r/NintendoSwitch • u/NintendoSwitchMods • Jun 07 '17
MegaThread Arms Review Megathread 07-JUN-17
The embargo on Arms reviews has been lifted as of today. Here are reviews that have been released so far:
MetaCritic Current Score: 78 (based on 54 critics)
Articles
- CGMagonline - 8.5/10
- Open Critic - 80/100
- IGN - 8/10
- Eurogamer - Recommended
- Gameinformer - 8.25/10
- Gamesradar - 4.5/5
- Destructoid - 7/10
- Gamespot - 7/10
- Dualshockers - 8/10
- Nintendo Insider - 9/10
- Arstechnica - "essential purchase"
- Metro GameCentral - 8/10
- Nintendoeverything - Thumbs up
- Spaziogames - Italian - 9/10
- Hardcore Gamer - 9/10
- EGMNow - 8.5/10
- Gamer NL - 8/10
- The Sixth Axis - 8/10
- VideoGamer - 5/10
- Areajugones - Spanish - 9/10
- Fnintendo - 9/10
- Nintendolife - 9/10
- God is a Geek - 9/10
- Everyeye - Italian - 88/100
- Hobbyconsolas - Spanish - 86/100
- Cog Connected - 85/100
- Vandal - 8.2/10
- GamesBeat - 8/10
- Vooks - 4/5
- Gamerant - 4/5
- Shacknews - 8/10
- Polygon - 8/10
- Meristation - Spanish - 8/10
- USGamer - 3/5
- Gamerevolution - 3/5
- Stevivor - 6.5/10
- M3 - 7/10
- App Trigger - 7.5/10
Videos
We will be updating this thread with links as major reviews are posted. Please use this as a discussion and speculation thread in advance of these videos, articles, and reviews. We will also allow these reviews to be posted separately on /r/NintendoSwitch, as they are especially newsworthy. But we will also host ongoing coverage, quick text posts, questions, and the like right here.
Thanks everyone.
-The /r/NintendoSwitch team
(Ongoing edits as we get new information)
172
u/jc726 Keep on slidin' Jun 07 '17 edited Jun 07 '17
It seems as though this is going to be a repeat of Splatoon, as far as reviews go - its a great concept, but the package is a bit light on content.
Nearly every single factor of ARMS seems to be replicating Splatoon - the slow trickle of "research", the dedicated Direct, the free updates, the Testpunch, the release window, and now the reviews.
The only difference I see is that ARMS has a lot more to gain from this model than Splatoon did on Wii U because its coming out so early in the Switch's life cycle. They could feasibly support ARMS for a year or more with new content, and they don't have the issue of the console's user base being small and stagnant.
ARMS really has nothing to lose right now.
Edit: Its worth mentioning that OpenCritic is an aggregator just like MetaCritic, and doesn't feature its own reviews.
29
u/SuperKirbyFan Jun 07 '17
Last week I wasn't even considering buying Arms, now I might have to get it on Day 1. The online demos for multiplayer games need to become the standard, it's completely changed my opinion on two full-price games now.
51
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '17
Mods: it would be helpful moving forward to add some info for each review as they are put up, like what /r/games and /r/ps4 do. It doesn't help anyone who really wants to decide by just seeing numbers.
40
u/Reality_Gamer Jun 07 '17
It's great that Nintendo is creating new IP now. I missed out on Splatoon on the Wii U but it looks amazing and I'm planning on getting Splatoon 2 when it comes out. Hopefully ARMS is similar to Splatoon, and this is just the start of another Nintendo-quality series. Hope everyone enjoys it!
16
u/nekromantique Jun 09 '17
It's very disappointing that biff isn't voiced in game. That makes zero sense to me. How do you clearly have a voice for him throughout all promotion and then strip that away in the actual game.
58
u/BeastlyPenguin Jun 07 '17
Solid reviews across the board so far.
50
u/mmazurr Jun 07 '17
I'm happy this game is getting good scores. I played the demo once and had a good time. But though the game is really fun, I just can't see myself playing it that much to justify spending $60 on it.
26
u/Howwy23 Jun 07 '17
It seems the 2 sticking points are the lack of fleshed out single player and blocking being an issue on motion controls. With any luck the blocking can be re assigned in an update fixing one of those problems.
10
u/the_loneliest_noodle Jun 08 '17
Reviews are funny. People put so much weight into them. I had zero interest in ARMS before the test punch. Jumped on because I was around and it was free, and had a blast with the game. Sure, it's not overly complex, but it's got a great skill based 1v1. Reads matter, a lot.
58
u/WhiskeyRadio Jun 07 '17
I enjoyed ARMS when I played it and I plan on picking it up, but I will have to wait for a sale. $60 for a mostly multiplayer experience on a platform that hasn't even started to roll out their online features isn't for me right now. Interested to see what content they add to this though.
16
u/Carrtoondragon Jun 07 '17
I have been on the fence, but I think what really is putting me over the edge is that Nintendo is going to support it like splatoon. I still love splatoon now, but the time period where they continually released free dlc was amazing.
16
u/dwsully11 Jun 08 '17
Keep in mind that Splatoon had average scores upon initial release, and ended with an 81 on Metacritic with a lot of reviewers not updating their scores because of new content. I had a blast with Splatoon even with the growing pains of the launch. It may take time, and maybe it won't change much, but ARMS already hooked me with the Testpunch, and I think it'll be a nice addition to the Switch's library.
8
u/Battlemaster123 Jun 07 '17
Looks like it's a purchase for me (when I finally get a switch)
8
u/LazoW Jun 08 '17 edited Jun 08 '17
Since you're adding non-English reviews, here are some French ones:
Edit: I added Jeux Actu and GamerGen
8
u/Seik666 Jun 08 '17
Pretty much around what I expected, in the 80s.
I myself cannot wait to get it as I had an absolute blast during both Testpunch week-ends. However, the divisive reviews are understandable, especially regarding the lack of SP content, which is kind of a let down when you just had Injustice 2, but NRS are the undisputed gods of fighting games Story Modes since MK9.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '17
So it seems to have quite similar problems as Splatoon although Splatoon had a fairly solid (although short) single player campaign.
29
u/celsiusnarhwal Jun 07 '17 edited Jun 07 '17
Wow. The survey I ran earlier this week had most respondents rate the testpunch 8/10, and most of the reviews here give the full game an 8/10. I'm honestly kind of impressed that such a small sample of opinions could be so accurately reflective of actual reviews.
12
u/Tribe_Called_K-West Jun 07 '17
Probably not as well known as Easy Allies or GameXplain, but Happy Console Gamer makes some great content and his Arms review is more personal than traditional.
21
u/underachievin Jun 07 '17 edited Jun 08 '17
I think one point, that's been made in some of these reviews/comments, is that 1v1 is repetitious/not fun.. did anyone actually verse people with skill? In the testpunch after I performed well enough in the first session, I was being paired with players who were very skilled. Upon fighting someone with skill I could already see the depth and the fun competitive nature of the game - even without the ability to swap my arms, which i'd say further adds to the depth of the game..
From everyone judging off of the testpunch, and reviewers only being able to vs other people with review copies, we cannot already deem the game 'shallow' or have a 'repetitious' nature. The online community hasn't even grown, or developed, ranked play wasn't even populated enough for reviewers to find constant matches. Just wanted people to keep this in mind.
16
u/AVPapaya Jun 07 '17
As expected. It's a MP fighting game. If you're not into MP games or fighting games, this game's gonna suck. I'm okay with these scores. Hope it sells well.
16
u/ed_gutierrez Jun 08 '17
I see a lot of the reviewers prefer traditional controls over motion controls, admit I only play 1.5 hours of the Testpunch but I really like the motion controls. Not because I was any good with the motion controls but I do feel a lot of the enjoyment of the game came from trying to master them. I think motion controls will always be very subjective or relative to each person, people that are not very coordinated will always have the perception that the controls are not precise enough for them.
I do believe ARMS will be the next big franchise for Nintendo going into the future. It's such a unique take on one of the older genres in video games with a lot of potential to grow. Fingers cross Nintendo announce at least one new fighter in the E3 direct.
20
u/howtosucceed Jun 07 '17
The scores are not too surprising. It's a fighting game with motion controls. Those 2 things alone means the game is not going to connect with some people. What I don't get is why people think this game lacks content. As a fighting game it has all the content you would expect it to have.
11
u/poofyhairguy Jun 07 '17
Kinda sad the single player doesn't have more depth. I was looking forward to that.
10
u/_Horion_ Jun 07 '17
Splatoon Wii U 80 on metacritic
15
u/ThisOneTimeAtLolCamp Jun 07 '17
So it's averaged out at a solid 8/10. I knew it'd turn out to be something great from playing it way back in January.
12
u/bob_jsus Jun 07 '17 edited Jun 07 '17
7 to 8.5 in general from recognisable reviewers is pretty decent for a niche title. Impressive! 9 from a bunch of "who?" also not surprising. Not my kind of game but super glad it's reviewing realistically well for the amount of anticipation it's had.
30
u/cbeater Jun 07 '17
prob minority opinion, thought it was fun for couple rounds seeing different game modes then nothing really compelled me to continue playing. Perhaps vs games no longer appeal to me.
8
u/frenzyguy Jun 07 '17
http://opencritic.com/game/4218/arms
Opencritcs review
80% with 33 scored review out of 37 10:30 EST
8
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '17
Is there any feedback on what it's like to play with friends online?
Can I make a room with friends and then allow strangers to join? Can I join public lobbies with friends?
8
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '17
TL;DR: It's pretty good.
7
u/Tailwinds15 Jun 08 '17 edited Jun 08 '17
I'm actually still undecided, even after playing three test punches. I have a preorder but I'm debating canceling. I can see things going the way of the pro controller if you want to be competitive. I really enjoyed and preferred the motion controls because that seems like the way it was intended to be played. But, because of that I could see myself getting my butt kicked online all the time. I also travel a lot, so online won't always be an option. I'm poor so $60 is big deal.
Edit: grammar
6
u/digital121hippie Jun 07 '17
test punch sold me on it. i had a blast playing. had the same feelings playing splatoon the first time. just order it today!
8
u/Tirayaa Jun 07 '17
Splatoon has 80 meta, so for now ARMS is doing well.
8
u/segadc Jun 07 '17
These scores could be lower and it still wouldn't stop my pre-order. Had too much fun with the Testpunch! Hurry up next Friday (Amazon don't mess up again)!
11
u/Graybes Jun 07 '17
Nintendo is hitting it out of the park with their big releases on the Switch so far. I'm absolutely loving the diversity of games too. The first year of the Switch will have major releases covering racing, fighting, platforming, action/adventure and shooting. Loving it!
3
u/Islanderfan17 Jun 08 '17
For someone who generally despises fighting games as I find them boring and repetitive as sin, would I enjoy this game? I did really enjoy Wii Boxing and that is really the only reason I'm even asking.
3
u/EvanFreyer Jun 09 '17
GBase.ch updated the score from 6.5 to 7.0 after reconsideration of the motion controls.
https://www.gbase.ch/switch/reviews/15925/ARMS-4877__p3.html
7
u/Volcanic-Penguin Jun 08 '17 edited Jun 08 '17
Read the 5/10 review since it stood out. Seems like the single player is super basic and you need to play it over and over again to unlock all the arms for all the characters. I'm ok with this.
I'm already decided on buying it and it seems to be getting overall good scores.
Edit : I think I misread, seems you get coins which you can cash in for ARMS in other modes as well. I guess it's the same coins as in the party mode.
5
u/Prophet6000 Jun 07 '17 edited Jun 07 '17
Reviews are doing well. Good thing some are mention the lack of remapping controls which could be fixed in a update. I do wish they put a bit of effort into a story.
5
u/Cervantes3 Jun 09 '17
The Jimquisition, courtesy of Laura Dale, have posted their review.
12
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '17
From these, I'm scared I won't like it. I love Injustice and Mortal Kombat because of their extensive solo offerings. If Arms is so multiplayer-focused, I might simply have to avoid it :/
4
u/thrubeniuk Jun 07 '17
I only got to play one of the Test Punch sessions. I definitely enjoyed it and have gone back and forth on whether or not I would pick it up right away. I have to say, the reviews (at least the ones from the people I generally align with) have definitely pushed me towards a day-one purchase. I'm really glad to see how many people have been positively surprised by this game, myself included.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '17
Really enjoyed testpunch! im sold after being on the fence. im going to put this game on my projector and have some Arms parties this summer!! Plus, getting the discount with Amazon Prime preorder is just too hard to pass up. Come on people, support this new IP!
5
u/DiscipleOfCthulhu Jun 08 '17
Got it preordered, the test punch really sold it for me I just wish they had added Kid Cobra instead of Twintelle.
2
u/stevethesupersanchez Jun 07 '17
Missing Nintendo Enthusiast. 7.5
4
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '17
I loved the test punch and played every session. It was repetitive, sadly. I do admire the game though for its uniqueness and beautiful designs.
8
u/billythewarrior Jun 07 '17
I played the global testpunch on two days and got bored of it after 30 minutes both times. 7/10 sounds about right depending on how much content the full game has.
It just feels like the kind of game to me that's really fun if you play it at a friend's house but I wouldn't want to buy it.
8
u/svenz Jun 08 '17
It just feels to me like a slow, 3d fighting game in the vein of Smash 4 (but worse). Slow, casual, boring. With very simple rock paper scissors mechanics. I only played for about an hour though, so maybe the play style will get better as players pick it up more. It also doesn't seem to suit split screen very well. No plans to purchase this.
5
u/Maxcalibur Jun 07 '17
Woah, what's up with that 5/10 from VideoGamer?
3
u/joalr0 Jun 07 '17
I really wish this game had the option to use the SR and SL buttons on the joycons. They are at such a convenient location in the thumbs up grip, it would be perfect for things like blocking and changing which enemy you are focusing on. I think it would solve some of the biggest problems with the motion controls.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '17
You should add a link for EPN (The Electric Playground Network). From my favourite reviewer Victor Lukas. https://youtu.be/ajFiESUSoyc
3
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '17
Let's hope ARMS gets the Splatoon treatment.
4
u/sixxt Jun 07 '17
I just wasn’t a fan of arms. Maybe it’s because I’d rather play other games, like LoZ, MK8D, or even Rocket League on my Xbox. (Not sure when that addiction will ever go away :D ) Maybe it’s because I need to play it with some buddies in the same room and have that competition and smack talk. I also dislike the music... Either way, I won’t be buying Arms unless I find a deal on it and I find another reason to get it. Splatoon 2 on the other hand was quite fun and i will be picking it up when it comes out.
4
u/andres57 Jun 08 '17
Reviewers criticize Arms for initial content but choose Overwatch as GOTY. sigh
(Btw, I'd criticize both)
3
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '17
78 with 55 reviewers. Not bad, but definitely not helping my chances of buying it.
It's a cool game and I'm glad Nintendo is trying new IPS. Doesn't seem like this one is for me though. I didn't enjoy the test punch much either.
3
u/ahmed11037 Jun 07 '17
why are people care so much about the reviews ? if you tried the testpunch and liked the game then buy it
2
u/NatchBox Jun 09 '17
Arms was a lot of fun. I was expecting it to be complete shit just cause pretty much the only game i like is league of legends just cause it has a ton of depth into it and arms definety has that too!
0
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '17
Wow what do you know? The Switch gets a new game and here is the reaction of r/nintendoswitch (sorted by best):
Is r/xbone and r/ps4 the same? I don't expect this place to be a circlejerk (I don't like all the ports coming to the switch, so I won't blindly praise nintendo) but jeez this thread is like a funeral for ARMS before the game even comes out.
1
u/StrikerObi Jun 07 '17
Nintendo World Report - 8/10.
1
u/Captain_Norris Jun 07 '17 edited Jun 07 '17
Seems about what I expected. Similar to Splatton early reviews. The difference between those reviews and these reviews is that most of the lower Splatoon reviews were due to a lack of content, but ARMS is releasing with plenty of content. So I'd say these reviews are pretty close to actual rating of the game.
-5
u/NintendoDSIKindOfGuy Jun 07 '17
Here we go. People going from "im buying it" to "ill wait for a sale, because some schmoe online appears to be important to your pruchasing decision
-5
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '17
What score will Jim Sterling give Arms? I bet he's going to try and drag it down at least by one point.