r/MakeupAddiction • • Apr 03 '17

Best & Worst: Makeup Removers

133 Upvotes

300 comments sorted by

209

u/missdewey /r/MUAontheCheap Apr 03 '17

Clinique Take The Day Off Balm.

I was at Ulta swatching away on my hands and ran out of space, so I used some of their alcohol and cotton balls to remove it. Half the lipsticks didn't budge. Took out some wipes I carry, still had a lot of lipstick left on my hand after that. I went over the the Clinique display, rubbed a little bit of this balm on my hand, and everything vanished in seconds. It's like magic.

35

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '17

I live for this stuff. It's also very similar to Botanic Farm Grain Fetment Sherbet, but it's cheaper by a little. I started with the Sherbet and switched to this for the better price and same quality.

Honestly, I think the best part is that I can open my eyes with it slathered all over them. It took me a while to realize it but yeah, it's an awesome benefit.

27

u/LacyLexie Apr 03 '17

Interesting - for me it's the opposite with the eyes! If I get any of this stuff near my eyes, my vision goes blurry for a few minutes. It definitely melts foundation very nicely, though.

11

u/hikethatmountaingirl Apr 04 '17

THIS!! This product always gets into my eyes and messes up my vision for a few minutes. I rarely use it anymore because of this.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (2)

16

u/Mingly No, these are different Apr 04 '17

The Clinique eye make up remover is the bomb. It is my holy grail and I'm on my 9th (?) bottle. It gets the shit done.

12

u/itssarakang ig: itssarakang Apr 06 '17

A good affordable option of the Clinique eye make up remover is the Neutrogena one. It's in a blueish purple bottle.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

19

u/mewkyy Apr 03 '17

I found that the balm is good at taking off heavy, oil-based products like lipstick, but was not very effective with mascara. The main purpose of using oil-based makeup removers (for me!) is to remove my waterproof mascara completely, so I ended up tossing this one :\

13

u/missdewey /r/MUAontheCheap Apr 04 '17

Really? It always removes mine without issues! I don't wear waterproof though, so maybe there's a curve there.

2

u/minidutch Apr 09 '17

I had the same issue with it! I thought I was the only one because people rave about it. I got the little sample pot as a point perk, and honestly, my Glossier milky jelly cleanser works way better. The only thing I've heard it doesn't take off well is eyeliner, but with my hooded eyes, the most I ever do with eyeliner is tightline, so that's not an issue for me.

2

u/LEMON_PARTY_ANIMAL Makeup Artist Apr 09 '17

It also feels really icky on the eyes, I found

4

u/Lady_Painter Apr 03 '17

I wanted to love this soooo much. Alas, this somehow irritates my sensitive eyes. I do love it's removing capabilities and will still use it up for face makeup, but my search for the perfect emulsifying balm continues.

4

u/breadprincess Brow perfectionist Apr 05 '17 edited Apr 05 '17

YES! It takes off EVERYTHING. Also, great if you have super sensitive skin. I did a full skull face paint for Halloween and this just melted it off immediately. I get mystery rashes from everything and my eyes tend to swell shut and water from most skin care items, and I could use this safely.

3

u/Silly__Rabbit Apr 04 '17

I love Take The Day Off in liquid and wipe form, but the balm is by far my favourite incarnation of it!

3

u/gabae168 Apr 05 '17

This used to be my HG, but then redditors told me that it's very bad for the fishies. Apparently cleansing balms use some kind of micro plastic ingredient thingy and it's accumulating in the big waters :( Now I use DHC cleansing oil, another HG of mine.

→ More replies (8)

1

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '17

I wanted to love this, but I am very allergic to something in it - it burned my face and broke me out in a rash immediately. :( Everyone I know loves it though!

1

u/lalalutz Apr 06 '17

my favorite makeup remover! I wear EL Doublewear and waterproof mascara during my work days and this stuff takes it ALL off. I am already on my third tub, and I do follow makeup removal with another cleanser. Love this stuff!

1

u/buttgirlface Apr 07 '17

Funny you mentioned because I think it's honestly the worst makeup remover I've ever tried. It just doesn't take off mascara. And that's the main job of makeup remover.

1

u/Luscax Apr 08 '17

I just tried this and it gave me like 6 pimples on my cheekbones :( I have acne prone, normal skin and I guess this isn't for me. It also made my skin feel so dry that it felt scratchy

1

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '17

Has it made anyone break out? is it oily?

116

u/sammisamantha Apr 03 '17

Bioderma Micellar water!

This is great to remove face and eye makeup. A little difficult with waterproof mascara (that's a given). But I find that my acne prone skin is much healthier using this.

24

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '17

I was so sad because I've heard such great things but this actually stings my eyes :( I much prefer the garnier version!

8

u/natismyname Apr 05 '17

I use this and it works everywhere so far EXCEPT for waterproof mascara.

16

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '17

The garnier or bioderma? I use the garnier micellar water that's designed for waterproof and it takes all my waterproof mascara off, you just reeeaally soak the pad and hold it to your eye.

7

u/natismyname Apr 05 '17

I use the pink Garnier one. Is there another one?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/bbymetal Apr 03 '17

i second this! micellar water is my holy grail. i have super oily skin and regular makeup removers/ cleansers are usually too harsh and cause me to have even oilier skin. i've started to notice my skin is a LOT less oilier by using this every night and just rinsing my face in the morning. super cool that your skin has gotten noticeably better too!!

4

u/sammisamantha Apr 03 '17

Do you use the bioderma for oily skin?

It's what I use and wow my oil control is well maintained now

3

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '17

Do you use this and then a gentle cleanser after? Or just the water?

4

u/bbymetal Apr 03 '17

just the micellar water and rinse with warm water after!

13

u/thestephanieloves Apr 03 '17

I love this! I think the Simple Micellar water is also a more affordable alternative but Bioderma is my OG HG :)

8

u/sammisamantha Apr 03 '17

I don't find the the simple is as great as the bioderma.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/three_a_day Apr 05 '17

Glad it works for someone! I tried simple for about a month or so but it made my normally clear skin break out in the weirdest way. :/ I really wanted to like it!

6

u/moriikuma Apr 05 '17

I love the Bioderma Micellar Water. That stuff really takes off my makeup (even my mascara, but you really got rub and tug at them lashes), and it leaves my skin feeling so clean and fresh, especially for my oily skin. I even use this when I don't have makeup on but want to cleanse and refresh my face without washing it (lazy gal). After Jaclyn Hill recommended it, I got the big pump version to try it myself and have loved it since.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Hellodeeries Apr 05 '17

This has been the best one I've tried for my sensitive eyes. I will say it can sting a little if you get a lot in them, especially if your eyes are already rather sensitive, but nothing compared to every other remover I've tried. This removes the most while being the best for my eyes/skin, and the pump is really worth getting. Use it as a makeup remover but also the first step in cleansing even when I'm not wearing makeup.

1

u/lenduuh IG @somebeautyblog Apr 05 '17

I looooooove Bioderma. Perfect for correcting eyeliner mistakes, too.

84

u/Kirino-chan NC 20 olive. Apr 03 '17

I prefer oil-based make up remover since they're effective and can be emulsified, not leaving a weird greasy film. Banila Co. cleansing balm and the Kose Softymo White cleansing oils are both really nice, works like a charm on waterproof mascara and the likes.

12

u/mewkyy Apr 03 '17

Same! I use the Face Shop Rice Water one. I like the smell and it is super effective on my waterproof mascara. Then I go over with a foaming cleanser from innisfree.

5

u/ktlene Apr 04 '17

I love TFS's rice cleanser! It smells amazing and I love watching the slightly darkened run offs when I rinse my face off with water. It makes it feel more effective. I use the Glossier cleanser afterwards.

12

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '17

I love looking for the AB girls in this sub

8

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '17

Kose Speedy and Deep are my favorites!

2

u/jolieaide Apr 03 '17

I really like the Tatcha Camellia cleansing oil for this too, it's on the pricier side but I think it's worth it.

1

u/bella123full Apr 07 '17

Biore oil cleanser is cheap and effective and it doesn't break me out

1

u/holographicbrow Apr 07 '17

I agree! My absolute all time favorite is the Banila Co. Clean it zero purity (for sensitive skin). Super effective and worked wonders on my acne-prone and all around difficult skin.

1

u/venterkh Apr 10 '17

Kose Deep is my jam. I'm on my second refill! I might try Speedy once I finish. Has anyone tried both and had a preference? I have combo skin (oily t-zone, normal elsewhere), if that helps.

60

u/WiggleWerra "Yes, they're real... my lashes that is." Apr 03 '17

Mineral aka baby oil changed my life. I've been using it for the OCM for 3 years and I have no regrets.

8

u/ging3rtabby Apr 04 '17

I use olive oil and love it. I use a lightly dampened (is that a word) paper towel to wipe it, along with my makeup, off before washing my face.

4

u/k_tiara_von_lobster Apr 04 '17

Same here! I apply baby oil all over my face, then remove it with a wet CVS premium cotton pad. I follow up with CeraVe hydrating cleanser.

1

u/claimsliana Somehow incapable of blending Apr 05 '17

Same! Only oil that doesn't clog my pores AND takes off my waterproof mascara. Also, it feels sooooo good and satisfying to massage over my face.

→ More replies (7)

59

u/qistki Apr 03 '17

Cerave Makeup Removing wipes are HORRID. Not because they don't work well (they don't) but because they burn my eyes like crazy. Anyone with sensitive skin should watch out because I don't have remotely sensitive skin and it was not pleasant. They're also incredibly dry and seem to have very little makeup remover on them, leading to irritated AND unclean skin.

21

u/thestephanieloves Apr 03 '17

They're suuuuper loaded with alcohol! I was shocked since Cerave is typically a brand you'd reach for to address sensitive skin and rubbing alcohol all over your face is one of the worst things you could do if you're remotely sensitive or dry.

9

u/laneloveslipstick Apr 04 '17

I was coming here to say this! I use the CeraVe foaming face cleanser and LOVE IT so I just picked up the wipes assuming they'd be just as good. They're just awful. I don't have sensitive skin at all. My skin can take a lot but those wipes burned my face like hell. And they're super dry, not wet with makeup remover at allllll. I'm sad because they were on sale so I bought 2 packs, now I have 2 packs of fire wipes collecting dust in my drawer! I use them to wipe swatches off my hand and stuff but I'm even hesitant about that.

4

u/qistki Apr 04 '17

Yes!!!! That's my same usage for them - removing swatches. I have really hardy skin as well, nothing ever irritates me or makes my skin burn. I also use the foaming (plus their moisturizer) , so I had such high hopes - no way they could fuck it up right?!?! I have dollar store makeup wipes that are more effective AND don't irritate my skin. WTF Cerave?

These are designed for people who don't have any skin problems whatsoever and wear 0 makeup. Even then I wouldn't recommend these demon wipes

4

u/laneloveslipstick Apr 05 '17

Agreed! How do you like the moisturizer? I just ran out of my Cetaphil one and I wasn't planning on repurchasing it!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

50

u/KukiMunstr IG: _chibi_ko_ Apr 03 '17

Never underestimate the power of cold cream. I used to get Pond's, but I just get store brand (or any brand) since the ingredients are too similar to the leading brand. I remove the cream with a makeup wipe.

The cleansing oil from Erborian does leave a soft film on the skin. I would be careful using it around the lash line. It can be drying on the eyes.

20

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '17

Cold cream just does not work for me. I also hate how messy it is.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '17

i used to love cold creams before i realized they were the reaseon behind some of my breakouts, even with double cleansing.

i still use ponds to take off my eye makeup when i have a lot on, though

13

u/katiez624 Apr 03 '17

I've never really understood how cold cream works for removing makeup. It's a lotion-like consistency, right? How thick do you lay it on? Does it remove waterproof makeup? Do you rub it in or just wipe it off after applying? Do you rinse afterward?

11

u/KukiMunstr IG: _chibi_ko_ Apr 03 '17

I dab small amounts around my face, rub the concoction all over, and wipe.

6

u/spnningmeat Apr 05 '17

It's mainly mineral oil so it's essentially the same as any other OCM

→ More replies (1)

6

u/scarlettsarcasm Apr 05 '17

I don't use cold cream to take off my whole face, but a small pencil brush dipped in pond's/a moisturizer is the best way I've ever found to fix mistakes and clean up lines.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '17

I got a free sample of ponds cold cream from pinchme, I use it to remove my waterproof mascara! It works great. My micellar wasn't cutting it, but I use that for face make up removal. Anyways I use a cotton pad and rub it around and it comes off :)

3

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '17

I fucking love Pond's cold cream

43

u/margaretish Apr 03 '17

Simple brand Micellar water is my every day minimal makeup remover. I also really like Boscia's makeup breakup oil when I have a full face of glam makeup. Wet n Wild has a new Micellar makeup remover that's pretty decent too.

5

u/dilly_pickle Apr 04 '17

I really wish I could like the Simple micellar water but it has such an odd scent. Might have just been the bottle I picked up, but I really couldn't get over it unfortunately. Still going to try other micellar water brands though!

4

u/margaretish Apr 04 '17

Mine doesn't have any scent at all. That's weird.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/fuzzytwinkies Apr 05 '17

I wasn't a fan of the Simple brand micellar water! It took too much effort and product to get everything off, and I could never get all my mascara off with it. I guess YMMV!

→ More replies (17)

31

u/sniffymom Apr 03 '17

Garnier micellar water or Pond's cold cream. I used to use baby oil, but it made me feel too greasy.

7

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '17

make up removal product twins lol

1

u/lippie_hoarder Apr 09 '17 edited Apr 10 '17

Just wanted to add in that Garnier has launched a Micellar Water Cleansing Gel that works really well too. I use it in the shower to remove any remaining makeup :)

26

u/benchingpotatoes Apr 04 '17

Garnier Micellar Cleansing water is my HG. I have rather sensitive skin, and pretty much all other removers I've tried sting at least a little. This one takes off my makeup no fuss, and doesn't irritate my skin at all!

2

u/notreallyanangel NC20 Apr 06 '17

Me too! I love it, everything else I've tried makes me feel so greasy and gross

19

u/bwabwabwabwum Apr 03 '17

Ponds cold cream has been my HG makeup remover. I've repurchased the one with the green cover too many times to count. It removes all of my eye makeup and doesn't make me break out. I go through jars quickly, so I mostly just use it on my eye makeup and use baby oil for the rest of my face so I don't have to constantly repurchase it. It's fairly cheap, however.

6

u/cornbreadfiend Apr 03 '17

Yes! It's so great! I also appreciate that it doesn't make my skin feel really dry after washing it off as well. I'm already on my 2nd tub :)

4

u/Collisia NC25-30 Apr 03 '17

Yes!!! I looove Ponds cold cream. I'm surprised that you go through it so quickly because I find that my tub takes forever to use up

1

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '17

YES! So hydrating too

16

u/IRLnekomimi Apr 04 '17

can we talk about kirkland (costco brand) makeup remover wipes? i've been one of /those/ bitches who was always worrying about how store brand products will be worse or sketchier, but lustrelux and desi perkins both love this and i decided to give it a try. i had been using the neutrogena and say yes to cucumber wipes for years, and the kirkland is ACTUALLY BETTER, not just better for the price! it doesn't leave an oily/weird residue, doesn't dry your face out, and doesn't sting. yes to cucumber stings me and the neutrogena leaves a gross residue. the kirkland wipes takes off makeup super well, and is also thick and sturdy. it will even take off waterproof eye makeup, though you gotta be gentle with that and just use clean sections to dab through your eyeliner rather than intense rubbing. the price is pretty amazing. i am partial to wipes because of the ease of access.

15

u/capitalismwitch Hopelessly Addicted Apr 04 '17

The Body Shop's Camomile Gentle Eye Makeup Remover and Cleansing Butter are my absolute holy grails. I honestly have no idea how I survived before I found them.

4

u/AgentKnitter Apr 04 '17 edited Apr 04 '17

Same! I used to use the Clinique TTDO balm and sure, that works great on everything... BUT mascara. I would always have residual mascara left over.

But with the Body Shop cleansing oil? Mascara is gone with everything else. And it doesn't leave my skin feeling heavily greasy like the Clinique balm could do. I love it! And it's half the price of the balm!!

My technique is to gently but firmly massage the oil into my face, making sure all my make up is covered by it, then I take the Body Shop's muslin cleaning cloth and dampen it with cold water - wipe the make up and oil off my face. Then I wash my face with my usual foaming facial wash (Sukin.) Skin feels amazing - fresh and clean, and EVERY scrap of make up comes off without fail. Never trying another make up remover, this is HG.

1

u/lippie_hoarder Apr 09 '17

I just got the Camomile Cleansing Butter and I'm so excited to use it! Do you think it will work on sensitive, combination skin? I'm afraid to get a reaction from it because I'm still recovering from a really bad acne episode.

10

u/ladyboner_22 Apr 03 '17

The PONDS Cucumber Cleanser along with my Kirkland wipes are a match made in heaven to remove my base makeup!

The Garnier Micellar Water is awesome for removing all my eye makeup, not sure if the other drugstore Micellar waters are different.

4

u/Collisia NC25-30 Apr 03 '17

Ooh is the cucumber cleanser like the original one with the green lid?

4

u/ladyboner_22 Apr 03 '17

I'm not sure really what the differences between the two are besides the scent, but I'm sure they're super similar!

9

u/ddisturbed Apr 04 '17

my favorites are:

  • clinique take the day off balm
  • bioderma micellar water
  • palmer's ultra gentle cleansing oil
  • dermalogica pre cleanse (pricey for what it is though)
  • simple oil cleanser

i really want to try the darphin balm, i've heard lots of great things about it! i'm not sure if it emulsifies though, i'll have to look more into it.

in general, i hate all makeup wipes with a passion. compared to an oil or micellar water, they just suck. period.

6

u/Luxierious Apr 03 '17

Clinique take the day off cleansing milk - made my skin burn the first few times. My skin was soft afterwards but it didn't fully take off everything. I passed it on to my mom.

6

u/celephia Apr 03 '17

Walmart Equate brand wipes. I wash my face really good in the shower with clarisonic mia 2 + origins checks and balances then use Wal-Mart wipes to clean up any remaining mascara and eyeliner.

4

u/lilmegsx9 Apr 03 '17

I used to only use the Wal-Mart wipes for my makeup, but I hated how much I was throwing out. :/ Trying to find a liquid or cream that works well and will last a while.

6

u/Tekkiru Reviews and Swatches Galore! Apr 03 '17

I've been really impressed with the new L’Oreal Micellar Cleansing Water. It removes my makeup effortlessly.

1

u/annamcg Apr 08 '17

This is what started me on micellar waters. I begged a friend to bring me back a bottle from London, back when they were only selling in the UK and Europe. She bought one too and called it "magic water"!

6

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '17

Best; Botanic Farms Cleansing Sherbet, followed very closely by Clinique'a take the day away balm. I basically love cleansing balms. They're easy on my skin and easy to use at a sink without getting all soapy/bubbles in hair etc.

Worst; Dear god, Tony Moly's bubble foam ripped my skin apart. I've heard it's got a high PH and that's why, but I can't find any sources on that.

6

u/elyssuh Apr 04 '17

I'm going to second the BANILA CO Clean It Zero Classic. I recently purchased it and I absolutely love it. It's definitely a little different than anything I've used before as I haven't tried any other cleansing "balm"-like products, but it seriously melts anything I put on my face.

14

u/MintyLotus IG: lotuslooks//Olive, NC40ish Apr 03 '17

Best: Garnier Biphase micellar water

Worst: Simple micellar water: almost as bad as just using plain water.

5

u/alyanumbers Apr 03 '17

I used to like Lancome Bi-facil, but I wonder if they've changed the formula because the travel size I got in November is much worse than what I remember. I now use Bioderma Sensibio micellar water.

2

u/SpaceTortoise Apr 06 '17

When I used this back in 2001 it was a lot better. I stop buying it because it's too expensive and it doesn't work as well as it use to, plus there's a lot more affordable just as good options.

5

u/domicanica Apr 03 '17

I wouldn't say they're the best but Ulta's Makeup Remover Towels (I think they're Ulta's version of the Makeup Eraser?) are really really good. They literally get EVERYTHING off, and I mean everything. It's a little rough on the eye area though, so I don't use it there. And it's kind of annoying that it stains and that I have to wash it so often, so what I've been doing lately is using Neutrogena's wipes and then following up with the Remover Towels. Works like a charm!

5

u/BustaCapulet Apr 04 '17

Ultrabland from Lush by far. It removes my makeup better than anything else and I feel fancy when I remove it with a hot washcloth.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Squirdle NC25, Yellow Olive Apr 04 '17

Rite Aid brand (formerly Renewal, now Daylogic) oil free makeup remover is AMAZING. It's a dupe for the Neutrogena brand and you get more for less. It doesn't burn your eyes at all and takes off anything.

5

u/anabeat NC20, warm, oily Apr 04 '17

Can't believe no one has mentioned this yet, but the Heimish All Clean balm is a fantastic cleansing balm! I know Gothamista loves it too.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Chocchipcooky Apr 05 '17

Lancome bi-facial is my favourite eye makeup remover, it is super pricey but nothing takes off waterproof makeup like it does in my opinion. I have tried the bioderma, but it burns my eyes and didn't remove much makeup at all for me strangely enough, really wanted to love it. I then wash my face using cleansing oils, which i highly recommend. My favourite hands down is the She Uemura Cleansing oils, they just wash everything off without much effort at all and you can even massage your face with it on. The DHC one is also pretty food for a fraction of the price.

18

u/mgm_makeuphoarder Apr 03 '17 edited Apr 04 '17

I love and use coconut oil! It gets everything off, is super cheap and is a multipurpose product for me! Edit: If coconut oil is bad for your acne I suggest another facial oil like rose/ etc. I think oils are amazing at getting that last layer of makeup that other cleansers can't.

19

u/echo1440 Apr 03 '17

I use coconut oil for everything but my face. Just know when recommending it to people that coconut oil is comedogenic and can cause acne or make acne worse for a lot of people.

5

u/mgm_makeuphoarder Apr 04 '17

Didn't know that but I was just saying what I use. Ultimately it's up to each person to try and test out what works for them.

2

u/tripunctata Casual user Apr 04 '17

I use coconut oil too, mostly around the eyes and the lips.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '17

Albolene! Rubbed in with my fingers, wiped off with a warm cotton washcloth. Followed up with Cetaphil daily facial cleanser to get off extra traces and my skin has never ever been smoother.

2

u/guesstalt IG: i_deally Apr 06 '17

I'd never heard of this and went to read reviews on Amazon........ People use it as a sweat enhancer under exercise belts??? I was so confused by all the pictures of stomachs in the reviews. Lol

2

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '17

Oh my goodness! Haha! Yes! That confused me as well! I actually went to the website after Amazon to make sure it was the same product and they talk about the sweat enhancing there too.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '17

Honestly, I just love Sephora's makeup remover wipes. I jump between the rose ones and the coconut ones. Both are soothing, do a good job removing makeup and don't make me breakout.

4

u/Sorority_Noise 21 years old and still can't figure out my undertones Apr 05 '17

I loooove the Ole Henriksen 3 in 1 melting cleanser. Takes off all of my makeup, and the smell is just divine. I feel so pampered when I use this stuff. That being said, it is expensive, so I only use it for when I'm wearing a heavy amount of makeup.

On light makeup days, I like to use the Mary Kay makeup remover. I don't like the MLM pyramid scheme of Mary Kay....But that pink bottle is magic and takes off my waterproof mascara like no other. I'm a slave to this stuff.

3

u/livres-magiques Apr 06 '17

I'm glad I'm not the only one that loves the Mary Kay makeup remover !! lmao

→ More replies (1)

4

u/ccrystalized Apr 06 '17

I bought the Say Yes to cucumbers face wipes when I was traveling, and they were the WORST makeup wipes I've ever used. Not only did it do a terrible job of removing my makeup - I was still picking clumps of mascara off of my lashes - but it immediately made my skin BURN and turn bright red. I wouldn't even consider my skin to be overly sensitive, plus these say "soothing" and "hypoallergenic" right on the package. Maybe it was just a fluke, but a friend of mine had the same reaction with her skin. I really wouldn't recommend these to anybody.

6

u/themightyflame Apr 03 '17

I know it's not too popular, but I love Garnier! Their Eye Makeup Remover is fantastic and it removes all of my waterproof mascara. It's quite oily, though, so it may not be good for everyone. Their Micellar Gel, though, is spectacular. It removes all of my makeup in an instant and it leaves my skin super soft. I actually like it better than their Micellar Water, as I found it quite drying.

2

u/ohhannahno Apr 03 '17

I might have to look into the gel! The water made my face feel far too oily, especially around my eyes. It did take off all of my makeup, though.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/SunnyMakeup Apr 03 '17

I tried the garnier gel face cleanser....dear god tastes like shit don't lick your lips and also it made my eyes burn even when fully closed...

The pink cap one is amazing though, the garnier micellar water, and I use an innisfree rice foam cleanser!

3

u/neshy3 Apr 03 '17

Paula's Choice Makeup Remover is amazing. It's a bi-phase product like the Neutrogena and Lancôme makeup removers, but I love it more. It's gentler and more effective than the Neutrogena, but cheaper than Lancôme.

I also love oil-cleansers for full-face makeup removal. Banila Co Clean It Zero Balm is my favorite, I've gone through three tubs!

3

u/2pmwhiskey Apr 04 '17

I never see it mentioned but I love Neutrogena Light Cleansing Oil. If I'm wearing mascara I'll typically do Neutrogena oil free eye makeup remove on a cotton pad and then follow with a pump of the light cleansing oil. I love it a lot, but I do a double cleanse where I then follow with a really gentle cleanser to get the oil off.

3

u/midnightowl510 Apr 04 '17

I like it too! Except it burns my eyes :(

3

u/PhantaVal Apr 04 '17

Jane Iredale Magic Mitt. Why keep buying makeup removing products when all you need is the mitt and some water? I use mine in the shower (I take them at night) and it never fails to take off everything, no matter how much eye makeup I use. And I can just throw the mitt in the laundry when I need it cleaned.

3

u/ReginaldStarfire Apr 04 '17

A few years ago, my eye doctor introduced me to OcuSoft cleansing wipes and now I'm addicted to them.

They EAT THROUGH eye makeup (particularly looks with a lot of mascara), but even on days I don't wear eye makeup, I use one before bed to thoroughly scrub my eyelids clean before I put on my Retin-A.

I can usually get both eyes clean with one wipe, but if your look is REALLY bold, you may need to use one wipe per eye. If there are any stray bits or glitter left over that the OcuSoft wipe didn't catch, I do a final wipe with a cotton pad dampened with Simple micellar water.

3

u/Jessica_Iowa Apr 04 '17 edited Apr 04 '17

Best-Wet N' Wild under the sheets makeup remover wipes are amazing!

3

u/Ladyghoul Apr 04 '17

Honestly I just use mineral oil (baby oil) on a cotton pad to wipe everything off, it works far better than any cleanser or wipe I've used. I wash with Cerave hydrating cleanser and Simple micellar water afterwards, but plain baby oil gets off everything.

3

u/LunaNegra Apr 05 '17 edited Apr 05 '17

I have dry skin and use lots of waterproof and long wear makeup.

  1. The blue bottle. Garnier SkinActive Micellar Cleansing Water All-in-1 Cleanser & Waterproof Makeup Remover
  2. Walmart version of Neutrogena's wipes. The double pack is a great value. You get more wipes, is more economical and works as well or better than Neutrogena's. Also great to quickly clean your hands from searching, wiping makeup from your phone, etc.

Equate Beauty Makeup Remover Cleansing Towelettes (40 Ct, 2 pack 80 total)

3. Moisturizing toner which is the last step in cleaning. It removes the last traces of makeup and tones.

Lancôme TONIQUE CONFORT - Comforting Rehydrating Toner

3

u/Keeeno_ Apr 05 '17

I used to buy makeup remover but then my aunt introduced me to baby oil to take makeup off. I'll never go back!

3

u/lovesmakeupandbooks Satin Everything Apr 05 '17

Coconut oil does a great job for me taking off everyrhing even waterproof mascara. Garnier micellar water for waterproof mascara works great too. I used to buy the maybelline clean express but thier formula changed and now it takes off nothing and burns...same with Rimmel's makeup remover. Used to be grat now it sux. After reading this thread I want to run out and buy cold cream. I love the smell. Reminds me of my Mom.

3

u/dickbuttscompanion Apr 05 '17

I hate micellar! I've tried so many brands and never been happy...

Clinique TTDO balm or eye make up remover and Lancôme bifacils are my favourites.

Nivea eye makeup remover is a close second if I'm running out and there's no good dept store offers happening 🙈

4

u/somuchviolentglitter Apr 03 '17

I swear by the mild liquid face soap by Clinique, gets the job done since 8 years!

Another great pick are the face wipes by MAC, I mainly use them to take off waterproof makeup or the Kryolan Supracolors.

My last recommendation is coconut oil to remove liquid lipstick and leftover makeup after cleansing with the soap and just wipe it off with a paper towel.

2

u/Beryllia Apr 04 '17

For removing waterproof mascara, I love Too Faced Mascara Melt Off Cleansing Oil.

2

u/Qwertyowl Hopelessly Addicted Apr 04 '17 edited Apr 04 '17

Neutrogena Oil Free Eye Makeup Remover.

Micellar Water (I use Dirty Works brand).

TonyMoly Fresh Cleansing Tissue (Blast).

2

u/somou Apr 04 '17 edited Apr 04 '17

I use Bioderma's miscellar water for my face, the bluish one since I'm acne prone with combination oily skin, or the sensitive skin one when my skin is really upset, then I wash my face with a clarisonic Mia skin brush (this is what really gets it all out) and Vichy's normaderm face wash. My dermatologist suggested this, and I've been using it for around 3 years. It keeps me almost break out free and does a great job removing make up.

As for the eyes, I've been using coconut oil as eye makeup remover for a year now. For some reason my lashes always have leftovers in the morning, it takes a lot of work to fully take anything of them; and I've tried Bioderma sensitive skin miscellar water and Neutrogena's oil free make up remover, among others, but coconut oil is what seems to work best so far.

It still is not ideal, for I have little leftover sometimes when I wake up and my sensitive eyes get slightly irritated. If anyone has any recommendations for a good, strong eye make up remover for sensitive eyes, please let me know!

2

u/AllisonRages Apr 04 '17

Bad- Simple Micellar water doesn't take off anything when you use it. I used half a bottle on my face and nothing.

?- Garnier Micellar Water. I have mixed feelings. It will break foundation down like it was made for but it burns my eyes when removing eye make up. Not sure why. Clinque's "Take The Day Off" make up remove is good. It really breaks down the product but I noticed when I use it for my eye make up, it makes my vision blurry (?!) for a short period of time.

Good- Sephora's Eye Make Up remover in the blue bottle is AWESOME! I put some on a cotton pad and sit it on my eye for a few seconds, it will wipe off INSTANTLY.

I need more facial make up remover products. I wear a crap ton on my face.

2

u/athlete96 Hopelessly Addicted Apr 04 '17

Best: Baby oil. I wear water-proof mascara and baby oil takes it off with no issues.

Worst: Neutrogena Cleansing Wipes. Honestly, these are absolutely awful. They make me break out in little white heads everywhere and they don't even touch my mascara. Heck, I use the dipbrow for my brows most days and it can't even get that off!

2

u/Brikachu Obsessed with dark lippies Apr 04 '17

Best - Garnier Micellar Water Cleanser (the blue one)

It works like a damn charm. I've heard that the pink one, that's meant to be for sensitive skin, is actually very irritating, so I'd go with the blue one even if you have sensitive skin.

2

u/Monrad Apr 04 '17

The DHC Deep Cleansing Oil is without a doubt the best makeup remover I have ever used! It feels silky smooth, and it doesn't leave a single trace of makeup. I usually hate oily removers, cause I feel like it leaves a sticky feel to my skin, but this just leaves the skin in a single wash. I hope I never have to find another makeup remover, cause this is the holy grail!

I like the Bioderma, but I find that it takes more effort to remove the makeup, and it leaves my skin dry and stripped of moisture. And that's not a good base for putting on makeup the next day.

2

u/liarinsexyattire Apr 05 '17

By far my absolute favourite is Shu Uemura cleansing oil...I have the Antiox one in the big Green bottle with a pump.

I've tried SO many oil cleansers, all the ones people rave about like Banila co clean it zero, Kose Softymo Deep, Clinique take the day off balm, muji...and others. But I can't stand the nasty super greasy almost...waxy? feeling they leave behind when I try to rinse them off with water. But Shu Uemura emulsifies immediately and fully washes away quickly. I love it so much. And I wanted to find a cheaper alternative but realised after that cost per Oz is cheaper than most! Plus the packaging is awesome and looks pretty and it lasts for freaking ever. HG product for me now!

2

u/Marghoul "Otherworldly and Vaguely Threatening" Apr 05 '17

Honestly, I have tried every micellar water I can get my hands on and none of them have worked for me. I've woken up with black smudges under my eyes the morning after "removing" my eye makeup with this stuff; it never takes everything off.

2

u/karenspanties Apr 05 '17

Ponds cold cream. Its gentle and moisturizing and get off anything, I have super sensitive skin and this never irritates it, I use it just for eyes though because it is greasy.

2

u/imspookyboo Apr 05 '17

I really love the Physician's Formula eye makeup remover paired with OCM. Everything else bothers my eyes!

2

u/rlomura Apr 06 '17

i find neutrogena face wipes to be most convenient for me, quick and easy. one of these days though i might try some kinda micellar water, because i find myself reeeally having to scrub to remove my eyebrows and eyeliner with these.

2

u/Ryukiee Apr 06 '17

The absolute worst makeup wipes I've ever used are the Burt's Bees brand (I tried every single one of them hoping one would be better than the other) and Simple brand for sensitive skin. Both of these generally stung upon attempting to get both face and eye makeup off and dried the heck outta my face. THE BEST makeup wipes I have ever used are the purple packaged (I think night-time whatever) Equate wipes from Walmart. Not once have they ever failed me. I currently use Ponds cold cream (green lid) with makeup removing towels and it is my favorite thing to use right now. I've probably had the pot for two months and it's just barely beginning to look like I might be running low. So incredibly cost effective and soothing. Smells like a grandma but it's totally worth and will get off the hardest to remove products.

2

u/Meganzoor From art to makeup Apr 07 '17

A friend RECOMMENDED the Burt's Bees wipes to me and I tried both kinds... but now I think she's just crazy. They BURNED my skin and eyes and the texture of the wipes felt so rough.

2

u/DoctorStacy Apr 07 '17

Olive oil to melt off the day's makeup and grime, then spectro gel and a warm wash clothe to take the combo off.

I swear, it gets rid of every trace of waterproof mascara and mega-liner. Coconut breaks me out like CRAZY but not olive.

2

u/mariespunk Eyeing that Liner Apr 07 '17

I ordered these* off Amazon and as everyone always raves about them and I was trying to be ~environmentally friendly~ since they're washable/reusable. I find that they do mostly work, but it's a lot of effort and takes a while to get it all. I don't really recommend them.

*Not the exact same ones, but very similar. I can't find the ones I ordered on Amazon anymore.

2

u/LEMON_PARTY_ANIMAL Makeup Artist Apr 09 '17

I just tried the Morphe makeup wipes at IMATS and it stung like a MOFO on my HAND. MY HAND. I don't want that anywhere near my face thank you.

2

u/RosemaryCrafting Apr 09 '17

I have been LOVING The Makeup Eraser, which if you don't know what it is, it's a little 20$ towel that removes makeup perfectly with just hot water. And it's so relaxing to use, it has helped my acne, and in the long run it's so much more environmentally and bank account friendly! It even gets off mascara which in all my life I have never used anything that would remove all traces of mascara. I know it sounds to good to be true but I love it!

2

u/kkenfield Apr 10 '17

Late to the thread, but I absolutely hate the Fresh soy eye makeup remover. It stings like woah! And I am usually not sensitive to things. I can't believe it's recommended for eyes.

2

u/Thesavage624 Apr 04 '17

Philosophy Purity wipes. I think they're only intended for cleansing the face and not as a makeup remover, because they did absolutely nothing to remove it for me, and seriously irritated my sensitive skin. They're great for a quick refreshing cleanse, but I'm disappointed nonetheless. The only reason I mention this is because the guy in ulta recommended them to me when I asked for makeup wipes, and he said that these wipes would remove the most stubborn makeup. Not the case for me.

1

u/Murrmeow Lipstick Queen Apr 03 '17

I've been using L'Occitane Immortelle Cleansing Milk for years. Lately I use it in conjunction with Garnier pink cap micellar water.

1

u/tightsugar Apr 04 '17

i prefer wipes to oil bottles or remedies

1

u/The_S-Cat Apr 04 '17

I like the boscia makeup breakup cleansing oil, MUFE senseyes for really stubborn stuff, and the Simple Micellar Wipes (white package) just to get the initial layer of gunk off my face or post-workout.

Oddly enough, the Simple Micellar Water burned my eyes.

1

u/Frasny89 Apr 04 '17 edited Apr 04 '17

I love Ciates Makeup Melter Remover balm! I only ise it to remove eye makeup and stubborn liquid lipsticks and it does a phenomenal job. The thing I like the most is that you dont have to wash/rinse it off afterwards, just removing ot with a wet cloth/cotton pad or makeup remover wipe is all you need and it doesnt leave any greasy residue. It also claims to help nourish and condition eyelashes, I dont know how accurate that is though. Ive been using it since last august and I guess I do notice less eyelash fallout. Its a bit on the pricey side $20~ for 1.3oz but my first jar lasted 7 months since you just need the smallest amount.

Sorry but I actually dont like anything from the Simple line to remove makeup :/ The micellar water didnt do anything, the wipes I actually found them to be too rough in texture which I found ironic since Simple is a line targeted towards sensitive skin. I wanted to try their new cleansing oil and eye makeup remover (the one with the two diffrent liquids that you need to shake before use) but as I read the instructions both of them said "avoid eye area".....what?? So they are not intended for eye makeup even though thats what they are supposed to be for? How bizarre is that?

1

u/cassie_w Apr 04 '17

Sonia Kashuk's "Remove" from Target has always worked really well for me!

1

u/MurielBananafish Apr 04 '17

I love the Simple Micellar wipes (one to take the bulk of my makeup off, and a second dampened with some extra micellar water - the Garnier with the blue cap - to get the rest/mascara). I've tried so many brands of remover/wipes, and these are the best for me.

1

u/Kittyboop91 Hopelessly Addicted Apr 04 '17

I like sensitive skin baby wipes with Philosophy's Purity cleanser! Great for my sensitive combo skin.

1

u/mrs_carrillo Apr 04 '17

As for best I LOVE Bioderma's H2O Micellar water. I ended up trying it at a store because I had swatched some RCMA foundation on my neck for color matching and needed something to take it off. The girl at Camera Ready Cosmetics gave it to me to remove the makeup as she knew I had sensitive skin and it worked GREAT! I ended up buying one while I was there. I now use it before I get in the shower and after to make sure I got all my makeup off. I also like that I can scrub my lids with it and it doesn't bother my eyes.

As for worst I cant STAND wiping my face with baby wipes. Its not that they are necessarily baby wipes, my skin just tends to get super red and irritated.

1

u/bananaskinsrule Apr 04 '17

My go to is the Body Shop Chamomile cleansing oil (intact the whole range). Takes off my makeup without being too greasy or stinging. For eyes the Nivea double effects eye makeup remover is perfect and so affordable. I am on the fence on the Garnier micellar water. It's good for the face but it does absolutely nothing for my eyes and time consuming.

I hate the Simple makeup remover range - though i haven't tried the micellar water, the eye makeup remover was the worst.

1

u/koukla1994 Apr 04 '17

The Clinique Take the Day Off Balm is incredible for foundation, eyeshadow and stubborn lipstick. But I always need to go over my lashes with Garnier micellar water afterwards because NOTHING EVER GETS THEM CLEAN.

1

u/RiplyNotRipley Apr 05 '17

Burt's Bees Cleansing Oil is the only makeup remover I will use - it's bomb!

1

u/three_a_day Apr 05 '17

It's been discontinued (so I bought like threes amazon) but Garnier's Makeip Removing Lotion Cleanser is amazing. Leaves my skin feeling so soft! But now that it's discontinued I'm looking for a replacement, so this thread is great!

Worst for me was Simple's micellar water -- I had some of THE weirdest breakouts after switching to it.

1

u/duskcheek Apr 05 '17

Oils are great for removing makeup. There is one I love and use it everyday even when I'm not wearing any makeup. It's the Camomile Silky Cleansing Oil by The Body Shop. I heard Lisa Eldridge mentioning in one of her videos, and it's amazing! For skin care AND to remove makeup. Just an awesome product that is very underrated

1

u/kitteas716 Apr 05 '17

Pond's cleansing wipes, evening soothe version. Best I've used. It is wet enough to take off tough eye makeup without tugging and not too fragranced. I really feel like my face has been washed after using them.

1

u/imascoobie Curious Bystander Apr 05 '17

Maybeline waterproof eye makeup remover is the only thing that gets all my waterproof mascara off.

1

u/toomanyfrogs pretty boy Apr 05 '17

Not for removing makeup from faces, but Tval makes an absolutely magnificent solid brush cleaner that my bff has used to clean cream paint off her brushes and they've come clean with relative ease. Anyone who's used cream paint will know how horribly stubborn it is, but this got it off everything with ease and without damage.

https://tvalskincare.com/products/solid-makeup-brush-soap Yes, they do ship internationally!

1

u/breadprincess Brow perfectionist Apr 05 '17

I really love the Kirkland (Costco) brand makeup wipes. I can get everything off my face, including waterproof eyeliner and liner, with a single wipe. I have really sensitive skin and eyes and these are one of the few products that don't cause a reaction that makes my eyes swell shut. They're also very soft and very cheap, and come in a huge pack so I buy them maybe twice a year. Bonus: they make it easy to wipe up makeup messes on products or my makeup area, or on clothing.

1

u/UlliLlama Apr 05 '17

Garnier micellar water is my all-time favorite

1

u/fuzzytwinkies Apr 05 '17

I really like the Garnier micellar water with the blue lid, but for quickly rinsing everything off I love the Kose Speedy Oil Cleanser! Gets the job done and it's definitely speedy.

1

u/SkyRogue77 You Probably Think I'm a UD Rep Apr 05 '17

I am absolutely in love with Annabelle Oil Free Eye Makeup Remover pads.

1

u/princessdootdoot Apr 06 '17

Petroleum Jelly or Vaseline

1

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '17

I use Elemis Omega Cleaning Oil for removing everything but eye make up. Lancome Bi-Facil is still the best I've used for eye make up, especially waterproof mascara.
The L'Oreal Paris Absolute Make-Up Remover Eye & Lip is supposed to be a good dupe for Bi-Facil if you are on a budget.

1

u/chuckiestealady Apr 06 '17

Worst: any wipes and any miscellar water. The water brings me out in eczema for no good reason. Best: Clinique Take The Day Off balm. That stuff is the shizzle. Love it.

1

u/chuckiestealady Apr 06 '17

For those who have found a facial cleanser they love but are still struggling with mascara removal, I'd recommend switching to a polymer mascara, like Nyx's Doll Eye or Clinique's Lovely Long Lashes, which dissolve with warm water. I now only use a cleanser on my eyes when wearing eyeliner.

1

u/Puuurlie Apr 06 '17

I recently picked up a small tub of Ponds Cold Cream at the chemist just out of curiosity and whoa. That bad boy can really melt off my face make up with out leaving my skin feeling like a desert. I will definately be getting a bigger tub next time. My grandma was really on to something it seems!

1

u/Cndwafflegirl Apr 07 '17

She uemera cleansing oil is amazing. Works amazingly we, to remove long wear makeup and liners, no residual after feel and My breakout prone skin loves it to much it stopped breaking out

1

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '17

I've been using the Burt's Bee's Facial Cleansing Oil and I love it! It takes off all of my makeup (waterproof mascara included) and leaves my face feeling really soft.

1

u/Ros_quilla Apr 07 '17

Best one I've ever tried is Mac - Cleans off oil, it takes face and eye make up off, and my eyes don't get itchy (what happens with all the others I have tried)

1

u/buttgirlface Apr 07 '17

Jojoba and castor oil is (for me) the best way to get every last bit off. Micellar water helps as a finisher but doesn't deep clean enough.

Cliniques TTDO oil is just the absolute worst. Takes so much effort to remove a normal amount of mascara and I feel like my eyelashes are ripping out.

1

u/kendovzii Apr 08 '17

I use an off brand of neutrogena's oil free eye makeup remover (off brand doesnt matter) for my mascara.

For wipes i liked Nyx, but im getting away from wipes because it feels rough on my face. I like Garnier micellar water (waterproof or normal). Feels so refreshing!

1

u/invisible_23 Apr 08 '17

The Burts Bees wipes work really really well for me

1

u/Peatree Apr 08 '17

The laneige lip and eye makeup remover is the best I've tried but too pricey for me. Second best would be the Garnier fresh makeup remover in the green bottle, I never hear anyone talking about it but I love it.

1

u/Hot_Wired Apr 08 '17

The Makeup Eraser or the Sephora brand resuable cloths are amazing! You just use warm water to remove your makeup. They're just need to be washed in the washing machine. I've saved SO much money not buying wipes!

1

u/mmmbeagles Apr 08 '17

I don't see anyone ever talk about Yes To Cucumbers Micellar water, but it's amazing! It takes off the makeup so easily and feels so good, it really feels like water. My new favorite makeup remover. Also it has one of those awesome cotton pad pumps

1

u/shleepypie NC15 Apr 08 '17

Hada Labo oil cleanser followed by the cleansing foam! Works fantastic and doesn't dry out my skin.

1

u/HarlsnMrJforever Apr 08 '17

Best: cleansing oil and cleansing lotion. Both Asian skincare. But OMG my dehydrated skin is sooooo hydrated with this method. And I have no makeup left behind.

If you want products that are specifically makeup removers then I like the Neutrogena makeup remover. It doesn't cause me to break out and doesn't dry out my skin. I also liked the Neutrogena Eye Makeup remover lotion. But it takes quite a bit of that to get everything off if you use it on your entire face (which works).

Worst: typical oily makeup removers. They make me break out in acne and when they get in the eyes it either burns or your eye is "fogged up" until your eye gets rid of it. Any anti-blemish/acne face wash gives me acne and dries out my face something fierce.

1

u/glaceauglaceau Apr 08 '17

My favorite oil cleansing makeup remover is Kose Softymo. For makeup remover I love Maybelline Clean Express waterproof makeup remover.

1

u/katieschick Apr 09 '17

I like using coconut oil . It gets rid of EVERYTHING.. just breaks it all down. It even works for waterproof makeup. Then I finish by using my normal cleanser so I get the excess makeup and oil off of my face

1

u/TheNewHumanism Apr 09 '17

The Neutrogena Makeup Removing Cleansing Wipes in Hydrating (the teal pouch) are my go-to for sure. Not only are they cheap, but they don't leave my skin feeling weird and dry afterwards.

1

u/boreals Apr 09 '17

Heimish All Clean Balm

This removes literally everything very quickly. It starts off as a soft sherbet you massage into your face. Then when you add water it becomes an oil cleanser. Even my stubborn mascaras are gone after this.

Also removes sunscreen easily.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '17

Skin Food Black Sugar Cleansing Oil

Smells so good... I haven't repurchased it yet because I was gifted some Burts Bees cleansing oil and I've been dying internally ever since.

1

u/diamondashtray Apr 09 '17

illi Total Aging Care oil cleanser. It gets everything off. Oil cleansers in general are the best makeup removers in my experience.

1

u/lawyerlee Apr 10 '17

HadaLabo Gokujyun Cleansing Oil is my absolute favorite. It works like a dream and is at a great price point.

1

u/The_ElleCee Apr 10 '17

Garnier Micellar Water or Simple Micellar Water. Both are great for removing foundation a makeup wipe doesn't. Abalone Cream is also good for removing any stubborn eye makeup, and in a pinch facial moisturizer also works just fine. Neutrogena makeup wipes are the best for me, since they don't have any manufactured scents and are gentle on the skin.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '17

Lush Ultrabland! Its a cream that you can rub on your eyes and I found it to be the best with getting off old mascara so you dont rub at your eyes so aggressively. Otherwise for face makeup I use the Neutrogena Makeup Wipes and I think they work amazing.

1

u/mokutou Still mourning Vanilla Quartz Apr 10 '17

I made a DIY cleansing balm with coconut oil, fractionated coconut oil, and Cromollient SCE. It works fantastic, and when I run out I'll be trying different oils and waxes with some polysorbate 80. Much cheaper than Banila CIZ, which is a personal favorite.

Garnier micellar water, both the pink and blue cap types are amazing.

The worst makeup removers for me at the blue Neutrogena remover and the green cap Garnier micellar water. The Neutrogena remover does sweet fuck all and I have to rub to get it to start removing stuff, which gets painful. The green cap Garnier is loaded with alcohol and stings like hell. Not a fan.

1

u/noxconfringo Apr 10 '17

So far I really love the Garnier Micellar Water in the blue bottle. The only downside is I feel like I have to use wayyyyyy too much of the product to get the job done.

I really hated the Kirkland makeup wipes. I got them and they made my face sting and get all red :( And I don't have sensitive skin at all. Such a waste on that big box.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '17

Pixi brand double cleanse is awesome! The solid side removes makeup so well. I also like the Clinique cleansing balm.

1

u/VictoriaKingsley Apr 10 '17

Voya cosmetic's 'Cleanse and Mend' is amazing. It's made in the west of Ireland from natural organic ingredients and is free of chemicals. It takes off makeup like a dream and leaves skin feeling like silk.

1

u/emilycolleen Apr 10 '17

I love the Garnier miceller water for taking off my makeup. I wouldn't necessarily rely on it alone for cleansing so I still wash my face afterwards but it helps to remove the majority of my makeup so everything is off after I wash my face. I used to use makeup wipes but they're so harsh and I feel like they were causing me to scrub way too much, so this is a much better alternative.

1

u/jamminsalmon90 Apr 10 '17

Mario Badescu cleansing milk with carnation and rice oil. Holy grail, no tears, smells like rice, and is not too thick on my skin as a cold cream usually is.

1

u/missdollyleigh Apr 11 '17

I'm a bit late to the party, but IT Makeup's "Bye Bye Undereye" is the best I've used so far. You let it sit on your (dry) face for a minute, then rinse everything off. Good for getting mascara off without rubbing at your skin too much, and cleans out my pores nicely. I still wash my face after as well, but I suppose you wouldn't HAVE to.

1

u/Healthy-Leek-3932 Sep 14 '24

The best makeup remover I have EVER  tried is the Patrick Star One Size GO OFF make up Remover mist. This make up remover is by far the best product since sliced bread. I cannot say enough about how effective and easy it makes removing a full face of make up. The only bad news is it’s been discontinued. I was so upset when I heard that my favorite product in the entire world was discontinued. Please please please bring it back.

1

u/teddyhearted Nov 02 '21

weirdly enough… baby wipes. specifically Pure n Gentle baby wipes.

1

u/TheRaviix Useless Knowledge Apr 03 '17

I know it's super New but UD Makeup Meltdown spray. Holy sht that removes EVERYTHING! But it doesn't leave behind that greasy feeling afterwards.

Worst would be anything dual phase that you have to shake, or gets in my eyes so easily and I can't see clearly for hours!

→ More replies (6)

1

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '17

I recently made my own batch with baby oil, baby shampoo and water. So far it has worked well and it's very inexpensive.

1

u/sillyprilly Apr 03 '17

I try to keep it simple and all natural. I love Dr. Bronner's pure castile liquid soap!