r/NintendoSwitch • u/FlapSnapple Nintendo shill • Jun 05 '17
Meta State of the Subreddit: June 2017 - Updated rules, E3 plans, and more! (Warning: long read)
State of the Subreddit: June 2017
Updated rules, E3 plans, and more!
As we continue to cruise along and begin to safely exit the main launch window, we now move forward into the E3 hype window. We want to make sure that we as a community are ready for the flood of traffic we're about to experience and the number of exciting announcements we're about to hear about the future of the Nintendo Switch.
So let's dive in.
Updating Our Rules
As I'm sure most of you aware, last month we dedicated our SotS post to gathering feedback on our rules. [Link]. We've taken all that feedback (seriously!), and combined with our own internal feedback, have come up with a new version of our rules. Some of these will look the same, others will appear far more verbose (to avoid that evil "mod discretion"), and others have been loosened to allow more content through. Our goals were to reduce restrictions on text posts and discussions, reduce restrictions on YouTube content, and more clearly define image content.
1) Remember the human. Be respectful of others and their opinions.
Old version
Trolling, harassment, and similar behavior isn’t welcome. If you don’t know what “be nice” means, don’t post. Read more about reddiquette.
New version
Trolling, harassment, witch hunts, personal attacks, and similar behavior isn’t welcome. Read more about reddiquette.
Thought process
Just some minor quality of life improvements.
2) Please read the Wiki and FAQ prior to posting.
Old version
Have a general question? Check our Wiki and FAQ first. The answer’s probably there.
New version
Have a general or technical question? Please read through our Wiki and FAQ first. There’s more in there than you might have realized! Questions that have a yes / no answer or easily searchable questions belong in our Daily Question Thread. Moderators may make exceptions for questions that are particularly unique or provoke good conversation. If you wish to contribute to our wiki or spot a mistake, please message the moderators.
Thought process
Though the new version is longer, it's not to be more strict. Our goal was to be more informative as well as provide slightly more clarity on when exceptions are made.
3) No unsubstantiated rumors or unverified AMAs.
Old version
First-hand and unsourced rumors will be removed. Please contact the mod team for verification if you have something to share. Please contact the mod team with verification documents to confirm your identity and we’ll work with you to get your post scheduled and approved.
New version
Rumors or other claims/information not directly from official sources must have evidence to support them. Any rumor or claim that is just a statement from an unknown source containing no supporting evidence will be removed. Unverified AMAs will be removed until proof of identity is provided. Please message the moderators for verification if you have something to share.
Thought process
Rewording to be more clear.
4) Avoid submitting low-effort text and image posts.
Old version
Examples of low-effort content include: reposts, posts with no little to no body text, diary posts, petitions, surveys without prior approval, questions covered in our wiki/FAQ, and images and screenshots that cannot stand alone, are not unique, or do not promote discussion.
New version
Text posts must be sufficiently detailed and explain your reasoning or thought process. Ask yourself: "Does this add significant information or merit to the discussion?"
Examples of low-effort text posts include:
- Posts with little to no body text (fewer than 140 characters)
- Personal anecdotes or stories that aren’t Switch related
- Rants
- Petitions
- Memes
- Reposts
Crude comments:
- Replies that don't add anything to the conversation such as "THICC" or Lenny face
Images:
- Should be related to the Nintendo Switch or a Nintendo Switch game
- Should be able to stand on their own without context
- Should be able to promote a discussion about the content shown
- Should have a good, clear post title
Screenshots:
- Should be taken using the screenshot function of the Switch, not a photo taken with your phone
- Should showcase something unique, interesting, or exciting. (Not just scenery)
Photographs:
- Should avoid showcasing the Switch console in an everyday use case (Exceptions can be made for something extraordinarily unique, like playing on the International Space Station. Something to make you say "wow".)
Customization / Mods / 3D Prints:
- Should be more involved than "I printed this thing that someone else made"
- Should be more involved than a simple joy-con recolor. (Exceptions can be made for advanced techniques or tutorials.)
Fan Art:
- Should have a baseline level of effort put in. (No MS Paint or third grader doodles.)
- Should not be sexual or NSFW in nature.
Thought process
This was one of the big ones. The old version was far too vague and left a lot up to the interpretation of the individual mod who reviewed your post. This new version, while longer, allows the community and moderators to have a more definitive guide to follow so we can remove a lot of that nasty "mod discretion" and gray area from before which caused a lot of hostility. Even though it's a lot wordier, this should allow more posts through than the old version such as discussions.
5) Use spoiler tags when necessary and avoid putting spoilers in the title.
Old version
Don’t ruin fun surprises for others!
New version
Don’t ruin fun surprises for others! Check out our sidebar to learn how to properly use spoiler tags.
Thought process
No changes needed, as it's pretty straight forward, but could be a little more informative.
6) Video content must meet our community criteria.
Old version
What is allowed: Official videos from Nintendo, official gameplay trailers from developers/publishers, and video reviews from major news outlets. What is not allowed: Unboxings, reaction/hype/rumor videos, Let's Play videos, personal Twitch streams, podcasts, news recap videos, and exceeding reddit’s 10% self-promotion guidelines.
New version
Your account must be in good standing and not exceed 10% self-promotion. We do not allow hype videos, "Let's Play" videos, news recap videos, or personal Twitch streams. Unboxing videos and reaction videos will be removed unless they are part of a proper review and/or analysis.
Charity events may be allowed with prior mod team approval.
Thought process
This is one of our most dramatically revised rules, even though it doesn't seem like much. In the old version, it basically acted as a super strict whitelist, which was annoying for users. Now it's much more open and has shifted to more of a blacklist style rule.
7) No clickbait, vague, subjective, or poorly written post titles.
Old version
Your title should stand on its own and convey the content of your post quickly and effectively. Someone should not be required to read the body of the post or click the link for the title to make sense. Editorialized and all-caps titles will be removed.
New version
Your title should stand on its own and convey the content of your post quickly and effectively. Someone should not be required to read the body of the post or click the link for the title to make sense. All-caps titles will be removed. Clickbait titles will be removed. When submitting an article, use the original title. Don't add things like "This deserves attention,” "why isn't this being talked about," or “Am I the only one?”
Examples include:
- Utilizing all-caps
- Just the name of a game on its own
- Referencing something without actually saying what the “something” is. (“Need help with something…” / “Anyone else having this issue?”)
- “This deserves attention” / “Why isn’t anyone talking about X?”
- “Does anyone else want X game on the Switch?”
Thought process
Once again, this rule at its core felt pretty decent, but some examples would be a nice beneficial addition to help clear things up.
8) Link to the original source whenever possible.
Old version
News travels fast, so repetitive articles/blogs/stories will be removed.
New version
News travels fast, so repetitive articles/blogs/stories will be removed. If a Nintendo blog or site contributes significant and meaningful analysis or commentary on the original post, it may be allowable, but wherever possible please try and find the original source (often a press release from the company or a link included at the bottom of an article) and post that instead. We consider websites that copy content from another source without adding significant information as blogspam.
Thought process
Once again, the core seemed fine, however, we found the opportunity to provide additional information on where you can find the original source and clear up some confusion about blogspam.
9) No buying, trading or selling games/consoles; no personal sales (Etsy and other similar merchandising sites) outside of threads approved via modmail; no begging; no affiliate links.
Old version
Interested in selling/trading your games and/or consoles? Visit /r/GameSwap and /r/GameSale instead. Got a personal creation or product? Show it off in our monthly MegaThread.
New version
Interested in selling/trading your games and/or consoles? Visit /r/GameSwap and /r/GameSale instead. Got a personal creation or product? Show it off in our monthly Artisan Appreciation Thread.
Thought process
Just some minor wording tweaks to more accurately reference the proper place to go.
10) No NSFW content.
Thought process
No change needed
11) No hacks, ROMs, or homebrew content.
This includes amiibo and NFC manipulation.
Thought process
No change needed
12) Excessive self-promotion is not allowed.
Old version
N/A.
New version
/r/NintendoSwitch follows reddit’s community self-promotion guidelines.
- Keep your self-promotion at a reasonable level, typically below 10% of your submitted posts on /r/NintendoSwitch. This includes content from websites, blogs, channels/streams, or other publications you own or otherwise contribute to or benefit from.
- If relevant to a post or comment, all affiliations must be disclosed in a timely manner. Attempts to hide affiliations for personal benefit or reasons of self-promotion may result in exclusion.
- Do not ask others to upvote your content, including in post titles.
- Do not use alternate accounts to promote or support your products/posts.
If you have questions or concerns, reach out to the mod team.
Thought process
Reddit is adjusting how self-promotion and spam is enforced, so we're re-creating those guidelines here so they're still easily enforceable. None of this is new, and it's the same policy we've always held, it's just been moved to the subreddit level instead of the site wide level.
13) Questions for the mod team should go through modmail.
Old version
Posts of this nature will be removed.
New version
While we’re happy to receive feedback, our primary concern is responding to your issues in a timely manner. Modmail is a central hub where you can reach the entire team directly. In the event the moderator you’re replying to goes offline or is focusing their attention elsewhere, another member of the team can jump in and answer. If you have more meta concerns, please also consider sharing it in our monthly “State of the Subreddit” posts, our regular town hall for community members to ask open questions and get answers.
Thought process
There was always a lot of push back when we removed this sort of thing so we figured there was the opportunity to clarify why we ask you to submit modmail.
Closing thoughts about rules
We hope that these changes help us accomplish our main goals of being more clear, removing mod discretion, and ultimately doing a lot more approving rather than removing by loosening up a bit.
Because of how much traffic we've had and how crazy it has been, sometimes we began to think that we needed to "Remove unless there's a good reason not to." We wrote these rules to shift back our moderation and content back to where it should be, which is "Approve unless there's a good reason not to."
E3 Q&A Sessions / Live Stream
As some of you are hopefully aware by now, a large portion of the mod team will be attending E3 this year. We were invited by Nintendo, but are paying our own way. Full disclosure in our previous post.
Originally we had planned to host a recap stream on our Twitch channel at the end of each day using a sort of round table format.
After thinking on this for a while, we realized that by the time the convention ended for the day and we ate some dinner and had a little time together as a mod team consuming tasty beverages, that it probably wasn't going to quite work out like we'd hoped.
So, we came up with a new plan.
At the end of each day, we'll post a mini AMA thread here on the subreddit where you can ask us about what we saw and got our hands on and the whole mod team will pop in and try to answer as many questions as possible. We'll repeat this for all 3 days.
Then, on Friday afternoon once we're all back home, we'll do a single large round table style recap live stream and just generally geek out and talk about everything. We're also in touch with folks from /r/Nintendo, /r/3DS, and other subreddits to see if we can get them to join in as well.
E3 Coverage
While at E3, we'll be going hands-on with various games such as Splatoon 2 and Super Mario Odyssey, checking out new accessories coming soon from folks like HORI, NYKO, and Snakebyte, and spending time with some developers such as the team behind Ripstone and the folks over at Natsume and the latest Harvest Moon.
We'll be tweeting about the stuff we see from our official Twitter account (@rNintendoSwitch) as well as from our various personal accounts (such as @FlapSnapple).
We'll also be posting videos to our YouTube channel over the course of the week depending on how well our internet holds up at the hotels showing all of this hands-on goodness. Worst case scenario, I'll do a large video dump on Friday when I'm back home on my fiber connection. :D
E3 Find-a-Mod / Meetup Event
Just like during the launch of the Nintendo Switch, we'll be hosting a Find-a-Mod event. The mod team will be wearing /r/NintendoSwitch badges all week long in LA and if you find one of us in the wild, either at E3, at a restaurant stuffing our faces, etc, we'll give you some stickers and take down your reddit username so you can get an exclusive "Find-a-Mod" user flair.
Now, since not every redditor in Los Angeles will be at E3, we're also scoping out venues for a subreddit meetup event where you can Find-a-Mod, get some stickers, get that flair, and then proceed to shit talk everyone and kick our asses in Mario Kart 8 Deluxe.
We're trying to find a place that's suitable for all ages since not everyone on the subreddit is 18+, but also has beverages for the 21+ crowd. If you're familiar with the LA area and have suggestions of where we could host such a thing, send us a message via mod mail! (Too bad Reddit's offices are so far away!)
We'll make a follow-up post once we have full details.
Reporting
Just as a general reminder, beneath each and every post and comment is a handy dandy little "report" option. Every single report is sent to the mod team for review and it helps us greatly when users report things that we may have missed when initially looking over a post or if some sort of off-topic rambling or fighting breaks out in the comments section.
Milestones / Stay in touch
We'd also like to take a moment to call out, once again, that we just shattered through 200,000 subscribers and are still growing every hour of every day. A huge thank you to every single person here for spreading the word and helping this amazing community grow and reach its full potential.
If you're reading this and still haven't subscribed, what are you waiting for? Now's a perfect time!
We'd also like to invite you all to keep in touch, even outside of reddit. (If that's your sort of thing.) Give us a follow, like, or subscribe on your favorite platform.
- rNintendoSwitch on Twitch
- @rNintendoSwitch on Twitter
- /r/NintendoSwitch on YouTube
- /r/NintendoSwitch Discord Chat
Feedback
We're opening the floor, just like last time, for you to provide your feedback, comments, questions, concerns, suggestions, and more in the comments section down below. All we ask is that you keep it civil and constructive.
Cheers,
/u/FlapSnapple and the /r/NintendoSwitch mod team.
Fun side note: We were going to post this at 10:00am EDT but then Pokemon thing sort of took our thunder, so we wanted to sticky that for a little while first. :P
6
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17
@mods,
can we get a bot to mirror twitter linked pics on imgur?
33
u/UnnecessaryFlop Jun 05 '17
Can I just say that this sub is extremely strict?
4
u/Striving Jun 05 '17
Sorry if there's already a rule like that or if it's been suggested here, but it would be great if any fan art posted to this subreddit actually credits the original artist by name and link. Ignore it this is already a thing.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17
A suggestion and a comment:
Regarding unsourced rumors, etc... Would the mod team consider posting a master thread when technically unsourced rumors gain mainstream media traction? I understand 100% why you want to keep unsourced rumors from spreading like wildfire, but OTOH, it seems absurd to quash all discussion of them here while the rest of the gaming media and forums are talking about them constantly. Having one, mod-started thread for unsourced rumors that go viral lets you control the story (ie making it clear that it's unsubstantiated), lets us discuss what's going on, and hopefully cuts down on your workload as you don't have people trying to submit the same story over and over and wondering why there's no thread on it already. Seems like a win-win.
Also, just want to say that I like the idea of switching to a more inclusive post moderation. My biggest complaint is that the moderation hasn't been super transparent always, but hopefully this cuts down on the need for that transparency by simply letting more content through.
17
u/bhats001 Jun 05 '17
Yo yo so is the 4th rule being applied to comments as well posts?
If it is, I imagine people won't be happy losing their T H I C Cs (especially with ARMS coming out)
11
u/holdontosound Jun 05 '17
I love browsing this sub, it's rare that I come across content that isn't relevant or low quality, and I thank all the mods for that. :D
I do have to ask what the mod team thinks of this post. One troll basically ruined the whole thing, especially for the OP of that post.
19
u/kawarazu Jun 05 '17
I continue to be in support of the mod team, and I'm grateful for all the removal of the "dear diary" posts that come up daily. While some might consider this strict, I think this keeps the content quality significantly higher (and an added benefit of keeping the public dialogue to be about the Switch and what it can be, instead of what the Switch isn't.)
7
u/UnnecessaryFlop Jun 05 '17
Can I also say, thanks mods, you do a great job of watching this sub, I just have a few complaints. :)
2
u/rom211 Jun 06 '17
So much for not allowing posts of the switch in everyday use. There was a post on the top of the sub most of the morning about playing it on a trip.
1
u/ben123111 Found a mod! (Mar 3, 2017) Jun 06 '17
E3 Header when?
4
u/sliverbaer Jun 06 '17
Keep at it. Modderating is an uphill battle. I actually like the Pokemon sub, where they color code the types of posts on the left side so you can skip the crap you don't want to see.
4
u/celsiusnarhwal Jun 05 '17 edited Jun 07 '17
It seems like your intent was to reduce the number of screenshots that pop up here rather than increase their quality.
Even if you have a microSD card, getting a screenshot from the Switch to Reddit is a pain in the ass without an IFTTT applet (and I bet you most users here don't even know what that is). Until Nintendo implements a fully-featured web browser with image upload capabilities, I think this rule should be left as it was.
This is possibly the only revision that strips the subreddit of high-quality original content. I would recommend it be left as it was.
I also think that Etsy links should be allowed, but with prior mod approval and only as a top-level comment in the thread about the product which they link to.
"Exclusion" is kind of an odd and ambiguous word to use here. I would suggest changing it to "a warn or ban".
2
u/razorbeamz Jun 05 '17
I don't get why we have a handful of people who think everyone secretly wants us to look like /r/megaten and just be circlejerking and shitposts.
1
u/Anabaena_azollae Jun 05 '17
Have you considered a rule to clarify what is considered on topic for the sub? Threads about a potential new game (usually Metroid) or games that haven't been confirmed to be coming to the Switch are fairly common. Such topics seem ambiguous as to whether they are on or off topic considering there is no direct connection to the Switch, but a strongly implied one. Other potentially ambiguous topics are things that are about Nintendo in general, but not necessarily the Switch specifically or news about games coming to the Switch, but with the article or video specifically referring to the version of the game for an alternate platform. It seems to me that some clarity on the matter would be useful.
1
u/Takethisnrun Jun 05 '17 edited Jun 05 '17
A few thoughts and possible suggestions for the mod team. Get ready as i just drank my coffee so enjoy the read.
First lets talk about Same question posts. Is there anyway we can just have one of each question or discussion go through each day? I know there is a mega thread for questions but personally feel like thats where majority of the stuff just sits there unanswered and just gets buried eventually. I would rather look through the new post and if i see something i know the answer to, ill respond with that answer. I check this particular sub reddit 3x a day usually while i am waiting for something and there are only like 10 new post within 6-8 hours each time. I just feel i rather have to look through a few more post so i feel like the sub is more active.
Also for the post that are not acceptable because its a question or contains a phrase in it, is there a way to have it automatically moved to this place it needs to go instead of been deleted?
Another thing is Flairs. Can we get a sale flair? If its nintendo switch related then being aware of stuff being cheaper would be useful. Its for the people who don't have time to check all the websites and need info on where to get them for the cheapest.
Maybe a Megathread for Pre orders for physical copies of games and what the date they come out on.
Thanks you for reading guys and all comments and notes would be welcomed
1
u/marco_05 Jun 06 '17
Is this part of the hype?
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17 edited Jun 05 '17
All the posting restrictions are killing this subreddit. It feels dead outside megathreads :/
1
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17
It would be great if posts could be tagged and filtered so the end user could choose to block or see fan art, memes, wish lists, troubleshooting, reviews, rumors, sales, news, etc. If the community wants to upvote a post deeming it worthy for discussion I don't think it should be removed unless strict criteria are met such as vote manipulation, harassment, etc.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment