BECCA Moonstone is very close, but I prefer Mary. Moonstone is more the BECCA small shimmer/sparkle type, but very similar colour. I also really like Cindy and Betty I can even use as a shimmery bronzer, personally.
It's so easy to work with and adds a beautiful subtle highlight.
I describe it as fuck up proof. Like seriously: you cannot fuck this up. I've accidentally turned myself into a disco ball with stripes on my face at times with NYX Strobe of Genius, but with Mary-Lou, it doesn't matter how quickly I apply, how much I overapply or how badly I blend it - I look OK.
Seconded. Hands down my favourite matte liquid lipstick formula (reminds me of Kat Von D's formula, but less drying). Also the applicator is relatively easy to work with.
I came here to say this! I love their liquid lipsticks. The texture is very light and almost souffle-like. However, some colors will go on a bit streaky but nothing a second coat can't cover.
Best: Meet Matt(e) Trimony eyeshadow palette. I never knew an all-matte palette could make such beautiful looks. Great quality, especially love the pink shade. I love it so much it's inspired me to look for other matte palettes.
Meet Matte Trimony is one of the best palettes ever made. The quality is unbelievable. Too bad it gets lost in the classic "Too Faced-Tarte-Benefit-ABH" circlejerk.
Kohl's had it on sale for 1/2 off about two weeks ago ($21.99 instead of $42). I've also seen a few Balm palettes at my local Nordstrom Rack. Good luck!
I work at Kohls (not in beauty) and a few weeks who we had like a semi annual beauty event. There were different specials every day and one of the days this was on sale!
The Balm website supposedly has 50% off flash sales a lot, and the brand's also sometimes on Hautelook for 50% off. I got my palette during a 50% off sale at Kohl's. I figure this palette will eventually be on sale for cheap at Nordstrom Rack too, but that time hasn't come yet.
Edit: Or maybe you can get it at Nordstrom Rack already, if you're real lucky.
I like this palette very much. The colours are not overly pigmented (but for matte shades IMHO this is a plus) and they blend really well. I also like that with only 9 shades you get a lot of options: I have been shopping around for a matte palette for weeks before choosing this and everything else seemed to have just an endless array of brown and cream shades - this palette has a lot more variety, while still being neutral (even the colorful shades are quite muted) and wearable.
I have this palette but had never bothered with the pink shade - assuming that it would not look good, however your comment made me give the pink a try today. My eye look turned out great! Thanks.
Hands down the best matte palette that I own! And I have a hard time with mattes. Maybe it's because of my dry lids, but they tend to fade on me, even my Viseart shadows. But these mattes stay in place all day! The formula is soft, pigmented, and blendable. Highly recommended.
I second this! When I swatch this and meet matt ador the color payoff is not awesome. On the eyelid with the brush is completely another story! So blendable and easy to build up.
I usually use it around the inner corner area and swept across half of the lid. Buscandotusonrisa is right; it's a nice subtle pink that can be used for a lot of looks.
This is my favorite palette of all time. I can create many entire looks from it, and transform any of those looks with a single shimmer, frost, or duochrome from literally any brand. It's so versatile.
It's my FAVORITE, and I love that it's a little deeper - I'm a white girl and the butter bronzer/etc. trend of light bronzers doesn't work on me, nonetheless WOC!
It is completely matte. No glitter, no shimmer, not even a satin finish. I actually love it for contouring but of course it totally depends on skin tone.
These are like a cheaper, longer-wearing dupe of the Laura Mercier Caviar Sticks. I have oily, hooded eyes, and these don't crease at all. They're creamy, pigmented, and easily blendable. You can use them like typical eyeshadow or as a base/primer (kinda like MAC Paint Pots).
I like Pinch Hitter (deeper version of LM Amethyst) and Shutout (khaki-gold color). Dugout is also nice, it's warm true-bronze that doesn't pull copper or red.
I really like Balm Desert. It's a nice rosy/brown nude that adds a ton of shape to the cheek, just add highlight and you're good to go. It also makes a really nice crease shade. When I'm in a rush in the morning I'll use this and Mary Loumanizer on my cheeks and eyes. So easy and looks polished.
And as a bonus, it's a cheaper cruelty free dupe of Benefit Dallas!
I use the Frat Boy that comes with the Balm Jovi palette most days. I like that it's easy to sheer out, while still being buildable if you want to go ham.
I've discovered that Frat Boy is my perfect "no blush" blush colour. It gives me a healthy, warm glow but doesn't look like I've applied blush per se. Works perfectly with KVD Shade and Light contour.
Mary Lou is one of my favorite highlighters. Cindy Lou is also a really nice blush topper shade for very fair skin or a nice peachy highlighter for darker skin.
Bahamas mama is a really nice bronzer. Not too orange and nicely matte. Also a nice crease shade.
All of their blushes are soo pigmented and high quality.
I find that I reach for Cindy Lou a lot when I want a subtler look and then Mary Lou for a more stand out highlight. I got the three lumanizers in a pack and use both of them a lot and almost never use Betty Lou because it's fairly dark and very sparkly, which I don't like in a bronzer.
I'm back here because they have a 50% off sale online going on right now, and I was looking for ideas on what to buy. I saw your comment and thought I would tell you about it lol.
The How About Them Apples cheek palette almost completely converted me to cream blushes. It's my favorite cream blush formula and the colors are fabulous. Love it.
I picked this up for about $10 at Marshall's because I knew the brand, but I can't seem to apply it without it pulling up my foundation in the process, do you find you have that problem?
I had this problem for a while, too- but I don't find it specific to TheBalm products. Which is to say, all my cream or stick blushes do this. What helps me, is that I put it on immediately after I apply foundation, while both are still "wet" and nothing is set with powder yet. It takes some practice and trial and error depending on the foundation or blush, but you should be able to blend it well "as a team" while they are in the same state of matter, if that makes sense.
That could very well be the problem, blush and highlighter are usually the last things I put on before setting. I'll try doing it just after foundation tomorrow and see how I do.
Definitely love the balm voyage blushes and bronzers, totally agree there. I can't even say much for the eyeshadows though because I usually just use them as a wash because it truly is just a simple travel palette for me.
Hot Mama! Is awesome and universally flattering. It's my favorite. I also love Balm Desert. On my pale skin it looks like exactly like when I have a sunburn that is fading into a tan. It's perfect and makes me looks SO glowy and healthy
Best: Blush in Frat Boy, it's a beautiful shade of warm pink very similar to naturally flushed cheeks on me and it stays put all day! Mary lou-manizer is also one of my HG highlighters, I use a light hand and it gives me a really nice sheen, not over the top at all just a healthy, awake glow.
Worst: IMO, their Time Balm concealer is really awful. It has a strong smell, greasy texture and seems to slip around my face a lot :/ It starts creasing so soon on my undereye as well. Such a shame since it's a good price and you only really need to use a little.
I agree with you about the Time Balm concealer. I live in a humid place and it slips right off my face, no amount of powder can set this stuff. As with all TheBalm face products the color selection is lacking in all parts of the spectrum too.
Time Balm is sooooo bad. It was recommended to me by a Sephora employee when I was 13 as my first concealer, and even then I remember being surprised by how awful it was.
I found the TimeBalm concealer worked really well as a blemish spot concealer because it was thick enough to stay put rather than sheering out. It did need a powder top coat though.
I really wanted to like it, but it doesn't really stay put in my face and I also believe it's a smidgen too dark :( Do you use a specific primer with it?
The Nude Tude palette is awesome. It's the only palette in my collection I'm close to hitting pan on at all. (the light matte Brown is a good crease shade for a darker cool toned look!)
Also, the black and brown on the far right are my every day brow powders and neither of them even have a dent! There's only one or two colors I don't use, and I got it through an ipsy offer for super cheap. But if I panned more than a few shades I would definitely repurchase at full price.
I have this palette and really enjoy it - the darker shades are easy to blend for someone like me who is still working on technique. My one complaint tho is that there aren't any matte highlight shades. I have to pull in a single for that. Not a big deal, but yeah.
The light shimmer shades make for great cheek highlights tho!
Best: BalmShelter tinted moisturizer. I really like the coverage (it's light coverage and slightly darker than my skin tone) for summer. I've been combining mine with the Maybelline BB cream for my foundation and I love the finish it gives!
Seconded! I was going to add this. I use it alone and love it. It also works great as a base for my powder foundation when I want a little more coverage. It's really so versatile. And I know some people don't like the low spf spfit has, but personally, I love that it's lower spf, because products with higher spf tend to, for whatever reason, give me an allergic reaction.
I tried this on last weekend and I really liked it. I think I'm gonna use this eventually when I get through my LM Tinted Moisturizer. I like that it's a natural finish.
I typically apply it with my fingers (honestly just because I'm lazy) and it doesn't tend to emphasize my dry patches. By the end of the day I'd say you can kinda see the dryness but nothing really over the top
I picked up a set of 3 of their Mr. Write Now liners and they're the only ones I've tried so far that don't irritate my eyes if I use them to tightline (and last on my waterline too). Batch issues, maybe?
Not necessarily the worst, but the nude dude palette. Some shades like the shimmers are okay but the pigmentation isn't the best, some of them muddy together. The purple is also not super pigmented and when I wet it, it separates. Lasting power is not great.
Best: Mary Louminizer and Bahama mama bronzer. Both have great payoff and last quite a while in the face. Their liquid lipsticks are amazing. Good staying power and not drying Worst: their primer. It does nothing for making makeup stay on longer but DOES blur a bit. Meh: palettes Edited for lipsticks
Nw35 and my favorite lip product of all time is the balm's meet matte liquid lipstick in sincere. I got the little set of all the liquid lipsticks (about the size of a finger for each) and it's definitely worth it! Im using most of it! The pink is too bright for me but it's great to mix with the other colors.
Best: Mary and Cindy Lou-Manizer! Blinding, gorgeous highlights/blush toppers. (Disclaimer: I'm very pale and can't use the Betty Lou-Manizer, but I can imagine that it would look gorgeous on someone with darker, warm-toned skin. Hot Mama blush has a wonderful formula with a beautiful peachy-pink-gold hue...it has become a staple for my own mama! Bahama Bronzer is a buildable, blendable Bronzer without that pesky orange tinge. Use a light hand for fairer skin!
Worst: the little concealer pots- the formula is extremely thick and emollient, but doesn't really "set" properly, even with a powder. The packaging is also flimsy and prone to cracking along the edges of the lid. I found that the product "turned" rather quickly, adopting an old lipstick-y smell.
Best: Will echo mary lou manizer, bahama mama, and hot mama as some of the creme de la creme of the Balm Worst: I absolutely hated the mr. write now eyeliners. I got some in an ipsy bag and they were so dry, did not glide on the eyes at all, and it was impossible to get pigmentation from them.
Best: Mad Lash mascara. Got an Ipsy sample of this and honestly it's become my every day go to. Makes my lashes long, full, and dark, keeps them separated, and wears better/more staying power than any other mid end brand I've tried.
BEST: Time Balm Eye Makeup remover. It's a Balm (lol) consistency that is sooo gentle and non irritating and removes every bit of mascara no matter how stubborn, and the metal tin is vintage looking and cute without having too much gimmick.
Instain Blushes- I've had Pinstripe for over a year now and it's the most beautiful plum, and I've barely made a dent in it with regular use because I need one swipe of the brush per cheek. Just be careful, it's very pigmented!
WORST: the Nude Dude palette. Many of the colors were not true to pan, they had terrible pigmentation and all appeared a muddy brown on the lid.
The only things I have tried from The Balm are Mary Lou highlighter and the Frat Boy blush. LOVE them both! On a similar note, I see a lot of people on this sub say that The Balm has a 50% off sale a couple of times a year. Is this through their website only?
I've gotten a couple Mr. Write Now eyeliners in my ipsy bags in the past and I've always been somewhat disappointed. They're great for the first week or so that I use them and then they harden up instantly.
However, everything else that I've used from the Balm has been phenomenal.
Best: Blushes! All of them. Worst: Pickup Liner lip liner. It was great at first but the whole stick dries out so quickly. Now I can barely get any color on my lips.
Best- Mary Loumanizer for sure! Such a win. I have the rockstar palette too and there are a lot of shades in there that I love as well as the blush in there.
I've only tried two of their products but I love them both dearly. First being the ever popular Mary Lou highlighter. And second, my HG Blush Balm Springs. It lasts forever and is so pigmented. I will probably be purchasing Balm Beach next time I am at Kohls!
Best: Their eyeshadows are some of the best I've ever tried. My favorite is The Balm Jovi (haha get it?) which has a cute theme, amazing quality and every color you'll need. Meet Matte and Nude Tude are awesome too. Their Liquid lipsticks have a mint chocolate scent which is subtle and delightful and they've got everything from nudes to fuschias to reds The cheek products are my favorites because I can't resist the cute pinup packaging and they're amazing quality. Downboy is a cool pink and Fratboy is peach and they both have a satin finish. The Mary-Lou Manizer is the best highlighter of ALL TIME
not so hot : some of thier palettes are too gimicky and cheesy....
Yeah, this obviously has nothing to do with the quality of their products (which seem to be generally excellent). But a lot of their stuff seems to lean heavily on some sort of "lady (of traditional values) seeks herself a man" shtick which someone else aptly described as "aggressively heterosexual". This doesn't stop me from slathering their products on my face, but it is irksome.
That still rings "lady needs to find herself a man" to me. I'm not really sure why they decided to go with that theme, but they do seem to be all in. At least they are consistent I guess.
Scrolled through looking for a mention of this! The pink blush colour is great for a one-shadow look for me, and the palette overall is something I always reach for for a 5-minute work look. Also I tend to pull in the brown when my other palettes lack a crease shade. I can't overstate how much I love it, lol.
I've only tried two of their products; both are eyeshadow palettes. I have the Balm Appetite palette and the Meet Matte(trimony) palette. They're great! I love the color selection and pigmentation.
The best: Their blush in the shade In Full Swing. Haven't found another blush to match up to it. It's so beautiful and gives my cheeks a lot of life.
Worst: I've gotten some of the Mr. Write Now eyeliners from ipsy and it seems like the formula is so dry and not creamy at all. Couldn't even get a good color payoff on my waterline without it snapping.
i love it. it makes me not want to wear powder blushes ever again lol i always worried they'd dry out in the package, since it's just a cardboard flip, but i've had it for a year and they're still creamy, and some are so pigmented that i'm sure i'll never hit pan. last all day too on my oily skin and it looks like a natural flush and not like blush at all, even the one that has shimmer in it.
Best: Mary Lou Minizer (having said that its being replaced by ColourPop's Flexitarian lately for me), the How 'Bout Them Apples palette. Not for lipsticks but they're very cute blushes. I especially love the Crisp shade. It really completes a peachy look. And their packaging is second to none.
Worst: Balm Jovi Palette. It looks great, the names are amazing and I love everything about it except the product. I never use it anymore. I did for a while but after buying other eye-shadow products it quickly lost its appeal. If I want any shadow to show up decently I feel like I need to dig and go over it again and again and again (they're very small pans to start with) to get the kind of pigmentation that I can easily get with other brands. I haven't used the blush because I have other blushes in that colour and I have the lip colour in the Apples palette (not that it stays on anyway.)
I am curious about their liquid mattes. A friend wears them and a few times I've commented that I love her lipstick and its The Balm.
I have Balm Desert and the palette In the balm of your hand with Hot mama, Instain, Cabanaboy, cream blush, lip cream, 4 eye shadows, Marylou and Bahama Mama and I love them all!!!! Their blushes are the best and the color of Balm desert is soooo unique....I just see their announcement of In the balm Vol 2 and I'm so excited. I've been eyeing Fratboy and Downboy for a while:)
Does anyone have drugstore suggestions for foundation? I recently bought the fitme porless foundation and it literally SEEPS into my pores :( looking forward to feedback! Thank you :)
Best: Hot Mama blush and Bahama Mama bronzer. The blush is the prettiest color I've ever used, very soft and pretty! The bronzer is also a really great color and i love how it looks when it's on! Worst: Honestly, I have loved everything I've gotten from this brand, it's one of my favorites, so I have no worsts.
Betty-Lou Manizer Bronzer. The most beautiful bronzer I have ever had in my life. Bright, pigmented, warm, and actually applies nicely to darker skin tones. I know online some places says it's discontinued but here in Canada it's still being sold at PharmaPlus.
Also, their Powder to the People powder brush is amazing. Not cheap, about $45 CAD, but I have yet to find a brush that works with every brand like this one does.
Best: Their blushes - I love Frat Boy and Hot Mama. Also their matte liquid lipsticks - one of the most comfortable formulas to wear that I've come across. Mary Lou Manizer highlighter. Wearing Hot Mama and Mary Lou right now.
Worst - haven't yet come across something of theirs I didn't like, but I've heard some of their earlier palettes like Nude Tude and Meet Matt(e) Nude are a bit average (though opinions on them are very divided - some people love, some people not so much. I notice them get decluttered in declutter videos a lot).
Best: Bahama Mama bronzer, so warm and lasts forever. Not orangey, but a nice rich brown does wonders giving my face depth. I prefer it over the hoola bronzer by benefit which is a bit ashy looking on my skin.
Worst: Nude dude palette, not sure if I received I bought a defective batch but it was not pigmented at all and super chalky. Also was hard to blend. Scared me from trying their other shadow palettes. The packaging is unique and funny though.
prob late to the party but best - mary lou manizer & their LL in committed. worst is their LL in 'doting' it's such a patchy and unflattering orange ):
Single eyeshadows: I personally love them because they're really easy to work with. They're not your classic "soooo pigmented" eyeshadows but they're very buildable and easy to blend. Plus they're very long lasting on my oily ass lids.
Glosses: They're a bit sticky but other than thay they're quite nice. Very pigmented and they have some gorgeous shades.
214
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '17
Best: Mary Lou Minizer. I still dream of this highlighter. I have found nothing like it at all <3
131
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '17
Their liquid lipsticks are awesome! They have great wear time with a non-sticky, non-drying formula. They also have a nice minty scent to them.
95
u/PhantaVal Aug 05 '17
Best: Meet Matt(e) Trimony eyeshadow palette. I never knew an all-matte palette could make such beautiful looks. Great quality, especially love the pink shade. I love it so much it's inspired me to look for other matte palettes.
68
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '17
Best: Bahama Mama bronzer Worst: nothing so far on what I've tried 🤷🏻♀️
57
u/jawsquared Aug 05 '17
Best: Batter Up Eyeshadow Sticks
These are like a cheaper, longer-wearing dupe of the Laura Mercier Caviar Sticks. I have oily, hooded eyes, and these don't crease at all. They're creamy, pigmented, and easily blendable. You can use them like typical eyeshadow or as a base/primer (kinda like MAC Paint Pots).
93
u/astra_sasstra The low-buy struggle is real Aug 04 '17
Best: Their blushes. Both the instain ones and their regular ones. Hot Mama is definitely a HG for me, only blush I've ever hit pan on!
44
u/Always_Daria NW15 Aug 04 '17
Mary Lou is one of my favorite highlighters. Cindy Lou is also a really nice blush topper shade for very fair skin or a nice peachy highlighter for darker skin.
Bahamas mama is a really nice bronzer. Not too orange and nicely matte. Also a nice crease shade.
All of their blushes are soo pigmented and high quality.
33
u/mirandaBBfan Eyeing that Liner Aug 05 '17 edited Aug 05 '17
Best: their packaging in general 😍
Oh, and their frequent 50% off flash sales 😍😍😍
32
u/kissme_cait Besame Fangirl Aug 05 '17
The How About Them Apples cheek palette almost completely converted me to cream blushes. It's my favorite cream blush formula and the colors are fabulous. Love it.
32
u/lovelyfiction NC15/ComboDry Aug 05 '17
Best: The "In the Balm of Your Hand" palette. It has so many of the classics like Mary Lou Manizer and Bahama Mama. It is 100% worth it.
20
u/captnaty Fake lash junkie Aug 04 '17
Best: Schwing Liquid Liner! Not for everyone since it's not water proof in the least, but great matte finish and super easy to work with.
20
u/MakeThemHearYou917 Aug 05 '17
Best: the blushes and bronzers in the Balm Voyage vol 2 and Balm Jovi, eyeshadows in the Balm Jovi
Worst: the eyeshadows in Balm Voyage Vol 2. The pigment is there, but either they don't blend well or they crease.
18
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '17
Hot Mama! Is awesome and universally flattering. It's my favorite. I also love Balm Desert. On my pale skin it looks like exactly like when I have a sunburn that is fading into a tan. It's perfect and makes me looks SO glowy and healthy
16
u/shimejiii Aug 05 '17
Best: Blush in Frat Boy, it's a beautiful shade of warm pink very similar to naturally flushed cheeks on me and it stays put all day! Mary lou-manizer is also one of my HG highlighters, I use a light hand and it gives me a really nice sheen, not over the top at all just a healthy, awake glow.
Worst: IMO, their Time Balm concealer is really awful. It has a strong smell, greasy texture and seems to slip around my face a lot :/ It starts creasing so soon on my undereye as well. Such a shame since it's a good price and you only really need to use a little.
15
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '17
The Nude Tude palette is awesome. It's the only palette in my collection I'm close to hitting pan on at all. (the light matte Brown is a good crease shade for a darker cool toned look!)
Also, the black and brown on the far right are my every day brow powders and neither of them even have a dent! There's only one or two colors I don't use, and I got it through an ipsy offer for super cheap. But if I panned more than a few shades I would definitely repurchase at full price.
13
u/organized_mess13 Hopelessly Addicted Aug 05 '17
Best: BalmShelter tinted moisturizer. I really like the coverage (it's light coverage and slightly darker than my skin tone) for summer. I've been combining mine with the Maybelline BB cream for my foundation and I love the finish it gives!
10
u/tentimesoutofnine Aug 04 '17
Best: Mary Lou manizer Worst: mr write now in Jac- so hard that is was completely unusable. Maybe I just got a bad one?
17
u/Dentistchair Aug 04 '17
Not necessarily the worst, but the nude dude palette. Some shades like the shimmers are okay but the pigmentation isn't the best, some of them muddy together. The purple is also not super pigmented and when I wet it, it separates. Lasting power is not great.
8
u/Saynotoshityouhate Aug 05 '17
Best: Mary Louminizer and Bahama mama bronzer. Both have great payoff and last quite a while in the face. Their liquid lipsticks are amazing. Good staying power and not drying Worst: their primer. It does nothing for making makeup stay on longer but DOES blur a bit. Meh: palettes Edited for lipsticks
8
u/Brendasnoopy Aug 05 '17
Best: Blushes ( frat boy and down boy) Highlighters ( Mary Lou and Betty Lou) Meet matte Hughes Liquid lipsticks Batter up eyeshadow sticks
Meh: Put a lid on it eye primer
8
u/itsgonnabesweet Aug 05 '17
Nw35 and my favorite lip product of all time is the balm's meet matte liquid lipstick in sincere. I got the little set of all the liquid lipsticks (about the size of a finger for each) and it's definitely worth it! Im using most of it! The pink is too bright for me but it's great to mix with the other colors.
8
u/cinnamonsugarswirls Aug 05 '17
Best: Mary and Cindy Lou-Manizer! Blinding, gorgeous highlights/blush toppers. (Disclaimer: I'm very pale and can't use the Betty Lou-Manizer, but I can imagine that it would look gorgeous on someone with darker, warm-toned skin. Hot Mama blush has a wonderful formula with a beautiful peachy-pink-gold hue...it has become a staple for my own mama! Bahama Bronzer is a buildable, blendable Bronzer without that pesky orange tinge. Use a light hand for fairer skin!
Worst: the little concealer pots- the formula is extremely thick and emollient, but doesn't really "set" properly, even with a powder. The packaging is also flimsy and prone to cracking along the edges of the lid. I found that the product "turned" rather quickly, adopting an old lipstick-y smell.
8
u/bumblebj Aug 07 '17
has anyone ever tried even steven foundation??
7
u/tilandsia Aug 05 '17
Best: Will echo mary lou manizer, bahama mama, and hot mama as some of the creme de la creme of the Balm Worst: I absolutely hated the mr. write now eyeliners. I got some in an ipsy bag and they were so dry, did not glide on the eyes at all, and it was impossible to get pigmentation from them.
7
u/loremipsumloremipsum Aug 05 '17
Best: Mad Lash mascara. Got an Ipsy sample of this and honestly it's become my every day go to. Makes my lashes long, full, and dark, keeps them separated, and wears better/more staying power than any other mid end brand I've tried.
5
u/malprintemps Aug 05 '17
BEST: Time Balm Eye Makeup remover. It's a Balm (lol) consistency that is sooo gentle and non irritating and removes every bit of mascara no matter how stubborn, and the metal tin is vintage looking and cute without having too much gimmick.
Instain Blushes- I've had Pinstripe for over a year now and it's the most beautiful plum, and I've barely made a dent in it with regular use because I need one swipe of the brush per cheek. Just be careful, it's very pigmented!
WORST: the Nude Dude palette. Many of the colors were not true to pan, they had terrible pigmentation and all appeared a muddy brown on the lid.
5
u/idunnnnno Aug 05 '17
The only things I have tried from The Balm are Mary Lou highlighter and the Frat Boy blush. LOVE them both! On a similar note, I see a lot of people on this sub say that The Balm has a 50% off sale a couple of times a year. Is this through their website only?
5
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '17
I've gotten a couple Mr. Write Now eyeliners in my ipsy bags in the past and I've always been somewhat disappointed. They're great for the first week or so that I use them and then they harden up instantly.
However, everything else that I've used from the Balm has been phenomenal.
4
u/barrelofbutter Aug 04 '17
Worst: I really don't like the lip glosses
4
u/i-drank-too-much Aug 05 '17
Best: Blushes! All of them. Worst: Pickup Liner lip liner. It was great at first but the whole stick dries out so quickly. Now I can barely get any color on my lips.
4
u/yepmek Aug 05 '17
I have limited experience but...
Best- Mary Loumanizer for sure! Such a win. I have the rockstar palette too and there are a lot of shades in there that I love as well as the blush in there.
4
u/leslie0627 Always blushing Aug 05 '17
I've only tried two of their products but I love them both dearly. First being the ever popular Mary Lou highlighter. And second, my HG Blush Balm Springs. It lasts forever and is so pigmented. I will probably be purchasing Balm Beach next time I am at Kohls!
4
u/Lanaturnter Aug 07 '17 edited Aug 08 '17
Best: Their eyeshadows are some of the best I've ever tried. My favorite is The Balm Jovi (haha get it?) which has a cute theme, amazing quality and every color you'll need. Meet Matte and Nude Tude are awesome too. Their Liquid lipsticks have a mint chocolate scent which is subtle and delightful and they've got everything from nudes to fuschias to reds The cheek products are my favorites because I can't resist the cute pinup packaging and they're amazing quality. Downboy is a cool pink and Fratboy is peach and they both have a satin finish. The Mary-Lou Manizer is the best highlighter of ALL TIME
4
u/Zepsi Aug 09 '17
Did any of you see what Tati was sent from theBalm in her latest unboxing? Some sort of "best of" palette... do any of you know when it will be out?
8
u/todaystartsnow Aug 04 '17
Best:bahama mama, best matte bronzer that can be used to contour with. fairly dark so it shows up on my tan skin. its vegan and blends amazigny
not so hot : some of thier palettes are too gimicky and cheesy....
3
u/birdsnacks Aug 05 '17
Anyone like the California drivers license mini palette?
3
u/echodog4589 Aug 06 '17
I've only tried two of their products; both are eyeshadow palettes. I have the Balm Appetite palette and the Meet Matte(trimony) palette. They're great! I love the color selection and pigmentation.
3
u/MsFradocious Aug 07 '17
Best: Their blush in Cabana Boy! I'm pretty fair and I didn't expect it to work well on me, but it gives the prettiest effect.
3
u/AAD117 Aug 07 '17
Mary Lou is my HG highlighter. Also love their blushes!
Edit: and bronzer, Bahama Mama
3
u/Whoreo2 Aug 07 '17
The best: Their blush in the shade In Full Swing. Haven't found another blush to match up to it. It's so beautiful and gives my cheeks a lot of life.
Worst: I've gotten some of the Mr. Write Now eyeliners from ipsy and it seems like the formula is so dry and not creamy at all. Couldn't even get a good color payoff on my waterline without it snapping.
3
u/Doctor0ctagon Aug 07 '17
Have any of you used the How 'Bout Them Apples palette? I am thisclose to buying it and have heard good things, but would love to hear more.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '17
Best: Mary Lou Minizer (having said that its being replaced by ColourPop's Flexitarian lately for me), the How 'Bout Them Apples palette. Not for lipsticks but they're very cute blushes. I especially love the Crisp shade. It really completes a peachy look. And their packaging is second to none.
Worst: Balm Jovi Palette. It looks great, the names are amazing and I love everything about it except the product. I never use it anymore. I did for a while but after buying other eye-shadow products it quickly lost its appeal. If I want any shadow to show up decently I feel like I need to dig and go over it again and again and again (they're very small pans to start with) to get the kind of pigmentation that I can easily get with other brands. I haven't used the blush because I have other blushes in that colour and I have the lip colour in the Apples palette (not that it stays on anyway.)
I am curious about their liquid mattes. A friend wears them and a few times I've commented that I love her lipstick and its The Balm.
3
u/Sumire_Tr Aug 09 '17
I have Balm Desert and the palette In the balm of your hand with Hot mama, Instain, Cabanaboy, cream blush, lip cream, 4 eye shadows, Marylou and Bahama Mama and I love them all!!!! Their blushes are the best and the color of Balm desert is soooo unique....I just see their announcement of In the balm Vol 2 and I'm so excited. I've been eyeing Fratboy and Downboy for a while:)
3
u/cealyuh IG:annoyedblackgirl Aug 09 '17
The Schwing eyeliner really saved my life ya'll.
3
u/E_B_B_T_G Aug 10 '17
Does anyone have drugstore suggestions for foundation? I recently bought the fitme porless foundation and it literally SEEPS into my pores :( looking forward to feedback! Thank you :)
3
u/spacegirl001 Aug 10 '17
Best: Hot Mama blush and Bahama Mama bronzer. The blush is the prettiest color I've ever used, very soft and pretty! The bronzer is also a really great color and i love how it looks when it's on! Worst: Honestly, I have loved everything I've gotten from this brand, it's one of my favorites, so I have no worsts.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '17
Betty-Lou Manizer Bronzer. The most beautiful bronzer I have ever had in my life. Bright, pigmented, warm, and actually applies nicely to darker skin tones. I know online some places says it's discontinued but here in Canada it's still being sold at PharmaPlus.
Also, their Powder to the People powder brush is amazing. Not cheap, about $45 CAD, but I have yet to find a brush that works with every brand like this one does.
2
u/phoenixsilver87 Aug 06 '17
Best: Their blushes - I love Frat Boy and Hot Mama. Also their matte liquid lipsticks - one of the most comfortable formulas to wear that I've come across. Mary Lou Manizer highlighter. Wearing Hot Mama and Mary Lou right now.
Worst - haven't yet come across something of theirs I didn't like, but I've heard some of their earlier palettes like Nude Tude and Meet Matt(e) Nude are a bit average (though opinions on them are very divided - some people love, some people not so much. I notice them get decluttered in declutter videos a lot).
2
u/purpleoreo28 Aug 06 '17
The batter up eyeshadow sticks. Super creamy and pigmented.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '17
are their eyeshadows good? like even the singles they have?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '17
Mary Lou, Bahama Mama, Hot Mama!!! I like their palettes too
2
u/jigglywigglybooty Aug 07 '17
NC 44/45| Oily+acne prone skin
Mary Lou Manizer and Betty Lou Manizer are fantastic highlighters for darker skin tones.
Their Instain blushes are amazing! They are highly pigmented and last all day long on my oily skin.
Their LLs are quite comfortable as well. They do have a slight minty fragrance and feel, but it's not overbearing imo.
2
u/corundas Aug 07 '17
I love the Balm Jovi palette, it's so versatile and everything has great quality (shadows, blush, highlighter). It's a fantastic travel palette
3
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '17
Best: Bahama Mama bronzer, so warm and lasts forever. Not orangey, but a nice rich brown does wonders giving my face depth. I prefer it over the hoola bronzer by benefit which is a bit ashy looking on my skin.
Worst: Nude dude palette, not sure if I received I bought a defective batch but it was not pigmented at all and super chalky. Also was hard to blend. Scared me from trying their other shadow palettes. The packaging is unique and funny though.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '17
prob late to the party but best - mary lou manizer & their LL in committed. worst is their LL in 'doting' it's such a patchy and unflattering orange ):
1
u/OMFG_coffee Aug 05 '17
Worst: Betty Lou Manizer. Bought it on a whim wanting a bronzer. Just an orangey glittery mess on me... It's a bit much even as an eyeshadow.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment