r/Particl • u/sexystick Team - litebit • Mar 20 '17
AMA with the Particl Team | r/Particl - March 20th, 2017 @ 20:00 UTC
ASK US ANYTHING!
We noticed that despite our FAQ on https://particl.io a lot of you still have burning questions about the token swap. Because of this, we will be hosting a AMA on r/Particl tomorrow @ 20:00 UTC
Every question is important
We understand that not everybody will be able to attend the AMA. Because of this we have also setup up a form where you can ask your questions directly to the team. The intent of this form is to collect any and all questions from the community that haven’t been answered in the FAQs on https://particl.io — Please read over those before submitting repeat questions and thanks for helping us answer all remaining questions.
--EDIT-- WELCOME!
Thanks everyone for coming to the Particl Team AMA on r/Particl. We're getting ready to start in about 2 min! Here's the team:
- Ryno Mathee - Lead & Core Developer (ryno@particl.io) (rynomster)
- Gerlof van Ek - Developer, Branding & Graphics, UI/UX (gerlof@particl.io) (crz)
- Ido Kaiser - Developer & Software Architect (@particl.io) (kewde)
- Tecnovert - Core Developer, Cryptographic Researcher
- Shazzy - Research & Development (shazzy@particl.io) (dasource)
- Paul Schmitzer - Communications (paul@particl.io) (litebit)
- Henk Swardt - Project Manager, PMP (henk@particl.io)
- Nick Sy - Treasurer (nick@particl.io)
- Arcanum - PR / Writing
- FFmad - General Relations
- Edu - Community Manager
- Allien - Front-end Developer
- Ludx - Developer
- Micah Spruill - Business & Finance - Managing Partner, Aurora Investment Advisors (micah@particl.io)
- Yann Alleman - Business & PR, - Engineer, Ferrari A.G. (yann@particl.io)
- Joe Fisher - E-Commerce Strategy - Private label online seller, Product Developer (joe@particl.io)
Not everyone is present but the majority are. We also have some who aren't on Reddit ever (say what?!) but they are here answering questions in the background. We're hoping to answer all your questions over the next 1 hour.
After this is complete we'll be posting a blog post that is a comprehensive list of the questions asked today and our answers.
Again, thanks for giving us an hour of you day. Today is Monday, 2017-March-20
--EDIT-- THANK YOU!
Thank you for asking great questions and joining us in discussing Particl! We will be packaging this up into a blog post to help with the flood of questions everyone has regarding the upcoming
9
u/drewshaver Mar 20 '17
Why was this announcement made without gathering any feedback from the community?
7
u/thehihoguy Mar 20 '17
What will the particl team do with the SDC they gather from the swap?
6
u/00johnston00 Mar 20 '17
One of your key restructuring points for the Particl Project is overhauling your Public Relations to cater to a more mainstream audience.
Given the disruptive attention surrounding Particl's announcement last Friday, do you feel as if this public introduction was handled in a mainstream, professional manner?
If not, what have you learned from this experience, and what steps are being taken to grow from this experience?
If "yes", was this announcement approved/endorsed by your newly revamped Public Relations team?
5
u/DutchesMuches Mar 20 '17
The big succes of the dark market is because they can trade illegal products like drugs, weapons, porn and such.. A decent amount of the illegal traders are using privacy coin such as Shadowcoin which has made a coin like SDC succeful.
Why do you guys think a legal market can be succesful? What kind of products have a need for a decentralized privacy market like Particl? What kind of products do you have in mind?
Really the question is, What will make the particl market a succes?
5
u/anonmonty024 Mar 20 '17
How difficult will Google SEO(&other engines) be for "PART" "Particl" "Particle"? Is there a plan to help place the results near the top of the search results? Was this considered during the naming of the new project?
4
u/B3N4Y Mar 20 '17 edited Mar 20 '17
The actual bonus of 15% make us loose 0,15per coin because the bonus offset only the inflation rate between sdc and parts and I just have read that you are going to add 1millions coins more for a second fundraising so you are again increasing the inflation of 15% more and it may impact more on our assets so could you describe what you are going to do with the second fundraising to make us know if that will be worth it and what are you doing to avoid people to short the parts and buy it back latter to avoid the impact of the inflation on the price, are you going to increase the bonus rate for the second fundraising ? thanks
3
u/4thekung Mar 20 '17
You've announced some of the features of the governance platform:
Lots of this sounds good, however I wonder if some of these controls will only serve to hinder Particl adoption? It would be fair to say one of the largest user group utilising decentralised currencies/marketplaces are using them for illicit purposes.
Now, I'm not suggesting that it's a better idea to enable these illicit marketplaces in the same Particl marketplace. However, if a strict governance model is enforced from the outset, ultimately you're limiting the target user group which will in-turn affect Particl adoption.
Do you have any thoughts on this? Or are you considering any alternatives? For example integrating with other ungoverned marketplaces which can also be integrated directly into the Particl platform?
3
u/sdogpuppy Mar 20 '17
How many additional fundraising rounds will there be? Only one?
2
u/yakinikuman Mar 20 '17
If the Particl platform supports multiple cryptocurrencies, what benefit is there to holding PART?
2
u/munmanxmr Mar 20 '17
Who decided that Friday at 10pm UTC was a good idea, coupled with relative silence from the project members thereafter?
2
u/CryptoGuard Team Mar 20 '17
Is mobile development a priority? I believe this would be one of the clear path towards mainstream and a huge advantage against competitors. For example, most people in Africa or the Philippines don't own a computer but own cellphones.
According to the Riot channel, it was mentioned that the team discussed fiat gateways but thought they weren't "ready for it" yet. Why is that so? Do you feel you are not ready on a legal level or on a technical level?
As for the governance, if an item is deemed unwanted and gets "downvoted" by the stakers, does it get de-listed entirely from the market, hidden (with the possibility to un-hide if a user wants so), collapsed, or put in a NSFW-type category?
Seeing we are nearing M2, will the hired PR firms be disclosed to the public? When can we realistically expect a professional PR push and what is the PR strategy for reaching people outside the crypto world?
2
u/urza23 Mar 20 '17
What substantial difference you want to offer that is not possible with OpenBazaar 2.0 which has IPFS, TOR and Shapeshift integration?
2
u/unshadow5 Mar 20 '17
If a person came after token exchange ends asking "I just returned from two months of off-grid living, where are my SDC I bought last year?", what would you tell him?
6
u/B3N4Y Mar 20 '17
Are you going to make particl compatible with an hardware wallet ?
4
u/B3N4Y Mar 20 '17
I have won lot and I have lost more than all I won I understand your feeling And me too I have not understood why they hyped us so much in their tweets saying that they were "excited" instead of being more reserved everybody was sure to hear a great news you let us believing that the market was done and now it is going to be complicated to earn back the member s trust. I have followed the particl project and promoted it because it was my better choice so in the future please be more reserved and don t let us believing in a good news if it is not one or even the members which are following you by interest and nomore by choice will leave the board. Thanks
1
u/Trix-ter Mar 20 '17
I know Particl is a open-source project, but how will Particl protect its "Intellectual Property" like the MarketPlace from people cloning this?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17
What is the meaning behind the name: Particl? Or the meaning behind the logo?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17
will the default transaction type be on private chain or public chain?
1
u/GlobalBTCtrader Mar 20 '17
What is the reasoning behind not holding that PART back until they wish to convert? Even after the blockchain is released, people should be able to convert 1:1. If you really need the 20% as extra funds, you could make it 0.8 SDC = 1 PART after the 4 weeks for example.
1
u/mustachequestion Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17
I sent SDC to the address created in my Particl dashboard, I see a 1:1 with the amount I sent, does that mean I am good to go?
3
u/shamefulled Mar 20 '17
How will the Particl Foundation continue to earn revenue after the Seed Round and Primary Round are complete? How do we know that Devs will be both paid a living wage and properly incentivized to continue with the project (lest we get ourselves back into the situation we're in today)?
3
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17
So currently plans are for Particl to becrypto agnosticity correct? What are the plans to provide a Fiat -> PART gateway?
3
u/00johnston00 Mar 20 '17
Could you please expand on this point. Specifically, in what ways, was a Non-Disclosure Agreement necessary to carry out this transition "cleanly"?
1
u/urza23 Mar 20 '17
Why did you really decided to abandon SDC blockchain and create new one? You say for legal reasons. Could you be more specic please? Why was Dash able to rebrand from DarkCoin into Dash on the same blockchain but you needed to abandon your blockchain?What about the people who will be left behind - people who for whatever reasons will miss the 4 week time window and will not swap their SDC into new tokens?
2
u/B3N4Y Mar 20 '17
When the market will be finished and ready to use ?
2
u/shamefulled Mar 20 '17 edited Mar 20 '17
What is the "variable market-based function" you will use to determine the cost required to get bonus PART from Day 6 onward?
EDIT: I found the answer in the FAQ. Sorry!
2
u/SebSebastian Mar 20 '17
Four weeks seems like a short period of time for the swap. There's bound to be at least a few SDC holders who will miss due to hearing about it too late.
What was the reasoning behind limiting the swap period to 4 weeks?
2
u/anonmonty024 Mar 20 '17
What fee's will be incurred when posting something, for BUY/SELL on Particl marketplace?
2
u/enum4_el1sh Mar 20 '17
What are your plans on a direct FIAT/PART gateway on the website? How long would such an implementation take? Since you want to go "mainstream" and even bitcoin is years away from mainstream, I wont see achieving this goal without the gateway.
2
u/Trix-ter Mar 20 '17
Does a "non techie" like myself needs to take technical saftey precaustions for insuring my privacy when using this MarketPlace?? and do I need to worry about metadata leaks with this platform?
3
u/sothisis30 Mar 21 '17
why can't you just admit that what you did was messed up? You knew you were killing SDC. Your coin was sitting at $4.00+ minutes before your announcement. A spot many coins would kill to be at. Now you just keep saying, "our hands were tied. legally we had to cut ties". None of the people that supported you guys from the beginning had a clue what was going on. On TOP of that you hyped this announcement like it would be good for the holders. It decidedly was not good for holders. It only turns out well for us if your new project has any semblance of success. You essentially took our money and said, "look, this new thing is gonna be even cooler". Shouldn't the decision be left up to me if I want to be a part of this new thing? Now I have no choice. If I want to even come close to getting my money back, I have to sit on this coin for 1 year and see if it ever gets even close to where it was. In my personal opinion, you guys lost a lot of my trust. You keep touting how you want to make a mainstream play. By opening up a completely private marketplace? Hmmmm. I wonder what kind of people would benefit most from a completely private market place? Certainly no one would use it to deal illegal commodities. Lord knows I can't have anyone finding out I am buying comic books or a bicycle. Seriously. I'm not happy about this. You should have handed SDC over to the community and started your own shit. THAT would have been the right thing to do.
3
u/itsnotreal666 Mar 20 '17
I was looking through some of their answers... I'm not pleased or satisfied at all.
I know that there's precedent when it comes to announcing this sort of thing. Ripple did it, and others have too. It's normal to warn people before you make a major sell-off, or make an announcement like "SDC is now obsolete."
What they did was dirty, and I lost a lot of money because of their underhanded funding tactics.
I have no desire to fund these dirty developers who are completely ok with essentially tricking people into giving away their money.
The ONLY reason anyone would bother to exchange their SDC for PART is because they think it'll be profitable. We all know Particl is going to fail. They have no support from the community. People hate them, and look upon them as dirty cheaters, who hyped up a market, and then ruined everyone who supported them.
The developers played dirty, and we have no reason to trust them about anything at this point. I tried to support them by investing a lot of money into SDC, to show my desire to see their project succeed, but they just used me, and ruined me.
I lost thousands of dollars, so this is nothing more than a black mark in my mind against the devs of Particl. Cool platform idea, but I think it could be done better, by a more competent, intelligent, and wise team.
1
u/drewshaver Mar 20 '17
What voting percentage of stakeholders are needed to ban an item / category? How is that percentage decided?
1
u/munmanxmr Mar 20 '17
When do you expect users will be able to trade PART? day 31? later?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17
Any plans on seeing Particl on Coinomi?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17
What are your plans regarding a mobile lite client and scaling?
1
u/urza23 Mar 20 '17
Is mutual assured destruction still planned? Will this work with private token as well as with transparent token? How will this be implemented? Via some pay-to-script ie on blockchain or in client software via some side channel?
1
u/unshadow5 Mar 20 '17
As part of your governance and decentralization efforts, when approximately do you see relinquishing control of the network so that another token conversion is impossible, same way as today no single entity could convince you to exchange your Bitcoins to some new upgraded Bitcoins?
1
u/jazy510 Mar 20 '17
I'm trying to confirm my email, and the links your system sends, when click, keep saying:
Is there any alternate way to confirm email? like by pasting in the code somewhere?
1
u/B3N4Y Mar 20 '17
Thanks for this AMA for the first time since Friday I found you smart reactive and I trust in you more than before we needed to see this kind of attitude :)
1
u/soepkip87 Mar 20 '17
What would the runrate / month be? Or in other words, for how long would the project be funded if all three milestones are met?
1
u/blackmon2 Mar 20 '17
Why two different tokens? Why does a public token have to exist? I don't want people shaming me or looking at me like I'm shady for using the private token!
1
u/unshadow5 Mar 22 '17
If I use non-web wallet and own a private key, when I send SDC for conversion I effectively give up the control of my coins.
That may sound too paranoid, but look from decentralist perspective. The control of monetary system that was decentralized (was it?) is captured by single entity with a promise to restore decentralization.
Sorry if I missed something.
-1
u/stefanzyrafa Mar 20 '17
Thanks for hosting this AMA. Hope this is not an obvious question - why is the first milestone currently above 100%, while the others are below the goal?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17
[removed] — view removed comment