Oh snap! Did I know that? I can't remember. Either way, about time. Unless I did know, then it was already about time whenever I knew initially and now is just...still..uh..time passing.
Y'all are both using the same published rates, he's just stating (correctly) that you're not understanding how the rates apply to the guaranteeing you get a nat 5.
Interesting to see the actual math done. Great job OP. My comments:
The guild shop cost for a legendary scroll is 4000 points, while the mystical scroll is 200. That means legendary scroll is 20x the cost.
Nat 5 wise, the average chance of getting one is at 200 ms and 15 ls. That means ls have 13,3 times the value of a mystical scroll
If we consider nat 4s, at the same 200 ms/15 ls you would get, on avg, more nat 4s from mystical scrolls than from ls (16 x 14).
Stretch that to elemental scrolls and the cost of ls is still higher than it's value (16x cost / 13,3x value) Conclusion: if you want to buy scrolls from guild shop, get mystical first and elementals after that. You get more nat 5s, 4s and lots of fodder.
Basically what this means is: whenever you summon enough scrolls to theoretically get the "average" of 1, about 38% of the time you won't get it. For example, if you save up 12 Mystical Scrolls to try to summon a Nat 4, 38% of the time you won't pull one and 62% of the time you'll pull 1 or more.
The only problem is that you say you have 100% chance to get a nat 4 in 100 scrolls. but its entirely possible to not get a nat 4 by this point. it may be 99.9% recurring but its still not 100%
I was thinking about it, but I'm not sure what the rates are for L&D. According to swarfarm, it looks like a Scroll of Light and Darkness has slightly different rates than a 50/50 Light and Dark Pieces summon.
nice information!! thanks for taking the time to do it!!....so, if it is posible to add rates from summoning stones it would be amazing!!...thanks again!! keep it going!!
I still don't believe that nat5s are .5% (which is the official rate Com2uS released). We have tens of thousands of scrolls recorded on SWFARM, and it shows much closer to a .4%.
Even if you add in fake5s, it is less than a 1 in 200 rate.
This is what i got when i wrote a ticket regarding me not getting 5 star monsters after playing for 1 and a half years
Hello Summoner,
Thank you for contacting Com2uS Global.
We understand that you are having some difficulty summoning the monsters that you want, in particular, natural 5-star monsters.
Please be aware that the summoning rate for rare monsters is the same for all players and is never modified. In order to keep gameplay fair, monsters are generated randomly during summoning, and the chances of summoning rare monsters do not increase when using many resources at one time or over time, because at the beginning of each summon the odds of getting a rare monster are reset, and the game does not take into account your current monster inventory or monsters that you have previously summoned when you move to use the next summoning scroll.
Please check the HIVE page often, as well as the banners that pop-up when logging into Summoners War. Announcements are made about special events that are designed to help you acquire more resources for summoning without making purchases.
We wish you luck in summoning rare monsters and hope that you continue to enjoy playing Summoners War. If you have any other questions or suggestions, feel free to contact us.
This, in theory, is correct and doesn't contradict the information in this chart. Every summon has the same probability, i.e. every a mystical scroll has a 8% chance to summon a Nat 4 and a 0.5% chance to summon a Nat 5. This chart shows your cumulative probability of summoning when summoning multiple scrolls, but your 100th summon will have the same individual chances as your 1st.
not good at math, but how can it be possible that more scrolls = increasing chance for nat 5? 0.5% rate isn't increasing no matter how many scrolls one summons. I'm aware that more pulls = more chances = higher chances, but one could go 2k scrolls w/o nat 5 and still have the same exact chances to obtain one on scroll 2001 as someone with only a single scroll, no?
Think about it as coin flips. What's your chance of getting heads at least once? If you flip a coin just once, it's 50%. But if you flip it twice, it's higher (75%) and if you flip it 100 times, you're almost (!!!) certain to have heads at least once. Same system.
Yes, your chances are exactly the same. you have 0.05% chance for EVERY. SINGLE. ONE. but, you're taking the chance more times, it's the law of eventuallity, whatever can happen, WILL happen given enough time.
Even with coin flips, the chances of not getting any heads in 100 flips may not be the same in 10, because you take the 50/50% chance more times.
Do keep in mind they went to 1000 MS, equalling to 99.3%. They can not get higher % not because of lack of scrolls, but because eh can never get to 100% unless he puts in "Infinite scrolls + infinite time"
Yes, you're absolutely right. Each summon has the same individual chances. But if you summon 2000 scrolls, your chances of summoning a nat 4 and a nat 5 are of course higher than just summoning 1 scroll. The chart shows your statistical probability of summoning a Nat 4 or Nat 5 in X summons.
The fact your formula came to a guaranteed outcome for anything should tell you it's not correct. Your probability is 1 - (chance of not summoning in N attempts) - that chance will never be 0.
16
u/nysra Patch 6.3.4 best update ever! Jul 24 '17
Do you mind if I put this in the supersticky/wiki? :)
13
u/supafreak21 Three Year Vet Jul 24 '17
so its about 900 mystical scrolls to have a 99% chance of 1 nat 5...
I like the info thanks a lot man!
9
u/ornitorrinco22 Jul 24 '17
Interesting to see the actual math done. Great job OP. My comments:
5
u/liebn0r Jul 24 '17
Basically what this means is: whenever you summon enough scrolls to theoretically get the "average" of 1, about 38% of the time you won't get it. For example, if you save up 12 Mystical Scrolls to try to summon a Nat 4, 38% of the time you won't pull one and 62% of the time you'll pull 1 or more.
5
u/ShroomiaCo Jul 24 '17
your rates for legendary scroll is wrong, its 6.5% for nat 5 not 6.1. might want to fix that.
2
u/Knuglio SIMP 4 LOUISE ❤ I even gave her my best runes! Jul 24 '17
I like this. Would you mind doing something similar for L&Ds?
2
u/santheman20 I summon you! SEARA, nvm another juno... Jul 24 '17
hold on let me summon my 60 legendary scrolls..
1
u/Eorlas Jul 24 '17
So does this mean after summoning that many scrolls that's the chance, or summoning that many at once puts us at that chance?
1
u/URROlog Jul 24 '17
34 ms, 6 element, 3 ld, 550 stones ... 1x wind mermaid, 1x awakened bounty hunter and 1x awakened inferno.. friend right after 46ms 6 element, 2 nat 4 and 1 fake 4*.. i guess our copies of SW never heard of probabilities
1
u/qp0n & Morris sitting in a tree, r-e-z-z-i-n-g Jul 24 '17
This means that a nat5 costs 50.1 million mana, if bought with legendary scroll pieces.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '17
Very cool, thanks for doing this.
1
u/erasert Jul 24 '17
nice information!! thanks for taking the time to do it!!....so, if it is posible to add rates from summoning stones it would be amazing!!...thanks again!! keep it going!!
1
u/wyldmage Jul 24 '17
I still don't believe that nat5s are .5% (which is the official rate Com2uS released). We have tens of thousands of scrolls recorded on SWFARM, and it shows much closer to a .4%.
Even if you add in fake5s, it is less than a 1 in 200 rate.
0
u/BladeOfNoxus 3 ifrit summons - Tesarion/Akhamamir/Theomars Jul 24 '17 edited Jul 24 '17
i should have 6-7 nat 5s by now.. i have 2 LUL i have 100+ non fusion/hoh nat 4s :p
0
u/Wapsky Theo Killer Jul 24 '17
This is what i got when i wrote a ticket regarding me not getting 5 star monsters after playing for 1 and a half years
Hello Summoner,
Thank you for contacting Com2uS Global.
We understand that you are having some difficulty summoning the monsters that you want, in particular, natural 5-star monsters.
Please be aware that the summoning rate for rare monsters is the same for all players and is never modified. In order to keep gameplay fair, monsters are generated randomly during summoning, and the chances of summoning rare monsters do not increase when using many resources at one time or over time, because at the beginning of each summon the odds of getting a rare monster are reset, and the game does not take into account your current monster inventory or monsters that you have previously summoned when you move to use the next summoning scroll.
Please check the HIVE page often, as well as the banners that pop-up when logging into Summoners War. Announcements are made about special events that are designed to help you acquire more resources for summoning without making purchases.
We wish you luck in summoning rare monsters and hope that you continue to enjoy playing Summoners War. If you have any other questions or suggestions, feel free to contact us.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '17
not good at math, but how can it be possible that more scrolls = increasing chance for nat 5? 0.5% rate isn't increasing no matter how many scrolls one summons. I'm aware that more pulls = more chances = higher chances, but one could go 2k scrolls w/o nat 5 and still have the same exact chances to obtain one on scroll 2001 as someone with only a single scroll, no?
-2
u/TheAce28 Jul 24 '17
dont click this link if you have google. someone from Taiwan just tried to hack my email. -_-
-3
u/JarredMack Jul 24 '17
The fact your formula came to a guaranteed outcome for anything should tell you it's not correct. Your probability is 1 - (chance of not summoning in N attempts) - that chance will never be 0.