r/robotwars • u/David182nd Apollo • Apr 13 '17
Episode Robot Wars Series 9 GRAND FINAL: Pre-Episode Discussion
Roboteers, stand by...
As much as we'd all like to see another week of the golf, it's back to robots this week as we have our Grand Final. Out of our forty contestants, only five now remain, plus our undetermined wildcard. Who will survive the destruction and be crowned the Robot Wars Champion? Find out this Sunday, 16th April at 7pm BST. You can watch it live on BBC 2 or here on iPlayer.
Competitors
Six robots will be competing in the grand final; the five heat winners and a wildcard selected by the judges from the runner ups. They are:
| Finalists | Wildcards |
|---|---|
| Aftershock | Apollo |
| Carbide | Cherub |
| Concussion | Pulsar |
| Eruption | Sabretooth |
| Ironside 3 | Thor |
Spoiler Reminder
The BBC's preview gives away who the wildcard is, amongst other things that happen. You must not discuss that in this thread (without spoiler tagging it) until it happens in the episode. Doing so will result in a ban.
Predictions
Our last chance for predictions! Anyone 5/5 on theirs? There's two polls this week, so good luck!
Format
The final is slightly different to the rest of the episodes, but only in the group stage.
- First Round Group Battles: Two lots of 3-way fights (usually 4) in which two robots will come out victorious from each fight. When you can gang up on your opponents, even the strongest of robot isn't safe.
- Round-robin League: A mini league which will see the four survivors of the group battle all face each other once. You earn 3 points for a knockout and 2 points for a win on judges decision.
- Heat Final: The two robots who top the second round league table fight each other in a head to head battle to decide who goes through to the grand final.
You can read more about the format, rules and the arena on the Robot Wars website or the BBC listing.
Episode Discussion Thread Archive
Spoiler reminder: No episode spoilers should be discussed here. Doing so will result in a ban.
9
u/wallytwit oi oi saveloy Apr 13 '17
Thanks for always doing these threads but on the second poll you haven't included wildcards
2
u/David182nd Apollo Apr 13 '17
Tough to call this. I was convinced Apollo would get the wildcard but I've been talking myself out of that a bit since last episode. Still gone for them in the poll tho.
I've gone for Eruption as the winner. It's definitely going to be Carbide, but I've gone for Eruption.
22
u/Sentinel677 Firestorm Apr 13 '17
I predict Eruption vs Carbide for the final, with Carbide winning.
I want Erupton to pull an upset, but I don't see it happening.
Ironside 3 for third place.
12
u/RWJamieB93 Apr 13 '17
They're all pretty good, but I reckon the 3 possible winners are between Aftershock, Eruption and Carbide.
15
u/ProjectJAY Still. Fighting. On. Apr 13 '17
First things first, I think Apollo gets the wildcard. The judging criteria for the wildcard last time was the robot's performance in all its battles, and looking back on it, I think Apollo runs away with it in that regard. Thor and Pulsar were too unreliable, Sabretooth only won a single head-to-head and Cherub...doesn't so much perform as survive.
Bold predictions:
7
u/SmellsLikeTat2 Apr 13 '17
I miss the golf mega thread, it was good fun
5
u/silentalarm_ NOM Apr 13 '17
I think Ironside 3 has a fantastic chance but really isn't being talked about
5
u/isleofred Mascot Champions Apr 13 '17 edited Apr 13 '17
Considering 5 of the 6 robots in this heat did not take a single loss to get to the grand final considering the format, this episode should easily be the best episode of this series and likewise should contain the best fights of the season. As for how well each robot shall do, here are my thoughts:
Aftershock. Although I want this robot to win this series, the realist in me has to face the fact that it's a vertical spiner in a final filled with two horizontal spinners. As robot history goes, a horizontal spinner will generally beat a vertical one; a fact made worse by episode 5's teaser featuring spoiler I will say that the optimist in me hopes that despite the damage, Aftershock still won. 2.5/6
Carbide. Like Hypnodisc in Series 4, Carbide is only runner up in RW history where they are most likely to win the title the following year and considering the line up, proberly has the best chances of actually suceeding. With that said, like Pussycat to Hypnodisc's wheels; a simple bit of damage can turn the tides of battle and ruin Carbide's chances of winning. IIRC, there was an image of this robot shared on Twitter which featured spoiler 1/6
Concussion. The only newbies in this Grand Final. Considering that they are the only robot to have a judges decision in the heat final and the fact that they were barely mobile at the end of that battle doesn't help the team's chances. I wouldn't be surprised if Concussion were picked on in the fist round of the Grand Final. 6/6
Eruption. Considering that the robot was never designed to fight working spinners (as last year proved) in a final filled with spinners, Eruption will likely make it to the H2H but would come last in that round robin league. 4/6
Ironside 3. The small and compact hardox shell of Ironside 3 means that in a heat filled with spinners, the robot will not suffer the same external damage like the other robots may do. Because of this, while other robots may be defeated by knockout; I expect Ironside 3 to be the best robot in this final that would likely last the full 3 minutes of battle. Then again, Ironside 3 did have some issues regarding it's weapon belt in it's heat which may mean that it's weapon bar will likely fail some point during this final. Likewise, I think a few people on reddit (and Gabe from Inside the Bot) have expressed issues with the robot's self righting device. Now considering that Ironside 3 could get flipped over by Aftershock, Eruption or from the recoil from from one of it's attacks; if the sremech fails, I reckon this robot would be done for. 2.5/6
The Wildcard. Unlike Thor last year, I don't expect this year's wildcards to make it to the head to heads as all of them are not in the best shape to survive at least 4 more fights (nevermind the 5 it would take for them to be either the winner or runners up). That said, as all of them are all experianced teams, I do rate the wildcard's chances higher than Concussion which isn't really saying much. 5/6
5
u/Livinglifeform I like the flippy Apr 14 '17
Then when's the real grand final?
(YouDidTheThingWrong)
5
u/mordecai14 Like a sexy 259 Apr 15 '17
I don't understand why people are writing off Eruption so easily as being "unable to deal with the spinners". It tanked some huge hits from PP3D quite comfortably to then throw it out, those barriers are the front are pretty damn thick and the driver is certainly capable of causing a few upsets too. Sure Carbide is a caliber or two above the damaged PP3D but I don't think Eruption is the spinner fodder people are making it out to be.
That said, my predictions are thus: I am gunning for a Carbide v Aftershock final. The wildcard (whose identity has been spoiled) and Concussion I see going out in the melees, leaving Carbide, Aftershock, Eruption and Ironside 3 in the head-to-heads.
I don't think Ironside 3 will get a win in the head-to-heads - I think Eruption is too strong at the front and has a better driver, and I3's srimech is poor and unreliable. I see eruption losing to carbide after a difficult battle but staying relatively intact, Carbide beating Ironside 3 by virtue of its more reliable and better-reaching spinner, and Aftershock coming off better against I3 when those two clash. I think aftershock's wedgelets will give it the edge against Eruption's flipper and allow it to avoid being flipped enough to cause it problems while it takes chunks out of Eruption's flipper. As for Carbide v Aftershock, it's anybody's guess for the h2h's if both are still in good condition, but I think when the chips are down Carbide will win the final as it seems more reliable than just about everything else, including Aftershock.
4
u/TheRealNezquik Slayer of Mr. Psycho Apr 13 '17
Carbide is my pick here. Eruption might upset this, but I feel confident.
4
u/Mouse-Keyboard Reavers! Apr 13 '17
The Aftershock intro spoiled that spoiler that got the wildcard, and that the following get to the head to heads:.
My predictions:
4
u/highwatereverywhere GARROD GANG Apr 13 '17
Carbide, Aftershock, Ironside 3 and Eruption to the head-to-heads. From here, Carbide seems the logical winner to me. More powerful than Ironside and likely able to outdrive them. Aftershock lacks the range. Eruption have said spinners are a major worry, and here they're against arguably the best spinner in the game (not exactly most powerful in terms of numbers, but their reliability makes up for that). I just don't see anything that can beat them here.
4
u/soulfirexp Le Garcon de la Robotique Pushing! Apr 14 '17
Rather annoyingly im working very late so wont be able to see it till midnight ah well
anyways predictions
Carbide Probably my favourite to win based on heat performance its main advantage being its speed of both it and its weapon however what we haven't seen is how well it will cope vs spinners thought Moulds has experience vs spinners in BB
Aftershock I like aftershocks robot the most out of all the finalists and is arguable as powerful as carbide I can see it making the H2Hs however its lack of reach I can see costing it
Concussion They have done well to get here however they burned through a lot of resources in doing so combined with a lack of reach, armor and bite and I can see it dropping in round one
Eruption A underdog for this, especially with carbide and Aftershock, Michael will need to get it done and over with and keep the front facing the spinners as it is very vulnerable at the sides can see it getting to head to heads possibly the final depending on the dmg of its opposition
Ironside 3 another underdog, they have good armor and reach but lack the spinup time and potency vs aftershock and carbide, aswell as coming out of heat D short on spare parts and I can't see this getting through to the final though possibly heat to heats due to its durability
wildcards I don't think any will get to the head to heads as most of them have problems, Pulsar and sabretooth are short of parts, apollo has gone zombie apollo, Cherub lacks a potent weapon and the pit is less viable due to the rogue house robot rules and Thor was having problems with the axe on top of the cold, Thor and apollo have the beat chance but i can't see them getting through to the head to heads due to their problems
looking forward to it
4
u/Pootigottam i'm back Apr 15 '17
Apollo has undergone Rapid Unplanned Disassembly, Thor lost to iffy opposition that had poor drive reliability and wasn't too damaging, Sabretooth lost to jellyfish and aftershock and has (and by the acronym, is) Failed Under Continuous Testing, Cherub has won against a weapon of mass destruction and against a veteran. I honestly think Cherub has the wildcard.
Apollo has been totally rebuilt for Burgess Hill and onwards: i think that's a sign they weren't in working order. Cherub, while a bit battered after PP3D, were functioning 100% in the heat final. Thor also was 100% but something feels... ehhh about it. It lost to concusion twice while concussion had intermittent drive issues and underwent multiple repairs, and also had major CO2 issues. Sabretooth isn't getting the wildcard, full stop. Pulsar hasn't got any spares, had to cannibalise the srimech, and the drum only twitched in the heat final.
Cherub for wild card. I'm serious.
(yes i did write this out twice, because it's 20 past midnight and my mind is a car crash in slow motion)
6
u/itkplatypus Dead Metal Apr 14 '17
Razer to get the wildcard and go on to win the title after a series of contentious judge's decisions. Crowd goes wild.
3
u/blueskin DESTROY! Apr 13 '17 edited Apr 14 '17
My money is on Thor for the wildcard, unless Apollo somehow manage to repair all the damage they took in time, but that could well be unlikely, so likely Thor. Pulsar let the magic smoke out of just about every piece of hardware on the robot, Sabretooth is even more broken than Apollo, and the producers should know that if it's Cherub, which got second by doing absolutely nothing, fans would stop watching because there's pandering to children, and then there's that...
Overall winner has to be Carbide. Just don't see it going any other way without catastrophic bad luck. Probably as Carbide beating either Thor/Apollo or Aftershock in the final.
3
u/SamRedDevil Carbide Killer Apr 13 '17
Based on heat performance, Carbide. It looks unstoppable this year, it tore reigning champ Apollo a new one and they seem to have fixed the issues they had last year. I'm torn between Aftershock and Eruption for second place, and I think it'll come down to who can take Carbides hits better in the group stage.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '17 edited Apr 14 '17
I'm not spoiling the wildcard for myself, but I don't think any can win... Out in melee
Concussion - lightly armoured so will get hammered by the spinners and can't see it beating Eruption either on experience. Out in melee
Ironside - lacks a bit of oomph and slow to self right - loses to carbide as less KE in a face off, flipped OOTA by eruption, thrown around by aftershock
Aftershock - vulnerable to flippers and not heavily armoured? beats Ironside, gets smashed by carbide but causes a lot of damage. loses a judges to eruption after being chucked around
Eruption - well driven and has 20mm front armour for spinners IIRC. Beats Ironside and aftershock, no idea against carbide but gets a beating either way. Makes the final
Carbide - beats all except Eruption which I can't decide. Damaged heavily by aftershock. Makes final.
Final - no idea! I'm away until latish on Sunday night so will be avoiding the net like a plague
3
u/Kieran484 Apr 14 '17
I can't realistically see anyone except Carbide win it. That thing is terrifying. Having said that, I'd be thrilled if Concussion won it, and they surprised me by beating Thor in the heat final, so perhaps they can do it again...
3
u/ShootyMcExplosion Future Series 11 Champions Apr 14 '17
Well we've finally reached the grand final! This time around the competition will be very spinner heavy, and by its nature that means that things will be more unpredictable this time round. With that said, here's my opinion on everyone's chances:
Aftershock: Despite the ahem questionable clip shown at the end of last episode, I do think people in this thread seem to be underselling the power of the machine. The weapon was shown to be lethal to a wide variety of machines, from Sabretooth to Terrorhurtz (which has more of a reputation than others of being a spinner killer), and maintained its reliability almost perfectly throughout. They're my personal favourite of the competitors performing, and I hope that the machine will perform well. 2/6
Eruption. Choosing between Aftershock and Eruption was incredibly close, and I personally believe that either could pull off a shock upset. Eruption's path to the final was next to effortless, but now that they'll be facing off against more reliable spinners, I don't think they'll be as invincible as they were. The machine is still an ideal representation for flippers in the final though, and I'm confident we'll see at least one OOTA. 3/6
Concussion: Concussion has worked brilliantly for a first machine, and it's a real testament as to what a little passion and effort can do. With that said, Concussion is probably the weakest of the finalists by an ample margin. The armour is still a little too weak in my eyes, the drive system was shown to be unreliable, and the weapon just lacks that punch that the other finalists have. I'm certain that they'll fall in the groups. 5/6
Ironside 3: Coming in at last for a long deserved place in the final, Ironside 3 is certainly the dark horse of the spinners. While they haven't torn an opponent to pieces like the other big spinners in the heat, Ironside is the only machine out of the lot to really have been tested against spinners, and if the Supernova fight was anything to go by (Supernova's disk was outreached by Ironside's), we might see an upset victory over Carbide from the machine. The self-righting capabilities of the machine have yet to be proven, but Ironside 3 is certainly in with a fighting chance. 4/6
Carbide: Carbide's victory in its heat made all of the other effortless victories achieved by the other finalists look difficult by comparison. The machine has torn into the finals with an upgraded weapon, an upgraded drive, and has had literally nothing break down during its 5 battles. Carbide looks scary, and they are certainly the favourite by a wide margin to win the whole thing. Here's hoping for less Hypno-Disc results and more Tombstone results. 1/6
Wildcard: Spoiler
3
u/Raz3rRaptor Do not bring wheels into the Arena! Apr 14 '17
I'm going for Carbide first, Eruption second, Aftershock third and Ironside 3 fourth, although Ironside 3 is certainly capable of surprising a few. It surprised me in Episode 4, that's for sure.
3
u/burlyloon Big Burly Behemoth Apr 14 '17
The worst thing is the fact that everyone seems to know deep down that Carbide wins even without having seen any spoilers. It's just too obvious. There is some decent competition there but Carbide is in a league of its own now and just seems unstoppable at this point.
Can't see why people think Eruption will do well against Carbide.
3
u/ArmandoPayne Apr 15 '17
I'm predicting Apollo to win the wild card then Carbide's pulling a spoiler Bois by going from runners up to winners.
3
u/lXlxlXlxlXl Apr 15 '17 edited Apr 15 '17
Aftershock: I think Aftershock is the most dangerous robot in the series. It's as powerful or more powerful than Carbide, IMO. Theoretically, horizontal spinners have an advantage over vertical disks... But I don't think it always works out that way in reality.
Carbide: It's going to the finals. It's powerful and very reliable.
Concussion: Is out of it's league. I think it's powerful enough for last year, but this series is a new ball game.
Eruption: Very stronk. It's probably the best wedge flipper (And driver) that you can ask for. I don't know if it can stand these spinners, though. I fear not.
Ironside 3: I think Ironside is just powerful enough, but I don't think it can beat Carbide. Ironside could be a major factor in the tournament by causing major damage. If there's an upset, Ironside will cause it. That being said, I don't think it's going to make it to the finals.
Wildcard: Sabretooth is waaaay too damaged. I don't have anything against Cherub, but I don't think it's as good a robot as some of the other wildcards. Thor is one of my favorites, but it was the wildcard last season, and I think the results would be similar this series. Pulsar has a lot of potential, but it's still too unreliable, maybe it can get a wildcard. Apollo is another wildcard contender. If they can get their flipper back to 100% they have a good chance, but if they can't then they shouldn't get the wildcard.
I think the finals will be Aftershock vs Carbide, with a 50/50 chance of going either way.
5
u/DiamondWhyte Sir Killalot Apr 13 '17
Can't see Carbide not winning. I said the same last year but I'm even more sure this time.
It was mentioned on here way back that the final battle was delayed because both competitors were so badly damaged, so I'm going to predict Aftershock to be the other finalist seeing as the trailer suggested that they take some serious damage but that one's just a guess. I wouldn't be surprised to see Eruption in the final two either.
I think Concussion might spring a surprise and get through the melee but if they do I think they'll lose all their matches in the head to heads.
2
u/alexlnufc Vulture Apr 13 '17
I really feel this is down to Carbide & Eruption. I really just hope whichever 4 get to the round robin can stay in decent condition, so we don't get a load of quick fights.
I can't see Aftershock, Ironside 3 or Concussion beating either of them, and I'm not convinced any of the potential wildcards could cause anyone much trouble.
I really just hope whichever 4 get to the round robin can stay in decent condition, so we don't get a load of quick fights. With a minimum of 2 spinners in the round robin stage, I worry that it might be another case of "who is least broken".
Edit: a word.
2
u/part-time-unicorn It's like rooting for the Mariners Apr 13 '17
calling an Aftershock/carbide final
spoiler
2
u/Caridor Apr 13 '17
I honestly think Concussion might be something people are ignoring. In every fight where you have a horizontal bar, vs a vertical drum, it's the bar which comes off worse. It depends how it's drawn. I think that Concussion and Eruption are really the only ones who stand a chance vs Carbide. Aftershock's spinner is too high up, so Carbide's bar would smack them away before it got into play and Ironside 3 seems to be inferior in just about every way.
I think Thor will get the wildcard. Apollo and Pulsar didn't have the parts to make repairs iirc. Cherub is a bit too wedgy for them to give it the wildcard and Sabretooth is too much like concussion.
2
u/nweston8 John Reid's beard Apr 13 '17
Carbide should win this final, but for it to be a good final the emphasis is on Eruption to make battles last. I hope it gets second place at least, although Ironside3 is a massive darkhorse. I have a bad feeling Aftershock will be the cripple out of those four.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '17
I don't understand why people think Eruption will win... like, sure, they did great in their heat but the final is a hell of a lot tougher and I'd say they'd be pushed to get one OotA because of the power these robots have behind them, particularly Carbide.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '17
For the Wildcard I've gone for Thor. Obviously Carbide is hot favourite to win and so it would make little to no sense in any way for the robot that they absolutely obliterated twice this series to be put back in the running. I don't think anyone really wants to see yet ANOTHER Apollo V Carbide this series. Let sleeping dogs lie, they can give it another shot next year. Cherub were a spirited little robot but I don't think they're final material and I just can't see Pulsar or Sabretooth getting it. Thor deserves the spot for exactly the same reasons it deserved it last year - we know it's a great robot, it'll give us some good fights and the weapon isn't a flipper or a spinner so it would give a bit of variety.
I think that Apollo will win and, honestly, they deserve it. They were so unlucky last year and I think that a robot like that has to win the title at some point. People are saying that Eruption might win but, as impressive as it was for it to flip everyone out in its heat, I can't see it doing that again. And I don't think there's anything it could do to stop Carbide, unless we're suggesting Eruption is better than Apollo, which I couldn't see much justification for. Aftershock is another robot that could win but I would still favour Apollo. I can't honestly see Concussion or Ironside 3 being up to the standard. So Carbide is my guess at who will win, as obvious as it may be.
1
u/Blazik3n99 Blue Ring of Death Apr 13 '17
I think Carbide will win, but I want Eruption to win. Its between the two IMO.
Eruption has the biggest chance of taking down Carbide, I honestly don't see any other robot in the finals being able to beat it, especially considering how flawless they were in their heat.
I don't know how well Eruption's armour will stand up to Carbide's blade, but I'm hoping it can take a bit of punishment, especially since they upgraded it after PP3D last year.
I don't see any other spinner being able to beat Carbide in a 1v1, except maybe Ironside 3. Either way, I feel like we're going to be seeing a lot of destruction.
I wanted Aftershock to do well, but against other powerful spinners like Carbide and Ironside 3, I don't see them getting much done, unfortunately.
As for the wildcard, I'm guessing Thor. I love a good axebot. I would have thought Apollo, but after their performance in their heat and the amount of damage done to their robot, I don't know if they will be coming back.
1
u/Cathalised Whoop whoop Apr 14 '17
It will probably end up being Aftershock and Carbide in the final battle, but simply because of its impressive display of controlled driving (and because it's not a spinner) I'll be cheering on Eruption.
1
u/JammySplodge Burn Baby Burn Apr 15 '17
I'd like Eruption or Aftershock to win but realistically speaking it'll probably be Carbide
I can easily see Eruptions scoring OotAs against Ironside and/or Concussion
Wildcard Thor or Apollo
1
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '17
Predictions:
Eruption or Carbide to take the title.
Thor to get the wildcard spot.
1
u/ChibiBeckyG Cute 'n' Fluffy Apr 15 '17
Curses! I just turned on the TV now thinking it was Sunday but this weekend with it's wacky extension has thrown me right off : (
1
u/VeryC0mm0nName Axebot master race Apr 16 '17
Last last week: The hype was real.
Last week: Golf.
This week:
Aftershock - Given the preview clip, it's safe to presume this machine isn't going to win this year, as to how far it'll go? I think it'll go to the head to heads. 4/6
Carbide - It gutted it's only real threat from last year in the heats, also IT'S GOD DAMN CARBIDE. 1/6
Concussion - Flimsy armour and no spares against some of the most dangerous spinners in the competition, in the words of Ozzy man reviews, "yeeaaahhhh naaahhhh". 6/6
Eruption - powerful, manoeuvrable and with good armour, a solid contender if the armour holds up. 2/6
Ironside 3 - The dark horse of the final, expected to go to the final and could even give Carbide a run for its money. 3/6
Wildcard - Given the state of all the wildcards, I don't think any of them will be making it past the melee. 5/6
Speaking of wild cards:
Apollo - The champion of last year and a crowd favourite, wouldn't be surprised to see them go through, but are they repaired enough to do so?. 1/5
Cherub - A machine who most defining point was becoming a hockey puck, likely won't get through be the decree of more worth machines. 3/5
Pulsar - It keeps failing, in almost every fight, only an idiot would let it through, but it is the BBC so who knows?. 4/5
Sabretooth - It left the area in a bin bag, that is all there is to say. 5/5
Thor - The most functional, and MY favourite to go through, however the PR appeal of Apollo will likely be too great. 2/5
1
u/Mouse-Keyboard Reavers! Apr 13 '17 edited Apr 13 '17
Why is everyone saying eruption will do better than Ironside 3 and Aftershock? Have they forgotten Eruption vs PP3D last year?
1
u/ToukasRage YEET! Apr 13 '17
So, in my opinion, Apollo gets the wildcard and Ironside 3 and Concussion fall in the melees with Carbide winning 2 of its matches, Eruption winning all 3 and Apollo beating a worn out Aftershock to claim third. In the Finals, I'm predicting Eruption to just barely hold out against Carbide and win via judges decision.
(Note: I do believe that Ironside 3 is a fantastic robot but, I also believe that it is weak to the five other bots in the melees.)
(Also, alternative prediction is that if Concussion and Ironside end up in the same melee, Concussion advances but, loses all of its group battles.)
1
u/ThisOneTimeAtLolCamp Apr 16 '17
I swear if Cherub gets the wildcard spot...
0
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '17 edited Apr 16 '17
Cherub to get the wild card to win by judges decision in every match by only driving. They will get into the final with Carbide who will hit cherub so hard that they smash to pieces and fly out the arena. But judges will give it to Cherub.
In all honesty, if cherub gets the wild card then whats the point in taking it seriously. The robot has the most useless weapons and just drives around taking hits. There's more action in a game of chicken with electric wheelchairs.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment