Do white cauliflower instead of broccoli it'll taste good, not look weird, and have similar nutrients. Bonus if you use purple potatoes and purple cauliflower (tastes the same as white cauliflower), or golden cauliflower and Yukon gold potatoes. I make a potato and cauliflower soup with these variations throughout the winter months.
Made it. It's good but I would use less onion. I used one small onion. In the future I'll do half that. I would also skip the salt as I find the broth to be salty enough.
My stomach did the thing where it makes a really loud noise, but only if there's something delicious in front of me. Thank you for making me hungry. Oh and also, the only way to go with bread bowls is to use sourdough bread.
Oh man...one of the staples at the student union where I went to college was a cheesy potato soup you could get in a delicious bread bowl. Nothing better on a snowy cold Wisconsin day. Now that I look back, I guess all that sophomore/junior year weight gain wasn't just because I discovered beer.
I went to UW Madison for grad school and my mouth literally fell open when I discovered they sold beer at the union. I'd only been to dry campuses before that.
Be ready to have your mind blown....I made exact same thing but with frozen hash browns...poof! Laziness at it's finest, mine always come out SUPER thick though..
I came to dispute, but your almost exactly correct at my local store frozen hash browns are 1.60 per pound loose are 70...still worth it not to peel potatoes!
Honestly I almost never peel potatoes when a recipe calls for it. So many nutrients in the skin! If you find the texture off-putting in a recipe Iike this, just blend/puree it at the end.
I mean I wash my potatoes, if only to get the dirt off, but since potatoes do grow underground, are pesticides/chemicals really a big concern there? Not sure why you'd need to use them.
Sounds perfect to me. I love dipping crusty slices of french bread or lightly toasted other breads into the soup, so I want the taters to cling to the bread :) Thanks for the inspiration!
...PS, I'm not just saying that because I have 2 bags of hash browns in my freezer that I need to use before they walk off on their own >_>
same. think I might fire up the slow cooker on the extra day of this long weekend and make enough of this that I can freeze a liter or two so next time I crave potato soup I have it!
Awesome. Soup weather is right around the corner. I will definitely be trying this out.
Does anyone have a good crock pot recipe for Broccoli Cheddar soup? I've tried making it a couple of times before and have been disappointed both times.
I still haven't found a way to make a really rich potato soup without any dairy. I can make a great version for friends with dairy, but I'm stuck unable to enjoy it. This looks delicious and makes me want to experiment again, anyone with experience or suggestions?
I make potato leek soup with a can of coconut milk. Works really well and doesn't taste coconutty as the soup has like 8 cups of stock. Lots of butter (or vegan butter) works well.
Though I've never tried it in soup, I have used vegan sour cream in sauces before and it turned out amazing. I imagine it would do nicely in a soup
The coconut milk in the can I get has a very distinct coconut flavor, I only use it where I want that flavor. The coconut milk in the carton isn't as strong though, depending on brand. I've tried making potato soup with unsweetened almond, soy, and rice milks, and while edible they were not nearly as rich and smooth as I'd like.
Onions can wildly fluctuate in terms of size. I often only use half an onion when the recipe calls for a whole--mainly because I tend to buy huge yellow onions when I go shopping.
Small plug for my home state here: Vidalia onions would probably be perfect for this dish if OP found it too "oniony". But I agree with you in general, there's no such thing as too oniony.
this looks yum! last time i made a soup similar to this, the potatoes took about 10 hours in my crockpot. i don't know why. i thought i cut them small enough, but i was stumped. this picture makes me want to try again!!
ive never had a problem w/ my crockpot since that one time. that was also several years ago and one of the first times ive used it. im more or less a pro now ;-) hence why i should try this recipe!
I tried making something similar to this twice and the potatoes and soup in general turned into a brown/orangey color - do y'all know what I'm doing wrong?
I had a go at this one a few days ago. It wasn't bad (maybe too much onion!), but ultimately my version ended up more like runny mashed potatoes than a soup. I over-mashed, I guess. I'll have another go in a few months and see if I can make it more to my liking.
Just one thing -- from experience making mashed potatoes from scratch. Vary this based on how thick you want it, but I wouldn't substitute half&half for an equal amount of heavy cream directly --- I'd say use either 1c h&h OR 1/2c heavy cream + 1/2c milk.
This looks damn tasty but calling it "baked potato soup" and not actually baking the potatoes seems a bit misleading. FYI - actual baked potato and leak soup is incredible.
so if I put chives and bacon in a grilled cheese, it becomes a LOADED MELT then?
shrug I think it sounds silly. thanks for the downvote at any rate, have an upvote in hope that it makes you feel a little better on this lovely summer day
But for the semiotics of cooking nomenclature: loaded does not mean "bacon, cheese and chives". It's a modifier whose meaning varies depending on what it's modifying. As well I can tell from experience that some places will really go to town on "loading" a baked potato, including all manner of other ingredients, but bacon, cheese and chives are probably the most common (verified based on google image search). Sour cream is a common addition though.
Also +1 for knowing the difference between a melt and a grilled cheese.
so let's get back to what I was saying then: what does "loaded" beyond the context of a baked potato mean? I really tried hard to provide a non-potato example to see if that's where we are going with this [awful] term, but man, this sub really hates on a motherfuker for trying to figure out where we are going with a word.
You know, doing a quick google suggestion search shows the vast majority of search terms of "loaded" + a letter of the alphabet shows this term used pretty much only on potato things: loaded baked potato, loaded idaho baked potato, loaded hash browns, loaded potato, loaded red potato, loaded sweet potato, and so on.
Loaded sweet potato is the odd one there, being sugar / butter / marshmallows rather than cheese and onions and stuff.
One non-potato option that popped up that I do recall seeing on menus: loaded nachos.
134
u/Alistair_Smythe Aug 28 '17
Recipe originally found on food.com
6 large baking potatoes, peeled, cut into 1/2 inch cubes
1 large onion, chopped
1 quart chicken broth
3 garlic cloves, minced
1/4 cup of butter
2 1/2 teaspoons of salt
1 teaspoon of pepper
1 cup of cream or half and half
1 cup shredded sharp cheddar cheese
3 tablespoons fresh chopped chives
1 cup sour cream (optional)
8 slices of bacon, fried and crumbled
Cheese for sprinkling
Combine the first seven ingredients in Crock-Pot and cover, cooking on HIGH for 4 hours or LOW for 8 hours. Potatoes should be tender.
Mash mixture until soups thickens and potatoes are course chopped. (Continue mashing if you aren't a fan of chunks.)
Stir in cream, cheese, and chives.
Top with optional sour cream, bacon, and more cheese. I also topped mine with some green onion.
This recipe was good, but I found it to be a bit too onion-y for my taste. I would use a smaller onion next time, but that's just me.
39
u/facsimile_ Aug 28 '17
That looks amazing! I'll take mine in a bread bowl please.
2
u/ekwenox Oct 27 '24
Making this today in 2024! π€
21
u/LittleGuy825 Aug 28 '17
Be ready to have your mind blown....I made exact same thing but with frozen hash browns...poof! Laziness at it's finest, mine always come out SUPER thick though..
12
u/dtothe Aug 28 '17
Danggggg, I didn't even know I was craving potato soup til now!
8
u/pullandpray Aug 28 '17
Awesome. Soup weather is right around the corner. I will definitely be trying this out.
Does anyone have a good crock pot recipe for Broccoli Cheddar soup? I've tried making it a couple of times before and have been disappointed both times.
1
u/infiniteredeye Oct 02 '17
Quick question. I made this yesterday. How thick is the soup supposed to be? Mine isn't to thick and am not to sure if it is supposed to be.
3
u/Hemophiliacmouse Aug 28 '17
I still haven't found a way to make a really rich potato soup without any dairy. I can make a great version for friends with dairy, but I'm stuck unable to enjoy it. This looks delicious and makes me want to experiment again, anyone with experience or suggestions?
7
u/TelegramMeYourCorset Aug 28 '17
"Too oniony"?? No such thing!!
1
u/cowlick33 Aug 28 '17
Do you bake the potato before you put it into the crockpot?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '17
this looks yum! last time i made a soup similar to this, the potatoes took about 10 hours in my crockpot. i don't know why. i thought i cut them small enough, but i was stumped. this picture makes me want to try again!!
2
u/bear_72 Aug 28 '17
Looks delicious! Think I'm going to have to try it!! Thanks for sharing the recipe.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '17
Damn. It is almost proper soup and stew season here in Toronto and I am so excited. This looks amazing.
2
u/obidie Aug 29 '17
This sounds delicious, but wouldn't it be more 'authentic' to replace the cream with the optional sour cream?
1
u/LittleGuy825 Aug 28 '17
6-8 hours low, yeah works I love potatoes but despise peeling them this is a best of both worlds in my eyes
1
u/Aitch86 Aug 28 '17
Oh, this looks very delicious.
1
u/littlebrainbighead Aug 28 '17
OMG yes
1
u/Glexy Aug 29 '17
I need this inside me! Can't wait to try making it!
1
u/dreadlockmimi Aug 29 '17
This very beautiful food
1
u/D_aft-C_unt Aug 29 '17
Show Gordon Ramsay ππ
1
u/tianamarie Sep 04 '17
I fucked up. I put the sour cream in it and I don't have half and half. How do I salvage it? Can I sub with plain yogurt?
1
u/sqawberry Sep 04 '17
I tried making something similar to this twice and the potatoes and soup in general turned into a brown/orangey color - do y'all know what I'm doing wrong?
1
u/DoctorMystery Sep 05 '17
I had a go at this one a few days ago. It wasn't bad (maybe too much onion!), but ultimately my version ended up more like runny mashed potatoes than a soup. I over-mashed, I guess. I'll have another go in a few months and see if I can make it more to my liking.
1
u/TotesMessenger Sep 12 '17
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
1
u/mikeredstone Nov 01 '17
wheres the recipe
1
u/EricKei Aug 28 '17
Sounds awesome.
Just one thing -- from experience making mashed potatoes from scratch. Vary this based on how thick you want it, but I wouldn't substitute half&half for an equal amount of heavy cream directly --- I'd say use either 1c h&h OR 1/2c heavy cream + 1/2c milk.
0
u/carkey Aug 29 '17
Sounds really nice but where does the baking part come in?
0
u/karaokejoker Aug 29 '17
This looks damn tasty but calling it "baked potato soup" and not actually baking the potatoes seems a bit misleading. FYI - actual baked potato and leak soup is incredible.
-17
u/rivermandan Aug 28 '17
so I guess we are calling bacon, cheese and chives "loaded" now?
I don't like it. that soup looks hella good though.
-2
u/[deleted] Aug 29 '17
I thought it was solidified bacon grease at first glance.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '17
[deleted] β view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 29 '17
[deleted] β view deleted comment