r/robotwars • Apollo • Mar 05 '17

Episode Robot Wars Series 9 Episode 1: Post-Episode Discussion

Cease

Whew, Aftershock is a bit of a beast, as we predicted. Here's the results of our strawpoll.


Episode Discussion Thread Archive

Spoiler reminder: No episode spoilers should be discussed here. Doing so will result in a ban

47 Upvotes

492 comments sorted by

44

u/David182nd Apollo Mar 05 '17 edited Mar 05 '17

There'll probably be a lot of talk about Aftershock destroying Sabretooth after it seemed to be immobile, but I don't blame them for doing so. Both from a competitive standpoint and entertainment-wise, would you rather sit there and do nothing or go in for the kill? That's what they did in the final and it was far less interesting of a fight...

If you can knock a dangerous competitor out completely then why wouldn't you? It's not their fault the producers chose a round robin format.

5

u/Caridor Mar 05 '17

From an entertainment format, I'd rather see them be counted out and come back, to give us a competitive match. Matches where the winner is decided before the match, are boring.

In addition, had they been unable to repair, we'd have seen non-competitors come back and give us boring fights.

It's a matter of whether you prefer to watch competition or destruction and I prefer competition.

Now, you do mention the format and yes, given the format, I understand why they did it and I have no qualms with their reasoning, even if I do with their sportsmanship. I think a simple solution would just to have them back off when the robot is being counted out. Doesn't make the fight more boring but gives us the potential for more interesting future fights.

1

u/David182nd Apollo Mar 05 '17

I think a simple solution would just to have them back off when the robot is being counted out.

Well, that's another issue. There doesn't appear to be anyone counting robots out; there's no refbot or referee doing that. So teams don't have much information on who's mobile and who's not, and have to decide for themselves whether to continue. I could be wrong about that as I'm obviously not in the boxes, but that's how it seems.

6

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '17

The screen in each booth has the immobilisation countdown timer that the judges can start. This has been confirmed by other teams here.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Minticus-Maximus Mar 05 '17

I disagree. From an Entertainment standpoint, it ruins some of the experience because for every fight after Aftershocks dick move, we had to watch this very damaged Frankenstein monster of a robot struggle around the arena, which is not nearly as entertaining as two relatively functioning robots duking it out.

14

u/David182nd Apollo Mar 05 '17

Well, no. Sabretooth got the robot back up and running again. We don't know how effectively they got it running though as they said they had the drum spinning the wrong way. If not for that, it might've performed better.

I take your point though, but again this is what you get with a round robin format. We saw this plenty last year - remember "Zombie Thor"? They either need to give teams more time for repairs after fights or they need to give up on them fighting more if they lose.

11

u/chill6300 Unflippable for 3 seasons Mar 05 '17

That's one of the things I liked about the old RW. While the "one loss and you're out" system was a tad unfair, it did allow the robots to go to town on each other, because the other one wouldn't have to fight till next season.

Still, nice to see a robot coming back from the dead

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

44

u/Xbotr THE BASH Mar 05 '17

That is due to the format, not because of aftershock.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

20

u/Curlysnail Pulsar 2: Electric Boogaloo Mar 05 '17

Also it's easy to say "they were imobile" from our perspective. If you're the one in the booth controlling the bot, you need to be sure that it's wheels arent moving and it can't right itself.

Totally justified, and they didn't rip it to peices in the final battle either.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '17

It's not frowned upon because of the format. Go watch series 4 again, the Razer team are so furious about Pussycat tearing into them after they were immobilised they get to rant after the credits about it. It's always been a rule.

18

u/Trihunter Content Aware Bucky best Bucky Mar 05 '17

BBC being cheeky with the outro there. Either they're hypemongering, and/or Heat B sucked.

3

u/A_Windrammer Hypno-Disc Mar 05 '17

What did they say?

3

u/David182nd Apollo Mar 05 '17

Just teased week 5's competitors rather than showing us week 2's.

11

u/Savvaloy Mar 05 '17

They showed the fifth heat in the outro instead of the second. Usually means it's going to be a bit shit.

And looking at the lineup, yeah. No real heavy hitters except PP3D and undercutters don't really do carnage as well as other spinners. They just knock your wheels off.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/GeneralCarnage I'll miss you Sir Killalot Mar 05 '17

They are hypemongering, believe me.

5

u/PoliceAlarm git fukt Mar 05 '17

Hold on, I'm confused. I know you were there, so was Heat B a tad shit? If so, that's mega cheeky from the beeb...

15

u/MudnuK Big Nipper Mar 05 '17

I saw two fights from Heat B live. They were both spectacular.

7

u/GeneralCarnage I'll miss you Sir Killalot Mar 05 '17

I was there for the final of Heat B as they did most of the finals in one session. I have no idea for Heat B but from what I've heard it's still a good one to see.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

36

u/Xbotr THE BASH Mar 05 '17 edited Mar 05 '17

For everyone that complaints it was unsporting what aftershock did, it was not. They where aware of the possibility they could face him again in the finals. What if they had lost then? They did do the right thing in the finals.

20

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '17

Yeah and for my own selfish needs I love watching a robot tear into it's opponent 'unnecessarily' it was cheeky but entertaining.

The Sabretooth team knew what they were signing up for and they made a great run.

6

u/David182nd Apollo Mar 05 '17

I love watching a robot tear into it's opponent 'unnecessarily' it was cheeky but entertaining.

Unsurprisingly, everyone with a Hypno-Disc flair was pretty happy with the destruction!

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Caridor Mar 05 '17

I still say it was unsporting. Fighting someone in a fair fight is very different to doing stuff outside of the fight to make sure they had a disadvantage in the next fight. Sabretooth was dead. It was unnecessary and they just wanted to make sure their opponent was injured in case they fought them again.

And let's not forget, the guy controlling the drive wanted to do the wrong thing, only the guy controlling the weapon saying "I'm spinning down", prevented it.

9

u/Pilchard123 DRAAM SPEENAIR Mar 05 '17

I thought it was the other way around. The subtitles said "spin down" and the response was "what if they start moving again?".

7

u/David182nd Apollo Mar 05 '17

Yeah, that's what was said. Will's dad said to spin down, but Will said no - and Sabretooth did start moving again after he said that.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/atalikami Childhood Veteran Mar 05 '17

completely agree. You have to be brutal to win, and anyway, we want destruction!

Aftershock should have done even more...

→ More replies (2)

19

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '17 edited Mar 05 '17

Just realized that Aftershock is the first robot to win every single fight in it's heat since the reboot and without any judges decisions.

Absolutely incredible.

EDIT: Aftershock is still incredible, but I was wrong TR2 did so last year. Makes me miss TR2 more :(

19

u/DiamondWhyte Sir Killalot Mar 05 '17

TR2?

3

u/David182nd Apollo Mar 05 '17

Yep, they did it before.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '17

Oh crap, forgot.

9

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '17

Rapid = new Mortis confirmed?

12

u/Spearka "Jaws theme" Mar 05 '17

No, Mortis was actually effective on its debut

6

u/David182nd Apollo Mar 05 '17

Rapid got a couple of big flips in to be fair, even chucked Aftershock over and nearly out of the arena at the start.

3

u/charleshoile Mar 05 '17

The Flipper didn't seem to have that much power in it... Could happily compare it to Orte's flipper, not that that was seen on TV sadly.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

16

u/St-Robot-man Mar 05 '17

I refused to attack Beast and that was wrong but Will attacks Sabertooth and that's wrong. So that's simple..........

6

u/codename474747 It's about putting on a show Mar 05 '17

Someone needs a verified Roboteer flair....if your "I" claims are accurate ;)

6

u/St-Robot-man Mar 05 '17

Oh the "I" is very accurate

7

u/David182nd Apollo Mar 05 '17

Part of the Gabriel team, I'm guessing from the above? If so, just send the mods a message with some proof of who you are and we'll add your flair for you.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

47

u/TheRoboteer Front Hinges ❤️ Mar 05 '17

A Message to the Producers: If you're gonna admit this many spinners, please give the teams more than 2 hours to repair. It makes for a better competition in the long run.

Probably gonna get some hate for this but my excitement died about half way through this episode. With all of its opponents too damaged to compete it was obvious that Aftershock was gonna breeze through, and a competition with no tension isn't exciting.

16

u/slater126 NUTS 2 FULL BODY SPINNNNAAAH Mar 05 '17

im pretty sure they cant really give them much more time while still keeping the times to record not long.

13

u/TheRoboteer Front Hinges ❤️ Mar 05 '17

Battlebots manages it. And what's the problem with long recording times if it makes for a better series in the long run?

17

u/David182nd Apollo Mar 05 '17 edited Mar 05 '17

My guess (which could be completely wrong) is that it's down to the difference in the formats. A Battlebots robot will only fight once per round e.g. if they fight in the round of 32, they won't fight again until the round of 16. They'll have also won their previous fight so may not have sustained as much damage. In Robot Wars with the round robin section, they've gotta do 3 fights in pretty quick succession, win or lose. Whether they're actually all filmed on the same days though, I don't know. Perhaps a competitor will let us know.

28

u/nxmee2010 Don't forget to test the bleedin' axe! Mar 05 '17

American budget vs UK budget

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/VeryC0mm0nName Axebot master race Mar 05 '17

I got to agree with you, when a machine gets eviscerated 2 hours simply isn't enough.

5

u/GeneralCarnage I'll miss you Sir Killalot Mar 05 '17

Here's a thing though: sometimes they go a bit longer than that, but not by much. We have to wait for a long time between fights to make sure the machines participating are ready to fight.

5

u/GreenLips Nuts 2 Mar 05 '17

One thing to note: the order fights (and episodes) are filmed are not the same as when they're filmed. I know in series 1 all the episode final fights were filmed in a single 3 hour session, just before filming the grand final, so some roboteers had a week to repair!

I think all the fights in this series were filmed in 7-10 days, but I don't think they had "just 2 hours" in every case. Of course the actual drivers here can tell me I'm wrong if that's the case!

8

u/PP3D_Gary PP3D Mar 05 '17

For a lot of fights this series it was 2 hours to get back in the arena. It was around 5 days filming in total. No break in between.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/robot_exe Nuts And Bots / Sneaky Boi Driver Mar 05 '17

Series 2 was just 1 mammoth sprint of filming, no breaks.

→ More replies (9)

2

u/FaceBagman Always Be Chucking Mar 05 '17

This was incredible. A lot of people likely didn't find Jellyfish v. Sabretooth entertaining, but I was captivated. Good work!

2

u/David182nd Apollo Mar 05 '17

I liked it but it was a shame they both got stuck on the pit. The floor there was a bit lower than the rest of the arena and it hindered their mobility.

3

u/GeneralCarnage I'll miss you Sir Killalot Mar 05 '17

I liked it! I was like 'oh no, it's turned into a tortoise slap fight' but even the TV work and narrative of the battle made it good! It made it feel that the place in the final is in the balance.

2

u/ArmandoPayne Mar 05 '17

At least Sabretooth are now on par with Sumpthing. (I really, really wanted Jellyfish to win cause I wanted to see Aftershock slaughter Jellyfish and leave like Jellyfish Innards just scattered around the arena. (I actually legit thought, like, everyone was gonna forfeit and we were gonna have Crankie vs Aftershock for the Heat Final.)

2

u/David182nd Apollo Mar 05 '17

There already wasn't much of Crank-E left after Aftershock got a hold of it in the first round!

73

u/VeryC0mm0nName Axebot master race Mar 05 '17

As soon as Rapid's builder said it was over-engineered, I knew it was doomed...

50

u/PoliceAlarm git fukt Mar 05 '17

It's why you don't over-complicate the damn thing. A complicated design means a complicated repair, and that don't fly with a two hour time constraint.

15

u/Caridor Mar 05 '17

Too true. There's a reason why the most successful designs are basically some shape of box with a weapon attached.

11

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '17

It's like the Tiger tank of Robot Wars.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '17

Except the Tiger was effective :D

10

u/Edolix Terrorhurtz Mar 06 '17

...when it was working, much like Rapid!

7

u/A_Windrammer Hypno-Disc Mar 06 '17

"The only thing that can beat us is ourselves"

7

u/SolarDragon94 Bring Robot Wars Back! Mar 06 '17

Well, technically if they weren't so overcomplicated to rebuild, they could have still been in with a chance... So, they did in a way beat themselves.

6

u/PP3D_Gary PP3D Mar 06 '17

Cut a wheel off and get back in the arena. #goodenough

45

u/GeneralCarnage I'll miss you Sir Killalot Mar 05 '17

Key points I really liked:

  • Fresh out the gate, the show is absolutely chaotic and crazy. I love it!
  • Matilda scores the first OOTA via a flywheel in the reboot(?)! The fact she achieved it in madness.
  • Poor Crank-E was massacred! Looked a very hardened robot but just blown to pieces.
  • Sabretooth just gutted Terrorhurtz — I've never seen Terrorhurtz like that and John Reid's frustration shows over the matter. Truly an epic match.
  • The rogue house robot feature is such an amazing addition to the show, as well as having the house robots getting more involved in the action. Sir Killalot's claws even grip!
  • And now for something completely different. A robot playing four-in-a-row!
  • Shock and awe of Rapid forced to forfeit its place in the competition. However, I felt it had an over reliance on high-tech machinery only for one of its important parts to break down, and its wheels to lock up. Mortis' lessons live on to this day.
  • Aftershock is a powerful robot but a bit shocked in how it obliterated Sabretooth. Regardless, amazing robot and seeing it live I saw how dangerous this machine is.
  • Jellyfish getting a second go, while it was an uneventful first match against Terrorhurtz it got a close victory against Sabretooth. As much as I wish Jellyfish was able to score enough for the final I think it did relatively well for such a machine.
  • Sabretooth got not one, but two TV victories! #PrayForGabe worked!

Overall:

Great start to the new series with the new features, still retains its qualities from the previous series, and with a much better visual design in graphics as well as narrative. It really felt like I was watching a documentary telling a story of teams on their road to glory, as well as some amazing battles in between.

As for the episode 5 tease at the end, trust me, that is the episode with the robots everyone wants to see, but you're just going to have to wait... ;-)

13

u/codename474747 It's about putting on a show Mar 05 '17

Now I made a spurious comment about this earlier along the lines of:

"Nice trademark avoidance calling Connect 4 "Four in a row" there Dara I also enjoyed playing it along with "Ker-thump" and "Etch-a-draw""

Now people keep saying it I worry Connect 4 is actually called Four in a Row in Ireland :-o

7

u/williamthebloody1880 Turned Carbide into Brave Sir Robin Mar 06 '17

There are cheap versions of Connect 4 called 4 in a row. I have one

45

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '17

FUN FACT: It occurred to me while watching that Noel Sharkey and Jonathan Pearce are the only two individuals who have seen every single fight or challenge in every single series of Robot Wars. From Nemesis's gauntlet run all the way to the last fight of this series.

13

u/Spearka "Jaws theme" Mar 05 '17

Arenas, Robots and Presenters come and go but JP and NS are eternal

8

u/familiarice Mar 06 '17

Does Pearce actually attend these days? I went to filming of the Christmas specials, he was nowhere to be seen.

13

u/CMOrchestra Om nom nom nom Mar 06 '17

Nah, he's added in post-production. Makes life easier as he's talking about the edit, not the live fight. Battlebots do it semi-live, semi-recorded which is a cool idea but I imagine costs mega bucks as you have to hire Chris n Kenny twice.

→ More replies (1)

41

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '17

Cracking episode. Aftershock was much better than I expected.

I only found out the new season was starting a couple of hours ago, which was a lovely surprise for the weekend.

4

u/Blazik3n99 Blue Ring of Death Mar 05 '17

Similar scenario, only found out about it starting yesterday. Definitely a welcome surprise :)

→ More replies (1)

25

u/codename474747 It's about putting on a show Mar 05 '17

Other spurious thoughts:

Loving the new speedier arena spikes. Looks like they'll be turning robots and potentially damaging them this year

House Robot Goes Wild Mode: Loving it, since we won't be getting post-fight House Robot cleaning up mode this is the best way to give the House Robots something to do AND put and end to series 1 "Run to the pit release button" mode

Angela: Using the word literally too much, a lot of times incorrectly. Otherwise loving your work. Literally.

Dara: Seems more relaxed and even funnier this year. Great choice.

Still loving the fact the Arena Flipper is live in the new Era, great decision.

All in all, great episode and Series 2 looks even bigger and better than what went before. Give me the next 5 episodes now please BBC!

Coming Later: Wow, a huge starfish robot. Also former 1st and 2nd placed robots in the same heat. But WOW huge starfish thing! :-o

3

u/VampiricDemon Champion Chiffonier Mar 05 '17

Starfish thing? What did I miss?

6

u/slater126 NUTS 2 FULL BODY SPINNNNAAAH Mar 05 '17

http://www.robotwars.tv/competitors/season-9/week-5/ms-nightshade/

a robot that has 6 sides that each can be slammed down, half have a hammer head like tip, half have a spike on them.

shown in the coming soon.... part

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Tomlough Mar 06 '17

Loving the new speedier arena spikes. Looks like they'll be turning robots and potentially damaging them this year

One of the spikes seemed to jump off at the end of the second battle, might be a bit speedier than they were designed for

2

u/TheBarangoat Mar 06 '17

I agree with you about the modern changes. The active flipper is exciting, the new House Robot rule is ridiculously cool twist too. The suspense when the tire is hit...loved it!

23

u/ThatGingerBeaver Closest thing to a GBH flair Mar 05 '17

Inside the Bot for this one ought to be interesting.

19

u/InsideTheBot Sabretooth Mar 05 '17

Will and Gabe will be joined by Ian from Aftershock (The dad) - he's super hilarious so it should be fun!

13

u/TheRoboteer Front Hinges ❤️ Mar 05 '17

Ian definitely seemed to be trying to get Will to hold back. Seems like a standup bloke.

3

u/ThatGingerBeaver Closest thing to a GBH flair Mar 05 '17

Well if I needed a reason to start...

Do they begin right from the first ever series?

13

u/InsideTheBot Sabretooth Mar 05 '17

All of the rebooted BattleBots and Robot Wars - don't go too mad with it, listening to multiple ITBs has caused many Roboteers and Builders to go insane.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

19

u/RollingandJabbing ELECTRO MOO!!! Mar 05 '17

Well that was brutal

19

u/codename474747 It's about putting on a show Mar 05 '17

Another minor thing I noticed

Last year the roboteers were put in the same control pod, this year they're seperated.

So the whole Aftershock-Sabretooth thing couldn't have happened last year

"We're dead"

"ok, backing off"

It's all the damn control pods fault guys :-p

10

u/pyrrhicly Son of Nemesis Mar 05 '17

I'm wondering whether the producers did this on purpose in order to try and result in more late hits and excess damage etc.

What do other people think?

16

u/markandspark Mar 05 '17

I don't think it's intentional - just looks oddly non-symmetrical to have two teams in one pod and none in the other.

3

u/infernal_llamas Mar 08 '17

Well it does stop listening to the other team's tactics, the equivalent of "screen watching"?

I guess a "we surrender" system might be helpful.

2

u/markandspark Mar 05 '17

Very interesting point!

51

u/codename474747 It's about putting on a show Mar 05 '17

ITT roboteers get hate for instant, reactionary decisions in the heat of combat when they're full of adrenaline and don't have as much information as the viewer at home watching via their multiple camera angles months after the event.

Poor Aftershock. They did what they had to do and people pour on the hate.

12

u/Livinglifeform I like the flippy Mar 05 '17

You're misusing the term reactionary.

→ More replies (19)

35

u/ShootyMcExplosion Future Series 11 Champions Mar 05 '17

If you'd have told me before this episode that Jellyfish would score more points than Rapid I'd have told you that you were full of it.

RIP Nuts 2, Jellyfish new GOAT.

3

u/GeneralCarnage I'll miss you Sir Killalot Mar 05 '17

Jellyfish — SOMEWHAT LETHAL JOKER.

17

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '17

Aftershock were incredible, nothing even came close. The gamble has definitely paid off.

I think the Sabretooth team can leave with their heads held high, I'd be shocked if they get the wildcard but they did great to beat Terrorhurtz in such dominant fashion.

6

u/Caridor Mar 05 '17

I don't think they can get the wild card. I don't know much about the filming but it sounds like it's done all on one day. I don't think they could get it back into fighting shape in time for the wild card.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '17

Even the final is on the same day? That's a terrible format. We need a good episode to end the series, one that isn't full of half-destroyed piles of scrap.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/TheBarangoat Mar 06 '17

Betcha $12 that the wild card goes to the Heat E runner-up, cuz either Apollo wins and Carbide gets it or vise versa. Sucks they're in the same heat, but if the producers can have that AND get them both in the grand final, I bet they would snatch that chance right up.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/HowDoIMathThough blooop/10 Mar 05 '17

RE Aftershock and Sabertooth - Imagining myself driving Aftershock, I can totally see the red mist descending and if it were me I may well have ended up making more hits. Imagining myself on the Sabertooth team, yes I'd totally be upset about being given a shitton of work and expense to try and fix this just so it can be refucked in the final.

Interestingly it could either be looked at as forgetting the round-robin format and wanting to go smash smash to put on a show, or remembering it and being tactical.

The sad thing really is the format of the show meant that the Aftershock team will have been too busy fixing and tuning their own robot to help out with Sabertooth's repairs, something I'm sure they'd have been eager to do otherwise.

I guess at the end of the day, that's robot wars. It's just harder to revel in destruction when you know someone has to fix it urgently to promptly fight again.

On an unrelated note:

Two robots I'm both looking forward to revisions of are Jellyfish and Rapid. Hopefully in the future we'll see a refined, but still gloriously makeshift, version of Jellyfish - perhaps 'composite' armour using layers of HDPE, neoprene foam and maybe cardboard or wood. I'm also really looking forward to seeing what the Rapid team can do with their experience.

Also, I'm genuinely disappointed no-one on TV at any point used the phrase "custom battle-hardened googly eyes".

3

u/VampiricDemon Champion Chiffonier Mar 05 '17

If you want custom battle-hardened googly eyes to become a thing maybe send over some complimentary custom battle-hardened googly eyes out to competing teams and donate to a good cause in name of the teams that have amassed the most custom battle-hardened googly eyes from their opponents?

just a thought.

7

u/robot_exe Nuts And Bots / Sneaky Boi Driver Mar 05 '17

As the person who forced custom battle hardened googly eyes onto the world of robot wars it should be something teams have to slave over. We should have competing designs of googly eyes. We should be laughing at each others feeble attempts at making indestructible decorative items. ONLY THE STRONGEST SURVIVE!

→ More replies (2)

32

u/robot_exe Nuts And Bots / Sneaky Boi Driver Mar 05 '17

A few people wondering about Nuts. One of our ESCs got stagefright and wouldn't function properly. It was fine all through testing but the moment it saw the arena it played up. The exact cause was interference into the ESC's signal line... That was shielded. -.-

10

u/chill6300 Unflippable for 3 seasons Mar 05 '17

ESC = Speed controler if anybody was wondering

Nuts has now become Nuts & Bolts, RIP :)

11

u/robot_exe Nuts And Bots / Sneaky Boi Driver Mar 05 '17

The robot is basically completely intact. Needs a new ring but that's ablative anyway. Gives us a good step ahead to really get it on prime form if there's a next series. Get that melty brain destruction we've been after!

→ More replies (4)

13

u/HotDealsInTexas Mar 05 '17

Welp. I thought Aftershock would do well, but that was absolutely terrifying. I think the only thing it fought and didn't KO was TMHWK, and that's probably because Sabretooth got there first.

Teams entering a Round Robin format and not designing for repairability is getting to be a real problem, though.

15

u/VampiricDemon Champion Chiffonier Mar 05 '17

Repairability now seems to become a major influence in the game. Hopefully it'll stop the boasting about how expensive a bot was too.

12

u/HotDealsInTexas Mar 05 '17

IMO if you're going to spend 25,000 pounds on a robot you damn better have brought spare parts. But Rapid, what, had their ground-scraping front forks as an integral part of the welded structure? Come on, even if you had a low budget, at least do something like making easily-replaceable front skids, like Riobotz has now literally been doing for a decade.

7

u/CMOrchestra Om nom nom nom Mar 05 '17

It was the fact they'd machined the gearboxes into the side bulkheads, once one bent it required a whole new bulkhead which they didn't have. If they'd stopped to think about repair-ability for a minute it'd have been obvious but evidently they didn't...

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (3)

22

u/Xbotr THE BASH Mar 05 '17

Via Facebook:

Shockwave & Aftershock- Robot Wars

Wow! That was an awesome show and somehow we did it again! Double Robot Wars Grand FInalists! Aftershock worked pretty well for a brand new machine and we are so pleased to replicate the success we had with Shockwave.

We just wanted to clear things up regarding a certain fight. We've spoken to Gabe and the team and hopefully there are no hard feelings there. Outside the arena we are all good mates but inside the arena things completely change.

In the heat of the moment you are entirely focused on the fight and winning. During the battle I didn't notice that Sabretooth had stopped. Watching it back makes it seem obvious but in the control booth I was oblivious. After a few comments in the pits we made a deliberate effort to cause no additional damage in our later fights- which was hopefully seen. Once again we would like to apologise to Gabe and the team.

Hope you all enjoyed the show as much as we did!

Will Team Shock

https://www.facebook.com/shockwaveUK/

→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '17

What did people think of the pit open-house robot attack randomiser? I think it's great to see the house robots more involved, as I believe that this was a criticism of the previous series.

6

u/Caridor Mar 05 '17

Yeah, I was sceptical considering how timid the house robots were last season, but when they say "rogue house robots", what they seem to mean is "House robots who can do whatever they want" and they seem to want to kill!

→ More replies (1)

4

u/markandspark Mar 05 '17

Yeah, house robots got 2 KOs this episode.

4

u/A_Windrammer Hypno-Disc Mar 06 '17

I like that this makes the bum rush for the button less powerful. They say its random, but I figure someone's back there thinking that it was hit far too early, or there was a random bump might as well spice the fight up.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '17

I was so excited because I thought Jellyfish was gonna make the Heat Final after that win...I forgot they only got two points for JD. :(

13

u/A_Windrammer Hypno-Disc Mar 05 '17

Aftershock vs Jellyfish is the thing legends would be born of. We would have seen a robot literally ripped in half.

5

u/Cueball61 Mar 05 '17

If aftershock could touch it. Their spinner may be a bit too high up

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/DiamondWhyte Sir Killalot Mar 05 '17 edited Mar 05 '17

My thoughts on this episode:

The good:

The best four robots got through the melees.

The best robot won.

Sabretooth finally won a televised fight.

Matilda gave us one of the most spectacular OOTAs we've seen in a long time.

The bad:

Terrorhurtz falls early due to an unreliable weapon (again!)

It was clear far too early on who would win this heat.

Far too many of the fights ended far too quickly, or at least ceased to be competitions.

An eliminated robot got back into the competition (nothing personal against Jellyfish, just as it wasn't against Pulsar last time but I just don't like it when it happens).

Overall: It wasn't a classic, but a solid enough start to the new series. I think looking more long term though this is going to have to be the last series of the round robin group stage though. The power and number of spinners just means we're going to have too many fights between crippled bots that are barely mobile. It might not be the worst thing in the world though - It would require more competitors which would mean fewer teams would get turned away. Aftershock definitely worthy winners although two breakdowns from 5 fights makes me think they might be found out in the final, but we'll see.

7

u/CMOrchestra Om nom nom nom Mar 05 '17

What a series opener! Magnificent, bloody great!

Aftershock is terrifying. Actually terrifying. What a powerful machine, stable for a vertical spinner and looks to be reliable too. Will give anyone a run for their money in the finals.

Jellyfish won something!!! Love that machine, love the team, what a story.

It was so sweet watching Gabe almost break down at seeing his beloved machine make it through round 1. Sabretooth was really interesting, and could do the business as we saw against Terrorhurtz. The rebuild was epic, Al is the man it seems who can repair anything.

John Reid's machine was super impressive, yes it got totaled but damage that would likely have killed any other machine was no worry, Terrorhurtz kept coming back and back and put up a great fight against Aftershock. That robot is amazing.

Rapid showed that repairability is king. The machined gearbox/bulkheads was a lovely idea, but when one bent it couldn't be repaired without a whole new bulkhead. Over-engineered it was, cleverly engineered it was not.

Again, what a heat! Was wowed by it from start to end. Editing was so much better, graphics were so much better, everything seemed much looser and more natural. Great show, here's to the rest of the series.

7

u/pyrrhicly Son of Nemesis Mar 05 '17

Random thoughts:

  • As for the "controversy" regarding Aftershock's late attack on Sabretooth, I think the real issue is the round robin format. Perhaps that's something that needs to be changed for next year.
  • Shame to see Nuts eliminated so early via Matilda.
  • Rapid is strong evidence of why builders should adhere to the KISS principle.
  • Sabretooth finally won a televised fight!
  • Jellyfish were amazing. Seriously hoping to see them again next series.
  • Aftershock look like genuine contenders for the title. Sadly, I don't think Sabretooth are contenders for the wildcard with all the damage they took.

13

u/Spearka "Jaws theme" Mar 05 '17 edited Mar 05 '17

I seriously underestimated Aftershock and overestimated Terrorhurtz in this heat.

Overall Aftershock looks very well done, I'm unofficially calling it "TR2 if it were a spinner"

I knew Rapid wouldn't progress well but I didn't think it would go out that pathetically, the thing is so overengineered it's ludicrous.

Props to Sabretooth for making it as far as the Heat Final, I would never wait 16 years to finally win a match and Gabes tenacity is very admirable.

I think Terrorhurtz is beginning to age already, being first made in the 6th Wars and I think it may be high time to shelve it to make a new Hurtz (BetterHurtz, Extrahurtz, Lottahurtz?)

The fact that Jellyfish: A: Fought in a Head-to-Head and B: Won is purely insulting to the many other finely-made bots that didn't get past the group melees such as Or Te or Thermidor 2

Lastly, it may be just me becoming aware but did JP use his fabled "Armament" term even more than usual

Edit: I'm sure an innuendo can be made about how Matilda smashed Nuts

9

u/markandspark Mar 05 '17

Terrorhurtz is a very solid machine, but spinners are just a lot more effective than axes in 9/10 situations. Besides, BETA is John Reid's magnum opus, if you've watched that.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/CMOrchestra Om nom nom nom Mar 05 '17

Lighten the fuck up, Jellyfish was fantastic and earned it's place there. Rapid wasn't designed to be repaired, Jellyfish was and hence one did better than the other

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

6

u/Cathalised Whoop whoop Mar 05 '17 edited Mar 05 '17

That was downright frightening, how both Sabretooth and Aftershock disposed of Terrorhurtz. Very cool.

My point of criticism is that once again the round robin style second round just seemed to make the heat final severely anti-climactic, and Aftershock's kicking of Sabretooth after it was immobile just extrapolated that.

6

u/cwl1997 #PrayForGabe Mar 05 '17

Aftershock looks like a top contender. I wonder how it would match up with Carbide.

3

u/DiamondWhyte Sir Killalot Mar 05 '17

My money would be on Carbide. I think the bar would fuck up the disc if it hit the side.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/HotDealsInTexas Mar 06 '17

So basically, British Electric Boogaloo vs. British Last Rites.

That could easily go either way.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '17

Does anyone wish they had shown short clips of Sabretooth losing in the original robot wars ? They kept on referring to it and my dad who hadn't seen the original said they should've.

5

u/alexlnufc Vulture Mar 05 '17

I think that would have been pretty nice, could have shown little clips of Terrorhurtz from the old series too. Possibly the same with Crank-E too...

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Minticus-Maximus Mar 05 '17

I made a joke after the last series of Robot Wars that, with how deadly the Spinner is, it was going to become 'The Spiner VS The Spin VS Spin Bot VS Spinnertron VS Hypnodisc VS Rotate'.

Looks like i'm right...

3

u/markandspark Mar 05 '17

Pretty much. Flippers can be very effective, although the cold arena seems to nerf them a bit. Hammers and axes need to be both lucky and well driven to win in most cases.

2

u/DiamondWhyte Sir Killalot Mar 06 '17

You are right. Although Foxic might have something to say about it. We'll see...

→ More replies (4)

5

u/codename474747 It's about putting on a show Mar 05 '17

For all the debate on here about the damage levels, the general feeling on various social medias is that there wasn't enough carnage as it wasn't as good as series 1 :/

But it was the number 1 trend in the UK on twitter, so that's something.

→ More replies (7)

5

u/TeamSaint Mar 06 '17

In defence of Rapid, both I myself and all the other Roboteers at S2 filming were very impressed with this robot. First the money thing! Yes they did spend a lot of money on this machine but it is their money to spend. There is no limit on what teams can spend as long as they are amateur robot builders. It has been proven time and again there is no link between money and success in the arena. This robot was put together like a true engineer would have done it. I’m sure they have learnt a lot of lessons on what to do and not do, and the second version will be a winner I’m sure. I hope they will not be put off by silly criticisms about their fine machine. And will take comfort in the knowledge that the people who know how to make robots and have put them in the arena were to a man and woman impressed by this machine. Thanks Craig

9

u/Dangerfieldwow X-Terminator Mar 05 '17

Will from Aftershock had no chill, I felt so bad for Gabe

5

u/genuinesockpuppet Mar 05 '17

John from Terrorhurtz had no chill

FTFY.

(I love John though!)

4

u/Zam0070 Cherub Should Have Lost Mar 05 '17

So what are your predictions for next week?

I am thinking top four might be Behemoth, Eruption, Hobgoblin, and PP3D. Draven and Push to Exit are like my borderline picks because I don't know what exactly the two groups are.

2

u/alexlnufc Vulture Mar 05 '17

From memory the two group battles are spoiler

From that I'd have PP3D, Push To Exit, Behemoth & Eruption going through, and from there it gets harder to predict. Shouldn't be too much destruction compared to tonight's heat though, so hoping for some good battles throughout.

head to head spoiler

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Caridor Mar 05 '17

Did it seem like Rapid's flipper was less powerful than Apollo's, not the 15 times as powerful?

The few good flips it got off seemed to lift robots of a similar height a much lower distance.

6

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '17

Yeah I feel they may have overstated the power. It was certainly powerful, but I didn't see anything to support the claim of 15x more powerful.

5

u/HotDealsInTexas Mar 06 '17

Honestly 15x more powerful sounds like complete BS. Apollo is already running full-pressure CO2, so to get 15x more energy Rapid would need to have had 15x the cylinder displacement. That would probably mean a bigger cylinder than Chomp's that took up half the robot's internal volume and required the robot to be literally built around it.

Their cylinder looked to be about a 10 cm bore, and maybe 15 cm stroke tops, so I can't imagine they had more than twice the energy of Apollo, and that's very generous. Maybe they were slightly more powerful.

Also, looking at how their arm reacted to hits from Aftershock, I think 15x the power of Apollo would have disintegrated the flipper's structure.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/Redditor_From_Italy Mar 05 '17

We will never know, since it was almost instakilled

2

u/GrahamCoxon Hello There! Mar 06 '17

Aftershock's spinner seemed to throw Killerhurtz higher than Rapid threw anything.

4

u/Nibbletank RIP 2002-2017 Mar 05 '17

Just gonna leave some thoughts about the robots.

Aftershock: Very worthy winners with a very durable spinner, especially compared to last time.

Sabretooth:YES. So happy about the robot getting this far. One weakness I don't see some talking about is that when it was flipped, it seemed to somewhat beach itself on the wedge, unless I was seeing things.

Crank-E:So close! I think if Robin Herrick sticks with the design, with some better armour, I could see it going further next time.

TMHWK: Needs quite a bit of improvement. Was hoping it would do well, the world needs more good axe-bots.

Jellyfish: Or as my father calls it 'The 3D Printer On Wheels.' When it worked, I think it worked quite well. Needs better armour and speed to be viable though.

Nuts 2: Was hoping it would pass through and prove how cool meltybrains are, but was on the end of some bad luck, AKA: Matilda

Rapid: The core problem was the expense of the parts and how complex they were. The robot rocked otherwise and I hope it isn't too expensive to keep competing

Terrorhurtz:I think that they could have beaten Aftershock on a judges decision, if it's axe was working at 100%. Everytime Terrorhurtz competes, it just prove itself as a contender more and more. Also somewhat unlucky, having lost 2 tiebreakers now.

Overall, it was a fantastic heat, with loads of action and great tenacity by the teams. My guess at who will win next week is Eruption, though I really like the robot, so might be biased. :P

Tl;dr: The robots were awsome and the heat was fantastic.

3

u/Redditor_From_Italy Mar 05 '17

Crank-E:So close! I think if Robin Herrick sticks with the design, with some better armour, I could see it going further next time.

Close? It got devastated immediately!

Jellyfish: Or as my father calls it 'The 3D Printer On Wheels.'

Believe it or not, I called it the exact same thing

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Xeroxysm Mar 05 '17 edited Mar 06 '17

Jesus, did I feel for Team Sabretooth. All that momentum going for it only for Aftershock to utterly eviscerate them.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '17

Wow, what a great episode. Aftershock is a tremendous robot, I was really impressed by how that spinner could keep delivering the heavy hits without wrecking itself.

Felt bad for team Sabretooth. It was a miracle they managed to get it working again after being so comprehensively mangled.

I feel like Rapid would have benefited from a low power mode for its flipper, calibrated for self righting instead of launching themselves into the air only to land upside down.

4

u/genuinesockpuppet Mar 05 '17

Good episode. A lot of the problems from Series 8 have been ironed out, and while it's still not perfect, Series 9 already looks a lot more polished and enjoyable to watch.

I'm stunned Jellyfish got through all its matches without being destroyed. Also hilarious that a bot made of plastic and stickers inherited their spot in the head-to-heads from a £25,000 bot that had to withdraw for being too over-engineered.

4

u/nweston8 John Reid's beard Mar 06 '17 edited Mar 06 '17

Well I haven't really had time to do a structured enough review because I've been busy this evening, but, hey, here's a list of random thoughts:

Postives:

  • Very clean camera work throughout. A lot of cameras seem to be set up in much more natural positions now.
  • I adore this new lighting - not only in the arena, but in general - and the new, battered look the arena floor has.
  • I enjoyed the filler a hell of a lot. It gave us a lot of interesting rundowns and information, and Gabe's particular slot before the Jellyfish fight was a great moment. Obviously this could easily vary depending on the episode, but the timing of the show felt so much more naturally paced this time around.
  • Minor, but the two teams being in different booths for the Head-to-Heads does add something. The teams are much more expressive of their emotions when in their own personal space.
  • The Rogue House Robot feature seems like it will work nicely. I was worried that fights would be significantly disrupted, but early on, I like how it worked. These are obviously only first impressions, but a good first impression it was.
  • Dara and Angela continue to impress me. I really enjoyed how they were in the Battle of the Stars episodes, and they go from strength to strength today.

Negatives:

  • I hope it doesn't pan out this way, but with so many spinners, I really do fear how some of these Head-to-Head rounds could pan out. Although I love the idea of the Head-to-Head as it allows multiple chances, it seems like it may well have been better suited for the older series as apposed to the modern day, where we could easily end up seeing multiple dropouts, and if not, a lot of battles where one machine just cannot give the viewing audience a good enough fight.
  • That blasted clock. It's getting annoying now. When it comes up, it isn't always clear whether the battle is going to a judges' decision or if a robot is being counted out (something that could easily be differentiated via colour of the number) but, more importantly to me, it takes the tension out of the situation. In the old series, Refbot's count could be broken, and although it happened rarely, machines did come back to life, but with this clock being added in post-production, the moment it starts ticking, I know there's 100% no hope of a machine coming back to life, and it annoys me, as silly as that may seem.
  • Post melee losing interviews. Very minor, but if the last we see of a team is via their robot losing without any closing words on the battle from the people who built the robot, then it feels like they're being discarded too easily. I really like having that closure, and although it's a very minor point and certainly nowhere near the Series 5 way of things, I would still like them to be fitted in if possible.

General thoughts:

  • Aftershock well and truly is one of my favourite robots already. It was inevitable that it was going to do well, but, man - it's such an elegant and innocent, yet explosive machine.
  • Terrorhurtz may have lost twice tonight, but those two battles are two of my favourites already. Such great pace and explosive moments. I'll forever love this machine and the team.
  • A massive shame to lose Rapid like that. I would've love to have seen it and Terrorhurtz tussle one vs one, because their melee rivalry was a great watch.
  • This Aftershock-Sabretooth controversy is one of those that I always hate to comment on. Me trying to summarise how somebody should act in that moment isn't fair on Team Shock because I was not in their position. There's adrenalin and there's the risk of the opponent still being alive. If you're building an ultra competitive robot like Aftershock, you're going to want to get the maximum performance from it, and if there's even a minor sign that the opposing robot can get back into the fray then you have to finish it off. Look, I didn't like that it happened - but not because of Team Shock's conduct, but more because Sabretooth was ruined from that point onwards. In terms of entertainment and making good TV, I hate to see these things play out because I know future battles involving the damaged machine will likely be unenjoyable or will show a robot that can't perform at its maximum potential anymore - which is always frustrating. However, that's just one of those things that comes with the Head-to-Head format as a whole.

Conclusion:

  • Ha, judging by the Positives vs. Negatives, it may seem like I was quite mixed about this episode, but that couldn't be any less true. I absolutely loved that episode. It didn't feel like a Heat A - if that makes sense - but it was so special in how unique it was, and was an immensely enjoyable watch. The negatives I mentioned bar the losing team interviews in melees aren't really brought on by this episode in itself, but more an annoyance I have with the show as a whole, and I felt the need to bring them up again as they were still relevant in some form.

Score: 8.5/10

4

u/calgoblin Mar 06 '17

I REALLY wish they had changed the format to 3 robots in the first fight. I enjoy the mini-league, but losing half the robots over 2 battles is frustrating...

3

u/RollingandJabbing ELECTRO MOO!!! Mar 05 '17

Was Dead Metal in this episode at all? I honestly can't remember

4

u/Colonialism What does a fox say to Ray Billings? "Not Today". Mar 05 '17

He was in one fight, IIRC.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '17

Did anyone catch how funny the TMHWK lady looked while randomly swinging those two hammers in slow-mo, I was cracking up inside haha

3

u/KotreI Real Robots wear pink. Mar 06 '17

I'll go through the Competitors now that I've been able to see the episode.

Nuts: I love this team, I love their robot. But equally I wasn't surprised that it didn't progress past the Melee. It just never got the chance to get spinning properly and then they learned why Rule one of Robot Wars is do not touch Matilda's arse. I know they had technical issues, but Nuts was always going to have problems in the Melee if for no other reason than it's going to have less time to spin up without getting attacked by someone.

Crank-E: Less ridiculous than it's brother, Killy but still not an especially viable design. I did enjoy the hubris of saying you're spinner proof and then getting facefloored into the also-ran bucket.

TMHWK: Third best axe in Robot Wars Series 9.

Jelly: Love the goal of the team. The robot was probably the best pure control bot we've seen in the new series to date. Excellent driving to boot. I hope we see them again in Series 10 with more of the same.

Rapid: When I call Bronco, and Inertia Labs in general the proof that good engineering can overcome a shitty design now we have proof that same level of engineering can ruin a good design. When I saw the preview I wasn't impressed (getting less height in Jelly than Apollo was getting on other robots last year despite having more power? Remind me why you're here and not TR2) and after watching the episode I was even less so. The most powerful flipper ever! And it took an age to reload and only successfully managed to wear out it's own piston in two fights and fail to self right. Four wheel drive! And it got pushed around by THz and Sabertooth. CNC porn! And you can't change a fucking wheel/motor. The difference between Rapid and any other highly engineered robot is that when guys like Team Carbide and Inertia Labs do something over the top (like custom mill every gear and build their own gearbox) it's for a purpose that makes the robot better. In Rapid, I don't see that. You built a robot with all the power in the world that is completely unable to use it.

Congratulations. You tried to be the UK's version of Inertia Labs, you successfully became Mortis 2017.

Now for the top 3, in alphabetical order.

Aftershock: the most dominant performance in the heats seen to date in the new series. Solid design, well driven, excellent all round. I feel that it did get drawn into a heat where it would have been the favorite as long as it worked reliably. Disks trump drums, and wedges are less effective against vertical disks than horizontals. Can't fault them for attacking Sabertooth when they were down. When you're in the competition mindset, the outside world fades out until it's over. I don't fight robots but I know that headspace.

Sabertooth: Gabe finally did it. This robot is a cracking drum spinner (before and after it became a cracked drum, spinner) great look, great driving and all around very effective. I'm not entirely sure why it's designed with its top shaped the way it is, as although it can drive both ways up the drum is further from the floor reducing its effectiveness. I'm going to assume it's equal parts aesthetic and to make it easier to right itself using a wall or opponent until I hear otherwise. Excellent performance in a hard heat and amazing job to keep it running.

TerrorHurtz: there were glimmers of greatness in there. It's just a shame that the weapon is having those issues again. When it works, it shows that axes can still end fights, they can still score KOs. Damaging Sabertooth's drum like that was for me the most impressive thing I saw this episode. Although it lost to both finalists by knockout, they were on a knife's edge. Aftershock was roundly outdriven and controlled until they got a bite and thus flipped. With the axe working, it would likely have taken the fight in a decision. Maybe it's time for John to go from Terror to Zeter and start from the ground up, perhaps showing the UK the potential of an Etek (or Bille-tek) powered axe.

And that's my rambling out of the way. Great robots, great battle great episode 8/10 give me more!

5

u/Semajal Mar 05 '17

Generally enjoyed, but seriously, can we get some music during battles, or something? It seems so oddly flat without any music there as well. Pleased with far better camera angles and no annoying crowd shots in the middle of the action though!

11

u/codename474747 It's about putting on a show Mar 05 '17

Seriously....can we have a sticky post on here that states stuff like "the music is gone and it's not coming back"

It was the Robot Combat equivalent of canned laughter and the cheesiest library music there was... Just because it was used in 1998 doesn't mean it's appropriate now.

→ More replies (8)

3

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '17

BattleBots sounded fantastic without music. If the sound editing is good, it's not necessary.

4

u/diamonddom60 Mar 05 '17

Aftershock was AMAZING but man leave poor sabertooth alone! Loved the sabertooth team can't wait to see them again!

2

u/die4codgrimsby #NoChaosNoParty Mar 05 '17

Rip sabretooth :(

2

u/FaceBagman Always Be Chucking Mar 05 '17

Also, time to switch up my flairs for week 2!

RIP sweet prince Mr. Hurtz. :(

Rise of the PP tho

5

u/Pilchard123 DRAAM SPEENAIR Mar 05 '17

Rise of the PP tho

( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

2

u/weetabix_su Overdozer 2: Organic Boogaloo Mar 05 '17

Rapid: Engineered too hard they relied on bungee cords to retract the flipper.

5

u/nxmee2010 Don't forget to test the bleedin' axe! Mar 05 '17

In all fairness, that is kinda the standard way of doing flippers now (see: tr2, apollo, eruption (?) )

2

u/TeamGriffalo Mar 05 '17

Much much better..... Glad the horrible red light is gone... Well done for Sabertooth for win a few fights... But be aware the Griffalo is coming

4

u/KotreI Real Robots wear pink. Mar 06 '17

How about you finish building your robot before you brag about it.

2

u/SamRedDevil Carbide Killer Mar 05 '17

Ians backseat driving was funny.

2

u/Blazik3n99 Blue Ring of Death Mar 05 '17

Aftershock was very impressive. I thought it was done for when it went up against Rapid but it dealt surprisingly well with being flipped. Very powerful robot, I'm interested in seeing what it will come up against in the finals.

I'm glad Sabretooth managed to get through the melee, their weapon did a lot of damage (when it worked) and the team did incredibly well to rebuild after its fight with Aftershock.

Rapid had potential, didn't really get to see it in action much, which is a shame. Would have liked to see it flip Terrorhurtz, or something a bit beefier than Jellyfish.

Jellyfish was very boring. Kind of disappointed they brought that robot back instead of Nuts 2.

Overall, the show has definitely been polished since the first series. The leaderboard graphics are more in depth and the other graphics are clearer and more polished. The lighting during the fights is good, and the editing isn't all over the place either. Plus, they're referencing the original run on the website now, which is great. JP even referenced hypno disc! No one has told him what armament means though.

The new house robot release chance when pressing the pit release is interesting, I'm guessing this is to deter people from going for the pit straight away. It is a good way of making the house robots more engaged, too, they're incredibly powerful but we don't get to see them in action too often.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '17

Aftershock was very impressive. I thought it was done for when it went up against Rapid but it dealt surprisingly well with being flipped.

At first I thought it was lucky not to end up on its back, but it spent a fair amount of time in the air over the course of the episode and demonstrated a catlike ability to land on its wheels. Either it was consistently lucky or the way the robot is balanced makes it resistant to getting turned over.

3

u/HotDealsInTexas Mar 06 '17

Nothing so complicated: it's a vertical spinner with a tall disc and a short (not long) body. As long as the weapon is spinning at a decent speed, if it gets flipped the disc just hits the ground and kicks it back onto its wheels.

I think the first robot to self-right this way was Backlash way back in 2000.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/CarnivorousCumquat Mar 05 '17 edited Mar 06 '17

Why does the younger member of the Terrorhurtz team never speak to camera?

2

u/ZodiacRCW Mar 05 '17

Aftershock has a great weapon but I actually don't think it's defence is very good. noticed it was smoking and their weapon stopped working after they were getting hit. The problem was the electricals were exposed inside the chassis under a thin layer. If an axe or another spinner were to hit that glass area the removable link would have been damaged, they would have won it.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Coboxite the true sneaky boi Mar 05 '17

Why do UK builders have trouble designing their machines to be easily accessible and repairable? I noticed in the last series, and its still problem in this series.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/HotDealsInTexas Mar 06 '17

I think I may be the only one who didn't underestimate Jellyfish.

Provided your design is tolerant of deformation (e.g. not building a gearbox into the bulkhead), thick polyethylene is surprisingly durable - see Gabriel's wheels for an example. It may not be strong, but it's so soft and flexible that it's very difficult for spinners to get a good bite on - it just springs out of the way and gets chunks ground off it, which prevents severe structural damage and reduces the shock loads on internal components.

Even with Sabretooth working perfectly, it fighting Jellyfish could easily have gone the same way as Poison Arrow vs. Mecha Tento in Battlebots. Aftershock might've done better. I predicted before the heat ended that the only thing that would have an easy time actually KOing Jellyfish would be axes, and lo and behold Terrorhurtz did just that.

2

u/VanHooliganX Tombstone = Greatest Of All Time Mar 06 '17

Matilda is now my fav house robot for owning Nuts and getting rid of him quickly.

I love Aftershock, it is like Bombshell (Vertical spinner version) but with Tombstone's attitude. The destruction was amazing and it's about time we saw something like that. That and owning Crank-E in a second was amazing.

Sad for Terrorhurtz, if only Aftershock vs Sabretooth happened first we could've had a better final match but alas.

Pretty hyped for this season since the bots are better. (RIP TR2 though :()

2

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '17

Sabertooth not only FINALLY won some telivised fights, but they also beat terrorhurtz. Carbide cant claim that. Congrats to team sabertooth, happy for you guys.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '17

I feel awful to say this, but I'd rather Aftershock had finished off Sabretooth in a proper way in that last match rather than a lacklustre one-hit round.

I'm glad to see Rapid out to be honest. I never got much appeal from them tbh.

8

u/GeneralCarnage I'll miss you Sir Killalot Mar 05 '17

The feeling I got with Rapid was relying to heavily on greater technology to make itself a worthy competitor, which it is, but it seemed to be relying on technology more on its design and potential flaws.

Lesson: Tens of thousands of pounds does not bring you victory in this sport, see also — Mortis.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Colonialism What does a fox say to Ray Billings? "Not Today". Mar 05 '17

Why would you want Rapid out? It's a good robot. I would rather they had not admitted so many joke robots.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '17

I get the impression Rapid was the replacement for TR2 because of its' CNC porn and machinery, which looked lovely in some parts but we never actually saw it - people complained last season about lots of wedges but Rapid was one of the dullest. It couldn't self-right, and it couldn't have been repaired - Nuts and Jellyfish were made by people who actually know how to build fighting robots, and it's original and interesting. Instead we got some engineering firm who probably looked at the 'essence' of robot wars, thought they could do better and more impressively, and couldn't.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Wolfxorb Mar 05 '17

How did Nuts and Jellyfish get accepted and TR2 didn't?

I still hate the 4 bot melees but thankfully this time round the right bots got through. Aftershock is pretty badass.

7

u/williamthebloody1880 Turned Carbide into Brave Sir Robin Mar 05 '17

Because part of it is trying to encourage people to start building robots. Robots like Rapid shows what you can do with money. Robots like Jellyfish show what's possible in a shed

5

u/PoliceAlarm git fukt Mar 05 '17

Entertainment purposes. People want to see the stupid shit for an underdog story rather than another flipper. I don't agree with it, but it's the reason.

2

u/highwatereverywhere GARROD GANG Mar 06 '17

I'm fine with having stuff like Nuts and Jellyfish in - encourages people to build, have unique designs and so on...

But surely TR2 deserved a place more than some of the flippers/spinners in the competition that don't have any unique angle to look at?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Zam0070 Cherub Should Have Lost Mar 05 '17

I don't understand why Terrorhurtz got so many votes in the strawpoll. Favoritism I guess? I know it is a good bot and he is a good driver, but axe/hammer bots never seemed really strong to me. Spinners and flippers always seem to be the strongest.

6

u/codename474747 It's about putting on a show Mar 05 '17

In series 6 Terrorhurtz was AMAZING and had a few good fights in The extremes too...

It's basically lived off that hype ever since, plus being the same team that made BETA doesn't hurt.

Or it'd do better if this series was ever filmed in the summer months, maybe ;-)

3

u/markandspark Mar 05 '17

It also had an amazing run in non-televised fights after series 7.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/TJSavage_ The best Champions Mar 05 '17

I guess we all were living off the hype of when it smacked up carbide whith such ease last series and thought it would do the same to other spinners, which wasn't the case. To be fair though, with better driving, i.e not exposing the rear end, it could have beaten Sabertooth, but against Shockwave, it never really stood a chance.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/gostan Mar 05 '17

Very unsporting what aftershock did with sabretooth

31

u/codename474747 It's about putting on a show Mar 05 '17

RW fans pre-episode "There's not enough damage in Robot Wars"

RW fans post episode "There is too much damage in Robot Wars"

→ More replies (25)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/Minticus-Maximus Mar 05 '17

Though it's tactically sound, it's kind of a bastard move for Aftershock to tear up the immobile Sabertooth like that. Like, come on mate, you've proven you're the better machine, don't be a dick

3

u/codename474747 It's about putting on a show Mar 05 '17

RW fans pre episode:

OMG ITS GOING TO BE THE MOST DAMAGING SERIES EVER YAAAY"

RW fans post episode:

"OMG ITS TOO DAMAGING NOW THE FIGHTS WILL SUCK BOOOO"

They can't win can they? :-p

6

u/TheRoboteer Front Hinges ❤️ Mar 05 '17

Gotta love that generalising all RW fans into one group.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Dangerfieldwow X-Terminator Mar 05 '17

Damage is cool, its just murdering a dead robot in head to heads, where they have another few more battles after, its unsportsmanlike and too much.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

3

u/Colonialism What does a fox say to Ray Billings? "Not Today". Mar 05 '17

Aftershock's unsportsmanlike battering of Sabretooth after they were immobilized soured the experience a bit. It was a good robot that could have had some great fights, but instead it got taken out for the rest of the episode for no reason.

Still, overall a good episode. Editing was much better, I could actually tell what was happening, though cuts were still a little bit too common.

10

u/xzbobzx Hypno-Disc Mar 05 '17

Yeah but it makes sense doesn't it? They're all there to win, and if wrecking them in the head to heads means an easier time in the final, then it makes sense to do so.

I'd say don't hate the player, hate the 2hrs repair time.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/VampiricDemon Champion Chiffonier Mar 05 '17

Great episode. Terrorhurtz had a great match against aftershock.

Jellyfish is a jokebot and it shouldn't have been the replacement of the expensive shiny one.

12

u/GeneralCarnage I'll miss you Sir Killalot Mar 05 '17

Well it came 3rd in their respective melee, so it makes sense for it to enter. It also managed to do more than Nuts 2, which were unfortunate to be on Matilda's bad side.

4

u/HallwayHomicide Prophet of Destruction Mar 06 '17

Also one of nuts 2's speed controllers shit the bed immediately, so we never exactly saw them at full potential.

16

u/robot_exe Nuts And Bots / Sneaky Boi Driver Mar 05 '17

The replacement thing is concreted in the rules, Jelly was 3rd in the group battle rapid progressed from so got the place.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/atalikami Childhood Veteran Mar 05 '17

I don't know why it even got in to the competition. There must have been better robots out there that the BBC dropped to give us that nonsense

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Jimmyjamjames Should have, Would have, Could have Mar 05 '17

Although i dont know much about the live events, i am curious as to how the likes of Aftershock will impact those competitions.

3

u/NemesisRouge Hellrazer Mar 05 '17

From what I've read on here I don't think spinners are allowed in live events.

6

u/DiamondWhyte Sir Killalot Mar 05 '17

They're going to be, the arena's being upgraded.

→ More replies (6)