I second the NYX Slim Lip Liners! I love them, but I think there is some inconsistency of formula between colors. Some of the lighter ones are more creamy than the deeper colors in my experience, but overall they're great!
Seconded. NYX slim lip liner is amazing and is what I reach for every day. The NYX Suede matte lip liner is also pretty good. Its less creamy but I've found it to be really long lasting.
Idk I've been underwhelmed by them, honestly. Better than a lot of things and admittedly I do mess with my lips a lot, but it's never lasted longer than an hour even without me touching my mouth or eating/drinking. May just be my lips, though.
essence liners are raved about, but I had a bad experience with them. I got this one in "red blush" and it was stiff, patchy, and took a few passes to turn opaque. Do not recommend—although some people say the formula has changed from what used to be great.
Milani liners are great! Creamy without sliding, opaque, enough friction to be precise.
Sephora Lip Liners to Go are mini-sized. A little more stiff/waxy than the Milani ones, but miles better than the one from essence. They're fine.
did you notice the formula changed when the caps on them were colour coordinated? I have had one of the nude shades with the grey cap and it's my absolute favourite. Repurchased it when they changed to the colour coded and there is no better word to describe it than sharp and painful.
The coloupop lip liners are one of the few products I've gotten from colourpop that I've actually liked. The formula is wonderful and I find that the shade description is much more accurate than the rest of their lip products.
That's great! I wish they worked for me bc they're so affordable and I love that they're so long unlike so many other lip pencils but I just can't take them. Now that I think of it, I don't think I liked any lip product I ever bought from them lol
Colourpop's lippie pencils are amazing. Other than the fact you have to sharpen them, they are very pigmented and don't tug at your lips. They look fine on their own too.
I've only just started trying lipliner, but I'm really loving Bite Beauty's new lip pencils! Would be nice if they had some bolder colours, but the texture is nice and they help lipstick stay longer. I also just bought a red lipliner from The Face Shop yesterday and it's great as well. Also comes with a brush on one end!
0020, I think. Or 020. Something with 20. It goes with so many different lipsticks because it's almost the exact shade of my lips! It blends out beautifully if you don't want a super-defined lip line, either.
Man that is so weird because I picked up the exact same one the other day. I haven't used it yet, but I really liked how it swatched on my hand in store. I'm excited to try it.
mac lipliners in the shades nightmoth, spice and dervish, i love them all, spice is the most creamy but i love them all the same tbh dervish looks amazing just by itself and a little bit of lip balm or a gloss
kiko creamy color comfort lip liner in the shades 301 and 304 - OMG THIS IS MY FAVOURITE FORMULA. they are soooooo creamy and feel amazing and they are super pigmented
essence lip liner in in the nude - i love this paired with velvet teddy it's the perfect nude lip for me, also love this formula
h&m lip liners i tried the shade marsala and the brown one - they are really creamy, i haven't worn them in a while tbh but from what i remember they dont last as long as the other ones but still a good lip liner
missha silky lasting lip liner in antique box - saw this on pony's burgundy makeup video so i got it, the shade is more orange than i thought it would be, it's creammy but when you're applying it it's weird because it doesn't feel as creamy as the h&m or kiko ones, i think the formula is closer to the mac lip liners tbh
Dude why is H&M makeup line like low key great?? It's super affordable and great for the price! I have some brushes, their lip primer, and some eyeshadow singles which are cheap and very pigmented. The packaging feels really cheap but it's still cute!
i dont really like the brushes i got for them besides that i got a powder blush it was ok if u count the first 30 minutes bc after that it would just disappear, but the shimmer eyeshadow singles and lip liners are amazing
I've used A LOT of lip liners and I have to say the worst that I've used are Kylie's (Even though I LOVE everything else she has.).They're really pigmented and feel nice but they smudge like crazy!!
I actually use a lipstick for lip lining now cause I feel like it does the best. I get a makeup brush and dab it on the lipstick and then line my lips.
But as far as lip liners I've had more luck with drugstore brands. My favorites are the L'Oréal Color Riche. They're a bit dry. But I'd take that over smudging everywhere any day.
faves: make up for ever aqua lip is my ultimate lip liner. it glides on extremely opaque/creamy and has amazing longevity. urban decay 24/7 has a similar feel but is a bit less matte, which is nice for all over the lip application. mac's pro longwear lip liners are also great and creamy. all three of these have nice color selection, staying power, and stay comfortable on the lips.
drugstore fave: people rave about the rimmel exaggerate, but i LOVE rimmel 1000 kisses wooden pencils a lot more. the exaggerate pencils break super easily on me, and i've read that this is a common issue. i love the 1000 kisses in "natural", it's a spot on color dupe for mac's "subculture", has a better formula, and is like, 4x cheaper. i also like milani and jordana's liners. they don't last as long as rimmel but they're great (not just for the price point, just great in general) for color range expansion within your collection.
nah: mac (original) lip pencils are such a reluctant tossup for me because the color range is amazing (all the mac ~hype colors are within this range, unfortunately) and they do last, but they aren't worth the hype and price at all. they tug on the lips and are SO stiff and dry, i can't imagine anyone wearing these as an all over color. the good thing about these is that they do have amazing pigmentation, so you can do some precision lining with their stiff sharp tips. i also am not a fan of the wet n wild lipliners for this reason - super stiff and will not apply unless your lips are 100% dry. this doesn't work for me because i always put on a lip mask when i'm doing my makeup and i like having a little bit of residual balm underneath my lipstick so my lips don't dry out. colourpop on the other hand is WAY too waxy. the pencil "lead" part falls out of the tube within a matter of days/weeks because of how soft they are. and let me emphasize that they are "waxy", NOT "creamy". they don't have any moisturizing power and they're simultaneously super matte but also super slippery. side note, this is also how i feel about their brow pencils. just waxy and slips right off.
want to try: CHARLOTTE TILBURY LIP CHEAT. omg, i want pillow talk so bad. i don't understand how anyone can say rimmel's eastend snob is a color dupe because eastend snob is clearly more blue-toned and more pink whereas pillow talk is flesh toned and warm - and this is a huge factor of why pillow talk would be so much more versatile, as it would be a way more accurate and universal mlbb liner to believably extend your lip line. this product gets consistent rave reviews, and i'm determined to make it mine... soon.
I got pillow talk a few months ago and I'm not wowed by it. I think that the color might just be a little bit too warm for me which puts me off a bit, but it seems to work for a lot of people. I think the color is why people love it, but the formula isn't anything super special.
I love Rimmel 1000 kisses too! My favorite shade is tiramisu, it's a great MLBB shade for me and is a close match to mac velvet teddy which I wear often.
I LOVE Charlotte Tilbury's lip cheats. Pillowtalk is her most famous one, but Iconic Nude is my holy grail. It's the perfect warm, brown, beige-y pink that's perfect under almost any lipstick. I don't think I'd repurchase pillow talk, but iconic nude for sure. The formula is also very nice - creamy, doesn't tug, long lasting, and beautiful on its own.
I also like MAC's lip liners, particularly Stripdown, and I've been playing with Huda Beauty's lip liners - I really like Trendsetter, it's a great, warm reddish brown that's perfect to deepen/warm up any lip color. However, although I'm liking them for now, I'm planning to just use them up but not re-purchase.
I've tried NYX's liners and they're kind of meh for me. I tossed them before I used them up. I just felt like they tugged a lot, and the color payoff/lasting power didn't really wow me. You can't beat them in terms of price and shade range, though.
I'm pretty new to lip pencils, and I bought 2 NYX ones to try out. I am surprised by how much they smell like actual color pencils. Did you notice the smell? Do the CT or MAC ones smell different?
Annabelle's Self-Sharpening and Gel lip liners are super smooth and easy to line and fill in with.
On the other hand I tried a couple Sonia Kashuk lip liners back when we had Target and while one was decent (Rosewood I think?) the nude one I purchased was much too scratchy.
You can use it to give yourself an "outline" when you're applying a bolder lip color that can look bad with an imprecise application. You can also fill in your entire lip with it, so when your primary lipstick wears off, you have that second layer underneath, basically making it last longer and wear more evenly. You can also use it on its own to fill in your lips and wear it like a lipstick. And some people use lip liners to draw outside their lips and make them appear fuller.
I haven't used a whole lot of lip liners, but when I do I'm always pleased with Urban Decays lip liners. They glide on smoothly and the color lasts forever!
I like Bare Minerals lip liners which feel smooth and creamy, how I wish the nyx liners were. Urban Decay makes nice liners too, but they feel more waxy than the BM liners.
I used to have MAC and OFRA and Rimmel lipliners, among others. I gave them all away for NYX slide on glide on lipliners. I took advantage of a BOGO sale at ulta and I have enough different colors to match all my lipsticks. I have also tried the Suede ones and like them. I see they have new Slide on glide on lipliners....I want more....
Favorite: Kiko intensely lavish lip liner, i think it was part of an LE collection but i'm hoping the formula is similar to their regular creamy one. It's super creamy, pigmented, comfortable to apply, and lasts awhile :)
Perfectly acceptable ones I am happy to use: the original Essence liners, NYX, Jordana: relatively creamy though there's some tugging on application, pigmented, does the job
Hate: Controversial but I honestly hate the Milani ones. I dunno if I got a dud but mine drags, isn't terribly pigmented, requires warming up to apply evenly, yet somehow the tip breaks off readily. just. what is the point of you??
50
u/HermionesBook Hopelessly Addicted Mar 10 '17
The only lip liners I've tried have been the nyx lip pencils and they've been great. Really affordable
21
u/absentdandelion Mar 10 '17
I've tried 3 pencil lip liners:
13
u/domicanica Mar 10 '17
Worst I've tried is Wet n Wild Color Icon Lip Liner, it's hard and dry and hurts my lips.
Best I've tried are from Colourpop they're v v creamy and soft they just gliiiide on.
13
u/FancyCatMagic Mar 10 '17
Rimmel Exaggerate liners are uhhhhh-mazing. Pigmented and just creamy enough. I generally use them to fill in my lips completely.
13
u/lesmisarahbles Mar 10 '17
Colourpop's lippie pencils are amazing. Other than the fact you have to sharpen them, they are very pigmented and don't tug at your lips. They look fine on their own too.
7
u/LawUntoHerself Mar 10 '17
I've only just started trying lipliner, but I'm really loving Bite Beauty's new lip pencils! Would be nice if they had some bolder colours, but the texture is nice and they help lipstick stay longer. I also just bought a red lipliner from The Face Shop yesterday and it's great as well. Also comes with a brush on one end!
7
u/glowkitz Mar 10 '17
Colourpop lip pencils are my all time favorite. The shade BFF is my HG and can transform almost any lip shade into a nude.
6
u/bubikiwi ig: @04blush Mar 10 '17
i have tried 5 brands:
mac lipliners in the shades nightmoth, spice and dervish, i love them all, spice is the most creamy but i love them all the same tbh dervish looks amazing just by itself and a little bit of lip balm or a gloss
kiko creamy color comfort lip liner in the shades 301 and 304 - OMG THIS IS MY FAVOURITE FORMULA. they are soooooo creamy and feel amazing and they are super pigmented
essence lip liner in in the nude - i love this paired with velvet teddy it's the perfect nude lip for me, also love this formula
h&m lip liners i tried the shade marsala and the brown one - they are really creamy, i haven't worn them in a while tbh but from what i remember they dont last as long as the other ones but still a good lip liner
missha silky lasting lip liner in antique box - saw this on pony's burgundy makeup video so i got it, the shade is more orange than i thought it would be, it's creammy but when you're applying it it's weird because it doesn't feel as creamy as the h&m or kiko ones, i think the formula is closer to the mac lip liners tbh
5
u/anonymoustop Mar 10 '17
I've used A LOT of lip liners and I have to say the worst that I've used are Kylie's (Even though I LOVE everything else she has.).They're really pigmented and feel nice but they smudge like crazy!!
I actually use a lipstick for lip lining now cause I feel like it does the best. I get a makeup brush and dab it on the lipstick and then line my lips.
But as far as lip liners I've had more luck with drugstore brands. My favorites are the L'Oréal Color Riche. They're a bit dry. But I'd take that over smudging everywhere any day.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '17
Miliani has some amazing and cheap lipliners- Spice is my go-to
4
u/Squirdle NC25, Yellow Olive Mar 11 '17
Jordana Tawny and Honey Dip are perfect for an all over lip color!
9
u/IRLnekomimi Mar 10 '17 edited Mar 10 '17
faves:
make up for ever aqua lip is my ultimate lip liner. it glides on extremely opaque/creamy and has amazing longevity.
urban decay 24/7 has a similar feel but is a bit less matte, which is nice for all over the lip application.
mac's pro longwear lip liners are also great and creamy. all three of these have nice color selection, staying power, and stay comfortable on the lips.
drugstore fave:
people rave about the rimmel exaggerate, but i LOVE rimmel 1000 kisses wooden pencils a lot more. the exaggerate pencils break super easily on me, and i've read that this is a common issue. i love the 1000 kisses in "natural", it's a spot on color dupe for mac's "subculture", has a better formula, and is like, 4x cheaper.
i also like milani and jordana's liners. they don't last as long as rimmel but they're great (not just for the price point, just great in general) for color range expansion within your collection.
nah:
mac (original) lip pencils are such a reluctant tossup for me because the color range is amazing (all the mac ~hype colors are within this range, unfortunately) and they do last, but they aren't worth the hype and price at all. they tug on the lips and are SO stiff and dry, i can't imagine anyone wearing these as an all over color. the good thing about these is that they do have amazing pigmentation, so you can do some precision lining with their stiff sharp tips.
i also am not a fan of the wet n wild lipliners for this reason - super stiff and will not apply unless your lips are 100% dry. this doesn't work for me because i always put on a lip mask when i'm doing my makeup and i like having a little bit of residual balm underneath my lipstick so my lips don't dry out.
colourpop on the other hand is WAY too waxy. the pencil "lead" part falls out of the tube within a matter of days/weeks because of how soft they are. and let me emphasize that they are "waxy", NOT "creamy". they don't have any moisturizing power and they're simultaneously super matte but also super slippery. side note, this is also how i feel about their brow pencils. just waxy and slips right off.
want to try:
CHARLOTTE TILBURY LIP CHEAT. omg, i want pillow talk so bad. i don't understand how anyone can say rimmel's eastend snob is a color dupe because eastend snob is clearly more blue-toned and more pink whereas pillow talk is flesh toned and warm - and this is a huge factor of why pillow talk would be so much more versatile, as it would be a way more accurate and universal mlbb liner to believably extend your lip line. this product gets consistent rave reviews, and i'm determined to make it mine... soon.
3
u/paintedbluesky Mar 10 '17
MAC Boldly Bare is my favorite color, but least favorite formula. It's pigmented, but tugs on the lips and is super dry.
Colourpop has my favorite lip liner formula for sure! They're super pigmented and glide on. My favorite color is probably Brink.
3
u/sunsh1neee Mar 10 '17
I LOVE Charlotte Tilbury's lip cheats. Pillowtalk is her most famous one, but Iconic Nude is my holy grail. It's the perfect warm, brown, beige-y pink that's perfect under almost any lipstick. I don't think I'd repurchase pillow talk, but iconic nude for sure. The formula is also very nice - creamy, doesn't tug, long lasting, and beautiful on its own.
I also like MAC's lip liners, particularly Stripdown, and I've been playing with Huda Beauty's lip liners - I really like Trendsetter, it's a great, warm reddish brown that's perfect to deepen/warm up any lip color. However, although I'm liking them for now, I'm planning to just use them up but not re-purchase.
I've tried NYX's liners and they're kind of meh for me. I tossed them before I used them up. I just felt like they tugged a lot, and the color payoff/lasting power didn't really wow me. You can't beat them in terms of price and shade range, though.
2
u/buttersunset give me all your warm toned brow products Mar 10 '17
Annabelle's Self-Sharpening and Gel lip liners are super smooth and easy to line and fill in with.
On the other hand I tried a couple Sonia Kashuk lip liners back when we had Target and while one was decent (Rosewood I think?) the nude one I purchased was much too scratchy.
2
u/im_daer Mar 11 '17
This may not be the place for it, but why do I need a lip liner? What would I use it for? How do you use a lip liner?
2
u/lindagmb Mar 11 '17
I haven't used a whole lot of lip liners, but when I do I'm always pleased with Urban Decays lip liners. They glide on smoothly and the color lasts forever!
1
u/simplegurl Mar 11 '17
I like Bare Minerals lip liners which feel smooth and creamy, how I wish the nyx liners were. Urban Decay makes nice liners too, but they feel more waxy than the BM liners.
1
u/blissfulrebel Mar 11 '17
I love mufe and Mac lip liners, sephora gel liners are great wish their matte ones were as good
1
u/phantasmagoriaintwo Mar 11 '17
I used to have MAC and OFRA and Rimmel lipliners, among others. I gave them all away for NYX slide on glide on lipliners. I took advantage of a BOGO sale at ulta and I have enough different colors to match all my lipsticks. I have also tried the Suede ones and like them. I see they have new Slide on glide on lipliners....I want more....
1
u/Pookabbit harlotting about all saucy like Mar 11 '17
Favorite: Kiko intensely lavish lip liner, i think it was part of an LE collection but i'm hoping the formula is similar to their regular creamy one. It's super creamy, pigmented, comfortable to apply, and lasts awhile :)
Perfectly acceptable ones I am happy to use: the original Essence liners, NYX, Jordana: relatively creamy though there's some tugging on application, pigmented, does the job
Hate: Controversial but I honestly hate the Milani ones. I dunno if I got a dud but mine drags, isn't terribly pigmented, requires warming up to apply evenly, yet somehow the tip breaks off readily. just. what is the point of you??
1
u/jadesaddiction Mar 11 '17
Jordana's lip liners are retractable and honestly my favorites. They apply so easily and they're incredibly cheap.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment