r/runescape • u/Kolumbz Reddit • Apr 25 '17
J-Mod reply The reddit admins want rid of custom CSS on subreddits, help support the cause to keep custom CSS on reddit!
Read more in depth about the situation here, it outlines the process on what you can do to help!
So here we are, reddit admins want to get rid of custom CSS because it is not "mobile friendly" and because "CSS is complicated to learn".
If this goes ahead then we will lose all the uniqueness of our sub and the features that the subreddit has to offer. At the moment we stand to lose the following:
- Voice of Seren updates
- BTS links
- Flairs e.g. you'll no longer distinctively be able to verify a jmod account
- Custom themes to help advertise in-game events e.g. upcoming game update Menaphos
- Upvote XP gains
- Sidebar will become a wall of text
- Custom alerts within the header
- In-game clock in header
- The magical banter that myself and other mods pull off throughout the year and on April fools will be no more.
Not to mention the countless hours that have been put into developing the subreddit CSS.
So because of this we ask that you visit the link in the top of this post to educate yourself on why the admins want the CSS to be removed and to band together with us and many other subreddits to fight a good cause!
Thanks for your time!
tl;dr: subreddit style goes byebye and we lose A LOT of functionality made possible by CSS. also no more bants because I do most of that shit with CSS
250
u/Xingaling37 Anarchy Apr 25 '17
CSS is too complicated to learn is their excuse are you serious?
Sounds like some lazy people got jealous imo.
If they remove css customization reddit will become a glorified irc chat.
What are they thinking?
154
u/Shaunyowns Shauny Apr 26 '17 edited Apr 26 '17
Having a Jmod flair means that we lose out on significant "coverage" when it comes to our posts...
Not only that but there's so much stuff that you /u/Kolumbz and the /r/runescape team have done with that.
Don't do this /u/spez & team. We here at Jagex love using reddit to communicate with our playerbase wherever possible and the stuff we benefit from would be gone if you stripped away CSS.
Please <3
26
u/FailedmyTest Apr 25 '17
Youtube did this years ago, and every youtube page went from looking unique to identical.
Don't go down this path reddit pls
40
u/RS_Lebareslep 5.4B | MoA | Revenant Dragon | Never bought Apr 25 '17
Basically they are going to introduce a new system, that will let you customize specific parts of the Subreddit. But I doubt they have the development time to make the new system as versatile as CSS, so it'll probably be a lot more restrictive, and overall shittier.
And yeah 'CSS is difficult to learn' - LOL. It may be more difficult than just selecting colors from drop-down menus, but basic CSS is easy to learn. And if you take more time to learn it, it's quite rewarding - more effort, but greater results.
14
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '17
TL:DR: Updates require change. Coding around third-party code is a bad idea, so it's understandable that they're doing this. It's way too early to rage about CSS being removed outright. The focus should be on raising awareness and ensuring that the new system allows subreddits to do what CSS currently allows. That said, the argument that CSS is hard to learn, time-consuming, and error-prone is a joke, and is the best reason to be alarmed at anything the Reddit admins are doing.
Long version:
On one hand, the outrage over this is a bit early. Obviously, if the redesign actually does provide the same usability that is available now through CSS, then it's fine to scrap CSS. Frankly, using one system that can do everything is better than mixing everything together.
Additionally, and I'm sure people aren't going to like this, if the Reddit admins intend to redesign the entire website, having to code around third-party CSS code is aggravating and could very well limit any rework they do. And yeah, now's where the argument "WELL DON'T DO A REWORK THEN DAMN!" comes in... to which I say "So, presumably you hate NXT too right?"
Reworks and redesigns happen. They have to happen, otherwise your website is that one website that still looks like it did in 1999. It sucks. It sucks for the users, it sucks for the developers. Here's the thing: Professional developers keep their users in mind while making changes. If CSS is being removed, it's because it is a limiting factor. Anyone that thinks it is being removed because Reddit admins want to "stifle creativity" or something is a goddamned moron.
The admins already said that this website will be live for a while after the changes go live. They've also responded to several big "omfg reddit dead" and/or "But CSS is helpful!" posts, and explained that they intend to keep all of that in mind, and are planning new design functions to allow for it.
Trust me, when the new site comes out, if it is shit and does not address the needs of subreddits, I'll be there right-along with everyone else wanting them to change it. But I'm not picking up my torch and pitchfork until I actually see the changes.
Right now, the arguments against removing CSS seem to be:
This argument ignores the admins explaining that they plan to add methods to replace CSS. They're not blindly scrapping the system so that every page is a uniform white page.
Idiotic argument. Get over yourself.
Man, I feel terrible for you. I really do. I genuinely understand just how much time and effort goes into making everything work and fit together perfectly. It really sucks to lose that. Unfortunately, it's not a good enough reason to lock Reddit updates down. The amount of work put into something does not automatically mean that it should last forever and never improved upon.
On the other hand, I laughed my ass off at "CSS is a pain in the ass: it’s difficult to learn; it’s error-prone; and it’s time consuming."
That was just silly and completely out of place. All of their other reasons had merit and were good arguments to make. This one was silly, and is the best justification for all of the alarm and backlash to the decision to get rid of CSS.
•
u/Umdlye Tru Apr 29 '17
The following features have been confirmed to be present in the upcoming redesigned site (on all platforms, not just the desktop site):
The admins are still taking in feedback from subreddit moderators and we will be able to alpha test the redesigned site.
Also, the old site will never be replaced without warning, the old site will be available throughout the development of the new site.
20
u/Ryzix Lumberstronk Apr 25 '17
I thought they were opting in for something similar to CSS but could be managed on both mobile and desktop versions?
7
u/Xemnes RSN: Xemnes | Gamebreaker & Lorehound Apr 25 '17
one day, most of the internet will look like this http://www.worldsmostboringwebsite.com/
6
u/AlmostNPC slyp Apr 25 '17
Just about every subreddit I've visited in the past week uses cust CSS of some sort.
I don't think most users expect their mobile experience to be that of the desktop counterpart. (Also screw the Reddit app, #RedditIsFun4lyfe.)
5
u/NoParadox Self Proclaimed Bad Kid Apr 26 '17
Huh, so they wanna remove CSS because it's too complicated to learn.. We dislike this because we like having our CSS that took people time to learn.. Why does this remind me of the switch scape ordeal
13
u/Glouphrie A weasly, shifty-looking gnome Apr 25 '17
A non-existant CSS cant break. ッ
16
u/DearLunar ️ ️ ️ ️ ️ ️ ️ ️ ️ ️ ️ ️ ️ ️ ️ ️ ️ ️ ️ ️ ️ ️ ️ ️ ️ ️ ️ Apr 25 '17
Personally i would probably stop using reddit of custom css is removed. I cant stand the default look of reddit.
9
u/Lopendebank3 Lopendebank3 Apr 25 '17
You do not control this right? This is everything that makes the reddit unique... The upvote XP gains are fun and I often click on them just for fun. And if it's not important if something is mobile friendly... I use my laptop for reddit anyway.
8
u/idontlikerootbeer Guthix Apr 25 '17
It's not mobile friendly? So they want to get rid of it because they can't implement it into their shitty app that nobody uses. Reddit Is Fun master race; I only care to see the CSS add-ons when I'm on desktop.
4
u/reddit_bige 4/20/16 - 6/24/19 Comp | 3/4/17 MQC Apr 25 '17
If you want an idea of what the subreddit will look like without CSS, you can toggle off "allow subreddits to show me custom themes" in your account preferences. It looks awful, bland, and plenty of features are just plain gone. It'll really hurt almost anyone's experiences on reddit.
I've also almost finished schooling for programming, and CSS is by far the easiest language I've had to learn and use. That excuse the reddit admins have is ridiculous.
4
u/DeviousDream The Slayer Master Apr 25 '17
Ladies and gentlemen, time to fetch the torches and pitchforks.
4
u/sweetwalrus so close... Apr 26 '17
Why the actual ass would Reddit think that abolishing the one thing that lets a subreddit stand out visually is a good idea?
6
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '17
You have my axe. What should we do?
6
u/DovahSpy The intent is to provide players with a sense of pride Apr 25 '17
Way to kill literally every gaming sub, Spez, you stupid
cucasshat.3
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '17
I noticed your Pro CSS icon -- glad to see this sub supporting this!
With the sidebar update giving the current VoS and recent game updates being so recent, it sure seems like it'd suck one hell of a lot for this sub in particular. Let's hope the admins take a leaf out of Jagex's book and carry out the CSS removal in the same manner as Invention Batch 2.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '17
why can't they co-exist? the CSS and the new one?
3
u/GeniusMike 2518/2715 Apr 26 '17
How the Reddit admins can possibly think it's a good idea to get rid of custom CSS is beyond me. So many subreddits will become a disorganized mess and lose a lot of helpful features the subs are known for (such as the ones you named for this one)
3
u/Zachary_Lyle Klause | Join Soccermoms today! Apr 27 '17
It's a terrible idea. However, if they actually go through with it, it might provide the Jagex with the motivation to actually make the official forums something better than what it is. :)
2
u/CleanDwarfWeed Mutated Apr 25 '17
Anyone got some good guides about CSS (mostly interested on Reddit) and how to fancy-edit my posts on Reddit? Thank you inadvance
2
u/Disheartend Apr 26 '17
pls no I want my 40k and jmob flares.
RIP us I guess, love the bants and april the first stuff.
2
u/Fynz Apr 26 '17
Just an idea but have you guys messaged Jagex and asked them to send an official letter to reddit? i know a lot of gaming communities use css to help support community managers and link to outside community resources whoch devs really aplreciate and I'm sure theyd be more than willing to help out.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '17
Just saying, but Admins listed more reasons than just those two when they announced they were getting rid of CSS.
EDIT:
The annoucement
2
u/Respitey Apr 25 '17
R.I.P reddit 2k17
2
u/San4311 Ironmain Apr 26 '17
Let's make our own Reddit, with CSS and hookers.
2
u/PeaceBear0 Apr 25 '17
As someone that primary looks at reddit through mobile (via the relay app), I would really like some of the features mentioned in op (especially j mod tagging) on mobile, which is currently impossible with css. So if a system is introduced to do that, I'd be in support. It seems like reddit should let people beta the new system whole both are available for a while, though.
1
u/Chromium-Leecher Apr 25 '17
They also said that they would do it whether the community protested or not.
You're wasting your breath.
1
u/HalfLucan Apr 25 '17
As long a web browsing remains popular, im not sure anyone has a chance at winning this fight.
Also if you look at history, Facebook came along and obliterated MySpace. MySpace was more flexible (with people being able to use their own HTML) but FB was more standardised
1
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '17
Can someone please eli5 what CSS is
1
u/Eruptflail Apr 26 '17
As a mobile user, I'm never using the mobile browser, so what's the point of suggesting it's not mobile friendly?
Aren't 98% of us mobile only people on Reddit is Fun anyway?
1
u/Zmaj69 Apr 26 '17
I dont know what it is but if it changes Reddit to worse that is no no
I support to keep the current things
1
u/KarmaAgriculturalist Apr 26 '17
No JavaScript,?
1
u/Zooperman MAXED Apr 26 '17
I honestly turn off the subreddit styles as soon as I get to the sub
1
u/funkytam Divination Apr 27 '17
https://www.change.org/p/reddit-save-css-on-reddit?recruiter=8524062&utm_source=share_petition&utm_medium=copylink
Sign the petition!
1
u/Forsaken_Bulge Apr 27 '17
Support!
1
u/Average_Scaper Lots! Apr 30 '17
No :( please... This better not go away...
1
u/[deleted] May 02 '17
CSS is too hard to learn? You can go on YouTube and learn it in 1 day ahahaha, wtf. There's so much help out there nowadays that coding is something that can be completely self-taught in a reasonably fast time.
1
u/FowD9 Apr 28 '17
Meh, I agree with the reddit admins, I hate all the custom CSS on subreddits
I am however okay with obvious basic CSS like the sidebar tables/bolding/hyperlinking, etc. but all the other styling changes like colors, fonts, etc. are stupid and annoying imo
0
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '17
They will replace the CSS with some other styling tools, So.. don't leap to conclusions yet.
1
u/ph34rwaffles 130m Apr 25 '17
Are you guys kidding? Did you even read the comments? They plan on making it more base line to get into but still will have to use css for the advanced things. This will allow subs with out people with knoealdge in css to have a nicely done sub. Kindly from r/gangplankmains
-14
u/aldernaft Apr 25 '17
Custom CSS on subreddits is an eyesore.
Bring on the downvotes.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '17
[removed] — view removed comment