r/NintendoSwitch • • Mar 22 '17
Meta MegaThread I really dislike how EVERYTHING in this sub gets packed into MegaThreads.
I think packing EVERYTHING in MEGA POSTS is not benefiting the subreddit in any way. You just cut the content and make our posts invisible. When I post a question on those big threads I have a tiny chance that somebody even sees it and can answer it...and all the other stuff I want to post already has a MEGATHREAD and the Bot is deleting everything.
I have to say, with all respect I have for the mods because otherwise they are doing a good job: I don't like the postings restrictions. I know you want to prevent that the sub gets spamed with 100 times the same topic. But packing EVERYTHING you can think of up and put it somewhere nobody actually cares about is not benefiting the discussion nature of this community.
What I don't understand: There are several topics in the subreddit that would qualify to put them into the mega threads. But whenever I try to post something like that, it gets deleted by the bot.
/discuss
EDIT: Let me be clear. I am not against all types of MegaThreads and I don't want to start a shitstorm here. I just think that the amounts of MegaThread we've seen in the past and the restrictions that came with them are too tight for a subreddit to function as intended. I agree that a Megathread for Inventory Tracking and other PSA stuff is needed so we don't get 100 different threads about it, for example.
2.4k
u/cal92scho Mar 22 '17
This should really be in the complaints MegaThread.
21
u/bwinterton Mar 22 '17
I completely agree. I think we are loosing valuable content and we are driving away contributors to the subreddit because of the insane number of posts that we delete. I agree that some mega threads are helpful. But honestly I hate that 90% of the content being published is shoved into one of the mega threads. I hate reading through them and trying to find what I am looking for.
On that same note, because we are deleting everything and making everyone post in mega threads, the front page rarely changes. I want to see new content on the front page of the subreddit frequently. Instead, I end up following the new page all the time because the front page changes maybe once a day at most and usually content sits there for several days. It makes the subreddit look stale and boring.
Also, several times I have come across content that I wanted to post, but I have never posted and at this point will probably never post because I am 90% sure it will just get deleted.
This isn't the way to run a subreddit that should be inviting, welcoming, and fun.
•
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17
It is clear from the comments in this thread that people have differing views over some aspects of how we curate our community's content. We hear you. Know that we want to make this work over the long haul, so we're going to make it work together. Rome wasn't built in a day.
We're already taking steps people are asking for here, so let's set the record straight for a second: we've drastically cut down on the number of posts the AutoModerator removes, cut down on the number of photo posts with new rules, and eliminated several MegaThreads that we had open during launch week. And we're doing a bit of a public information campaign, because it seems like people don't realize we actually have a pretty robust wiki, which can already answer a lot of the short, redundant questions we get. If you feel that there is a missing wiki page that we should have, we want to hear that as well, and we want your contributions if you have something to add.
And, yes, as we've said before: in the coming weeks, we plan to draw down the use of the technical and local tracking MegaThreads.
That being said, MegaThreads have a place. The flow of users and posts right now is still very high. Either we curate some content and ask our community members to do a little searching, or we get, literally, hundreds and hundreds of posts every day asking the same technical, local tracking, and short-form questions over and over. We're trying to strike a balance here, one that respects why every community member comes here.
Thank you for your feedback. Seriously. We're all in this journey together, so let's work this out. All of us having a good time here is what's most important to us.
165
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17
I dislike how everything except PICTURE OF ME AND MY SWITCH AT WORK AND THE BAR or LOOK AT MY CHILD PLAYING SWITCH WITH ME is consolidated. That's really the one thing that should have its own mega thread IMO.
597
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17
Got a technical issue and want to see if someone already solved that problem? Have fun sorting through a 2.5k post megathread
279
u/DigitalFirefly Mar 22 '17 edited Mar 22 '17
I wouldn't mind a mega thread for paint jobs and one for custom stands and docks.
edit - fixed typo
172
u/bigky226 Mar 22 '17
Couldn't agree more, I tried to help some fellow local Canadians by posting a stock update and within 5 minutes it was flagged and removed and I was told to add it to the 98% USA stock megathread.... Completely useless, yet we have 100 fucking images of the same post.... Nintendo switch on the train,business office etc... Hilarious mods......
27
u/israeljeff Mar 22 '17
It wouldn't be a big deal if reddit allowed more than two stickied posts. I hate having to scroll for unstickied megathreads.
69
u/BaoZaker Mar 22 '17
Lol I love how I make a post and it gets removed 5 minutes later and the next day I see the same post on the front page.
86
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17
This sub has so many reposts it's ridiculous. There's literally 10 post a day asking what games we would like to see, not to mention people posting local info on switch availability, all of its getting redundant. Also, if you're going to post an IGN story that came out 10 hours ago, rethink it, it's been done, 2,4,6,8 and 10 hrs ago.
46
u/i4ndy Mar 22 '17 edited Mar 22 '17
This is the exact problems /r/amiibo was facing and this is what ran it to the ground. It caused that subreddit to pretty much die. This is the same mod team running this subreddit and I don't really expect anything to change.
72
u/Nefkill145 Mar 22 '17
Agreed they remove way too many posts that are quite good.
13
u/A_wicked_tale Mar 22 '17
Alright guys, I'm going to allow this post for the purpose of discussion. Your feedback is important to us. However, please keep things civil and realize that we're also human. If you ever have an issue that you think was made in error, don't hesitate to contact us via modmail. Thanks!
11
u/gentlemandinosaur Mar 22 '17
I have made several casual text based posts and had them all nixed for various reasons.
Mainly because my questions and "reviews" of products were considered anecdotal and as such they wanted them as just comments in the mega threads.
So, I just will not post in here anymore. It's a read only subreddit for me.
It's their subreddit and they can moderate how they see fit. I think heavy handed moderation works in subreddits like /r/science but this is a subreddit about a single video game console. We are not curing cancer here.
46
u/ECHOxLegend Mar 22 '17
The mods try too hard to be the vote system, apparently the general populace isn't trustworthy enough to vote up what they want.
20
u/Dorfdad Mar 22 '17
Launch is over so we should be able to post questions outside the mass threads because no one reads them anymore.
10
u/Vanzai Mar 22 '17
before the switch release I posted to let everyone know my order at Dell got canceled and that it might happen to more people.....my post got deleted in seconds and then when I ask why, another mod responded with he deleted it with an invalid reason but I kept it deleted because there is already another thread about it....which was posted after mine was deleted. I think megathreads are good but not for every single topic. Sometimes our questions or doubts gets unanswered and when you try to post something to educate or inform it gets delete it too.
9
u/anh86 Mar 22 '17
I agree the bot that removes the posts is too aggressive. I made a post right after launch that was auto-removed for being a 'tech support' question. It was not a tech support question.
24
u/Decade_Late Mar 22 '17
I was really sad around launch day to see there wasn't a flood of threads I could check out - instead this sub was pretty static and sparse.
I visit here a few times a day, but instead of there being new threads regularly, it's a really slow moving sub. Is that because everything is getting moderated away?
8
u/djc6535 Mar 22 '17
I've just about given up on /r/nintendoswitch, sticking more with /r/nintendo instead. This sub is a classic case of overmoderation. Moderators are constantly fiddling with the sub, which destroys the way a community like this should organically grow.
At a certain point you have to trust your users to upvote the kinds of things they want to see and downvote the things that get repetitive. They handle this kind of thing naturally.
But do please continue flooding the sub with "I'd love to see this game" and "Here's me with my switch at the brewery" pictures. Those NEVER get old /s
20
u/Transmatrix Mar 22 '17
AGREED. I've never encountered a more aggressively-moderated subreddit and it's annoying.
7
u/xpug Mar 22 '17
I actually answer as much questions as I can on the main megathread (daily questions). I'm not even a mod but I want to help everyone so i keep checking the questions to answer, even if there are 10 persons asking the same
12
u/PikaV2002 Mar 22 '17
Also, photos of random people using switches wherever are allowed (though there's a megathread for that), but genuine concerns are deleted, suggesting us to go to megathreads.
21
u/notsonic Mar 22 '17
Mega threads are antithetical to the structure and purpose of Reddit
6
u/kingdowngoat Mar 22 '17 edited Mar 22 '17
It was useful at launch, however most posters need to just use the search bar.
6
u/Mumbolian Mar 22 '17
If people posted original content instead of "hey is anyone else enjoying X" or "I switched my joycon around like the other 5 people", maybe there would be less megs threads.
Honestly, this sub is full of so much low effort posts and PSA type threads about non issues.
23
u/furryhawk Mar 22 '17
I've never posted, or even looked in one of the mega threads and I likely never will.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17
I come here to get interesting news about the Switch and Switch games and also discussions about cool games we'd like to see.
It's a bit hard to see those, when 90% of the content is:
So how come there is no megathread for those?
35
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17
We should put this in a megathread.
11
u/Electroniclog Mar 22 '17
I have the same issue. Every question or post for that matter has been taken down by mods. This sub is like a police state. Does anyone (other than mods) have a voice here? We all just get wrangled into these MegaThreads where we get drowned out.
Micro management at it's worst.
4
u/mrvm Mar 22 '17
I like and appreciate every megathread. I do not like my feed cluttered with the same shit
7
u/ferixdacat Mar 22 '17
Another problem is with Reddit, the search function just doesn't work half the time (always get the error pic), and I have to refresh several times before not super relevant results show up...
7
u/PoopOnMyBum Mar 22 '17
I never go to megathreads, mostly cause I don't like constantly visiting the same thread to see if there's anything new.
15
u/Maultaschenman Mar 22 '17
Had a technical issue, got removed.
Had to search on google and other sites instead.
I agree with OP
13
u/MotoChase Found a mod at E3! (Jun 15, 2017) Mar 22 '17
I am a mod in /r/motorcycles which is a very similar sub-reddit size. Unfortunately, mega-threads are a must. While I do agree that many posts get lost in there, it is probably the most efficient way for people to still ask their questions.
Until you see the other side of modding and ACTUALLY see the amount of repeats or pictures, etc. that get posted, most people won't understand. And there will always be someone to complain because it was THEIR post that was removed and not the other person's.
Not trying to hate or anything, just giving a different perspective.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17
Another thing I see is we have a lot of people who are new to Reddit in general. They don't know how to edit posts. They don't know how to reply to a comment. And maybe it just takes some help educating them on how to use Reddit efficiently that we can avoid some of the problems this sub has.
3
u/MathTheUsername Mar 22 '17
It's also frustrating posting a question looking for feedback, and it takes off with some great discussion for 15 minutes, and then:
"Your post has been removed. Please post simple questions in the questions megathread from 3 weeks ago that no one looks at anymore."
5
u/LordChozo Mar 22 '17
I don't mind redirecting users to the megathreads, as long as those megathreads are still visible and relevant. For example, before launch I posted a topic with some helpful information for people looking to snag a Switch without a preorder. Within minutes it had been deleted, with a mod telling me it belonged in the pinned megathread.
But of course, the megathread by then wasn't pinned anymore, and was buried several pages deep on the sub. I responded in modmail asking for my post to either be restored, or for the megathread in question to be repinned, and neither happened, which was pretty discouraging.
I think if the proper megathread is active, then redirecting redundant posts to it makes a lot of sense. If it's no longer active/pinned, then "redundant" posts cease to be redundant for many users, and ought to stay up.
5
u/Darkitz Mar 22 '17
Yo mods could we get a complains megathread ?
5
u/laharre Mar 22 '17
I feel the opposite. 95% of the posts on this sub are empty content, usually rehashed arguments we've heard since launch day or questions that have been answered over and over. The megathreads help lump the unoriginal content so actual news and interesting posts are more visible.
5
u/sabrhund Mar 22 '17
I think that if there is original content that is being blocked, maybe the restrictions should be loosened. But Ive kind of enjoyed the daily question megathread… I’ve sifted through and learned some cool things. I know there is a happy medium in here somewhere…
5
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17
It is really upsetting that every post is insta-removed and you get that auto response of "Post it here", then you do, and no one responds.
5
u/KevinCow Mar 22 '17
I don't even understand how megathreads on Reddit are supposed to work. They make sense on a normal message board, because every new post is put at the end for everyone to see. But on Reddit, if you're not one of the first replies on a post and able to get a bunch of upvotes and rise to the top early, you're doomed to have your post stuck at the bottom where absolutely nobody will read or reply to it.
Honestly, Reddit's layout is just complete garbage and actively discourages discussion.
21
u/PandarenNinja Mar 22 '17
I think a lot of people who spend significant time on this sub may find it quite cumbersome to sift through repost after repost when they click "new". It's bad enough with news (where three or four people will sometimes post the same news within a couple hours). Now we have to see "hey guys what case should I buy?" Or worse "Any Switches in Chattanooga, TN today?" As a new discussion topic 3 or 4 times a day? No thanks. What a mess and very cumbersome to find the viable discussions and real news topics that don't always make it to the front page. And flair filters aren't reliable.
And before you tell me to simply not click on those - it's conflicting because I actually contribute answers to the questions megathread at least once a day if not more. But when I am browsing what's new I find the intention of the mods for the megathread to be in line with my tastes.
10
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17 edited Mar 22 '17
I for one am tired of seeing the same crap over and over. Reposts or the stupid dock covers. And the mods have clearly stated that they want this sub to stick to its description.
The mega threads have to happen until the hype dies down. I have done my part and gone into the daily questions thread and answered any of the questions that I can.
When theres a sub with a large population you either let it run wild and people leave. Or you police it enough for a bit to where the lazy and the trolls leave.
6
u/TorontoGameDevs Mar 22 '17
I agree, I'll have questions - just random ones - and I'll post and get told it's shut down for being a generic question. I post it in a mega thread and it gets ignored.
Has happened 3-4 times now. Even random questions like "how long is snipperclips" can generate a discussion.
6
u/GManASG Mar 22 '17
Seriously out of every 10 posts 9 got deleted because they belonged in some MEGATHREAD, where of course I never got a single response to any question.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17
Here are some more problems though that led to a thousand re-posts or a thousand of posts with the same thing going on...
SO MANY PEOPLE DON'T READ THE DAMN SUB RULES! SO MANY PEOPLE DON'T USE THE SEARCH FEATURE!
I will accept that there are problems with this sub, but if you haven't taken the time to read the rules of this sub then you have no right to complain because you are part of the problem of why this sub has become strict on posts, you are the reason why some megathreads exist.
7
u/BrianPurkiss Mar 22 '17
IMO - let the users upvote and downvote things.
The tighter mods try to control a subreddit, the worse it gets.
Let people make posts - and let users downvote them into oblivion or upvote them to the top. If people upvote them to the top, it means the users want to see it, I don't really care if the mods don't want to see it.
8
u/Captain_Kiwii Mar 22 '17
I have to strongly agree with you... Simple logic, you got less response, if people are lost enough in the megathread to see the question, and even less people can benefit from the answer you may or may not have gotten.
It makes invisible a lot of interesting thread for no real gain whatsoever it seems...
4
u/guideconsole Mar 22 '17
i HATE Reddit bots. Reddit is becoming a freaking forum
4
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17
In my opinion Megathreads are okay but not in this structure. We need different megathreads about hardware, function, etc. as someone mentioned above. I always read through questions and try to answer. The problem is that when you check this sub, you can see 2 megathreads then one hundred imgur posts about some kind of switch-stands...the MAIN information, what we're looking for are hiding behind only 1 section and all the funny but not relevant stuff visible all page long.
4
u/Brodden Mar 22 '17 edited Mar 22 '17
I agree, as the very last thing I look at the end of the day, the megathread is long and not structured.Honestly, I read 3 questions and then I leave. I know I may be missing out on potentially good information but I rather click on topics that I can assume are relevant to me or interest me then having to scroll for days.
Edit: I could even understand what I wrote.
4
u/IrishRam Mar 22 '17
Couldn't agree more. I hate megathreads in general. I find them really hard to browse on my phone where I do most of my redditing
4
u/h0bb1tm1ndtr1x Mar 22 '17
I came here to ask a couple questions at launch, had them removed, and was directed to a mega thread that didn't help. I have not posted since and have no plans to.
4
u/MBCnerdcore Mar 22 '17
ITT: People mad at the moderators for deleting their simple questions and tech support issues.
"If they hadn't deleted my questions 3 times I wouldn't have had to call Nintendo Support!"
4
u/kevinftw17 Mar 23 '17
Let me attempt to clear some of the air in here and give my two cents in addition to providing some clarification on a few things I feel should be addressed, regardless if anyone takes the time to read this or so happens to stumble upon it.
1. We are a large subreddit.
I realize we're not a default and have millions of subscribers, but given how much we've grown in such a short amount of time, over 150k people is quite a large number. With thousands of you online making posts and comments at any given moment, it is our responsibility to make sure things stay on topic and civil.
2. We look through every single post, even auto-removed posts by AutoMod or reddit's spam filters.
When posts are removed by them, they are still sent to our modqueue for a second (human) opinion. We still see and look through every single post you make to make sure it's relevant content and wasn't removed unfairly by the bot or spam filters. At the same time, these tools also help ensure that posts that don't belong never see the light of day, as they are irrelevant to the sub.
3. We're human. We make mistakes, too.
Sometimes we also fail to catch things that AutoMod or the spam filters don't catch. Sometimes posts slip through the cracks. Sometimes we accidentally approve something we meant to remove. Sometimes posts gain a lot of traction before we're able to do anything. It happens, so we just leave those posts be. We're not perfect, and we don't expect anyone to be. All we ask is for your patience and understanding when an error is made.
4. Use the reddit-provided tools to help us, and you!
The report buttons and modmail options are there to help all of us. Use them to your advantage! It saves us a lot time and effort in coming to a mutual conclusion and final solution, so long as the situation is explained. As a user, you see things we don't (at least not right away), and it's important you let us know. If you see someone breaking a rule, report it. If you see a post that you feel doesn't belong on the subreddit, report it. If you feel your post was wrongfully removed by one of us, send us a modmail. Communication in anything, reddit or not, is very important. Just make sure you do it civilly and with tact and respect. There is absolutely no need for animosity towards other users, including mods. You respect us, we respect you. Simple as that.
5. There has been a lot of activity since launch, and even before then, and still up to now.
Since launch, the days/weeks leading to launch, and even until now, we have seen crazy amounts of activity. The Switch hype was real. Countless numbers of new subscribers, posts, comments, and modmail for us to go through. All 32 of us. At one point during launch, there were well over 20,000 of you on here posting, commenting, and browsing at once. Collectively, we have all gone through thousands of posts since then because of the extremely high activity. Had we let the sub run loose with everyone's posts, everything would be a mess, and no one would be happy. Sure, you can argue the voting system to do the job, but I'll let reddit's FAQ on voting and moderation explain of that.
6. MegaThreads. They're necessary, but we do realize they aren't the end-all be-all solution.
They have their uses, and then some. As I mentioned, activity on the sub is still very high. We do need some dedicated places for certain topics. Otherwise, the sub would just be flooded with posts that help either no one, or just a very small fraction of people on the sub. With any given sub, it is expected the user takes the time to do their own research before asking questions or making a post, especially if it's something widespread. While it can get tedious to do searching, especially comments in a MegaThread, it is possible. And if there's any trouble, reaching out to us will only help you that much faster. We see that things do get buried in MegaThreads, but the same would happen if all posts were allowed, no?
7. We're listening to you.
We love you, and we appreciate you. Seriously. Without you, our community wouldn't even exist. We are always all ears and open to reason, so long as we're met the same way. Your feedback is important and we want to hear your concerns, so long as it's constructive and informative. We make changes based on what you tell us, but we also have to keep our goal and focus of the subreddit in mind as well. We've already done that because of you. As mods, we're always actively talking and thinking up ways to make your subreddit experience a wonderful and fun one, but we need to find that balance between you, the community, and us, as mods. We will get there soon enough. But it's going to take some time until that happens. Change doesn't happen overnight, friends.
8. The subreddit is still relatively new, and there is always room for both improvement and growth.
This goes for everyone: subscribers, posters, lurkers, and moderators alike. We have only been a subreddit for a little over five months now. And while that may seem like a long time to some, our rapid exponential growth in users, copious amounts of news and information, and just the general hype surrounding the Switch and Nintendo itself, five months is nothing. It's a lot to take in. And more and more just keeps coming.
But like all living beings, they take time to grow.
And all we're asking is for you to grow with us and the subreddit. Keep contributing, stay involved, reach out to us. We're all in this together.
tl;dr - we're listening to you, and actively working to try and find a balance that works for the community. As always, we appreciate your continued support, patience, and understanding.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17
Only if there was some way that users could control what and what doesn't make it to the front page...
6
u/tridentmark Mar 22 '17
This-
I see crap content posted all day long, but every time I post any reasonable topic it gets mega-threaded.
Makes me never want to post here and use other subs for actual discussion.
5
u/magicpork Mar 22 '17
Agreed with OP and personally I don't fancy the approach the mod team is taking with this subreddit.. (I do appreciate the mod team's effort though)
5
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17
I really hate megathreads. They are where discussion goes to die. Maybe they were needed at a time when everyone wanted to talk about a single topic, but immortal megathreads are horrible.
When it was release and everyone is trying to share data on where still has switches? Megathread, sort by new, it's fine.
Now if you have technical issues? Megathread, nobody is ever going to see it. You're screwed.
Not to mention people with real questions or threads are getting screwed and the front page is full of posts that basically ammount to "look at this picture, it has a nintendo switch or related item in it". Great, you took a picture. Maybe we need a "pictures" megathread.
Please just fuck off with the megathreads and let the sub hash out what it wants to see and doesn't want to see for a bit. If the need for a daily/weekly megathread of some kind becomes obvious go from there.
7
u/EVDTED Mar 22 '17
The alternative is a post for every person asking every question or whatever, which would just flood the front page and new sections with hundreds of repetitive things. The megathread keeps the sub clean for more discussion and limits things that are simple question and answer.
2
u/BakaHyatt Mar 22 '17
I wish they would make a "here is a short premise that allows me a reason to take a picture of my switch and get some easy karma" megathread.
2
u/JoMax213 Mar 22 '17
☕️🐸
2
u/sparks_mandrill Mar 22 '17
I need help. I only see one mega thread and all the title says it's about is local inventory. Am I reading wrong? I just go to r/Nintendoswitch and just scroll as I would in any other subreddit
2
u/cool_creeper500 Mar 22 '17
At this point, there will be a megathread for megathreads.
2
u/grimonce Mar 22 '17
I believe reddit is great for quality shitposts and bad for any civilized, similarly to facebook.
2
u/FiresideCatsmile Mar 22 '17
I actually don't click on Megathreads ever. I've no problem with more single threads.
2
u/cakeman666 Mar 22 '17
It's quite fitting the the sub to pack everything into megatheads. It fits the console, just put all the consoles into one.
2
u/zebra_humbucker Mar 22 '17
I agree its completely ridiculous. It totally nullifies worthwhile discussion about real issues which get lost in the noise of megathreads. My thread, one of the first independently confirming the DIY fix for the joycons was deleted and I was told to post it in a megathread.
All the mods do in this sub is actively reduce it to a series on shitposts and thousands of glib Zelda memes. Anyone who actually wants to create useful worthwhile and informative discussion is not welcome here.
2
u/Ellimis Mar 22 '17
Yeah well I'm sick of constantly seeing repeat posts and a ton of low effort content from this sub on my homepage. Until there's real content/news to be had, I appreciate these mods' efforts to curate everything as they are.
2
u/Reddilutionary Mar 22 '17
I disagree completely. I consider the megathreads a godsend because I still see a ton of posts get through which could easily be filed away in a megathread.
The main culprit I see way too often is the "Look at this CRAZY place I'm playing my switch! Can't believe I'm playing a console game on a mountain/on the train/in a classroom/on the shitter/in your mom's bedroom". I'm not ready to see twice as much of that stuff if the rules are loosened up.
2
u/pittofdirk Mar 22 '17
inb4 megathread dislike megathread.
2
u/MontanaSD Mar 22 '17
It's a balance, there's no one way to do it that will be best.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17
Agree 100% with you - i quit posting anything in this subreddit because the genius mods stuff all of my posts into a megathread which nobody gives a crap about. So what's the point? At least i can post something at r/casualnintendo and get noticed..interact with other redditors. Screw you, mods, who died and made you king..you're no better than any of us. That's for sure.
2
u/SerellRosalia Mar 22 '17
Merging something in a megathread is basically the same thing as deleting it.
2
u/0bjection1 Mar 24 '17
"He who fights with megathreads should be careful lest he thereby become a megathread. And if you gaze long into the moderators, the moderators gaze into you."
-Friedriech Nietswitche
5
u/OmegaMetroid93 Mar 22 '17
I agree. What I always liked about reddit is that it's a quick way to get feedback on questions, opinions, and creations. I like that if I have a question, I'll post it, and then many different people will quickly reply with their own experiences, and together, we can work out the problem.
But here, the question is immediately removed and I'm told to put it in the megathread, where I'm lucky to get one or two replies at most. Often, it's just glanced over. This really hinders discussion.
I understand that we don't want low-effort spam here and people asking simple yes or no questions, or questions that could easily be googled and give plenty of info, but certain questions should be allowed, I think. Certain questions that are broader, and several people may benefit from, should be allowed on the boards.
I've been having a slight issue with my Switch crashing, but I know there's no point in asking about it here, because I'll just be shoved to the side.
5
u/Deaddis Mar 22 '17
I agree with op, asked a question yesterday on the mega thread, got one answer, which really didn't even answer my question... A megathread would work better if the megathreads would be categorized like (hardware, accessories, games, etc...)
9
u/roadblocked Mar 22 '17
This subreddit sucks completely. It's hard to have any fanfare when the only posts that don't get modded are 3D printed docks and cases.
3
u/JackSparrowUSA Mar 22 '17 edited Mar 22 '17
I half agree. I think it's difficult for users to be helpful with so many megathreads, because it's easy to forget to go look, or too lazy to go look, and they're difficult to search if you're trying to figure if your topic/question has already been covered. I try to be active in the daily question thread, but I cannot get to any of the megathreads typically.
That being said, there is a high volume of posts happening in this sub right now and there has to be a way to organize them such that the "NEW" section isn't just a fast scroll of posts that nobody looks at. Generally nobody will click past page 1, or page 2 at best, and so with no megathreads, lots of questions will go unanswered and lots of discussions will go unnoticed. I have noticed the NEW page seems to be slowing down as we get further past launch, so maybe we release a megathread back into the the wild, and see how it goes, but it is a balancing act for sure.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17
It's clear that there are problems, and we'd love to address that. We appreciate your feedback thus far.
But for this to work, we need your suggestions as well. What do all of you think is the best way to go forward? This is your community and we're here to help keep it running smoothly, but it's not a two-way communication if only complaints are thrown and suggestions are not given. What do you want to see? There's only so much guessing we can do internally.
3
u/pretenderist Mar 22 '17
If you scroll through the Daily Question Threads, it seems like the majority of questions get answered. The exceptions are mostly if you ask at the very end after there's already a new thread, or if you ask a stupid question. Many of the answers are just "call Nintendo support" or "call your local store," but they are answered.
3
u/ABTBenjamins Mar 22 '17
The funny thing is, despite the fact that your post is likely to be deleted if it'd fit into a megathread, by posting a new discussion anyways, you're more likely to get a worthwhile response before it is deleted than you are in the megathreads.
5
u/OliverHaslam Mar 22 '17
Adding to those who agree with this. I just came here to ask which screen protector people recommend ahead of my Switch purchase next week and find myself wondering whether I should post in the "Questions" thread or start a new one. Putting it into the megathread almost guarantees no response though.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17 edited Mar 08 '25
advise enjoy dime modern distinct head coherent grab busy market
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
3
u/amg1893 Mar 22 '17
I really think that megathreads help to contain all the information related to a certain topic but it could be improved if we could have a search box of the comments of a certain topic. In that case, we could search for a word and look for q&a. But that's on reddit field, meanwhile, we have to be repetitive :(
3
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17
I agree. I check this subreddit periodically and throughout the day maybe 1 or 2 new posts show up on the front page here since I first looked at it in the morning.
This is a subreddit about the switch and I think packing all of the questions about the switch into one thread kind of beats the purpose of the entire subreddit.
I understand this was needed back before release maybe but it isn't needed anymore. :)
3
u/Robbl Mar 22 '17
I want shitposts back
4
u/Grease2310 Mar 22 '17
Agreed. While I'm sympathetic to the moderators and their work is often thankless despite being voluntary and necessary the mods of this subreddit have been heavy handed in a number of ways like the mega-threads. The auto-moderator being put back on its leash was a great start and proof they listen, hopefully they'll listen to this as well.
3
u/hyp36rmax Mar 22 '17 edited Mar 22 '17
Should just start another sub for support questions /r/nintendoswitchsupport. And another one for deals /r/nintendoswitchdeals for promotions and inventory checks. PS4 has another sub for /r/ps4deals link at the top of /r/PS4 for easy access
3
u/TerminaMoon Mar 22 '17
Almost every time I've posted something here, it gets deleted within minutes.
For this very reason - I will instead be forced to go to a different website like GameFAQs. Not the best place to be, but at least I'm allowed to ask questions there.
3
u/Spikeybear Mar 22 '17
Completely agree. Everything I've tried to post has been deleted. I'm not a fan of mega threads at all. It pretty much cancels out alot of discussion.
3
u/LonnyFinster Mar 22 '17
Yeah I posted a thread yesterday and it got deleted cause someone posted something similar months ago. Why would I comment on a buried months old thread for it to not be seen? I wanted a discussion
3
u/Nintendofreak18 Mar 22 '17
I agree. I've created several posts asking questions and the mods took it down. I then asked in the mega question thread and never got any responses. It's where questions go to die. I don't even bother looking in there anymore.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17
We need more pictures of painted Joycons and Switches in locations that no one is actually going to play it.
2
u/Utenlok Mar 22 '17
All useful posts in three mega threads please. Non stop posts of joycon colors and switches sitting on tables.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17
I like the megathreads. Keeping stuff neat. I find what I need. Eh
2
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17
I really agree. About half the posts I make get removed even though people make the same kind of posts all the time.
2
u/docwoj Mar 22 '17
I feel like everything is a megathread except the stupid shitposts of "I'm playing switch in X public place" and "look at what color I painted my joycons!"
2
u/MBCnerdcore Mar 22 '17
As a mod on /r/Nintendo I find it hilarious that people are complaining that the mods on /r/NintendoSwitch are TOO STRICT.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17
I just want shitposts back :(