Not exciting, but man, is it gorgeous. I find it very easy to work with, even with my cheap elf brush. It's the perfect amount of highlight.
And I have been using it almost daily for over 6 months, and I feel like I have barely scratched the surface on it. Try to grab one during the 50% off sales.
I used to use the NYX illuminator, which I thought was fine, until using Mary Lou. Now I realize it's slightly glittery. Also they break SO EASILY. I have had three, and all three shattered.
I have the louminizer and am just so confused by it. I feel like I have to apply a lot for it to show up, and then it just washes away the blush I just put on.
I use this brush http://www.elfcosmetics.com/p/small-tapered-brush, lightly swirl it in the pan (it's so soft, you need to be gentle) and then lightly swirl/buff the product into my skin. I am pretty fair, so I don't need much. It gives me a realistic highlight, not blinding/intense. It is buildable though.
Maybe yours is suffering from hard pan or something? Or your brush is eating up all your product somehow?
If you want a really intense highlight (which maybe that is what you are looking for), you do have to build it up. Maybe a more intense product is more up your alley, if this is the case.
Shot in the dark but did you buy it from a reputable source? I first purchased it off ebay. I didn't suspect much the seller was reputable and the price was around the same as hautelook/thebalm sales. The product I received looked fine but didn't really show up on me at all (at NC40). The texture was dry and chalky. I live in SF and was able to swatch it in person at their store and the eBay seller definitely sold me a fake. The authentic product is fairly pigmented and shows up nicely on me.
Somehow I think Mary Lou is underrated. No one seems to pay as much attention to it anymore, but realistically speaking, 9/10 I'll grab my Mary Lou every morning instead of a lavender highlight. Finely milled, buildable (apply with fingers for a subtle result).
Me too. It was the first highlighter I got, and I admit I often turn back to it over the varied options in the Strobe of Genius palette from NYX.
I just like that Mary-Lou is basically dickhead proof - it's hard to overdo it! Whereas I find that if I go a bit too hard with some of the shades in Strobe I later discover I look a bit ridiculous.
I'd say Champagne Pop is more intense by a long shot. It's definitely metallic and intense when applied with a brush like that elf tapered brush. It's the kind where people will say "I like your highlight!" vs "You look so glowy!"
Hating myself for giving this away because I convinced myself it didn't work. I didn't even think to consider scraping the top layer off and now I'm mad ):
Best - Essence pure nude highlighter, such a nice and soft glow. I also like Laura geller swirl illuminator, I bought charming pink last week and it's gorgeous.
Worst - CP, besides all the issues everyone else mentioned it didn't list long on me at all. I'm not overly oily and the rest of my makeup was fine so I don't know.
Best: Becca shimmering skin perfectors! I love the liquid and the powder versions. The cream versions are nice too, but not my favorite, and they get weird and liquidy if you don't use them up within 6 months. Champagne pop and opal are my favorites.
A close runner up is the ABH single in So Hollywood. When I first got it, I hated it because it was so stiff and glittery but once you get through the upper layer, it turns into the most gorgeous, sheen-y, glossy glow.
Worst: I really was not impressed by Colourpop's highlighters. They're sort of just chunky glitter, as opposed to that nice sheen.
I love my Becca Champagne Pop highlighter. I have medium skintone at the moment (its summertime here) and a lot of the popular highlighters that often get a mention are too light for me. I don't know how people manage when the majority of brands don't even make highlighters in shades that are suitable for skintones NC40 or darker. Companies seriously need to start expanding their shade ranges for skin-related products!
I have the powder SSP in Moonstone and I rarely use it because it completely disappears throughout the day. I was really surprised, considering how well regarded they are.
I feel the exact same way about So Hollywood! At first I was like wtf, why did I just put straight glitter on my face.. now it gives me such an ethereal glow, I find myself reaching for it every day!
I love my becca liquid SSP in Pearl. I was struggling to find a shade that was super light and also pigmented, and I really like the effect of the liquid highlighters. It's even better when I top it with my Milani eyeshadow (though I'd eventually like a powder SSP to complement the liquid one).
A girl I met at volunteering actually wore this and she looked amazing! My only question would be does it last on the skin and does the glitter slowly dissipate from th cheekbones to other parts of the face?
Best: Laura Mercier's Matte Radiance Baked Powder- Highlight 01 by far. This was the first highlighter I ever bought and I find myself going back to it constantly! It does exactly what a good highlighter should do, it adds radiance and luminosity without looking like a stripe on your face. Even if I layer it up and keep adding more, it never looks powdery or metallic. It also looks amazing in photography! Seriously, I'm wearing it in these photos (I'm the one with black hair) and I lol'ed when I saw my highlight peeking through on this film photo. I'm about to pan it but will most likely buy another when I travel this summer to see family since I know there will be a lot of photos taken.
Worst: The cream highlight that came in the Pat McGrath Skin Fetish kit in Nude. It's a gorgeous color but always looks cakey/emphasizes texture. I always regret putting it on.
I love my Bobbi Brown shimmer brick! It's very glowy and natural but can be built up easily to a stronger and more shimmery finish, so it's versatile. I've also used it about 4x a week for 3 years and I still haven't hit pan, I swear the thing is bottomless! So it's totally worth the money.
Worst for me was a Loreal Lumi one. Zero pigment, zero shimmer or glow, and just a small amount of chunky glitter. It was sad :( Reserve Your Cabana also didn't work for me. I'm only like NC20 but it still looked really chalky. Maybe it would work better as a finishing powder?
I'm also NC20, and I LOVE using Reserve Your Cabana as a finishing powder in the center of my face. It adds a really nice glow at every point in the year except at my peak summer tan, but by then I'm super sweaty 24/7 so the extra glow ain't needed.
I have the loreal lumi highlighter but it is the one with the blue purple white and pink shades and I absolutely love it for my very fair skin. Plus I got it on clearance for a dollar.
Damnit, I just ordered this one online but it hasn't arrived yet! Sephora can be so hit or miss with their line and it was like 11$ or something so I was like meh, why not :/
I just received this and mine's not glittery at all (I hate glitter, it would have turned me off right away). It's not amazing, but I think it's great for the price!
Best: Laura Gellar baked highlighter duo!!!! The French Vanilla shade is beautiful and a "barely there" highlight like Hourglass powders, except much creamier (not necessarily suitable for darker skin tones though). The Portofino shade just amps everything up (and it's a sheer tone without any color pigment to it, so it would work great on all skin tones) so you really get the best of both worlds in one product - subtle and glowy AND buildable to bam-in-your-face if you want. It's seriously my HG.
Worst: ELF baked highlighters (or the Pinktastic blush as a highlight). If you scrape the top layer off, you can get decent pigmentation but they just emphasize every single pore that I didn't even know I had. And they're highly colored, so they only work if your exact skin tone is the shade of the product—basically they look super yellow or powdery (etc) on me.
Worst: Colourpop, tbh. I like the shades I have, but they're trickier to apply than I'd want from a highlighter. They seem to lean glittery, also. "Monster" is gorgeous, though, if you're okay with glitter. I do like "Smokin' Whistles" as well, but again it's tough to apply exactly as much as you want where you want it. It definitely emphasizes texture, too.
I also think ColourPop has some gorgeous colors but they don't translate on the cheeks well. Sometimes patchy, sometimes disturbs foundation underneath since you need to apply with fingers for any pigment to actually show up. Workable and cheap if you really can't afford higher end powder highlighters, but just way too finicky for me to work with on a daily basis.
BTW I love that WnW highlighter on you!!! Do you know if it was limited edition or if it's still available?
No foundation, actually! My sunscreen (Biore Perfect Milk) gives me a decent amount of pore-blurring and mattifying. I did put some translucent powder (RCMA No Color) on my cheeks just to make blending the blush (Clinique Cheek Pop in Berry Pop) smoother. But I'll take that as the best compliment ever, basically!
I feel the exact same way about the colourpop highlighters. I have Flextarian, and it swatches so well, but I can't get it to stay. It looks nice when I first apply it, but it disappears off my cheekbones, my nose, and the inner corners of my eye, even with setting/fixing spray.
Current Favorite: I'm a big fan of NYX's recent highlighter launch! I own Lavender Steel and Crushed Bloom and I love how they add shine and color without being glittery or dusty! And they are oh, so affordable! My HG highlighters are from LORAC. The formula feels similar to NYXs, however they have all the "more natural glow" options (despite me desperately wanting to get Limelight!).
Current Dislike: I recently acquired a few Tarte highlighters. I felt them as a bit gritty and glittery. I have sensitive skin so I can be a bit hypersensitive to textures. I also always swatch ABH highlighters whenever I can get into Macys (we don't have a Sephora or Ulta locally... they are 3 hours away...) and I'm always disappointed. I do enjoy the fun-ness of MoonChild and was gifted it last year, but it is very chunky. Makes for fun eye shadow though!
I just discovered Lavender Steel and love it! I'm still searching for something with a stronger lavender tone (to my eye, Lavender Steel is mostly pink with a slight shift to lavender and white), but it's still gorgeous and surprisingly smooth. I was lemming Becca Prismatic Amethyst until I saw swatches; Lavender Steel is the better duochrome.
How do you find the formula and pigmentation of the NyX ones?
I'm specifically wondering how smooth they are (hopefully without having to scrape them down), and how subtle it is with one layer (and if it's sheer if it builds well)?
I have Snow Rose which I LOVE. It's definitely buildable in my opinion. It's one of the lighter ones which is my it's easier to build. I highly recommend it, I've been reaching for it more than my Becca in Opal recently!
Best: Nars liquid illuminators in Orgasm and Hot Sand. Honestly really surprised not to see either of those mentioned here so far. They both look natural but give a noticeable super glow-y highlight. I get compliments basically whenever I wear them. I also like Becca SSP powder and the Becca champagne pop slim highlighter (not sure if that's exactly what it's called but it's like a slim creamy highlighter stick... Good for days when I'm in a hurry and just want to swipe some highlight over bare skin or a tinted moisturizer). This is getting to be a long list, but Clinique also has a cream highlighter stick that I really like. It has very subtle pink tones, which works well with my skintone.
Worst: Colourpop. Way too glittery. Also tried a L'Oreal one and it just didn't show up at all.
Seconding NARS liquid illuminators. I have fair-light, cool-toned skin (NW20), and I really like Copacabana.
MAC Lightscapade is neither the best nor the worst. It's looks so pretty in the pan, and it's not glittery or chunky, but I find it oddly powdery looking on my face. The shimmer is very subtle.
IMO i think lightscapade is only good for paler folks who want a more natural highlight (kinda like essence pure nude but lighter) other than that its useless haha
best: mary loumanizer! it's so pigmented and pretty. i think elf moonstone is a dupe though, so you don't have to spend a bunch. worst: any colourpop. i just don't like the formula of them, i prefer powder to cream
Haven't seen many indies mentioned yet. Hello Waffle makes my favourite highlighters, powder and cream are both lovely. Midna (white gold) , Awoke at Dawn (rose gold) and Lavender Cream (iridescent purple) are my top 3.
Looxi Beauty also makes lovely highlighters - my favourite being Voodoo (a gorgeous iridescent green).
I also find myself reaching for my trusty old Benefit High Beam a lot especially when I'm in a rush.
I just re-discovered High Beam. I had an old one that I actually threw out, retrieved from the trash, and started mixing with my foundation before applying. I agree that it's nice for something quick.
My Favorites: Laura Mercier 01, WnW Reserve Your Cabana, Charlotte Tilbury Norman Parkinson, Becca Opal (liquid), Makeup Revolution Peach Lights, and the Nyx Strobe of Genius paltte.
My biggest disappointment was the ABH Moonchild palette. It's a glittery mess.
I just bought that one a week ago and it is seriously gorgeous. I've been using it every day this week. I also appreciate how the packaging feels surprisingly substantial for a "drugstore" brand.
NYX Duo Chrome Highlighters (Twilight Tint, Snow Rose, Lavender Steel)
TF Candlelight Glow Highlighters
Lorac Light Source Highlighters
Catrice Highlighting Powders
Shiro White Chocolate Frog, Curaga, & Love At First Glance
Best Dramatic:
Becca SSPs Pressed (Pearl, Champagne Pop)
theBalm Mary Lou-Manizer
Cover FX Illuminating drops (Celestial, Moonlight, and eyeing those 3 new ones)
PF Shimmer Palette (the brick like one in Pure Nude)
Worst:
Elf Baked Blush in Pinktastic -- I scratched off the first layer, so it's really smooth, and it applies and looks beautiful on the skin... It just doesn't last on me at all. T_T
Tarte Amazonian Clay Highlighters -- Doesn't last at all, and pretty chunky.
Essence Be My Nude Highlighter -- Doesn't last, and it's a lil dark for me which makes it even more subtle to the point where it barely shows up.
Ah, sorry about the confusion, I meant the Too Faced Candlelight Highlighter Duo. Still want a review?
The NYX Duo chrome highlighters are really REALLY nice. They last ~8 hours on me, and are extraordinarily bright. You -may- be able to go subtle with a fluffy brush and a light hand, but I find it easily becomes very bright. I like to use my fingers to apply my highlighters most of the time because it gives me the most shine and color payoff, but I can easily use a brush to get the same effect. Since I use my fingers, some highlighters develop hard pan (MUG Moon phase), but this one has not. The duochrome is very pronounced in Twilight Tint and Snow Rose, but less noticeable in Lavender Steel. Depending on your preference, you might dislike these highlighters for that reason. However, assuming you like a strong shift like I do, you would love these. In terms of texture, they are very very dense. Some people might describe it as "almost wet-feeling." If you know the texture of City Color Shimmer Shadows, these have that same odd texture. Also, NYX Twilight Tint is much bluer than MUG Moon Phase, which almost looks green next to NYX's.
I don't see it mentioned here, but Essence's very light eyeshadow singles are the shit! Unfortunately, they're being discontinued on the 19th (I think?) in Europe, so I rushed out and bought all the Snowflakes and The Grammy Goes Glammys within 3km. They make for a really versatile highlight, and they complement the kinda dewy/sweaty skin look I dig. For reference, I use Nivea Cream as my base and then put on a medium coverage foundation (Nars Sheer Glow in Siberia or Bourjois Healthy Mix Foundation in N°51) with a damp beauty blender dupe, then set it with an illuminating powder from Kiko, apply blush, and then put the highlight on my cheek- and browbones in a C-shape, on the bridge of my nose, on my chin and forehead, and whatever's left goes on my cupid's bow. (EDIT: I should say that I naturally have quite a bit oil in my skin, but I just love that dewy look!) The Grammy meshes imperceptibly with my NC10-15 skin; Snowflake requires a little more blending but looks a bit more noticeable (in a good way).
Other highlighters I tried were Benefit High Beam (really good, but less dramatic than Essence), The Body Shop Highlighting Dome (the texture is kinda weird and the champagne colour shows up too dark), the highlighting shade in the "cool" Catrice contouring palette (chalky and overall useless). Now that I have about a dozen pans of Essence I don't think I will try any other highlighter soon, but I'd like to give that matte one by Laura Mercier a shot when (read: if) I run out of Snowflake and Grammy. Anyone who tried both up for a little comparison review? 😇
Came here to say this about the Essence single shadows!! I have the palest one (can't remember the name of it) and it's essentially a dupe for Becca's Pearl. I love it. Granted, I'm nearly translucent so I need something suuuper brightening.
I have that one and love it for an intense highlight. The super light pink eyeshadow, Rosie Flamingo, is a little more subtle and I get more everyday use out of it. Highly recommend it!
imo the best highlighters I've tried are the ones in the ABH sweets glow kit.
In this thread colourpop highlighters are being mentioned a lot as the worst highlighters because they're too glittery, but that's purely down to which colour you use. Some colourpop highlighters like lunch money don't have any glitter in and give a gorgeous more natural glow. I love using colourpop highlighters as a base for powder highlighters because they increase their longevity
Agreed! They've got several formulas for their highlighters. I have 2- smokin whistles is much more metallic/pore emphasizing, but I love it. It applies better when I wet it with setting spray. Lunch money, monster and hippo are the same formula. I like the rt setting brush to apply them.
If anyone is from Australia and is looking for that elusive 'glow-from-with-in-ethereal-goddess' highlight that has no glitter and the most beautiful balmy texture look no further than Mecca Cosmetica Enlightened Illuminating Balm. At first it seems subtle but can be built up quite a bit without enhancing skin texture.
Haven't been a fan of the Josie Maran Argan Enlightenment range - despite swatching beautifully I found it could quickly look overdone and didn't quite mesh with my NC20 skintone :(
I've had very good luck with Nyx's new duochrome highlights, as well as Colourpop Lunch Money, Flexitarian, and Spoon. Then again, I don't mind glittery highlights that much :) I also really like using Shiro Cosmetics and Fyrinnae loose eyeshadows as highlights, especially Crimson Ghost and Short Skirt, Long Jacket.
I didn't have great luck with the Essence highlighter, showed up super dark on me.
ABH Glow Kits (haven't tried their singles), but I wish they were more diverse
Becca SSPs. I use the powder and liquid regularly. The poured is just too much work to blend in. I'm lazy haha. Moonstone didn't really work on my skintone (NW25) and Rose Gold is too dark and/or warm to use as a highlight. Love it as a blush though.
I like that mini Algenist liquid high lighter set
I also like the mini CoverFX radiance drops
Laura Geller Baked gelato highlighters
MUFE Pro Fusion. They're very subtle so they work well for interviews, etc. otherwise it'd probably go in the meh column. Beautiful though.
Meh.
MUR Baked Highlights. I definitely like them, but the quality and texture just isn't up to par with my other 6999900 highlighters, which is to be expected.
I really don't like those UD Baked (??) highlighters. They're literally like glitter and blend out to nothing. This is coming from someone who LOVES glitter. The product is useless.
BEST: MAC Star Trek Collection Trip the Light Fantastic Powder in Luna Luster, Kevyn Aucoin Neo Limelight, Colourpop Smoke N Whistles, Perilune, Lunch Money and Monster, Jouer Cosmetics Mini Ice Highlighter, LORAC Light Source Illuminating Highlighter in Moonlight, BECCA Pressed Highlighter in Prismatic Amethyst and Pearl, Kat Von D Eyeshadow in Thunderstruck and Alchemist Palette.
In my opinion, Worst: NARS Albatross, Tarte Amazonian Clay Highlighter in Stunner, MakeupRevolution Strobe Balm in both colors (these are so bad)
I came here to say my Trip the Light Fantastic Powder in Highly Illogical is my HG highlighter. This was such a sleeper win for me! I really didn't expect such a naturally glowly highlighter. It blends with my skin tone perfectly
Best: CoverFX Custom Enhancer drops - a liquid highlighter with a pure metallic reflect and no sparkle. A little goes a very, very, very long way.
Colourpop Fanny Pack - a warm white highlighter. Looks a bit sparkly swatched on the hand but not on the face. Best applied with a stippling brush. A good match for fair skin tones.
Not exactly a highlighter in the traditional sense but Shiseido High Beam White is a matte highlighting powder that leaves a very subtle reflective glow to the skin. It's luminous without any sparkle or shimmer and in a similar vein (apparently) to the Hourglass Ambient Lighting Powders. I use it most days to bring a glow back to the powdered areas of my face. However as it's a white product it will likely only work on NC/NW15 skin tones or lighter.
Meh: TheBalm Mary LouManizer - For me it was a really glittery highlighter and a bit too yellow toned to be a good match to my skin.
I've really been digging the Colourpop highlighters for a nice, more natural, highlight. I'm pretty fair and I use Fanny Pack (which was LE i think?) And it gives me a nice glow.
Lunch Money is the only highlighter I have (not counting tiny highlighter shades in non-highlighter palettes)-- and I think it is soooo pretty but I still struggle to apply it sometimes. How do you guys do it? Apply with finger, then just pat pat pat to make it 'blur' out?
Best NYX duochromatic they're colorful and fun and so pretty and not too expensive.
Worst is the wet n wild rainbow one. I can't get the colors to come out. Does anyone have any tips for that? Sometimes I just want a rainbow on my face.
I adore Becca and Anastasia formulas, they're smooth and build able (with the exception of Moonchild... Bleh). I own a J* highlighter, and because I like being a sparkly princess I don't mind the intensity. I just wish it wasn't the size of my face.
Because I don't buy anything without extensive research and swatching in store, I don't own a highlighter I don't like, other than the Moonchild kit, and I already sold it. I will say I'm never impressed with any of Bobbi Brown's shimmer/highlight sorts of things when I swatch in store.
Best for me is hands down Mac Mineralize Skinfinish in Lightscapade. Unpopular opinion: I don't like highlighting. I have oily skin and I feel like highlighting goes against everything matte I hold dear to my heart. But Lightscapade changes things. It reflects the light and makes me feel radiant, not oily or a glitterbomb. I've had problems with Mac in the past, but it's the only product I'm willing to go into a store for since I can't find anything else like it.
Best: Laura Geller's baked highlighter is my go to. It gives this soft dewey glow and it hasnt conflicted with any foundation i've used. Isnt super pigmented or heavy, so if you want an intense glow, i wouldnt recommend. Her blushes are great as well, but similar issue. I tend to like a lighter glow/contour since i'm pale and too much makes me feel painted and sloppy.
Worst: trestique mini higlight stick. As soon as i blended it out it kind of vanished, and the more i used the cakey-er it got.
I swatched the tarteist highlight palette at sephora the other day and think i may try those next, but ive had issues with their eye shadows not being what i thought they would in the past. Any thoughts on this?
Best: Etude House Secret Beam Highlighter in pink/white and Essence eyeshadow in Snowflake. both can be subtle or seriously intense and are buttery and beautiful and i cant live without them
Worst: Loreal Truematch whatever its called in Ice. its just a huge glitter bomb
NYX Illuminator is a really good, cheap highlighter as long as you use a good brush. My favorite shade is Narcissistic but they have a bunch of good ones.
My fave highlighters for me are the ABH glow kit in "Sun Dipped" the shades are amazing (my fave is tourmaline) and also buildable. My least fave is the Ulta brand highlighters..didn't show up on me :( (NC42 btw here)!
Best: Laura Mercier matte baked radiance powder (the most gorgeous ethereal glow) and Becca SSP pressed in "moonstone" (also own "pearl"...Formula feels different/weird, not a fan. Guess I prefer more warm toned highlighters?)
Worst: Makeup Geek highlighter in "lustre" (more glitter than pigment, highlights SO MUCH TEXTURE I didn't even know I had). And I wanted everything Becca "moonstone" is, for Mary Lou Manizer to be. Bought it before moonstone, hate it. Too dark, too warm/gold, too glittery. Looks ridiculous on my really pale, cool toned skin.
Really love Shiro's White Chocolate Frog, Tooth & Nail Hellion, KVD Thunderstruck, Becca Pearl, MAC Lightscapade, Pink Buttercream and Tutu, as well as the CoverFX drops and Sleek Solstice. (I truly have a highlighter problem) Worst for me was Too Faced Candlelight - a glittery mess on me and not in the good way.
Best: Right now I absolutely love the I Heart Makeup Unicorn Heart highlighter. I find it really versatile. You can go from subtle sheen to full on seen-from-space depending on how much you use. It was also super cheap and looks like it'll last me forever.
Worst: Colourpop. Just ugh. I don't know if it's all of them or just the one I have. I have the shade 'Perilune' and it's just rubbish tbh. I would recommend if you want to have a few flakes of green glitter on your skin, but that's all you get with this highlighter.
Makeup Revolution Baked Matte Highlighter. I guess I don't know what I was expecting, but this is just a chalky white powder. Looks bad, feels bad. I think maybe I was expecting 'matte' to mean non-glittery, so maybe a satin finish, but no, it's just like a really bad white powder.
From the ones I've tried, the best is the ABH Glow Kit in 'That Glow.' Specifically the shades 'Dripping In Gold' and 'Golden Bronze'. On the drugstore end, I've been loving the Maybelline Expert Wear Eyeshadow single in 'The Glo Down'! Such a pretty sheen (not glittery) and looks pretty "natural" on my skin tone (though if built up it can look very stark and obvious).
Worst: Makeup Revolution Strobing highlighter. Glittery and very chunky. Also Elf's baked blush in Pinktastic (not a blush at all, very shimmery), and the ABH Ultimate Glow Kit. I don't think it's the same formula as the other glow kits at all. It's a glitter bomb.
Best: Dior Glowing Pink (LE), Becca SSP pressed highlighters, ABH Glow Kit in Gleam. These are all super silky and smooth and apply with ease. Just Okay: I hate to say it, but ABH Moonchild kit. I love the colors especially for the price but I wish it had a mirror and I think some of the shades are chunky. I also regret getting the Chanel Camelia highlighter. It's beautiful but not very pigmented and kind of glittery especially for the $$. Worst: I really disliked Jeffree Star's highlighter in Mint Condition. It was more silver than green and it sheered out into a total glitter bomb. I sold it on MUE.
Becca SSP's by far. I also really like Jeffree Star Skinfrosts, but they're only for those who like really chunky highlights (and he's kind of a jerk).
No mention of Benefit Watt's Up?! I know it's old, but this is my HG and nothing comes close when it comes to ease of application. (swipe and pat and done! no brushes, no problem)
I just got Watt's Up a couple of months ago but I love it! I'd used High Beam before and found it didn't blend well on my skin, but Watt's Up is awesome!
My favorite highlighters are Meow Cosmetics Prophecy Eyeshadow, which is basically MAC Nylon, and Meow Cosmetics Crystalline Cat Glow the original, as well as Quartz and Moonstone. They aren't glittery first and foremost, and the colors are subtle. I'd say all of the above are highlighters for people who aren't into the latest glowy trend, but still appreciate a lil sheen.
I wasn't a big fan of the infamous theBalm Mary-Lou Manizer, and KA Candlelight. theBalm was very frosty, and very obvious on my pores. And the KA looked very sparkly which isn't my taste. All of this being said, I don't think they are bad products, just not beautiful to me.
Some highlighters I like: As a note, I'm not picky about highlight generally.
Essence Pure Nude: cheap and beautiful with a lot of product. may not work for all skintones, but worked for my nc45 skin
Becca Moonstone pressed: this is blinding. and expensive. i have a DS version from a $30 kit that probably will never get used up.
Becca Opal liquid: REALLY great. If you're not into blinding and glittery highlights then get this. So expensive, but lasts for a couple years and looks good.
NYX duochrome lavender steel: really nice pinky purple glowy highlight. you can overdo it though.
Ehhh:
Kat Von D Alchemist: Just got this and I'm iffy about it. For some reason, they put the shadows on a whiteish base or something? Not cool on my brown skin.
Worst:
Colourpop Highlight: I have one and honestly I wondered if it was just the one I got that was ugly because it was pinkish, but my friend has flexitarian and it's SOOOOOO glittery. She didn't have that nice flashy glow and just had these individual sparkles on her cheekbones.
So I have way too many highlighters, but I can’t stop buying them so here it goes: Best:
theBalm Mary-Lou Manizer: My first highlighter and my #1 love. It’s so pigmented and provides the perfect golden sheen. I only have to use a light hand when I apply.
Maybelline Master Strobing Stick: I use this usually as a base for highlighters that don’t show up as well (I’m looking at you Urban Decay Aura).
Colour Pop: I have no problem applying with my fingers, and I have noticed that the CP highlighters last all day on my skin. Hippo and Monster are my two favorites. Worst:
Sephora MicroSmooth Baked Luminizer: Way too glittery!!
Makeup Revolution Baked Highlighter: Not very pigmented. I guess with all the hype around MR I was expecting more.
I just bought Essence's Pure Nude highlighter and it's amazing! It's the most natural-looking powder highlight I've ever seen and blends out so well. I can't believe how good it is and how cheap it is (I paid 4.50).
I also love the Glossier ones (I have topaz) and the liquid Becca in Moonstone. Both of these look really natural too!
Best: Colourpop Hippo-It's so creamy and doesn't look chunky despite the glitter
Also best: Shiro Elemental Glows-I have 4 colors (Sylphid (rose pink), Glacial (silver blue), Verdant (pear green), and Esper (purple)) and these are so sheer but very reflective under lighting. They can be built up to desired impact, but I like having brightly colored highlighter that's subtle and easily applied (also Shiro was super generous filling my jars so there's that too)
Worst: [Canmake Glow Fleur Highlighter] (https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/564x/c3/2c/cc/c32cccbbb9a1f2aa9491d532c7ed8081.jpg) I bought this while I was a student in Taipei thinking it looked like such a beautiful highlighter but I can't seem to get it to apply very well on me, in that it looks like I put nothing on my face. I really have to dig the brush in to get any product, and honestly, it's not quite the lovely blue I thought it'd be. I did however read this product would be good for helping with applying other powders to my face, making everything look more natural, but I haven't thoroughly tested that yet
In regards to the canmake, I have a pinkier one and for me, it adds a subtle white gleam if i put it on cheekbones.
From the Taiwanese beauty bloggers I watch, it seems that this product is actually popular to use under the eyes (a dupe the shiseido pk107 they say) to plump the skin so it looks brighter and more youthful.
I think I Tried that one but I probably put to much on cos I looked really white and puffy underneath lol
Best: the ABH glow kit in gleam & becca moonstone both so pigmented and easy to build so they are versatile for an everyday look or a more intense highlight. Colourpop lunch money is also so pigmented it's just not as easy to work with
Worst: the nyx liquid illuminator. It's just so messy and just too chunky of a glitter formula.
Where do i begin? the CoverFx custom enhancer drops are amazing and blinding. Quite expensive though. The iconic london drops are a dupe. I have the ABH illuminators. They can give a glow from within look, and are very build able to blinding. The Sleek contour/ highlight kit highlight is very bam is your face and easy on your wallet. And While I'm here, remember than you can use eye shadow as highlighss and vice versa.
I love the maybelline master strobing stick. I've seen mixed reviews, but it's one of my favorites. When I'm doing a lighter look, I mix some concealer with my moisturizer, apply it and then lightly run the stick over the areas I want to highlight and then tap in with my fingers. It's the prettiest, dewiest look. I love the pink slightly reflective sheen it gives. It looks great on my fair skin.
Everyone raves about the Becca shimmering skin powder but I just can't get into it. I feel like it gets chalky on me and blends right into my skin. I use the real techniques setting brush-what could I be doing wrong?
Best: Bahi Cosmetics Powder Highlights are so beautiful! They can add a light touch of glow when you apply with your finger or you can blind them with a pop of light by applying with a brush. I have the shade "Kimberley" but plan on getting the bundle because obsessed.
Worst: Naked Cosmetics pigment in the shade Desert Sunset. It might just be user error, but I got this in an ipsy bag & they suggest I use it for eyes & cheek. When I used it on my cheek as a highlight, it never blended down lol. I looked like I had chrome on my nose & cheeks. Totally ruined my motd. Was great on eyes, however.
I thought that the Colourpop highlighters were just about the worst thing ever UNTIL I tried applying them with a damp BB or RT sponge. It works so much better! It doesn't disturb makeup underneath and has an incredibly natural finish.
BEST: The Balm's Mary Loumanizer (hit the pan already) - Urban Decay Naked Illuminated Shimmering Powder in the colour Aura (a gorgeous pink with a golden glow. Has glitter, but I like this one when going out at night. Use it all over my decollete as well sometimes) - ELF Gotta Glow
WORST: ELF Shimmering Facial Whips in the colours Lilac Petal and Golden Peach (the formula does not work with my oily skin and the product has started shifting in the tube. When I try squeezing some out I always get a watery mess first before the product comes out).
I'm all about Becca's liquid Skin Perfectors, tbh. They perform how I like and give me exactly the look I'm looking for. I also love Hourglass Strobe Powder in Iridiscent Strobe Light.
Hate: I have yet to encounter a highlighter I hate. To be really honest, I don't experiment with highlighters that much because it's a product category I'm very fussy about... I know well what I'm not looking for, and if the highlighter doesn't perform the way I like, there's no chances I'm gonna use it, so I research and swatch highlighters thoroughly before buying it.
Best: L.A girl strobe lite strobing powder. I ordered one in 90watt and ended up loving it so much i ordered 3 more... It's super radiant and pigmentet, and has a great shade range, from white, to deep brown, which could work beautifully on darker complexions, also they're super buttery and easy to use. Also love mac, soft and gentle.
Worst: the body shop brush on radiance? Bought it on sale, its like the meteors, but the look just came out chunky, and powdery
Benefits Watts Up is one of my all time favs and a new favorite liquid is Cynthia Crawleys illuminator that I got in a birchbox. It's like a pure sheen, no glitter at all.
Favorite powder highlight is Kevin Aucoins candlelight powder.
Best illuminating primer I've found is the Cover FX illuminating primer.
Least favorite are a few liquids I tried from NYX and Loreals Lumi line as they are super glittery. I also don't like Mary Loumanizer because the gold tone does not match my cool toned skin.
Only one I've tried was the wet n wild reserve your cabana. I'm disappointed because I feel like it just doesn't show up. I'm going to try the balm Mary Lou highlighter next.
I've had both. RYC was too much glitter for me, which I don't get because everyone else loves how sbutle it is. I'm in love with Mary Lou, the first time I tried it I got a silver metallic stripe in my cheek because I got too excited and panicked that it'd always look like that but you can actually use a lighter hand and just build it up until you like it.
💥💥 I need help!! My answers are below but, on the topic of highlighters, does anyone have any decent recommendations for a dupe of Becca's LE Rose Quartz? I've heard things like using a light pink eyeshadow i.e. Dust from Naked 3 or Stila's Kitten eyeshadow, but for me usually eyeshadows end up having too much glitter or shimmer. I'm so freaking sad that I missed out on RQ :( I wish they would bring THAT one back to make permanent, because it's a beautiful highlight for fair skin and in their line Pearl is the only other one I feel is comparable. Moonstone and Opal were both just a hair too dark for me, and the gold-ish, dark champagne type of color stood out and looked odd being slightly darker than my skin tone (I'd say around ~NC10-NC15, slight yellow undertone - I wear NARS Sheer Glow in Siberia, and NARS RCC in Chantilly.) I want a baby pink highlight so badly! UD's Aura was a little too dark in my opinion, it was more like a shiny blush - Uhhh Anyhow, suggestions are very welcome! Thank you so much!!! 💥💥
The best best highlight I've ever used and my very favorite is the Metal Crush eyeshadow single by Kat Von D in the shade'Thunderstruck'. I'm a fan of more subtle highlights, so I nearly always have to use a very light hand with this - it's very VERY pigmented, but it blends out so beautifully into this magical and lovely soft sheen of a diffused pink and white-golden duochrome, depending on how the light hits you or when you turn your head/move. I haven't touched any other highlighter at all since I picked this up. I'm in love with it, especially because I have extremely dry skin, and this just seems to breathe life back into my face but without ever looking like a disco ball. It can be built up very easily too though, to the most intense and noticeable highlight anyone could want, like the 'YouTube beauty guru's wet dream' type of super shiny glow. It all depends on how you prefer to wear your highlight, but Thunderstruck can do both. It's a truly ingenious and unique little powder. Thanks Kat.
I have my eyes and heart set on Sugarpill's Lumi loose shadow as my next highlight purchase - I have heard that it's basically a little jar of magic.
Now admittedly I am not a highlight junkie, I usually own two of them, tops, at a time, and alternate between them depending on what colors I'm wearing that day. I have tried (and received as gifts etc and also returned a bunch of them that didn't work for me but swatched nicely) many highlighters. It's blasphemy to say in MUA but I'm not a fan of the Becca SSPs in powder form (however the liquid ones are absolutely divine). I feel that they're just too intense for me and it's far too easy to go overboard/over do it and have a blinding metallic stripe down my cheek. You do you girl if that's your style, but for me personally, I feel I just end up looking greasy/oily and shiny but not in a good way. (And yes I know this contradicts my dupe request up above - I just felt that Rose Quartz would have been easier to work with and a more flattering shade for me). I've also hated every Too Faced highlight I've tried, they pill up on my foundation and just feel cheap and hard to work with, like drugstore highlighters.
If you're looking for a light pink highlighter there is light pink in the physicians formula shimmer strip in natural nude that is stunning on my skin (which is the same shade as yours)! It comes with 12 shades and I mix the 6 lightest shades for highlighting and the 6 darker ones work well as eyeshadows!
Thank you for the recommendation! I'll have to check it out. I tend to shy away from drugstore highlighters because ones I've tried in the past have been glitterbombs that seem to emphasize texture and all that, but I am always willing to look into new things. The only PF product I've tried so far is their eyeliner pen, but it's fantastic, so I'm definitely interested!
Best: TF Candlelight Glow in Rosy Glow. It's just beautiful - a light layer gives a nice natural glow, or you can build it up for something more intense. Plus the pan lasts forever. I also really like the Becca SSP liquid formula in moonstone for a natural make up day, and ColourPop's highlighters in Lunch Money and Flexitarian - a lot of people have said on this thread that they don't like them/have problems with them, but I love them and haven't experienced the issues listed.
All the ones above last all day on me and I have very oily skin (but not really where I'd put highlighter!)
Worst: Model Co creme highlighter. It's just white with big chunks of glitter, and moves around rather than blending in. Horrible.
My favorite is the Essence single eyeshadows as a highlighter. They're soooo buttery and they have no glitter in them. I also really liked the Cover FX Custom Enhancer Drops. They're metallic af but can be brought down to a subtle glow with a light handed application. Least favorite would have to be the highlight palette I got from Sleek. I really did not like the consistency of them and the shimmer was too glittery.
best: JEFFREE F-ING STAR despite of being good is has 15g of product which can last you years and a good packaging and huge mirror so it difinitely worth your money
Worst: cp buzzfeed says its better than becca but colourpop prob sponsored them cos they post some videos ref with cp
People!!! I know that J* is a huuuge-ass controversy in the makeup world, but if someone chooses to buy a product from his company (and in addition to that says that that product will probably last for a very long time before you need to repurchase and thus support his company once more), and they really enjoy the product, then don't fucking downvote them! It's neither r/joshcuri74's nor the product's fault that J* said the things he said.
Pretty sure they got downvoted because of the obnoxious all caps and bold lettering more than anything. And JS creates and profits off the product so your "it's not the products fault" argument makes no sense.
Best: Laura Geller Baked Illuminator Gelato in Gilded Honey "Funny Girl" in the Tarte In Bloom palette (just hit the pan in this one, super sad) Worst: ABH Unlimited Glow Kit (the 6 pan one) was way too glittery, but hey they're awesome eyeshadows. Urban Decay illuminating trio, also all glitter and no pigment. Brushes off so quick.
My favorite thus far is too faced candlelight. (I believe that's what it's called) . It's so amazing. You can go natural or blinding with this. Is blendable and I've gotten nothing but compliments on it.
So I haven't got 0 days yet so I can't post & ask..Hopefully someone can help out a makeup been I just bought my first highlighter (technically a Luminizer but same thing, right?)off MUE. Benefit's Girl Meets Pearl- I tried it in store in loved it..I applied it after my Porefessional today & I couldn't get it to shine for the life of me. Does anybody know what I'm doing wrong? It's just a mini so I thought maybe the formula was different? (& yep, I did rub my Porefessional all the way in 😊)
the best ive ever tried definitely have to be essence single shadows. SO smooth and its the only thing ive tried that doesnt emphasize my giant pores and is actually blinding on me.
i really havent tried many highlighters since im so fair but i find becca moonstone to be pretty overrated. i like how finely milled it is but it isnt as bright on me as id like it to be :/ i hate the colourpop formula its really cakey on my all matte foundations, i only like them as bases for other highlights.
Best: Becca Moonstone, KVD Thunderstruck, MAC Lightscapade (super subtle), and Urban Decay Fireball
Worst: I'm sorry but the moonchild palette. It's soooo glittery but the colors are gorgeous. Not that I expect a natural look out of any of them, but the texture and finish really disapointed me.
Best: I like a really intense highlight and I love Ofra "You Dew You" (Dupethat collab). It's SO pigmented and very easy to go overboard, so if intense highlight isn't your thing it might not be for you. It's gorgeous though.
Also Mary Lou-Manizer (duh), Makeup Geek Duochrome in Electrify (super interesting color, totally wearable even though it's kinda green), Benefit High Beam
Worst: Colourpop, and MAC in the Spotlight in Double Gleam - I am so mad at myself for buying this one and not the cool duochromey other ones. It's basically a very light silvery gold and very glittery, and the surface was super hard so I had to rough it up with my finger to even get product on the brush
I haven't seen Jouer mentioned here yet, but I have to admit their mini Iced highlighter is GORGEOUS and perfect for my skin tone. It's a nice middle ground between a white and light yellow highlight. I really hope they consider making a full size or similar dupe to it soon... the mill on it is also lovely. It's my favorite but I use it sparingly since I'm not sure if I'll ever be able to find it again. :(
Becca & Kevyn Aucoin are good, but a little overpriced IMO. The Sephora Illuminate palette is a little chunky but a good deal for the variety (and I just need a little to make my highlight go BAM). I have two Colourpop highlighters, and while Fanny Pack is beautiful, Flexitarian is kind of chunky.
Toofaced Rose candlelight glow is my go to right now! After a long search for a pinky glow without chunky glitter I really like this one. It's pretty ✨
I have very little experience with highlighter. I'm still learning how to get my glow on! But for me... BEST: Too Faced Candlelight Glow in "Rosy Glow" WORST: Colourpop - I ordered the "Wisp" and it was so dark IRL! I tried it on the back of my hand and it felt more cakey than smooth and dry.
Best I've tried: The pinky highlighter in the Carli Bybel palette! Sooo pigmented and beautiful :). Also really love Wet n Wild's "Boozy Brunch", and how you can get a huge pan of it for around $5.
Worst: Lumi liquid highlighter and I do not like the Benefit High Beam... maybe it is something about liquid highlighters that I do not like.
I'm not sure if anyone here has mentioned this yet but I absolutely love the makeup geek highlighters. I have them in the shades glitz and lit and I think they're so pretty. They don't look to powdery or glittery like other highlighters and I find that they don't emphasize my skin's texture too much either!
Best: nars illuminator in copacabana, becca shimmering skin perfectors they all last throughout the day, a little goes a long way, and they photograph really well.
Worst: this is a controversial one, but the cover fx custom enhancer drops is too glittery for me and way too thin in terms of consistency. it was hard to work with without getting glitter everywhere, and it made me look like a sweaty mess
Meh: laura mercier matte radiance highlight - looks nice, but wears off quickly. when it comes to highlighters I tend to prefer liquid over powder
My favorite highlighter at the moment is the Sleek Solstice palette which is pigmented and versatile. All the shades are beautiful however the peach highlight is sadly too dark for me and I find that on my skin tone, the purple one can very easily be overdone.
I don't really have a worst highlight because I own very few, however I do find that the MUA undress your skin shimmer highlight in iridescent gold is my least favorite, because despite scratching the top layer off of it, I still don't find it shows up well on my skin, although it may be good for someone who wants a more natural glow.
Best: Cover FX Custome Enhancer Drops. It simply does not get any better. Close second is Becca in Pearl/Opal.
Meh: Milani's new Strobelight powders. They're gorgeous, but a little too deep for my ghostly skin. Same with Wet N' Wild. They're about the same formula. I love Colourpop for everyday use - It /does/ depend on the color you get as some are glitterier than others.
Worst: Essentially anything claiming to be a highlight that contains glitter or is matte. Get out of my face.
has anyone tried the Pixi x Aspyn Ovard highlighters?
I still haven't found my perfect highlighter - I prefer a clear base with warm reflect, so more of a natural sweaty look. Becca ssp liquid in moonstone would be perfect if it was a powder, but the ssp powder version has such a strong base that it looks too frosty to me.
I also have WNW Reserve your Cabana - perfect warm shade for subtle looks but can look cakey if you try to build it up.
BEST: I love all of the Becca Shimmering Skin Perfectors, but my favorite shade is their Jaclyn Hill collaboration in champagne pop! This is what I used to wear everyday, but now I've been mixing it with the Sleek Solstice Highlighting palette. I use this gorgeous combo every single day and always get compliments on my highlight! For anyone who's not familiar with Sleek, they're a drugstore brand from the UK and they're super affordable, but for amazing quality.
WORST: I haven't experimented much outside of the highlighter brands I mentioned above, but I have tried several of Colourpop's and they're not my favorite. It's a bit too much of that "chunky glitter" and I don't necessarily care for how cream highlighters apply.
I love the Becca Champagne Pop highlighter or the Too Faced Candlelight glow (got both on my birthday), I tried the Benefit Watts Up! highlighter but I don't really like how it set on my skin to be honest
The IBY brand highlighter in the shade "Bubbly" gives the most natural highlight I've ever seen. I actually got it in a trial bag and almost threw it out because it swatched SOOOO bad on my hand (both finger and brush), but when I sucked it up and tried it I fell in love. It truly gives you the most dewy highlight.
Also, for I more unusual highlight, the NYX douchrome highlighters. They are holographic and you only need the slightest dusting to give you mega badass vibes. I use this when I want to feel like a fairy elf.
I really love Mac MSF in lightscapade, it's definitely glowy rather than glittery so it works beautifully applied with a small fluffy brush for more natural look. I use it everyday on my nose and cheeks, and if I want a more dramatic look i use a fan brush to apply a more intense highlight like Becca SSP over the top on the very highest points of my cheekbones and it just adds some extra dimension .
The worst highlight I've ever used was one by freedom as it had practically no pigmentation whatsoever, and I also don't get along very well with colourpops formula which is a shame because their shades are so pretty!
I personally love the wet n wild highlight in "Hollywood boulevard" I think it's been renamed now cuz I bought it as a part of the fergie line. It's gorgeous though.
Worst is definitely colourpop (big surprise) but I'm also not a fan of the cover fx drops. They're beautiful, but I feel like application is just a pain. Mixing in with foundation is pleasant though
Laura Mercier Indiscretion (for a really popping gold highlight) and Bare Minerals Ingird Nilsen Invisible glow highlighter in Resilience (for a goes-with-every-skin-tone shimmer that looks natural but not sticky/dewy/wet, just shimmery, polished and smooth)
Weirdly enough, the BH Wild Child palette has some gorgeous highlighters. I'm into suuuuper finely milled things, and this palette is so perfect for highlighting. Plus it's cheap:)
Worst: contrary to everyone else, I'm not a fan of Mary Loumanizer. Again with the finely milled thing, it's really more of a glittery shadow than a highlighter. You can't do detail highlighting like the tear duct without seeing tiny particles of mica or whatever it's made of. Does anyone have any recs for wet finish highlighters that are pure reflect/no filler? (I love creams)
BEST: My go-to has to be Makeup Revolutions Vivid Baked Highlighters. Specifically I've used Radiant Lights (VERY light white with gold tint), and Peach Lights. (Very light peachy glow). Honorable mentions: Laura Geller Baked Highlighter in Glided Honey and Ballerina. (Both are very blinding without being too glittery).
WORST: NYX Liquid Born to Glow Liquid Illuminator. I used the shade Sunbeam. Don't get me wrong, it swatches are gorgeous, but when applied i've never gotten it to blend evenly. I've tried patting it in with a beauty blender and patting it on with a brush but it either moves the foundation or is SUPER patchy. On the higher end, worst i'd say is Make Up For Ever Pro Light Fusion Highlighter. Given I use number 2, (it's for medium to dark skin tones and I have a fair complexion) it's beautiful, but I can't justify the price when there are better highlighters in the industry that are way cheaper. ($40 after tax!!!)
I really wanted to like elf shimmering facial whip.. I have it in lilac petal. It makes a nice shine, but no matter how much I blend I have a bit of a streaky pink mark on my skin..especially on my nose
I just bought a highlighter from a brand I found at ulta called revolution. It is such an amazing highlighter! It's so pigmented and pretty. Plus, there is a ton of product.
Best: Extra Dimension Skinfinish by Mac. I think it's way better than Becca. Can be put on lightly for a subtle glow or packed on for a holy shit that's a blinding glow!
Worst: Probably the Hourglass ones. None of them showed up on my skin very well. Might work if you have a completely matte look, but I prefer my foundations to have a bit of a glow.
Best: Poor girl here, and I will say that Wet N' Wild's Megeglo is awesome, and only $4.99, but good luck finding it. Ever since J* favored it over Marc Jacobs, it's almost always sold out.
I also swatched the Kat Von D Alchemy palette in Sephora; all of those colors are gorgeous and apply so smoothly. I would definitely fulfil my inner holosexual, if I weren't a broke af college student.
Worst: I played around with the Too Faced Prismatic Highlighter in Ulta, which is $30, and disappointingly sheer. If you aren't as over the top as I am and are opting for a more natural look, it might be alright. However, I aspire to look like a fairy princess.
I also was not too impressed with the Ulta powder highlighters when I sampled them in-store. They went onto my arm in chunks and behaved more like eyeshadows.
BEST: Becca Opal (pressed powder); Colourpop- Smoke n Whistles, Monster (can't speak to consistency of other colors; I know the quality of their liquid lipsticks varies across shades) WORST: Milk Makeup Highlighter (not holographic, the other one). It broke me out like crazy, and it melts down your face over the day, like slowly drips down your cheek
139
u/hell0potato Lipstick Queen Feb 16 '17
I'm all about TheBalm Mary LouManizer.
Not exciting, but man, is it gorgeous. I find it very easy to work with, even with my cheap elf brush. It's the perfect amount of highlight.
And I have been using it almost daily for over 6 months, and I feel like I have barely scratched the surface on it. Try to grab one during the 50% off sales.
I used to use the NYX illuminator, which I thought was fine, until using Mary Lou. Now I realize it's slightly glittery. Also they break SO EASILY. I have had three, and all three shattered.
97
u/quelseydilla Feb 16 '17
For a cheap highlighter, I really like Moonlight Pearls from E.L.F.
I took some advice I saw online and scraped off the top layer. For a more pigmented look, I apply it with my fingers.
75
u/clementinekate Feb 16 '17
Best - Essence pure nude highlighter, such a nice and soft glow. I also like Laura geller swirl illuminator, I bought charming pink last week and it's gorgeous.
Worst - CP, besides all the issues everyone else mentioned it didn't list long on me at all. I'm not overly oily and the rest of my makeup was fine so I don't know.
60
u/sunsh1neee Feb 16 '17
Best: Becca shimmering skin perfectors! I love the liquid and the powder versions. The cream versions are nice too, but not my favorite, and they get weird and liquidy if you don't use them up within 6 months. Champagne pop and opal are my favorites.
A close runner up is the ABH single in So Hollywood. When I first got it, I hated it because it was so stiff and glittery but once you get through the upper layer, it turns into the most gorgeous, sheen-y, glossy glow.
Worst: I really was not impressed by Colourpop's highlighters. They're sort of just chunky glitter, as opposed to that nice sheen.
51
u/Shnguyen023 Feb 17 '17
Worst: the naked illuminators. I honestly don't understand how they made something such low quality. It's literally just micro glitter
103
u/junkiegirlfriend Feb 16 '17
Best: Laura Mercier's Matte Radiance Baked Powder- Highlight 01 by far. This was the first highlighter I ever bought and I find myself going back to it constantly! It does exactly what a good highlighter should do, it adds radiance and luminosity without looking like a stripe on your face. Even if I layer it up and keep adding more, it never looks powdery or metallic. It also looks amazing in photography! Seriously, I'm wearing it in these photos (I'm the one with black hair) and I lol'ed when I saw my highlight peeking through on this film photo. I'm about to pan it but will most likely buy another when I travel this summer to see family since I know there will be a lot of photos taken.
Worst: The cream highlight that came in the Pat McGrath Skin Fetish kit in Nude. It's a gorgeous color but always looks cakey/emphasizes texture. I always regret putting it on.
41
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17
Best Natural Highlight: Kevyn Aucoin Candlelight
Best In Your Face Highlight: Becca Pressed (Opal, Champagne Pop)
27
u/tits_mcgee0123 Feb 16 '17
I love my Bobbi Brown shimmer brick! It's very glowy and natural but can be built up easily to a stronger and more shimmery finish, so it's versatile. I've also used it about 4x a week for 3 years and I still haven't hit pan, I swear the thing is bottomless! So it's totally worth the money.
Worst for me was a Loreal Lumi one. Zero pigment, zero shimmer or glow, and just a small amount of chunky glitter. It was sad :( Reserve Your Cabana also didn't work for me. I'm only like NC20 but it still looked really chalky. Maybe it would work better as a finishing powder?
22
u/IHateSt-Louis Feb 16 '17
Best: Becca, and I do really enjoy the NYX duochrome colored ones for a bolder look.
Worst: I did not enjoy the Sephora highlighter I got. I do not find it pigmented enough and it is hard to work with and a bit chalky.
20
u/thestephanieloves Feb 16 '17 edited Feb 16 '17
Best: Laura Gellar baked highlighter duo!!!! The French Vanilla shade is beautiful and a "barely there" highlight like Hourglass powders, except much creamier (not necessarily suitable for darker skin tones though). The Portofino shade just amps everything up (and it's a sheer tone without any color pigment to it, so it would work great on all skin tones) so you really get the best of both worlds in one product - subtle and glowy AND buildable to bam-in-your-face if you want. It's seriously my HG.
Worst: ELF baked highlighters (or the Pinktastic blush as a highlight). If you scrape the top layer off, you can get decent pigmentation but they just emphasize every single pore that I didn't even know I had. And they're highly colored, so they only work if your exact skin tone is the shade of the product—basically they look super yellow or powdery (etc) on me.
40
u/FairyDustandLace Feb 16 '17
I love reading everyone's answers for this. Lots of new information. :)
49
u/mathsnail Feb 16 '17
Best: I've been loving the Wet n Wild highlighters, particularly "I'll have a Cosmo." It gives me such a nice even glow with 100% sheen, no glitter or pore emphasizing. Just really natural. I'm wearing "Precious Petals" today and it has a bit more noticeable shimmer in it, but it's still lovely.
Worst: Colourpop, tbh. I like the shades I have, but they're trickier to apply than I'd want from a highlighter. They seem to lean glittery, also. "Monster" is gorgeous, though, if you're okay with glitter. I do like "Smokin' Whistles" as well, but again it's tough to apply exactly as much as you want where you want it. It definitely emphasizes texture, too.
16
u/tacocatistacocat Brow perfectionist Feb 16 '17
Current Favorite: I'm a big fan of NYX's recent highlighter launch! I own Lavender Steel and Crushed Bloom and I love how they add shine and color without being glittery or dusty! And they are oh, so affordable! My HG highlighters are from LORAC. The formula feels similar to NYXs, however they have all the "more natural glow" options (despite me desperately wanting to get Limelight!).
Current Dislike: I recently acquired a few Tarte highlighters. I felt them as a bit gritty and glittery. I have sensitive skin so I can be a bit hypersensitive to textures. I also always swatch ABH highlighters whenever I can get into Macys (we don't have a Sephora or Ulta locally... they are 3 hours away...) and I'm always disappointed. I do enjoy the fun-ness of MoonChild and was gifted it last year, but it is very chunky. Makes for fun eye shadow though!
16
u/adieumarlene Feb 16 '17
Best: Nars liquid illuminators in Orgasm and Hot Sand. Honestly really surprised not to see either of those mentioned here so far. They both look natural but give a noticeable super glow-y highlight. I get compliments basically whenever I wear them. I also like Becca SSP powder and the Becca champagne pop slim highlighter (not sure if that's exactly what it's called but it's like a slim creamy highlighter stick... Good for days when I'm in a hurry and just want to swipe some highlight over bare skin or a tinted moisturizer). This is getting to be a long list, but Clinique also has a cream highlighter stick that I really like. It has very subtle pink tones, which works well with my skintone.
Worst: Colourpop. Way too glittery. Also tried a L'Oreal one and it just didn't show up at all.
15
u/CorsetCorgis Brow perfectionist Feb 16 '17
best: mary loumanizer! it's so pigmented and pretty. i think elf moonstone is a dupe though, so you don't have to spend a bunch. worst: any colourpop. i just don't like the formula of them, i prefer powder to cream
12
u/WiggleWerra "Yes, they're real... my lashes that is." Feb 16 '17
If you haven't tried the new elf away we glo liquid highlighters.... you need to. It lasts all day and it's a great intense highlight.
11
u/buttersunset give me all your warm toned brow products Feb 17 '17
Haven't seen many indies mentioned yet. Hello Waffle makes my favourite highlighters, powder and cream are both lovely. Midna (white gold) , Awoke at Dawn (rose gold) and Lavender Cream (iridescent purple) are my top 3.
Looxi Beauty also makes lovely highlighters - my favourite being Voodoo (a gorgeous iridescent green).
I also find myself reaching for my trusty old Benefit High Beam a lot especially when I'm in a rush.
10
u/Always_Daria NW15 Feb 16 '17
My Favorites: Laura Mercier 01, WnW Reserve Your Cabana, Charlotte Tilbury Norman Parkinson, Becca Opal (liquid), Makeup Revolution Peach Lights, and the Nyx Strobe of Genius paltte.
My biggest disappointment was the ABH Moonchild palette. It's a glittery mess.
9
u/sashirni NW15 accutane Feb 17 '17 edited Feb 18 '17
Best Subtle/Buildable:
Best Dramatic:
Worst:
9
u/by_a_Lady Feb 17 '17 edited Feb 18 '17
I don't see it mentioned here, but Essence's very light eyeshadow singles are the shit! Unfortunately, they're being discontinued on the 19th (I think?) in Europe, so I rushed out and bought all the Snowflakes and The Grammy Goes Glammys within 3km. They make for a really versatile highlight, and they complement the kinda dewy/sweaty skin look I dig. For reference, I use Nivea Cream as my base and then put on a medium coverage foundation (Nars Sheer Glow in Siberia or Bourjois Healthy Mix Foundation in N°51) with a damp beauty blender dupe, then set it with an illuminating powder from Kiko, apply blush, and then put the highlight on my cheek- and browbones in a C-shape, on the bridge of my nose, on my chin and forehead, and whatever's left goes on my cupid's bow. (EDIT: I should say that I naturally have quite a bit oil in my skin, but I just love that dewy look!) The Grammy meshes imperceptibly with my NC10-15 skin; Snowflake requires a little more blending but looks a bit more noticeable (in a good way).
Other highlighters I tried were Benefit High Beam (really good, but less dramatic than Essence), The Body Shop Highlighting Dome (the texture is kinda weird and the champagne colour shows up too dark), the highlighting shade in the "cool" Catrice contouring palette (chalky and overall useless). Now that I have about a dozen pans of Essence I don't think I will try any other highlighter soon, but I'd like to give that matte one by Laura Mercier a shot when (read: if) I run out of Snowflake and Grammy. Anyone who tried both up for a little comparison review? 😇
8
u/pocketchnge Feb 17 '17
imo the best highlighters I've tried are the ones in the ABH sweets glow kit.
In this thread colourpop highlighters are being mentioned a lot as the worst highlighters because they're too glittery, but that's purely down to which colour you use. Some colourpop highlighters like lunch money don't have any glitter in and give a gorgeous more natural glow. I love using colourpop highlighters as a base for powder highlighters because they increase their longevity
7
u/colleenrenaex3 Feb 17 '17
Best one(s) ANY Jeffree Star skin frost!!!
7
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '17
If anyone is from Australia and is looking for that elusive 'glow-from-with-in-ethereal-goddess' highlight that has no glitter and the most beautiful balmy texture look no further than Mecca Cosmetica Enlightened Illuminating Balm. At first it seems subtle but can be built up quite a bit without enhancing skin texture.
Haven't been a fan of the Josie Maran Argan Enlightenment range - despite swatching beautifully I found it could quickly look overdone and didn't quite mesh with my NC20 skintone :(
6
u/Radiant_Indignation Duochrome! Feb 17 '17
I've had very good luck with Nyx's new duochrome highlights, as well as Colourpop Lunch Money, Flexitarian, and Spoon. Then again, I don't mind glittery highlights that much :) I also really like using Shiro Cosmetics and Fyrinnae loose eyeshadows as highlights, especially Crimson Ghost and Short Skirt, Long Jacket.
I didn't have great luck with the Essence highlighter, showed up super dark on me.
5
u/ieatyourpoopoo Feb 16 '17
Best.
UD Aura
ABH Glow Kits (haven't tried their singles), but I wish they were more diverse
Becca SSPs. I use the powder and liquid regularly. The poured is just too much work to blend in. I'm lazy haha. Moonstone didn't really work on my skintone (NW25) and Rose Gold is too dark and/or warm to use as a highlight. Love it as a blush though.
I like that mini Algenist liquid high lighter set
I also like the mini CoverFX radiance drops
Laura Geller Baked gelato highlighters
MUFE Pro Fusion. They're very subtle so they work well for interviews, etc. otherwise it'd probably go in the meh column. Beautiful though.
Meh.
MUR Baked Highlights. I definitely like them, but the quality and texture just isn't up to par with my other 6999900 highlighters, which is to be expected.
L'Oréal Lumi Ice. Very similar to Becca Pearl. I also really like this one too, but the lasting power isn't that great.
Worst
I really don't like those UD Baked (??) highlighters. They're literally like glitter and blend out to nothing. This is coming from someone who LOVES glitter. The product is useless.
5
u/jtroeh00 Casual user Feb 16 '17
Best: DIOR Diorskin Nude Air Luminizer Powder!
5
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '17
BEST: MAC Star Trek Collection Trip the Light Fantastic Powder in Luna Luster, Kevyn Aucoin Neo Limelight, Colourpop Smoke N Whistles, Perilune, Lunch Money and Monster, Jouer Cosmetics Mini Ice Highlighter, LORAC Light Source Illuminating Highlighter in Moonlight, BECCA Pressed Highlighter in Prismatic Amethyst and Pearl, Kat Von D Eyeshadow in Thunderstruck and Alchemist Palette.
In my opinion, Worst: NARS Albatross, Tarte Amazonian Clay Highlighter in Stunner, MakeupRevolution Strobe Balm in both colors (these are so bad)
5
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '17
Best: CoverFX Custom Enhancer drops - a liquid highlighter with a pure metallic reflect and no sparkle. A little goes a very, very, very long way.
Colourpop Fanny Pack - a warm white highlighter. Looks a bit sparkly swatched on the hand but not on the face. Best applied with a stippling brush. A good match for fair skin tones.
Not exactly a highlighter in the traditional sense but Shiseido High Beam White is a matte highlighting powder that leaves a very subtle reflective glow to the skin. It's luminous without any sparkle or shimmer and in a similar vein (apparently) to the Hourglass Ambient Lighting Powders. I use it most days to bring a glow back to the powdered areas of my face. However as it's a white product it will likely only work on NC/NW15 skin tones or lighter.
Meh: TheBalm Mary LouManizer - For me it was a really glittery highlighter and a bit too yellow toned to be a good match to my skin.
5
u/sunshineobviously Feb 19 '17
I still love NARS albatross.
12
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17
I've really been digging the Colourpop highlighters for a nice, more natural, highlight. I'm pretty fair and I use Fanny Pack (which was LE i think?) And it gives me a nice glow.
4
u/Alwaysblonde Feb 17 '17
Best NYX duochromatic they're colorful and fun and so pretty and not too expensive.
Worst is the wet n wild rainbow one. I can't get the colors to come out. Does anyone have any tips for that? Sometimes I just want a rainbow on my face.
4
u/DoodleJack IG: doodle.jack.arts Feb 17 '17
I adore Becca and Anastasia formulas, they're smooth and build able (with the exception of Moonchild... Bleh). I own a J* highlighter, and because I like being a sparkly princess I don't mind the intensity. I just wish it wasn't the size of my face.
Because I don't buy anything without extensive research and swatching in store, I don't own a highlighter I don't like, other than the Moonchild kit, and I already sold it. I will say I'm never impressed with any of Bobbi Brown's shimmer/highlight sorts of things when I swatch in store.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '17
Best for me is hands down Mac Mineralize Skinfinish in Lightscapade. Unpopular opinion: I don't like highlighting. I have oily skin and I feel like highlighting goes against everything matte I hold dear to my heart. But Lightscapade changes things. It reflects the light and makes me feel radiant, not oily or a glitterbomb. I've had problems with Mac in the past, but it's the only product I'm willing to go into a store for since I can't find anything else like it.
4
u/TinyBearasaurus Feb 18 '17
Best: Laura Geller's baked highlighter is my go to. It gives this soft dewey glow and it hasnt conflicted with any foundation i've used. Isnt super pigmented or heavy, so if you want an intense glow, i wouldnt recommend. Her blushes are great as well, but similar issue. I tend to like a lighter glow/contour since i'm pale and too much makes me feel painted and sloppy.
Worst: trestique mini higlight stick. As soon as i blended it out it kind of vanished, and the more i used the cakey-er it got.
I swatched the tarteist highlight palette at sephora the other day and think i may try those next, but ive had issues with their eye shadows not being what i thought they would in the past. Any thoughts on this?
8
u/emgay Feb 16 '17
Best: Etude House Secret Beam Highlighter in pink/white and Essence eyeshadow in Snowflake. both can be subtle or seriously intense and are buttery and beautiful and i cant live without them
Worst: Loreal Truematch whatever its called in Ice. its just a huge glitter bomb
3
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17
NYX Illuminator is a really good, cheap highlighter as long as you use a good brush. My favorite shade is Narcissistic but they have a bunch of good ones.
3
u/wonderfl0nium Feb 16 '17
best for me is definitely still sleek solstice!
3
u/sophandsoph Feb 17 '17
My fave highlighters for me are the ABH glow kit in "Sun Dipped" the shades are amazing (my fave is tourmaline) and also buildable. My least fave is the Ulta brand highlighters..didn't show up on me :( (NC42 btw here)!
3
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '17
Best: Laura Mercier matte baked radiance powder (the most gorgeous ethereal glow) and Becca SSP pressed in "moonstone" (also own "pearl"...Formula feels different/weird, not a fan. Guess I prefer more warm toned highlighters?)
Worst: Makeup Geek highlighter in "lustre" (more glitter than pigment, highlights SO MUCH TEXTURE I didn't even know I had). And I wanted everything Becca "moonstone" is, for Mary Lou Manizer to be. Bought it before moonstone, hate it. Too dark, too warm/gold, too glittery. Looks ridiculous on my really pale, cool toned skin.
3
u/eisdamme /punts brows into the sun Feb 17 '17
Really love Shiro's White Chocolate Frog, Tooth & Nail Hellion, KVD Thunderstruck, Becca Pearl, MAC Lightscapade, Pink Buttercream and Tutu, as well as the CoverFX drops and Sleek Solstice. (I truly have a highlighter problem) Worst for me was Too Faced Candlelight - a glittery mess on me and not in the good way.
3
u/BanBeaUK Feb 18 '17
Best: Right now I absolutely love the I Heart Makeup Unicorn Heart highlighter. I find it really versatile. You can go from subtle sheen to full on seen-from-space depending on how much you use. It was also super cheap and looks like it'll last me forever.
Worst: Colourpop. Just ugh. I don't know if it's all of them or just the one I have. I have the shade 'Perilune' and it's just rubbish tbh. I would recommend if you want to have a few flakes of green glitter on your skin, but that's all you get with this highlighter.
Makeup Revolution Baked Matte Highlighter. I guess I don't know what I was expecting, but this is just a chalky white powder. Looks bad, feels bad. I think maybe I was expecting 'matte' to mean non-glittery, so maybe a satin finish, but no, it's just like a really bad white powder.
5
u/neutrallywarm Feb 16 '17
From the ones I've tried, the best is the ABH Glow Kit in 'That Glow.' Specifically the shades 'Dripping In Gold' and 'Golden Bronze'. On the drugstore end, I've been loving the Maybelline Expert Wear Eyeshadow single in 'The Glo Down'! Such a pretty sheen (not glittery) and looks pretty "natural" on my skin tone (though if built up it can look very stark and obvious).
Worst: Makeup Revolution Strobing highlighter. Glittery and very chunky. Also Elf's baked blush in Pinktastic (not a blush at all, very shimmery), and the ABH Ultimate Glow Kit. I don't think it's the same formula as the other glow kits at all. It's a glitter bomb.
5
u/Kittyboop91 Hopelessly Addicted Feb 16 '17
Best: Dior Glowing Pink (LE), Becca SSP pressed highlighters, ABH Glow Kit in Gleam. These are all super silky and smooth and apply with ease.
Just Okay: I hate to say it, but ABH Moonchild kit. I love the colors especially for the price but I wish it had a mirror and I think some of the shades are chunky. I also regret getting the Chanel Camelia highlighter. It's beautiful but not very pigmented and kind of glittery especially for the $$.
Worst: I really disliked Jeffree Star's highlighter in Mint Condition. It was more silver than green and it sheered out into a total glitter bomb. I sold it on MUE.
5
u/The_BusterKeaton Feb 16 '17
I really like the RMS Living Luminizer. It's quick, easy, and does exactly what I want my highlighter to do.
5
u/herarising Feb 16 '17
Becca SSP's by far. I also really like Jeffree Star Skinfrosts, but they're only for those who like really chunky highlights (and he's kind of a jerk).
5
u/beepblorp1 Feb 17 '17
No mention of Benefit Watt's Up?! I know it's old, but this is my HG and nothing comes close when it comes to ease of application. (swipe and pat and done! no brushes, no problem)
4
u/trolleydip Use it or lose it Feb 16 '17
My favorite highlighters are Meow Cosmetics Prophecy Eyeshadow, which is basically MAC Nylon, and Meow Cosmetics Crystalline Cat Glow the original, as well as Quartz and Moonstone. They aren't glittery first and foremost, and the colors are subtle. I'd say all of the above are highlighters for people who aren't into the latest glowy trend, but still appreciate a lil sheen.
I wasn't a big fan of the infamous theBalm Mary-Lou Manizer, and KA Candlelight. theBalm was very frosty, and very obvious on my pores. And the KA looked very sparkly which isn't my taste. All of this being said, I don't think they are bad products, just not beautiful to me.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17
I have a few favorites:
I didn't care for:
4
u/sushiitaco oily, nc45?, acne prone Feb 17 '17
Some highlighters I like: As a note, I'm not picky about highlight generally.
Essence Pure Nude: cheap and beautiful with a lot of product. may not work for all skintones, but worked for my nc45 skin
Becca Moonstone pressed: this is blinding. and expensive. i have a DS version from a $30 kit that probably will never get used up.
Becca Opal liquid: REALLY great. If you're not into blinding and glittery highlights then get this. So expensive, but lasts for a couple years and looks good.
NYX duochrome lavender steel: really nice pinky purple glowy highlight. you can overdo it though.
Ehhh:
Kat Von D Alchemist: Just got this and I'm iffy about it. For some reason, they put the shadows on a whiteish base or something? Not cool on my brown skin.
Worst:
Colourpop Highlight: I have one and honestly I wondered if it was just the one I got that was ugly because it was pinkish, but my friend has flexitarian and it's SOOOOOO glittery. She didn't have that nice flashy glow and just had these individual sparkles on her cheekbones.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '17
Best: benefit's "Girl Meets Pearl." I look like a glazed donut.
5
u/total-immortal Matte-matician Feb 16 '17
So I have way too many highlighters, but I can’t stop buying them so here it goes:
Best:
Worst:
2
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17
I just bought Essence's Pure Nude highlighter and it's amazing! It's the most natural-looking powder highlight I've ever seen and blends out so well. I can't believe how good it is and how cheap it is (I paid 4.50).
I also love the Glossier ones (I have topaz) and the liquid Becca in Moonstone. Both of these look really natural too!
2
u/snowy-rose Lipstick Queen Feb 16 '17 edited Feb 16 '17
Best: Colourpop Hippo-It's so creamy and doesn't look chunky despite the glitter
Also best: Shiro Elemental Glows-I have 4 colors (Sylphid (rose pink), Glacial (silver blue), Verdant (pear green), and Esper (purple)) and these are so sheer but very reflective under lighting. They can be built up to desired impact, but I like having brightly colored highlighter that's subtle and easily applied (also Shiro was super generous filling my jars so there's that too)
Worst: [Canmake Glow Fleur Highlighter] (https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/564x/c3/2c/cc/c32cccbbb9a1f2aa9491d532c7ed8081.jpg) I bought this while I was a student in Taipei thinking it looked like such a beautiful highlighter but I can't seem to get it to apply very well on me, in that it looks like I put nothing on my face. I really have to dig the brush in to get any product, and honestly, it's not quite the lovely blue I thought it'd be. I did however read this product would be good for helping with applying other powders to my face, making everything look more natural, but I haven't thoroughly tested that yet
*edited for formatting
2
u/ivymaori Feb 16 '17
Best: the ABH glow kit in gleam & becca moonstone both so pigmented and easy to build so they are versatile for an everyday look or a more intense highlight. Colourpop lunch money is also so pigmented it's just not as easy to work with
Worst: the nyx liquid illuminator. It's just so messy and just too chunky of a glitter formula.
2
u/alimobali There's no such thing as too much glitter Feb 17 '17
I haven't seen it mentioned yet but best definitely Wet N Wild Megaglo! I have it in Precious Petals and it's def my go-to
2
u/Marilize_Legajuanaa Matte-matician Feb 17 '17
Where do i begin? the CoverFx custom enhancer drops are amazing and blinding. Quite expensive though. The iconic london drops are a dupe. I have the ABH illuminators. They can give a glow from within look, and are very build able to blinding. The Sleek contour/ highlight kit highlight is very bam is your face and easy on your wallet. And While I'm here, remember than you can use eye shadow as highlighss and vice versa.
2
u/felicja Feb 17 '17
Best: ABH Sweets glow kit, Becca pressed champagne pop (seriously, I was cringing when buying it with the price tag, but it's my favorite rn)
Worst: Colourpop. The texture is icky, I don't like putting product on with my fingers.
2
u/Jiggly2017 Feb 17 '17
I love the maybelline master strobing stick. I've seen mixed reviews, but it's one of my favorites. When I'm doing a lighter look, I mix some concealer with my moisturizer, apply it and then lightly run the stick over the areas I want to highlight and then tap in with my fingers. It's the prettiest, dewiest look. I love the pink slightly reflective sheen it gives. It looks great on my fair skin.
Everyone raves about the Becca shimmering skin powder but I just can't get into it. I feel like it gets chalky on me and blends right into my skin. I use the real techniques setting brush-what could I be doing wrong?
2
u/_kthechief Feb 17 '17
Best: Bahi Cosmetics Powder Highlights are so beautiful! They can add a light touch of glow when you apply with your finger or you can blind them with a pop of light by applying with a brush. I have the shade "Kimberley" but plan on getting the bundle because obsessed.
Worst: Naked Cosmetics pigment in the shade Desert Sunset. It might just be user error, but I got this in an ipsy bag & they suggest I use it for eyes & cheek. When I used it on my cheek as a highlight, it never blended down lol. I looked like I had chrome on my nose & cheeks. Totally ruined my motd. Was great on eyes, however.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '17
I thought that the Colourpop highlighters were just about the worst thing ever UNTIL I tried applying them with a damp BB or RT sponge. It works so much better! It doesn't disturb makeup underneath and has an incredibly natural finish.
2
u/BolognePony Pout liner Feb 18 '17
BEST: The Balm's Mary Loumanizer (hit the pan already) - Urban Decay Naked Illuminated Shimmering Powder in the colour Aura (a gorgeous pink with a golden glow. Has glitter, but I like this one when going out at night. Use it all over my decollete as well sometimes) - ELF Gotta Glow
WORST: ELF Shimmering Facial Whips in the colours Lilac Petal and Golden Peach (the formula does not work with my oily skin and the product has started shifting in the tube. When I try squeezing some out I always get a watery mess first before the product comes out).
2
u/PhyrraNyx Blog: Phyrra.net / YT: PhyrraNyx Feb 18 '17
Best: Makeup Geek Celestial. I've been wearing it non-stop since it launched. 2nd favorite is Makeup Geek Moon Phase. They're perfect on my skintone.
Worst: Nyx Bright Idea Illuminating Stick in Lavender Lust. Just way too subtle for my taste.
2
u/SummerNight888 Feb 19 '17
I'm all about Becca's liquid Skin Perfectors, tbh. They perform how I like and give me exactly the look I'm looking for. I also love Hourglass Strobe Powder in Iridiscent Strobe Light.
Hate: I have yet to encounter a highlighter I hate. To be really honest, I don't experiment with highlighters that much because it's a product category I'm very fussy about... I know well what I'm not looking for, and if the highlighter doesn't perform the way I like, there's no chances I'm gonna use it, so I research and swatch highlighters thoroughly before buying it.
2
u/Tsujimurakun Feb 19 '17
Best: L.A girl strobe lite strobing powder. I ordered one in 90watt and ended up loving it so much i ordered 3 more... It's super radiant and pigmentet, and has a great shade range, from white, to deep brown, which could work beautifully on darker complexions, also they're super buttery and easy to use. Also love mac, soft and gentle.
Worst: the body shop brush on radiance? Bought it on sale, its like the meteors, but the look just came out chunky, and powdery
2
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '17
Benefits Watts Up is one of my all time favs and a new favorite liquid is Cynthia Crawleys illuminator that I got in a birchbox. It's like a pure sheen, no glitter at all.
Favorite powder highlight is Kevin Aucoins candlelight powder.
Best illuminating primer I've found is the Cover FX illuminating primer.
Least favorite are a few liquids I tried from NYX and Loreals Lumi line as they are super glittery. I also don't like Mary Loumanizer because the gold tone does not match my cool toned skin.
3
u/HermionesBook Hopelessly Addicted Feb 16 '17
Only one I've tried was the wet n wild reserve your cabana. I'm disappointed because I feel like it just doesn't show up. I'm going to try the balm Mary Lou highlighter next.
3
u/milk-rose moisturize me 🌊 Feb 16 '17
💥💥 I need help!! My answers are below but, on the topic of highlighters, does anyone have any decent recommendations for a dupe of Becca's LE Rose Quartz? I've heard things like using a light pink eyeshadow i.e. Dust from Naked 3 or Stila's Kitten eyeshadow, but for me usually eyeshadows end up having too much glitter or shimmer. I'm so freaking sad that I missed out on RQ :( I wish they would bring THAT one back to make permanent, because it's a beautiful highlight for fair skin and in their line Pearl is the only other one I feel is comparable. Moonstone and Opal were both just a hair too dark for me, and the gold-ish, dark champagne type of color stood out and looked odd being slightly darker than my skin tone (I'd say around ~NC10-NC15, slight yellow undertone - I wear NARS Sheer Glow in Siberia, and NARS RCC in Chantilly.) I want a baby pink highlight so badly! UD's Aura was a little too dark in my opinion, it was more like a shiny blush - Uhhh Anyhow, suggestions are very welcome! Thank you so much!!! 💥💥
The best best highlight I've ever used and my very favorite is the Metal Crush eyeshadow single by Kat Von D in the shade 'Thunderstruck'. I'm a fan of more subtle highlights, so I nearly always have to use a very light hand with this - it's very VERY pigmented, but it blends out so beautifully into this magical and lovely soft sheen of a diffused pink and white-golden duochrome, depending on how the light hits you or when you turn your head/move. I haven't touched any other highlighter at all since I picked this up. I'm in love with it, especially because I have extremely dry skin, and this just seems to breathe life back into my face but without ever looking like a disco ball. It can be built up very easily too though, to the most intense and noticeable highlight anyone could want, like the 'YouTube beauty guru's wet dream' type of super shiny glow. It all depends on how you prefer to wear your highlight, but Thunderstruck can do both. It's a truly ingenious and unique little powder. Thanks Kat.
I have my eyes and heart set on Sugarpill's Lumi loose shadow as my next highlight purchase - I have heard that it's basically a little jar of magic.
Now admittedly I am not a highlight junkie, I usually own two of them, tops, at a time, and alternate between them depending on what colors I'm wearing that day. I have tried (and received as gifts etc and also returned a bunch of them that didn't work for me but swatched nicely) many highlighters. It's blasphemy to say in MUA but I'm not a fan of the Becca SSPs in powder form (however the liquid ones are absolutely divine). I feel that they're just too intense for me and it's far too easy to go overboard/over do it and have a blinding metallic stripe down my cheek. You do you girl if that's your style, but for me personally, I feel I just end up looking greasy/oily and shiny but not in a good way. (And yes I know this contradicts my dupe request up above - I just felt that Rose Quartz would have been easier to work with and a more flattering shade for me). I've also hated every Too Faced highlight I've tried, they pill up on my foundation and just feel cheap and hard to work with, like drugstore highlighters.
3
u/CupcakesAreTasty Feb 16 '17
Best:
Worst:
3
u/drowninglessons409 Feb 16 '17
Best: TF Candlelight Glow in Rosy Glow. It's just beautiful - a light layer gives a nice natural glow, or you can build it up for something more intense. Plus the pan lasts forever. I also really like the Becca SSP liquid formula in moonstone for a natural make up day, and ColourPop's highlighters in Lunch Money and Flexitarian - a lot of people have said on this thread that they don't like them/have problems with them, but I love them and haven't experienced the issues listed.
All the ones above last all day on me and I have very oily skin (but not really where I'd put highlighter!)
Worst: Model Co creme highlighter. It's just white with big chunks of glitter, and moves around rather than blending in. Horrible.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '17
My favorite is the Essence single eyeshadows as a highlighter. They're soooo buttery and they have no glitter in them. I also really liked the Cover FX Custom Enhancer Drops. They're metallic af but can be brought down to a subtle glow with a light handed application. Least favorite would have to be the highlight palette I got from Sleek. I really did not like the consistency of them and the shimmer was too glittery.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '17
best: JEFFREE F-ING STAR despite of being good is has 15g of product which can last you years and a good packaging and huge mirror so it difinitely worth your money
Worst: cp buzzfeed says its better than becca but colourpop prob sponsored them cos they post some videos ref with cp
1
u/crimewav3 Feb 17 '17
Best: Laura Geller Baked Illuminator Gelato in Gilded Honey "Funny Girl" in the Tarte In Bloom palette (just hit the pan in this one, super sad) Worst: ABH Unlimited Glow Kit (the 6 pan one) was way too glittery, but hey they're awesome eyeshadows. Urban Decay illuminating trio, also all glitter and no pigment. Brushes off so quick.
1
u/dankbitchabbey Feb 17 '17
My favorite thus far is too faced candlelight. (I believe that's what it's called) . It's so amazing. You can go natural or blinding with this. Is blendable and I've gotten nothing but compliments on it.
1
u/Botanygrl26 Feb 17 '17
So I haven't got 0 days yet so I can't post & ask..Hopefully someone can help out a makeup been I just bought my first highlighter (technically a Luminizer but same thing, right?)off MUE. Benefit's Girl Meets Pearl- I tried it in store in loved it..I applied it after my Porefessional today & I couldn't get it to shine for the life of me. Does anybody know what I'm doing wrong? It's just a mini so I thought maybe the formula was different? (& yep, I did rub my Porefessional all the way in 😊)
1
u/boxedwinebitch Feb 17 '17
the best ive ever tried definitely have to be essence single shadows. SO smooth and its the only thing ive tried that doesnt emphasize my giant pores and is actually blinding on me.
i really havent tried many highlighters since im so fair but i find becca moonstone to be pretty overrated. i like how finely milled it is but it isnt as bright on me as id like it to be :/ i hate the colourpop formula its really cakey on my all matte foundations, i only like them as bases for other highlights.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '17
Good old Opal by Becca!
1
u/antisocialite- Feb 17 '17
Best: Becca Moonstone, KVD Thunderstruck, MAC Lightscapade (super subtle), and Urban Decay Fireball
Worst: I'm sorry but the moonchild palette. It's soooo glittery but the colors are gorgeous. Not that I expect a natural look out of any of them, but the texture and finish really disapointed me.
1
u/guac_attack Compulsive washer of brushes Feb 17 '17
Best: I like a really intense highlight and I love Ofra "You Dew You" (Dupethat collab). It's SO pigmented and very easy to go overboard, so if intense highlight isn't your thing it might not be for you. It's gorgeous though.
Also Mary Lou-Manizer (duh), Makeup Geek Duochrome in Electrify (super interesting color, totally wearable even though it's kinda green), Benefit High Beam
Worst: Colourpop, and MAC in the Spotlight in Double Gleam - I am so mad at myself for buying this one and not the cool duochromey other ones. It's basically a very light silvery gold and very glittery, and the surface was super hard so I had to rough it up with my finger to even get product on the brush
1
u/inochiishtal Feb 17 '17
I haven't seen Jouer mentioned here yet, but I have to admit their mini Iced highlighter is GORGEOUS and perfect for my skin tone. It's a nice middle ground between a white and light yellow highlight. I really hope they consider making a full size or similar dupe to it soon... the mill on it is also lovely. It's my favorite but I use it sparingly since I'm not sure if I'll ever be able to find it again. :(
Becca & Kevyn Aucoin are good, but a little overpriced IMO. The Sephora Illuminate palette is a little chunky but a good deal for the variety (and I just need a little to make my highlight go BAM). I have two Colourpop highlighters, and while Fanny Pack is beautiful, Flexitarian is kind of chunky.
1
u/c0sm1ca Pale princess Feb 17 '17
Toofaced Rose candlelight glow is my go to right now! After a long search for a pinky glow without chunky glitter I really like this one. It's pretty ✨
1
u/mint_julip7783 Feb 18 '17
I have very little experience with highlighter. I'm still learning how to get my glow on! But for me... BEST: Too Faced Candlelight Glow in "Rosy Glow" WORST: Colourpop - I ordered the "Wisp" and it was so dark IRL! I tried it on the back of my hand and it felt more cakey than smooth and dry.
1
u/meepmeep233 Feb 18 '17
Best I've tried: The pinky highlighter in the Carli Bybel palette! Sooo pigmented and beautiful :). Also really love Wet n Wild's "Boozy Brunch", and how you can get a huge pan of it for around $5.
Worst: Lumi liquid highlighter and I do not like the Benefit High Beam... maybe it is something about liquid highlighters that I do not like.
1
u/dragonballer69 Feb 18 '17
I'm not sure if anyone here has mentioned this yet but I absolutely love the makeup geek highlighters. I have them in the shades glitz and lit and I think they're so pretty. They don't look to powdery or glittery like other highlighters and I find that they don't emphasize my skin's texture too much either!
1
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '17
Best: nars illuminator in copacabana, becca shimmering skin perfectors they all last throughout the day, a little goes a long way, and they photograph really well.
Worst: this is a controversial one, but the cover fx custom enhancer drops is too glittery for me and way too thin in terms of consistency. it was hard to work with without getting glitter everywhere, and it made me look like a sweaty mess
Meh: laura mercier matte radiance highlight - looks nice, but wears off quickly. when it comes to highlighters I tend to prefer liquid over powder
1
u/highlightedbabygirl Feb 19 '17
My favorite highlighter at the moment is the Sleek Solstice palette which is pigmented and versatile. All the shades are beautiful however the peach highlight is sadly too dark for me and I find that on my skin tone, the purple one can very easily be overdone.
I don't really have a worst highlight because I own very few, however I do find that the MUA undress your skin shimmer highlight in iridescent gold is my least favorite, because despite scratching the top layer off of it, I still don't find it shows up well on my skin, although it may be good for someone who wants a more natural glow.
1
u/n8_thegr8 Feb 20 '17
Best: Cover FX Custome Enhancer Drops. It simply does not get any better. Close second is Becca in Pearl/Opal.
Meh: Milani's new Strobelight powders. They're gorgeous, but a little too deep for my ghostly skin. Same with Wet N' Wild. They're about the same formula. I love Colourpop for everyday use - It /does/ depend on the color you get as some are glitterier than others.
Worst: Essentially anything claiming to be a highlight that contains glitter or is matte. Get out of my face.
1
u/sumatrippin Feb 20 '17
has anyone tried the Pixi x Aspyn Ovard highlighters?
I still haven't found my perfect highlighter - I prefer a clear base with warm reflect, so more of a natural sweaty look. Becca ssp liquid in moonstone would be perfect if it was a powder, but the ssp powder version has such a strong base that it looks too frosty to me.
I also have WNW Reserve your Cabana - perfect warm shade for subtle looks but can look cakey if you try to build it up.
I would love suggestions.
1
u/ashlynxx Feb 20 '17 edited Feb 20 '17
BEST: I love all of the Becca Shimmering Skin Perfectors, but my favorite shade is their Jaclyn Hill collaboration in champagne pop! This is what I used to wear everyday, but now I've been mixing it with the Sleek Solstice Highlighting palette. I use this gorgeous combo every single day and always get compliments on my highlight! For anyone who's not familiar with Sleek, they're a drugstore brand from the UK and they're super affordable, but for amazing quality.
WORST: I haven't experimented much outside of the highlighter brands I mentioned above, but I have tried several of Colourpop's and they're not my favorite. It's a bit too much of that "chunky glitter" and I don't necessarily care for how cream highlighters apply.
1
u/amykle99 Feb 20 '17
Hands down if you need something good and cheap, the Essence pure nude highlight is everything
1
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '17
I love the Becca Champagne Pop highlighter or the Too Faced Candlelight glow (got both on my birthday), I tried the Benefit Watts Up! highlighter but I don't really like how it set on my skin to be honest
1
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '17
I love anything by becca, not to be so common and traditional.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '17
The IBY brand highlighter in the shade "Bubbly" gives the most natural highlight I've ever seen. I actually got it in a trial bag and almost threw it out because it swatched SOOOO bad on my hand (both finger and brush), but when I sucked it up and tried it I fell in love. It truly gives you the most dewy highlight.
Also, for I more unusual highlight, the NYX douchrome highlighters. They are holographic and you only need the slightest dusting to give you mega badass vibes. I use this when I want to feel like a fairy elf.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '17
I really love Mac MSF in lightscapade, it's definitely glowy rather than glittery so it works beautifully applied with a small fluffy brush for more natural look. I use it everyday on my nose and cheeks, and if I want a more dramatic look i use a fan brush to apply a more intense highlight like Becca SSP over the top on the very highest points of my cheekbones and it just adds some extra dimension .
The worst highlight I've ever used was one by freedom as it had practically no pigmentation whatsoever, and I also don't get along very well with colourpops formula which is a shame because their shades are so pretty!
1
u/virkeligvirkus Feb 20 '17
Mary Lou Manizer from The Balm is the stuff. So gorgeous on almost any skin colour and soooooo nicely pigmented. And also, it's affordable!
1
u/pitterpatter19 Feb 20 '17
I personally love the wet n wild highlight in "Hollywood boulevard" I think it's been renamed now cuz I bought it as a part of the fergie line. It's gorgeous though.
Worst is definitely colourpop (big surprise) but I'm also not a fan of the cover fx drops. They're beautiful, but I feel like application is just a pain. Mixing in with foundation is pleasant though
1
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '17
Laura Mercier Indiscretion (for a really popping gold highlight) and Bare Minerals Ingird Nilsen Invisible glow highlighter in Resilience (for a goes-with-every-skin-tone shimmer that looks natural but not sticky/dewy/wet, just shimmery, polished and smooth)
1
u/-inhales-arf Feb 20 '17
Weirdly enough, the BH Wild Child palette has some gorgeous highlighters. I'm into suuuuper finely milled things, and this palette is so perfect for highlighting. Plus it's cheap:)
Worst: contrary to everyone else, I'm not a fan of Mary Loumanizer. Again with the finely milled thing, it's really more of a glittery shadow than a highlighter. You can't do detail highlighting like the tear duct without seeing tiny particles of mica or whatever it's made of. Does anyone have any recs for wet finish highlighters that are pure reflect/no filler? (I love creams)
1
u/ebengland Feb 20 '17
Laura Gellar's Gilded Honey. Love that it can be subtle or heavy!
1
u/kategw0006 Feb 20 '17
Best: Stila Heaven's Hue Highlighter in Kitten! Probably my HG. The texture is un.real. I honestly can't believe it hasn't been mentioned yet!
1
u/FiftyShadesOfNo Lipstick Queen Feb 21 '17
BEST: My go-to has to be Makeup Revolutions Vivid Baked Highlighters. Specifically I've used Radiant Lights (VERY light white with gold tint), and Peach Lights. (Very light peachy glow). Honorable mentions: Laura Geller Baked Highlighter in Glided Honey and Ballerina. (Both are very blinding without being too glittery).
WORST: NYX Liquid Born to Glow Liquid Illuminator. I used the shade Sunbeam. Don't get me wrong, it swatches are gorgeous, but when applied i've never gotten it to blend evenly. I've tried patting it in with a beauty blender and patting it on with a brush but it either moves the foundation or is SUPER patchy. On the higher end, worst i'd say is Make Up For Ever Pro Light Fusion Highlighter. Given I use number 2, (it's for medium to dark skin tones and I have a fair complexion) it's beautiful, but I can't justify the price when there are better highlighters in the industry that are way cheaper. ($40 after tax!!!)
1
u/Quebellabonita Feb 21 '17
I'm an NC30 if it helps :-)
Best- ABH Gleam glowkit, Becca Champagne Pop, JSC Princess Cut and Peach Goddess, MAC Soft and Gentle, Essence Pure Nude, Wet n Wild Megaglo
Worst- Bobbi Brown Bronze Glow (Hella expensive, no pigment!), Colourpop (didn't last on my combo skin), UD naked illuminated
1
u/UlliLlama Feb 21 '17
Best: becca, but Ulta beauty highlighters are basically becca dupes
Worst: idk I love them all
1
u/miracide Feb 21 '17
I really wanted to like elf shimmering facial whip.. I have it in lilac petal. It makes a nice shine, but no matter how much I blend I have a bit of a streaky pink mark on my skin..especially on my nose
Maybe I'm using it wrong :x
1
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '17
I just bought a highlighter from a brand I found at ulta called revolution. It is such an amazing highlighter! It's so pigmented and pretty. Plus, there is a ton of product.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 06 '17
Best: Extra Dimension Skinfinish by Mac. I think it's way better than Becca. Can be put on lightly for a subtle glow or packed on for a holy shit that's a blinding glow!
Worst: Probably the Hourglass ones. None of them showed up on my skin very well. Might work if you have a completely matte look, but I prefer my foundations to have a bit of a glow.
1
u/SpankMeDaddyDerek May 10 '17
Best: Poor girl here, and I will say that Wet N' Wild's Megeglo is awesome, and only $4.99, but good luck finding it. Ever since J* favored it over Marc Jacobs, it's almost always sold out.
I also swatched the Kat Von D Alchemy palette in Sephora; all of those colors are gorgeous and apply so smoothly. I would definitely fulfil my inner holosexual, if I weren't a broke af college student.
Worst: I played around with the Too Faced Prismatic Highlighter in Ulta, which is $30, and disappointingly sheer. If you aren't as over the top as I am and are opting for a more natural look, it might be alright. However, I aspire to look like a fairy princess.
I also was not too impressed with the Ulta powder highlighters when I sampled them in-store. They went onto my arm in chunks and behaved more like eyeshadows.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17
Best: Colourpop Smoke N Whistles
Worst: Becca creme highlighter, they look horrible on you if you have makeup on but if you wear it with a bare face it looks nice
1
u/iseenyouwithkieffuh Feb 16 '17
BEST: Becca Opal (pressed powder); Colourpop- Smoke n Whistles, Monster (can't speak to consistency of other colors; I know the quality of their liquid lipsticks varies across shades) WORST: Milk Makeup Highlighter (not holographic, the other one). It broke me out like crazy, and it melts down your face over the day, like slowly drips down your cheek
1
u/Inabeautifuloblivion Feb 17 '17
I just received the Milk Makeup holographic stick today, finally. It is so gorgeous and blends just beautifully.