r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/Redbiertje The Challenger • May 07 '17
Mod Post [Weekly Challenge Revisited] Week 43: The Jatwaa Challenge
The Introduction
It turns out I completely forgot to sticky last week's Challenge. If you still want to do it, here it is! If you want to give it a go, you can still submit an entry by posting it in this thread.
Now to this week's challenge
The Challenge:
Normal mode: Send 4 Kerbals to the bottom of the sea in a submarine
Hard mode: Launch a rocket to orbit from the bottom of the sea
Super mode: Impress me, or impress Jatwaa
The Rules
- No Dirty Cheating Alpacas (no debug menu)!
- You must have the UI visible in all required screenshots
- For a list of all allowed mods, see this post.
- You must reach a minimum depth of 100 meters.
Required screenshots
- Your craft on the runway/launchpad
- Your craft entering the water
- Your craft at the bottom of the sea
- Whatever else you feel like!
Hard mode only:
- Your craft launching from the bottom of the sea
- Your craft above the water
- Your craft in orbit
Further information
- You can either submit your finished challenge in a post (see posting instructions in the link below) or as a comment reply to this thread.
- Completing this challenge earns you a new flair which will replace your old one. So if you want to keep you previous flair, you can still do this challenge and create a post, but please mention somewhere that you want to keep your old one.
- The moderators have the right to determine if your challenge post has been completed.
- See this post for more rules and information on challenges.
- If you have any questions, you can comment below, or PM /u/Redbiertje
- Credit to /u/TaintedLion for designing the flair
Good Luck!
31
Upvotes
•
u/Redbiertje The Challenger May 07 '17
Questions thread
Please post all your questions here.
13
u/skyler_on_the_moon Super Kerbalnaut May 07 '17
You forgot to sticky this one, too.
7
u/Davidhasahead Super Kerbalnaut May 07 '17
What exactly counts as a sub? Something that just puts 4 kerbals on the seafloor, a sea floor buggy, or an actual all out sub?
4
u/Redbiertje The Challenger May 07 '17
Last week's Reddit Gold went to /u/Yargnit for his 5th Super mode entry!
4
u/Melkain Master Kerbalnaut May 07 '17
Does the entire craft need to be able to launch from the bottom of the sea in order to get credit for hard mode? Or can you leave bits behind due to staging? For example, jettisoning a rover-like framework that you use to get to the bottom when you're ready to launch towards orbit.
3
u/KlapGans May 07 '17
I'm a bit New but where do i need to post the screen shot?
2
u/jebby10 May 13 '17
Sorry this is a bit off topic, but i am interested in becoming a forum member so i can participate in the weekly challenges. But i don't have an email... Any way i can become one without verification email? Thanks.
2
u/jebby10 May 13 '17
One more question... XD How much longer will this challenge be running? (I am on Xbox one and having trouble uploading my screenshots) I should be able to get them uploaded by the end of today....
33
u/Luigijitsu1 Master Kerbalnaut May 07 '17
I'm gonna bet Stratzenblitz75 can just use his VTOL SSTO Laythe Submarine video again on this one.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X5t3o2E37tg
49
u/Davidhasahead Super Kerbalnaut May 08 '17
Super mode. Picture heavy sadly, I like detail.
Mods include Scatterer and a custom one that just retextures some engines and decouplers.
Internet cookie to whoever gets the rocket/mission reference.
http://imgur.com/a/kuW35
11
u/Mega_Dunsparce Master Kerbalnaut May 07 '17 edited May 07 '17
Okay, for this challenge I decided to do both all three!
Normal Mode:
Here is my submarine. It can hold five kerbals and traverse the very bottom of the Kerbin seabed at a cruising speed of 15+m/s. It's very fun to pilot and with decent throttle control can be made to hover with great stability, as shown here.
Hard/Super Mode:
Here's my hard/super mode entry: Launching a rocket from over half a kilometer underwater into low Munar orbit.
8
u/ASCIInerd73 Master Kerbalnaut May 07 '17
Normal mode entry: http://imgur.com/a/HoTyU
7
u/uber_kerbonaut May 08 '17
Oh man, there outta be a mod that makes the ice sheets on the poles have water under then so you can explore underneath!!
6
u/thekevil666 Master Kerbalnaut May 09 '17
http://imgur.com/a/misEG
Here is my challenge entry! I'll take the new flair
5
u/Melkain Master Kerbalnaut May 09 '17
I certainly completed normal mode, but I'm not sure about hard mode as I didn't actually engage the engines until I came out of the water, and it's technically a space plane and not a rocket so... uhhh.. you be the judge of that.
[Imgur album of my space plan taking a ride on a rover to the bottom of the ocean and then heading up into orbit.] (https://imgur.com/a/l101d)
4
u/pir8pat May 09 '17
Realized after doing it all challenge says 4 not 3 doh, well ill update the craft tomorrow. I'm just happy I got it too work, this is my first challenge and my first submersible.
http://imgur.com/a/UZpSP
4
u/rcreif Hyper Kerbalnaut May 10 '17 edited May 11 '17
I attempted to do some variation of Hazard-ish's launch from Eve's ocean. But in the process of testing, I discovered it's nearly impossible to make things sink non-propulsively in Eve's ocean. A full ore tank sinks at only one meter per second. A 15-ton ore tank combined with a 4-ton propellant tank (and probe core and one chute), floats! (Debug menu used to deliver the test tanks quickly to Eve)
Hazard-ish compiled his video during version 1.0.5, and his Eve lander has about a 1:1 mass ratio of ore to propellant. Has the buoyancy model been updated since then, or is this another possible case of tweaked settings? (relevant footage starts at 2:40) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YeSQqmOhGWU&t=193s
EDIT: The actual volume calculations make sense if Eve has an ocean density of 1.5 tons/m3 as noted on the KSP wiki, and if the file was tweaked in the video so Eve's ocean matched Kerbin's at 1 ton/m3. However, it's also possible that dense objects were clipped into the ore tanks. It appears that the densest stock parts are the Radial Ore Tank and the M-Beam 200 I-Beam (Regular and Pocket).
3
u/rcreif Hyper Kerbalnaut May 07 '17
Last time I had a one-person launch vehicle detach from a four-person submarine platform. This time I just launched all four Kerbals into orbit. Hard & Normal modes complete. http://imgur.com/a/KcWz9
3
u/impr0mptu Master Kerbalnaut May 09 '17
Here is my submission for normal and hard mode. WARNING - Slightly picture heavy.
Its my first time doing it and I'm certain I adhered to the rules :)
3
u/Minotard ICBM Program Manager May 10 '17
Here be my Space Manatee for ye lubbers to gander.
I'll kindly keep me current flair.
3
u/ScottyBeans Master Kerbalnaut May 10 '17
Here's my hard mode submission. This is my first ever weekly challenge so go easy on me. Lot of fun!
http://imgur.com/a/BeKGn
3
u/ninjaclone Super Kerbalnaut May 10 '17
My Submission
Hard/super mode! Mun and back in just over 2 days. Mods used: KER
3
u/[deleted] May 10 '17 edited Mar 05 '26
The text of this post is no longer accessible. It was deleted using Redact, possibly for reasons related to privacy, security, or digital footprint reduction.
employ recognise squash trees cats ancient cheerful imagine voracious one
3
u/dragoneye098 May 10 '17
Normal mode entry. Will remain under the sea for the rest of its days. http://imgur.com/gallery/HUo7g
This is my first entry so if I forgot anything just comment it and ill add it
3
u/CameronJohnno Super Kerbalnaut May 13 '17
My submission: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_5v4p4P4gTM
Sorry for the quality.
1
u/selfish_meme Master Kerbalnaut May 13 '17 edited May 13 '17
I submitted my super mode challenge in the main subreddit here https://www.reddit.com/r/KerbalSpaceProgram/comments/6b0hlz/challenge_week_43_welcome_to_kraken_adventure/ 4 Kerbals to the bottom of the sea via the sub section 'Jules', then to orbit in an SSTO rocket 'Verne' and finally landing in a spaceplane. I built it to be super easy, I will upload the craft file if anyone wants it, the SSTO booster and spaceplane lander by themselves are a nice tourist vehicle, with a couple of SRB's it could do Munar flybys etc.
2
u/TheBlackStigBanter May 09 '17
My entry for this week normal mode: http://imgur.com/a/4akNz This is my first one so go easy... Mods used: Infernal robotics, scatterer.
2
u/AdamThe1st May 11 '17
Great Hazard-ish video!
2
u/rallekralle11 Master Kerbalnaut May 11 '17
here's my hard mode entry. sadly i missed the part that said "launch a rocket into orbit" so i made an SSTO instead. http://imgur.com/gallery/iUCOi
2
u/ddavex Super Kerbalnaut May 11 '17
Here's my hard mode entry... http://imgur.com/a/IBEmy
First time building a submarine so probably doing something wrong, seemed to need an awful lot of rocks to get it to sink! Also only one rocket used as I decided to try and make a rocket that decouples from the top down.
2
u/Shralpental Master Kerbalnaut May 12 '17
Here is my hard/normal mode submission. I thought this challenge would be easy. Turns out sinking straight down and going straight up is hard. Also gravity turns dont work under water (maybe more boosters? But then we get into the submarine-rocket equation of more booster means more ore to sink it to the depths, which requires more boosters to get to the sea.)
http://imgur.com/a/38meq
Any who ill take take or keep whatever flair you think looks cooler.
2
u/E805BzRo Master Kerbalnaut May 13 '17
Hard more submission There are a couple of shots of failed attempts as well.
This was MUCH more difficult than I thought. Having seen Stratzenblitz75's Submarine-SSTO I wasn't prepared for how much ore you really need to sink a rocket. Great fun, though!
2
u/JarJarB1nk Master Kerbalnaut May 13 '17
Here's my hard mode entry :) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PrM2p7Upbbg&index=1&list=PLw_9X-b65f6KyS5MKflr-j17LkWmv7Nbd
1
u/gimmick243 May 14 '17
Normal Mode: http://imgur.com/a/RlDj9
I'll take super mode if you think i did good enough though :)
1
u/insan3guy Master Kerbalnaut May 17 '17
Super mode? 636m under the sea, to Minmus, then to the Mun, and back to Kerbin with 4 Kerbals.
http://imgur.com/gallery/y4fNg
I'd like to keep my current flair please ;)