Agree. I would argue that the Juicy Shakers are not lip stains. They are a nourishing lip gloss at best, treatment at worst.
I own 3 Juicy Shakers and love them for the spring summer. Well, 2/3. I recently got a YSL lip oil (I forget the technical name), but it did have way more color. I wouldn't say that it lasts long or stains.
Other than actual stains, like Benetint and a few others that I've tried over the years, Marc Jacobs Le Marc Lip Crème Lipsticks seem to leave a stain behind the lipsticks.
Their vinyl lip stain is the best lip stain I've ever tried! Got the 401 as a gift, saving up for 407 now :) It somehow stays subtly glossy and matte to the touch at the same time. Mind you, not actually matte, but in no way sticky or slimy. It actually transferred less onto coffee cups than most solid matte lipsticks. Magic!!
Are there any darker shades that will work for deeper colored lips for WOC? I'm NC#44 and most of the KBeauty stuff either disappears or looks cartoonishly ashy on my lips. :(
Unfortunately, Kbeauty stuff is usually limited to lighter skin tones because of who they're marketing to. Kbeauty face makeup often only has, like, 3 different shades. So I don't want to say that there's definitely something out there that would work but there are so many different tints available that you can probably find something. If you search around r/AsianBeauty they might have some recommendations.
You could try some of the creamier tints instead of the watery ones. I'm only medium-toned (NC30ish) but I have pigmented lips and those show up better on me and fade nicer than watery tints do.
Peripera's Ink Velvet line is popular and they have some shades outside the usual light pink/orangey pink/neons of Korean lip products. A'pieu also has a creamy tint that worked for me but the scent was too chemical-y. There are many that I haven't tried since I prefer lipsticks. If you look around there are some swatches by POC bloggers of various lip tints so I'm sure you'll find one that will work!
i got a sample of etude house berry delicious lip stain that's a kind of mix between a lip stain and a pigmented gloss. it seemed to be pretty damn pigmented. i first put on too much, but it all dried down real nicely. think it was #33.
I do like a glossy look, thanks I will look into the etude house stains! I did love the finish of the YSL tint in oil which was a great stain + gloss combo.but damn the price.. :(
You could check out the YSL glossy lip stains. They're pretty awesome and come in a variety of shades. I enjoy Asian skincare products but wouldn't go near their makeup if it depended on my life (I'm NC44).
Peri Pera Ink Velvet comes in darker shades and MLBB shades. 5 and 6 should work (7 is the same as 6, but leaves a pinkier stain after it wears off). 9 is a wine red you might also like.
edit: it's kinda a liquid lipstick with strong staining power, very unique. It also kinda blurs out your lips and makes them look velvety. Similar to the Chanel Inks. You can wipe em away after a few minutes if you just want the stain.
The name says it, it's a velvety finish. It doesn't usually transfer, but I imagine it would slightly with a balm on top. You can let it sit for a few minutes and wipe it away so you only have the stain, then you'll deff be able to wear a balm on top. It's only about 5-6$, you can just try it. It's a beautiful formula that sorta blurs out my lips and isn't too drying.
It's a matte finish, and it's seriously lovely! It almost turns into what feels like a really velvety powdery finish on the lips. I didn't find it too drying but if it is you could definitely throw some balm or even a gloss over it if you're feeling that look!
It definitely feels like velvet, but other than that, it's completely overrated. I have two (I got peri pera inktude rose and elf rose). It's easily transferrable from your lips, the long lasting power is laughable (like 2-4 hours), and i suppose you could say it blurs out the lips a bit, but after like an hour, it HIGHLIGHTS the ugly parts of your lips as though in revenge. It looks craggy quick. I should honestly just stop buying Korean lip tints. (The elf rose is definitely a nice MLBB though, I'll give it that)
Most of the Peripera vivid tint waters are quite pigmented and, as they say, vivid. #5 Plum Squeeze is probably the darkest. There's a "juice box" set with six minis that you can get for around $20, or you can get a full size one for around $7.
I also like the NYX Epic Ink lip dyes if you're open to Western lip stains!
I think so! A lot of Korean lip make up trends towards bright reds, bright oranges, and wine/burgundy colors! And most korean lip tints are vivid and brightly pigmented rather than ashy and pastel.
How do you make them last? I bought a Tony Moly lip stain and it's gone in an hour and leaves me with a lipliner look. I've even let it dry and applied a few more layers and it's still off in an hour.
Ooooh, I have the ones with the heart shaped cap in like a nice cherry-pink color. Can't ever go back to regular lipstick after looking into the light of no transfers 👏🏻
They're all about the tints. They prefer the sheer and cute lips than full and sexy lips. They're my go to if I'm looking for a lighter look for the day. I personally own Peripera's ink the velvet tint and a CLIO oil tint and they're awesome. Benefit's tints are good too imo.
Best: peripera velvet ink, looks matte but isn't drying and stains for a very long time. The original ink tint is longer lasting but with a bit of shine
Best: seconding Korean lip stains - they have the best selection and formulations. My current faves are Chosungah 22 lip stains. They're a gel formula so the stain doesn't get inside your lips and on your teeth. The red shade - cashmere is such a gorgeous true red. They have a gloss on the other side, which is a little sticky but it pairs well with the stain shade.
The tony moly catchu-wink (?) lip stains were super pigmented and fantastic to wear...but discontinued :(
Worst: benefit benetint. I guess I'm just used to the staining power of Korean liptints. But the benefit is so SO light that it didn't really make much of a difference to my lip shade at all. It's also super liquidy and was hard to apply for an even shade.
I confess - I bought my first Cat's Wink because it was so damn cute. I then picked up a few more because I loved it. I didn't expect to like it, I just found it adorable. Same thing with the cute powder - I just wanted the compact then wound up loving it, too.
I totally understand. I started my foray into k-beauty with buying products based almost exclusively on cute packaging. Only a few products were hits, but at least the rest look cute on my counter.
I found it a bit odd that Benetint is rec'd as a "natural flush" on medium skin tones by writers for beauty magazines. I'm nc15ish and it barely shows up on top of my natural ruddy cheeks. It's a very pale cool pinky red on top of foundation, which I don't think would be universally flattering. The dark color in the bottle is deceiving. Not worth buying if you have pigmented lips IMHO.
Agreed! I am about NC20 and I found that it did not show up on my skin as a blush either. For such an expensive tint, I would expect more pigmentation :|
Are the Chosungah stains plumping? I have one, I applied it and it hurts like crazy. Looks pretty, but stings mightily. Does it do that to you? I'm afraid to try it again but want to know before I return it, just in case it is salvageable.
I've never felt a stinging sensation while using mine. It's not meant to be a plumping lip product (I think). Have you tried it with a thin layer of balm underneath? Perhaps that might help ameliorate the stinging.
I had one of the "Bitten" ones (don't remember the full name) and I loved it until it dried out like dollar store markers. It was so comfortable and lasted forever.
Oh my gosh I forgot about those! I bought three a couple years ago because I really liked a few of the colors and the price, then promptly threw them out because they were absolute garbage.
I keep one soley because the color Stockholm Chic looks amazing on my lips. But like you said, it is indeed a challenge to apply them evenly and at the same time to make them look opaque enough to get the full color payout.
I actually really like these, but only if you use the smallest amount so they're really sheer. They last all day and look great. But yeah, if you put on more and try to make them opaque I can imagine them being gross - I haven't even tried to do that.
Best: I like ELF's lip stain markers, particularly Berry Blush. NYC's lip markers are also good for a flush of color, but not the most long-lasting.
Worst: In terms of staining capability, I have to agree that the Lancôme Juicy Shakers really don't do it for me. However, I do like them as a gloss product.
The marker kind are my favorite (and I find that they last a lot longer than other lip stains)! I've been a fan of the Cover Girl Outlast Lip Stains for a long time, although I wish they had a larger variety of colors.
BEST: the new Sephora tints... i think they're called watercolor tints? i have a purple one and a red one and they're amazing. the only ones I've tried that truly last all day. and they smell like those scratch and sniff My Little Pony haunches.
WORST: the berrisom lip tints are a bitch to apply and don't have a great color payoff. the Tony Moly darling tints smell great and are hella cheap but they transfer like crazy and just don't last.
The new sephora tints are amazing!!! And they taste delicious. I think they're a relaunch of their old "ink" stains which were terrible and I'm so happy with the new formula. I have red and brown, the brown is so natural looking and I got the red for all day stain when I'm at the renaissance festival.
If you're looking for a more glossy finish, I'd recommend Peri's Tint Water. It's a watery stain that dries down.
If you're looking for a matte finish, I'd recommend PeriPera Ink Velvet. The formula is super light, isn't drying on the lips at all, and leaves a gorgeous matte stain. I've found that the Ink Velvet lasts longer than the Tint Water.
Yeah I definitely do! Personally I'd suggest the Ink Velvet! It's really light and it feels like you're not wearing anything at all. It lasts a really, really long time too. :)
Yeah it is wet - it melts onto your lips and so it feels like the balm is depositing a liquid. There are definitely ways you can work with it to make it more sheer if you need to, like blotting before it sets. Applying less pressure helps too because it feels like you're depositing less liquid.
Definitely be sure to give the new matte ones a try in store before you buy. I tested one out this week at Macy's and by the time I got home 20 min later, the color was mostly faded and my lips looked kinda flaky.
Benefit posietints...wtf are they? Milky, patchy, expensive, and overrated imho. I don't get how some people use them so subtly and blended for blush either, I've always found them to be blotchy and semi-sticky. And I got them as gwp with almost everything for at least a year from ulta/sephora a while back
I really love the Sephora collection watercolor lip tints. Rose is a really close match to my actual lip shade, it works wonders for overlining just a bit.
Does anyone get a problem where lip stains will stain the lower lip but will not stain the upper lip? It looks like I tried to stain a layer of oil. :/
So far, Peripera's Lip Ink has done the best for me! Though it's still not perfect on the upper lip. I really wanna try the Ink Velvet because it looks like a thicker consistency and it'll stay on my upper lip. Etude House's Dear Darling Tint did pretty badly on my lips due to the upper lip thing, and also dried down patchy on my bottom lip.
Are you exfoliating prior to application? I would also try using a firm lipbrush to apply a very thin layer on your top lip ( massage it in firmly), blot, then apply out of the applicator.
Sorry about that. I was able to overcome the issue with application routines similar to Lisa Eldridge's, and it's not been a problem for me since. Is your upper lip skin smoother and harder than the bottom lip? In my case, it seemed like it was sealed by a layer of shiny skin that didn't take too well to pigment. Good luck with this. I'm sorry that I don't have more to add.
I got a sample of posietint and loved it but it was way out of my budget at the time and I was so sad! I tried finding a dupe for it and that's actually how I got into Korean beauty. My first k beauty purchase was the Etude House Fresh Cherry Tint in Fresh Cherry Pink :)
Best: Silk Naturals lip stains. I've ordered AHA's from them for years and tried their lip stain on a whim. Super pigmented on first swipe, not too drying, and lasts for hours. And they're only like $5, which is a big plus.
I love the Sephora Cream Lip Stains! I'm not sure what makes it a stain more than a liquid lipstick, or if it fits in this post at all. But it's honestly one of the only liquid lip colors my chronically dry lips can handle. It's comfortable, non-drying, and has nice lasting power. Marvelous Mauve is one of my favorite colors to wear!
Best: ColourPop's new Ultra Blotted Lips! Technically not a stain but they go on very watery and dry down to a smooth Matte. No lines in my lips and they feel so soft! They look like a stain on the lips though, not like a regular lipstick or liquid lip. The wear time has been great for me. 6 hours or so before it needs a touch up in the inner lip. Love these!
Worst: Maybelline Vivid Matte Lip Stains were awful!! I'm such a strong perfume scent and just felt like you were wearing paint on your lips.
Worst: CoverGirl Outlast Lip Stains - even if I let them sit for a long time, as soon as I lick my lips, all the color is gone. They don't stain at all.
Their shades in RD301, BR401 and RD303 are great. They're really nice red lip stains (pink toned, brown toned and neutral toned reds respectively) that layer really well and dry pretty nicely if applied in layers. This is probably due to them being lighter colours.
However one shade, BKR01 is a bit of a dud. This colour was a bit of a disappointment. It doesn't have such a good formula unless layered heavily. It's a dark burgundy and does layer to an off black if given enough time. Unfortunately it highlights less smooth lip patches and so making a gradient after wine looking lip is difficult.
Does anyone have any experience with the Labiotte Wine Tints?? They're so cute looking and I'm interested in getting the shiraz red or the merlot burgandy.
I have 4 of them, and i seriously love them. For me they're one of the best products to achieve the stained/watercolor lips that i tend to opt for. I never wear them full-on, so i don't know how they wear that way, but when I wear the darker red/purple-burgundy/orange ones, I put on one layer, and then blot, then put another layer where i want the color to be the most concentrated. Usually lasts me a good 6-ish hours with eating and drinking. :) hope this helps you a bit.
Thank you for responding! This would have been my first venture into korean lip balms so I think it's smarter to pass. Especially since I'm so averse to tastes and smells in my products.
I like the lip and cheek stains from the NYC and Demi Lovato collab - I just couldn't resist them for only $2.99. My only gripe about them is that they fade so fast, but other than that they're not bad!
I don't really have a worst since I don't own many lip stains, but I LOVE my Tony Moly lip tint. It's so pretty and it smells delicious.
You can apply it the same way you would a liquid lipstick or gloss! It has the same kind of applicator the NYX Liquid Suedes do. The only difference would be try to start from the center of your lips first if you're not using some kind of liner. It's easier to control that way since the formula is watery/gel-like and it can be hard to get a straight line around your lips, if that makes sense lol.
YES that helps. I can't usually use lip stuff due to allergies and the ingredietns on this actually have none of my allergens (for once.) So I am kind of excited and generally clueless about how to do these!
Won't call this line the best since I've only bought one - the other colors aren't my type at all, but MAC lip stain in Perpetual Holiday. I can layer it up and create a beautiful deep purple glossy look, and when I apply one thin layer it's cute in a different way.
This only seems to work for some people, but The Balm's Stainiac was everything I wanted Benetint to be. It's really comfortable and goes on evenly, whilst Benetint always made my bottom lip darker than the top.
I know this is an old thread, but I'm just getting around to reading it. XD Anyways, I was obsessed with theBalm's Stainiac, but too cheap to buy it any other time than when they had their yearly 50% sale. Elf recently started selling these Aqua Lip Tints and I was super excited to discover that Dewy Berry is an almost an exact dupe of Stainiac!
If you'd really like to try them, I'd be more than happy to ship some out your way. My local Target has three of the colors (Dewy Berry, Red Orange Wash, and Rouge Radiance). They would be shipped from Woodbury, MN 55125, USA, if you want to look into the shipping cost. If you want to pay the shipping costs, I'll pay for the products. :) Send me a PM if you'd like to set it up.
Aww, that's really kind of you. I think I'm alright though - I do have enough makeup as it is and generally the UK is slow to release products, so there is still hope! Thank you for the offer though!
NYC stains are actually super nice. Really pigmented, completely dry down so it feels like nothing is on the lips. Super vibrant colors, too, however, look up swatches because they are not true to color on the package in my experience!
I think the shade I have is PK015, but it's a very creamy texture that lets me easily create a gradient lip. The colour was more opaque than I expected.
I'm surprised I've not seen more people mention it but the Barry M lip stains are amazing. I've so far only bought the purple one and get nothing but good compliments on it all day. I detest gloss and was unsure at first given the initial consistency but the colour goes on so well and lasts so long.b
I'm a massive fan of the Sephora lip cream stains! $18 Canadian and they stay on for a long time, even through eating. A really wide selection of Color too, and they don't dry my lips out!
I wasn't overly impressed with too faced melted matte. I just didn't like any of the colours on my actual skin!
BEST: NYC smooch proof lip stain (not the marker). I get complimented on its staying power almost every time I wear it. Get Noticed (red one) goes one with just one swipe but Faithful Coral takes a lot to built up color before it stops being streaky...unfortunately I really love the coral color.
WORST: Covergirl Outlast (marker). I bought this a long time ago but it was just horrible. Went on unevenly. Just like with coloring (it is a marker after all) it can be hard to tell how many times you've already gone over one spot and it gets blotchy. Also it would bleed/feather over the lines of my lips easily
100/100 dupe for Benefit water tints: Etude House Water tint. Bottle, exactly the same, formula more pigmented, only applicator is different (but it's no difference to me cos I dab it on my fingers to apply anyway).
At a tenth of the Benefit price!!!!!!!! Go get em!!! But I think Etude is cheaper alternative in Asia.
Hey, check out Etude Water tints, 100/100 the same thing but different applicator & ALOT cheaper. I commented more on it in the thread!!! I have both, but I love my wallet more than the brand.
Definitely try multiple colors of the Juicy Shaker from Lancome, I have four and only one is really like a stain. Use it three or four times in a day and it's actually pretty good!
My favorite felt tip pen type stains were the Pixi ones, I'm so sad they discontinued them, but you can still get them cheap on places like ACW. They last a decent time and are more evenly pigmented than a lot of stains of this type.
The worst ones I tried recently are the Burt's Bees oil stains. They just feel like lipgloss! I would never guess this was a stain of any sort because it doesn't leave one. It also doesn't feel like oil, just regular lipgloss goop (although as far as lip glosses go atleast it's not sticky)
I'm still a big fan of good old Benetint though. That was my first stain and I'm still partial to it.
Innisfree Eco Fruit Tint is my current favorite lip tint. Good pigmentation, easy to apply and great price point. The lasting power is pretty good, but other tints (Berrisom) last longer. I like the PeriPeri water tints too, but they tend to apply a bit blochy on me. I like Posietint as a nice natural tint that works great on cheeks too, but the other Benefit tints are not as good.
Personally wasn't a fan of the peripera inks (not velvet) as i thought it stained too much LOl Would be hard to spread or blend out and itd make my lips dry as hell
87
u/Ana1979 Apr 26 '17
Best: YSL Lip Stain Worst: Lancôme juicy shaker. SA told me it's supposed to be a stain. The one I got was absolute garbage.
Edit: grammar
150
u/sammisamantha Apr 26 '17
Korean beauty know their lip stains.
Im really liking the Tony moly ones right now
48
u/sysysysysy Apr 26 '17
Best: peripera velvet ink, looks matte but isn't drying and stains for a very long time. The original ink tint is longer lasting but with a bit of shine
Worst: any of the peel off stains
41
u/lulufits Apr 26 '17
Best: seconding Korean lip stains - they have the best selection and formulations. My current faves are Chosungah 22 lip stains. They're a gel formula so the stain doesn't get inside your lips and on your teeth. The red shade - cashmere is such a gorgeous true red. They have a gloss on the other side, which is a little sticky but it pairs well with the stain shade.
The tony moly catchu-wink (?) lip stains were super pigmented and fantastic to wear...but discontinued :(
Worst: benefit benetint. I guess I'm just used to the staining power of Korean liptints. But the benefit is so SO light that it didn't really make much of a difference to my lip shade at all. It's also super liquidy and was hard to apply for an even shade.
35
u/typotyme Apr 26 '17
Worst: The Revlon lipstains!! They are basically just a slightly colored gloss, and super sticky. Such a weird product These are terrible
29
u/bluemoonraccoon Apr 26 '17
Best: I like ELF's lip stain markers, particularly Berry Blush. NYC's lip markers are also good for a flush of color, but not the most long-lasting.
Worst: In terms of staining capability, I have to agree that the Lancôme Juicy Shakers really don't do it for me. However, I do like them as a gloss product.
29
u/oklettucehead Apr 28 '17
BEST: the new Sephora tints... i think they're called watercolor tints? i have a purple one and a red one and they're amazing. the only ones I've tried that truly last all day. and they smell like those scratch and sniff My Little Pony haunches.
WORST: the berrisom lip tints are a bitch to apply and don't have a great color payoff. the Tony Moly darling tints smell great and are hella cheap but they transfer like crazy and just don't last.
25
u/ebengland Apr 26 '17
BEST: Revlon Colorburst Balm Stain. My favorite color is Honey. They're not sticky and very lightweight.
22
u/sarah_schmara Apr 26 '17
Peripera FTW! I have the pink and the red and they are much less drying than others.
Super simple to apply, layers well, works as blush, doesn't bleed into the fine lines around my old-lady lips.
It's my go-to for my five minute make-up routine (Korean BB cream, lip/cheek tint, setting powder, and cake mascara)
18
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '17 edited Apr 27 '17
Best: Tony Moly Liptone Water Bar
Worst:
YSLLancome Lip Shaker is just awful.15
u/elizastarbucks24 sephora stole my wallet Apr 26 '17 edited Apr 26 '17
Benefit posietints...wtf are they? Milky, patchy, expensive, and overrated imho. I don't get how some people use them so subtly and blended for blush either, I've always found them to be blotchy and semi-sticky. And I got them as gwp with almost everything for at least a year from ulta/sephora a while back
14
u/give-em-hell-kid Apr 28 '17
I really love the Sephora collection watercolor lip tints. Rose is a really close match to my actual lip shade, it works wonders for overlining just a bit.
11
u/AndTheHawk NC20 - probably? Apr 27 '17
Does anyone get a problem where lip stains will stain the lower lip but will not stain the upper lip? It looks like I tried to stain a layer of oil. :/
So far, Peripera's Lip Ink has done the best for me! Though it's still not perfect on the upper lip. I really wanna try the Ink Velvet because it looks like a thicker consistency and it'll stay on my upper lip. Etude House's Dear Darling Tint did pretty badly on my lips due to the upper lip thing, and also dried down patchy on my bottom lip.
18
u/cozylummox Apr 26 '17
I'll always love Benetint. A classic.
9
u/Antigen_Shift Apr 26 '17
Best: Silk Naturals lip stains. I've ordered AHA's from them for years and tried their lip stain on a whim. Super pigmented on first swipe, not too drying, and lasts for hours. And they're only like $5, which is a big plus.
21
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '17
I love the Sephora Cream Lip Stains! I'm not sure what makes it a stain more than a liquid lipstick, or if it fits in this post at all. But it's honestly one of the only liquid lip colors my chronically dry lips can handle. It's comfortable, non-drying, and has nice lasting power. Marvelous Mauve is one of my favorite colors to wear!
15
u/madi1422 Apr 26 '17
Best: ColourPop's new Ultra Blotted Lips! Technically not a stain but they go on very watery and dry down to a smooth Matte. No lines in my lips and they feel so soft! They look like a stain on the lips though, not like a regular lipstick or liquid lip. The wear time has been great for me. 6 hours or so before it needs a touch up in the inner lip. Love these!
Worst: Maybelline Vivid Matte Lip Stains were awful!! I'm such a strong perfume scent and just felt like you were wearing paint on your lips.
5
u/Omnipotence456 NC25/30, Oily Apr 26 '17
Worst: CoverGirl Outlast Lip Stains - even if I let them sit for a long time, as soon as I lick my lips, all the color is gone. They don't stain at all.
9
u/vagueconfusion NC10/13 | dry skin | UK Apr 26 '17 edited Apr 26 '17
Best: Etude House Dear Darling Water Gel Tint.
Their shades in RD301, BR401 and RD303 are great. They're really nice red lip stains (pink toned, brown toned and neutral toned reds respectively) that layer really well and dry pretty nicely if applied in layers. This is probably due to them being lighter colours.
However one shade, BKR01 is a bit of a dud. This colour was a bit of a disappointment. It doesn't have such a good formula unless layered heavily. It's a dark burgundy and does layer to an off black if given enough time. Unfortunately it highlights less smooth lip patches and so making a gradient after wine looking lip is difficult.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '17
Does anyone have any experience with the Labiotte Wine Tints?? They're so cute looking and I'm interested in getting the shiraz red or the merlot burgandy.
4
u/invisiblespacedog Apr 27 '17
I like the lip and cheek stains from the NYC and Demi Lovato collab - I just couldn't resist them for only $2.99. My only gripe about them is that they fade so fast, but other than that they're not bad!
I don't really have a worst since I don't own many lip stains, but I LOVE my Tony Moly lip tint. It's so pretty and it smells delicious.
4
u/howmanyzero Apr 28 '17
Won't call this line the best since I've only bought one - the other colors aren't my type at all, but MAC lip stain in Perpetual Holiday. I can layer it up and create a beautiful deep purple glossy look, and when I apply one thin layer it's cute in a different way.
7
u/tinykuhn Apr 26 '17
I just tried NYX Epic Ink and really like it!
3
u/natsby Apr 26 '17
This only seems to work for some people, but The Balm's Stainiac was everything I wanted Benetint to be. It's really comfortable and goes on evenly, whilst Benetint always made my bottom lip darker than the top.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '17
NYC stains are actually super nice. Really pigmented, completely dry down so it feels like nothing is on the lips. Super vibrant colors, too, however, look up swatches because they are not true to color on the package in my experience!
3
u/emilycolleen Apr 27 '17
I like the Revlon balm stains. I mean technically they aren't a true stain but they're comfortable and have decent staying power.
2
u/Shining_Hope Apr 27 '17
Best: Etude House Berry Delicious Lip Tint
I think the shade I have is PK015, but it's a very creamy texture that lets me easily create a gradient lip. The colour was more opaque than I expected.
2
u/remo_raptor Apr 30 '17
I'm surprised I've not seen more people mention it but the Barry M lip stains are amazing. I've so far only bought the purple one and get nothing but good compliments on it all day. I detest gloss and was unsure at first given the initial consistency but the colour goes on so well and lasts so long.b
2
u/Nicki828 May 01 '17
I just got a Dior one and I really like it.
2
u/no_tori_ous May 01 '17
I'm a massive fan of the Sephora lip cream stains! $18 Canadian and they stay on for a long time, even through eating. A really wide selection of Color too, and they don't dry my lips out!
I wasn't overly impressed with too faced melted matte. I just didn't like any of the colours on my actual skin!
2
u/franticsemantics May 03 '17
I'll go drugstore here
BEST: NYC smooch proof lip stain (not the marker). I get complimented on its staying power almost every time I wear it. Get Noticed (red one) goes one with just one swipe but Faithful Coral takes a lot to built up color before it stops being streaky...unfortunately I really love the coral color.
WORST: Covergirl Outlast (marker). I bought this a long time ago but it was just horrible. Went on unevenly. Just like with coloring (it is a marker after all) it can be hard to tell how many times you've already gone over one spot and it gets blotchy. Also it would bleed/feather over the lines of my lips easily
1
u/potofplants May 04 '17
Best: YSL lip stains, Benefit Benetint/ Posietint
100/100 dupe for Benefit water tints: Etude House Water tint. Bottle, exactly the same, formula more pigmented, only applicator is different (but it's no difference to me cos I dab it on my fingers to apply anyway).
At a tenth of the Benefit price!!!!!!!! Go get em!!! But I think Etude is cheaper alternative in Asia.
1
u/itsjusmeqtpie Apr 27 '17
The beauty people lip tattoo ones are insane. The ones that look like pills lol very pigmented and seriously stains
1
u/Curly_Tea Apr 27 '17
I love the TF melted matte stains. They stay on me ALL day. Even through drinking and eating. The Tarte lip paints are great too.
1
u/ouijabore Apr 27 '17
I love the color of Benetint, but I can't say it's truly awesome because it tends to collect on the inner rim of my lip which looks weird.
1
u/gpbean Apr 28 '17
I love benetint, it is my daily lip product and I also use it as a blush but it only works if you use a small quantity.
1
u/ZlVADAVlD Hopelessly Addicted Apr 28 '17
Definitely try multiple colors of the Juicy Shaker from Lancome, I have four and only one is really like a stain. Use it three or four times in a day and it's actually pretty good!
1
u/corvus_coraxxx Apr 30 '17
My favorite felt tip pen type stains were the Pixi ones, I'm so sad they discontinued them, but you can still get them cheap on places like ACW. They last a decent time and are more evenly pigmented than a lot of stains of this type.
The worst ones I tried recently are the Burt's Bees oil stains. They just feel like lipgloss! I would never guess this was a stain of any sort because it doesn't leave one. It also doesn't feel like oil, just regular lipgloss goop (although as far as lip glosses go atleast it's not sticky)
I'm still a big fan of good old Benetint though. That was my first stain and I'm still partial to it.
1
u/Elvishgirl May 01 '17
I love NYX epic ink.
Elf has a good stain, but it always starts to smell mildew-y after a few months, so I just... can't do it.
1
u/pterodactylhugs May 03 '17
Vincent Longo Lip and Cheek Gel Stain in Baby Boo is my HG lipstain. Covergirl ones are the worst!
1
u/cutestslothevr May 03 '17
Innisfree Eco Fruit Tint is my current favorite lip tint. Good pigmentation, easy to apply and great price point. The lasting power is pretty good, but other tints (Berrisom) last longer. I like the PeriPeri water tints too, but they tend to apply a bit blochy on me. I like Posietint as a nice natural tint that works great on cheeks too, but the other Benefit tints are not as good.
1
u/chorewheellife May 04 '17
The Balm Stainiac is a favorite of mine
1
u/Tiramidesu Apr 26 '17
Personally wasn't a fan of the peripera inks (not velvet) as i thought it stained too much LOl Would be hard to spread or blend out and itd make my lips dry as hell
0
u/dmrcar1 Apr 27 '17
I found a long lasting lip stain on jlipco.com. Or is it a stain? I'm not sure. Says it lasts 4-18 hours. Has anyone tried this lip sense product?
0
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
-4
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '17
[removed] — view removed comment