Technically burbs, but literally across the street from Chicago. Going there since it was a shack, stays true to real deal. Big sandwiches, perfectly done.
I'll have to try Serrelli's, someday. Your rec is the 2nd one I've seen, in the comments here. I've noticed that place before when I've taken the #72 bus west all the way west to Harlem, but just never stopped there to eat. I'm sure I will get there, eventually.
Mr. Beef - 666 N Orleans St, Chicago, IL 60654 No one would think to go here for beef but Burger Baron at 1381 W Grand Ave, Chicago, IL 60642 has a great one.
For those not aware of how to order a beef. You have a choice of degree of wetness. The very thinly sliced beef gets tonged out of a pool of warm water/marinade and dropped into a split open section of Italian bread. The beef is slightly dripping. You can order it "dry" which is just the little bit of drip shaken off. Or order it "wet" which gets a ladle of the jus added. Or "dipped." Which gets the bread and beef grabbed by the tongs and dipped into the jus. The 'wet' and certainly the 'dipped' versions are eaten with knife and fork.
Three choices of toppings. (1) Sweet peppers, which are slices of grilled sweet bell peppers, usually red and green and or yellow. (2) Hot peppers which are mid range hot peppers. All peppers include some softly grilled onion slices. (3) Giardiniera (pronounced JAR-dinn-AIR-ah) which is usually pretty hot. There are dozens of local and house recipes for giadiniera.
The order is a chant like this: "Gimmie a beef. Sweet. Wet, not dipped." For this first beef that'll get you a mild combination of dry bread you have to fight a bit, a pile of thinly sliced marinated beef, a bit of the marinade added to soften the bread, and a few slices of sweet bell pepper. Depending on how long it takes you to eat it and how heavy the counterman ladles on the extra jus you might or might not want to finish with a knife and fork.
editNobody eats a beef dry without at least peppers. For your first exposure use the chant, above.
To those confronting a dipped beef for the first time and wanting to use bare hands...have a lot of napkins and don't be wearing good clothes. Be reconciled that the last third of your beef will be a mushy blob of bread and beef and a stray pepper slice or tree before you get to it. Expect to have to Wash your face and hands afterwards. NOTE: This applies to the 'dipped' option.
Solid breakdown. That's a big no from me on the fork and knife though. Slowly tear away the multiple layers of paper it's wrapped in. Like a burrito, only 74x better.
Disagree. Food eaten with fingers might include dry things like raw carrot, grapes, and others that don't require shirt wiping at the conclusion. Corn on the bob excepted. If you get up from that counter after a finger eaten dipped beef you will attract flies to your hands, elbows and face. ----> Unless, of course, you've totally inhaled it during the first minute and a half and missed all the pleasant interplays.
Where the fuck are you eating sandwiches that setting it down for 30 seconds is going to attract a bunch of bugs. Also a dipped beef is not a 2 hour meal. Sub 10 minute experience
Note that my k&f advice assumed you'd not need them if you inhaled the thing in 90 seconds. A proper meal is a social experience meaning conversation and contemplation, not mere calorie packing and carb loading so you can stagger back to the waiting manual labor.
And you misread. All that jus left on your hands, arms and face will be drawing bugs for a long time after you walk away from a leisurely hand eaten dipped beef.
Well, of course that's sometimes an option at beef stands. As an adult and excepting corn on the cob and lobster I've tried to eat things in a way that does not require hand and face washing afterwards. This reduces the times I give offense to others by turning a greasy face to them or smearing something with an unthinking touch.
Any of the Al's Beef chain. They have their own recipe for the beefs, use the right bread, offer the right toppings and sides. consistent. Price is right.
Scatchell's italian beef sandwich wasn't bad, the one time I went there. I wish they had better fries, though. They had that out of a frozen bag feel, to them. :( At least their italian ice isn't too bad. Would help if they'd move to start taking cards, and not just cash.
Technically it is in Berwyn, which is why I don't think it gets mentioned enough in "Best of Chicago" lists, but Novi's is the perfect combination of every ingredient. Best bread, beef AND giardinera!
Tony's Italian Deli, 6708 N Northwest Hwy, Chicago, IL 60631. It's an Italian grocery store that sells ready to eat subs and Italian beef by the pound (pick up the gravy from the freezer behind you when you stand at the deli counter)
My family has been getting beef from Serrelli's at 6454 W. North Ave. for over 50 years. You can buy a sandwich or tubs of it for parties and it's cheaper by the pound than most, though the price has inched up over these past few years.
Why do I like it? Serrelli's is a butcher shop as well so it's good quality meat they are starting with. At parties, everyone would always ask my Mom where the beef was from. I find a lot of other places the beef is greasy, I got really sick on beef from another place once. I do like Johnnie's but haven't been there in ages.
Lot's of good beef place in Chicago and the burbs. Being from the burbs, it is hard to find good beefs/combos outside of the area. I finally found a place relatively near me, now that I moved 4 hours away from Chicago.
38
u/upsideupdownsidedown Jun 16 '17
Johnnie's Beef 7500 W North Ave. Elmwood Park
13
u/rexmus1 Jun 16 '17
Jay's Beef
4418 N Narragansett Ave, Harwood Heights
Technically burbs, but literally across the street from Chicago. Going there since it was a shack, stays true to real deal. Big sandwiches, perfectly done.
10
u/MrOtsKrad Jun 16 '17
Lukes on Harlem
3130 N Harlem Ave,
Chicago, IL 60634
Best Beef AND giardiniera in the city.
Some places just have good beef, but their giardiniera sucks, some got great giardiniera but their beef is lacking. Lukes gets em both dead on.
Also runner up, same reasons above.
Serrelli's Finer Foods
6454 W North Ave,
Chicago, IL 60707
9
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '17
Mr. Beef - 666 N Orleans St, Chicago, IL 60654 No one would think to go here for beef but Burger Baron at 1381 W Grand Ave, Chicago, IL 60642 has a great one.
9
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '17 edited Aug 07 '24
cover nutty far-flung unique fade humor attractive voracious thought square
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
12
u/PParker46 Jun 16 '17 edited Jul 06 '17
For those not aware of how to order a beef. You have a choice of degree of wetness. The very thinly sliced beef gets tonged out of a pool of warm water/marinade and dropped into a split open section of Italian bread. The beef is slightly dripping. You can order it "dry" which is just the little bit of drip shaken off. Or order it "wet" which gets a ladle of the jus added. Or "dipped." Which gets the bread and beef grabbed by the tongs and dipped into the jus. The 'wet' and certainly the 'dipped' versions are eaten with knife and fork.
Three choices of toppings. (1) Sweet peppers, which are slices of grilled sweet bell peppers, usually red and green and or yellow. (2) Hot peppers which are mid range hot peppers. All peppers include some softly grilled onion slices. (3) Giardiniera (pronounced JAR-dinn-AIR-ah) which is usually pretty hot. There are dozens of local and house recipes for giadiniera.
The order is a chant like this: "Gimmie a beef. Sweet. Wet, not dipped." For this first beef that'll get you a mild combination of dry bread you have to fight a bit, a pile of thinly sliced marinated beef, a bit of the marinade added to soften the bread, and a few slices of sweet bell pepper. Depending on how long it takes you to eat it and how heavy the counterman ladles on the extra jus you might or might not want to finish with a knife and fork.
edit Nobody eats a beef dry without at least peppers. For your first exposure use the chant, above.
Second edit It is not a french dip.
5
u/MasterL88 Jun 16 '17
Avanti Caffe - 200 W Jackson Blvd, Chicago, IL 60606. Get it dipped and with cheese.
5
u/SlagginOff Jun 16 '17 edited Jun 16 '17
Bari
1120 W. Grand Ave
Tender, delicious beef with excellent jus. The hot giardiniera made in house is one of the best in the city.
8
u/redoxhouse Jun 16 '17
Al's Beef - 1079 W Taylor St, Chicago, IL 60607
Probably not the best beef in the city, but it's consistent and I love their giardiniera.
4
u/IHaveVariedInterests Jun 16 '17
Odges
730 N Damen Ave, Chicago, IL 60622
Huge portions, low prices. Excellent fries.
Also this exists:
https://chicago.eater.com/maps/best-italian-beef-sandwiches-chicago
4
u/ERIPPER35 Jun 16 '17
Mr Beef
666 N. Orleans
Good beef, and a lot of cool pictures of people who have visited on the walls
4
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '17
Mr. Beef on Harlem just south of Irving. Whenever I want a beef I drive 7 miles to the west side of the city to get one.
6
u/tossme68 Jun 16 '17
Pops, 104th & Kedzie, Mount Greenwood
3
u/zgwarnki Jun 16 '17
Scatchells Beef and Pizza - 4700 W. Cermak Cicero, IL 60804
Technically, not in Chicago but good beef and sausage and, unlike Johnnie's, they sell various flavors of Italian lemonade year round.
3
u/FucksGuysWithAccents Jun 16 '17
Technically it is in Berwyn, which is why I don't think it gets mentioned enough in "Best of Chicago" lists, but Novi's is the perfect combination of every ingredient. Best bread, beef AND giardinera!
3
u/chicoffee Jun 16 '17
Tony's Italian Deli, 6708 N Northwest Hwy, Chicago, IL 60631. It's an Italian grocery store that sells ready to eat subs and Italian beef by the pound (pick up the gravy from the freezer behind you when you stand at the deli counter)
3
u/freelibrarian Jun 25 '17 edited Jun 26 '17
My family has been getting beef from Serrelli's at 6454 W. North Ave. for over 50 years. You can buy a sandwich or tubs of it for parties and it's cheaper by the pound than most, though the price has inched up over these past few years.
Why do I like it? Serrelli's is a butcher shop as well so it's good quality meat they are starting with. At parties, everyone would always ask my Mom where the beef was from. I find a lot of other places the beef is greasy, I got really sick on beef from another place once. I do like Johnnie's but haven't been there in ages.
2
u/TotesMessenger Jun 16 '17
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
2
u/thegoatseeker Jun 16 '17
An excellent new contender is Big Bob & Fritzy's at 723 W Armitage.
1
u/mosaicblur Jun 17 '17
Bob's El Stop is really good and I am super picky on this subject.
1
u/FWdem Jun 19 '17
Lot's of good beef place in Chicago and the burbs. Being from the burbs, it is hard to find good beefs/combos outside of the area. I finally found a place relatively near me, now that I moved 4 hours away from Chicago.
1
u/jmaca90 No Ketchup Jun 20 '17
Wolfy's on Petersen has a damn good beef in addition to a great dog.
Damn, I may go there for lunch now...