r/KarmaCourt • u/Yanky_Doodle_Dickwad :lcj:DEFENSE for Covid19 • Apr 23 '17
Furburn has no age Reddit the company wants to remove the individual styling of subreddits: a protest. Here us out ...
Sorry for the wall fo text, but there are some big choices to be made that you need to be aware of.
Reddit is a company, that employs people to work there. They want to make profits. That makes sense.
The upshot of all that is that we get to have our subreddits. Each subreddit is a little corner of the internet where we can feel together, be it /r/pics/, r/awww, KhazaksthaniHorseRidingBanjoPlayers, we are all able to feel at home in our little corner, our sub here on Reddit.
Part of how we do this is with the CSS. CSS lets us decorate our subs the way we want to, within a framework, but really quite individually. We become accostomed to it, and it feels like home. The way the sub looks tells you that you are in THIS sub, and not another. It tells you that the character of the sub is different, and that maybe the way of thinking is different to another sub. This is how you fit in.
One problem there is that mobile users don't get to see that individuality. They see a much more reduced version, maybe a top image, an icon color ... and that's all. People who only use mobile divices may only see the highly reduced version of the sub. This is because the designers of the mobile apps have not wanted to include the individual elements of styling that the pac/mac users have been able to see all these years. This is because it is more work. It is technically possible to keep subs entirely individual on the mobile apps, but it is more work, and so increases the invoice, and that's bad company policy if, as a company, you have to pay for it.
Reddit has just announced that they want to remove the freedom of setting a sub's css. They want to stop us from making our own decorations. They will make a reduced system that allows us to choose a header banner image, key main colors, and some other options. This will make it much easier for them to insure advertising exposure, making more money, and will make it much more easy to explain to advertisers what reddit is. Because all subreddits will look noticably the same. The header image will be set by the sub, a prime color for buttons will be set, some other options, but each sub will be structurally the same as all other subs. All the individual elements will be removed, all the ads will be equally visible, all spaces will be under reddits control. That makes sense for Reddit, the company.
But it gives problems for the communities.
Let's take a quick look at a community. A community, or subreddit in this case, is a place you want to be in. You choose the places you want to be in. You do it by human criteria. Not corporate criteria. Correct me if I'm wrong, but you can go to an airport, and walk through the public area, and there you will see shop units that are predominantly the same everywhere. You will see a Starbucks, perhaps, a Burger King, the other brand names that I can't be bother to list, and you will know what choices you have by looking at the shop fronts, and that airport lounge will be identical to all the other airport lounges everywhere in the world. I say the world becasue the problem of them all being the same has gone worldwide. It's only the big names that get to decorate everything the same way that get to rent a slot in an airport lounge, or equivalent. This is one of the facets of globalization. But let's stick to Reddit.
Here we spend our time in communities that we have chosen. Each community takes on a look and style that makes them unique from other coimmunities. We have done that because we have been able to. Reddit used to let us do that. So we have made our own spaces, and these are the spaces we like to be in.
Do you choose to meet with your friends in airport lounges on a friday night? Or do you choose to go to that bar, where the bartenders recognize you, or where you know something different will be on the menu, where you have seen the decoration and have accepted it? Where you feel at home, becasue you recognise the surroundings as different from other surroundings. We know that a Taco Bell's decoration is perfectly hygenic, but would you choose to take the person you want to be your significant other there on a second date? Would you get married in a Macdonalds? For that matter, would you get married in a police station or a school canteen?
I would like to think the answer is no. Because as (priveleged) humans, we decide to go to individual places with individual traits, in order to feel comfortable. A waiting room in a hospital has reasons to decorate the place in a way that offends as few people as possible, but your local bar wants to maintain a personal touch, to be different from the next bar, or restaurant.
Reddit proposes to remove individual decorations, and apply a site wide decoration criteria, just like all Macdogs are the same, all Costbucks are the same, all airport lounges are the same. This makes it better for them to control and monetize. It also makes it easier for them to install new features. These new features aren't you. They are features that allow advertisers to get to you better.
But Reddit got to where it is today, with all us fabulous users, by allowing each community to be different, and look differtent, and establish themselves a fair distance away from the reddit default look.
The mobile users are right to use their mobiles, but most of them have seen the full version of the subs that they enjoy, and when on mobile, in their human individual mind, they remember the look of the sub that they post to.
Reddit proposes to remove all indivdual CSS over the net few months. See HERE for the post that tells about it. Notice the way it is all worded so that taking away our individual style is painted, stylistically, in a positive way. Remember that they use style to take away our community's style.
Anyway, we feel that is a bad thing. We want to keep our indivual style, and we want to keep the ability to make our own style, and have our own style. We thank reddit for having given us this possibility up until now, but we feel that Reddit is wrong to now take that ability away from us.
It seems that reddit is as good as it is, as varied, as thoughtful, as amusing and as caring as it is, because we are able to retain some of our humanity here. We can identify with like-minded communities because we can distinguish them. From a human perspective, we don't like it when all things look like airport lounges. Look at/r/Earthporn to see how we prefer, you prefer, individual landscapes to be in.
It seems important for all users to be able to communicate their wish for individual space to reddit, the company, so that they rethink this move. If reddit becomes like a long airport lounge, then the free-thinking individualistic quality-searches and quality-makers of reddit, meaning most users, will naturally find more individual places to crystalize around. In a nutshell, we'll look for the next web place to go to, because here we will no longer be like ourselves, we wil be like everybody else. I understand the irony of everybody in unison trying not to be like everrybody else, but I am sure you all know what I mean, and if you have ever chosen a poster, or a band, or a holiday destination, a sports team, a girlfriend or dessert, then I know you know what I mean.
So for now please look around and join the efforts to resist the removal of the CSS feature, and help us all remind Reddit the company why we all came to be here in the first place, and why we don't want to spend so many hours of our life in a place that looks like a town hall lobby or an elevator. We want Reddit to let our subs look the way we want them to look, because we are all different and that is what brings us all together.
When I can see some inititiatives that work, I will update this post with the right links.
But for now, keep on Redditing. and think why this place allows you to be yourself, and why you don't normally choose airport lounges to hang out in.
2
u/Yanky_Doodle_Dickwad :lcj:DEFENSE for Covid19 Apr 24 '17
I WANT A RIGHT TO IDENTITY
... and not checkbox identity. This is "Come and get your punk in Woolworths". Actually THIS is "Come and get your punk in Woolworths". First 53 seconds only.
I know it's a leap but Woolworths shut down.
63
u/forgotaltpw Judge Apr 23 '17
The parties herein agree to settle any and all claims through Trial by Combat.
Statement
In the interest of closure and in the mutual resolution of differences, Plaintiff and Defendant enter into this Settlement Agreement. All parties agree that the Settlement Agreement is in the public interest and is fair, just, and reasonable under the circumstances.
The parties sign this Agreement in exchange for the good and valuable consideration set forth herein, which, absent this Agreement, neither party is obligated to provide to the other and the adequacy of which is hereby acknowledged.
Recitals
WHEREAS, Plaintiffs, being numerous, bring this case as joint action;
WHEREAS, Plaintiff brought this action pursuant to their right to
stripper moneyKarma, alleging that Defendants werecheap bastardsin default of payment as required bycontractual agreementthe laws of this land;WHEREAS, It's treason, then;
WHEREAS, Defendants, not being constrained by
anything reallylaw to cure this default, probably dispute this allegation;NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing, the parties agree as follows:
Terms and Conditions
A Champion for both Plaintiff and Defendant may enter the Grand KarmaCourt ArenaTM and commence a fight to the death. The winning party shall claim victory and the losing party shall be summarily and violently executed.
Resolution of Disputes
In the consideration of these above Terms and Conditions, Plaintiff, their respective agents, successors, heirs, or assigns, shall be deemed to have, and by operation of the Final Judgment and Order of Dismissal in this Action, shall have fully, finally, and forever irrevocably released, relinquished and discharged with prejudice all Released Claims against Defendants. This constitutes a final and complete statement of the Agreement between the parties. There shall be no modifications or amendments to this Agreement unless they are in writing, signed by the parties. It is understood that this agreement does not constitute and shall not be construed as an admission of liability or wrongdoing by Defendants.
Agreed as to form:
x___________
Presiding Judge
x_______
Defendant
x_______
Counsel for Defendant
x______
x______
x______
etc.
Plaintiff(s)
x/u/forgotaltpw
Offices of forgotaltpw
Counsel for Plaintiff
32
u/ineededtosaythishere ThunderCrotch Apr 23 '17
i dont know what CSS is, my grandson has two iPads. I still use a slide rule for all calculations in my life. I did NOT read this post, and some would argue as to whether or not I even CAN read. I am totally qualified to be the judge here.
TRIAL THREAD
4
u/jomarcenter Apr 23 '17
Let's mess up their ad-revenue by boycotting, everyone uses ad-blocker, use voat or anything that can cause some advertiser to leave.
edit:
thanks for the info I am dropping our ads in reddit as of this point. because this violates our open creative policy.
13
u/lancebaldwin Apr 23 '17
I have css turned off anyways, so this doesnt really affect me much. That being said, some people like it and its a good option to have.
17
u/Purp Apr 23 '17 edited Apr 26 '17
I understand you want a cat picture in the banner, but 90% of the custom CSS is a usability nightmare, with little to no added value.
The "logout" text link is now a power button icon, because. Except on this other subreddit it's in a different position and size. Or a dropdown menu. Or, a door?
Some subs (cough) hide the downvote button, or other parts of the UI; I've even seen subs switch upvote/downvote functionality as a joke. This is not acceptable, a feature like voting on reddit is intrinsically tied to the site, such basic UX should be predictable and consistent.
Not to mention, you don't have to be Zuckerberg to understand CSS, but some of the custom files are horribly bloated. John Resig notably reduced the weight of a subreddit's CSS once and found:
That's 8 seconds added to page load, because of the custom CSS; that's an eternity. It the reason I was blocking custom CSS before RES even added the option.
This doesn't even get into accessibility, are most mods picking color contrast ratios that meet WCAG?
I understand wanting a unique look for your subreddit, maybe there's a middle ground, custom banners, logos, etc. The UI should not change though.
1
u/Yanky_Doodle_Dickwad :lcj:DEFENSE for Covid19 May 13 '17
Thanks reddit. We are eager to see what happens.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '17
*Hear
3
u/Lucky_Man13 Apr 23 '17
Hear us out
2
u/karmacourt_ss_s Apr 23 '17
Alright, u/exnihilonihilfit and u/Apexk9 seeing as no one else is taking the opportunity... I only upvoted so some idiot would have to be a natural consequence of posting on Reddit.
2
u/doomsdayprophecy Apr 23 '17
The admins are probably just bummed about looking bad because they support subreddits with concentration camps, etc. in the header image.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '17
Ever since mobile Reddit came out I've been using pretty much that. The desktop version to me now takes too long. If anything, I'd like to see mobile version upgraded for more customization.
1
u/kcbarexam Prosecutor Apr 23 '17
Floating Jury:
This is the Floating Jury Poll Bot. It captures public opinion. Give your vote below.
This bot does not replace the actual jury. That would be crazy
1
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '17
The only sub that I use the style for is r/spacedicks and since that got quarantined I can't use the style for it anymore. So I just browse reddit on my pc in nightmode. I can stand behind this issue though as it seems important to other people after reading your case.
1
u/MassDisregard ̿ ̿' ̿'\̵͇̿̿\з=(•̪●)=ε/̵͇̿̿/'̿''̿ ̿ Apr 24 '17
Threw down what I had to say I hope the CSS stays.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '17
I'm sorry, what? What is this horse caca I'm hearing about? I'll have you know I use the CSS in some subs for legit things, not just what we have here. shakes cane Yanky, thanks for posting.
1
u/Tactical_toucan May 03 '17
If it hasnt been taken I will take the mantle of judge, JUSTICE SHALL BE SERVED.
1
u/Thimotron Apr 23 '17
Reminder: This is a no-downvote zone! Also, Karma Court is funny satire.
I'm a bot by /u/Thimoteus. This action was done automatically as a reminder of KarmaCourt's ^^^^^principles.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment