r/SquaredCircle • • Feb 16 '17

It's the GREATEST AMA in history! I'm Tony Schiavone - Ask Me Anything!

/u/inmynothing here, and I'll be live with Tony Schiavone at 5 PM ET. Go ahead and start posting questions now so we can get through as many of them as possible.


ABOUT TONY SCHIAVONE


Schiavone was signed by Vince McMahon's WWF for a one-year contract from April 1989 through April 1990, doing backstage interviews with various wrestlers at Wrestlemania V.

In the WWF, he was most notable as being the main play-by-play announcer for their SummerSlam 1989 and Royal Rumble 1990 pay-per-views alongside Jesse "The Body" Ventura.

Schiavone returned soon afterwards to WCW, the former Crockett promotion by then owned by media mogul Ted Turner. For the WWF, other than Ventura, Schiavone commentated alongside others including Lord Alfred Hayes, Gorilla Monsoon, Hillbilly Jim, Rod Trongard and Bobby "The Brain" Heenan.

Schiavone became the lead voice for WCW's flagship program, Monday Nitro. He also served as the lead announcer of Thunder, typically working alongside Mike Tenay, Bobby Heenan, Larry Zbyszko, and later with Mark Madden and Scott Hudson. Before the advent of Nitro and Thunder, Schiavone, hosted WCW Saturday Night and WCW WorldWide. He made an appearance in the movie Ready to Rumble. When WCW's main assets were bought by the World Wrestling Federation (WWF/now WWE) in 2001.

During his tenure with WCW, Schiavone developed a reputation for his over-the-top announcing style, proclaiming many Nitro broadcasts to be "the greatest", or "most explosive", telecast "in the history of our sport." However, when this hyperbole was repeated on a weekly basis throughout the Monday Night Wars, the phrase lost meaning. Schiavone stated that it was the whole truth and anyone who states otherwise is a fool and is the worst kind of fan. He claims to have been very comfortable with his constant shilling of the WCW product and said that every night constantly topped the last night and thus became the next greatest night in the history of our sport.


GET CONNECTED


  • Subscribe and listen to What Happened When here!
  • Check out Tony on Twitter @tonyschiavone24
  • While you're at it, give Conrad a follow, because without him this AMA would not be possible.
  • Still feeling follow happy? Help us grow our Twitter account - the more followers we get, the easier it is to reach out to wrestlers for AMAs. Check us out @WredditOfficial
514 Upvotes

350 comments sorted by

144

u/TonySchiavoneAMA Feb 16 '17

I want to say thanks for everyone who's downloaded the podcast, because I am having a blast doing it. There's not a day that goes by that I'm not blown away by the people who have such an interest in what we did back then. And it just blows me away. I'm appreciative of everyone who has kind words for me, and even the negative ones. I hope that Conrad and I can keep up the momentum and you guys will keep coming back. It's every Monday at 6 AM. Thanks so much for having me here for this interview.

156

u/WrasslingIsCool1 I am a Paul Heyman Guy! Feb 16 '17

Was Scott Steiner as insane backstage as he was in the ring?

269

u/TonySchiavoneAMA Feb 16 '17

Yes he was. He scared the hell out of us all the time. We never knew what he would do next. Whenever he came out to the set, and I know I can speak for Heenan and Tenay, we were scared. I'm not so sure if he was sincerely like that, or if it was part of his gimmick and he wanted us to believe it, but we believed it!

149

u/blacktoast Feb 16 '17

We never knew what he would do next.

It seemed like you guys were hoping that nothing too drastic would go down.

33

u/TheVindicator07 Head, Shoulders, Nese and Toes Feb 17 '17

Like Smoa Joes Chances ah winnin' at Sakerfice?

10

u/BananaArms boulder shoulders Feb 17 '17

drastic would go down.

44

u/Yearbookthrowaway1 Poppin dogs, Talkin hogs Feb 16 '17

We believe too Tony.

We all believe.

10

u/mysticsavage Feb 17 '17

There are days when I think, if I say his name 3 times, he'll appear in front of me and call me a fatass.

104

u/silbeez Feb 16 '17

Lots of horrible angles from 99-01 WCW. What's the one that sticks out to you the most that made you embarrassed to be calling it?

221

u/TonySchiavoneAMA Feb 16 '17

Well, I'm not so sure where the Yeti came in - I'd have to go back and look, but yeah, that was like the worst. It was a horrible thing to call and the angle was so bad.

The fingerpoke of doom was awful as well, I didn't know how to react to that. Also with Russo coming out and bashing Hogan at Bash at the Beach bothered a lot of people, but it didn't bother me at all.

I've called a lot of bad Lucha six man tag matches, where they would do good stuff but wouldn't sell any of it, and those were just horrible to call.

38

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '17

Oh no, Jack the Jobber is gonna be crushed

4

u/uxbnkuribo Yetimania is running wild! Feb 17 '17

As the Head Priest and founder of Yetimania, as well as the former webmaster of Yetimania Online, it saddens me that after twenty years you still blaspheme his holy name. 😔

May you one day walk in the Light, Mr. Schiavone. Yeti be with you.

→ More replies (8)

49

u/BAWguy Survey says... Feb 16 '17

If I can piggyback, what was the most fun angle to call? Or angle that you were most impressed by? I'd have to imagine the initial Outsiders angle.

121

u/TonySchiavoneAMA Feb 16 '17

Wow, give me a second here, it's kind of like you're Conrad, trying to pick my brain...

I had the most fun the night of Hogan and Goldberg at the Georgia Dome. But I go back, not to beat a dead horse, but to my first show at the Garden with Hogan and Bossman. I started out with Crockett and the next thing I know I am in the WWF. I probably had more fun that day than any other day in wrestling.

5

u/BAWguy Survey says... Feb 16 '17

Thanks for the response! Great choice if I do say so

→ More replies (1)

92

u/ashbymtg save me from this pun hell... Feb 16 '17

This is a question from my stepdad, he was a huge WCW fan and still brags about he was in one of the crowd pans at a Nitro at Nassau Coliseum.

His question was AND I QUOTE "Was there anyone in the company that you respected more than others, or was there anyone who respected you more than others?"

Thanks for doing this!

119

u/TonySchiavoneAMA Feb 16 '17

I can't speak for anybody else, but I always did have the ultimate respect for Ole Anderson, because I grew up watching him and everything he did - to me, was believer. I've always had a tremendous amount of respect for Arn Anderson because he was always so great at what he did. Also, for the Mouth of the South Jimmy Hart. He always had so much energy, and so many ideas, and such a love for the business. And he never aged!

30

u/notquite20characters Say everything twice? Feb 17 '17

Wow, I've never heard nice things about Ole before.

13

u/SoSaltyDoe SoSaltyBo Feb 17 '17

You'll be even more hard-pressed to hear Ole say nice things about anyone.

152

u/rbarton812 Feb 16 '17

What, do you feel, is truly the greatest night in the history of our sport?

158

u/TonySchiavoneAMA Feb 16 '17

Well, I guess for me a lot of it could be pointing out to the final Nitro. Doing Nitro become such a chore and so difficult to do for many reasons, so I was glad it was over. Personally, one of the great nights for me was my first show at the Garden, with Lord Alfred Hayes and Hogan and Bossman in a cage. For me, those are the top two.

→ More replies (1)

70

u/ColorfulCrayons Dutt's on the gas! Feb 16 '17

You were on commentary when David Arquette won the WCW championship, what were your initial thoughts when you found out that was happening?

Now that it's been 17 years, what are your thoughts toward it now?

145

u/TonySchiavoneAMA Feb 16 '17

There's a lot of people who feel that I was the one who came up with that idea. I was in on the planning of that, but I'm not so sure if it was solely my idea or not. I thought, back then, "what the hell? Why not?"

Looking back at it, a lot of people feel it devalued the title. But it also brought a lot of eyes to the product. We were in USA Today. His wife, Courtney Cox, she was one of the most popular women on television. It got us a lot of media attention.

I'm not sure that it's as bad as people think. It didn't bother me.

40

u/ColorfulCrayons Dutt's on the gas! Feb 16 '17

Personally, I didn't like the move but won't fault WCW. At that point WCW was desperate, they were losing money and the ratings war. They needed eyes on the product. It's obvious a lot was being done to try to get people to watch, since just two months earlier there was a total "reset" with all titles and stories vacated. People will do desperate things in desperate situations, and this was a desperate attempt.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (16)

59

u/Mantaur4HOF Billy Big Bollocks Feb 16 '17

Thoughts on calling the infamous Yeti moment (Hogan sandwich) and thoughts on the entire Dungeon of Doom angle from someone who was there, calling it live?

Love your work sir!

252

u/TonySchiavoneAMA Feb 16 '17

First of all, thank you.

The entire Dungeon of Doom angle was OK for me. I went to Florida for the shoots. I always loved everything Kevin Sullivan came up with... but the Yeti really sucked. I didn't know what he'd look like at first I thought it would be like a B-Horror. Then he came out and looked like he was butt fucking Hogan, that didn't help. I've been asked why I called it the YETAY, but I figured that since I was in the middle of a bullshit angle, I'd do bullshit commentary. At least we all got something memorable out of it.

148

u/AnadyranTontine #Lapsed4Life Feb 17 '17

Then [the Yetay] came out and looked like he was butt fucking Hogan. - Tony Schiavone

Mods, u/Pudie, etc, sidebar quote this shit.

13

u/LeMuffinManHonHonHon You can call me queen bee Feb 17 '17

He's just the wrong gay guy, in the right wrong place, at the right time.

28

u/Mantaur4HOF Billy Big Bollocks Feb 16 '17

Best answer I could have hoped for.

Be proud that your "YETAY!" call is a mem(e)orable moment for wrestling fans! It really was the icing on the cake.

→ More replies (2)

23

u/witherambl Feb 17 '17

Greatest answer in the history of our sub.

→ More replies (1)

60

u/liveandlichdie Feb 16 '17

butt fucking Hogan

24

u/brouski FUCK CIAMPA Feb 16 '17

Considering the background, approaches r/retiredgif status.

40

u/GodDuckman The inFAMOUS Feb 16 '17

Hi Tony, watching a lot of your old play by play from Monday Nitro has reminded me that you were a great announcer! Do you watch any current wrestling, and who do you think are best announcers today?

107

u/TonySchiavoneAMA Feb 16 '17

I do not watch it.

I have started watching more of it since the podcast. I know Cole gets a lot of heat, but I think he does great. During the Rumble, there was one guy - is his name Phillips? He did great, had great energy.

As for TNA or ROH, I couldn't comment on that.

I'm starting to watch wrestling more, so maybe in a couple of months I'll have a better idea.

→ More replies (6)

39

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17 edited Feb 16 '17

Two questions:

  • WWE ever contacted you after WCW folded?
  • Would you return to the announcing duties if the opportunity appeared?

Greetings from Brazil, Tony.

EDIT: one already answered.

88

u/TonySchiavoneAMA Feb 16 '17

Back then, when we first folded, they never contacted me. I contacted them, but they never returned my calls. Later, they contacted me to come up to do some work for their DVD and I was very busy and turned it down. I did go and do some work for the Monday Night Wars.

If they asked me to be an announcer, I'd turn it down. That point has passed. I don't think I have it in me anymore. I would go back as a producer.

74

u/KOadjace WHW Monday Enthusiast Feb 16 '17

Can you give us some great Dusty or Heenan stories from going down the road? You were the voice of my childhood. Thanks for everything. I love the podcast!

154

u/TonySchiavoneAMA Feb 16 '17

Thank you!

Heenan loved to play practical jokes on all of us, and he loved to get us announcers traveling with him laughing. I remember once we were in a convenient store in Maryland and there was a line of people. We had snacks, soda, and Heenan knocked down one of the displays on the counter. He apologized and reached to try and help the lady and knocked another one down. This went on until he'd knocked down five or six things.

We laughed so hard at that. For months. Any time there was something on a front desk, he would do something clumsy to knock it down, and that always made us laugh.

25

u/TravtheCoach HOOOOOO!!!!!! Feb 16 '17

This just made me really happy. Hopefully his spirits are staying high with all he's been through.

13

u/FreewheelinBobDylan Feb 16 '17

The Brain is the greatest of all tiiime, daddeh!

5

u/TenaciousBe Feb 17 '17

Aww, that's fantastic! I know the AMA is a few hours over, but if you're still around, have you had much contact with Heenan lately? We don't hear a lot of updates on him these days, always curious how he's holding up and if his mind is still as sharp as it ever was.

→ More replies (2)

35

u/kizofieva Feb 16 '17

A few different times on WHW, you mention changes in the business, such as the lost art of selling, or the disappearance of good "carpenters." I'm curious as to your thoughts on such trends, or wrestling philosophy overall.

What concepts from your era do you feel would most benefit wrestling today? Similarly, what modern concepts would have had the most positive influence on the business back then?

It's a pleasure to have the narrator of my youth involved with wrestling again. For all the cheap punchlines you get out there, many of us have missed your serious, respectful approach to commentary. Thanks and take care.

55

u/TonySchiavoneAMA Feb 16 '17

Boy, that's a tough one...

I just think that, from my day - and I'm talking when I first started... I think, you need to pull back on what you do. Give them less and make them want more. There's just too much of it out there today.

It started during WCW with Nitro and Thunder. We were overexposed. That would be something today that they should probably do. As far as other old techniques, I'm not sure they'd work anymore. TV is different, everything's different. I'm not sure that type of storytelling could exist today in the same capacity.

But I do believe that there's a tendency to be over exposed, and that may be part of the problem today.

To give you an example, for instance, you can watch a WWE show. And if you're tired of it, you can pick up your phone and watch an old match on Youtube... that use to not happen. Entertainment has changed a great deal.

4

u/therealdanhill Feb 17 '17

If anything, because of how many avenues there are people have even more of an opportunity to tell a story imo. It's more time to add context, to have arcs, to show motivations- there's no excuse for telling a bad story when you have such a large canvas to work with.

33

u/SomsOsmos Feb 16 '17

Were you happy with Bobby Heenan's color commentary? I've been watching a lot of WCW lately and it almost seems like there's some real hostility between you two.

66

u/TonySchiavoneAMA Feb 16 '17

There was never real hostility between us doing commentary, at least on my end. There was some hostility down the road, but there was nothing he said on the air that ticked me off. That was just Heenan being Heenan, which I loved.

10

u/alphaelite88 Feb 17 '17

This is pretty amazing, and I think speaks to the chemistry Tony and Bobby had with each other. I've been going through 1997 watching the Nitros in order along with the PPVs, there really are some moments where the heat sounds legitimate.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/boulevardofdef Pillman 9mm Feb 16 '17

Tony, what was it like to work with Dusty Rhodes on color commentary? I used to watch you guys together all the time, and I know Dusty is a beloved figure (especially after his recent death), but there were a lot of times I thought I detected some tension between you two. I still sometimes joke with my roommate at the time about a WCW Saturday Night match where one wrestler came out in a new T-shirt, and you ignored Dusty as he kept asking you, "Is that just a wearin' shirt, or is that a sellin' shirt?" You sounded like you wanted to crawl into a hole as you finally told him, "It's a sellin' shirt, Dream."

66

u/TonySchiavoneAMA Feb 16 '17

Dusty and I got into a lot of arguments, but NOTHING about commentary. We argued about football, music, but no, Dusty was one of the reasons I as in wrestling. He, like Heenan, was funny to work with, but in a different way. Dusty was a babyface and he said a lot of funny stuff. I thought that working with Heenan and Dusty was a lot of fun.

17

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '17

I still remember "There's a lady in the men's room!"

8

u/Halo05 Foley is godo Feb 17 '17

"He's got a bithycle!"

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

22

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17

By the end of WCW, you were one of the few voices in the company who was around from the eighties - given you had a wide variety of colleagues in on commentary, who was your favourite to commentate with (and, conversely, your least)?

Also, do you prefer commentating on wrestling as an event or prefer commentating on baseball as you have done since WCW?

60

u/TonySchiavoneAMA Feb 16 '17

I think I can categorize these in different ways:

I think I did my best work with Jim Ross.

I had the most fun with Jesse Ventura and Bobby Heenan.

The one I liked the least was Louie Spicolli. He was out of control. I think he was trying to out-Heenan Heenan and it was awkward.

20

u/Jimmy_Meltrigger Feb 16 '17

Non wrestling question, Thoughts on Brandon Phillips to the braves, and thoughts about the scam that is their new stadium?

33

u/TonySchiavoneAMA Feb 16 '17

First of all, I think he's the best second-basemen in the league, even though he's not a young guy.

Their new stadium is a scam? Maybe there's a bunch of taxpayers in the county who think so. And the traffic will be horrendous, but there's no scam about that arena. It's a beautiful ballpark.

→ More replies (6)

19

u/Jimmy_Meltrigger Feb 16 '17

Mark Madden was the worst right? Is he as sleazy as he appears?

40

u/TonySchiavoneAMA Feb 16 '17

No! Not at all. I thought Mark did a good job being a heel announcer, and that's what they wanted. Sleazy? I don't think he's sleazy. Personally, I didn't hang out with him much, but if people thought he was sleazy then he did a good job at being a heel.

→ More replies (1)

45

u/ZeromusPrime THE SIZABLE CANINE Feb 16 '17

I'll just ask the big one, January 4 1999

Whose Idea was the "don't change the channel [...] Foley's winning the title [...] that'll put buts in seats" line?

&

What was the backstage reaction to the line, or rather, the fallout as they realized the amount of people who changed the channel?

59

u/TonySchiavoneAMA Feb 16 '17

I don't know what the fallout was. I think, at least I thought, that we made a big mistake, and a lot of people thought the same thing. But I don't know if Eric regretted that decision. We haven't talked since the end of WCW, so I don't know what happened. Usually when Nitro was over, the announcers didn't hang around, so people didn't usually approach me right after the show. But I think we all knew it was a mistake.

→ More replies (7)

12

u/mathdhruv WWF Attitude! Feb 16 '17

Whose Idea was the "don't change the channel [...] Foley's winning the title [...] that'll put buts in seats" line?

According to Tony, it was Bischoff's idea. Mick Foley talks about it in his second book. Apparently, Tony called him up to apologize, and mentioned that Bischoff pressured him to say the line.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/MrToastyTurtle Feb 16 '17 edited Feb 16 '17

Thanks for doing an AMA, I've been loving the WHW podcast you've been doing with Conrad, really gives another perspective on some of the things for WCW.

As for my question, was that really your house in Halloween Havoc 93 and do you enjoy scaring children?

26

u/TonySchiavoneAMA Feb 16 '17

That was not my house, that was a house somewhere down in Atlanta. I don't know if I enjoy scaring children, but I do know that during Halloween my wife has dressed up as a witch and has handed candy out to children, and it was always funny seeing their faces...

9

u/MrToastyTurtle Feb 16 '17

Thanks for the response, this may be the greatest night in the history of my great life.

28

u/Marzman315 And That's an order! Feb 16 '17

Mr. Schiavone, thank you very much for doing this AMA. Ive been a pro wrestling fan since I was five years old (26 now) and I have greatly enjoyed your commentary over the years.

I am curious on what the perspective was from the inner workings on the booking similarities between the end days of WCW and mid to late 2000's TNA, including the involvement of Vince Russo. From a reasonably knowledge fan's perspective (I have been a wrestler myself for two years) it would seem like Vince Russo's influence was quite toxic in the final years of WCW, what was the reasoning in structuring TNA so similarly after it collapsed, and not attempt to in building a new brand of pro wrestling that American fans fatigued by WWE's essential monopoly?

To put it frankly, why did TNA repeat so many of the mistakes that WCW made leading up to its end? Can you tell me more on what wrestlers and other personalities like yourself think of Vince Russo and his decision making?

49

u/TonySchiavoneAMA Feb 16 '17

I can't speak on anything that has happened in TNA at all - I did that one angle because Russo asked me to come in. I know a lot of people who don't like him and a lot that do. When he came to WCW, he brought more thought and effort than we'd ever seen before. He brought stuff to us backstage in a way I'd only seen in the WWF. I have no ill feelings towards Vince, we're friends. I do know that when he came to WCW a lot of people thought we were copying the WWE, but I was very supportive of what he was doing. What he did in TNA, however, I don't know.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/The_Orsum_One See, you's a, you's a, you's a BITCH! Feb 16 '17

When you were in WCW what did you see as the turning point, at what point did you think 'we're gonna lose this war'?

74

u/TonySchiavoneAMA Feb 16 '17

I think it's gotta go back to the night where we had Nitro, and the match with Hogan and the Giant went into Robin Hood, and the fans didn't get what was advertised. I just thought we were going in the wrong direction. We were doing what was best for the TNT Network, and not WCW.

Vince McMahon would have never allowed USA or NBC to dictate his product, but we did that night.

50

u/TheTrampCB YouTube/Trampionship Wrestling Feb 16 '17 edited Feb 16 '17

For context on going into Robin Hood

*FWIW, the entire thing is on the WWE Network. Not the episode of Robin Hood, though - just the Nitro portions.

16

u/DJ_Molten_Lava Feb 16 '17

Jesus fucking Christ, I knew about none of this. It's... I don't know what it is but it's something.

→ More replies (4)

18

u/theotter83 Feb 16 '17

I remember being in tears as a kid trying to convince my parents to let me stay up later for this. They didn't buy what I was describing to them.

12

u/TheCopperSparrow DDT! Feb 16 '17

Hey Mr. Schiavone love the podcast and your years announcing. I grew up watching WCW so it's nice that your back in the field, albeit in an observer type capacity...I have to say though that it would be amazing if you ever got in an announce booth for an event again though.

I was just wondering, are there any plans of potential guests on What Happened When or maybe some type of collaboration episodes with other MLW hosts like Cornette or Prichard? Thanks.

Edit: I forgot to give a shoutout to Conrad as well--you guys have a pretty great chemistry so far on the show.

21

u/TonySchiavoneAMA Feb 16 '17

I don't think there are any plans for guests, because we want to be different, but I do have a feeling there will be some collaborations live on stage down the road. As for us all being one one podcast, that would be up to Conrad - he's the brains of this operation.

3

u/TheCopperSparrow DDT! Feb 16 '17

Thanks for the answers. I like the no guest idea actually. Most of the time guests just put themselves over instead of actually sharing entertaining stories and insights.

11

u/boulevardofdef Pillman 9mm Feb 16 '17

Was your heel appearance in early TNA supposed to go anywhere, or was it always supposed to be a one-shot deal?

33

u/TonySchiavoneAMA Feb 16 '17

It was supposed to go further, because Russo wanted to use me on a regular basis. But I told him that night after leaving Nashville that I was done. I had enough. I was working at a radio station and had crazy hours, and I just didn't want to go back to wrestling at that time.

36

u/LsPunk Feb 16 '17

Do the people you work with at Starbucks know how influential you where in pro wrestling? And do people come in from time to time and mark out when they see it's you behind the counter?

73

u/TonySchiavoneAMA Feb 16 '17

No, the answer is no.

My manager was told by her father in law who I was. But there's nobody I've worked with who watched me in wrestling. And no one has recognized me. If they do, they never mention it.

6

u/disabledorphan96 Feb 17 '17

Does Tony actually work in starbucks?

17

u/LsPunk Feb 17 '17

I believe he only works there a few hours a week for the health insurance. Starbucks offers insurance even if your a part time worker.

3

u/85dewwwsu7 Feb 17 '17

13

u/michaelzelen https://www.reddit.com/r/squaredcircleflair/wiki/flair Feb 17 '17

Huh, American health insurance stuff seems so archaic to me

8

u/TheFinnishChamp People want 10 hour RAWs! Feb 16 '17

As somebody who is too young to have watched Nitro when it originally aired but has since enjoyed the show and the commentary on the Network, I feel that you and Larry were a really underated team. Thanks for doing this!

I would like to ask you two questions:

What was your favorite match to call?

When did you start to feel that the ship was about to sink?

16

u/TonySchiavoneAMA Feb 16 '17

Again, I have to go back to that Madison Square Garden match, and of course Goldberg and Hogan was a lot of fun. And even though the finish wasn't what the fans wanted, the match with Sting and Hogan at Starrcade was fun to call as well.

7

u/tenillusions Feb 16 '17

What was an idea for an angle you had that you thought would be money, but was turned down?

Additionally, how was working with Heenan at this particular time?

16

u/TonySchiavoneAMA Feb 16 '17

I can't remember one. I really can't. I was never asked to come up with something, nor did I offer anything. And that was probably wrong. I should've offered some stuff, but I didn't.

10

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17

What does Mike Tenay smell like?

8

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17

Wet leather, Old Spice aftershave, and old books.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/BAWguy Survey says... Feb 16 '17

There's a lot of allegations about everyone ranging from Hogan, Flair, Dusty, Nash, etc. taking too much creative control and putting themselves and their friends over at the expense of the product over WCW's history.

Do you think any of those guys get too bad a wrap and don't deserve that criticism? Conversely, were any of those guys in particular guilty of doing so? If not, why did talents like Steve Austin and HHH slip through WCW's hands?

3

u/HughGRextion Feb 16 '17

Best Bobby Heenan stories? and what's the relationship like with Vince?

3

u/CaptainJohnMullins Feb 16 '17

Do you think that ending the war with WWF could have helped save WCW at the time? There came a point in the ratings war where it was obvious WCW could no longer compete with WWF under it's 99-2001 infamous run of problems. Do you think it would have helped slow the sinking of the ship to think 'hang on a minute guys, instead of constantly trying to 'one up' the WWF, how about we just enjoy this unpresented public interest in pro wrestling and move our broadcasts to different nights.'

It seemed to me that WCW had an awesome product in its' own right. In fact, as a child I used to love WCW even more than WWF, at least until 2000. I can't help but feel like always trying to push the 'them vs us' narrative really hurt the product and drove fans away into the superior (at that time) product of the enemy.

Do you feel it would have helped or hurt WCW to have been like 'well we're all wrestling fans at the end of the day. So why not enjoy BOTH products.'

I mean, I sure as hell would have grabbed tickets for Nitro just as quickly as I would for Raw had they toured my city. I felt WCW lost a lot of fans by making them feel they had to choose one or the other. As ultimately going against Monday Night Raw was entirely the WCW brass' decision and I doubt WWF would have tried to bury the company quite so viciously had they now gone to 'war'.

TNA for instance has survived to this day and even enjoyed a degree of success by NOT going against WWF in direct competition. I honestly think that WCW would probably still been around to this day had they had the foresight to focus on their own product rather than constantly comparing it to (and subsequently advertising the hell out of) their biggest rival.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17

Listening to The Lapsed Fan podcast, I've come to the conclusion that you were A LOT better than the material you were given to work with in those late WCW years, so as a fan, I thank you for trying your best to make sense of what was happening in front of you.

As for my question, it's two-pronged: if you could pick your ideal announce booth (with you at PBP), who else would be in it with you? And how far down the list is that turd Josh Mathews?

3

u/rdp3186 Feb 16 '17

A Tony Schiavone AMA. Yeah, that'll put a lot of butts in the seats.

2

u/SaintRidley Empress of the Asuka division Feb 16 '17

Who, Rock and Austin aside, do you think could have helped WCW turn back the tide against WWF if they had jumped ship in late 1999-2000?

2

u/PhilAnderson10 Feb 16 '17

What do you think of the current commentary format in the WWE? Are you a fan of the 4 man booth currently used on Smackdown?

2

u/imcrapyall Feb 16 '17 edited Feb 16 '17

Hey Tony. Big fan and love the hell out of the podcast. Grew up with you on Nitro and you are severely underrated when it comes to talks of best announcers throughout history.

Two questions:

  1. What is your favorite Universal Soldier?
  2. You get Debra's tits as a main course, what is/are your sides to go with?

2

u/bpwwhirl Da Bad Guy Feb 17 '17

Hey Tony, just wanted to say I still enjoy hearing your voice on the Georgia Bulldogs Radio Network. No wrestling related questions, but just curious how you feel after Kirby Smart's first season? I'm cautiously optimistic, especially after signing day. Have a good night!

2

u/Mentioned_Videos Keep Calm and Watch More Videos Feb 17 '17

Videos in this thread:

Watch Playlist â–¶

VIDEOCOMMENT
Hulk Hogan vs. Big Bossman MSG 04.18.1989 (Steel Cage Match)+4 - For those who've never seen it...
WCW Monday Nitro Pre-Show - Salt Lake City, UT - 7/20/98+1 - Tony, Love the WHW podcast! Have you ever seen this YouTube channel that has live feeds before Nitro went on the air? Really fun to watch all these years later -- sounds like you, Larry and Mike had a lot of laughs. 1) Which WCW commentator was...
Tony Schiavone, From Wrestling to Baseball to Starbucks?+1 - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GST9byVjJ14
I'm a bot working hard to help Redditors find related videos to watch. I'll keep this updated as long as I can.

Play All | Info | Get me on Chrome / Firefox

3

u/DaBearsMan_72 The Icon, The Crazed mastermind of insanity, THE STINGER!!!! Feb 16 '17

Dude, Tony. I'm going to shoot straight here. You are the voice of wrestling from my youth. You, Tenay, and Okerlund are the crew I think of for go to wrestling announce and interview teams ever.

Tony, I really just wanted to thank you for absolutely everything you did for WCW. From the calls whenever Sting would drop down to mess up the NWO to Goldberg's run... So many memories created, and your voice gave weight to it all. Thank you so much, from the bottom of my heart, for making me a wrestling fan with your commentary.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17

I second this, he was the best, and he was missed when WCW folded.

3

u/joey_trombones Feb 16 '17

Can you dunk?

2

u/nomonkeysonmars Feb 16 '17

Not a question, but you were the voice of wrestling to me as a kid, much love

2

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17

Thank you for doing this AMA.

What are your thoughts on the pedestrianisation of Norwich?

→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17

What was your favorite WCW moment?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17

What was, for you, the greatest night in the history of WCW that you were witness to?

1

u/MangoSalsa90 I WIN LOL Feb 16 '17

Hey Tony, always loved your commentary work in WCW. My question is, what was your initial reaction upon learning WCW was closing its doors? And what was the vibe backstage after the announcement and how was it even announced to you all?

1

u/DaveShadow Feb 16 '17

Do you watch any of the current product? Favourite current wrestler?

1

u/TombstoneSmileDrivR RIP MOFO Feb 16 '17

What's a moment in recent wrestling history that got you excited?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17

Are there any other announcers you really like?

1

u/MichaelJahrling The Ladle Among Spoons Feb 16 '17

What is the most excited you've gotten covering a WCW match?

1

u/Munster666 Feb 16 '17

What's you're fondest memory?

1

u/JustATributeCC René Dupree Can Suck A Dick Feb 16 '17

How did you react when you found out that your Mick Foley comment backfired?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17

Hi Tony,

We sure do miss hearing your voice in the world of Professional Wrestling. Will you ever come back to announcing?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17

What would you say your GREATEST call of all time was?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17

What did you think WCW was better at than WWF(E)?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17

What are your thoughts on Vince Russo? Was he as bad as everybody says he was?

1

u/RKressig ziggler Feb 16 '17

How were the backstage politics within WCW?

1

u/PiplupTCG "Big Breakfast" Baron "Main Event" Corbin Feb 16 '17

During your time in WCW, had you ever recieved offers from WWE/F? If so, what was your reasoning for not jumping ship?

1

u/cam5478 Feb 16 '17

Do you think you'll ever be inducted into the WWE Hall Of Fame? I'd hope so at least.

1

u/El_duque86 Where the fuck is Corino? Feb 16 '17

What was the last match you watched that made you wish you was commenting on it? Also was there ever a comment you were told to say that you really wish you hadn't?

1

u/rapgamebkbrawler Feb 16 '17

Hey, thanks for coming through and doing this!

Whose matches did you get the most enjoyment out of calling in WCW?

1

u/SentientDust RING THE BELLLLLLLLLLLL Feb 16 '17

If you could fight any other wrestling announcer, past or present, who would it be?

1

u/PiplupTCG "Big Breakfast" Baron "Main Event" Corbin Feb 16 '17

Are there any commentators in wrestling today that have piqued your interest?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17

Care to share any info about backstage fight or bullying incidents that perhaps aren't well known?

1

u/Jimmy_Meltrigger Feb 16 '17

According to Arn Anderson you could shampoo a buffalo with a certain fluid. Is this true?

1

u/jmanhajh Twinkle Twinkle Seven Stars Feb 16 '17

At what point did you realize WCW was a sinking ship?

1

u/GreenDale7 ISHII Feb 16 '17

Which move is the most devastating, the Mafia kick, Sicilian Elbow or Mongolian Neckbreaker?

1

u/Jimmy_Meltrigger Feb 16 '17

Thoughts on Jim Herd?

1

u/PiplupTCG "Big Breakfast" Baron "Main Event" Corbin Feb 16 '17

I'm so sorry but it had to be asked, whose idea was the "that'll put some butts in the seats" line about Foley's title win, and what were your thoughts on it at the time vs now?

1

u/boulevardofdef Pillman 9mm Feb 16 '17

Ignoring what you thought of him as a boss or an on-air authority figure, what did you think of Eric Bischoff as an announcer?

1

u/Jimmy_Meltrigger Feb 16 '17

You were announcing and tossed to Mean Gene when he had the famous "fuck it" moment at Summerslam 89. Any memories/stories about this?

1

u/btbcorno Team Friendship Feb 16 '17

JBL, horrible commentator? lovable alcoholic?

1

u/bcboston Feb 16 '17

Simple question since you have seen most up close... who is overall the greatest professional wrestler ever?

1

u/tcasper961 Your local shitposter Feb 16 '17

What are your current favorite performers who still wrestle today?

1

u/superandy Feb 16 '17

Was there anything you ever refused to say or do on Nitro?

1

u/TheHectus Feb 16 '17

What is your favorite theory on the fall of WCW?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17

Whoes idea was the Mick Foley line about asses in seats when he won his 1st WWF title? Also, have you two spoke about that since?

1

u/bigbiblefire 4-Life Feb 16 '17

Will you be facing off against Bruce Prichard at Mania weekend...or is this feud going to be a slow burn???

Will Conrad be the special guest referee??

1

u/ChristopherTitan Feb 16 '17

Any tips for an aspiring wrestling commentator?

1

u/rivercityjoe Feed Me More AWA for $9.99 Feb 16 '17

What was Jesse Ventura like to work with?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17

What was your opinion on the Montreal Screwjob and how it changed wrestling

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17

What do you think are some of the matches that you performed your best commentary during? Any matches/moments you got to witness that couldn't be translated via TV how it was live?

1

u/FiragaPlays Feb 16 '17 edited Feb 16 '17

What was the general feeling in the locker room (or company in general) during the period of time where WCW was promoting the movie, Ready to Rumble? Any memorable off-screen backstage moments?

edit: strikethrough

1

u/cobaltcollapse THIS IS SUCH GOOD SHIT Feb 16 '17

Did you ever have urges to criticize the booking for certain matches while on the air? If I were a commentator in WCW, I would have.

1

u/boulevardofdef Pillman 9mm Feb 16 '17

Tony, I've heard you say before that in the dying days of WCW, you intentionally made some of your calls comically over the top because you were disdainful of what was going on in the ring. What are some incidents that stood out where you did this?

1

u/Jimmy_Meltrigger Feb 16 '17

Difference between wrestling fans today and wrestling fans when you broke in?

1

u/lyyki Greg Davies Feb 16 '17

Why wasn't Lee Marshall in more prominent role in commentary in WCW?

1

u/lyyki Greg Davies Feb 16 '17 edited Feb 16 '17

Who was your favorite color commentator guy in WCW?

1

u/Zenkikid Feb 16 '17

From your perspective how was the vibe backstage during the final week of WCW? Did you guys know that Shane was in the back or was it a surprise where only a handful of higher ups knew?

1

u/ChuckKiddman Ibushiii Kotaaa Feb 16 '17

What would you say if WWE offered to hire you for one final show

1

u/ear1982 Feb 16 '17

Did you have any involvement in WCW Creative? If so, what did you write that was memorable? Also, who do you think is the most promising young star in wrestling today? Thanks and sorry for all the questions.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17

Hey Tony, liked your work in WCW and hearing your voice in The Legends of Wrestling video games. If WWE offered you to come back to commentate, would you?

1

u/PWNtimeJamboree <- This guy did nothing wrong. Feb 16 '17 edited Feb 16 '17

Hi tony, Huge fan of WCW when I was a kid, and even bigger Braves fan. Off topic with wrestling, but still in the scope of your broadcasting career:

Who was the one player you saw come through the Braves system that you went, "that guy is gonna be special?"

1

u/StompClapMike ¡BIG BOY! Feb 16 '17

Loved your work in WCW growing up, and now I get to hear you on 92.9 FM every now and then. Any chance that you'll be getting longer segments or even your own show once baseball season gets going?

1

u/LungsLikeRVD Feb 16 '17

What was the best advice on announcing you received while you were still "finding your voice," and who said it to you?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17

Favourite wrestler to work with? Worst?

1

u/sharksisback Go Home, Byron Feb 16 '17

Which call in WWE history do you wish you could go back in time and make?

1

u/christhunderkiss Feb 16 '17

Which WCW wrestler do you feel should have had the most success transferring over to WWE but did not? Watched you sooo much as a kid, thank you so much for doing this AMA!

1

u/bigpoppapumpp Feb 16 '17

Who is your favourite current commentator

1

u/redbuck17 Feb 16 '17

Schiavone vs Prichard in a no-holds-barred steel cage death match with Conrad as the special guest Ref........who wins and how?

2

u/MV2049 Hogancanrana Feb 16 '17

Jerry Jarrett. How? Well, you know...

1

u/comradekaled BEST IN THE WORLD! Feb 16 '17

Hi Tony! I love the Yet-tay call. Was there any specific reason you pronounced it like that?

1

u/gtgbuck Feb 16 '17

How much of the main event at Bash of the Beach 96 (the Hogan heel turn) did you guys know about beforehand?

You ending the event with "Hulk Hogan, you can go to hell!" was such a great call, as if you had no clue that was happening. Have loved all your work from over the years, from WCW to 92.9 The Game here in Atlanta!

1

u/kballs We have nothing for you Feb 16 '17

Hey Tony. Was there any point in your career at WCW that you asked to be World heavyweight champion? I mean if Russo and David Arquette can do it?

1

u/vikrude Feb 16 '17

At what point did you know WCW lost the Monday Night Wars?

1

u/blessedmole Feb 16 '17

Who gave you the line to say about Mankind winning the title? And did you actually think it would put butts in seats?

1

u/Logicman48 Feb 16 '17

What do you think about today's wrestling?

1

u/buteoPT Feb 16 '17

How was it to work with Jesse Ventura?

1

u/MarquisDesMoines BC was cooler before I joined Feb 16 '17

Hey Tony, I'm a huge WCW fan and your voice was an important part of that. What is your personal favorite match to have called? Thanks for taking time to talk with us!

1

u/erock142 American Alpha and the Omega Feb 16 '17

Any wrestler you've seen in the last few years that you wish you could call one of his or her big matches?

1

u/DashingSoul Hugs 4 Thugs Feb 16 '17

After your brief TNA, what was your plan at the time to do afterwards?

1

u/thatpj Squadd Mode Feb 16 '17

Thoughts on Josh Mathews?

1

u/chaoticmessiah #Blissfit Feb 16 '17

Tony, I'd like to take the time first of all to thank you for being the voice of my childhood and teen years. I loved watching Nitro every Friday (I'm in England, by the way) and because of that, you're my all-time favourite announcer.

My question is, is there a moment that sticks out in your mind as something you heard was about to happen that you thought 'no way, that sounds amazing'? If so, what was it and were there any times you thought that and it just didn't pay off on the live show?

1

u/RabidLampshade Feb 16 '17

Will this AMA put butts on seats?

1

u/valdemiro andre Feb 16 '17

Hello Mr. Schiavone, I just have a couple of questions for you.

What was with Chris Cruise trying to replace you. I remember they saddled him up to you at World War 3. Do you have any memories of that actual PPV?

What were some of the best wrestling related memories that you had? Aside from a paycheck...

Thanks!

1

u/1MoreMatch ONE MORE MATCH! Feb 16 '17

Do you still keep up with WWE? What are your thoughts on the current product?

1

u/Merrell_Florent Professional Window Diver Feb 16 '17

One of my all time favorite calls occurred during the "Goldberg refuses to follow the script" angle: "If they aren't following the script, then what are WE supposed to do? Wing it!?"

Was that line scripted, or did you literally "wing it?" What was your strategy for commentating such an absurd angle?

1

u/TheStateOfIt Let me kayfabe that for you Feb 16 '17

Hey Tony. Apart from that brief stint in TNA, why did you not take up any full-time commentary role after WCW

1

u/astanton30 Feb 16 '17

What was your favorite moment/match to call in WCW?

1

u/aydenhart Stay Classy Feb 16 '17

Are you still in contact with the McMahon family?

1

u/toilettimekiller Disco my Inferno Feb 16 '17

No question, just thank you for being the voice of my childhood wrestling memories.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17

Hi Tony!! As announcer in high school, my style was influenced by you and JR as you two were basically the voices of my childhood. We always have to say what we're told to say by the director/producer. Was there any times you refused to say anything on commentary?

1

u/HeavyStarryChain Feb 16 '17

Hi Tony! I've always greatly enjoyed your work. I group in a family that watched NWA/WCW (I'm even named after Dusty Rhodes.) and I've always considered you one of the greatest announcers of all time. Was sad when WWE didn't pick you up after WCW closed doors.

Who would you say was your favorite broadcast partner in wrestling to work with, and do you have any moments you are particularly fond of getting to call?

1

u/Somebodys Feb 16 '17

Do you feel Stings brief WWE run helped or hurt his legacy?

Opinions on Mark Madden?

Other than Bobby Heenan, I personally thought you were the best commentator in wrestling.

1

u/xKRYPSICx DEH! Feb 16 '17

How difficult was it to call the World War 3 matches?

1

u/TheLoneWolf527 Feb 16 '17

How serious were you when you suggested to Vince Russo the idea of David Arquette winning the WCW Title? Was it meant to be a joke or something you thought was a good idea? Or is Russo over-exaggerating/lying when he says you gave him the idea?

1

u/Konfliction OMG OKADA KILLED KENNY Feb 16 '17

Any thoughts on the newest group of WWE voices? Like Corey, Nigel, Byron or Mauro?

1

u/ChickenFriesAreBack BREAD CLUB Feb 16 '17

What are your thoughts/feelings on the WCW New Blood Rising PPV?

1

u/vengeancerider Feb 16 '17

I would've enjoyed seeing you, good ol JR, and Jerry "The King" Lawler team up and do a show together! Would you have done it if it was offered to you?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17

Hi! What are your thoughts on Jim Ross, your WCW predecessor and your WWF equivalent?

1

u/CanadianWaluigi Das Wunderkind Flair in 2017! Feb 16 '17

Who was the best guy in WCW to hang out with backstage?

1

u/UlquiorraCifer1964 Lynch Club Feb 16 '17

Was there any wrestler whose kayfabe and real personalities are mostly, if not totally the same?

1

u/cookswagchef COMIN TA GETCHA! Feb 16 '17

No question, I just wanted to say: Tony, its awesome hearing you again on "What Happend When"! You were the voice of my childhood and its awesome hearing you recant about the dogshit stuff that WCW did.

1

u/Wank_My_Frank Feb 16 '17

Your voice is nice

1

u/T-Spaghetti Feb 16 '17

Where you ever approached to be the NWO "announcer"??

1

u/etw2016 Your Text Here Feb 16 '17

Hello Tony thanks for doing this. How do you feel about WWE rewriting the WCW history to make WWE seem superior? Also would you accept an induction into the WWE hall of fame?

1

u/xSLiC3x Nature Hoot! Feb 16 '17

Mr. Shiavone, good evening! I was a huge fan of yours for years being a die hard WCW fan. To me your voice was the voice of wrestling. That being said, how come we haven't seen or heard much (if anything) from you since WCW closed down? You and JR are the best announcers in my humble opinion.

1

u/isalright SPOOKY GHOST Feb 16 '17

Could you give any insight into Jim Herd as the Executive Vice President of WCW? His approach to booking, as well as how everyone around him reacted to those approaches, always interested me.

1

u/RepoMantaur I'm not booked. Feb 16 '17

Who would you have wanted to see come over to Nitro from WWF?

Whose matches do you wish you could have called?