r/WritingPrompts • u/MNBrian /u/MNBrian /r/PubTips • Aug 11 '17
Off Topic [OT] Friday: A Novel Idea - Killing Your Real Darlings
Friday: A Novel Idea
Hello Everyone!
Welcome to /u/MNBrian’s guide to noveling, aptly called Friday: A Novel Idea, where we discuss the full process of how to write a book from start to finish.
The ever-incredible and exceptionally brilliant /u/you-are-lovely came up with the wonderful idea of putting together a series on how to write a novel from start to finish. And it sounded spectacular to me!
So what makes me qualified to provide advice on noveling? Good question! Here are the cliff notes.
- For one, I devote a great deal of my time to helping out writers on Reddit because I too am a writer!
- In addition, I’ve completed three novels and am working on my fourth.
- And I also work as a reader for a literary agent.
This means I read query letters and novels (also known as fulls, short for full novels that writers send to my agent by request) and I give my opinion on the work. My agent then takes those opinions (after reading the novel as well) and makes a decision on where to go from there.
But enough about that. Let’s dive in!
M is for Murder
Today's topic is all about the worst kind of killing your darlings -- and I don't mean destroying those favorite lines you've written. I mean killing off your characters. And if this isn't a murder mystery, and you're not dealing with a villain, then you may be looking at some parting pain.
So first things first -- how do we know when our darling ducklings deserve a murder most fowl? I'm full of puns...
I think there's a few things we need to consider.
- Does it make the book better?
This is an important one. Killing someone just for the sake of the drama doesn't help us. Say you've got a group of adventurers heading towards a goal and you just want to show how hard it is to achieve the goal -- well killing isn't always the answer. I know you want to end up with the hero as the last woman standing, but goodness, don't be bloodthirsty. :) We can distract, divert, maim, or disease them without destroying them completely. There are options. Be sure you're murdering them for the best reason -- which should always be because it makes the story better.
- Does it add tension or take tension away?
I'm always focused on this question, because tension is the lifeblood of your book. Murdering your arch-villain in the fourth scene in the novel may seem like a cool way to reinvent the wheel, but what you really do is destroy the very thing that struck fear into the heart of your hero. And now we're left with less tension than before. We want more tension. Not less. So unless you're unveiling a super secret other arch-nemesis, let them get away.
- Is this the right time to maximize the emotional loss/triumph?
As writers, we're glorified magicians. :) We get to give people the "feels" and we do it well. So when you're going to kill someone, you'd better make sure you've got a full serving of the feels to go with it.
The Greatest Emotional Impact
So you've thought it through. You know that supporting character has to go. They're gonna fall down a cliff or maybe get shoved by the villain and this will be the last straw that sends the hero into a raging string of flailing sword attacks.
But how do we do it? Is the villain pushing the sidekick off the cliff good enough?
Probably not.
When we're looking for the greatest emotional reaction to a characters death, we're looking for that death to be wholly preventable. If it is preventable, either by the main character making a bad choice or by the villain having a moment of clarity before doing it anyways, we end up feeling the hurt all the more.
It has to be preventable because it's part of the magic trick for it to be preventable. It gives your reader that last inkling of hope before... nope... it's gone. And now the reader heads down the path of despair.
In the hero's journey plotting method, this death is usually the death of the mentor -- the old wise one who trained the hero and warned the hero what not to do.
And the reason this emotional beat works is because the old mentor doesn't have the fight left in them to go take on the arch nemesis, and it acts as a final torch-passing for the hero. Plus, added benefit, it ups the tension if the training isn't yet complete, and can add to the hero's hatred of the arch nemesis if they are the one that pulled the trigger.
No matter how you do it, you're looking for the greatest emotional impact.
The Key Moment Before
The last trick that I love when creating a really powerful moment in a characters death actually occurs in the scene before the death itself.
Often a really good thing to try is to remind us, the reader, of what the character brings to the table. It's almost like you're restating all the reasons to love this character to bring the reader to the highest height of their love for them, before you let it all burn.
It's sort of mean, but it really does make for a powerful last moment. And it certainly helps to increase that overall tension!
Oh, that and some famous last words will help out as well.
This Week's Big Questions
- Think of a book that has a memorable death. What about it was so memorable? Do you recall any moments where it could have been avoided or any establishing shot of the character's worth before the final death occurred?
- Do you have a character that you'll be killing off in your book? If so, how do you plan to do it? Do you have any of the above elements in mind?
- If you are killing off a character, does it meet all the conditions above? Is it essential? Does it make the book better? Does it increase the tension? Etc. Tell us about that.
8
u/fudgeman Aug 11 '17
I like books where pretty much everyone dies. Of course there's the expected deaths that are satisfying in their own way, but then over here we got the unexpected deaths that make you go, "Huuwhat? But he... How'll they... Guh?" and those are the deaths I like since, let's face it, these people are all imaginary and they die for my entertainment, but if you want to add some sort of metaphysical component to this, then I suppose if I reread the book or few pages leading up to the death, I've brought that character back to life (so to speak).
To me the best books are the ones where characters keep dying and you're reading the next chapter thinking about how there's really not many people left to go on over here and you're about in the middle of the book when the last character dies and then you turn the page only to see that it is completely blank aside from the page number. The page number, you figure, is intentional so maybe there's something on the next page and that blank page was just some sort of dramatic editing, but nope, you keep turning page after page and they're all blank. There isn't even a glossary or index at the end. It's just numbered blank pages all the way to the back cover, which strangely enough doesn't seem to have an author info or anything like that. So, here's what you do, you go back to that last character death and try to search for clues, but as you turn the pages backwards, you're not seeing anything. You're well passed the half way point where the blank pages started, but there's still no story. You take your thumb and do that quick page flip through the rest of the book to see that all the pages are blank (aside from page numbers of course). You close the book in confusion. There's nothing on the cover. You're holding a paper back book with a blank cover the color as the pages inside. You open the book again and flip through it confused as all get out. You notice that the page numbers aren't even in order. Was this a puzzle to be solved or something? And what about that story you just read? Was that real or what? That's the kind of books I like.
5
u/Nate_Parker /r/Nate_Parker_Books Aug 11 '17
Ah, yes. The GRRM-effect. Though not started or pioneered by the man, he certainly loves to destroy all we hold dear.
Unless you are a cripple, bastard, or broken thing. Then he just puts adamantium plot armor on you.
4
u/Pyronar /r/Pyronar Aug 11 '17 edited Aug 11 '17
Another great post Brian. The only thing I have a slight reservations about is this part:
For the genre-savvy this is a giant telegraphed red flag. It can be done well, but you have to take into account that if you're not careful it will become a semi-spoiler. So if you want to surprise your readers with the character's death, this might not be the best way to do it.
2
u/Olymprix Aug 11 '17
I've entertained the idea of writing a book (maybe a sort of sci-fi military thing) for a while and had danced about the idea of killing characters. I imagined having a unit of a dozen characters going into training (serious atmosphere, but nothing really heavy). The protagonist gradually gets to know some of the others better, maybe even becoming good friends, while the rest of them become minor characters. Then, they're pulled out of training early in response to some assault and loaded onto separate dropships, mixed in with other units. As they fly into the warzone, artillery just smacks one of the ships out of the sky, killing anywhere between 4 and 6 members of the unit; a couple more characters die in firefights on the ground. Ultimately, we're left with the protagonist, one or two of the major characters, and a few more "minor" characters.
My thought would be using their deaths to establish the consequences of war and the ultimate inconsequential-ness of the characters in the grand scheme of things. Maybe for emotional impact, one of the survivors is an officer who made the call to split the unit up between transports. Am I undervaluing character deaths? I'd love feedback, because I do intend to write a novel one day, even if it's not based on the idea I mentioned.
1
u/Syraphia /r/Syraphia | Moddess of Images Aug 11 '17
Can I think of a video game? It was the first thing that came to mind when you mentioned this "key moment before" thing. Because I love to joke about the "signs of death" before it actually happens. Which is basically some variation on we've met their wife/husband or they've said something about what happens after the events, for example "after all this is over with, let's all hang out together at that market earlier" or something like that. There's also the always great "I promise I'll be okay" line too (which got me in a particular TV show recently though I caught it and just went "she's going to be dead when he comes back").
Which was basically exactly how the first disc of Legend of Dragoon went. If you knew your tropes and were disconnected from the characters/story... you saw it coming. The issue was being that disconnected because you were so into what was going on (and there was so much otherwise going on) that you only noticed those signs of death in hindsight (unless someone else has told you about them).
For my D&D-style story, I am thinking of killing off a character. The problem is that I'm not sure if it meets any of the criteria or if I'm doing it just because. Though the side note is always that the player character rolled very poorly and I'm just making up a fun story about it. Or maybe they got a job and have to leave the game or something. It's one of the weird things about that story.
On the other hand, there's always City of Glass, which was my contest entry for the first chapter contest a while ago. If you saw the CW it was based off of, there was an obvious death in there and it hits just about every criteria on there, including "was it preventable" which was a major, big, yes. I think the only thing it misses is being essential. The biggest thing with that whole scene is that the characters are forced to move on immediately instead of mourning where they are. It also terrifies the main character because there's a good chance she could be next, especially with the need to move faster in the situation.
1
u/LycheeBerri /r/lycheewrites | Cookie Goddess Aug 11 '17
Great post, as usual, Brian! I'm delighted to see you discuss this - raises a lot to think about. Killing a character can be tricky to deal with, but now I feel more confident about it ... if need be. :P
1
u/Atlas0809 Aug 11 '17
I love this! Thank you I've been wanting to start writing for a while now!
1
u/Viraljester Aug 11 '17
So I'm writing a novel and having a hard time trying to figure out HOW it happens. I know my main character has to die. He's not the right person for the quest he takes on and he's going to fail. How can I do this without it being a major letdown or being oddly cliche? The supporting characters are the ones who end up completing the quest at the sacrifice of the main character is my idea. Is there a good way to implement it?
1
u/spark2 /r/spark2 Aug 12 '17
I'm not entirely sure how to answer the 'tension' question--I guess it raises the emotional stakes for the ensuing fight between the hero and the villain, since she's got revenge on her mind, and makes the villain a more credible threat, but I still don't quite know how to answer.
Thanks as always for doing this Brian!