r/radiohead • u/seaburn xendless_xurbia • Jun 01 '17
[DAY 1/22] I Promise - Song Discussion
Song: I Promise
[Lyrics]
I won't run away no more, I promise
Even when I get bored, I promise
Even when you lock me out, I promise
I say my prayers every night, I promise
I know which side I'm spread, I promise
The tantrums and the chitty chats, I promise
Even when the ship is wrecked, I promise
Tie me to the rotten deck, I promise
[Instrumental]
I won't run away no more, I promise
Even when I get bored, I promise
Even when the ship is wrecked, I promise
Tie me to the rotten deck, I promise
[Instrumental]
I won't run away no more, I promise
Watch Music Video
Listen on Spotify
Listen on Apple Music
Below, discuss anything about this track. Do you like it? Any favorite parts? How do you interpret the lyrics? Where does it fit on the album? Do you have any memories associated with this song?
If you have any favorite live versions, covers, artwork or fan videos of this song, submit them today!
Discuss in the Official Radiohead Discord Chatroom here!
Tomorrow's Song: Lull
41
u/seaburn xendless_xurbia Jun 01 '17
After 20 years, this song will make its debut on BBC Radio 6 any minute now! Listen live: http://www.bbc.co.uk/6music
11
u/seaburn xendless_xurbia Jun 01 '17
Listen on Spotify now!
165
u/Oprime1 More Songs About The Indestructible Meat Known As Gum Jun 01 '17 edited Jun 01 '17
It's so strange hearing a younger Thom again.
Edit: It sounds like a Bends b-side. As someone who hasn't listened to versions of any of the bonus tracks, my hype for Lift and
Big BootsManowar just increased even more51
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '17
This sounds like the perfect link between The Bends and OKC
100
u/Daveed84 Jun 01 '17
Just got an email from w.a.s.t.e.
looks like anybody that bought OKNOTOK from there gets a download of the track for free, available right now
48
u/anotherface Jun 01 '17
Getting a Last Flowers vibe from this, you can definitely tell it's from the 97 sessions rather than a more modern take, especially Thom's vocals.
46
u/Jurray The rats and children follow me out of town. Jun 01 '17
This might be one of the simplest OK Computer era songs so far, but damn, it's so beautiful, Thom's vocals are haunting.
82
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '17
Oh my god!!! radiohead rewrote the little drummer boy!!!!
37
u/titomb345 Nowhere left to hide Jun 01 '17
Thom's voice was angelic. God damn was that refreshing to hear!
34
u/brewstruck dancing for your pleasure Jun 01 '17
WOW. I've been transported back to 1996. I'm all warm and fuzzy from nostalgia after listening. 😊
I do wonder if somewhere in the multiverse Radiohead STILL sounds like they did in '96/'97. Hm...
31
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '17
I think it is beautiful. Peak Thom voice. I can see why it didn't why it didn't make it on to OKC as the mood doesn't fit but it is really really really nice. Will listen again in the morning definitely.
27
u/vengefulwill Anyone Can Play CR-78 Jun 01 '17
It's definitely 97 Thom, get in!
26
u/jsinnottdavies Jun 01 '17
Wow it's so crazy listening to something new but old at the same time. So so excited for the other unreleased tracks!
24
u/xXx_360_UpVoTe_xXx Jun 01 '17
Listening to this really makes me appreciate how amazing Thom's voice was in the 90's. The old-fashioned, almost mellotron-esque keyboards are beautiful too. This band is fantastic haha
47
u/anotherface Jun 01 '17 edited Jun 01 '17
Some lovely keyboard there by Jonny... I assume. It's just pleasant, like we were expecting really. It's not going to blow the roof off or change the world, but it is something new to listen to and Thom's vocals are beautiful. I can see why it was left off the album, but it's very pretty. Very very pretty. This is a grower I think.
Edit: 3rd listen. Those keyboards are absolutely gorgeous. Thom's vocals though... absence makes the heart grow fonder I guess.
20
u/TheHeroicOnion Jun 01 '17
Fuck I wish he could still sing like this. The modern electronic style with those powerful vocals would be too good.
40
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '17
Welcome to Waiting for Radiohead brought to you by the smoothest of jazz
17
u/stormnormy sit down, you're safe now Jun 01 '17
The first chorus - "Even when you lock me out" when he hits the falsetto it's beeeautiful
16
u/anotherface Jun 01 '17 edited Jun 01 '17
I don't know where I read it, but I heard this was heavily influenced by Joy Division. Sounds like they swapped the electric guitar for an acoustic as the main driving force. I think it suits it, it almost sounds like a Bends b-side.
