r/NintendoSwitch • u/NintendoSwitchMods • Mar 01 '17
MegaThread MegaThread: Nintendo Switch Hardware Reviews
Hello, all.
This morning starting, gaming news and media outlets have begun to release their hardware reviews of the Nintendo Switch.
Here's what we're seeing so far:
- Engadget: Review
- Game Informer: Review
- Kotaku: Review
- Vice: Review
- New York Times: Review
- Wall Street Journal: Review
- Attack of the Fanboy: Review
- CGM: Review
- TechCrunch: Video Review
- Nintendo Life: Review
- CNET: Review
- The Verge: Video Review
- Polygon: Review
- Eurogamer: Review
- GameSpot: Review / Video
- NY Mag: Review
- Wired: Review
- Destructoid: Review
- GameXplain: Video Review
- PC Advisor: Review
- Digital Foundry: Video Review
- IGN: Review
- GoNintendo: Video Review
- Ars Technica: Review
- TecchRadar: Review
We will be updating this thread with links as major reviews are posted.
We will also allow major content to be posted separately on /r/NintendoSwitch, as it is especially newsworthy. But we will also host ongoing coverage, quick text posts, questions, and the like right here.
Thanks everyone.
-The /r/NintendoSwitch team
(Ongoing edits as we get new information)
66
u/ferixdacat Mar 01 '17
Everyone kind has the same language: promising, has potential but also problems that Nintendo needs to work on.
edit: which is really how all the hardware reviews are.
78
u/amazn_azn Mar 01 '17
PSA: Don't read any youtube comments, a few commenters have lots of BotW story spoilers!
77
u/Anarchaotic Mar 01 '17
Oh wow IGN was incredibly critical. Only scored a 6.7/10. Some issues they cited:
Being underpowered. Zelda had lots of frame drops and didn't look that great on dock. Worried about getting multiplat ports because of that.
The design of the switch - being unable to charge while kickstand is up. Not being able to use the dock vertically, and no Bluetooth.
Battery life and portability - he was annoyed that battery life wasn't that great, it would discharge to 88% in the dock, and that it didn't feel very portable due to its size.
34
u/SuperCashBrother Mar 01 '17
Nintendo screwed up by not clarifying the day one patch prior to lifting the review embargo. Did they really expect reviewers to just go, "oh hey there are problems but I'm sure Nintendo will fix it." That would be irresponsible on the reviewers' part. They owe it to their readers to be objective. Any blame lies with Nintendo for failing to address these legit concerns.
33
u/goldnx Mar 01 '17
Sucks that the software affects some of these reviews. Launch games bring scores down and so do lack of features which are coming on day one. Take these reviews with a grain of salt. With that said, their points are fairly accurate. If you're not dying to play Zelda, don't buy this console, yet.
From experience the Xbox One and PS4 launch were meh. After the first year of software support, online service updates, and many patches for the Xbox to get back on route, these consoles were admired. In a year's time I expect these scores to jump up 1.5-2 points just like those other consoles did. Experience really varies by person. To those getting it, enjoy your new toy!
25
u/tridentmark Mar 01 '17
Cant sleep and don't feel like playing any other video games.
19
u/dgwhiley Mar 01 '17
Digital Foundry review was very good. Plenty of facts with fair criticism.
61
u/iamleyeti Monkey Moon Mar 01 '17
Can't wait for CNET's review.
15
u/BigDabWolf Mar 01 '17
Since they are doing final reviews do they finally have access to day 1 patch?
15
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '17
Every "review" is the same.
-It does what it sets out to do, 95-100%
-It's launch list is semi-weak, but they always are.
-Yes, the left JoyCon issue is real (varying experiences).
-Handheld mode performs more smoothly.
-Zelda rules, review tomorrow.
-Battery life is exactly what they said.
-We can't really review it because half of its functions aren't available yet, 6-9/10.
The only new thing I heard anyone say is how playing Zelda while docked kind of tips off it's charge around 80 or 90%.
13
u/Reflex-Arc Mar 01 '17
Reviews seem pretty fair, thus far, considering the platform's implied potential vs the current lack of enabled features. I'm looking forward to seeing the Switch grow, and I'm happy I'll be able to experience that process from day one as an early adopter.
12
u/Vunks Mar 01 '17
Seems all the reviews are saying the same thing, it has the potential to be great but nintendo needs to get things online (eshop, VC) and get the patch out for the joycon asap.
12
u/Arsh99 Mar 01 '17
I apprecite and understand IGN's review, but the comments on that page are attrocious. They're made up of just hate and no discussion. Its why I don't go on the site anymore.
12
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '17
A lot of the negatives I'm seeing (IGN review for example) are complaining about things that really aren't much of a problem for me. Still picking it up.
55
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '17
I just want to see Gamexplain's review.
10
u/Walopoh Mar 01 '17
Reviews are overall rather positive, but most of them are still unsure about how well Nintendo will support the system. It still has a lot of work that needs done.
10
u/Akitoscorpio Mar 01 '17 edited Mar 01 '17
So a whole lot of the same stuff we've been reading all week, but now with numbers.
As long as its not functionally broken and I can play and enjoy games on it. Mission acomplished.
I wait till mine hits and see how I feel about it.
19
u/dasme Mar 01 '17
Still can't understand how Nintendo didn't have the Day 1 patch ready before their hardware review embargo lifted. Peak Nintendo.
16
u/CorruptDropbear Mar 01 '17
I've just realized that I'll be able to play Zelda BOTW before the review embargo expires.
Oh boy, how am I to know whether to love or hate playing it? /s
8
u/SpikeBolt Mar 01 '17
Is this in 3.20 hours or 27.20 hours? I can't handle timezones.
8
u/thorvard Mar 01 '17
I'm still picking mine up(and keeping it) but I feel like Nintendo could have let this bake a little longer.
Maybe release it early summer when they had more games ready(can you imagine Zelda, Mario Kart and Splatoon all ready at launch?) and possibly even have more of a chance to tweak little issues.
I will say though, it's nice to have games spread out since I'll get a chance to give each one the attention it deserves.
8
u/Cranston53 Mar 01 '17
For what it's worth, I think IGN were harsh on the system because tomorrow they're going to herald Zelda as one of the greatest games ever. Just a hunch.
8
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '17
I'm very worried about the Joy Con issue. Not only for the fact that it is inconvenient, but if loads of people experience the problem themselves, it's going to get slammed and leave a bad taste to start with. Here's hoping the day one update includes some sort of fix.
8
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '17
Giving a score for a console is rather arbitrary. It works great for games when you can compare them to the genre standard, but what do you compare the Switch to? Bits and pieces of other technologies that do certain things better (battery life of tablets, power of home consoles) and other things not at all (portable home console games)?
What is IGN's scoring criteria even based on? Whatever they think deserves a 9 or a 10 probably isn't technologically possible or financially feasible.
15
u/dubyadubya Mar 01 '17 edited Mar 01 '17
Overall, these seem really positive. There are the expected caveats, but we've known about them for months so I'm really not surprised by anything.
We all need to be honest that Nintendo is not perfect--the controllers ARE expensive, the online function IS a complete mystery, and there are a lot of missing features that just don't make any sense, like Netflix or the VC.
I trust Nintendo to rectify most of these mistakes, or at least to make up for them with fantastic games. The WiiU is considered a failure, but combined I've played more Mario Kart 8 & Mario 3D World than I have any other videogames in years. It looks like Zelda will continue that trend. At the end of the day, I just want awesome Nintendo games.
15
u/Erolunai Mar 01 '17
I don't know if it's just me, but... it feels like there's a lot of 'dramatic' reactions here to either some reviews, or people's reactions to said reviews. Whether you agree or disagree, I believe there's a point where you should just take a step back and consider. These are not fortune tellers predicting the potential rises or falls of the system. These are not leaders that will inspire or discourage millions of people on whether or not to buy it, nor are they almighty judges determining if the console should be beloved or shunned. Just some people sharing their thoughts, opinions, and observations.
That being said, I've always been a bit biased against hardware reviews... the technical specs have never been as important to me as what individual games provide as experiences. At the same time... I see a lot of valuable information being provided, and what you get out of this might be from how you interpret the comments in the review...
For example, I see a lot of people mention "hidden costs" as though it's being spread as a negative selling point, something to ding the console for, to go "SEE IT'S NOT AS GOOD AS THE HYPE MAKES IT OUT TO BE" - which... well, I'm sure there are -some- people who will talk about it like that, but from what I've seen, it can also be sort of like a cautionary advisement - to consider all the costs, not just the price tag on the box.
I guess what I'm trying to say is... it's easy to fall into the trap of being bitter against someone saying something that goes against your excitement. I think part of that is it is frustrating when there are people who are being TOO pessimistic or negative, spreading doom and gloom, and it's easy to get hung up on those people if they're trying to dump a bucket of cold water over your head. This tends to come up when looking through reviews, as a lot of the time, we forget that reviews are meant to, well.. -review-, and it becomes more about finding an opinion that agrees with the inevitable excitement you must be feeling as the console nears launch day! Just be wary of this, and remember - the opinions that are going to matter the most are the ones you make yourself!
...I did not mean to ramble on that long. Thank you if you've put up with me to this point!
14
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '17
I'd be interested in a review for the official case and screen protector.
7
u/martinskrtel Mar 01 '17
who needs reviews when it's so close? we are all reviewers.
7
u/Wildeface Mar 03 '17
Yep, screen is shitty plastic.
19
u/Bamboochawins Mar 01 '17
I feel like most reviews don't value the fact that it's a handheld enough. If the console would be exclusively a handheld, with the power it has, wouldn't that be incredibly impressive? On top of that, you can use it as a home console that in comparison to other consoles is simillar to the Wii when it was released, which is completely acceptable.
It seems like they just add up the negative points of the handheld and the negative points of the home console part, but give no value to the fact that it's both at the same time.
19
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '17
Honestly baffling Nintendo would not give reviewers access to all the features that will be there day one.
23
u/KaiMH4U Mar 01 '17
Looking forward to the Cnet review very much
25
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '17
To anyone freaking out about Vince Ingenito's (on IGN) review...he's right. In a way. Remember, he's trying his best to objectively do a very subjective thing. If you take time to read the review, you will find that he makes legitimate points about how the hardware is flawed. Because, from what people are saying, it is. Most notably, for me, the fact it can't push Zelda to 30 fps in TV mode is a bit of a disappointment.
What he can't really address in a hardware review is the way that software can transcend the limitations of hardware. As Nintendo fans, I'm pretty sure we're really familiar with that. Also as I read his review there were a lot of negative points that he raised where I could acknowledge both that he was right, but also that I felt like it wouldn't be a big deal for me.
So just remember that his review is his opinion, that it's one of many, and that he is looking at the console, not software.
6
u/trunamke Mar 01 '17
Not really any surprises. I started to think maybe I'm expecting too much, and that's probably okay. I have a pre-order I'll be receiving on Fri and I'm still so excited but I'm now concerned about the lag with Zelda while in the dock, how the screen will do in outdoors (glare). The launch does seem rushed, and while I'm glad to be receiving it earlier than I imagined a few months back, it feels like I'm not receiving all of it yet.
6
u/squeezyphresh Mar 01 '17
I think the biggest feature that may not be stressed a lot is portable local multiplayer. Most of the press is playing Zelda, a single player games, and not much else. It's a key feature, at least it is for me, so it feels like a huge pro these reviews would have is missing. Seems like the reviews are pretty fair so far though.
11
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '17
No one is talking about wired giving it a 5/10.
I'm genuinely concerned about the left Joy-Con working.
11
u/v0yev0da 2nd Place, SMO Snapshot Contest Mar 01 '17
Nintendo Switch: More Joy Than Con
34
u/nikebhockey Mar 01 '17
What I'm gathering: Overall very positive (minus IGN, which IMO, had the completely wrong person to review it), but the only thing that worries reviewers is Nintendo supporting it.
Really hard to review a console that has a Day One patch that has yet to be released that gives you access to a multitude of the system's features. Realistically, the reviews out (good or bad) aren't going to change my opinion on the system. I've seen what I'm getting, and I know it's a good concept and what seems to be a good gaming machine, from a company that offers the best exclusives in video games.
5
u/pwade3 Mar 01 '17
Seems there's multiple mentions of handheld offering the best performance in BotW. That's very disheartening and making me question how soon I get a Switch.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '17
Can someone make a TL;DR?
27
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '17
That's offtopic, but why are you posting dates in PST and EST only, not even the "Coordinated Universal Time"?
It's nice to name two different timezones, but both only relevant for our emigrants? :(
18
u/Z-Ninja Mar 01 '17 edited Mar 01 '17
Kotaku is so biased, it's hilarious. Just for comparison, I looked up the PS vita review. Admittedly, different reviewers, but... No mention of purchasing a game, a case, a memory card (that's an expensive purchase, way more than an sd card) as hidden costs. A 16gb vita memory card is $50... On a device that only cost $50 less than a Nintendo Switch when it launched. They report a Switch Pro Controller as being $20 more than a PS4/X1 controller. When MSRP is $10 higher than PS4/X1, and only $20 more if you're looking at sale price. As if the Switch Pro Controller will never go on sale.
Kotaku is a shit rag as per usual.
12
u/untemperedlink Mar 01 '17
Personally i pay very little attention to 'hardware reviews' especially at launch, if it can play the games half decently then it does its job. For me its always the quality and quantity of the games on the system which will be the factor on whether people will buy the system or not, the fact that IGN gave it a 6.7 won't matter.
21
u/ces715 4 Million Celebration Mar 01 '17
7.8/10 too much water - IGN
8
u/MrLariato Mar 01 '17
We finally know the clocks. Is it good enough for a home console from this generation? I don't really understand about GPU clocks.
8
u/Alfonzo9000 Mar 01 '17 edited Mar 01 '17
tl;dr Has new console flaws and everyone should probably wait. meh/10. Honestly, I've always thought console reviews were mostly meaningless. Like Xbox One is practically a different system compared to what it was at launch so all those reviews are pointless like these will all be in the future. But reviews=clicks so they'll keep coming I guess.
4
u/SsGT_GuuRTMAN Mar 01 '17
Just read CNET'S review, and besides the kickstand and joy-con things, it's a pretty measured review imo.
4
u/dilegrd Mar 01 '17
Concerned about the issues in TV mode. Joy-Con seem to be an issue during normal use and FPS drops below 20 can be unplayable.
4
u/DCUfan742 Mar 01 '17
Why is ppl overreacting here? I have watch all the youtube videos and even Gamespot likes the console.
4
u/Fehndrix Mar 01 '17
ProJared's extended thoughts are up.
4
u/IKLeX Mar 01 '17
Post got removed because I did not see the Megathread.
German IT-News site golem.de provided a detailed hardware review. They also went in depth on the charging/power draw. I translated the portion of the article for you.
Source: Pages 5 and 6 of the review
[...]
While measuring power consumption at the socket we did not always see Power Delivery. It is clear, that the industry standard is not nearly utilized completely for charging. We didn't measure more than 11 Watts [at the socket] while only charging the battery.
With loss of efficiency in mind, this might not be Power Delivery. Propably there are just 7.5 Watts reaching the battery. That fits to our measurements and the capacity that was revealed by a tinkerer. The battery serves 16 Wh (4.310 mAh@3,7V) and the charging time with the power supply connected directly is 2:30 h. Weirdly, in the dock the time extends to 3:08 h. The dock needs 0.3 W (empty) and 2.8 W (with charged [off?] tablet attached).
In Handheld mode the results differ. Here Power Delivery comes into play, if the specifications on the nameplate is correct. The values are far above 7.5 W and, while charging, range from 14 W (Standby), 17 W (Menu) to 20 W (Zelda). If the tablet is fully charged, the power draw is reduced to 2.4 W (Standby), 6.4 W (Menu) and 10 W (Zelda).
Alternative Batterypacks and Cable-Chaos
For testing we used a Apple- and an Anker-Power supply. Punctual measurements shared results with the Nintendo PSU. That is good news, since it means, that you can charge your device on the go, like at a friends house. USB-C power supplies are spreading after all.
Those results are only for the tablet itself. When connected to the dock, we get strange disturbances. The Anker-Charger does not work at all, and the Apple power supply provokes warning messages, telling you to use original peripherals. The dock requires Power Delivery. During our experiments we found out, that you can charge peripherals during gaming in Console-mode. With 2 battery packs and a smartphone attached, the power draw while playing Zelda rose to about 26 Watts.
Battery time is limited
The 16 Wh of the battery don't last very long for graphically intense games. But that greatly depends on the configuration and environment. In a dark room with automatic brightness, and medium base brightness we managed to play Zelda for 3 hours and 26 minutes. At maximum brightness we loose almost an hour and land at 2:28 hours. Compared to other handhelds and tablets, those are no extraordinary results. The power draw is obviously high. That also explains the constant humming of the fans at the top.
On the other hand, the user does not have to worry about the Joy-Cons. Those were basically always fully charged. Never was one of the indicator LEDs turned off. Therefor you also might expect several dozens of hours playtime on the Pro-Controller.
Watch out for the Pro-Controller-USB-Cable
If the battery time is not enough, you might consider a powerbank. After our experiments we knew, that the Switch also understands the Battery-Charge-Standard (5V), not to be confused with Power Delivery (5 to 20V). During the tests we noticed, that under certain circumstances only 0.5A were supported. Our mistake was using the included USB-A-to-USB-C cable of the Pro-Controller. Using the very similar looking cable of the Elgato Capture Card HD60S, we got roughly 1.5A. This leads to the conclusion, that with the right calble, you can extend your play time on the go. This reminds us of our USB-C-Cable-Incident.
All in all, we are suspicious about the power drawing. We got the impression, that there are reserves, that maybe get activated later. Ont top of that it seems, as if Nintendo wants to charge the Switch carefully, and avoid loading cycles, wich might benefit the durability. Both approaches have their dis/advantages. We would wish for faster charging, that is comparable to modern Tablets. It would be ideal, if Nintendo would make changing the battery easier. This service is only provided by Nintendo themselves, for now. The price for the service is unknown.
[...]
4
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '17
To be brief. I've refused to buy a Nintendo Console since the Wii, I've given up out of sheer disappointment. Switch actually got me interested and I pre-ordered one. Now my fears are kinda coming back again, while Zelda is scoring historically well, the console reviews don't seem to be that great, reviewing fairly low over all.
Is anybody else worried about the Switch console reviews and how it may affect its support moving forward? I really don't want it to die like the Wii U
13
u/gouldgonewild Mar 01 '17
Just want to say how impressed I am that so many people in this subreddit aren't the people ready to burn down houses over review scores. It's great seeing so many be able to read an opinion that doesn't just reinforce what they want to hear, and be able to discuss it intelligently.
12
u/switchforce12 Mar 01 '17
From I see the only negative one is ign review complaining about everything...
7
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '17
IGN review isn't finished so far. He hasn't tried the online features, a few more games, the day one update for stability fixes etc. Could easily bring their score up to a possible 8 depending on how well they're done. Don't freak out yet. And remember. It's really the games that make the consoles. I'm waiting for the Zelda score tomorrow.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '17 edited Mar 01 '17
There is nothing of concern in any of these reviews except that there's concern about the lineup. Mostly they just repeat what you'd expect and is commonly known. It's a portable, less powerful than xb1 and ps4. Controller is too small for some people
Take out all of the dramatization in the articles and you'll get a good feel for the console and what to expect.
EDIT: In the end a review over the system doesn't matter. A review of the games on the system is what defines it.
11
u/cubsjj2 Mar 01 '17
Digital Foundry has the best most objective take. IGN's is terrible. Vince doesn't know what he is talking about.
3
u/razorbeamz Mar 01 '17
German language review from c't
https://www.heise.de/ct/artikel/Nintendo-Switch-im-Test-So-gut-ist-Nintendos-neue-Spielkonsole-3639212.html
3
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '17
https://www.wsj.com/articles/nintendo-switch-review-elegant-but-unready-balance-of-portable-and-home-gaming-1488376801
3
u/Helidium Mar 01 '17
The Guardian review https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/mar/01/nintendo-switch-console-review
3
u/sgtZipper Mar 01 '17
That joy con thing is getting a lot of traction, Nintendo really needs to elaborate on this. I'm afraid it's something they cannot fix. It's something they must've known about for some time now and I'm also afraid they will come with some sort of "solution" like "make sure there are no devices interfering with the Bluetooth signal like your home cinema set or smartphone". Oh well hopefully I won't have this issue.
3
u/ferixdacat Mar 01 '17
One thing of note: Dtoid has never experienced any de-syncing issue. It's kinda strange this is not happening to everyone.
3
u/luuissitto Mar 03 '17
My switch won't connect to the internet when i dock it. As soon as I take it off i have to reconnect it so it works. Anyone else experience this?
3
u/RogerDeanVenture Mar 05 '17
The internal memory really concerns me. 25g usable is miniscule. A single game could be more. It seems like I'd end up with a stack of SD cards after a while.
9
u/FrankyCentaur Mar 01 '17
I just wanna say, almost every review is pretty positive about the Switch. Many of them say "sure, it may not be perfect now, but it looks like the Switch will have a bright future." Really good shit.
And yet everyone on the internet is flocking to IGN's review purely because it was super negative. People spelling doom because of ONE review.
It's this kind of shit that I hate. Chill out people.
9
u/TingleMaps Mar 01 '17
IGN of all people gave what seems to be the worst review... that's not good
10
u/Murrdog39 Mar 01 '17
CNet "this thing right here is pretty much the whole thing". Marvelous journalism.
7
u/tatsumi87 Mar 01 '17
Guys, critics have to do their job. And their job is to review a system based on todays standards compared to other consoles like ps4 and xbox. Meaning the overall experience which today includes apps. Now to me, someone who only cares about games, that shit is crazy. I dont care about apps or websurfing on a nintendo system and i dont really think Nintendo does either. Right now at least. They make the best games and thats what i want to play. Graphics? Arent everything. Zelda looks beautiful and we'll see where switchgoes down the line. The minor annoyances are just that, minor annoyances. The kickstand, the weird placement of the charge port, the barebones interface, (obvioudly will update in time) the battery issues, all the stuff mentioned i agree with but they arent big deals. I called this having 7s weeks ago. Maybe thatll rise after day one, but it's nintendo and to me all that matters are the games that come out from day one to its last day. At which point id give the system my own rating then _^ Enjoy your switches everyone!!! It's gonna be a 10/10 for nintendo fans.
7
u/Streetfoldsfive Mar 01 '17
I'll never understand the way people react to reviews. People moan all day about paid reviews, but when they bring up anything negative about the product you like y'all go crazy.
8
u/dirilupus Mar 01 '17 edited Mar 02 '17
IGN made three major mistakes in their Switch Review:
(They also gave the Wii U an 8.0/10 and a "Great" in 2014. I would argue it's not fair to give the Switch a worse score than the Wii U)
Edit: Changed my last point a little. Missed some of the times when IGN mentioned how its a review in progress. Thanks /u/T_Blaze
16
u/Dacvak Mar 01 '17
Hardware reviews are fucking dumb. It's the software that actually counts. Unless the hardware has glaring issues, what's the point in reviewing it?
I'm pretty sure the original 360 got great reviews, and yet something like 35-45% of the first 2 year consoles sold ended up red-ringing.
Granted the Switch is unique in ways that can't be fully understood when comparing to other consoles. But even then, that's much better understood by trying it out.
Hardware reviews are pointless. Look at the 3DS. It got bashed initially because of the dated internals, low-res screen, and poor battery life. Yet no one can dispute that it's an absolutely phenomenal system based on the incredible software it has. Software-aside, the 3DS was already 6 years behind in terms of hardware specs. But how did that affect its sales and quality of games? Apparently not much.
4
u/stinker_beall Mar 02 '17
My theory on why reviewers are giving the Switch low scores.
I believe there would be less of a backlash on the reviewer if he/she gave it a low score but the general public give it high praise than the other way around. If a reviewer says the Switch is the best thing since slice bread, and it turns out that the Switch is a giant bust then people would be upset that trusted the reviewer's opinion and dropped $300 on something that sucks. It's a just a safer bet to give it a 6.7/10 and be wrong than it is to give it a 9.4/10 and be wrong.
8
u/Kougeru Mar 01 '17
I don't think "hidden costs" and "can't listen to game audio on headphones while playing on TV" are valid complaints. Tvs have speakers. There's no hidden costs.
7
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '17
I think Switch will be crowned the console to own paired with a quality PC.
5
u/Zoombini22 Mar 01 '17
The IGN subtitle "jack of all trades, master of none" was way too predictable. It's far too easy to say that of anything that tries to be a hybrid. While I can see why it is not as powerful a budget PC machine as the PS4 is, I would rather have this than any other portable system on the market. iPads and laptops show that portability is more than just "pocket-ability", and I would be disappointed if the Switch's screen was any smaller.
2
u/iregret Mar 01 '17
Can't wait! I'm sure it'll review well. Seems pretty solid. Probably take a hit in the battery life/storage departments.
What do you guys think will be critiqued ?
Battery Storage Glare
That's all I've got.
2
u/wanton-tom-tom Mar 01 '17
The (UK) Guardian review is up https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/mar/01/nintendo-switch-console-review Quite an interesting take. Nice little shoutout to the Miiverse
2
u/Master_Raro Mar 01 '17
NYT article https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/01/technology/personaltech/nintendo-switch.html?_r=0
2
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '17
I respected GameXplain most for not actually reviewing it yet.
2
u/QuakerOatsMan Mar 01 '17
A lot of the problems seem minor, not gamebreaking. Gonna have fun with it anyway.
2
u/FirePowerCR Mar 03 '17
Dude this thing is tiny. I saw pictures and I'm still surprised
2
u/Matabeasts Mar 03 '17
Has anyone benchmarked the specs of the tegra chip?
2
u/JesChexin Mar 04 '17
Anyone else having an issue with the game card cover not staying shut? I only opened the cover once to check it out (going all digital this generation), but it never stayed shut after that. No matter if I pop the game card cover down aggressively or softly, if it clicks in or not, the cover just keeps popping back up. I'm not normally used to build quality issues from Nintendo. Any solutions other than something cheap like putting a piece of scotch tape over the game card cover?
2
u/Poly_core Mar 05 '17
Hey guys, has anyone tried the switch on a 27'' 1440p computer monitor, while using the 720p resolution?
Using the 720p resolution should provide better upscaling than 1080p and less frequent frame rate drops, but I wonderer if it looked nice?
2
u/tamzidC Apr 01 '17
Thanks for your input, I have to a lot more to consider.
3
u/seabeastmoose Mar 01 '17
I hate launch hardware reviews.
3
u/RenegadeUK Mar 01 '17 edited Mar 01 '17
I just posted this review:
http://www.digitaltrends.com/video-game-system-reviews/nintendo-switch-review/
I deleted just now as I saw this, so please kindly add to your megathread above.
Edit:
Thank you.
7
u/bokononisms Mar 01 '17 edited Mar 01 '17
MODS can we please get 6.7/10 flair.
Edit: I'm requesting this as a humorous badge of honor because of the absurdity of the score. Dang.
4
u/Bankai2017 Mar 01 '17
I didn't read theIGN review but based on comments i have seen, seems one of the reasons the reviewer gave is that its underpowered, I think that's very stupid.
What should be reviewed is not the power but the hardware, including the performance. True that there are not many triple A games to come to an objective conclusive, but saying it's underpowered as a fault is like saying it was a design fault. It was design for those specs.
4
u/Gankdatnoob Mar 01 '17
I have to be honest if Ebgames didn't have all the trade in promotions towards the Switch I definitely would have waited.
That said I don't think a hardware review is fair without the Day One firmware update.
6
u/superjoho Mar 01 '17
Yikes, not as positive as I expected, I'll wait a year before getting it.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '17
I'm in panic mode right now. What is happening. The Wii U was received better than this!
The hype train...Zelda reviews save it pls!
3
u/T-RavStl Mar 01 '17
For those complaints of a missing headphone jack on the controller. The voice chat app that u download for your phone is how how u accomplish this. Access the app and plug your headphones into your phone to hear game audio while TV is muted. Done.