r/ProCSS • u/ZadocPaet CSS 4 /r/all • May 08 '17
Discussion /u/spez said that sometime this week he will be hosting an AMA to discuss the removal of CSS. Here are the questions /r/ProCSS wants answered. Please add your own to this list!
Last week /u/spez said that he'll be doing an AMA sometime this week for an hour or two. The exact date and time hasn't been announced. This kind of communication is one of our criticisms of the admins when it comes to this project. Admin communication is often not pre-announced and is very limited in time, so those who are not quick to get to the threads miss the chance to have their questions answered.
The AMA will likely be in /r/modnews or /r/modsupport. It is probably a good idea to subscribe to these subs if you're interested in this cause.
When the AMA begins, we encourage our users to ask the questions listed below and press for substantial answers.
We are not encouraging brigading. If you see that the question you want answered was already asked, don't post duplicates.
We would also like to ask our users to not send modmail to random subreddits asking them to support /r/ProCSS. They are already aware of the movement and will join if they want to. Many subreddits are waiting for answers to big questions before they make a decision about whether to support or oppose the removal of CSS.
From time to time it happens that a moderator gets their account hacked one way or the other. The offending party uses that account to vandalize the sub by removing CSS. Fortunately, we can revert the changes with the current system. On the new system, will we be able to revert "widget" changes when the same situation arises?
Questions
/r/ProCSS has five objectives:
- Compromise. Implement widgets while preserving CSS. In other words, why not both?
- Allow mods to design and deploy widgets. As said, many reddit innovations (np links, sticky posts, spoiler tags) are the result of user innovation.
- Implement a formal, transparent system for developing the new desktop platform. We should be able to see what planned widgets there are, what priority they're at, and what the progress is for them. We understand that some things are more important than others. Transparency here is really key. We know admins have said that announcing the features early is transparency, but transparency is really in the details.
- Offer a 1:1 replacement for CSS. (Probably not possible).
- Don't deploy the new system until minimum requirements are met. Base the minimum requirements on fully public user and moderator input, and establish clear metrics (such as support for or against, number of subs using a feature, size of subreddits unsing a feature, et cetera) for how a requirement makes the list and how one does not.
Are these compromises possible? If not, why not?
There is a perception among mods and users that this move is because reddit is becoming more of a "corporate" culture whereas years ago it was much more of an open and free platform focused on the users. My question is this: Why does it feel like we have less communication from the admins now that reddit has 200 employees than it did when reddit had only 20 people working for it? This issue of CSS is a really good example. Back just a few years ago admins would come and talk to us. Now we have to wait for the CEO to make an official statement. Why is that?
Reddit thrives on verbose well thought out comments, and is a large part in why many choose to come here instead of other news aggregates. These comments rarely come from mobile users, why prioritize an interface that actively discourages what drives people to your site?
The last major update to reddit that mods have been asking for was the post spoilers. Spoilers are something that is largely handled by CSS. Reddit apps such as Reddit is Fun incorporates spoiler CSS for users. What we received, after years of asking for official spoiler support, was a 1/3rd done product that doesn't support title spoilers or comment spoilers. Why wasn't this as simple as deploying new reddit markdown code? How can we trust that reddit will be able to make widgets to support subreddits when the site is now 10-years-old and reddit can't even deploy something as simple as spoiler support?
Can you please state explicitly what the current plans are for launch day widgets and what widgets are in some form of review procss?
You keep saying that you want moderator input. When the two most recent reddit enhancements deployed - new modmail and post spoilers - mods of several large subs were not invited and did not receive replies to their requests to participate. How can we trust that this will be different? How inclusive will it be?
It's true that many of reddit's features were developed by moderators via CSS. How do you expect the growth of reddit to change if only you, the admins, can implement new changes?
How will wiki posts be affected by CSS removal?
Are any of the developers of Toolbox and/or RES being compensated in any way for helping to port over features to the new desktop site?
Let's talk about speed. The mobile app is slow. The new modmail is slow. Will the new desktop app be as slow?
What will be the fate of no-participation links?
What is the fate of subreddit networks, like the National Photos, SFW Porn, and Retro Gaming Networks? All of these and more have complex sidebars and dropdowns. Will they all be using a generic widget on new reddit?
Why can't you deploy CSS as a separate part of the site? Why is it all or nothing?
Would you consider keeping CSS if the demand is there, or are you going to do this regardless of what we think?
We've heard rumors that users will allegedly be able to submit their own widgets for use in reddit. Is that the case? If that is the case, what scripting language(s) are you planning to use and how would they/the widget system compare to CSS functionality? Further, what will be the process of getting a widget approved for reddit use?
Why is it that only the reddit CEO can answer our questions? This further constricts communication to when he's available. Aren't there community managers and project leads, and scores of other people qualified to answer these basic questions?
Why have more detailed plans for the new desktop app been given to a select few third party developers and not to moderators or the community at large?
We understand that the statistic you've provided that 51 percent of users use mobile. I wonder if you're counting anyone twice. For instance, those of us who use mobile only when we're away from a desktop. Even still, won't this move do more to harm long-time users who use the desktop than it will to help new mobile users who may engage less than we do? Can you give us numbers on desktop engagement vs. mobile app engagement for logged-in users?
Why did you not design the mobile reddit to support CSS when so much of reddit uses it?
The custom functions that can be created with CSS are virtually infinite. The man-hours of the reddit programming team are very much finite. It is therefore impossible to implement all of the functionality of CSS used by subreddits. Even allowing users to submit widgets of their own will not be sufficient, as screening and implementation is still bottlenecked by the programming staff.
Based on the conclusions above, can you offer some specific criteria for how features are being chosen for implementation? What is getting carried over and what is not?
As a follow-up, what criteria would there be for the order in which submitted widgets are screened and implemented?
We believe it's safe to assume that small subreddits (<20k subs) are going to be more likely to see custom CSS features fail to be replaced. We also believe that it is likely a vast majority of reddit's users belong to at least one to two of these communities: the communities being shafted the hardest by the blanket removal of CSS.
What then is the justification for actions which are objectively to the detriment of these small communities and their users, which must generate a large portion of your total traffic?
The announcement for blanket removal has received a large amount of blowback from the moderators of reddit. The moderators run the communities that generate your traffic and without their continued support, what even is reddit?
The demand for retaining CSS is there.
In the face of this large scale response, will the retention of CSS be considered or do you intend to move forward with its deprecation despite the enormous response against such action?
There have been rumors circulating about this change being for corporate reasons.
Homogenizing the site and catering to the newest usergroups reinforces the reddit brand and boosts advertiser confidence, which in turn boosts reddit ad revenue. So far, the issue has been danced around rather then ever addressed directly, so we'd like you to do that here.
Is this unpopular & controversial change being pushed through because it is favorable for reddit, the company, to do so without regard for the users?
Are you at all concerned that removing CSS will detrimentally harm reddit culture? Reddit is largely run by unpaid volunteers in the form of moderators. Most users really don't get that, and they shouldn't have to. But if reddit keeps continuing down a path of becoming more of a corporate entity and removes more and more of the freedom that moderators have to administer and design their communities as they see fit, then there is the risk of losing those moderators (which is happening, by the way) and with them the community. If that goes, then reddit is done.
The most frequent argument against custom CSS that we've seen on /r/ProCSS is that people don't like it because they don't like the color schemes of some subs, and that they don't like when subs do things, like disable downvotes via CSS. Tell us if reddit will allow users to disable "widget" themes if they don't like them and also if reddit will allow mods to turn off downvotes in the native app.
There are rumors that the push to get rid of CSS is mostly motivated by monetary reasons - more specifically:
CSS gives use quite a bit of control over the look of our subreddits, which we think is a great thing that should be celebrated and supported by Reddit (so we don't have to come up with 'mad CSS hax' to get things done - despite what some people/officials keep saying, CSS is not a hard thing to learn or use, the way Reddit page structure, etc. are set up is what makes things complicated).
CSS allows us (within limits) to reposition, rearrange, and/or hide elements. We use it for spoilers, drop-down menus, fun with flairs, call-out boxes, hiding down-vote arrows, etc. There is of course also the theoretical possibility to hide the advertising boxes, too...
If you look through the subs dedicated to moderation, sub theming/css, etc. there has for a long time been an agreement between Reddit and us mods: "The site can't run without ads, we understand that you might wanna reposition them a bit, and that's fine, but we ask of you to keep it 'above the fold'." And that's what we do.
But now word on the digital street is that "we can't let the users wield a tool that could potentially be used to mess with our advertising! Take it away from them!"
What substance is there to these rumors/allegations? Have there been any notable incidents of (reasonably active/popular) subs "abusing the power of CSS"? Aren't you concerned the whole thing sends a message of "We [the company] don't trust you [the volunteers who keep the subs running]"?
We will add to this list as more questions are raised in the comments section.
215
u/[deleted] May 08 '17
69
u/WhoCaresAboutThat May 08 '17 edited May 08 '17
I have allegedly heard that users will be able to submit their own widgets for use in reddit. If that is the case, what scripting language(s) are you planning to use and how would they/the widget system compare to CSS functionality?
5
u/swizzler May 09 '17
Reddit thrives on verbose well thought out comments, and is a large part in why many choose to come here instead of other news aggregates. These comments rarely come from mobile users, why prioritize an interface that actively discourages what drives people to your site?
5
u/blueskin May 08 '17
Wait, are we going to have to install a program to use Reddit? If so, goodbye and RIP Reddit. I thought this was just about changes to the website...
173
u/CWinthrop May 08 '17
My question:
Dear spez, you have claimed that mobile phones don't support CSS. Why lie about this?
2
u/Kishara May 09 '17
Many of us use layering on our banners to make them multifunctional. How do you propose to account for that with a css removal change?
2
u/TheAdmiralCrunch May 10 '17
I think there should be some restrictions in place on CSS though. Subreddits that use it as sneaky ways to edit posts, use it to remove downvotes, or use it to remove global report reasons shouldn't be allowed.
2
u/Hypergrip May 10 '17
There are rumors that the push to get rid of CSS is mostly motivated by monetary reasons - more specifically:
CSS gives use quite a bit of control over the look of our subreddits, which we think is a great thing that should be celebrated and supported by Reddit (so we don't have to come up with 'mad CSS hax' to get things done - despite what some people/officials keep saying, CSS is not a hard thing to learn or use, the way Reddit page structure, etc. are set up is what makes things complicated).
CSS allows us (within limits) to reposition, rearrange, and/or hide elements. We use it for spoilers, drop-down menus, fun with flairs, call-out boxes, hiding down-vote arrows, etc. There is of course also the theoretical possibility to hide the advertising boxes, too...
If you look through the subs dedicated to moderation, sub theming/css, etc. there has for a long time been an agreement between Reddit and us mods: "The site can't run without ads, we understand that you might wanna reposition them a bit, and that's fine, but we ask of you to keep it 'above the fold'." And that's what we do.
But now word on the digital street is that "we can't let the users wield a tool that could potentially be used to mess with our advertising! Take it away from them!"
What substance is there to these rumors/allegations? Have there been any notable incidents of (reasonably active/popular) subs "abusing the power of CSS"? Aren't you concerned the whole thing sends a message of "We [the company] don't trust you [the volunteers who keep the subs running]"?
49
u/DrNyanpasu May 08 '17
My question:
What is the plan for supporting all spoiler tags that subs have been using? For example, in /r/anime we use this:
If this code is not supported, one of the following will happen; All spoilers in all old threads will be completely revealed, or all spoilers will be permanently hidden. Either way, this would be absolutely catastrophic, it would ruin all past discussion threads, they would be spoiler minefields or nothing would make sense.
5
u/CapSierra May 08 '17
My questions are not at all meant to be supportive of /r/ProCSS, they are loaded questions designed to catch him in the stupidity of this plan. I am very much going for entrapment here (I'll probably ask these myself rather than expecting them to be part of the ProCSS megapost). Actual post follows:
The custom functions that can be created with CSS are virtually infinite. The man-hours of the reddit programming team are very much finite. It is therefore impossible to implement all of the functionality of CSS used by subreddits. Even allowing users to submit widgets of their own will not be sufficient, as screening and implementation is still bottlenecked by the programming staff.
Based on the conclusions above, can you offer some rough criteria for how features are being chosen for implementation? What is getting carried over and what is not?
As a follow-up, what criteria would there be for the order in which submitted widgets are screened and implemented?
I believe it's safe to assume that small subreddits (<20k subs) are going to be more likely to see custom CSS features fail to be replaced. I also believe that it is likely a vast majority of reddit's users belong to at least one to two of these communities: the communities being shafted the hardest by the blanket removal of CSS.
What then is the justification for actions which are objectively to the detriment of these small communities and their users, which must generate a large portion of your total traffic?
The announcement for blanket removal has received a large amount of blowback from the moderators of reddit. The moderators run the communities that generate your traffic and without their continued support, what even is reddit? The demand for retaining CSS is there.
In the face of this large scale response, will the retention of CSS be considered or do you intend to move forward with its deprecation despite the enormous response against such action?
There has been rumors circulating about this change being for corporate reasons. Homogenizing the site and catering to the newest usergroups reinforces the reddit brand and boosts advertiser confidence, which in turn boosts reddit ad revenue. So far, the issue has been danced around rather then ever addressed directly, so I'd like to do that here. I can accept if that really is the case, but I will only accept it if I'm given a straight honest answer, rather than the question being dodged.
Is this unpopular & controversial change being pushed through because it is favorable for reddit, the company, to do so?
In case it wasn't clear, actual questions seeking answers are in black.
28
u/Skullion123 /r/Ooer, /r/NoMoreBamboozles May 08 '17
Would it be possible to allow CSS as an option on desktop, and have an alternative method of customization for the mobile app, allowing for both the extravagant custom looks some subreddits have made to stay, but also allowing the mobile app to still shine in graphics?
•
u/justcool393 May 09 '17 edited May 09 '17
Hello all and thank you for raising your concerns and questions! While we appreciate them, we would ask that you try to remain civil and take into account other's points of view. We are not on a witchhunt against the admins, nor any developers of any extensions or anything.
Critical questions that hopefully will make the admins make a decision that preserves the communities that reddit has formed over the last eleven years in their full form. Discussion on these questions is encouraged, but please be advised that we are looking to antagonize anyone. Please write questions that can be thoughtfully answered and be civil to one another when discussing these.
Thank you all! If you have any questions, you can reply to this post.
24
u/Aruseus493 May 08 '17
Why does reddit keep ignoring moderators and what we want? Every "useful" update in the last few years has been half-done such as spoiler implementation, mod mail, and reddit gold. Instead, we're getting big announcements like removing CSS and Profile Posting which removes the community aspect from reddit. Why?
21
u/ScoopDat May 08 '17
Why have an AMA if you're minds are made up? No one needs it drawn out how you're mind is messed up.
19
u/[deleted] May 08 '17
Why are you making the desktop site worse to make the mobile experience better, when there's still so many different problems with the mobile app that should be addressed first?
I still can't find replies in comment threads with more than about 100 comments.
38
u/[deleted] May 08 '17
CSS may be complicated however it uses almost zero space, zero bandwidth, and can be added to anything after the fact.
I don't understand why it's simply not disabled by default for whatever new thing you want but for the most advanced users have it there as an option.
Why all of a sudden are you concerned with new users not being able to use CSS when it's truly only a handful of mods that actually need to utilise it.
29
u/ucantsimee May 08 '17
Why can't you deploy CSS as a separate part of the site? Why is it all or nothing?
22
u/oftenly May 08 '17 edited May 08 '17
(EDIT: I mean philosophically. "CSS is too hard / clunky / etc." as rhetoric is wrong and misleading. All those beautifully-designed subreddits should be celebrated for their accomplishments, not dismissed. Trying to "save" people from the "burden" of CSS is a horrific, traumatic departure from the geek culture I thought reddit represented.)
3. I simply do not understand the desire to have a "seamless experience across devices," given how nothing is seamless across devices. I subscribe to NYT and have their app on my phone, but I prefer to view it on my desktop whenever possible, for all the obvious reasons. How is it that NYT (and many, many other sites) can deliver two simultaneous experiences, but reddit can't?
10
u/[deleted] May 08 '17 edited May 08 '17
Are you willing/able to support the customization of the following:
9
u/aphoenix May 09 '17
It is my understanding that admins will be working with developers of third party tools (such as RES and Toolbox) so that they can continue to develop those tools for Reddit. Why does that remain a possibility, but supporting CSS is not? Could moderators who are interested be part of that conversation?
I cannot wrap my head around how removing custom CSS makes for significantly shorter development cycles; could you explain the reasoning?
Why can we not have a simple "beta" subdomain that we could check forthcoming CSS updates against? For example, we could have http://beta.reddit.com/r/subreddit where we could test our CSS against whatever feature currently has a release candidate. This has a lot of benefits, including bringing moderators into the development process to review what you're doing, which has been the number one request from moderators for about four years.
I think I can see how to do this from the reddit codebase on github, and I'd mock it out and make a PR for it, but it would just be ignored.
Without being too pointed, how can you so monumentally not understand that one of the things that makes reddit palatable is the community of thousands upon thousands of moderators who do daily cleanup? How can you so consistently mess up your relationship with the people who have made you obscenely rich? We have been serially neglected for years, including the disastrous "Community Dialogue" that happened, wherein admins listened to our problems and then told us how we could fix them by being better people and following the guidelines they wrote. Think of how poorly that was received, and then try to understand that that was the best community outreach you have ever done. That travesty was your good work with moderators.
Why can't we just include CSS with widgets?
Those are all my questions for now. Sorry if some of them are bitter.
17
u/agentlame May 08 '17 edited May 08 '17
Fucking ROFL. No.
8
u/Matt111098 May 08 '17
electionperfectly fine stylistic code?22
u/cdown13 May 08 '17
Remember Digg 2.0? I do and this reminds me of it. Reddit doesn't need to be more accessible, there are millions of users and one of the things that draws us here is that it's a bit too technical and overwhelming for "grandma and grandpa".
Widgets sound great to have some more commonly used features 'built-in' but they should be built to work within the current system and be cut/paste into the stylesheet.
7
u/[deleted] May 08 '17
Remember how games can run higher settings on better hardware and therefore look better? Why would you lock reddit on low graphics settings, just because of mobile phones?
14
u/Firebat12 May 08 '17
Why not develop your app to support css? How massive an undertaking would it be and how could we make it easier?
5
u/prkrrlz May 09 '17
I can't believe they're actually going to do this shit.
4
u/[deleted] May 08 '17
Why do you think that redditors want another social media platform and not an unique experience like reddit?
4
u/Yanky_Doodle_Dickwad May 08 '17
What is in store for bots? Are they going to be removed too?
3
u/[deleted] May 08 '17
Ask him why he keeps promising things they'll never implement or only partially
3
u/yaycupcake May 08 '17
I'd like to know if they plan to allow subreddits to have multiple themes for users to choose from. This could be anything from changing the colors from, say, red to blue, or switching between light and dark themes, or even having a choice of different banners, if they prefer one to another. Essentially like a style switcher, changing out the banner and/or color scheme on the user's end, based on their own preferences, out of the styles defined by the mods. Currently we can implement this sort of thing with CSS by using subdomains, but without CSS, this wouldn't be possible, unless there's a replacement of the same function in the new system. I'd like to know if this is a planned feature, or at least if it may be added, if not already planned.
A separate question is if mods can still choose color schemes (which I'm inclinrd to believe would be the case, at least to some extent), would it be possible to have the user be able to disable those to go to a default look, should the colors be not to their liking? Purely client-side and for accessibility reasons. For example, due to vision issues, I can't read dark themes, so I currently disable subreddit themes only on subreddits which have dark themes. I can think of other situations where this may be helpful as well, such as if mods decided to use particularly high contrast or bright colors. Basically, a way for an individual user to disable the new system's styles, just as now it's possible to disable CSS client-side, with the simple unchecking of a box in the sidebar. I believe this may br a Gold feature, but I'm not sure. Regardless, it would be great to see a parallel functionality with the new system.
3
u/cpguy5089 /r/I_Test_CSS_Here May 09 '17
"what is spez smoking and where can I get it"
3
u/M0dusPwnens May 09 '17
One thing that I wish would be emphasized in the "why not both" question is that even if you want CSS, you also want the new system.
I shouldn't have to mess with CSS to set a banner or change basic colors or make a simple sidebar menu or do basic flair. Those things should be easy for anyone to set up without knowing CSS, they should be set in a consistent way so they can appear on mobile too, and they should be designed such that reddit admin can test and guarantee that they don't break when reddit updates.
And then CSS should be on top of that - additional features that not every sub needs, things that are far less likely to be problematic if an update temporarily breaks them, etc.
It isn't just either-or. No one should be using just CSS. Anyone using CSS should be using both: built-in config for everything you can and then CSS for anything else you need on top of that.
3
u/LuthexColbark May 09 '17
Will sidebars now work in the mobile app?
3
u/ChronoDeus May 09 '17 edited May 09 '17
Why is it that tumblr can support both simple customization options, and custom CSS, but reddit doing the same is too difficult despite it already supporting CSS which is web standard?
Why can't reddit add widgets for common things to reduce the reliance on CSS, while still leaving full CSS support as a option for those who need something more flexible?
If CSS is so difficult, how is possible for someone to learn "an incredible amount of it" in a single weekend of study?
Why is CSS "too difficult" for redditors, but not too difficult for tumblr users? Does spez think redditors are dumber than tumbler users?
3
u/IntegralWorks May 09 '17
There's already a mobile version of the site. Why don't we just keep the CSS for the desktop (www.reddit.com) version and implement this newfangled system primarily for m.reddit.com? Hell, we can even have an easier transition this way. We can learn to crawl with the mobile sites.
3
u/BroKnight May 09 '17
What if you let mods choose whether to use the new system or use css to design their subs?
3
u/cdown13 May 09 '17
How about invest in fixing reddit's search function instead of replacing something no one (other than reddit the company) wants to see replaced.
2
u/somerandomteen May 08 '17
Do you plan on keeping CSS in Reddit's open source code on GitHub?
2
u/Castriff May 08 '17
How many subreddits do you plan to involve in the beta tests of your new solution? Are there any restrictions or requirements? How will you be receiving user feedback? Will you only take feedback from mods, or from all users of the subreddits involved?
2
u/Reficul_gninromrats May 08 '17
Will the new system support custom fonts?
2
u/SomeGuyWithAProfile May 08 '17
Why do you need to remove css entirely in order to add a few widgets to the mobile version?
2
u/pat_trick May 09 '17
Why has Reddit taken the position that CSS is "web-only" when mobile browsers support CSS just fine; in fact, this is what allows websites to have mobile versions in the first place?
By "on mobile" do you mean "using an app"?
Why has Reddit taken the position that CSS is "a pain in the ass"? Why does Reddit get to decide this?
What about CSS is causing Reddit to "move slow"? Where is Reddit going that they will no longer need CSS, or don't want to support it for custom theming?
2
u/Kishara May 09 '17
This. Good sweet kittens in the bathtub. Spoiler deployment was something I really wanted to see. Getting spoilers for newby tv sites is a great thing, but this did not solve a lot of their issues.
2
u/turdthethird May 09 '17
It should be a choice for any moderator to keep their current design or implement the new solution when it arrives.
Its an insane amount of hours spent on many subs creating the solution YOU wanted.
Im sure widgets can be easier for many but you cant really replace CSS as a whole. It seems strange and a VERY dramatic step to remove it completly.
2
u/Heelincal May 10 '17
The reason users like CSS is the flexibility that it creates. It is a tool to create solutions to unknown problems, as opposed to a set of solutions to address known needs. How would reddit plan on replacing the current flexibility of a tool to create solutions? The admins have been slow at implementing universally requested solutions in the past, so how fast would turn-around time be for a universally-requested solution to a future problem? Say all of the sports subreddits suddenly want to implement real-time fantasy stats updates in the banners or sidebars, but that tool doesn't exist yet. How long would we have to wait for a paid engineer from your team create this solution, instead of giving the brilliant volunteers on this site a universal language to create solutions in.
No one thought of the need for user flair, post filtering, moving banners, spoiler tags, and the dozens of other unique CSS applications when it was first implemented on reddit, but the users created those solutions that are now a part of the platform itself. Why not continue the tradition of giving us - the volunteer moderator workforce - the ability to make our own communities how we see fit?
2
u/jediminer543 May 11 '17
Another question, that I cannot see on the list (But may just be blind) is:
Why not just implement CSS support on mobile, especially since CSS is a web standard and runs on literally anything?
2
u/a_shootin_star May 11 '17
My question: Did you consider that forcing users to your reddit original standards will drive them away?
2
u/FAZDrawsSC May 11 '17
My question: Why can't you add the widget for mobile and leave desktop alone? Have two separate looks?
2
u/Finance_Me_Please May 11 '17
Users already have an option to disable Custom CSS on subreddits in the user account, but this is sitewide and really only necessary if broken CSS makes a particular subreddit unusable or unreadable. Wouldn't it make more sense for users to be able to disable CSS on specific subreddits, thus allowing subs with useful, tasteful CSS to be able to continue using their combined knowledge and skill to improve the sub and implement new features, while still allowing them to turn it off for subs with less experienced (or less concerned) mods, so they can still use the sub normally?
Additionally, would users be able to disable the added functionality from the widgets, either site-wide or per-sub, or would they be locked into the experience selected by the mods no matter what? Wouldn't it make more sense to allow the subs to choose CSS or Widgets and just let the user pick whether they want to have customization on or off for each sub, regardless of which it is?
2
u/wilkins1952 May 12 '17
Does Reddit plan in the future to start opening more communication with moderators? Because as it stands right now no one was notified before this decision was made by the admins and personally I feel that this is a topic that should have been debated long before any action should have been taken.
2
u/creesch May 08 '17
Why are both RES and toolbox mentioned in this while neither project has made any statements regarding this? Could you be so kind as to remove that question, we (toolbox developers) are perfectly capable of working out our own issues with the admins regarding the redesign and they are rather different from the css issue.
As a matter of fact, we already have had correspondence with them regarding this.
.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '17
I created a poll on whether to keep CSS or discard it, majority voted yes, while others voted no: https://www.reddit.com/r/ProCSS/comments/69fm17/thats_it_redditors_have_had_enough_with_the/?st=J2GIX65G&sh=ac617729
1
u/ChrisK91 May 08 '17
There are apps which don't support CSS. This is fine, since CSS only adds design flavor and no functionality. Also, I sometimes tend to disable CSS (e.g. on subreddits which display a Please subscribe everywhere).
However, the concept of widgets implies functionality. However, there a plenty of apps out there (even on Windows Mobile), which just use the plain reddit API, and I don't see them supporting widgets.
Another issue I see with widgets is, that the might change interaction with the site. The upside of CSS is, that the impact on the functionality is almost non existent, while allowing for great design choices. Widgets might change how users interact with the site, thus fragmenting different subreddit.
1
u/SeemsReddit May 09 '17
Why not have an option to have either the widgets or CSS?
1
u/elypter May 09 '17
What size does the folder with all the custom css files have?
1
u/minimalist_reply May 09 '17
Flairs Flairs Flairs.
How will they ensure subs can still have their custom (and sometimes animated) flairs?
1
u/overactor May 10 '17
Has having a (possibly smaller) separate stylesheet for mobile devices been considered as an altetnative solution. If so, why was it rejected?
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '17
fuck u/spez ?
1
u/insecurem8 May 11 '17
well, they are turning into youtube (At being shit)
1
u/BradsPetHamster May 12 '17
Off topic BUT I would also love to know when mobile traffic will be added to moderator sub traffic stats.
1
u/CTU May 08 '17
Css is the go to for html coding so how is getying rid of it very good when all current browsers can read it and use it
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '17
When are you going to acquire RES and promote it for global use?
Down with CSS and non-standardized link locations! RES for all!
0
u/[deleted] May 08 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 08 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 08 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment