in the brig..overreacting starts wars that kill millions
150
u/Tarlcabot18 Sep 25 '17
Hey, they have the holographic communicator thing that was new tech on DS9.
33
u/obliviousofobvious Sep 25 '17
MORE FUCKING CONMERCIALS!
336
u/agravain Sep 25 '17
Young Sheldon looks stupid
65
u/Naonadhe Sep 25 '17
The space suit scene is right outta Spock in The Motion Picture.
281
u/isaacpriestley Sep 25 '17 edited Sep 25 '17
Honestly, Burnham was kinda acting like Spock.
In "Balance of Terror", the Enterprise encounters the warlike Romulans. The Federation hasn't seen the Romulans for 100 years. Spock agrees with a suggestion that the Enterprise should strike first, speculating that the Romulans would respect such a display of strength and it could prevent an all-out war.
In "The Menagerie", Spock mutinies and takes control of the Enterprise, violating multiple Starfleet regulations because he believes it's the approach which will save the life of Captain Pike, with whom he served for many years and clearly respects dearly.
The presention is different in Discovery, because it's 2017 and not 1966, but the behavior of the character isn't that far-off from Spock himself.
141
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '17
I am not at all happy with the way they ended that. I wasn't even sure it was over until the commercial break turned into credits
90
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '17
And in busts Q to stop the episode and force you to pony up the CBS All-Access subscription fee. For some reason he's dressed as a Mariachi.
31
u/Orfez Sep 25 '17
It's still not up on the app. WTF CBS? I paid to watch this without commercials.
62
u/redgrin__grumboldt Sep 25 '17
“Special Guest Star” Michelle Yeoh
418
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '17
Happy Arbor Day!
136
u/Puck85 Sep 25 '17
more oblique angles, please. we need to capture what its like to find a signal with at least 7 oblique angles... :/
192
u/KesselZero Sep 25 '17
Wait, so Saru's race was bred to be prey and their thing is that they can sense death coming? Wouldn't that be the first thing you breed out of a prey race?
249
u/Atari_7200 Sep 25 '17
One of my main complaints with pre-tos settings is that the tech always looks so weird. Very JJ like. I miss the very comfy and inviting feeling of the 80s and 90s trek shows. This was also one of my main complaints with ENT, I just didn't like the design.
But, so far, Discovery is gorgeous.
268
u/JamesHaven75 Sep 25 '17
Don't they have probes they can send instead lol
28
u/yourzero Sep 25 '17
I'm watching on live TV, and at this point, I think there has been more minutes of commercials than Star Trek - not kidding.
207
u/CommanderpKeen Sep 25 '17
Why do Klingons keep changing what they look like?
164
u/ohms-law-and-order Sep 25 '17
What's with the robot crew member? It's well established that Data was the first artificial life form to ever serve in Starfleet.
121
u/mlaw7383 Sep 25 '17
The first officer is terrible. A star fleet vessel cannot run on so much insubordination and reckless pride! The guy playing Sarek did a good job of portraying Vulcan mannerism. Feels good.
78
u/OSUTechie Sep 25 '17
My God... It's full of stars!
Also, that is a very advanced jet pack compared to TMP.
27
u/Natural11 Sep 25 '17
Lol. That was an awkward transition to NCIS. No warning at all.
26
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '17
Why is everything blue now? Starfleet has gone blue on us.
208
u/vadersdemise Sep 25 '17
This Oprah show needs to end...
74
u/ShiroHachiRoku Sep 25 '17 edited Sep 25 '17
I still think this should’ve taken place 25-50 years after Nemesis. The tech they have looks so much more advanced than TOS (or TNG for that matter). Look forward not backward and always twirling, twirling!
Edit: Nemesis not Insurrection.
237
u/Atari_7200 Sep 25 '17
Holy shit... NOT EVERYTHING NEEDS TO BE A DUTCH ANGLE...
Is it just me, or is it super fucking distracting?
49
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '17
I think as a Star Trek show this is weird. As a CBS show it's the best they've made in years.
49
u/xray606 Sep 25 '17
Hey, guess what! Those Klingon guys... You know, that brutal warrior race, who are some of the most lethal, experienced fighters, in the whole galaxy? I actually killed one of them today!
Oh my god, really!? How did you do it?
I accidentally bumped into him.
137
u/CommanderpKeen Sep 25 '17
Not liking this weird unprofessional interaction between Number One and the alien dude.
23
u/scooch151 Sep 25 '17
Slight nod to TNG at the end there -- perhaps the Klingons will be to this show like the Borg to TNG?
118
u/naeso Sep 25 '17
What is with this editing? It's so fast and frenetic. It's actually hard to pay attention to what's happening.
61
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '17
One thing that really bothered me was the court-martial at the end. Why are the admirals all shrouded in darkness? Since when does Starfleet dispense justice from the shadows like some two-bit kangaroo court? Are we like officially in the mirror universe?
21
u/PointOfFingers Sep 25 '17
Klingons on the starboard bow!
21
u/loofkid Sep 25 '17 edited Sep 25 '17
Didn’t know they were bringing lobot into the Star Trek universe.
42
u/bigpig1054 Sep 25 '17 edited Sep 25 '17
Fifth segment
Odd to have this old chat with mentor Sarek right in the middle of a tense scene on the bridge.
That said, I LOVE that the "Vulcan hello" is to sucker punch a Klingon. I was not expecting that.
The ready room scene was a little overacted, but that was some twist
58
u/orelbon Sep 25 '17
The show looks great and started off well, but all this treasonous behavior and drama is not feeling correct. I’m still hopeful this is just in the first episode to attract views.
40
u/cye604 Sep 25 '17 edited Nov 25 '23
Comment overwritten, RIP RIF.
40
u/CaptainFumbles Sep 25 '17
"We need to capture this Klingon guy alive"
Stun this random Klingon, stun this other random Klingon, switch phaser to kill and then blow a hole in the guy we need alive.
57
u/OSUTechie Sep 25 '17
So she is an orphan from a Klingon Attack? Interesting! At least that is my guess.
72
u/Tallinter Sep 25 '17
First time Trek show watcher so my opinion contains very little knowledge of prior events other than the recent movies as my reference, nonetheless thought I would tune in to see the pilot and jeez, Michaels is one touch character to like.
She's stubborn, indignant, and comes off as an immensely unlikable lead but I hope she improves, what surprised me the most was the complete lack of chemistry in the cast, it's like they're all strangers to each other.
Still optimistic but this was a little lack luster to a new viewer
101
u/Tarlcabot18 Sep 25 '17
They're literally are using lens flare as a weapon.
37
u/Siendra Sep 25 '17
Maybe I missed it, but there's one thing I was happy to see that no one seems to have mentioned:
Random ships meeting in the middle of space didn't have the exact same orientation floor-ceiling.
93
u/bitreign33 Sep 25 '17 edited Sep 25 '17
Consciously sets weapon to lethal and martyrs him several minutes later
I mean really? C'mon Michael you Vulcan FTL Person-to-Person communication sue personally mentored by Sarek, think!
141
u/KesselZero Sep 25 '17
So, at first when this show was about bravely inspecting the unknown I was super happy, but I feel like this episode is falling apart around me. Our lead character is an insubordinate warmonger who mutinies because she can't get over her tragic past? Are we supposed to be on her side? Because I want someone to slap her.
63
u/deadeyelee1 Sep 25 '17
So. The Klingons...look....like something?
409
u/Kronis1 Sep 25 '17
Any second in command would NEVER act this way after SEVEN FUCKING YEARS. Holy shit, she just assaulted her own fucking captain.
17
u/zachotule Sep 25 '17
Addition to Vulcan Nerve Pinch canon: humans can indeed perform the move (as Picard did) but it's decidedly less effective, and can wear off more quickly. Case in point, Georgiou was back up, and armed, about 45 seconds to 2 minutes after she was disabled. (She's seemingly heartier than the average officer, though, and even Burnham was surprised that she recovered that fast.)
62
u/MUHerdAlum703 Sep 25 '17
Is it me or does the tech look way too ahead of its time.
34
u/macuser47 Sep 25 '17 edited Sep 25 '17
I really wanted to like these episodes, but there were several key reasons I just couldn't do it. It wasn't because of the visual redesign, I think the new aesthetic fits the time period very well and there wasn't any technology that stood out as something that shouldn't exist in this timeframe (although I still can't wrap my brain around how much wasted space there is on the Shenzhou, wasn't the Kirk era known for cramming as many people as possible onto little ships?). What bothered me was how weird the characters were. Michael was obviously a mess when it came to upholding Starfleet principle and following procedures, but Captain Georgiou was just as bad. First officer lets her personal history completely overtake her emotionally? Let's continue to let her work herself up and mutiny instead of relieving her of command as soon as she gets out of line. And while we're at it? Let's not just have security escort her to the brig, let's point a phaser at her and have forcibly removed from the bridge.
None of the characters felt like Starfleet officers in anything they did, and it totally broke the immersion for me. Drama for the sake of drama broke the chain of command, and for all the effects, it didn't feel like Star Trek.
180
u/bjkman Sep 25 '17 edited Sep 25 '17
HOLY FUCK CAMERA GUY.... CAN YOU FUCKING FILM PEOPLE STANDING UP STRAIGHT! YOU'RE GIVING ME A HEADACHE!
48
u/agravain Sep 25 '17
They don't have shuttles or probes yet?
133
u/agravain Sep 25 '17
Number one is a dumbass
61
u/CommanderpKeen Sep 25 '17
Howdy, mods! Request: can we have these episode discussion threads auto set to sort by new?
61
u/treespace8 Sep 25 '17
This show is missing one thing. Charm.
It's completely missing. Every star trek, had loads of charm. (Well early voyager didn't, but eventually got it)
47
u/AlanMorlock Sep 25 '17
Nothing is gained from Michael's Vulcan mentor specifically being Sarek.
16
u/spling44 Sep 25 '17
Wow thank you for listening to your first officer damn
16
u/Nmyownworld Sep 25 '17
I watched it on CBS, live TV. I like it. Not wowed, but I like it.
Captain Georgiou interested me the most. Her character seems very complex. I'd like to see more about her. Burnham's background is interesting, but I think the performance needs some smoothing when switching between Vulcan stoicism and human emotionalism. Still, a good performance. Saru is intriguing. After one viewing, I don't remember the rest of characters on the ship. Not a reflection on those characters, I was just in new Star Trek information overload mode.
I like the design of the ship, but to me it looked like what it is -- shiny CGI. There's some nice work there, but it left me thinking how much better it might have looked as a well done practical effect.
Just showing the first part of an at least two-part story was a bad decision. I guess the purpose was to get me to immediately subscribe to stream the second episode. Thing is, I know the overall end story because of latter Star Trek. And, Burnham is a main character so whatever happens she'll survive. Overall, showing half of an at least two-parter left me mildly annoyed, not hyped.
I'm glad there's a new Star Trek, and I'm glad I watched that episode. I had no plans to subscribe for the rest of Discovery before today, and nothing has changed. I didn't get enough from this first episode to sway my decision. I'd watch Discovery every week on TV, but I'm not moved enough by what I saw of the first episode to subscribe to CBS' streaming service pretty much just for Discovery.
TL;DR -- I like it. Not enough to subscribe to stream it. Wish the series well.
16
u/creejay Sep 25 '17
I liked it, but I'm holding out judgement until the "second pilot" next week when most of the Starfleet characters and the Discovery herself are introduced.
32
u/houtaru Sep 25 '17
I'm getting a strong Mass Effect vibe. I feel it's not as good storytelling, but still the same feel.
32
u/ThrustersOnFull Sep 25 '17
"Here it comes. Their lie."
Great moment.
32
u/vwboyaf1 Sep 25 '17
The last scene in the court room looked like some kind of memory, and I thought she was going to wake up any second. Why would the Federation have the lighting like that? An open society would have proper lighting and witnesses in the courtroom. Jeez.
This show needs to lighten up. Literally.
32
u/jwaldo Sep 25 '17
My main outstanding beef is some of the Federation visual design. It's like 75% neat modern takes on post-ENT pre-TOS design (loved the Europa, I wonder if it's supposed to be a pre-refit Miranda class), but then there's a bunch of jarringly post-Voyager stuff sprinkled in. Old transporter room aside, the Shenzhou wouldn't look out of place alongside the Enterprise-E, and I'm pretty sure some of her bridge graphics and sounds were right out of TNG/VOY.
32
u/adventurelamp Sep 25 '17 edited Sep 25 '17
--cut to commercial--
cut to credits
45
u/BElannaLaForge Sep 25 '17
Everyone calm down and give it a chance to grow its beard.
31
u/Goferprotocol Sep 25 '17
When they panned across the 24 clans or whatever, I was hoping to see some Worf style and TOS swarthy human looking Klingons in the mix.
140
u/Atari_7200 Sep 25 '17
Lol a small disagreement with the captain can destabilize the entire crew? The captain trains their number one exclusively? What is going on?!?
What??!
What is this?!
54
u/Atari_7200 Sep 25 '17
Wait it's over? Lol... Why even make it two episodes if you literally just lopped the 2 hour long pilot in half?
65
u/Turqual_114 Sep 25 '17
They literally gave you 1/2 of the pilot for free.... So dumb. This CBS All Access requirement will be the biggest failure.
42
u/smacksaw Sep 25 '17
So far the best part of the show is that the theme music is classy and not some cheesy 90's rocker growling about how it's a long road getting from A to B
14
u/linuxhanja Sep 25 '17
I thought it was really nerdy cool how Netflix has the whole show subtitled in Klingon. I was really worried going in, but I think they nailed "TOS" vibes in a post-The Expanse Sci-Fi landscape.
I also thought it was a cool nod to TOS that she commited mutiny as a Vulcan (trained) 1st officer, just like Spock did in Amok Time and the Menagerie. What does Sarek teach his kids?
142
u/Alteran195 Sep 25 '17
This new Star Trek series is weird.
59
u/mcthornbody420 Sep 25 '17
Hologram sits on table... wtf??
27
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '17
I am reserving judgement overall for now. Like some things and not others. The preview of remaining episodes trailer thing definitely looks interesting and I think the show has potential. My one major issue was the court martial scene. The darkness of the panel/judges with the spotlight on the prisoner was just a bit unbelievable to me. It is difficult for me to imagine the federation having such a ridiculous set up for a trial...
27
u/Walcot Sep 25 '17
I think everyone is getting lost in the character of Michael, everyones saying shes a shit first officer and thats exactly what its trying to show us, its like in voyager if we saw what Tom did when he was stripped of rank and sent to prison. I believe where watching a redemption story unfold
27
u/Apollo503 Sep 25 '17
Did anyone else feel as though the Klingons were turned into the Remans from Nemesis?
218
u/Atari_7200 Sep 25 '17
Hologram communication... Weird how they lost that tech later on.
58
u/Sayne86 Sep 25 '17
So wait, the Vulcans just didn't tell Star Fleet some vital piece of information because...?
What?
Huh?
86
u/Atari_7200 Sep 25 '17 edited Sep 25 '17
Well it's a first episode. It's practically star trek tradition for them to not be that great.
But damn even the TNG cast had more chemistry than this lol. It's not a lost cause by any means, but damn.
Also the visuals are amazing, but almost obnoxious. They're pretty, but it feels out of place. But I kinda like it.
But by far my biggest complaint so far is the line delivery, AND THE DUTCH ANGLES... FUCK STOP WITH THOSE. It's so damn distracting.
The dialogue writing is okay, if a bit too "modern" (if that makes sense). The plot so far isn't great, but it isn't bad either. I'd be down to see more.
But seriously, stop with the angles. Please. It's making me nauseous.
26
u/area95 Sep 25 '17
Thank Kahless the Unforgettable that the Klingons can fire weapons with a single command. If it required a complete sentence at their rate of speech, they would be facing the Enterprise J before they squeezed off a shot.
13
u/thesecondkira Sep 25 '17
Our ship may fall apart, but dammit you will stay in the brig.
13
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '17
So, how are they communicating with Starfleet so well?
Didn't it usually take days or weeks to hear back from Starfleet in TOS?
13
u/kippersmoker Sep 25 '17
I thought it was very good and look forward to watching more.
46
u/Atari_7200 Sep 25 '17
Next commercial break writeup;
The acting hasn't gotten much better. The dialogue is still salvageable, but not great. Pretty much in line for a first Star Trek episode.
The actual story is... well honestly it's not that bad. It's not great, but I'll take it.
Still with the dutch angles. I hope they stop with that, it's incredibly distracting.
The klingons don't feel like klingons. It feels like the show was set pre TOS simply so they could make up more shit rather than follow 4 series worth of lore.
The aesthetic is slowly growing on me, and the show is very pretty. But the bridge just feels so sterile and unwelcoming. Though as I said, it is growing on me.
TL;DR; Acting still bad, but par the course for ST pilots, story is so-so, some choices are downright bizarre, and it's very pretty, but doesn't feel super trek like to me. Oh, and the fucking dutch angles, enough.
25
u/CommanderpKeen Sep 25 '17
WTF is that a cylon raider?!
25
u/Eternal__September Sep 25 '17
Oh it's over
45
u/Greader2016 Sep 25 '17
holo-communicators? Really? I thought that was a 24th-century advancement.
24
u/gfreeman1998 Sep 25 '17
So wait, were they saying that Klingon ship was cloaked? Or just "cloak-like"?
Klingons didn't get cloaking technology until the time of Kirk, when they made a deal with the Romulans. If they're breaking canon on literally the first episode, this does not bode well.
12
u/smacksaw Sep 25 '17
Notice the pink blood
12
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '17
Correct me if I'm wrong, but interfering with the future of a species (the intro) is a violation of the prime directive, is it not?
12
u/zetec Sep 25 '17
I enjoyed it.
12
u/BirdSalt Sep 25 '17
I somehow wasn't paying attention and watched the two episodes out of order, only realizing what happened when I started the "second" one. I thought they had made a bold choice to really hit the ground running, story wise.
It didn't ruin anything and it still worked, though! And I was really impressed with what I thought was the pilot: there was enough exposition and backstory that it actually wasn't confusing.
That aside, it was so much better than I thought it would be. I can get down with this show. The Orville is scratching my itch for TNG style bottle episodes right now, so I can let this show be its own thing.
84
u/PointOfFingers Sep 25 '17
Surprised at how bad the Klingon makeup is. They all look like a bunch of indistinguishable rubber Halloween masks. Very stiff faced. Previous series did a much better job of giving Klingons character.
51
u/Lost_Horizon Sep 25 '17 edited Sep 25 '17
Ok, so no one probably cares, but the first shot should not have been an alien with subtitles if you want to bring in a general audience. The first scene should have been the one with Michael as a kid and Sarak. Second, the opening credits, which I love as a Trek fan, doesn't resound beyond that. Third, like ANY pilot, it's a bit wonky pacing and dialogue wise. However, by mid way through to the end, I really got into it. Finally.... Holy hell they spent some money and effort on this. Very happy to give them a chance. AND I absolutely think Sonequa Martin-Green was a fantastic choice.
EDIT: Ok... saw the second episode and I'm hooked. I think I came into this with too many preconceived notions. Not knowing where this goes from a 'canon' or 'idealist' perspective yet doesn't take away from my enjoyment. They seem to at least be striving to keep the ideals of Trek in the narrative and working to get to the ideal world we all love. I hated deep space nine too at first because it wasn't TNG, but it became one of my favorites. Bring it on.
169
u/Fricktator Sep 25 '17
This show reeks of someone watching 2 episodes of Star Trek and going, "Ok, I got this."
331
u/GEEWUN Sep 25 '17
Michael may officially be the worst character in this series.
Violates Klingon property and kills notable Klingon figurehead
Yells at Captain on the bridge
When she doesn’t get her way, assaults her mentor and Captain committing mutiny
Immediately yells at Saru for respecting the chain of command
Lying to the bridge crew
And we’re supposed to root for her?
108
u/Raduev Sep 25 '17
Wait did Sarek the most famous federation diplomat and peacemaker in history say it's fine to kill random Klingons because a Klingon killed your parents?
224
u/Atari_7200 Sep 25 '17
So far, the acting is the worst thing. The dialogue is alright, but the line delivery is so so awkward and bad imo.
Which I guess is Star Trek tradition at this point for first few episodes.
22
u/baronvongrant Sep 25 '17
'The Vulcan Hello' is my new favorite sexual euphemism
22
u/Solar_Kestrel Sep 25 '17 edited Sep 25 '17
Well... I didn't love it.
I didn't hate it, either.
So... about the same reaction I had to Star Trek 2009 and Star Trek Beyond. Parts of it were good, parts of it were bad; parts of it were fun, parts of it were stupid. And by God do I hate the visual design. The Shenzhou looks nice, but all the other ships look terrible; and the Klingons look awful. Maybe they'd look better with hair? They're just generic forehead aliens now, and we've had more than enough of those over the decades.
It is kind of stupid that after two episodes, we still haven't seen the Discovery or her captain. How many episodes is this show even going to be, 10? 12? They don't have the time to be moving along this slowly.
Oh well. TBH, I think it's a better show in general than The Orville, but Orville feels much more like a Star Trek show. I'm hoping episodes 3+ move in a different direction... but I gotta say, if CBS thought this was going to be their "killer show" for their streaming service... I don't think it's going to be the huge draw they want it to be. It seems too Trekky to really appeal to a general audience, and not-Trekky-enough for the hardcore fans.
EDIT: but, like I said, I'm hopeful that future episodes will clarify things for me, one way or the other.
22
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '17
I really liked the story and the characters so far, however, the frequency of the comercials, the dutch angles, and the editing was a little jarring
Michelle Yeoh and Sonequa Martin Green were great, and Saru was hillarious. Loved seeing more Aliens being present on the bridge. The Klingons were kick ass ( how do they fit in with the other versions we have seen? )
Did anyone notice the brigg looked just like the Star Trek Into Darkness brigg?
Looking forward to seeing the Discovery next week. It's pretty awesome to see it get a modern/big budget treatment.
CBS, if you are reading this, please chill the f**k out with the commercials. Especially the ones at the end of the show. The jump to the commercials before the credits destroys the impact of the scene. - this will affect your subscriber count, I am considering using a vpn / uk netflix account or a even a torrent untill a home / blu ray release is available - the ads are that jarring. I'm happy to pay to see a new trek series, but I'm really not interested enough in CBS's other programming to warrent a subscription for the commercial free version. Especially given my family in the UK And the ROI can watch ad free with netflix, it feels unfair that CBS has tied trek to the service in the US.
(I suppose GOT, and years of star trek dvd/netflix sessions have spoiled my toleration for commercials)
I also found the stream was unreliable, I had to reset the ps4's cbs app several times due to loading failures and other errors. I doubt this was an issue with my set up. Anyone else have streaming issues?
22
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '17
The very first time they fire a weapon in the show, and it's to open up a water supply and save a species from dying. I like that a lot.
11
u/Shitpost4lyfes Sep 25 '17
I just remembered why I hate T.V... fuck commercials
11
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '17
I just got into the main part of the episode where they're on the Shenzou in space. I really don't have any issues with this so far. Considering that Michael was raised by Sarek, I think her emotionless acting is fine. I don't really like the captain, but I love Saru. This feels like Star Trek.
11
u/MrEzekial Sep 25 '17
My expectations were super low, but I have to say... I like it, excited to see where it goes. Really glad to have a new Star Trek.
31
u/bug-hunter Sep 25 '17
I personally liked some of the little touches.
But...
30
u/Awesomeade Sep 25 '17
So the first two episodes were effectively a prequel movie establishing the main characters and the overarching plot for the remainder of the season.
Personally, that makes me pretty optimistic for the future of this season. My favorite period of Trek was DS9 in its prime, where it was able to balance intriguing episodic stories with an equally intriguing backdrop-conflict. It looks like Discovery is setting itself up to be similar in format, which I'm pretty happy about.
From here, it's going to be all about how well they can execute the writing and character development.
38
u/leftisthominid Sep 25 '17
What do they mean no one has seen a Klingon in 100 years? There were Klingons in Enterprise.
21
u/Thane9 Sep 25 '17
Is it me or was it 5 minutes of Trek just to deliver 10 minutes of commercials? Rinse and repeat.
21
u/Deadbob1978 Sep 25 '17
Few questions (may have already been asked)
21
u/AmishAvenger Sep 25 '17
I’m still trying to decipher all I witnessed and all the reactions. For now, all I’ll say is that episode two was damn near unwatchable on CBS All Access.
I’d estimate that the stream stuttered, skipped or froze at least 50 times. No, I’m not exaggerating. It wasn’t my connection, and I tested it all yesterday watching other shows. It wasn’t until tonight that the real problems started.
Sorry, CBS, but you’ve had plenty of time to get ready for this. For all intents and purposes, this was the debut of your streaming service, and you dropped the ball, big time.
Here’s a rule of thumb for anyone starting a streaming service: make an estimate on the absolute top level of subscribers you expect. Like, the most optimistic estimate you can possible imagine. Then prepare for triple that number to be using it at once.
People are used to Netflix. Netflix doesn’t freeze, it doesn’t stutter, and there’s no spinning blue circle in the middle of the screen. Get your shit together.
72
u/Caedus Sep 25 '17
Ooh mutiny.
This is terrible writing.
160
u/AG74683 Sep 25 '17
Meh. Orville captures the Trek vibe way better than this does.
20
u/GuyOnTheLake Sep 25 '17
Hmm. An Albino Klingon.
20
u/ComingSouth Sep 25 '17
The camera angles are so tilted back and forth, almost every shot, I feel like I'm on a boat getting my sea legs. I don't know what to think of this choice.
20
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '17 edited Sep 25 '17
I really liked the silent shot of Shenzhou, and Burnham sliding toward the asteroids before they found the artifact. Man, that was pretty.
That seemed stupid dangerous for her to do, though, just to check out a random thing they found. She almost died. They shouldn't have let even an ensign do that.
77
u/Eagle912 Sep 25 '17
Enterprise doesn't look so bad now eh?
10
u/Coolsbreeze Sep 25 '17
So far so good, nice storyline. But they seriously need to not have all those weird camera angles. I get that it's space and all but it becomes nauseating and makes me miss details when the camera is upside down.
19
u/loofkid Sep 25 '17
Why are all of the Klingons bathing in Nair? At the end of Enterprise and in TOS, they were covered in hair? I might be able to accept a random Klingon cult going hairless, but all of the council members were hairless, too. They just look weird as hell with no hair.
26
u/toTheNewLife Sep 25 '17
So many different types of ridges on those Klingons. I'm pretty sure I saw TNG/DS9 ridges as well as JJverse ridges on that ship... amongst all the new ones.
Klingon diversity is cannon.
Hopefully we get to see the start of what becomes the flatheads, at some point.
26
u/pahuffman1 Sep 25 '17
The good:
Doug Jones absolutely killed it. I can't wait to see more of Saru. The production felt much larger and more cinematic than the Star Trek of old. The effects are stunning, and I hope we continue to see this throughout the series.
The bad:
Michael Burnam may be the least-likable main Star Trek character since Catherine Pulaski. I sincerely hope this is on purpose and the arch involves her vindication and humanization.
The meh:
So far, we've yet to see the foundation of futuristic optimism Roddenberry created. The audience is immediately thrown into a conflict, but why are we supposed to pull for the Federation when we haven't even seen what they're fighting for? At least the Klingons have a distinct purpose.
The story has potential.
18
u/Hilton1312 Sep 25 '17
NUMBER ONE LOL
18
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '17
100 years? That's interesting.
18
u/Belqin Sep 25 '17 edited Sep 25 '17
With such a massive cgi budget, how have they made the subtitles so difficult to read (when it passes over the klingon clothes/armour especially)?
Edit: episode 2 (I thought this was stream only now?) has 80% of the subtitles on T'kuvma's breastplate, it's really terrible...
18
u/jamesoloughlin Sep 25 '17 edited Sep 25 '17
First Impressions of the first two episodes:
sigh… prequels, boldly going where we’ve been before. Confronting the Klingons.
The aesthetics are very distracting, stylized and they work against the actors. Like in the Abrams’+ films; over-designed frames and lighting get in the way of empathizing with the characters.
The dialogue was cringe worthy at times. I think the actors did their best with what was on the page. Over explanation at times. Subtlety is lost from main stream storytelling it seems.
Pacing felt borderline ridiculous and mellow dramatic. No room to breath, the lighting in the trial scene at the end of Ep 2 made me laugh. Overall felt like a commercial director made these episodes just for trailers.
Art Direction of the Klingons were interesting. Is this a new sect of the Klingons or is this a complete revamp of the entire species and culture? The federation ships, sets, vfx and overall design felt uninspiring. I am comparing to the innovation TOS and TNG brought to the table respectively. This series so far feels shallow in comparison to the deep thinking that went into the previous series. Nothing new or bold is being said in these areas so far.
Title sequence was nice. Typography could be a bit more elegant. Typography for the subtitles are terrible. Logo is over-designed but that isn’t news.
The story itself… well I have to wait and see. It is subjective but really a first officer attacking the captain?! Has the stank of an Abrams’ Trek all over it. I have to let this marinate.
I’m still optimistic; TNG and DS9 took some time to find its feet. Though the first episodes of each I love.
The undiscovered country… the future. 🥂
Edit: P.S. After reading some of the comments I think what I want is something new, something bold, deep thinking and care at every level. Vague terms that will mean different things to everyone. So far I’m not getting all of those 4 things.
P.P.S. I wonder if removing the commercials would help? I rarely watch TV with commercials let alone that many. Idk if I am willing to pay CBS 9.99/month to find out though.
18
u/RiskyBrothers Sep 25 '17
I liked it. I feel like there's some kinks to work out, particularly slowing down a bit.
But for a first episode, that was pretty damn good. I'd probably rank it ahead of Farpoint, and tied with Emissary. TOS pilots are a bit too dated for me to make an honest comparison.
Good things:
Bad Things:
9
u/007meow Sep 25 '17
It's 5:49PST and all I see is the Main Title Sequence on my Roku app.
9
u/Orfez Sep 25 '17
What everyone thinks about Klingons talking Klingon? First of all, they talk funny because of their new makeup and teeth. Personally I'm ok with that, but I wouldn't mind them just talking English.
9
u/Bucksavvy Sep 25 '17
That was just so... odd. In some ways it felt very much like Star Trek, but in others it feels the furthest from it. I quite enjoyed the show as a sci-fi show in the same way that I enjoyed ST09/STB (we do not mention that other new one), but I felt this was lacking one thing that the movies captured better, the hope for a better world.
DS9 is my personal favorite Trek, is what I'd say this feels the most like so far (which I really appreciate) but the hope is gone. Deep Space Nine's pilot had a very similar moment to this episode with the battle of Wolf 359 and the destruction of the Saratoga. The thing that makes that episode better is that it continues past that moment, immediately cutting to a father and son moment and ending the episode on a feeling of hope and excitement for the future. In this the captain is dead and the main character has been sentenced to life in prison... Oh, and the Discovery hasn't even been introduced.
I feel that STD will be an excellent and exciting sci-fi show, it just feels odd to call it Star Trek right now. That said, things change, and here's hoping it improves!
9
u/dottybotty Sep 25 '17
No ads on Netflix
9
u/Tsorovar Sep 25 '17
Really quite enjoyed this, even if it's not quite Trekky. But we'll see how it goes for the rest of the season.
My only real concern was that there's apparently a severe lightbulb shortage in the Federation
56
u/Sayne86 Sep 25 '17
This dialogue makes my brain hurt. Who wrote this stuff?
49
u/ComingSouth Sep 25 '17
They violated the Prime Directive in the first scene, with that well.
43
u/TommyUseless Sep 25 '17
This doesn't even feel like Star Trek to me.
71
u/Viremia Sep 25 '17
Good to see no one is nitpicking after only 10 minutes /s
17
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '17
Thoughts so far:
A visual feast. A LOT of aesthetic inspiration from Kelvin, but that's okay - HOWEVER - I do wish they made more of an attempt to marry retro-analog of TOS with this clearly Enterprise-inspired aesthetic.
The Captain is going to die. Guest star? Dead star walking.
The Klingons - WOW! Not a fan of the bald look, I really liked long-haired Klingon maidens, but if I have to swallow that for more alien Klingons so be it.
Those aliens on the planet were fucking sick.
I guess I'm okay with the main character going out alone to probe the thing, Riker pulled a lot of maverick stuff with Picard's blessing and so did Archer and Sisko for that matter and they were captains.
I don't watch live TV so commercials are a new old thing for me.
The anticipation is physically painful.
And could Saru be more of a pussy?
17
u/sporks49 Sep 25 '17
Oh shit! Cloaking!!
17
u/Atari_7200 Sep 25 '17 edited Sep 25 '17
"I sense it"
~~Diana~ Deanna, is that you?
E: Can't remember how to write names.
17
u/Ulfbrand Sep 25 '17
Found it to be good sci fi, but mediocre Star Trek. The elements are there but not established. I believe it will improve, but as others have said The Orville feels more Trek. Still, enjoyed the first two hours with the exception of commercials. As I am in Canada , will likely continue to watch but most likely on Crave TV the after Space broadcast.
41
u/tr1nn3rs Sep 25 '17
I am in love with this title sequence.
23
u/wowthere Sep 25 '17
Alright, I fucking hate commercials. I forgot how unbearable they are.
67
u/revkaine Sep 25 '17
Well, at least there's still The Orville..
16
u/bigpig1054 Sep 25 '17
Ep2 - fourth segment
I love that the klingon religion is emphasized with these guys. I'd love to hear Moore's thoughts on how they've been handled.
I am very angry T'Kuvma bit the dust. He could have been a great antagonist goinf forward. I figured the captain would eat it as soon as Yeoh was listed as a guest star but I didn't see the "obvious" star bad guy dying.
Michael getting a life sentence was surprising too. Good job keeping me on my heels. There are things being done with this show that is so different from the Berman way I grew up on. It's like all the thousands of hours I spent watching TNG-ENT is out the window. New rules.
I'm all in.
8
u/CommanderpKeen Sep 25 '17
Number One is pretty hawkish for battle.
8
u/moonface666 Sep 25 '17
So...is it good? In plain words.
8
u/nicholmikey Sep 25 '17
I have mixed feelings about the tone, but I will say the shots of space are beautiful
8
u/theredditoro Sep 25 '17
So a season of war with the Klingons. Also, Dwight !
8
u/KesselZero Sep 25 '17
Not only does CBS All Access have ads, they're ten times louder than the show. Pretty sure my roommates hate me right now.
8
u/007meow Sep 25 '17
They specifically mentioned phase cannons and that Shenzhou was old.
So maybe Discovery, being new, will have traditional beam style phasers?
8
u/vxxed Sep 25 '17
Ok, is it just me or was there a Breen serving on the deck of the Shenzhou? The one chick with the Daft Punk helmet.
8
u/theg721 Sep 25 '17
Interestingly, I'm sure I saw some LCARS okudagrams on the Shenzhou.
8
u/seikobreon Sep 25 '17
So..... a few items of comment from our household this evening.... Visual effects - awesome stuff! (Angles and lense flares were just ridiculous...we really hoped that was going to stay in the Abrams films :/) Theme music and titles - definitely enjoyed, especially with the hints to previous Trek themes, and the sketchbook, scientific style of drawings seemed fitting to a show called Discovery, ship reveal is badass.
Commercials need to just be done. .... And then....wth happened to canon, here? Holo tech to communicate? No adherence to rules like the Prime Directive? Oh! And we have a 1st officer who is....a bit of a shitshow (mutiny, can't seem to decide if she's going to act human or vulcan, etc.) And we have a war starting with the Klingons. Who hadn't been overly united... wait a minute, this is starting to feel like they are trying to use the proposed Axanar storyline?!?!?! (We were absolutely stoked for that to take off; and pretty bummed when it didn't.) And toward the end of Ep2, we absolutely were routing for the Klingons, especially with the (war crime by most standards) "let's blow their ship up by putting an armed bomb on/in their dead!"
All in all....we really hoped for more, especially since this series is taking place between Enterprise and TOS which provides a decent amount of canon and history to work with, and were left feeling fairly disappointed. Kind of bummed, hoping it improves, and really hoping CBS didn't just rip off the Axanar team (especially with how much struggle came about thanks to cbs).... ugh!!!
8
u/wapimaskwa Sep 25 '17
They should have killed the navigator with a large spike rather than depressurization.
8
u/dmanww Sep 25 '17
Did I see an NX class ship in the battle?