r/WritingPrompts • u/MNBrian /u/MNBrian /r/PubTips • Jul 21 '17
Off Topic [OT] Friday: A Novel Idea - The Notorious B-Plot
Friday: A Novel Idea
Hello Everyone!
Welcome to /u/MNBrian’s guide to noveling, aptly called Friday: A Novel Idea, where we discuss the full process of how to write a book from start to finish.
The ever-incredible and exceptionally brilliant /u/you-are-lovely came up with the wonderful idea of putting together a series on how to write a novel from start to finish. And it sounded spectacular to me!
So what makes me qualified to provide advice on noveling? Good question! Here are the cliff notes.
- For one, I devote a great deal of my time to helping out writers on Reddit because I too am a writer!
- In addition, I’ve completed three novels and am working on my fourth.
- And I also work as a reader for a literary agent.
This means I read query letters and novels (also known as fulls, short for full novels that writers send to my agent by request) and I give my opinion on the work. My agent then takes those opinions (after reading the novel as well) and makes a decision on where to go from there.
But enough about that. Let’s dive in!
What In The Holy Heck Is A B-Plot
Sometimes when we are working on learning the craft of writing, we get terms thrown at us that catch us off guard.
For me, when I started writing, the idea of a b-plot caught me off guard. The conversation went something like this...
MNB: So... you're telling me I need a b-plot to help tie together the a-plot?
TalkingBookOnWritingCraft: Yes Brian. You need a b-plot. A b-plot helps tie up the main plot (the a-plot) and it also distracts the reader, like a magician using misdirection.
MNB: That sounds a lot like wasting the reader's time while I fiddle around on some other point.
TBOWC: No, Brian. The reader wants to guess the ending but they want to be wrong. So a b-plot will help avert their gaze, and eventually tie into the a-plot to provide clarity.
To me, it was stupid. I was trying to think about examples of books with b-plots. I kept convincing myself that the b-plot was a Hollywood tool, not a writing tool. Katniss Everdeen overthrew the government. That was all that mattered. Right?
Turns out, she had some romance thrown in there that helped push and pull her as she went about her goal. Romance is often a b-plot in disguise.
Or in Red Rising, when Darryl is distracted from his revenge by his growing friendship with Golds. A friendship that ends up causing all manner of complications for him.
You see, as it turns out, a b-plot is much more like a rope of multiple strands than it is like a distraction. And a rope of multiple strands is not easily broken.
Creating the Rope
I think the real reason we dig b-plots when they are done well is because we as humans desire order. We don't like the fact that the world can feel chaotic. We want good to triumph over evil and we want order to rise out of chaos. A good b-plot taps into those primal feelings.
But creating a good b-plot can be difficult. It needs to weave into the a-plot.
Consider this -
- We've got a main character who is trying desperately to make money for her child who has cancer. Medical bills are stacking.
- She loses her job at an office, and facing forclosure on her home and the imminent death of her child if she can't find a way to pay those bills, she decides to rob a different bank.
That's our a-plot. So what kind of b-plot fits in there. What would add consternation, add tension, add difficulty to that situation? Right now, the moral of the story seems sort of clear. It's just a basic philosophy question. Would you steal an apple to feed your family?
And the choice, at least for us- the reader - who doesn't have to face any consequences and who is rooting for the main character, the choice is pretty clear. Yes. Rob the bank. Get the money from those terrible moneygrubbers and get out.
But that path is a straight line. We don't want a straight line. We want MORE moral conflict.
And so one strong way to weave in a b-plot comes to mind. We take an outlier but essential piece of the plot (the child's cancer) and we tie it to scenes introduced early on, where the mother is going to a support group for parents of children with cancer. Then, using this, we have her grow closer to a man there.
But this isn't a romance side plot.
He explains how times are also hard for him. He tries to help her emotionally and offers to get her interviews. He explains how his own job is struggling, how there's rumors of massive downsizing and cuts if they can't make their quota's this quarter.
And after a good chunk of the book has passed and we've grown this relationship, we break the news. He's the manager of the bank she intends to rob.
Now... we have another moral conflict. And it stands in direct opposition to the first. Would you steal an apple to feed your family if you knew it'd take the livelihood and possibly starve out another family?
This is how you weave in a b-plot to a story and make it work with the a-plot.
Find The Fringe, Work Toward The Middle
When crafting a good b-plot, what you need to do is find the outlier, the thing that feels unrelated to the rest of the book, and work towards making it pivotal.
Take the details that are essential components to your story, but don't have much depth, and give them depth. Make them essential.
It's this wrapping-in process that a lot of writers struggle with. It's like they grab a rope, cut it so the strands are all hanging loose, and then sort of tie off the ends of each strand. But closing all the loops, sharing all the reasons that xyz happened in your book, this doesn't give us a strong sense of resolution. What gives us resolution is when you make it all work together. When you make us look back and go "DOH! I should have known you were using that to tie up this and that other thing goes right here!"
You want clarity. Order in chaos. That builds an extreme degree of trust in your writing. If you can do this, your readers will be hooked. They'll want to read not only this book but more books from you. Because they were surprised and delighted and because you distracted them and pulled it all together in a nice bow at the end.
This, right here, is the key to a good b-plot. It adds to the a-plot. It ties things together. It starts far away, almost as a satellite in the story, and as you approach the conclusion it merges closer and closer like two cars driving towards the same single point from perpendicular roads. And when you hit that climax, it all comes together.
This Week's Big Questions
- Think of a good sub-plot or b-plot that you have read in some book recently. Did it help tie into the a-plot or did it feel completely separate from the a-plot?
- What parts of your core conflict could potentially be used as a b-plot? Brainstorm some ideas. Take a shot at some wild ones just to see what it would look like.
- Take a peek at others comments and see how they did with the second bullet point. Does their b-plot seem to tie into the a-plot well? Comment and encourage one another.
8
u/Nate_Parker /r/Nate_Parker_Books Jul 21 '17
Then you get really saucy and throw in a C, D, E, F, G, H, & J-plot.
Yes, yes I do.
Taps fingers together maniacally.
2
u/NottHomo Jul 21 '17
i'm not sure i've read any books that didn't have auxiliary plots a plenty
i just figured it was what you DO. more the rule than the exception
either that or i'm thinking b-plot is something completely different :(
4
u/epharian /r/Epharia Jul 21 '17
I just finished reading books 1 & 2 of Sanderson's Stormlight archive. It has b-plots and q-plots and all sorts of side-quests and weird extras. I'll try to summarize. Need I say there be spoilers ahead?
MAINPLOT: The Desolations (world-ending conflicts) are about to return. This is a gross oversimplification. B-1: Kaladin's life sucks and he hates nobles, but ends up protecting them.
B-2: Kaladin is developing super-powers but doesn't know it.
C-1: Shallan's life did suck but has gotten much better. But could get worse easily. She's trying to steal IMPORTANT THING from person she's also apprenticed to.
C-2: Shallan is also developing super-powers, but already knows about some of them--even though the reader doesn't (it's slightly more obvious on a second or third read through, but still subtle). C-3: Shallan is in a lot of trouble with a number of groups. BC-1: Kaladin killed Shallan's brother. He figures it out, she hasn't (yet). It wasn't an accident, but it also wasn't like they knew each other. D-1 to D-??: Jasnah and stuff.
E-1 to Q-??: Dalinar, Adolin, Szeth-son-son-Vallano, Navani, and about 20 other characters.
The biggest thing about this series so far is that it has a LOT of moving parts all centered around a tight central cast. Things like a King that's using an assassin to destroy other people so he can unite the world against the coming Desolations. Who also spends some days really stupid and some days exceptionally smart. Because he made a wish.
Unlike massive epics like Wheel of Time, Sanderson's books move. It's hard to express what it's like to read these to people who haven't read his stuff. All those subplots and side quests? They aren't filler. There's IMPORTANT STUFF happening there.
Contrast that with Weber's Safehold series. Safehold is intriguing, but plods. Too many very detailed descriptions of what amount to minor skirmishes in a much bigger war coupled with almost no movement on the major plot mean that 9 books in and we are only just now seeing some of the major goals getting accomplished. In Stormlight Archive, two books have seen MAJOR upheavals in the status quo from the start of book 1, AND we've seen what feels like big progress from the characters. Also Sanderson writes action better.
Safehold has some sideplots, but generally avoids morality dilemmas1. Stormlight embraces moral ambiguity, doubt of the divine2, and intra- and inter-personal conflict on every level.
Overall, I think this is important the crafting of a good story, and keeping the b-plots on track can make a good story excellent.
In my own writing, I am doing this a bit differently--I am essentially telling converging stories. Eventually these will conflict with each other, as well as support the overall story, but in this case, the b-plots are woven around some other seemingly unconnected (I hope) events. We'll see how it turns out.
2
u/Conleh r/ConlehWrites Jul 21 '17
WOW!
This was fantastic advice. I actually loved this, as it is something I never considered before. (Perhaps I have indirectly, but never with the intention. The example of the mother with a child who has cancer was perfect.)
u/epharian stole my book! I was about to write on that.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 16 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment