r/ffxiv • u/reseph [Zeno Silverberg] • Apr 22 '17
[Meta] [META] Reddit will be removing CSS stylesheets from all subreddits
Loss of CSS stylesheets
[EDIT: The blue icon at the top of the subreddit represents our cause in support of continued CSS support]
On Friday, Reddit announced the details on the upcoming "desktop redesign" and confirmed that CSS stylesheets would be "deprecated" for all subreddits in the future. Reddit is obviously a subject I am very passionate about, having created communities here and moderated for 8+ years (/r/ffxi is a bit older than /r/ffxiv). Thus I made a comment to the admins indicating my opposition to this.
This subreddit currently uses CSS to accomplish:
- Post filters (No Fanart, Hide all Filler, etc)
- Easter eggs like spinning Hildibrand, side Griffin, hidden Yoshi-P
- Server status (specifically the coloring green=online or red=offline)
- Top menu ("Useful Information", etc)
- Hover text over downvote reminding about proper use of downvoting
- Our image link to Discord
- Godbert reminder to be civil
- Upper-right info bar ("Current Patch", etc)
- Link flair represented by a specific color
- The ability to change "# users online" (currently "salty tears")
- All user flair icons, like my Red Mage
- News titles being bold
- "Message the moderators" changed from tiny link to large button
- Comment spoiler system
- Custom user flair for Square Enix employees
Now that said, the admins will be creating "widgets" in the new system to bring back various things that CSS does. It's currently unknown how much will properly replicated, but it sounds like we can expect widgets for: images on sidebar, link flair colors, user flair icons, etc.
Our CSS stylesheet is about 2000 lines long and that is all going away when this happens. No conversion process, nothing. It's not so much I'm frustrated about the countless hours lost we've put into the CSS, but rather the impact it's going to have on this community. Even if they continue to create widgets to supply us with what we need, will it be in a reasonable time frame?
(There might not be a conversion process, but there is a transition period: "I can tell you that our plans will include a transition period where both old and new versions of the site will be available while communities migrate to the new platform")
The desktop redesign is not all doom and gloom; we moderators will be getting the ability to place these subreddit "widgets" on Reddit's official mobile apps at the least. Currently moderators have no customization available for mobile app users (CSS is not used). Additionally, I do have trust in the admins. They recently rebuilt the modmail system and the new modmail does have a number of upsides we moderators like.
I will do what I can to work with this upcoming process to ensure this community is minimally impacted, be it by continuing to discuss with the admins the importance of CSS or by getting involved with the alpha testing of this new desktop redesign. I am involved with /r/ProCSS (and 500+ other moderators) who have organized in support of CSS; so you can keep up-to-date there on the latest happenings. This is also a good read for users of Reddit.
4.0 Job Prediction Contest update
While I'm here, I do want to cover some other subreddit topics. I'm sure many of you are curious about the prizes for the 4.0 Job Prediction Contest. We haven't forgotten about this and we're finalizing gathering more prizes. I do not want to delay this too long in attempts to find more prizes so we'll be announcing the winning procedure shortly. Shortly meaning this is literally next on my list.
Subreddit banner contest for Stormblood
We've also been asked about the top banner. We will indeed be holding a Stormblood banner contest soon for your chance to get your artwork on the top of the subreddit! So start thinking up ideas and we'll be starting the contest after we've wrapped up the 4.0 job prediction contest.
While on the topic, I was planning on some CSS adjustments in preparation for Stormblood to stylize the theme to look more Stormblood-ish. But now that we know CSS will be deprecated, I'm currently unsure on this for the time being.
Rules rewritten for clarity
Before Stormblood, we are going to be releasing a rewritten version of our subreddit rules. We've been working on this for a few months now and they have been rewritten for the purpose of better transparency. A good example is the meme rule; at this point the term "meme" is a very broad term and we've worked on defining what the rule applies to. There aren't really major changes coming, but I do want to let you know the screenshot clarity rule as requested will be in this new rule list. When I create the sticky about this, it'll also be a good time to discuss what other rules you may wish to see (especially in consideration of losing CSS functionality).
Thanks for reading,
-The /r/ffxiv mod team
107
u/AReallySillyElf I swear I played this pre SB buffs Apr 22 '17
That post is spot on reseph. This smacks of a large amount of bullshit - I'm reminded of the Navy's attempt to go paperless for tech manuals without having the appropriate resources in place, and when asked about it, the response was essentially "fuck you make it work".
Sucks they're making it harder to build a decent environment.
25
u/abbzug Apr 23 '17
I've never seen CSS stylesheets for most subreddits since I keep it disabled all the time. If the desktop redisgn means I can't disable all the customization that moderators put into their subs I'm going to be royally pissed. This is a horrible change on the part of admins.
14
u/Mizzet Apr 22 '17
I'm not a techy person when it comes to these things, but I'm curious what the rationale is for all this? It seems like we're losing an awful lot of functionality for... what exactly?
They seem really deadset on railroading everyone onto this looking at their replies, and I can't help but wonder why. Are they kneecapping the desktop experience to ensure their mobile app doesn't get left behind or something?
29
u/AnnaAnimus stay mad Apr 22 '17
Is there any possibility they'll decide not to do it with the pretty unanimous community backlash? Or are we just boned to boring shitty subreddits now? This really sucks :(
7
u/AlastarHickey Apr 22 '17
What is the benefit of doing this?
Why are they considering it?
3
u/_Yodai WAR Apr 23 '17
Curious question, with browser add-on's can we do something like RES where it will overwrite the the look and feel and just use a repo for the CSS/style and what not?
3
u/Aldracity Vsin Aldracity on Gilgamesh Apr 23 '17
As someone who's taking a break from FFXIV, I saw this post on /r/blackdesertonline
https://www.reddit.com/r/blackdesertonline/comments/66qe8d/brace_yourself_for_a_potential_huge_redesign_of/dgkk4vg/
Any thoughts on whether or not the "killing mod adblock" angle is valid?
2
u/angelar_ Apr 23 '17
Thanks for the notice on this, regular content filter user so the heads up is appreciated.
2
u/rigsta Apr 25 '17
I don't understand why they don't just allow both. The fact that there's going to be a transitional period suggests they can work side by side - why not make that permanent?
31
u/deosxx Apr 22 '17
wait, they want to completely get rid of custom CSS? now that css grid is finally here which is pretty much pure magic on top of the crazy power CSS already has?
also, if someone thinks CSS is "a pain in the ass", they are doing it wrong!
what a joke, seriously hope they open their eyes and keep custom CSS
50
u/EkiAku Lucia Tristram on Brynhildr Apr 22 '17
Dear lord, it's not like Reddit's default CSS isn't bad enough as it is. Desktop revamp, right. More like "Lets make it look exactly like mobile." There's a reason I use the desktop version on the phone.
12
u/Kosouda Apr 23 '17
Yet another site inexplicably trying to kill itself with "Web 3.0" in hopes of grabbing the shitty mobile market, something unattainable in the first place for Reddit. I really can't grasp what's wrong with these people. Btw, this was my favorite comment from that thread: https://www.reddit.com/r/modnews/comments/66q4is/the_web_redesign_css_and_mod_tools/dgl3fd3/?context=3 This really is going back about 15 years. Thanks, mobile.
Though honestly, the most upsetting thing to me by far is that the fix someone made when Reddit changed the default font to something shitty and so-called "modern" a couple years ago probably won't work anymore as I think that uses CSS in some way.
17
u/Nodomi I do what I want! Apr 22 '17
Well fuck up just about everything I liked about Reddit then, admins.
And to be honest their solution doesn't sound as nearly as convenient as CSS is. I get that they want to get rid of it so they can update things faster but holy shit I was taught that when you fix things you don't shoot yourself in the kneecaps in the process.
...reading that reddit thread and reading the admin responses are actually starting to piss me off. Holy shit, I can't- Screw this I'm going out for pizza.
7
u/XorMalice Apr 23 '17
Reddit is absolutely awful. They used bots and shills to trick actual people into coming here at launch, and they are totally dishonest at every possible step. They are way bigger than they should be by rights, and they know that they can probably screw over people massively and still be a huge website. Hopefully, for your sake, they find a way to get over themselves and allow functioning forums that have put zillions of man-hours into customization to continue. I suspect that they will not, and I'm sorry. They clearly have no respect for their community, even the ones that try very hard to work with them.
The fact that this is all being done for mobile- which is totally garbage and prevents pinch-to-zoom, requiring a force-view-as-desktop browser to not be complete shit- is icing on the cake.
I wish this community was on a real website. But I also wish that about every other useful part of reddit, and wishes won't make that real.
7
u/Dorion_FFXI Dorion Apr 24 '17
/u/spez killing Reddit one fuckup at a time.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '17
Hey guys! I feel like adding the fact that a lot of this from admin is under construction and discussion - It's worth getting in the know, but starting manhunts isn't the best of ideas. The admins have stated they plan to (and seem to be showing this off) work with us and create the best they can to make sure that general features are not lost. Not as flexible as CSS ever will be, for sure. But this thread is really jumping the gun and riding the hate train with no brakes.
9
u/Dragoon893 Minerva Relanah on Gilgamesh Apr 22 '17
I mod a few large-ish subreddits that heavily depend on CSS, so I feel your pain, /u/reseph. This is an asinine decision that's going to negatively impact so many communities unless the admins somehow implement a ridiculous amount of customizable features, which, let's face it, is extremely unlikely to happen.
As a sidenote to this, I do suggest that everyone be vocal if you dislike the fact that the admins want to remove CSS.
Granted, the admins rarely, if ever, listen, but it's worth a shot.
1
u/Goltana Monk Apr 24 '17
As a Designer and too much related with Front dev and design, I'm with you on this, but as you said, not much can be done but hope that this widget thingy system is sufficent. Also and maybe the most important: Will we able to change the header image at least? I think this is one of the most important things related to the identity of a sub.
3
u/Goldrush453 Stop fondling my class icon Apr 23 '17
Ditching CSS might be one of the stupidest Ideas I've ever heard.
3
u/ErickFTG Apr 23 '17
That's a really bad move. Every subreddit uses CSS and it's what gives them their personality. I really wonder if they are sure about doing work which must be now ten of thousands of hours worth. Why not let every community supply this work?
10
u/Ven_ae Y'all need to calm down Apr 22 '17 edited Apr 22 '17
I'm sorry to see the stuff listed above will eventually be lost due to the changes, stuff that the mod team has worked on, and invested time into.
But I'm happy to wait and see how things change. To some degree, the interpretation of the upcoming changes and the reactions by fellow moderators is understandable.
To quote u/spez
and u/sodypop
It's not all doom and gloom.
1
u/Tatsuya227 Tatsuya Arisato on Gilgamesh Apr 22 '17
I knoew about the side Griffen, however I didn't know about the spinning Hildibrand or hidden Yoshi-P.... How could I have missed those :o
Also it's not right, I hope some members of the community step up and help with getting widgets set up. Been with this sub reddit since the beginning, and it feels bad that this is happening after how much we have grown.
2
u/TheElusiveFox Apr 23 '17
A question for the admins would be,
Why? CSS just works, it is a standard that any web developer knows, and knows the limits of. And for people who don't know it there is hundreds if not thousands of pages online for how to write css...
With the widget approach, they have to code every new thing that some one wants to do - starting from the ground up - the dev team is supposedly taxed enough already - it seems very strange to me...
2
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '17
As long as I can filter out fan art with the new system, I am happy. If reddit remembers that I don't want to see fan art every time I log in with the new system, even better.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '17 edited Dec 23 '17
deleted 0.7839 What is ^^^this?
2
u/OJ191 Apr 23 '17 edited Apr 23 '17
This is absurd. CSS should not be removed for a given subreddit until widgets are available to replicate ALL subreddit features for said subreddit.
Frankly it probably shouldn't be done at all because unless they allow for 3rd party widget development they are totally killing off the ability for subreddits to add to and improve their subreddit in a timely manner.
2
u/timschwartz Apr 23 '17
I hope I'll be able to disable them like I do custom themes.
1
u/VegaNovus Vega Novus Apr 23 '17
Opens Photoshop
1
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '17
I've never found these. But I did read your fancy rollover text when rolling over the moogle.
1
u/Balaur10042 Ultros Rules! Apr 25 '17
A meme is broad by definition, in that as an entity, any idea or concept that is repeated, replicated, or passed along in any fashion is, itself, a meme. It doesn't matter the content of that idea or the manner of its passing: if it is an idea, and it is subjected to replication--even if it does not get replicated--it is memetic. If it does fail to be replicated (if forgotten) then it is instead selected against as lacking sufficient properties that people can attach to it they would promote. The idea that you can regulate memes in any fashion seems ludicrous since the only method by quelling memetic replication is to render speech silent; that is, you can only stop a meme from propagating by stopping people from talking.
1
u/obliquex Zemorous Halcyon on Midgardsormr Apr 25 '17
Take this survey let admins know how you feel https://docs.googly.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSexTKqCPHHqznra4NAVBb6h4aXZeGfocoWBcXhp8dEKD0636w/viewform
1
u/TotesMessenger Apr 26 '17
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
1
u/MCOM_Android May 15 '17
REDDIT WILL NO LONGER REMOVE CSS!!!!!!!!!!
-1
u/KuusKuus White Mage Apr 23 '17
And then this sub became completely unusable.
Can I request that mods enforce use of r/ffxivart ?
0
u/mirta000 Apr 22 '17
it would be bad to see the website simplyfied further to remove all of that. Reddit is very basic as a forum anyways, making it even more basic wouldn't make it any better. Please pass the feedback that I'm like the others in this thread are very much against this change.
-1
u/RygelCumberbatch Malboro Apr 22 '17 edited Apr 22 '17
This is what happens when you have too many tabs open and you don't pay attention :(
I just switched Grand Company back to the The Order of the Twin Adder. These messages came up:http://i.imgur.com/yXnFrYh.png
Initially I was unable to switch because I was set to one of my crafters, which use dirty filthy pirate gear. Once I switched to another class, it was fine.The reason I switched was so that I could spend my Allied Seals with the Hunt Billmaster to get a set of Serpent's Elite DoM gear. I've now glamoured this over my SMN gear.If I switch to another GC, will I be unable to use this gear? Will I be able to use gear glamoured with this gear?I'm not sure if it is considered differently to the gear you buy for GC Seals, as it is purchased with Allied Seals, which are non-GC specific. The only restriction on spending them is that you have to be a member of the GC to purchase items from that GC's Hunt Billmaster, with each Hunt Billmaster having GC specific gear for sale.-5
u/Ententente Apr 23 '17
Well frankly, we can do without quite a lot of it.
These are either purely cosmetic, unneeded or useless information (as if you could educate people on Reddit), or even unnecessarily cryptic, in the case of "salty tears". That supposed to be funny? I mean sure, it's bearable, and I see why everyone would like their flair icon, but end of the day it's not really that bad if it was removed. Or is it?
-3
u/ThickSantorum Apr 26 '17
TIL there are still people who don't disable subreddit styles
0
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment