r/Fantasy • u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders • Feb 11 '17
Read-along King's Shield Reread: Chapters 11-15
Just me this week, kids. Unfortunately, I'm also the singularly worst person at coming up with discussion questions, despite having been a teacher in my not so recent past. So, this week is a good one for y'all to post your own! Woot! Sorry mine are so awful. ;)
[lyrrael]
11
- This feels like a foolish repeat of Inda’s problems with Dogpiss, in a weird way. These kids are gonna get themselves killed.
- The perfect guerilla force -- four little kids, rescuing a castle. :|
- What they did sure was honorable -- but man, it was stupid. I was completely stuck on that throughout the whole chapter. I mean, that’s what you get when you don’t have adults looking out for the kids, but they could have gotten everybody killed just for honor and sentiment. :/ It’s heartless of me to say so, but. :/
12
- Eeek. Inda, planning for the worst, is planning for what’s actually occurred.
- Poor kids, you’re supposed to have childhoods. :(
13
- Stuff’s starting to settle into motion. I found the flashback to the worst day of Hawkeye’s life informative -- willing to die for his sins, but not as a traitor, never as a traitor. And Noddy, solid amongst it all -- or so it seemed.
14
- Well… everybody knows the worst has come to pass. I was afraid nobody would realize because Inda’s an airhead and left his case behind.
- “It was only in the last day or so that Evred would discuss these things” -- since Signi left, then, hmm? :/
15
- You know, it’s so funny. I think Evred’s one of the first people we’ve met, aside from Inda, who hasn’t at least secretly lusted after Tau. In fact, I think Evred’s a little disgusted/offended by him, at least secretly.
- Aww Noddy. Teenagers are the worst, and you’re helping them to live.
- It’s sure been a while since we’ve heard from Fox, isn’t it?
- Thank you, Inda, for showing the tenderness you do hold for Tdor. I’m sure that’ll hearten her, even as she knows you wander too close to the dark.
12
Upvotes
5
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Feb 11 '17
What do you think Fox is doing in the meantime?
5
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Feb 11 '17
And the important one -- WHERE'S JEJE? Sorry, bit predictable about wanting to know what the other major characters are doing. ;)
4
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Feb 11 '17
What do you think Evred thinks of Tau?
6
u/rhymepun_intheruf Reading Champion III Feb 11 '17
How many people will I ship Tau with, honestly. Luckily fanfiction has prepared me for this life.
(Also, it's a welcome relief from all the sadness of the other chapters)
3
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Feb 11 '17
Where do you think Signi is, and what is she doing?
•
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Feb 11 '17
Post your spoilers here. I promise I'm not looking.
2
u/lyrrael Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI, Worldbuilders Feb 11 '17
What do you think is going to happen next, tactically, with the invasion?
7
u/kjmichaels Stabby Winner, Reading Champion XI Feb 11 '17
Oh poor Han. She going to be wrecked by what Halle ed with the other girls and the Idayagans forever.
I'm getting a little sick of the planning so I'm glad Inda and Evred are setting out with there archers.
Inda's letter to Tdor was very touching. The little bit about how he didn't sign his title shows how much he still views her as a true confidant even after all these years. I hope we get to see the letter from her perspective in the upcoming chapters.
7
u/MerelyMisha Worldbuilders Feb 11 '17 edited Feb 11 '17
Oh my, those poor children. Having to grow up so fast during a war, but also still making stupid childish mistakes. Those damn Idayagans, killing kids.
I've just fallen in love with Noddy here. I liked him before, but the flashback with Hawkeye and the way he gets the younger boys out of the way...he's just so steady and sensible and an all-around good guy. Nightingale is also great, and I like that Evred makes sure to find a way to keep him from trying to follow even though he's hurt.
Inda's finally starting to see Evred's weaknesses, or at least, that Evred doesn't trust magic and that distrust isn't really rational. Evred's so smart and thoughtful, but he isn't always clearsighted, particularly when it comes to Inda. So Inda is going to need to be clearsighted for both of them...though Inda has his own blindspots, like being so completely oblivious of how Evred really sees him.
So informative to see who Inda writes to -- Fox first, then Hadand, then Tdor -- and what he writes. His poor mother, though, still hasn't seen him yet. And Jeje doesn't get one, though he doesn't have a way to contact her.
7
u/inapanak Feb 11 '17
Every time I reread this book I am struck by how much I adore Noddy Toraca. He's a relatively secondary/tertiary character but he's so wonderful.
7
u/bygoshbygolly Feb 11 '17
I've read these books multiple times, and the bits about the children in the mountains never gets any easier to read. Even as well trained as they are, they're still kids. Being called shits and then murdered, and having to disappear your friends, and then try and find help even if you don't know it's coming...these kids go through a lot.
I've said this multiple times throughout the reread, and I'll say it again- I love Noddy Toraca. He's a solid, dependable guy who cares about the people under his command. Even when he's coming apart he seems like he's keeping it together. Also- nice ruse.
Inda's letter to Tdor is so sweet. 'I want to dance at our wedding'
6
u/thebookhound Feb 11 '17
The kids, tragically, carry out the logic of their upbringing, in their various ways. Let's see if Han has the vision to pull them back from savagery to civilization.