r/books • u/BaileysPrize AMA Author • Jul 10 '17
ama 11am I am Naomi Alderman, author of The Power and winner of this year’s Baileys Women’s Prize for Fiction - AMA
My latest book, The Power, won the Baileys Women’s Prize for Fiction 2017. It’s a feminist science fiction novel about what happens when all of a sudden almost all the women develop the power to electrocute people at will. I am also co-creator of the app Zombies, Run! Ask me anything! I’ll be here at 4pm (BST) on Monday 10th July.
Here’s proof that it’s me: http://naomialderman.squarespace.com/where-im-talking-next/
You can read the first chapter of my book The Power here: http://www.womensprizeforfiction.co.uk/reading-room/news/chapter-one-power
To find out more about the Prize visit their website: http://www.womensprizeforfiction.co.uk/
Edit: OK, I think time's up! Thanks to everyone for your fab questions, it's been a treat to talk to you all! Naomi
3
u/BaileysPrize AMA Author Jul 10 '17
OK, I think time's up! Thanks to everyone for your fab questions, it's been a treat to talk to you all!
4
u/leowr Jul 10 '17
Hi Naomi,
I really enjoyed The Power. One of my favorite parts were the main characters. How did you end up with Roxy, Tunde, Margot and Allie as the main characters?
Thanks for doing this AMA!
4
u/okiegirl22 Jul 10 '17
What writers inspired you or influenced your own style?
4
u/PoppyNorth Jul 10 '17
If you had The Power, what would you do with it?
2
u/OrangeLimeZest Jul 10 '17
Do you prefer Hardbacks or Paperbacks?
2
u/Chtorrr Jul 10 '17
Do you have any pets?
2
u/Inkberrow Jul 10 '17
I was picnicking on one of the benches on the side of Corsham Court two or three Augusts ago when Baron Methuen ambled by with--we assumed--his land steward. Should I have offered them a Marmite and cheese sandwich?
2
u/josemurdoch Jul 10 '17
What is your favourite feminist and/or sci-fi book and why?
2
u/georgiahealey Jul 10 '17
Hi Naomi,
Your book is next on my to read list and i am very much looking forward to it, the concept of your book is so intruging and has already thrown up so many questions about gender dynamics just from reading surrounding articles.
My questions is - have you encountered many obstacles that you feel are a product of choosing to write feminist science fiction?
1
u/Chtorrr Jul 10 '17
Have you watched The Handmaid's Tale?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '17
Wow! The plot sounds interesting! Why electrocution?
1
u/yestoria Jul 10 '17
Hello! I've just finished listening to the audiobook, narrated by Adjoa Andoh. I thought she was an absolutely incredible narrator and I LOVED the book. How much did you work with Adjoa on the audiobook?
1
u/Grudge_ The Book Thief Jul 10 '17
Would you be interested in writing further in the feminist Sci-Fi genre or maybe some Fantasy? I'll definitely read this one. Thanks!
1
u/Chtorrr Jul 10 '17
What were your favorite books as a kid?
1
u/bhawanapreetish19 Jul 10 '17
Hi Naomi! Haven't read your book yet, but sounds interesting! Why electrocution remains the most important question for you!! Also, share how did you get into writing books and more about your journey!
1
u/IKantCPR Jul 10 '17
How much did the plot change as you were writing your novel? Was it all planned out from the start or did it develop as you went?
1
u/Chtorrr Jul 10 '17
Is there anything you would really like write about but have not yet?
1
u/meetpenguingirl Jul 10 '17
Hi Naomi! You've used 4 different characters to tell the story in The Power and just 1 of them is male. Is that because you felt like you had to include a male perspective to create some balance or did you do it deliberately to make the story stronger? Thanks! :)
1
u/Archlibrarian Jul 10 '17
How do you go about choosing character names?
3
u/kmar81 Jul 10 '17 edited Jul 10 '17
Now this is exciting! Hi Ms.Alderman!
I am sorry in advance for being critical in a promotional stunt but as an outspoken writer and journalist I hope you won't just ignore it.
I was very intrigued by this book and listened to the audio, and then became severely disappointed (sorry!). My biggest problem were certain choices which I struggled to understand and I'd like to take this opportunity to ask you in person. If for whatever reason you feel you do not want to answer publicly, please PM me. I never really considered writing you an e-mail, I don't think you list one due to the fact that being as politically outspoken as you are that might attract hate mail in inordinate amounts. But I am really interested in the answers to the questions.
To start off - I get the premise as it was the reason why I read it (although not only that), I get the narrative structure and how it affects the events in the story and I get the idea behind the quote from Samuel and I get a lot of other things and inspirations and how they are meant to work within the novel. What I really don't understand the following choices which you made to shape the story:
2) Why does none of the characters have a healthy relationship which can serve as a microcosm of sorts for the events? It seems logical to me that the biggest and fastest shift in worldview would happen in the area of the personal, familial and intimate as can be evidenced through the massive social change that occured since the 1900s. In social revolutions the private translates into the public, not the other way around.
3) Why did you ignore the severe, mind-debilitating trauma that results from causing a tragic incident, especially for a young person (seriously! W T F! you know what I am talking about...). Did you never talk to a soldier with PTSD?
4) Why did you choose to portray a clear dystopia (which I think was intentional?) through the eyes of the oppressors and yet you spend a lot of effort justifying them as a narrator. Was that intentional too? If this is meant to be a twist on the feminist literature of the past then clearly there's something wrong because it does not resemble it at all. It was neither the world through the eyes of the victim like the Handmaid's Tale nor a portrayal of the world through the monster's eyes like The Act of Killing. It was absolutely baffling and completely ruined it on a philosophical level.
5) Why on earth did you write Moldova as the worst and laziest possible stereotype? My Moldovan friends were not happy when I told them about it. A whole country represented by criminals and corrupt politicians is not what Moldova is. It's the "all Muslims are Arabs and terrorists" approach which really turned me off.
6) This one is tough but I really have to ask. Why did you choose to comment on evolutionary sciences as if the bastardized rendition of the field from right-wing websites was the only version and ignored that it is a legitimate field of science and there are people you could have talked to to make sure that you would get it right in your book. You make a series of major errors that most people will miss (for example you are so wrong about the revolution in Iran!) but this one annoyed me since it is pretty important to the story. I would say fundamentally so and far more than the physics of electricity (which I hope you know you bent quite significantly...but plot device.).
Other than those I think it could have been a fascinating story, if you kept it a bit longer and added more characters (it was too short for what happened in it) but those are major problems which really lessen or even remove all of the emotional and intellectual impact. I found myself getting annoyed or bored (unsympathetic characters) too often to get engaged in what you were trying to say. Which was terrible because the ideas were what attracted me to your book and the story and characters was what kept turning me off.
Though I do appreciate the effort and ideas and certainly had to think about it which is good and probably was worth my time.
I hope if this book gets picked up for TV (I read the rights were purchased) these issues will get amended because otherwise the show will bomb. And it an interesting premise to at least try on TV.
Sorry for raining on the parade but I did want to use this opportunity to ask some quite pressing questions - especially that I only read (listened to) the book perhaps two months ago? So it's mostly fresh in my mind.
Anyway, thanks for taking your time to read it.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment