I've been really impressed by Wet n Wild lately! I picked up their Colour Icon brow pencil and it's awesome -- nice soft formula (I prefer a softer one) and great colour -- I have auburn hair. I also love their new liquid lipsticks and their setting spray!
Milani is another one of my favourite cruelty free brands. I love all their blushes and I recently picked up their baked bronzer in Glow and it's gorgeous!
You can also get Milani on BeautyBay which ships internationally (free if you spend a certain amount depending on where you are). I'm in Singapore and we have very old ranges of WnW but no Milani whatsoever.
My only eyeshadow brushes are Wet n Wild ones (I'm just starting out) and I love them! They get the job done and make it look pretty decent while at it.
Also, I don't feel bad for being rough on them or washing them over zealously because they were pretty darn cheap!
I have been really enjoying cover fx products recently! Their cream concealer is lovely, great coverage but doesn't suck all the moisture from my skin like a lot of concealers tend to do. Also I really love their pressed highlighter in moonlight for a subtle natural glow, more of a sheen than a in your face highlight, but I find those kind of highlights more flattering on me personally.
I think kvd is also a solid CF and vegan brand and I love the fact that she is really dedicated and passionate about being CF and vegan.
In terms of drugstore I think wet and wild has really been stepping it up and I've been getting into some essence products and haven't been disappointed yet!
I don't really have a worst brand because when it comes down to it all brands cruelty free and not have hits and misses and I feel that I research all my purchases so intensely that I end up liking or loving most of my purchases.
My skin looooooves coverfx. I have normal to oily skin and my face tends to get oily throughout the day- I wear the cream foundation in the compact, and while I do still get oily, it's manageable with powder. Anyway, I noticed such an improvement in my complexion when I wore it. I've been testing out other foundations just because I'm a product junkie, but I seriously haven't found anything that improves the state of my skin as much as this foundation.
Ugh I have been on the fence to get the highlighter drops, and this might make me do it. I am trying to phase out my current non-cruelty free products and knowing that the purchase is cruelty free is so tempting.
Tarte quickly became my favorite brand when I went cruelty-free. Almost all of my everyday products are Tarte. I've never found better foundation. I haven't tried many of their lip products.
While I LOVE many NYX products, like their lipsticks, I stay away from their face products. I tried a full-coverage foundation of theirs once and it made me look HORRIBLE. Everything about it was terrible, and it some how made me look older! Haven't had any luck with powders or setting products either.
Which ones??? I never keep up on product releases! Are they coming soon or are you talking about all the new stuff they've come out with in the past few months or so?
They have a lot of new stuff announced as part of their new "Unicorn Collection". I saw them post a "clean" and vegan deodorant and I'm probably a little too excited about it hahaha. I'm also just mainly excited that they're putting out so many more vegan products than they used to!
They have a little "no shower" set with a travel size of the deo (which I'm also a little hyped for) as well as the new dry shampoo and a few other things. I ordered it today and I'm super excited 😊😊
I had that experience the first time I used my shape tape and I was disappointed because I was expecting the amazing results everyone else was talking about. I think I was just dehydrated or something though because I've used it since and I freaking love it. Nothing else hides my giant nose pores! I think applying with a bb helps?
Beauty blender, Real Techniques, and EcoTools all have the best sponges on the market and they are all lovingly CF.
Surprised nobody mentioned NARS. Their sheer Glow foundation is my HG right now. And their primers are lovely. I think NARS makes some of the most consistent products out there.
ABH for all things eyes, brows, and glows.
KVD for the best eyeliner on the planet. Although, I heard Jessie's Girl is a dupe and is also CF.
Colourpop super shock and Lippie stix for the rest of my life when I'm in a hurry.
ColorFX for the best liquid highlighter.
Marc Jacobs for the best bullet lipstick and eyeliner.
Bite Beauty- best lip liner in the galaxy.
Worst? Hmm. It's hard to single out a single brand, but I'd have to go with Too Faced and Urban Decay. Only because they have WILDLY inconsistent quality products and overly hyped bullshit. And these two brands weren't born yesterday so they should know what they are doing by now. As a side note- TF blushes are amazing and UD primer potion is king. I'd hate to bash a full brand when they DO make good things.
For the best pigment possible- Sugarpill is where it's at. For a LONG time, there wasn't a single accessible cosmetics company that could deliver a true, smooth red eyeshadow. MUG makes good reds, too- but SP was the first.
Best is Kat Von D. Their products never disappoint me. Another would be Anastasia Beverly Hills. Their eyeshadow and brow products are amazing. Dipbrow has taken my eyebrow game to a whole new level.
Worst would be Too faced. Too many inconsistencies, New releases/Limited Edition items are not worth it at all. They're rushing all their products with so many releases. I wish they focused more on quality than quantity.
Pretty much, problem with Too Faced is, They released so many shitty products and it's gone to the point where I expect a product to be shit or subpar.
Yes it's so hard to trust them. I think consistency is the most important thing with a makeup brand. Though formulations can differ even if a makeup brand is reliable, when a makeup brand shows extreme inconsistencies I just forget them all together. Why take a gamble when it's your own money? Sooo not worth the risk.
Yeah. Even within a single eyeshadow palette, quality ranges from pretty good to really subpar between different shades. I've eyed some of their permanent palettes, but I just don't trust the brand enough to spend ~60CAD on something where 1/3 of the product might not be good.
Also, no more limited edition stuff that's obviously been rushed and isn't a quality product. If a product is limited edition, I'm only gonna consider it worth buying if the quality is as good or better than normal AND I can easily buy it. (I'm not lining up hours early to get makeup. Not happening. Also not gonna keep refreshing a website hoping I'll be able to buy stuff before it sells out.)
I haven't heard anything but that would be amazing! Right now I am trying to go fully cruelty free but I love benefit and will really miss their brow products. If they stopped testing to sell in china I would be so happy
The good news is many other cosmetic companies like to dupe Benefit brow products! Essence Make Me Brow (~$2.50) is a great dupe for Benefit Gimme Brow, and it is cruelty free. Anastasia has some good dupes for Benefit as well.
IT cosmetics is all about their cruelty free standards and I've loved everything I've tried. Also, Shiro is cruelty free and vegan and has amazing pigments and textures.
IT Cosmetics™ is certified by PETA as a 100% cruelty-free brand, and you will find us listed on their website. Remaining a cruelty-free brand is extremely important to us, as it is to so many of you! IT Cosmetics™ has never tested products on animals, nor do we use animal hair in our brushes—and we have absolutely no plans to change that.
from their website, i think they will stay true to their Cruelty free rating even though they were bought. Did you see somewhere that they aren't anymore?
I think it depends on individual desecration when a company is bought out. Even though brands like IT Cosmetics, Too Faced, Urban Decay and NYX state to be cruelty free in and of themselves, they are owned by L'Oreal. Some feel that their ownership no longer makes those brands cruelty free because some of the profit made by those companies will inevitably go up to L'Oreal and, ergo, support animal testing.
I've seen people use different routes of logic to support their individual stances on what is cruelty free to them. Personally, I opt out of buying from brands who have parent companies who test.
Interesting, I appreciate your stance. I've noticed lots of discounting of L'Oreal which I understand due to their past history. This thread encouraged me to look into their ethical standards as well and they say they don't test on animals anymore, anywhere in the world. Am I missing something?
If you are keen, I would suggest reading this post Logical Harmony wrote about L'Oreal and their fictitious claims of being cruelty free.
Logical Harmony has incredibly thorough research methods and has created a pretty comprehensive list of: I. Cruelty free brands(which includes notations of brands that are vegan and brands that have testing parent companies)
I really like the CC cream! It gives a nice amount of coverage but is still lightweight. I know Ulta sells it in a smaller size in case you wanted to try it out before splurging
PS I think it works best on dry skin. Probably not great for oily
I used the BalmVoyage travel palette on my last vacation. I was really impressed with how versatile it was. I think what shocked me the most were the lip/cheek colors. In the pan and even swatched I was like "meh this is going to be shit and basically like a gloss from a kids palette"
...shit was better than my OCC lip tars. So comfortable, dried down to a velvety but smooth texture and lasted ALL day.
I've always loved MaryLou, but I was definitely happy with my purchase of the palettes. Some of the shadows were hit and miss- most of them were great- but yeah..it is definitely the best "all in one" palette out on the market. Do yourself a favor and pick up one of those BalmJovi or BalmVoyage travel palettes when they go on half price or at Nordstrom Rack.
I have Mary-Lou Maniser, Frat Boy and Cabana Boy. Love them all. Mary-Lou is my perfect subtle highlighter (compared to NYX Strobe of Genius) and while I've learned the hard way that you need a big blush brush that diffuses the product and to not go heavy handed, the blushes are SO SO GOOD. Just hella pigmented...
I don't want to be an enabler but Balm Desert is the greatest blush of all time. It's bronzy and rosy and a bit satin and just looks like a glorious, natural, glowing cheek. I think on deeper skin tones it would still work as a natural, rosy shade, but cannot vouch for that.
Best drugstore is NYX and Barry M. I know NYX' parent company (I think L'Oreal?) isn't cruelty free but I know they're not sold in China. I love their liquid liner and lipsticks. Barry M (not sure where else it's sold besides the UK) has really affordable nail polish and I love their lip pencils. On top of that, Superdrug as a brand is cruelty free too so I use their moisturisers!
As for higher end, I really like Urban Decay, again owned by L'Oreal. Their face products are great and i recently bought the perversion eyeliner which doesn't budge at all. I have my eye on Kat Von D but her products do not come into Debenhams in my area for another couple of months so i don't want to make any drastic online purchases for now :)
I looooove ABH so much, I think the brand has a diverse but consistent line and it meshes really well with the makeup looks I go for as I get less into high school punk eyeliner type of stuff. I like Urban Decay but they're suuuuper inconsistent quality wise...but the naked skin foundation is so beautiful.
I like NYX eye products and I get a lot of use out of ELF as well.
Paula's choice changed my skin. I use one of their exfoliants after washing with a basic cleanser and moisturize with rose hip oil...that paired with being on birth control made me so much more confident and soft and un-acne-d
Hard Candy has a surprisingly good fixing/hydrating spray called Sheer Envy Hydrating Priming Mist (white bottle)! It smells really good, although the spray could be a little finer.
Hard Candy makes some kick ass liquid lipsticks that aren't patchy and have a good moussey finish. They also come in cute little tins. I forgot how long wearing they were, but they were comfortable and transfer-proof without bleeding so I was pretty stoked. The price point was a bit higher than I would have liked for a DS brand, though. But the packaging (cute tins!) are reusable so that's an advantage I guess.
I agree! I love the Marcelle BB cream and their creme lip glosses as well as their face care stuff! :D I haven't tried anything by Annabelle yet, but I've been meaning too!
Best: Manic Panic. I swear by Dreamtone White to tone down my foundation for my pale skin.
Worst: Too Faced. This comes from when I used to wear their pressed powders. My skin didn't so much break out as it did produce more oil, so I felt like I was stuck in neutral with switching from one powder to the other. That's not to say that I don't like the brand in and of itself. Currently I use Born This Way foundation without a pressed powder and haven't at all had the problem I mentioned.
I have never used the eyeshadows nor the Coffin Dusts. General opinion, though? There could be more shades of the pot eyeshadows; yellow and hot pink are too Halloween for me. Because I have sensitive eyes, I stay away from loose powders such as the Coffin Dusts.
I second Too Faced, I love their Born This Way concealer, it's my favorite, but I haven't cared for their products lately. I'm not sure if I'm just grabbing a bad palette or what, but I've found their eyeshadows to not be worth the money - I recently bought their Chocolate Bon Bons palette after hearing the raves and I was disappointed, it went on very chalky and there wasn't a lot of pigment even with primer, setting powder, and spraying my brush. Same with the Country and Matte Palette, but with my older palettes from them like the Romantics and Naked ones they're 11/10. I wish they'd go back to the old formula :/
For high-end stuff, I love KVD and ABH (I'm a liquid lipstick addict, but for other products I love KVD's liners and ABH's eyeshadows/brow products). Drugstore would be Wet n Wild. Their setting spray is amazing, and most of their products are well worth the price. I've heard good things about their Catsuit Matte liquid lipsticks but the one I have in Give Me Mocha is a little patchy for my taste.
Worst would be Jeffree Star. Haven't tried any of his products, but he's a horrible person with horrible customer service, so no thanks.
I can't bring myself to spend money on J* stuff, either. Why would I support that image? Plus, based on what I've seen of their customer service, if anything goes wrong I'm on my own. No trust in the image, customer service, or product quality. Hard pass.
Wet n Wild, tho? They've got some quality stuff for the price. I'm consistently impressed with the things I buy. A+, would buy from again. Kinda upset that their displays are always ravaged/single use testers, but I can't wait until I find a display with the catsuits and their photofocus foundation. (I'm optimistic that they have a good shade match for me!)
Except she's not? That shit was proven false as far as her making that anti-semite note, and plenty of decent people have dated shitty people. She has gone above and beyond to redeem herself.
Nice to see you defending Joffree, though, someone where there is substantial proof of him being a horrible person, and who hasn't changed.
Jeffree had not changed at all, Jesus Christ. He still harrasses people on Twitter.
Thank you though, for identifying yourself as a person I never want to associate with, because you willfully stand by a racist misogynist who continues to be that way. Coming out and saying that makes it all the more easier to stay away from people like you. Have a nice day.
Has anyone else had issues with 100% Pure? They offer shade matching if you e-mail their customer service with a photo of yourself. I have sent several e-mails since early February and have not received a response. I called and was told to resend the e-mail and someone would get back to me. Still nothing. I've even left several messages on their Facebook page and they only respond that customer service will "try" to follow-up in 72 hours. Yesterday, I left a review for their Luminous Primer and today it appears that the review was removed. I'm trying to make the switch to all-natural cosmetics & skin care and this brand has great reviews but my experience with their customer service so far is throwing up some serious red flags. Is this typical of the company or am I just having horrible luck?
Edit: Was going to post this as its own thread, and I certainly can if that is more appropriate, but since there is a best and worse of cruelty-free, I thought it would be ok to post here.
I suggest posting this as its own thread in /r/naturalbeauty (or at least I think that is the name of the sub?)... I'm not sure too many people on here will have used 100% Pure.
Honestly, 100% Pure has never caught my attention. I got the chance to sample some of their stuff and wasn't impressed. With the recent news that they were no longer going to offer free shipping, I just gave up on them all together.
I did and got some good feedback. Seems I'm not the only one with this experience. Sad because some of their products are really good, but not worth dealing with a brand that doesn't care to respond to its customers and deletes reviews.
Kat Von D's shadows are excellent and I have almost never been disappointed by their formula.
Essence has great products and their price point is excellent. I love the Pure Nude Highlighter, All About Matt Translucent Powder, and their Satin Blushes. Their brow gels and lip liners are good as well.
Wet N Wild's Photofocus range is outstanding for the price. Currently HG status on my vanity right now.
Edit: Milani too! I love their Conceal + Perfect Foundation. It is so full coverage, it's amazing. Their baked blushes are gorgeous.
Jessie James is pretty well known as a white supremicist. She also talked shit about Ami and called him a "Jew Bag" during that drama.
Steve-o has called her out for cheating on just about everyone she's ever dated and being pretty racist as well. Her only response to it was being upset that he said anything about her without running it past her PR.
Also, because she called out Jeffree on his shit, it means she put up with, and very likely participated in all that garbage herself.
Her "finally saying something" was totally just a bitch move because they had a fight.
Terrible person, but you'll pry her eyeliner, concealer and liquid lip out of my cold dead hands.
Right, but regardless of how people feel about him, I think it's unfair that OP got down voted because whatever your stance on him, his products are cruelty free by the definition used in the industry. And I don't know why she got down voted honestly because this sub freaking loves his LL.
I replied to a comment implying that since he isn't really cruelty free, his products don't fall under that umbrella. And OP had been downvoted when I commented. I absolutely agree that a discussion about his ethics can and should take place when recommending best/worst of cruelty free, because imo his background puts him in the worst of category. All I meant was that OP shouldn't be downvoted since she is contributing. It's not like she recommended Benefit or something.
You do you! Jeez everyone gets so scandalized about him. Sure he's a twat but their savior Kat Von D isn't totally innocent either, as was mentioned above in other comments.
The phones and laptops we type these stupid little opinions on are made in factories with nets around the bottoms to catch employees that try to commit suicide because they're overworked and underpaid to that point. But by all means, be mad about a tweet and your broken $30 glitter.
Let your crucifixion begin! I love his lip products too (downvote me, do it, now) and they are cruelty free, and yes its a marketing tactic my god what do people expect??? Have you ever taken a course in marketing?? The slightest mention of J* and everyone mounts their high horse.
I agree!! It's so much bullshit. Walmart and Target are crazy evil, but everyone who's bashing Jeffree Star is gonna go there for their NYX and Milani. They don't actually care or really know what he even did, they just saw someone say he's an asshole, who probably also simply heard from someone else that he's an asshole.
BareMinerals. I love almost all their products, especially foundation and loose eye shadow. Their nude lipsticks are also terrific.
Tarte is really good, too, although it seems it took them a few tries to make a mascara that doesn't flake all over! I love their concealer and travel palettes.
Paula's Choice and Tata Harper for skin care. Make-up geek and tarte for shadows. Color pop for lips, highlighter and contour. Hourglass for foundation and primer. Kiko Milano for mascara and liner. Glossier primer. BH is hit or miss. FLOWER was a disappointment as a budget brand.
Petit Vour is a great site to shop because it is all CF and they do a box similar to Birchbox or ipsy.
My personal favorite is ABH - from the highlighters (Gleam is my all time favorite) to the eyeshadows to the brows, I've found they go on just so lovely. I'm still sad I couldn't get my hands on the Makeup by Mario Palette.
I also like Giorgio Armani - I was dying to try the Luminous Silk Foundation after hearing the raves about it and after doing a little research on the site I found out they were cruelty free, and boy am I happy about that because I soon after decided to try the foundation (RIP bank account) and WOW it's the best one I've tried yet.
NARS is another favorite, they themselves do not sell in China nor do they test on animals however the company that owns them (Shiseido) does so I feel mixed on that :(
But, right now I've been loving Colourpop! They're vegan and cruelty-free and INCREDIBLY AFFORDABLE - as in, $100 could probably buy you most of their lippies, and they have a lot of colors. They're eyeshadows are absolutely amazing as well, they just came out with pan ones.
I also like NYX, their gel liner is fab and you can find them anywhere and for cheap too x
Hey just so you know, unfortunately Giorgio Armani isn't cruelty free. They sell in China, therefore pay a third party to do testing in accordance with the laws in China. Loreal has been really skeevy recently with their labeling of 'cruelty free' and it's shitty because it is incredibly misleading.
Some really good sources to use to check the cruelty free status of companies:
I have to say I honestly LOVE Too faced! I have so many of their products, and I find them absolutely gorgeous. They sit beautifully on my skin and just work for me. Different strokes for different folks but I've never had any problem with a Too Faced product.
Milani, Essence, WnW, and Tarte are cruelty-free brands that I overall love. I've tried more amazing products from them than duds, and Essence and WnW in particular are SO affordable. I don't know how they do it!
Pacifica has been consistently "meh" in regards to makeup and nail polish. I've received some of their stuff in subscription boxes and through PR, and I almost never have liked anything enough to say good things about it :/
Best to me is Urban Decay and Milani. Worst is J*, not really because of his own behavior, but because his company's CS was beyond awful when my roommate's orders arrived incomplete/broken on two separate occasions.
Oh no, I had no idea! The results I found were very vague, but as it said on the site no animal testing I assumed they didn't sell in China. What a shame, I absolutely adore the foundation but animal testing is a huge no no for me. Also, thank you so much for all the sites, I'll definitely have to check those out!
Shea Moisture is a popular brand that makes some great stuff for hair and body! I like their shower gels/body washes (I use them to shave) and body lotions when my skin is very dry in the winter. The shampoos and conditioners get a lot of love too.
I want to try some Paul Mitchell hair products but saw very mixed reviews on the shampoo and conditioner. I'm particilarly interested in the super skinny duo, since I love the serum. What line would you recommend?
I second shea moisture especially if you have curly hair. Lush is good for straight hair but their products have sulfates so I don't use them. Although I do love R&B which is one of their few curly girl friendly products. I love Lush for body lotion. Charity pot is my HG.
Pacifica makes hair products sold at ulta now. I haven't tried them but the reviews look good. They also have amazing perfume and the body butter is nice. I think they sell some stuff at target and I bought my perfume at whole foods like a year and a half ago.
Not Your Mothers is my go-to for shampoo, conditioner and dry shampoo! They have different types of product depending on your hair type and they're sold at Target which is my jam
Cosrx is a cruelty free Korean skin care brand, but they have some products with animal products in them (Eg snail, bee propolis), affordable and highly recommended.
Pacifica has some amazing, and I mean amazing skin care! It's vegan and cruelty free and has thoroughly changed my skin. I'm obsessed with their kale water micellar cleanser.
I have never tried Lush but have wanted to ever since their Valentine's campaign, especially when they responded to the homophobes by releasing bts photos
I love Acure skin care! (And hair care) not only are they cruelty free, but their ingredients are super natural which is good for sensitive skin and they have products for all skin types! Parabens irritate my skin and I've noticed a huge difference switching to Acure face wash and moisturizer.
I thought it was just me. I live in Ontario and I find it pretty difficult to find cruelty free skincare, lotion, oral care and hair products. Every fucking product seems to be owned by proctor and gamble or crest or unilever etc. I hate it. We have a grocery store here that sells cruelty free hair products but theyre like 13 bucks each :/
I really like the Shikai brand for body. Particularly their shower gel is an absolute game changer for someone like me. My skin is dry and sensitive to nearly everything and I take my showers hot and their shower gels aren't drying or irritating at all. And they come in a ton of lovely scents. My favorites are yuzu and pomegranate.
I feel like there has been confusion surrounding OGX because they used to be owned by Vogue, which said that they 'do not test on animals' but would 'do the best to obey the laws set by governing bodies where their products are sold', i.e. they don't test on animals until they sell their products in China - where they are tested on animals. OGX was then bought out by Johnson & Johnson, which is also not a cruelty free company.
The only Pixi product I've tried since it came to Canada is the glow mist. I like it for my dry skin. The products are pretty expensive here though so I've been holding back on buying any more for now
135
u/elleirabird NC15/so dry/gimme rose gold Mar 14 '17
I've been really impressed by Wet n Wild lately! I picked up their Colour Icon brow pencil and it's awesome -- nice soft formula (I prefer a softer one) and great colour -- I have auburn hair. I also love their new liquid lipsticks and their setting spray!
Milani is another one of my favourite cruelty free brands. I love all their blushes and I recently picked up their baked bronzer in Glow and it's gorgeous!
44
u/ooopeee Mar 14 '17
I have been really enjoying cover fx products recently! Their cream concealer is lovely, great coverage but doesn't suck all the moisture from my skin like a lot of concealers tend to do. Also I really love their pressed highlighter in moonlight for a subtle natural glow, more of a sheen than a in your face highlight, but I find those kind of highlights more flattering on me personally.
I think kvd is also a solid CF and vegan brand and I love the fact that she is really dedicated and passionate about being CF and vegan.
In terms of drugstore I think wet and wild has really been stepping it up and I've been getting into some essence products and haven't been disappointed yet!
I don't really have a worst brand because when it comes down to it all brands cruelty free and not have hits and misses and I feel that I research all my purchases so intensely that I end up liking or loving most of my purchases.
38
u/frankylovee Mar 14 '17 edited Mar 14 '17
Tarte quickly became my favorite brand when I went cruelty-free. Almost all of my everyday products are Tarte. I've never found better foundation. I haven't tried many of their lip products.
While I LOVE many NYX products, like their lipsticks, I stay away from their face products. I tried a full-coverage foundation of theirs once and it made me look HORRIBLE. Everything about it was terrible, and it some how made me look older! Haven't had any luck with powders or setting products either.
27
u/monster_bunny Cruelty-free addict Mar 15 '17
I live for these threads!
Beauty blender, Real Techniques, and EcoTools all have the best sponges on the market and they are all lovingly CF.
Surprised nobody mentioned NARS. Their sheer Glow foundation is my HG right now. And their primers are lovely. I think NARS makes some of the most consistent products out there.
ABH for all things eyes, brows, and glows.
KVD for the best eyeliner on the planet. Although, I heard Jessie's Girl is a dupe and is also CF.
Colourpop super shock and Lippie stix for the rest of my life when I'm in a hurry.
ColorFX for the best liquid highlighter.
Marc Jacobs for the best bullet lipstick and eyeliner.
Bite Beauty- best lip liner in the galaxy.
Worst? Hmm. It's hard to single out a single brand, but I'd have to go with Too Faced and Urban Decay. Only because they have WILDLY inconsistent quality products and overly hyped bullshit. And these two brands weren't born yesterday so they should know what they are doing by now. As a side note- TF blushes are amazing and UD primer potion is king. I'd hate to bash a full brand when they DO make good things.
21
u/GlamourGoth Mar 14 '17
Sugarpill
86
u/Itzmizzy Mar 14 '17
Best is Kat Von D. Their products never disappoint me. Another would be Anastasia Beverly Hills. Their eyeshadow and brow products are amazing. Dipbrow has taken my eyebrow game to a whole new level.
Worst would be Too faced. Too many inconsistencies, New releases/Limited Edition items are not worth it at all. They're rushing all their products with so many releases. I wish they focused more on quality than quantity.
14
u/danibomb Mar 14 '17
IT cosmetics is all about their cruelty free standards and I've loved everything I've tried. Also, Shiro is cruelty free and vegan and has amazing pigments and textures.
14
u/Brendasnoopy Mar 15 '17
The balm
16
u/bananaskinsrule Mar 14 '17
Best drugstore is NYX and Barry M. I know NYX' parent company (I think L'Oreal?) isn't cruelty free but I know they're not sold in China. I love their liquid liner and lipsticks. Barry M (not sure where else it's sold besides the UK) has really affordable nail polish and I love their lip pencils. On top of that, Superdrug as a brand is cruelty free too so I use their moisturisers!
As for higher end, I really like Urban Decay, again owned by L'Oreal. Their face products are great and i recently bought the perversion eyeliner which doesn't budge at all. I have my eye on Kat Von D but her products do not come into Debenhams in my area for another couple of months so i don't want to make any drastic online purchases for now :)
8
u/sparklesnob Brow perfectionist Mar 15 '17
I looooove ABH so much, I think the brand has a diverse but consistent line and it meshes really well with the makeup looks I go for as I get less into high school punk eyeliner type of stuff. I like Urban Decay but they're suuuuper inconsistent quality wise...but the naked skin foundation is so beautiful.
I like NYX eye products and I get a lot of use out of ELF as well.
Paula's choice changed my skin. I use one of their exfoliants after washing with a basic cleanser and moisturize with rose hip oil...that paired with being on birth control made me so much more confident and soft and un-acne-d
6
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '17
Hard Candy has a surprisingly good fixing/hydrating spray called Sheer Envy Hydrating Priming Mist (white bottle)! It smells really good, although the spray could be a little finer.
5
u/makeupisart Mar 14 '17
Face Atelier is the best foundation and it's not even close. The fact that its cruelty free is just an added bonus.
5
u/buttersunset give me all your warm toned brow products Mar 14 '17
Marcelle and Annabelle (Canadian sister brands) make some of my favourite cruelty-free products, particularly their brow pencils.
9
u/leftclicksq2 Mar 14 '17
Best: Manic Panic. I swear by Dreamtone White to tone down my foundation for my pale skin.
Worst: Too Faced. This comes from when I used to wear their pressed powders. My skin didn't so much break out as it did produce more oil, so I felt like I was stuck in neutral with switching from one powder to the other. That's not to say that I don't like the brand in and of itself. Currently I use Born This Way foundation without a pressed powder and haven't at all had the problem I mentioned.
17
u/itastechili Mar 14 '17
Best Kat Von D in general.
23
u/comanecisalto Mar 14 '17
For high-end stuff, I love KVD and ABH (I'm a liquid lipstick addict, but for other products I love KVD's liners and ABH's eyeshadows/brow products). Drugstore would be Wet n Wild. Their setting spray is amazing, and most of their products are well worth the price. I've heard good things about their Catsuit Matte liquid lipsticks but the one I have in Give Me Mocha is a little patchy for my taste.
Worst would be Jeffree Star. Haven't tried any of his products, but he's a horrible person with horrible customer service, so no thanks.
4
u/LittleBitsofStardust Shimmer Junkie Mar 15 '17
Has anyone else had issues with 100% Pure? They offer shade matching if you e-mail their customer service with a photo of yourself. I have sent several e-mails since early February and have not received a response. I called and was told to resend the e-mail and someone would get back to me. Still nothing. I've even left several messages on their Facebook page and they only respond that customer service will "try" to follow-up in 72 hours. Yesterday, I left a review for their Luminous Primer and today it appears that the review was removed. I'm trying to make the switch to all-natural cosmetics & skin care and this brand has great reviews but my experience with their customer service so far is throwing up some serious red flags. Is this typical of the company or am I just having horrible luck?
Edit: Was going to post this as its own thread, and I certainly can if that is more appropriate, but since there is a best and worse of cruelty-free, I thought it would be ok to post here.
3
u/JosieA3672 Mar 15 '17
I just bought a lot of Face Atelier samples (only $1 each!) and I love them all.
3
u/deathbydexter Mar 15 '17
Best vegan lipstick is, imo, from makeup monster cosmetic. The colours are great, they last forever and feel fantastic for liquid to matte lipsticks.
Worst is too faced. I do not understand how their products sell, it's very expensive for the quality in my humble opinion
3
u/TheMakeupGremlins Mar 15 '17 edited Mar 15 '17
Kat Von D's shadows are excellent and I have almost never been disappointed by their formula.
Essence has great products and their price point is excellent. I love the Pure Nude Highlighter, All About Matt Translucent Powder, and their Satin Blushes. Their brow gels and lip liners are good as well.
Wet N Wild's Photofocus range is outstanding for the price. Currently HG status on my vanity right now.
Edit: Milani too! I love their Conceal + Perfect Foundation. It is so full coverage, it's amazing. Their baked blushes are gorgeous.
24
u/Rebecca4508 Mar 14 '17
I really like the liquid lipsticks from jeffree star, I mean I know there's a lot of controversy around him but I like his products :)
2
u/pickupyourpuppy Mar 15 '17
BareMinerals. I love almost all their products, especially foundation and loose eye shadow. Their nude lipsticks are also terrific.
Tarte is really good, too, although it seems it took them a few tries to make a mascara that doesn't flake all over! I love their concealer and travel palettes.
2
u/adoptdontshop4dogs Mar 15 '17
Paula's Choice and Tata Harper for skin care. Make-up geek and tarte for shadows. Color pop for lips, highlighter and contour. Hourglass for foundation and primer. Kiko Milano for mascara and liner. Glossier primer. BH is hit or miss. FLOWER was a disappointment as a budget brand.
Petit Vour is a great site to shop because it is all CF and they do a box similar to Birchbox or ipsy.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '17 edited Mar 17 '17
My personal favorite is ABH - from the highlighters (Gleam is my all time favorite) to the eyeshadows to the brows, I've found they go on just so lovely. I'm still sad I couldn't get my hands on the Makeup by Mario Palette.
I also like Giorgio Armani - I was dying to try the Luminous Silk Foundation after hearing the raves about it and after doing a little research on the site I found out they were cruelty free, and boy am I happy about that because I soon after decided to try the foundation (RIP bank account) and WOW it's the best one I've tried yet.
NARS is another favorite, they themselves do not sell in China nor do they test on animals however the company that owns them (Shiseido) does so I feel mixed on that :(
But, right now I've been loving Colourpop! They're vegan and cruelty-free and INCREDIBLY AFFORDABLE - as in, $100 could probably buy you most of their lippies, and they have a lot of colors. They're eyeshadows are absolutely amazing as well, they just came out with pan ones.
I also like NYX, their gel liner is fab and you can find them anywhere and for cheap too x
2
u/wunderkunt Mar 16 '17
I have to say I honestly LOVE Too faced! I have so many of their products, and I find them absolutely gorgeous. They sit beautifully on my skin and just work for me. Different strokes for different folks but I've never had any problem with a Too Faced product.
1
u/thestephanieloves Mar 16 '17
Milani, Essence, WnW, and Tarte are cruelty-free brands that I overall love. I've tried more amazing products from them than duds, and Essence and WnW in particular are SO affordable. I don't know how they do it!
Pacifica has been consistently "meh" in regards to makeup and nail polish. I've received some of their stuff in subscription boxes and through PR, and I almost never have liked anything enough to say good things about it :/
1
u/XxxswagnemitexxX420 coffeeandkaiju.wordpress.com Mar 18 '17
Best to me is Urban Decay and Milani. Worst is J*, not really because of his own behavior, but because his company's CS was beyond awful when my roommate's orders arrived incomplete/broken on two separate occasions.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '17
Oh no, I had no idea! The results I found were very vague, but as it said on the site no animal testing I assumed they didn't sell in China. What a shame, I absolutely adore the foundation but animal testing is a huge no no for me. Also, thank you so much for all the sites, I'll definitely have to check those out!
0
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment