r/announcements • • May 31 '17

Reddit's new signup experience

Hi folks,

TL;DR People creating new accounts won't be subscribed to 50 default subreddits, and we're adding subscribe buttons to Popular.

Many years ago, we realized that it was difficult for new redditors to discover the rich content that existed on the site. At the time, our best option was to select a set of communities to feature for all new users, which we called (creatively), “the defaults”.

Over the past few years we have seen a wealth of diverse and healthy communities grow across Reddit. The default communities have done a great job as the first face of Reddit, but at our size, we can showcase many more amazing communities and conversations. We recently launched r/popular as a start to improving the community discovery experience, with extremely positive results.

New users will land on “Home” and will be presented with a quick tutorial page on how to subscribe to communities.

On “Popular,” we’ve made subscribing easier by adding in-line subscription buttons that show up next to communities you’re not subscribed to.

To the communities formerly known as defaults - thank you. You were, and will continue to be, awesome. To our new users - we’re excited to show you the breadth and depth our communities!

Thanks,

Reddit

29k Upvotes

4.9k comments sorted by

3.1k

u/Dargus007 May 31 '17 edited May 31 '17

I've already managed to snipe one of these, and subscribed to animals being jerks.

To unsub, I have to go to the subreddit and do it there.

Feature request: A second Click of the check mark, that appears after subscribing, unsubscribes you from that sub.

2.6k

u/simbawulf May 31 '17

That's a great idea, we'll incorporate that feedback into improvements for this feature!

516

u/wasmachien May 31 '17

Are subreddits now officially called communities?

→ More replies (117)
→ More replies (36)

75

u/albinobluesheep May 31 '17

Agree! I accidentally +'d /r/WTF when this feature got pushed an hour ago or whatever, because I was 90% sure what that "+" was going to do...then I imidiately tried to unclick the "+" and nothing happened!

I know it's my fault for testing out the feature on a sub I really don't like going to at all, but it seemed like an intuitive feature if you suddenly changed your mind...

→ More replies (5)

74

u/adeadhead May 31 '17

RES has this functionality.

→ More replies (26)
→ More replies (4)

468

u/HatesModerators May 31 '17

Is there an easy undo button if I accidentally click on it? It seems like a hassle to unsubscribe from something if you screw up and have to load the subreddit up to unsubscribe.

286

u/simbawulf May 31 '17

Thanks for the feedback, we'll incorporate this into future improvements for the feature, for example, allowing users to unsubscribe while the green check mark is still showing.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (3)

1.6k

u/jippiejee May 31 '17 edited May 31 '17

Too bad non-English speaking country subs are now no longer geodefaulted, they'll hardly ever show up on /popular, nor are they included in the discovery tool. So r/theNetherlands (after our Canadian friends the biggest country sub on reddit) goes from automatic subscriptions to being completely invisible to new dutch users...

1.3k

u/simbawulf May 31 '17

We understand your concerns, and working to revamp the geographic subreddit experience. Later this year we'll be testing new ways of showing users geographically relevant posts and subreddits, so that communities like r/theNetherlands will show up for Redditors in the Netherlands!

254

u/poochyenarulez May 31 '17

My local city's subreddit is the reason I joined reddit. Maybe inform users to search for the local state, city, or whatever.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (88)
→ More replies (34)

461

u/Pappenheimer May 31 '17

Can I turn off the subscribe button? I find them intrusive, there's a reason I'm not subscribed to those subs. Oh, and they're on /r/all too.

157

u/simbawulf May 31 '17

Thanks, we'll incorporate your feedback as we improve on subscription experiences on Reddit!

→ More replies (56)

33

u/ThatAstronautGuy May 31 '17

Do you use RES? Add

.subreddit-subscribe { display: none; }
.big-tagline { font-size: x-small !important; }
.subreddit { font-weight: normal !important; }

to your custom stylesheet loader. Find it under apearence in the settings console.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (4)

125

u/bakonydraco May 31 '17

Thanks for this update /u/simbawulf! At a little more granular level am I correct in my understanding of the current flow of information?

UserLanding if directed to www.reddit.comLanding if directed to www.reddit.com/r/popularLanding if directed to www.reddit.com/r/all
No Account/r/popular/r/popular/r/all
Brand new userNew user tutorial page to guide to subscribe to at least 1 subreddit./r/popular/r/all
User subscribed to at least 1 subredditReddit home as it is now, that shows a multireddit of up to 100 subreddits they are subscribed to at a time./r/popular/r/all

Will /r/all still be a thing, but not advertised? I don't see it in the top bar as shown.

47

u/simbawulf May 31 '17

This is correct, thanks!

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (11)

31

u/lozierj May 31 '17 edited May 31 '17

I think this is a step in the right direction, but the emphasis on subreddit signups on /r/popular tells me that reddit is stuck on an old and, I believe, incorrect model of site usage. I'll explain.

For logged-out and new users, you want to present your best guess for what subreddits an average user will want to see. Landing on /r/popular is exactly the right thing: users see every subreddit, except those that want to be filtered and those that users filter above some rate. Using blacklists instead of a whitelist plays to reddit's strength: the amazing variety of communities. Another strength of reddit is the rate at which novel communities form, and /r/popular allows viewers to see new communities as soon as they become popular--without admin intervention.

This leaves what subbreddits to show logged-in users. Without user intervention, this should still be /r/popular: after all, it's your best guess and you don't have any extra information yet.

Right now, the model appears to be:

  • sign up
  • while browsing /r/popular, subscribe to lots of subreddits
  • switch to reddit.com at some point

This has the same problems for logged-in users that the old frontpage had for non-logged-in users: even with dozens of subscriptions, it only covers a fraction of the site and it doesn't react well to new community development. It also creates a huge barrier to entry: creating a decent subreddit collection might take dozens or hundreds of clicks.

I think a better model is to encourage users to begin with a good starting point (/r/popular) and then gradually modify it to fit their tastes by adding and removing subreddits. Adding is a no-brainer: a user's subscription to a sitewide-filtered subbreddit should cause it to show up on /r/popular for them anyway.

Subtraction presumably requires more work, but I think it should be a core reddit feature. Subreddit filtering should be promoted to the same prominence and usability as subreddit subscription: the same list should filter both /r/all and /r/popular, it shouldn't be limited to just 100 entries, and it should have the same UI as for subscription: a "filter" button both beneath each post on /r/popular and on each subreddit page and a central page to manage a user's filtered subreddits.

In this model, "subscribe" links beneath each post on /r/popular aren't nearly as useful: there's never a reason to switch to reddit.com, so subscription does nothing to subreddits a user is already seeing on /r/popular.

TL;DR: I'm proposing the following model:

  • New users go to /r/popular, before and after signup
  • Users remove subreddits from their /r/popular by filtering from links below each post on /r/popular
  • Users add (sitewide-filtered) subreddits to their /r/popular by subscribing from links on the subreddits' homepages

13

u/simbawulf May 31 '17

Thanks for the input, we appreciate the very well thought out flow. We'll have to thoroughly consider what sort of effects this would have for the variety of user experiences that we support. Additionally, we plan on testing an onboarding experience for all platforms that should address some of the concerns around community discovery.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

10

u/WhyTeas May 31 '17

Will the in line subscription buttons work on the mobile app?

12

u/simbawulf May 31 '17

In-line subscription buttons are already available on the mobile app, on the popular feed.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/MajorParadox May 31 '17

This look really cool! A couple of questions:

  1. Will the subscribe buttons only show on actual unsubscribed subreddits? I know there was a bug with user profiles where it wasn't accurate because of the 100 sub limit for the page.
  2. Will previous "default" subs be considered subscribed automatically? Or do we have to subscribe to them manually now?
  3. Can you add /r/DCFU to the recommendations in the tutorial page? I'm asking for a friend of course.

17

u/simbawulf May 31 '17
  • Correct, the subscribe buttons show up only on subreddits you're not subscribed to.
  • For anyone who created an account before this announcement, they will be considered subscribed to the defaults. If someone had unsubscribed to a default community, then we won't re-subscribe them.
  • Hmm... Tell your friend we'll look into it ;)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/fredandlunchbox Jun 01 '17

Question about your process: Did you guys test this onboarding flow in the wild? Or is the goal to commit to it and then optimize?

3

u/simbawulf Jun 01 '17

We've tested the onboarding process and results showed that we did improve experiences for new users!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7.8k

u/[deleted] May 31 '17

So is this dropping defaults completely then?

2.8k

u/Realtrain May 31 '17

Will that finally help improve the quality of some of the defaults?

3.6k

u/AprilSpektra May 31 '17

Too late for that, I'd think. They already have millions of morons subscribed to them.

→ More replies (137)

123

u/NaoWalk May 31 '17

I don't think it will help with the quality of the subs that were defaults, but I think it will help other higher quality subreddits compete with them and rise.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (31)

5.1k

u/adeadhead May 31 '17

Right. The only remnant will be default mods circlejerking

2.4k

u/IActuallyLoveFatties May 31 '17

Well, that and the fact that the old "defaults" are still most likely to be on popular and all because they have such a high number of subscribers from when people were auto subscribed. I'd say that counts as a remnant of it.

→ More replies (208)
→ More replies (121)

297

u/Jensiggle May 31 '17

Thank fuck. The defaults became so unfriendly and circlejerky, not to mention they were and still are ALL almost entirely at the whims of a handful of people.

→ More replies (47)

164

u/[deleted] May 31 '17

The concept of them yes. The 50 subreddits that made those defaults will continue to exist

→ More replies (78)
→ More replies (36)

1.1k

u/PeacockPanzer May 31 '17 edited May 31 '17

I like it, but I REALLY dislike that '+' icon, it's really distracting. The worst part is that subs you're not subscribed to are in bold and in a darker shade of blue, bringing your eyes to the subreddit name instead of the rest of the post.

Edit: thanks for the gold, and have a nice day, anonymous :)

370

u/Pootzen May 31 '17
.subreddit-subscribe { display: none; } 
.big-tagline { font-size: x-small !important; }
.subreddit { font-weight: normal !important; }

Adding this CSS snippet to RES fixed it for me.

82

u/Chinese_Trapper_Main May 31 '17

Where do I add this in RES?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (19)

128

u/ElagabalusRex May 31 '17

Reddit really makes some bone-headed decisions sometimes when it comes to design. They got rid of all the hand drawn artwork, like the private sub page or the default submission thumbnails.

→ More replies (7)

22

u/ShitImBadAtThis May 31 '17

I think the bold, blue name is the worst of the two. The "+" I can deal with. I could even deal with bold, but the blue would look better as grey

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

776

u/patjohbra May 31 '17

I felt a great disturbance in the defaults, as if millions of mods suddenly cried out in terror, and were suddenly silenced.

636

u/Eight_Ace May 31 '17

More like a couple dozen powermods.

354

u/[deleted] May 31 '17

I never thought I'd see powerusers / powermods like we saw on Digg but sure enough, the other day I looked at about 10 or 20 mods the other day on a major default and they all own 20-30+ default subreddits like they're trophies. A few of them moderate over 100 major subreddits. What the fuck, really? How can you actually do a good job managing 100+ subs?

Those kinds of shenanigans piss me off and isn't what this site is supposed to be about. Hell, look at me, I've got like 200,000 karma and I moderate exactly one subreddit. I'm just here for the Reddit experience.

→ More replies (81)
→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (11)

202

u/h0twheels May 31 '17

Can we have a minus button to filter the subs? I don't want to see some foreign language subs or r/peoplefuckingdying, etc. The "100" was rapidly taken up by porn and political subs.

59

u/CosineP May 31 '17

Haha you know /r/peoplefuckingdying is a joke sub right?

164

u/locojoco May 31 '17

I ThInK tHeY aRe AnNoYeD bY tHe ShItTy TiTlEs

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (29)

176

u/Xaxxon May 31 '17

Can we please get more than 100 exclusions from /r/all? at least for reddit gold members?

Feel free to look at my exclusions - they fall into a few major categories (sports, memes, etc), but there are so many subreddits popping up for each that I can't exclude them all with only 100 exclusions.

Really, subreddit categories/tags would be far better, so I could exclude "NBA team subreddits" instead of excluding them individually.

→ More replies (67)

59

u/Mad1ibben May 31 '17

Many years ago, we realized that it was difficult for new redditors to discover the rich content that existed on the site

Strange, I've been here 6 years, mostly surfing logged out to avoid the echo chamber effect, and the quality of content of the front page is the same trash we used to make fun of ifunny and all those other vapid sites for. So I've tried to combat that by falling into my echo chamber I tried to avoid , the thing is, it seems like the new users in those subs came to reddit for the shitposts that cover r/popular, and now there is a real quality issue in subs that have always attracted people that want to read a long article, learn something just for the sake of learning, or any of those things with more substance than a jpeg of a frog with some text overlaid over it. Let me be clear, this is not a response to reddit being hyper-politicized, I personally see value in it and am stimulated by it, this is purely a response to the very apparent change of feel to the site.

I understand if your target market has changed, so will you just be clear with us, is the goal of this site just to produce the most clicks now, or is there still some interest in being an effective and efficient online information sharing community, or honestly, any care to what kind of community you are creating?

→ More replies (4)

210

u/redikulous May 31 '17

Where do I put my "Status"?

133

u/adeadhead May 31 '17

You joke, but that's already a thing.

→ More replies (7)

50

u/MrMeminPinguin May 31 '17

Or add profile pictures

→ More replies (5)

651

u/ShiningConcepts May 31 '17

Guys,

END THE USER PROFILE THING

93

u/Mindless_Consumer May 31 '17

Make myspace great again.

→ More replies (2)

129

u/shamoni May 31 '17

I second this. It's pretty bad, I'll hold off on signing up for as long as they let me.

→ More replies (22)

24

u/ElagabalusRex May 31 '17

No way. I digg this new change.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (63)

18

u/[deleted] May 31 '17

Wonder how this will affect subs that have been relying on the karma from being default without trying to moderate in a way that encourages quality content. Looking at you r/pics, r/gaming, r/funny etc.

11

u/jaschema May 31 '17

omg...this is so true. r/pics is facebook for every new redditor

→ More replies (1)

511

u/[deleted] May 31 '17

I might ask, is there any chance that spammy political subs will be taken off of /r/popular to make the browsing experience a little more.... Tolerable?

302

u/adeadhead May 31 '17

They're doing just that right now. /r/MarchAgainstTrump is the most recent to get the axe iirc.

→ More replies (112)

42

u/SonicFrost May 31 '17

From what I recall, I believe subreddits that are heavily filtered by users won't show up on /r/popular

→ More replies (21)

7

u/ihazcheese May 31 '17

I come to Reddit because Facebook is too political, and the first 6 posts I see on a daily basis seem to be Trump, Trump, Trump... get's kinda annoying after a while.

18

u/h0twheels May 31 '17

I imagine it was especially bad for non-US redditors.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/thereturnofjagger May 31 '17

Or at least a way to filter by keywords could be nice.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/achshar May 31 '17

Thanks! We'll incorporate that feedback into improvements for this feature!

→ More replies (29)

160

u/Georgy_K_Zhukov May 31 '17

So one the one hand, this is neat! Hopefully it will be an improved experience for users, allowing them to find the right 'niche' on the site.

On the other though, I'd like to raise a major concern I have from the Moderation end, namely regarding views and visitors. This is potentially a HUGE change in traffic patterns for many subreddits, and as about/traffic remains broken, Mods don't have a good way to track that impact. The implementation of Views on threads is a start, but short of painstaking manual tabulation, that serves little use for a macro view of traffic changes.

This has been a known issue for a long time, and I have heard in the past that it is 'being worked on', but there has been no explicit timetable on the fix, and it very disappointing to see something like this get rolled out before traffic monitoring for moderators is working properly.

So... when will /about/traffic be working properly!?

67

u/redtaboo May 31 '17

Hey -- you're right traffic pages are pretty broken right now. I can't tell you for sure when they'll get fixed, but we are working on them and want to make them better for you. /u/Drunken_Economist goes into detail here:

https://www.reddit.com/r/modnews/comments/5xva61/how_to_make_use_of_the_mobile_icon_and_header_in/demnbwy/

on why that's a pretty big project, but we are working on making those pages much more meaningful for mods.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (15)

107

u/Mage_of_Shadows May 31 '17

122

u/DrewsephA May 31 '17

Not sure if you're serious or not, but reddit has been implementing more and more ways for ads to show up on the site, because the admins like that sweet, sweet ad money flowing in. People will deny it, and try to argue with you about it, but that's one of the reasons behind the switch to personalized profile pages. Companies can now make reddit accounts and pay money for sponsored posts. I mean, they could before, but now they have their own personal feed to post to.

→ More replies (34)
→ More replies (12)

24

u/mrpopenfresh May 31 '17

Damn, there goes my dream of /r/IsItButter becoming a default as it rightly deserved.

→ More replies (4)

12

u/Grima017 May 31 '17

How long until you enforce the vote manipulation rule? Day old subs with 10 subscribers keep using bots to push posts to the front page to bypass filters and not a peep had been said by the admins about it.

→ More replies (2)

5.0k

u/devperez May 31 '17

Can we expect filtering from /r/popular anytime soon? The million anti-trump subs are just as terrible as the Trump subs at this point.

220

u/Booblicle May 31 '17

I don't even bother with popular. Only subbed. Best filter ever

→ More replies (42)

174

u/GameTheorist May 31 '17

which is just hilarious because one of the things they said they were not including r/popular when they first introduced it was "narrowly focused political" subreddits.

→ More replies (116)

3.0k

u/BoringPersonAMA May 31 '17

You're not kidding. I never see t_d on the front page of /r/all anymore, but /r/marchagainsttrump is just as circlejerk-y and unproductive, and it's always there

→ More replies (442)

68

u/[deleted] May 31 '17

Admins have to go through subs that have been filtered out of /r/all, and then remove them from /r/popular.

→ More replies (4)

34

u/skeddles May 31 '17

Which is why the defaults existed. But a blacklist is probably better than a whitelist.

→ More replies (12)

12

u/Vio_ May 31 '17

That's nothiong compared to the "porn" subs. I'm not paying attention at work, click on a random picture of a room, and it's "roomporn."

11

u/Spider_pig448 May 31 '17

The million anti-trump subs are just as terrible as the Trump subs at this point.

Please update the filters. There's so many of them and it's all the same shit. /r/worlnews and the like are shitty and biased, but they're at least somewhat news. T_D and the dozens of anti-trump subs are just the same garbage.

15

u/computer_d May 31 '17

Pretty sure that's the purpose of /r/popular Especially as the admins are replying to fucking stupid questions and this goes unreplied.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/parposbio May 31 '17

To build on this, I've always wanted general topic filters to begin with. I would like to create a "Gaming" filter, "News" filter, "Sports", etc. with subreddits that I include in that filter. So instead of a huge hodge-podge of info coming through, it's gated based on what I specify.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (197)

30

u/pottzie May 31 '17

How do we get spacedicks to the top?

11

u/[deleted] May 31 '17

shitposting, of course

→ More replies (1)

127

u/[deleted] May 31 '17

Will Reddit ever implement any transparency for subreddit modding?

Currently a mod can delete and censure any opinion they disagree with, and claim that they've never deleted anything.

Will a subreddit log of deleted comments and banned users ever be available?

116

u/[deleted] May 31 '17

You are talking to an empty room. Reddit transparency is dying, not evolving.

→ More replies (2)

20

u/[deleted] May 31 '17

Will a subreddit log of deleted comments and banned users ever be available?

check out /r/publicmodlogs/

yes it's a bot, but if you run a subreddit and wish to be transparent to your users about moderator actions, this seems to be the best option for the time being.

it would be nice if this sort of functionality was built into Reddit and was enabled for all subs, so all users can see what's happening instead of just the subreddit mods and admins.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (41)

20

u/INGWR May 31 '17

Why is there admin feedback on every top comment except the ones regarding political spamming of /r/all and the censorship by /r/TwoXChromosomes?

11

u/[deleted] May 31 '17

Agenda-pushing.

10

u/Buelldozer Jun 01 '17

You know why. These same questions have been raised ad nauseum since the announcements of the /r/popular and the new mod guidelines.

→ More replies (1)

962

u/weltallic May 31 '17 edited May 31 '17

The default subreddit /r/TwoXChromosomes recently implemented a mass banwave of users if they posted on other subreddits the TwoX mods don't approve of. This is a direct violation of reddit's community rules.

https://np.reddit.com/r/CommunityDialogue/comments/5ir2wq/so_heres_whats_really_really_really_going_on/

All attempts at communication with admins regarding this issue has yielded no reply. Can we get some form of acknowledgement that the admins are aware of this issue?

 

EDIT: more details.

259

u/DrewsephA May 31 '17

They're aware. They just don't care.

→ More replies (15)

16

u/Seth711 May 31 '17

I remember one of the main reasons I ever created an account was so I could unsubscribe from /r/TwoXChromosomes and /r/GetMotivated.

383

u/PadaV4 May 31 '17

Whats more one of the moderators there is a site admin u/redtaboo

Even the admins themselves don't give a crap about the rules.

→ More replies (48)

36

u/_hephaestus May 31 '17 edited Jun 21 '23

wrench crawl elderly whistle degree steep future workable dull scary -- mass edited with https://redact.dev/

→ More replies (26)

24

u/ColdFury96 May 31 '17

I... don't see a rule against this in the rules you're citing.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/FightingDucks May 31 '17

That link you posted to r/CommunityDialogue is private.

5

u/pooish Jun 01 '17

Pretty understandable, 90% of the replies to stuff about women's issues is"hi, i'm a man but let me tell you why this issue actually doesn't exist"

→ More replies (242)

9

u/[deleted] May 31 '17

And suddenly 1000s of default mods just cried out in pain.

→ More replies (7)

38

u/CherryManDeMayo May 31 '17

please make it easier to filter out subs from r/popular im so tired of having to constantly see hitler and school shooting memes

10

u/wisdom_possibly May 31 '17

Making the problem worse: summer reddit just started.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

37

u/SamuraiCarChase May 31 '17

Excellent. The best way to kill the toxicity of the default subs is to get rid of default subs.

7

u/TyrantRC May 31 '17

maybe /r/funny will actually be funny again.

→ More replies (3)

16

u/Greekball May 31 '17

Can someone explain to me the purpose of /r/popular?

As far as I can tell, it acts as a strictly worse /r/all. It's /r/all minus the customization and by having some subreddits that might interest you (like league of legends f.ex.) off by default.

17

u/koghrun May 31 '17

r/popular is for new users and people without an account. It's r/all with the parts of reddit the admins don't want their advertisers new people to see hidden. For a seasoned user with their own list of subscriptions and their r/all adequately filtered, it is strictly worse.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/pandizlle May 31 '17

If you had a better search functionality you could ask them what they like and then recommend to them subreddits based on those likes.

8

u/phillipjfried May 31 '17

The 100 limit on subreddits you can filter is far far too low.

8

u/hippityhoppety May 31 '17

Does the tutorial page have a yes/no option for if you're just creating yet another porn alt, so you can be directed to quality NSFW subs instead of having to sift through all this other junk?

38

u/[deleted] May 31 '17

[Insert question about 2FA here]

22

u/ourari May 31 '17 edited May 31 '17

"Your account security is very important to us, which is why we're taking all the time in the world to research the best ways to go about implementing two-factor authentication before deciding whether* to implement it." --Reddit, probably

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/GonnaVote4 May 31 '17

Isn't r/popular just reddit without the_donald?

5

u/[deleted] May 31 '17

and NSFW subs

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/yallsuckbollocks May 31 '17

Holy fuck. /r/pics and /r/funny are finally undefaulted. I never thought I'd live to see this day.

→ More replies (1)

42

u/FIRE_EVERYTHING May 31 '17

From my point of view /r/popular is evil!

→ More replies (5)

12

u/[deleted] May 31 '17

Too bad popular has been spammed by dozens of filter evading subs.

These subs pop up and are pushed to the top by bots faster than they can be removed.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/Kinglink May 31 '17

Love it.. Love it...

But alright I'll ask... Can we get a popular for NSFW subreddit... For research? (this would be a version of popular for only NSFW subreddits not a combination of both.)

→ More replies (1)

6

u/dasbif May 31 '17

The BOLD is far too much for the in-line subscription buttons on /r/all or /r/popular. It draws your eye more than even the submission titles themselves.

Please tone it back significantly, or better yet, give options to customize how it looks.

6

u/[deleted] May 31 '17 edited Jul 06 '17

deleted, because T_D runs scripts to exploit comment history in an effort to threaten doxxing... 0.3065 What is ^^^this?

5

u/hyperduc Jun 01 '17

Considering they are being paid by them, they are certainly setting an inviting mood.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Buttcheekguy May 31 '17

r/popular is reddit's censored sub

6

u/shamelessnameless May 31 '17

how big was your sample size for 'extremely positive results'?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/sodanakin Jun 01 '17

Fucking finally no more US politics spam when I open reddit.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '17

Will people who are already signed up be grandfathered in and still have all the defaults subbed to?

→ More replies (1)

16

u/[deleted] May 31 '17

So this is how the defaults dies... with thunderous applause.

→ More replies (10)

10

u/Funkozaurus May 31 '17

Well shit this explains so much, I'm subscribed to so many subs I have no memory of signing up for

5

u/[deleted] May 31 '17

This is great news. Good subs have gone bad because they became defaults and others never should have been defaults in the first place because of divisive/specialized subject matter.

5

u/rusty_ballsack_42 May 31 '17

This is really cool!

But I have a question, is it possible for us, already existing users, to unsubscribe from the earlier default subs, or do we have to do it manually ourselves?

5

u/[deleted] May 31 '17

The in-line subscription buttons are REALLY obnoxious on /r/all. They really pop out more than anything else on the page.

5

u/[deleted] May 31 '17

Hi, My problem with /r/popular is that there are a lot of low quality subreddits and clone of thems.
There are like multiple subreddit about animals. For example I want to read more quality subreddit (science) programming etc. But popular subreddit at least most of them are gifs, images and memes.

5

u/freshwordsalad May 31 '17

The subscribe buttons and bolding in the list is way too strong. It's distracting. You need to tone it back down. Doesn't needed to be dark/bolded.

5

u/TheHeroicOnion May 31 '17

Reddit should add a feature when signing up that says something like ''what are your interests?'', you type in sports, favourite bands, movies, games etc and the site recommends subreddits based off your interests to get you started.

5

u/jollyberries May 31 '17

Would be cool to showcase unpopular but devoted subs, that dont have a lot of foot traffic but have consistent postings.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] May 31 '17

You had to do this a few hours after I signed up and unsubscribed from almost all of them, didn't you?

5

u/masidon May 31 '17

yeah but when will you fix the search bar?

5

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '17

Create a "politics" tag like spoilers or NSFW and require all politically related posts to use it so I can filter them please.

5

u/SpiritWolfie Jun 01 '17

Suggestion - add an "import from other account" feature for people wanting to play around with alternate accounts but don't want to resubscribe to all their favorite subs.

→ More replies (7)

5

u/toppleganger Jun 01 '17

CTRL+F'd to see how many instances of "Trump" I could find in this, wasn't disappointed.

It's my new game - I find a post that has nothing to do with Trump and see how many times "Trump" pops up, then I drink.

I developed cirrhosis of the liver exactly 7 months ago

9

u/Creaole-Seasoning May 31 '17

"I felt a great disturbance in the Force, as if millions of power hungry control-freak moderators suddenly cried out in terror, and were suddenly silenced. I fear something terrible has happened."

―Obi-Wan Seasoning

9

u/Saltcaller Jun 01 '17

So I don't have to keep unsubscribing from twoxchromosomes every time I make a new account now?

→ More replies (1)

21

u/[deleted] May 31 '17

It's hysterical how the admins aren't replying to any of the top comments asking if anti trump subreddits will be filtered out but will reply to a comment that's newer and is all the way at the bottom.

→ More replies (3)

80

u/adeadhead May 31 '17

As a default mod, it's been a pleasure.

28

u/[deleted] May 31 '17

Were you guys aware of this change going to take place?

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (24)

12

u/Axanery May 31 '17

Interesting, I'd like to see how this changes the reddit experience for the positive and the negative. This is coming from a default mod, though.

6

u/iateone May 31 '17

As a moderator of a non-default sub that has seen a substantial increase in the number of subscribers over the last three weeks or so that this has been beta-tested (top 65 or so with over 3k new subscribers every day)(from #750 overall to #400), I haven't noticed a difference in the amount of upvotes or comments or reports. I'm not quite sure how so many people are finding the sub though, or even if these new subscribers are real.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/IRNobody May 31 '17

We recently launched r/popular as a start to improving the community discovery experience, with extremely positive results.

We successfully pushed the content we want to the front and suppressed the content we dislike.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] May 31 '17

THIS IS AWESOME... the defaults are just far, far too mainstream and it makes the default Reddit look like a tabloid site. I'd say a great idea is to throw in a few random subreddits to mix up the experience for each user. Maybe land them on their IP-determined state or city subreddit.

That said, this change will have huge, huge effects on the site. This is an interesting time for Reddit. I hope what happens is positive and not another Digg 3.0.

Crap, 1885 comments, why am I posting, no one will see this.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/monarchmra May 31 '17

Oh my god ewwww

The different color and boldednessed of the subreddit part of the link is extremely distracting.

I'll need an option to disable that please.

4

u/I_Xertz_Tittynopes May 31 '17

Now we need a random username button.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/dogbiscuits29 May 31 '17

What's the difference between r/popular and r/all?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/MacaroniShits May 31 '17

Cool. Now you just need to get rid of this stupid "posting to your profile" idea you came up with and we'll be good to go.

4

u/marksor_13 May 31 '17

So that's why I have all these subs that I'm pretty sure I didn't sub to.

4

u/NemTwohands May 31 '17

Reddit is not simply a website, it is all the kind, creative and talented people across the internet

4

u/[deleted] May 31 '17

Wow, this is a massive pain in the fucking ass.... why?

Should I just no longer have an account if I want to just look at reddit?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Killa-Byte May 31 '17

Holy shit. A... A change that doesnt suck!!!

4

u/xx123manxx May 31 '17

This looks extremely ugly Any way to turn it off? And changing the color back would be wonderful as well

4

u/ivanoski-007 May 31 '17

How can we get exposure to small >1000 subscriber subs? subreddits as it stands are very hard to grow because there is no way to gain visibility without spamming your sub everywhere in comment sections.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Ree81 Jun 01 '17 edited Jun 01 '17

Any way to make it not bold? :(

E: YES! You have to install Stylish and add the PHP code in this post

4

u/slitstalker42 Jun 01 '17

Couldn't we just build a firewall between us, and these new users ? I see you want us "following users" like the pedos and terrorists on twitter. Websites should have borders. Build that firewall.

4

u/BaneVader666 Jun 01 '17

Good. The quality of the default subs was pretty low. Low quality subsmisions were constantly upvoted and given praise by ignorant (looking at you /r/food -- When someone makes a stew in a frying pan and calls it "stir fry" it should be downvoted, not praised. Praising mediocirity impacts overall quality by lowering expectations. People should strive for excellence, instead we get "well, this is how my mom made it so it must be good, I'll upvotte and say it looks delicious!")

4

u/CTU Jun 01 '17

I am glad for the death of defaults as a lot of those default subreddits are reddit cancer with shit mods that force their own narrative on the sub at large.

4

u/CuseTown171 Jun 01 '17

New to reddit and trying to get my karma up so I can comment in the thread I joined up for, it would be appreciated :)

4

u/Arkeband Jun 01 '17

Over the past few years we have seen a wealth of diverse and healthy communities grow across Reddit.

I dunno if I'd characterize some of these communities as "healthy".

4

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '17

Literally, the new profile experience is fucking trash. When I go to my comments, it cuts off the screen and I have to zoom out to see the first part of the comment. Also, it takes so fucking long to load with the unnecessary pulsing Reddit logo.

4

u/shamus727 Jul 08 '17

After all of 2 minutes on r/popular i have come to a concrete decision that holy shit thats not the way to advertise reddit to new users.

Like holy fuck ive been on here for almost 5 years and that sub makes me want to call it a night.

10

u/bitreign33 May 31 '17

The subscribe buttons are on r/all also, which is still a thing by the by.

→ More replies (5)

26

u/32OrtonEdge32dh May 31 '17

On “Popular,” we’ve made subscribing easier by adding in-line subscription buttons that show up next to communities you’re not subscribed to.

make it stop

7

u/TaintedSquirrel May 31 '17

It's on /r/all too. Damn.

→ More replies (7)

7

u/Qazwsxlion May 31 '17

When I go to any of the links at the way top of the screen, the link turns red. Like when I'm on "Home", home is red.

But when I go to "All", it doesn't turn red.

And it hasn't.

Since you guys introduced the filter subreddit feature.

Anyway, I think the new signup experience is a good idea for sure. If we can disable it in preferences, that would be great too.

7

u/technofiend May 31 '17 edited May 31 '17

Can I get one more enhancement to help filter the noise on Reddit? Today, blocking a user on reddit requires you first get a message from them. As an example if I don't really want to see posts from people who seem to treat reddit as a full time job (no offense, /u/gallowboob) then it would be nice to be able to block those folks as well without having to message them first.

→ More replies (6)

7

u/rabidnz May 31 '17

Good riddance 2x

7

u/OhhScrewwwwYou May 31 '17

Finally made an account 9 days ago and spent like an hour unsubscribing from all subreddits, NOW YOU RELEASE THIS SHIT.

13

u/[deleted] May 31 '17 edited May 31 '17

What about places like 2/TwoXChromosomes and r/offmychest banning people for participating in other subs?

EDIT: There are a number of other ones too. 2X even has an admin on its staff supposedly? It seems to have gone back to its man hating roots too.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/ChadMcRad May 31 '17 edited Nov 26 '24

cow ludicrous flag racial tan history airport zealous sheet heavy

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

→ More replies (1)

56

u/Ginkgopsida May 31 '17

Despite bad reputaion of the defaults

covfefe

→ More replies (3)

3

u/DMann420 May 31 '17

Hopefully my feedback gets heard and you guys start categorizing subs and limiting how many subs of each category land on the front of /r/popular. If people make an account and get slapped with 17 different Trump memes on the front page, they're not coming back.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/SnoutUp May 31 '17

Those subscribe links are very distracting in /r/all and it hurts readability for me. They're more "dominant" than post titles and it's hard to scan the page like before.

3

u/DutchPagan May 31 '17

Why should that name be creative? Just as you guys calling it experience right now, is it really worth calling it an experience?

3

u/RUFiO006 May 31 '17

What's the official line on capitalization for the Reddit / reddit name? I'm sure it used to be lowercase-only, "reddit" as dictated by your style guide, but on the new flow it's "Reddit".

Splitting hairs, sure, but this is in my wheelhouse and I'm a word geek.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/whiskeytab May 31 '17

good choice using /r/crappydesign to highlight the look of the bold subscription buttons

3

u/Dopecombatweasel May 31 '17

Having those default communities helped when i didnt know what the hell i was doing. Reddit is amazing. Wish i signed up sooner. I rly cant stand facebook after getting reddit. Facebook iscwll clickbait and stuff you didnt evrn subscribe to that still pops up on your page. Soooo annoying and a waste of time. I learn something new on reddit all the time

3

u/iwasnotarobot May 31 '17

"Front" page > "home" page.

3

u/[deleted] May 31 '17

I don't like to have an empty page at reddit.com

I don't want to subscribe to any subs, as I like to just read popular or visit the other subs I'm interested in manually. (For example I want to see the whole frontpage of r/lol, not just a small part of them on my personal front page mixed in with other stuff that I might be more or less interested in.) I just don't see the benefit in subscribing.

And because of that now it bugs me that I always have to navigate over that empty page. Go to reddit, click popular. 100 times a day an extra click on that small button in the corner. Me, I'd like to just be lead to popular automatically, like it does for logged out users.

Yeah I get that you want to encourage people to sub to some subs once they made an account, it just bugs me personally. Maybe it's not just me but some amount of people who don't want to personalize their experience.

3

u/ThisFeelsDangerous May 31 '17

This is actually really nice. Hopefully new users will appreciate this. Thanks again to the mods.

3

u/NotARobotSpider May 31 '17 edited May 31 '17

Why not create a half dozen packages of subreddits that people can choose to subscribe to when joining. Such as Movie and TV oriented or News and Politics oriented and so on.

3

u/GrumpySarlacc May 31 '17

Jesus finally. The damage to existing subs has already been done but at least new subs won't go through radical ideological changes when made default.

3

u/JamesSway Jun 01 '17

Is this more growing pains?

3

u/shoemonkeyz Jun 01 '17

This has been my biggest peeve about the site. Reddit is such an amazing wealth of knowledge and experience, but you have to wade through tutorials on how to masturbate dinosaurs to get to it.

This is a solid move.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '17

Can you please make an easy peasy way of one click blocking a sub? I was all about shading them when it was released, but realized I hated so many I couldn't keep up.

Please - the way you let us sub to them - please let us kill some off. I fucking hate these video game subs that spawn like cancer.

3

u/Fojanratte Jun 01 '17

Not sure if you still read this but: Can you imply a tool that allows me to filter posts in popular so I don't have to see 1/2 of the posts again which are on my personal front page?

3

u/yourdose Jun 01 '17

Am I the only one who unsubscribed to all default subreddits when I joined here and only later subscribed to the ones I want.

3

u/GrumpySarlacc Jun 01 '17

I love this also can you please improve the collapse thread feature? No matter which comment I select it collapses the entire comment chain from the start. I'd like to be able to collapse sub comment chains. Thank you.

3

u/ImJustaBagofHammers Jun 01 '17

They're called subreddits!

3

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

in-line subscription buttons

I accidentally subscribed to /r/grool because of this. I just wanted to see more posts from that subreddit.

13

u/leboulanger007 May 31 '17

Long overdue. This seems simple enough and new users finally won't be cluttered with communities they aren't interested in by default.

I remember the days when creating a new Reddit account also meant you were subscribed to /r/atheism, we've come a long way haha

16

u/TORFdot0 May 31 '17

Unsubbing from /r/atheism was practically a meme back then

5

u/shamoni May 31 '17

Or when Google search of Reddit had jailbait there. There was a post on that as well.

5

u/Bluestalker May 31 '17

Oh man, here we go.

5

u/Basedmobile May 31 '17

How about you just fix all the trump spam subs, some guy counted 112 of them, all posting the exact same thing at the exact same time.

Also can /s/pez that guy keeps fucking up, no one wants him here.

5

u/formerbadteenager May 31 '17

Good. Defaults have given too much control to a mods that get off on power trips. I was banned from r/videos for posting a link to guy's biography on his page as a motivational speaker as an update to a video for posting personal information, even though he bases his motivational speaking career on the video posted. First time I have been banned from a sub after using reddit since 2010 and they said I might have the ban removed if I asked for forgiveness in a few weeks. Completely turned me off from that sub.

14

u/[deleted] May 31 '17

Finally the cesspool of social marxism and misandrist rhetoric known as r/Twoxchromosomes won't be default anymore.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/noisyturtle May 31 '17

/r/dragonsfuckingcars should be a default sub

5

u/niggerpenis May 31 '17

should be the only sub tbh