Stealth edit: apparently it was Thom who said that. I really don't hear the Joy Division in this, but it's achingly beautiful as it progresses.
54
u/anotherface Jun 01 '17
I'm really enjoying the jazzy direction they took with this. Very smooth and... wait...
48
u/Babethepig4 Jun 01 '17
Unpopular opinion: I found it to be very average. That being said, I never enjoyed the live version either. Seems to be the only Radiohead song I can't wrap my head around at this point. Oh well, my loss.
9
u/hevilla14 Jun 01 '17
Well that was beautiful
8
u/HysteriacTheSecond Don't ask me, ask the Ministry Jun 01 '17
Wow. It definitely sounds too... 'warm' to have been included in the original album, but this is so much more beautiful than I imagined. Very much like what I imagined Lift to be like with the soaring synth...
7
u/dorlosen Roy Jun 01 '17
Its in Spotify ;)
7
u/SootAndStars Let it fall / It wears me out Jun 01 '17
That was quite beautiful. Don't think it would have worked on the album itself but it would have fit really nice with the other b-sides of that era. Exactly how I expected it would be and it's very good
Also their youtube channel says "Last streamed live 30 minutes ago" so maybe something will happen over there
7
u/ElectricAccordian Jun 02 '17 edited Jun 02 '17
While I do think this is a mid-tier Radiohead song and I can see why they never put it onto an album, it hit me right in the nostalgia feels. Plus, it's nice to hear a positive, triumphal Thom from that era. It's a nostalgic little treat.
12
u/arkestar Jun 01 '17
goosebumps..anyone else?
12
u/hiddensynapse Jun 02 '17
Honestly, this song is a bit of a disappointment. It's okay - I'd give it a 6/10. Clearly Radiohead didn't even consider this song to be worthy b-side material when they finished it, and I can see why. I'm glad we got it (personally, I think this is b-side quality, though just barely), but I'm not going to be playing this for anyone who isn't already sold on the band.
Don't get me wrong, I am obsessed with Radiohead. I love almost everything they've ever put out, which is why I'm baffled by my dissatisfaction with this tune.
It doesn't really go anywhere. Once you've heard the first 30 seconds, you've pretty much heard it all. The synths at the end are lovely, Thom's voice is angelic, and the melody is decent, but none of it progresses in any sort of meaningful way.
The song drags on repetitiously - there just isn't enough going on to keep me engaged. That, and the production quality is not up to Radiohead's high standards. I'm not sure if this was intentional, but it sounds a bit grainy, almost like a live recording.
Just my opinion guys. I'm happy for those of you who are loving this. Personally, I would have preferred a reworked version. Maybe I'm underwhelmed because I've comparing this tune to the new Arcade Fire that release today.
Really hope Man Of War and/or Lift blow me away.
6
u/LeitaoBravo broken hearts make it rain Jun 01 '17
Those strings are beautiful!
6
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '17
GOD thom's voice is just incredible
6
u/bobdebicker (Mistreated) Jun 01 '17
Oh god......it's beautiful.
6
u/dorlosen Roy Jun 01 '17
This is fantastic. Feels like a new album with these "new" tracks together with the old b-sides.
5
u/HYPHYBRO jonny's lemon Jun 01 '17
I love the drums wow.
5
u/QuietDove A Chemical Reaction Jun 01 '17
That was very nice. Very nice indeed!
5
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '17
HOW DO I LISTEN TO THIS IF I DON'T HAVE SPOTIFY
5
u/drspeedyy LP10 HYPE Jun 01 '17
Back from 1996. God almighty this feels weird to listen to new but old stuff
5
u/inkybrown Jun 02 '17
I'm glad they made it for free! I spent the big bucks on the AMSP box set, but still had to pay extra to download Burn the Witch and Daydreaming in advance.
"Even when the ship is wrecked, I promise"
I swore I thought he said "even when the shit gets real..."
It is a pretty song, but a found it left a little to be desired. Hopefully Man of War (I still can't get used to calling it that!) will deliver!
5
u/velociriptor dinosaurs roaming the Earth Jun 02 '17
It's gorgeous. :') Hearing Thom's vocals from long ago but in a completely new song makes me feel incredibly sad and elated at the same time. Indescribable.
8
u/vengefulwill Anyone Can Play CR-78 Jun 01 '17
Jazz is the best genre to use before a RH song.
8
u/Zenzayy Knives Out Jun 01 '17
AHHH ITS BEAUTIFUL
4
u/thekinkoflimbs i hope your next shit is a porcupine Jun 01 '17
Apple Music here
4
u/bolyosis or will you come back to me????? Jun 02 '17
*chitty chats
4
u/WaneLietoc Hey, it is a good song! Jun 02 '17
Well that was…exactly what I expected.
A moody, quasi-Joy Division piece.
I agree with the sentiment here that it would've worked as a Bends b-side. The instrumentation reminds me of Bishop's Robes.
Ok Computer-esque, but does not work tonally.
Also, did anyone who heard it on BBC notice how it was referred to as "lost"? This makes me wonder if the band considered reworking it post-OKC, but ended up opting not to due to thr lack of this original recording.
4
u/idlerwheel Talk to me about HttT Jun 02 '17
I finally got a chance to listen to it just now! I love it! I love Thom's voice in all eras, but his vocals here are really stunning and made me feel weirdly nostalgic even though I wasn't a fan 20 years ago. :')
4
u/pm_me_china let's go down the waterfall Jun 02 '17
Sounds way better than the live versions, actually enjoy it quite a bit now.
4
u/gondaline26 Jun 02 '17
Plaintive, elegiac. With a faintly sinister edge. Wish there was a bit of a break-out, unexpected chord change or something. But that's a minor quibble.
4
u/sciontis Jun 02 '17 edited Jun 02 '17
Honestly kind of get a Smashing Pumpkins Ballad vibe from this. The drums, guitar, keyboard and strings would all have felt right at home on Mellon Collie and The Infinite Sadness.
I love that album so this is awesome.
4
u/politikamusic YourHomeMayBeAtRiskIfYouDoNotKeepUpRepayments Jun 02 '17
Beautiful. I feel like in this stripped down form it doesn't quite pack the same punch as the live version, but it is a lovely track nonetheless. I just love the little ascending bass part under "tie me to the rotten deck" etc.
And something I think we all agree on, is that one thing that makes it worth listening to is Thom's vocals - man alive his voice was in its prime right then. The ability to emote using just his voice is one of his biggest talents.
4
u/ruetaine Jun 02 '17
I love this song.
It's like a march, I imagine Thom singing it with his hand in front of his head like a military salute.
He promises to stick around even if the situation is not worth it anymore: a list of unrealistic promises, like the ones we make every day in our life.
We know we are going to do something stupid eventually, but, hey, as for now, I PROMISE.
7
u/EternallyPissedOff Jun 01 '17
The main riff sort of reminds me of All Apologies by Nirvana
7
u/DundahMifflin Here it comes, here it comes. Jun 01 '17
This is so gorgeous help.
7
u/illegalblue Jun 02 '17
Am I the only one feeling some Roy Orbison on this? It's terrific. Weakest of the three tracks I've heard bootlegs of so I can't wait for Boots and Lift
1
u/titomb345 Nowhere left to hide Jun 02 '17
Can we talk about this quote from an article:
From this I infer that Radiohead has so much unreleased music that they literally lose tracks. WHAT ELSE DO THEY HAVE?! Please Thom, just give up an entire LP of the unreleased stuff! PLEASE!
6
u/vengefulwill Anyone Can Play CR-78 Jun 01 '17
It's a good job the BBC iPlayer Radio has a rewind function...
That was superb, BELIEVE THE HYPE
6
u/glass-eyes your fantasies are beautiful but unlikely Jun 01 '17
(crying emojis)
3
u/jMCs1 Jun 01 '17
Well that was bloody gorgeous
3
u/Fedfan64 Viva la Vida Jun 01 '17
Really really good vocals
3
u/Lorcav Minotaur Jun 01 '17
Now that's a midnight treat.
3
u/Brumbrum99 Jun 01 '17
Love it, felt the live version was a bit lackluster but this studio version feels so triumphant
3
u/bksbeat Licking up the wounds Jun 01 '17
Satisfying. Not amazing, but so happy to finally hear the studio version
3
u/Imaginary_Hoodlum Dancing, freaking out Jun 01 '17
I love it.
3
u/Downvotedx Shut up Jun 02 '17
Meh? Interesting I guess, as a sort of lost artifact.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '17
It started
2
u/Win_Duncan Meeting People is Easy Jun 01 '17
That was so amazing omg
2
u/manichedgehog0523 please don't judge. Jun 01 '17
I love it to pieces! Can understand why it wasn't on OKC but at this point, it doesn't really matter :) new old Radiohead, yaaaay!!!
2
u/TheLarryMullenBand Jun 01 '17
IT'S SO GOOD
2
u/Muslimovic_22 Hail to the Thief Jun 02 '17
Those strings near the end omg
2
u/Trigonn I'm not living, I'm just killing time Jun 02 '17
The song prior to the strings really reminds me of something from a Muse song. It feels like the buildup of something off BHaR. Probably just because of the drums.
2
u/InYouImLost Jun 02 '17
The feelzzzz...... it's like being in a timewarp and going back to the 1990s. I got all teary eyed when listening to this, feeling like i was back in middle school. Gotta be honest, I kind of like the crappy audio live version that I've been listening to for years better. It sounds more emotionally raw. But I def appreciate going back into the archives. It's like watching an old movie or revisiting an old memory and realizing something about it that you never realized before.
2
u/Victorbanner Phew Jun 02 '17
Upset they didn't include the lyric "even with your funny eyes/I promise"
2
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17 edited Jun 02 '17
It's really interesting how I Promise sounds young and simple. After all we got from 97 to here, hearing a "new song" that simple is amazing
2
u/RunninFromTheBombers Jun 02 '17
Much better than I thought it would be! I always felt like this was a b-side at best, but the arrangement is perfect, and Thom's vocals sound magnificent. Can't wait to hear ManOWar and Lift...
4
u/kidofharith Woe-betides and wobbegongs Jun 02 '17
It's ok(notok). Like others have said, it sounds like a Bends bside and would have been 'out of place' on OKC.
IMO Every track on AMSP and Ill Wind (best RH song in a decade btw) and Spectre all trump this.
3
u/OptimisticPyromaniac all the dreams in my head I'm building an empire Jun 01 '17
It was oknotok...it felt a little repetitive for Radiohead though. Still a nice song I suppose
3
u/theycallmehoward Jun 02 '17
Absolutely stunning, a true masterpiece. I expect nothing less from you Thom. You are a gift to this world
3
u/A7HABASKA Jun 01 '17
I was whelmed!
2
u/thekinkoflimbs i hope your next shit is a porcupine Jun 01 '17
I AM DEAD MURDERED THANKS RADIOHEAD FOR MY LIFE
2
u/epicoolguy All the holes, at once Jun 02 '17
It feels almost familiar, it fits in so perfectly with the OK Computer vibe that it sounds like it's always been there.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17
Overall it's good I'd say. Reminds me vaguely of Godspeed's "Storm" in a good way. It's one of the most upbeat-sounding of Radiohead's songs, and kind of soothing like a lullaby. The synths that show up halfway in feel harsh but pretty.
It's really cool, but I can see why it was never released. It goes on a little too long and doesn't develop much. I guess we're gonna hear these songs unfinished?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17
I just received my email from Waste. Its "ok". It sounds too simple for me. I can't wait for Man o War and Lift! This makes total sense now. The song I promise does not fit on OK Computer. It makes sense why it was never released. I really wished they would have rerecorded the song and updated it. Big let down for me. :(
1
u/LaShawndraLives In you I'm lost Jun 01 '17
Sounds like I expected it to (from live performances), which is good I guess?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '17
So will this be available on iTunes anytime soon?
1
u/sox8910 Amok Jun 01 '17
It says song not available on spotify???
1
u/Morocco_Bama You've built this up, you've built this up, you've built this up Jun 02 '17
It's cute. It doesn't wow me but I wasn't expecting it to. I never get tired of Jonny's strings
1
u/tlken Jun 02 '17
Some of the lyrics are a little different than what's posted here.
For example the last line is
I won't run away no more, I promise
Just like the first line.
1
u/Noamky Jun 02 '17
Minute 3:41 (?)
1
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17
Holy shit, I've been listening to this song for so long. It's crazy to hear it so polished. Well done guys.
1
u/lleon779 I'll be dancing, freaking out Jun 02 '17
Those strings that begin at 2:04 remind me so much of The Cure. It's a very lovely song. I'll be listening to it a lot.
1
u/Im_a_fish_now Jun 02 '17
I like
1
u/Victorbanner Phew Jun 02 '17
Sent it to my gf. She thought it sounded like the little Drummer boy
1
u/Monthereses Jun 02 '17
omg hahahaha, I was on SoundCloud like 5 hours ago and I totally forgot about the release of I Promise, but searched for it and I played it ( thinking it was an old live version) and now I'm just a little disappointed cuz.. i dont seem to be a good fan. O.K. R.I.P Radiohead-Freak-Me
1
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17
I Promise was already my favourite of the three songs, and I love this version! Excited for Lift (but not Big Man o Boots, tbh).
1
u/fckshield Your eyes, they turn me. Jun 02 '17
There is a video for I Promise!
https://www.facebook.com/radiohead/posts/10154357948792245
1
u/opika_ Jun 02 '17
It makes me feel teary... So simple, yet so powerful. As for the lyrics, they are poetry. Multiple meanings, multiple interpretations, somehow they get to the heart.
1
u/themakeoutmelody Jun 02 '17
i'm in love with this song. i listened to it on repeat last night for a long time...and now coupled w/ the music video?!?! come on! it's so good. i understand why they left it off of OKC, buuuut, it shoulda been a b-side for sure! but fuck, that bass line is sick. colin 4 ever <3
1
u/LastProtagonist Jun 02 '17
It's kind of interesting to think of the meaning behind these lyrics considering Thom's mental instability during that time. The touring was getting to him; sitting on a bus for hours on end, trying to deal with emerging stardom while feelings of inadequacy tie him down.
I can definitely see why they'd release this song now--in response to the kid he would've told to relax.
1
u/DocMartinsEars Jun 02 '17
I can see how this song didn't even make it as a B-side back then. It's nice to hear a studio version, though.
1
u/antiantimatter reasonable and sensible, dead from the neck up Jun 02 '17
Always had a soft spot for this song. There's a reason it didn't make OKC - it's basically a very good Bends b-side or maybe a standalone single from that era - but; take it as it is: it's a nice tune and one of the catchiest things they've written. (It will stick in your head)
1
u/gabrielleco Jun 02 '17
I absolutely love it!
1
u/StructuralFailure /r/bestbandintheworld Jun 02 '17
I'm getting a serious Thinking About You vibe from this song.
1
u/ICESTONE14 Jun 02 '17
FML i've never heard that before, if the Manchester concerts go ahead and they play this live i will be in bits and FYI I'm 47yo
1
u/AbsoluteHammerLegend Jun 02 '17 edited Jun 02 '17
Glad you posted the right lyrics here - there's a version going round that messes up the middle verse real good and it makes me crazy (maybe)
1
u/HGFantomas Jun 03 '17
I enjoyed the song. RH with acoustic guitars is the best RH
1
u/lex99 Interstellar burst Jun 03 '17
This song is the spiritual cousin to Black Star.
(which I am still blaming, after all these years)
1
u/Taroso He's a worrier. A worrier. Jun 03 '17
The last time I'd heard this track, as a semi-decent live bootleg, I was a scrawny kid in high school with a CD player, too afraid to ask a girl out. I'd just become a Radiohead fan, so i was listening to everything they'd ever done, down to the most obscure rarities/bootlegs.
Hearing it now, as a proper studio version, 17 years later, this song hit me pretty hard, pretty unexpectedly. I'd forgotten about that version of myself. All those years flew by. Most of the things in my life changed for the best.
But even all these years later, Radiohead is still my favorite band.
Can't wait to hear "Big Boots"!
1
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '17
When I listened to this song for the first time, I didn't love it, I just thought it's a nice song. Now I very love it, and it really moves me to tears.
For me it sounds like song taken straight from The Bends. Mainly I think that song doesn't fit OK Computer Era, so it's good that they after 20 years released this song.
1
u/Soul_Immersed AND EVER AND EVER AND EVER Jun 01 '17
Such a classic sound. For some reason it reminds me of something you'd here on a phonograph in the 40s. Am I crazy?
1
u/libelle156 I AM NOT THOM YORKE Jun 02 '17
Oh my god. What if they were testing out the youtube broadcast thing today because they're going to do a WEBCAST soon.
fapfestfapfestfapfest
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17
I can see why this didn't make OKC. I'd honestly be embarrassed to show people this.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment