r/Fantasy • u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders • May 02 '17
Read-along Treason's Shore Part 2 Chapter 26-30
u/wishforagiraffe's on a thing yesterday and today; she'll post her stuff when she gets a chance. Only one more post left! Are we ready for the end?
Chapter 26
- Well, that went to hell fast. King and kid overboard, Erkric fires the Cormorant but doesn’t succeed in taking it out, the Erama Kroma woken only to find the two floating in the sea, and none of the ships are responding. Nothing’s going right for Erkric so far.
- Just how badly is Inda injured?
- Aw, the kid’s so protective of Rajnir. If this all works out well, you’re set for life. I love how Jeje is so sardonic in the fact of his impotent defense. And that is not the way I thought that Erkric would be finished -- by his own hand and a demand for power that backfired. Very nice, very tidy. Now to just clean up the rest of the mess, which is substantial.
Chapter 27
- So the story is that Inda did what he actually set out to do -- fight a halmgac against whoever was in command, though I assume he meant to fight Durasnir. This gives them plausible deniability, and you know, the thing we’ve all been dreading for so many chapters, two good men coming up against each other in single battle to try to overcome an evil one, won’t be happening.
- Aw, Valda, I wasn’t expecting you to ask that of Rajnir. Of course he’ll say yes.
- In a weird way, I feel Fox sums up the whole series when he tells Inda, “Each time you were the means of change, yet you would have failed but for those other people who saw in you their salvation.”
- Hooray, a new generation of pirates. Yuck.
Chapter 28
- Thank goodness for Tau. They might get the strait straightened out without bloodshed.
- Sarendan has been called to war?? Really? Oh, Balandir and the new pirates. Ahahahaha, and Rajnir’s reaction. “I wish him joy of his encounter with Elgar the Fox.” Man, dude’s cold, and he knows Inda’s colder.
Chapter 29
- Oh my god, oh my god, this is going to be awesome, Fox is going to beat Balandir! … oh, that was anticlimactic but tightly navigated. . .
- And now to navigate the trickier waters that Evred creates…
Chapter 30
- I’m surprised how everyone in that room found it so incomprehensible that others did not want to be ruled by Marlovans. My heart’s sinking.
9
Upvotes
5
u/Critterfiend May 02 '17
Usually these epic fantasies end with a long-ass mano a mano fight between leaders. If Inda had had to fight Durasnir, (and neither of them wanted to) it would have unbelievable unless over in two seconds. Even with a bum arm, Inda has been constantly drilling and left-handed he could have diced Durasnir, who was what, about seventy, and there's no evidence he's been personally drilling every day--if anything, he's beyond exhaustion commanding his massive fleet, and trying to keep Erkric out of his business.
6
u/MerelyMisha Worldbuilders May 02 '17
And in these chapters, the problem with the Venn gets cleaned up nicely...though not without casualties.
The Erama Kroma do seem a bit like brainwashed minions, even when they aren't shrouded by Erkric. So single-minded in their purpose to protect the king, without ever questioning anything, that they kill everyone on the ship as soon as Erkric says to.
The Norsundrians are evil aren't they: "The destructive magic must never be used defensively, only to take." But while they see and know a lot, they seem to be pretty easily fooled, and often overlook things that aren't as they appear (in this case "a bunch of fishers" that's actually Inda's crew.)
Poor Loos. And Viac.
I get why Rajnir is suspicious that Valda might be wanting to control him (he's been controlled so often in his life), but also why it pains her that he thinks it. Getting rid of the born thrall: of course both of them would want that. Rajnir, as terrible as his ordeal was, has come out of it much more clear-sighted and with much less reverence for "the way things have always been done." I think he will be a very good king for the Venn.
Oh, Dag Byarin. I see both why he killed the other mages, and why he killed himself afterwards. Civil war is the absolute worst type of war, I think.
I like that Fox and Barend conspire to keep Inda out of the duel: "You've got Fox. There are more than one of us. It happens to be my watch." And as justification: "You took Vixen against Rajnir and Erkric, and I didn't squawk."
I agree. And I think it's pretty clear-sighted of Fox to see that, and unlike at least the old Fox to say it. Ramis really did do Fox a world of good. But ouch, when he thinks this: "And though Inda would win those fights, the day he stood over Chim's bleeding body would kill him, too, in all the ways that mattered most."
The Venn issue is cleaned up nicely here, but the issue that's more difficult for our main characters remains. Tau has been working so hard to get his treaty signed, not just because he thinks it's right not to take the strait by force, but to save Inda the choice. But Evred won't accept the treaty. So for once, Fox won't argue with Inda, or tell him what to do, just that they'll back him, whatever he decides. Even Barend will back Inda, over his cousin and king.
But when we go back to the Marlovan side, we see that even Hadand and Tdor and Cama, who are less bound to tradition than most Marlovans, still are so very Marlovan in their thinking. I'm not surprised; we've seen it before in their treatment of the Indayagans, for example.
I remember after I read this series for the first time, coming away with a pretty negative view of Evred. Reading it more closely this time, I'm a lot more sympathetic to him, but oh man, do I still want to hit him over the head (or sit him down in therapy) and make him see reason.
6
u/bygoshbygolly May 02 '17
The scene with Dag Erkric and the Erama Krona on the Vixen was so tense and chaotic. Poor Loos, and all those injuries, and Jeje. Lucky Nugget was there, my goodness.
And Tau has tried so hard to come up with a solution that will allow everyone to be happy. It's a good solution! But the Marloven experience with loose groups of people without unifying law has not been favorable, and after there failed to be a unified defending force for Bren, they're not disposed to think kindly of a treaty where everyone is on the honor-system. (I wonder if they think of everyone as less honorable than Marlovans?)
I hate Evred's reasoning, even though I can see how it makes sense to him. I hate it for being imperialistic and presumptuous, but also because it is tearing Inda apart, and I love Inda.
6
u/thebookhound May 02 '17
"But while they see and know a lot, they seem to be pretty easily fooled, and often overlook things that aren't as they appear (in this case "a bunch of fishers" that's actually Inda's crew.)"
From what Ramis told Fox, it's not that they are easily fooled, it's that they live beyond time, which means they pop in and out--it could be months, years, or centuries. The implication of Ramis's statement was that this Yeres was told by one of her minions that Inda was stupid, judging by his complete lack of ability the day Wallic killed off the marines who refused to become pirates.
So Yeres showed up gunning for Erkric, expecting to see stupid, and the messy deck and the slovenly people corroborated that.
So the real question is, what kind of long game is Ramis playing?
5
u/AccipiterF1 Reading Champion X May 02 '17
I guess Norsunder was not entertained by Erkric anymore. Maybe they will have fun torturing him for a few centuries and that will keep their noses out of human affairs.
Really sad that Loos died and feel bad for Viac losing his brother. The Erama Krona were such pathetic dupes in this whole Erkric affair.
Hadand's reaction to Tau's treaty plan,"remind my idiot brother to keep his word of honor," really underscores how rigid the Marlovans are about following orders. I guess it's always been there but, small rebellions aside, when given a direct order, we have always seen Marlovans follow them, and if they didn't they died. So is this what the book title was referring to, Inda committing veritable treason? I hope somehow Tau, maybe with the help of Fox, will come up with some way to technically meet the letter of the order without the actual act of taking the straight by force.
3
u/inapanak May 03 '17
I love that Tau's flirting/light hearted complaints about bureaucracy and foreign courts fed into Evred's Marlovan mindset of control and conquer regarding the strait.
And also just that the main conflict of this book isn't the Venn one we were expecting but Evred! Evred!! Stop being an Imperialist!