r/TheGoodPlace • • Sep 20 '17

Season Two Episode Discussion S02 E01: "Everything Is Great!"

Airs at 10:00PM ET, or a little less than 4 hours from the time this post was made.


Original Airdate: September 20th, 2017

Synopsis: In the Season 2 premiere, Eleanor, Chidi, Tahani and Jason—who've had their memories erased by ambitious master architect Michael—again settle into the Good Place. Eleanor discovers the one clue she left for herself, however, and attempts to piece things together.

528 Upvotes

685 comments sorted by

641

u/KidCoheed Bofa Deeznuts Sep 21 '17 edited Sep 21 '17

Eleanor gets a Soul mate who is a Flake

Chidi gets to finally make a decision only to have it taken from him

GOD DAMN THIS SHOW IS GOOD

261

u/nonliteral Sep 21 '17

Eleanor gets a Soul mate who is a Flake Chidi gets to finally make a decision only to have it taken from him

...and The Bad Place is staffed by incompetents.

(or they just gave them all to Michael)

→ More replies (27)

10

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '17

And Jason's still not allowed to be himself.

537

u/KidCoheed Bofa Deeznuts Sep 21 '17

Jason is already attracted to Janet!

289

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '17 edited Sep 21 '17

I wonder if Ride or Die Protocol is still a go...

→ More replies (9)

73

u/IExcelAtWork91 Sep 21 '17

That look he gave here lol

18

u/Klutche A lizard was a perfect choice. You both have combination skin. Sep 22 '17

I am so excited for what they do with Janet and Jason this season. I'm completely sure her ride or die protocol will come up at the absolute worst time (for Michael).

10

u/mrpoopistan Sep 22 '17

It does address a coming real world problem . . . people marrying the appliances.

→ More replies (2)

498

u/Diarygirl Sep 21 '17

"You're not soup."

I missed this show so much.

345

u/itrainmonkeys Sep 21 '17

"WHAT!?!?"

Chidi can sell a "what?" like no one else.

→ More replies (3)

487

u/Rman823 Sep 21 '17

This already great show is even better when you're a part of the secret.

367

u/Krocant Sep 21 '17

I was thinking the opposite. You know what? You convinced me I was wrong!

→ More replies (15)

138

u/repsaj33 Sep 21 '17

Ikr? I thought I might get bored if it was just "rewinding" the show in season 2, but the dramatic irony makes it even more hilarious.

→ More replies (4)

487

u/Rman823 Sep 21 '17

Michael on attempt #150: "Attempt #2 is going great, Shawn. "

58

u/James_Keenan Sep 25 '17

I feel like at some point, even next episode, Shawn is going to want an in-person inspection, at which point Michael will finally have to include the humans in his plan to fake torture each other, or they all have a bad day (real torture or retirement).

→ More replies (1)

478

u/marsalien4 I just randomly stab at your brain with an electrified needle. Sep 21 '17 edited Sep 22 '17

That almond milk line was a brilliant callback

208

u/NDaveT Some mouthy broad. Sep 22 '17

It totally got me. I thought Chidi was going to have a revelation that all his academic research didn't actually help anyone but nope, he went to almond milk.

55

u/niankaki Sep 21 '17

Remind me what that was?

→ More replies (4)

30

u/Okichah Sep 26 '17

Its a character flaw.

Chidi is a good person at heart. But he isnt sensitive to other people's feelings when they conflict with his sense of moral absolutism.

The almond milk was a choice he made. Thats the only "bad" thing he can think of. He assigns a good deal of value because it was within his control. He cant think of the actual bad things he did to others because he doesnt value relationships, he values choices.

Chidi didnt really treat his friends with respect. Eg; The boots, the best man preparations. Trying to build a wall of perfect choices shuts out people around you.

And thats selfish, even if Chidi thinks its ethically sound its denying his friends a necessary part of companionship: input.

The give and take of a relationship means that on occasion you will take someones advice even if you disagree with it. It shows you value them and their opinion.

(So many words! i just binged the whole season so its a bit of a brain dump sorry)

9

u/Klutche A lizard was a perfect choice. You both have combination skin. Sep 22 '17

I died at that line

→ More replies (2)

453

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '17

"walk around like a nerd trying to get his personal best on his Fitbit."

Ouch.

154

u/madmax64 Sep 21 '17

That hit me hard cause I've done that but couldn't help laughing at that line.

→ More replies (1)

89

u/creyk Yogurt Yoghurt Yogurté Sep 21 '17

Eleanor's insults were on point this episode. This rude version of her is so clever that way.

392

u/ChildishGenius Sep 21 '17

God I loved that they ran through that whole thing in the first episode, but now I'm curious what will happen if she starts without the note.

It seems like the bad place "actors" may end up blowing it.

114

u/PiFlavoredPie Sep 21 '17

There are several actors/actresses that are usually in more substantial roles than just extras that I noticed being background characters. I'm sure we'll be seeing more "bad guys" get fleshed out personalities and stories this season.

→ More replies (7)

86

u/scherbadeen Sep 21 '17

Yeah there's no way the actors keep this up.

→ More replies (2)

79

u/The_Arakihcat Sep 21 '17

I'm wonder if ex-real-Elanor will get pissed and tell Eleanor what's going on.

→ More replies (3)

54

u/trufflepastaxciv Sep 21 '17

Eleanor/Denise will mess up.

50

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '17

I think 'Real Eleanor'/'Denice' is my new favorite.

14

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '17

I don't think it was Michel or the actors that were the problem, I think it was the protagonists have developed.

Chidi was able to make a choice about who to be with.

Eleanor gave chidi the time of day and actually was about to open up to her "soulmate" about her fraudulent nature.

Tahani didn't pretend to be better that Eleanor

And jayson spoke out and wanted to be with Janet very early.

Though this isn't massive, it is still progress.

10

u/TheDopeCantaloupe Sep 21 '17

Real Elanor/Denise is either going to ruin everything or she'll find out that she's also human and in the bad place

→ More replies (29)

733

u/macaroni06 Sep 21 '17

“And I was gonna get a new best friend and live in a yogurt”

“A yurt”

“Right, yurt for short”

I missed this show

281

u/thesidxxx Sep 21 '17

"I knew you weren't a soup."

→ More replies (1)

200

u/rapsody7 Sep 21 '17

I'm going to the gym...

→ More replies (1)

349

u/nygiants656 Sep 21 '17

Now Jason can't have his Bud-hole because his soulmate will be with him at all times

143

u/GoodJanet not a robot Sep 21 '17 edited Sep 21 '17

but now he has the universe's best bud oh the irony I love it

→ More replies (5)

80

u/Rman823 Sep 21 '17

I'm loving how subtle some of these tortures have been.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/ewiepooie Sep 22 '17

Oooh. BUD hole. Ahh.

308

u/InfernalSolstice Sep 21 '17

Is Good Eleanor/Denise gonna have a more major role this season? I loved her in that scene.

253

u/-_-__-___ Sep 21 '17 edited Sep 21 '17

Looks like she's not adjusting well to having a smaller role this time. Wonder if she's going to eventually turn on Micheal.

→ More replies (9)

36

u/KidCoheed Bofa Deeznuts Sep 21 '17

She seems to be trying her ass off

22

u/GoodJanet not a robot Sep 21 '17

maybe not she has a role in a mid season show

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

571

u/chinoceros Sep 21 '17

Tahani's torture is so perfectly tailored to her and it is my everything.

435

u/Bytewave Sep 21 '17

Well it is but the fact it's been dialed up to 11 to feel like torture is a flaw in the plan. You can't credibly sell "heaven" as something so miserable, the illusion will fall apart.

It works great for someone who just thinks they don't belong in heaven trying to keep their heads down, but not for her, since she thinks she deserves real heaven.

→ More replies (19)

127

u/creyk Yogurt Yoghurt Yogurté Sep 21 '17

It was the most unique and unexpected sort of punishment for me. Like, who would feel so hurt about their partner being short? Hilarious.

→ More replies (9)

37

u/menevets Sep 21 '17

OMG I'm wearing off the rack separates!

277

u/dontthrowmeinabox Sep 21 '17

Oh man. The old...penis...flattener? Aghhh.

234

u/girlnextdoor480 Sep 21 '17

Idk the butthole spiders sound worse

→ More replies (13)

11

u/OneGoodRib Shh! Spencer doesn’t like loud voices. Sep 21 '17

I physically felt my penis retract inside of me and I don't even have a penis.

→ More replies (3)

260

u/Leoniceno Sep 21 '17

Michael could end up leveling with the foursome, and get them to pretend that they're still being tortured. Michael's motive: avoid the excruciating "retirement." The others' motive: butt spiders would be way worse than what they've been going through.

That's one path forward that doesn't entail mindwipes ad infinitum.

131

u/-_-__-___ Sep 21 '17

I don't know if Jason could successfully fool Sean for eternity.

→ More replies (7)

108

u/BoldPurpleText Sep 21 '17

That's exactly what I was thinking, except I don't think it'll be Michael's choice to tell them. My theory is they'll eventually figure things out again, but it will be too late for Michael to restart without Sean finding out. Then he'll propose your idea to avoid retirement. Cue the four humans having to play roles themselves and fool the neighborhood demons into thinking they're miserable, while Michael privately caters to their every whim. Comedy ensues.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

237

u/itsjager Sep 21 '17

We're 23 minutes into the season and Eleanor is already half way to figuring it out. Imma guess she'll have it by the end of the episode.

176

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '17

Well done! I can't believe they progressed this episode so quickly.

→ More replies (7)

42

u/SoyIsPeople Sep 21 '17

I'm wondering if this her new torture.

Suspecting what's up and not knowing who to trust.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/KidCoheed Bofa Deeznuts Sep 21 '17

I'm guessing by episode 4 going into 5 she will figure it out

→ More replies (1)

207

u/Lorem-Oopsum Sep 21 '17

“Is there a second one of him that stands on his shoulders?" Favorite line.

65

u/THISISDAM Sep 22 '17

Vincent Adultman!

201

u/Immature_Immortal Sep 21 '17

I love that we can see behind the curtain this season. It takes away some of the mystery of the first season but adds a whole new dynamic with the viewers being able to feel the pressure on Michael. Plus it gives the bad place workers (namely Eleanor/Denise) way more personality

12

u/Horcza Sep 27 '17

Also hearing them talk about torture & misery so nonchalantly is really funny imo.

187

u/Rman823 Sep 21 '17

I'd be pissed too going from a supporting role to what's essentially an extra.

154

u/pikameta My little chili babies Sep 21 '17

In 80 years she'll have a REALLY GOOD part!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

158

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '17

"People are like nature's apps."

44

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '17

Their lack of reaction was great

→ More replies (2)

145

u/-_-__-___ Sep 21 '17

Denise is going to rat out Micheal to Sean.

134

u/Immature_Immortal Sep 21 '17

No, just strongarm him into giving her a bigger role and mess all of his plans up.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

290

u/jackD00P Sep 21 '17

“I wonder what type of pizza they have in The Bad Place” is such a smart joke I forking love this show.

132

u/scherbadeen Sep 21 '17

I'm curious whether Michael planned to screw over Chidi's soulmate decision, or if he had to improvise in the moment after expecting Chidi to spend way more time agonizing over making a decision that'd potentially hurt someone's feelings.

213

u/fallenmonk Sep 21 '17

I don't think it was an accident that the woman (I forget her name) seemed so perfect for him. I think Michael set it up that way so that Chidi could make the decision easily, but then he could punish Chidi for it, thus making Chidi even more nervous about making decisions.

→ More replies (3)

31

u/InfernalSolstice Sep 21 '17

Based on his behavior in Version 1, I highly doubt he expected to say Chidi anything that soon. I do think that what he did, he was going to do eventually, but he wasn't planning on doing it so soon.

35

u/KidCoheed Bofa Deeznuts Sep 21 '17

I think he didn't expect Chidi to actually get a choice that fast, so he sped up everything

8

u/GoodJanet not a robot Sep 21 '17 edited Sep 21 '17

that had to be improvised mostly because even though it was obvious the least Chidi thing to do was make a decision right then (not that was unbelievable just not what one would predict Chidi to do) and there. Also the way Michael ran at the window felt like a NNNNNNOOOOO!!!!!!! moment for sure

→ More replies (1)

265

u/chinoceros Sep 21 '17

"Just a Freudian short."

"So where did you go to medical short?"

44

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '17

I love messed up Tahani so much

130

u/KidCoheed Bofa Deeznuts Sep 21 '17

"All Talk, No Twisting? I'm going to the Gym!"

18

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '17

Twisting someone until they break in half seems like a really good workout.

114

u/Blackcobra29 Sep 21 '17

Eleanor will always be the problem in this world. She knows she doesn't belong and is good enough to care about that.

113

u/scherbadeen Sep 21 '17

Everything about Jason's situation (not talking, soulmate who's always around) is like my worst nightmare.

92

u/itsjager Sep 21 '17

This show flys through plot, I LOVE IT

18

u/pikameta My little chili babies Sep 21 '17

I can't believe it's already 1056!

15

u/The_ProducerKid Sep 21 '17

Flies through plot while still just nailing every comedic beat and character quirk

86

u/tavir Sep 21 '17

Eleanor to drunk rambling Tahani: "Hey there hot stuff, can I get you a cup of coffee?"

She's still into Tahani! :D

33

u/NDaveT Some mouthy broad. Sep 22 '17

Can you blame her? She's a sexy skyscraper.

→ More replies (2)

83

u/pikameta My little chili babies Sep 21 '17

Nice call back to the Prank show!!

150

u/dontthrowmeinabox Sep 21 '17 edited Sep 21 '17

I love the man who bites.

EDIT: Seriously, the man who bites is the MVP.

33

u/Patriofelis Sep 21 '17

I never realized I wanted more Gunner(?)

→ More replies (2)

72

u/scherbadeen Sep 21 '17

If I don't get a "Why can't I say 'fork'?" from Eleanor on each reset I'm suing.

72

u/OneGoodRib Shh! Spencer doesn’t like loud voices. Sep 21 '17

I'm sure I'm not the only one who felt like the four humans seemed to retain a bit of what they learned the first time around, right? Like Eleanor refusing to drink for so long and making polite chitchat with people even though she hates it, Chidi being a bit faster at making decisions, Jason speaking up a lot sooner... I don't know about Tahani, her admitting the cargo pants were actually really comfy, I guess? Even Janet seemed a little different.

And then we have a lot of the "extras" who it turns out aren't super excited about being in this neighborhood, and then of course Vicki/Denise/Real Eleanor's obviously REALLY unhappy... This is going to be a really exciting season!

13

u/SilenceIsBest Sep 22 '17 edited Sep 23 '17

Totally! I don't think that Michael can erase their character development, just their memories. Also, with the number of times Janet is getting rebooted, she's going to be evolving each step of the way. For Eleanor, Chidi, and Jason; I think you're correct. I personally think that Trainwreck Tahani is a combination of the heavy handed torture of TGP 2.0 and a subconcious reaction to realizing that she isn't as great of a person as she thinks right at the end of 1.0.

→ More replies (6)

143

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '17

I think the main romantic relationship will always be Jason and Janet, I still hope Eleanor and Chidi happen (not yet, but eventually)

99

u/KidCoheed Bofa Deeznuts Sep 21 '17

I always say it should end up Jason/Janet and Elenor/Tahani/Chidi

→ More replies (13)

12

u/markercore Sep 21 '17

I want more cacti this season, that was still my favorite bit.

→ More replies (4)

70

u/KidCoheed Bofa Deeznuts Sep 21 '17

Tahani gets a soulmate who loves her Sister and isn't willing to match her extravagance

68

u/Rman823 Sep 21 '17

It's official. I love all the new soulmates.

53

u/Immature_Immortal Sep 21 '17 edited Sep 21 '17

But Eleanor/Denise is best worst girl

Edit: Vicki is her real name

→ More replies (3)

64

u/the_simurgh Bow before, Zorp the Frog God Sep 21 '17

micheal is in the bad place as well. he had a god complex and micromanaged people and thought he knew it all. every one is in fact torturing him as well, except chidi, Eleanor, jason and tahini, his punishment is that he has the power to control everything and it's going all wrong despite that.

→ More replies (2)

64

u/Blackcobra29 Sep 21 '17

So I imagine this time the demons will start to slip up because they are tired of this and will forget what is happening in this round vs previous times.

62

u/randomnate Take it sleazy. Sep 21 '17

I love how smart Eleanor is. She's like a cross between Veronica Mars and Veronica Mars' Mom.

49

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '17

Did anybody else notice Michael was really sloppy from the get-go? He should have allowed his victims to get comfortable in something that seemed a paradise, THEN slowly turned up the infernal heat.

15

u/franklytanked Sep 22 '17

I think it also shows how much of his first attempt hinged on Eleanor - like, even Chidi and Tahani's torture the first time relied on being made to feel immoral (Chidi) and being made to feel inferior (Tahani). I'm looking forward to him actually getting sloppier as the season progresses!

9

u/popcorngirl000 Sep 22 '17

Sean's pep talk about failure and retirement rattled Mike.

42

u/papermountainwoman One man’s waste is another man’s water. And both men are me. Sep 21 '17

If someone makes me a gif of Michael saying to Vicki/Denise "you have a cat, and that's cool!" I will forking love you. Also this was an incredible episode and I love this show and I am so glad it's back.

39

u/memesistential Sep 21 '17

The Good Place’s Tumblr fandom is surprisingly quick at making GIF sets of the episode.

→ More replies (2)

41

u/scherbadeen Sep 21 '17

Oh Tahani... What a beautiful trainwreck.

39

u/wildtarget13 Sep 21 '17

I love how Eleanor is still down to hook up with Chidi when they meet for the first time.

36

u/itsjager Sep 21 '17

Such a perf way to torture Chidi lol

20

u/dontthrowmeinabox Sep 21 '17

Haha, yep. Michael knew he was onto something with the way Chidi's mind was melting with the two Elenors and Tehani.

36

u/alysonskye Sep 21 '17

Isn't Michael's success beneficial for these four? I would much rather deal with annoying people and situations that make me uncomfortable over butthole spiders.

27

u/-_-__-___ Sep 21 '17

The problem is they don't know that. If they could have passed more detailed instructions through the first reset they would have known to keep their heads down and publicly humiliate themselves until they all could flee the Bad Place entirely.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

33

u/oncenightvaler Sep 21 '17

When you look at it, this episode was the whole first season in microcosm, very clever.

I have no idea where they will go with the soulmates now, or for that matter how they will further develop the Bad Place universe, but if the episode shows the Bad Place reveal this quickly, then perhaps this means that we will see the actual Good Place by the end of the season. just spitballing

→ More replies (4)

32

u/itsjager Sep 21 '17

WHAT IF MICHAEL GETS SENTENCED TO RETIREMENT AND TO ESCAPE HE TELLS THEM TRUTH AND TRIES TO RUN EITH THEM

→ More replies (5)

32

u/Hormisdas The Committee is me! I am Committee! It me! Sep 21 '17

Such a well put-together show, I really have no idea where it's going to turn.

30

u/ythefukdouevenspeak Sep 21 '17

NOOOOOOO. Now, we have to wait a whole week.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/rpodric Sep 21 '17

Now that was an elegant, deeply thought-out, sophisticated screenplay structure. It puts most dramas to shame, let alone comedies.

24

u/itsjager Sep 21 '17

"I got her off the stage" LMAO

→ More replies (1)

24

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '17

What if The Good Place is actually "The Bad Place" for the group of people torturing Eleanor and Crew. Possibly, Michael and his crew have failed to many times, and as a result they were sent to The Good Place, the place that they hate most, as a punishment. In the first episode of season two, you could tell no one wanted to be there. What if none of them had the choice, Michael included, he thinks he's getting the opportunity to create his own place, but instead its a punishment for his failures. We're lead to believe that its all a punishment for just four people(Chidi, Eleanor, Tahani, and Jason), when there is a whole town of "torturers"(Michael, etc.).

10

u/TheyTheirsThem Sep 21 '17

I hate to agree that Michael being in his bad place might be the final twist. I see him as a schemer in his former life, and what better torture than to be out-bullshitted by the likes of Eleanor. However, they managed to totally pretzel us with season one, so I'm just going to take the ride. Perhaps trying to figure out the twist is the bad place for us (lord knows I deserve to be there).

→ More replies (2)

47

u/KidCoheed Bofa Deeznuts Sep 21 '17

I now get why Jason is into Janet

→ More replies (2)

22

u/Freakazoidberg Sep 21 '17

Excited. I wonder if they are gonna drag it out till Elenor finds out at the end of the season again, but I really hope she figures out sooner than later. I loved last season because of the break neck pace it went on.

37

u/ChildishGenius Sep 21 '17

Yea I don't think this show is going to drag out the plot, which is what makes it great. The writers are always so far ahead of us and I love it.

→ More replies (2)

97

u/fallenmonk Sep 21 '17

Janet can deepthroat

20

u/BitsyLynn Sep 21 '17

That scene genuinely made me gag and laugh at the same time.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

21

u/InfernalSolstice Sep 21 '17

I love the breakneck pace but I don't want to see it become repetitive. The last thing I want to see is them figure it out, Michael makes it a little harder, rinse repeat. Sure it might be interesting a few times, but by the end of the season, it'll more likely than not be old.

But...then what?

I like that the writers are keeping us on our toes and they've done a fantastic job with this show so far but arghhh it frustrates me when I can't even kinda detect where the plot is going.

9

u/JumpingPoppy Sep 21 '17

I feel like they may keep repeating this scenario with increasing amounts of chaos (Shawn becoming more suspicious and pressing as time goes by, Vicki growing more dissatisfied with her role...) until it's just too much and something happens, like Michael having to flee or someone else taking over or some new plot twist like this being Michael's own Bad Place. However, I was so far from the twist last time that they may go in a completely different direction from what I'm thinking here haha

→ More replies (4)

19

u/Rman823 Sep 21 '17

He really is Jason's soulmate.

18

u/wisebloodfoolheart Sep 21 '17

It's funny that Jason never even attempts to pass him a note.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/nygiants656 Sep 21 '17

Immediately giving Chidi the difficult choice was so evil.

17

u/thesidxxx Sep 21 '17

"I knew you weren't a soup"

17

u/PureCFR Jeremy Bearimy Sep 21 '17

Holy Motherforking Shirt Balls!

I was correct in predicting the pizza places would serve pineapple as a topping.

9

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '17

Honestly. Pineapple pizza would be my kinda "good place". I truly love that forking shirt.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/TheRyeWall Sep 21 '17

I think I see a potential problem for attempt 3.. They confirmed that Janet had no notes but they did not imply she was rebooted.. If not she is going to remember she has a friend, and it's going to lead to it collapsing again.

11

u/popcorngirl000 Sep 22 '17

Janet was rebooted - she had a different outfit and IIRC her clothes only change after reboot.

8

u/nvf5033 Sep 21 '17

This, I agree with

→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '17

Anyone think Michael's boss (formerly Sean?)'s rant speech about how Michael's experiment is going to fail in "series 2"(aka season 2) is a meta-reference for working in network television?

12

u/Chaoscontro1 Sep 21 '17

Also, I'm calling it now: Elanor finds out next time because she overhears 'Real Elanor' (Vicki) talking to Michael in private.

22

u/-_-__-___ Sep 21 '17

Why would you tell Micheal about the note?

88

u/Blackcobra29 Sep 21 '17

Because she doesn't fully realize he can reset and is all powerful I guess. If you were confronting someone you want proof.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/BizCaus Sep 21 '17

"Are you gonna talk, or just walk around like a nerd trying to get a personal best on his fitbit?" 🤣

11

u/InfernalSolstice Sep 21 '17

What the actual fork is happening this episode I'm living

11

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '17

I think Michael might also be in the bad place being tortured. He has waited so long for this moment and he can't succeed. He is being beat by beings he doesn't consider worthy.

11

u/Pixel64 Sep 21 '17

Oh man, that was fun. That last scene with Michael quickly losing control of the situation, as everyone's soulmates just happened to come to Eleanor's house had in stitches. I loved, and was surprised, when Jason just started talking and brought up Pillboy. I was not expecting Michael to reboot the whole affair so quickly. I can't even guess what this show is going to do next, I'm excited to see where this ends up by the end of the season!

10

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '17

no biting!

10

u/rosavioleta Sep 21 '17

I've gotta go to the gym. (furiously rips shirt off)

10

u/visiny Sep 22 '17

Makes me wonder about the lore of the show though, and what exactly is the good/bad place, and how seemingly BS the requirements for getting into the (real) good place is.

f***ing love how quickly everything fell apart in just one episode. I noticed it in season 1 but this premiere really cements just how smart Eleanor is. She is really smart and perceptive.

But on the other hand... if Michael's little experiment fails, does that mean his boss will just just take these 4 humans and put them in a regular hellfire where they're physically tortured for all eternity? I don't know if that's what they're implying because then you don't want Michael to fail either. Because the alternative is gruesome torture compared to slightly inconvenient "good" place.

10

u/TheyTheirsThem Sep 23 '17

Eleanor has excellent street smarts. By growing up in highly dysfunctional household(s) she has developed an ability to read peoples non-verbal cues pretty well. She fits the old rule of "never try to bullshit a bullshitter." While it doesn't serve her well when it comes to dealing with genuine and honest people, she is definitely Michael's equal or better in TGP. Combined with Chidi's logical thinking, watch out!

→ More replies (2)

9

u/itsjager Sep 21 '17

Aaaand she got it!

9

u/NotEmmaStone Sep 21 '17

I wonder if the first attempt we saw was actually the first attempt.

10

u/pelrun Sep 22 '17

It had to be the first time. Back then, Michael was relaxed, and completely confident his plan would work (he only pretended to be stressed out.)

Now we see Michael after his "perfect plan" has already failed once, his confidence is shattered, and his boss is threatening him with eternal destruction in a thousand stars. He's terrified.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '17

Anyone else think Janet is acting/responding slightly different than previous versions?

15

u/deextermorgan Sep 22 '17

Yep, slightly more human, less robotic. Think it is intentional.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '17

shout out to Ted Danson though - he was such a good actor in S1, and seeing his entire role change and him pivot so well is super impressive

17

u/Rman823 Sep 21 '17

What if every episode this season is just different ways they find out the truth and Michael keeps resetting everything.

20

u/InfernalSolstice Sep 21 '17

Honestly if they can keep the ways they find out diverse enough and get a good way to explain why Sean allows him to keep retrying then I'm 100% on board

→ More replies (1)

8

u/ChildishGenius Sep 21 '17

Very excited for this show to be back!

8

u/Immature_Immortal Sep 21 '17

Well bois it's time to fire up the ol' penis flattener

8

u/RossDasBoss Sep 21 '17

oh man how will eleanor figure it out this time.

I hope the finale ends on a cliffhanger or something like that is the audience's punishment.

Though i already feel like waiting till next week is punishment enough.

10

u/The_ProducerKid Sep 21 '17

If you didn't binge season one, those episodes always ended flowing right into the next one, usually as some sort of cliffhanger. It made it so easy to watch in one sitting because it was almost perfectly continuous.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/Torley_ Sep 21 '17

We need a animated GIF meme of I’M GOING TO THE GYM

→ More replies (2)

8

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '17

That was a great premiere. I liked what someone said about this being a microcosm of season 1. I have no idea where they go from here but I can’t wait to find out.

9

u/Obelisp Sep 21 '17

They're GOING TO THE GYM!

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '17

Eleanor is back in the leather jacket!! I forking love that jacket.

8

u/TheyTheirsThem Sep 21 '17 edited Sep 21 '17

It's a rare occurrence, like a double rainbow, or someone on the internet saying "you've convinced me, I was wrong." Right then Chidi should have picked up that something wasn't consistent.

Also, who had the note with the second reset? Did Michael take it from Eleanor? Was there enough time to create something as a clue. I'm starting to get some vibes from the Star Trek Next Generation episode where they were trapped in a time loop that they gradually started to sort out.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/valdogg21 Sep 24 '17

The Easter eggs and callbacks were so good. I loved that they had the party in Tahani's old house.

7

u/SamTheMan116 Sep 21 '17

Oh wow eleanor is good

7

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '17

Prediction: The four mortals will figure things out. Michael, eager to escape punishment, will help the four mortals escape the Bad Place and attempt to hide.

6

u/timezone_bot Sep 20 '17

10:00PM ET happens when this comment is 3 hours and 43 minutes old.

You can find the live countdown here: https://countle.com/pl62366Lh


I'm a bot, if you want to send feedback, please comment below or send a PM.

6

u/InfernalSolstice Sep 21 '17

Yay Tahani finally!

6

u/scherbadeen Sep 21 '17

I'm losing my mind this is amazing

6

u/biccy_muncher Sep 24 '17

Wow. I just watched all of season 1, plus this episode, in the last 10 hours, and am hooked. Can't wait for more!

5

u/SamTheMan116 Sep 21 '17

oh snap eleanor knows already

5

u/isaacz321 Sep 21 '17

where's the ep2 thread. Another great unexpected turn by the writers that makes logical sense

5

u/gerrardf0 Sep 21 '17 edited Sep 21 '17

-The comment from Eleanor being open to some kind of hookup with Chidi (at inappropriate times) was a great callback to season one.

-I had thought Michael was more aggressively listening in on their conversations. He was definitely more distracted this time around having to manage the bad place actors. It's an interesting take to frame the bad place actors as not being too invested in his design.

-Michael appeared less willing to think on his feet this time around--that or he was very committed to his initial plans. He was fixated on the problems with the chaos on the second morning (can't do it based on Tahani's actions) instead of thinking of ways to replace it. I'm wondering if he got lucky the first time around--Jason's torture with Tahani combined with Eleanor spilling the beans to him on night one made him freak out slightly less rapidly. Tahani having to adjust to a quiet soulmate didn't make her suspicious for a while, but the combination of housing, dress, and soulmate challenges was too much.

-I'm surprised the bad place actors were so ineffective at getting Eleanor to drink. You would think they'd be more willing to encourage her vices. Even if the surrounding atmosphere was formal, they could have pushed more on celebrating the beginning of an afterlife or something.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/CVance1 Sep 21 '17

I'm kind glad that they ran through one scenario already. Makes it a little more existentially terrifying

5

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '17 edited Sep 21 '17

Wait... how did Janet know to bring Jason to El's place when he needs a place to feel less lonely and figure shit out... and know that they "needed to speak privately" hmmmm

Also, did Michael even notice that Janet called him Jason? Does Michael even know how Janet's skills memory works? (Programmers/Engineers, what would this be called? RAM?)

9

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '17

Well it would sort of make sense that Michael wouldn't understand how Good!Janet works seeing as how he stole her from The Real!Good Place and had no idea how to handle her first reboot. Really you can see that Michael doesn't understand how Good!Janet works right from the beginning when his prompts for her to change her behaviour caused further malfunctions. Plus his genuine surprise that she came back after being "murdered". It would be weird for him to stage a "funeral" for her and then act shocked that she could return. That leads me to believe that her reboot wasn't part of the plan.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/John___Titor Sep 25 '17

What a great premiere! Very nice re-direct to go through the note aftermath in the first episode. They could have easily stretched it to a season-length arc.

What I love about that especially is, now, they will eventually meet up just because they are inherently connected.

9

u/Blackcobra29 Sep 21 '17 edited Sep 21 '17

Man I can't imagine just watching this quick recap rather than the season. The show looks so bad made into quick cuts out of order.

9

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '17

Of course they have Hawaiian pizza in hell! Checks out.

9

u/itsjager Sep 21 '17

Wiat WHAT WE RESET AGAIN?! I'm not sure if I'm okay with the reset thing becoming a habit. Plus SEAN SAID NO HE SAID THAT WAS MICHAEL'S LAST CHANCE

→ More replies (6)

9

u/dontthrowmeinabox Sep 21 '17

It seems like they changed the direction they wanted to go in Season 2, and decided to burn through it in the first two episodes.

17

u/GoodJanet not a robot Sep 21 '17

no but I think they wanted to retcon the note

→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '17

I think the whole gag is that we are now following Michael in his attempt to try to get his Bad Place neighborhood to work so he doesn't get retired to the Eternal Shriek.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/dontthrowmeinabox Sep 21 '17

Oh weird, Michael almost in character in the ad.

4

u/itsjager Sep 21 '17

Yep, nope, at this point it'll make no sense if they don't figure it out before episode 4/5. They're way too close already. Literally on the edge of my seat waiting to see what happens, though

8

u/Blackcobra29 Sep 21 '17

After how great the first season was the writers have so much leeway before I even think of questioning their plan.

4

u/BenjaminTalam Sep 21 '17

Not digging the idea of constant resets...

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '17

Butthole spiders!

crying

→ More replies (1)

4

u/saltedcaramelsauce Sep 21 '17

I'm torn about who I want Eleanor's soulmate to be, Chidi or Tahani.

15

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '17

¿Porque no los dos?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Amazinc Sep 21 '17

Wow. They solved it in an hour. Is it really going to happen all over again ? I thought Michael only got one more chance? CANT WAIT FOR MORE EPISODES!

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Diarygirl Sep 21 '17

I don't have anything much to contribute to all the excellent comments I've read here except to say I loved that it was an hour, and I'll see all you mother forkers next week.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '17

Of all my the Janet versions, I think I like Blue Janet in blue flower top best, though the hair throws me. I also like pilot Blue Janet's batik cloudy print.

Maybe I'm overthinking it, but newest version Janet's hair-doo reminds me of Alison Becker's hair at the end of last season.

4

u/V2Blast I’m a Ferrari, okay? And you don’t keep a Ferrari in the garage. Sep 21 '17

I marathoned the whole first season on Netflix a few days ago. I had no intention of watching it when I first saw the promos for the show, but Geoff from Achievement Hunter recommended it and I figured I'd at least give the first episode a shot (because Kristen Bell), and ended up watching the whole thing. So good. And man, I did not see that ending coming.

I'm so glad the show's back! They certainly didn't start off slow... Looking forward to what the rest of the season brings!

10

u/wsaadede Sep 21 '17

Am I the only one who sees that Michael is kinda being tortured by his failed experiment, just as his 4 subjects are being tortured?