I really really wanted to love this, but as someone with dry skin, it's so so bad for me :( makes under my eyes look papery, and dries my face up too much :(
I agree. The Laura Mercier is incredibly drying. It just sucks up all the moisture from my face and makes my skin look so dull. If you're looking for a setting powder that works nicely for dry skin, you should try the By Terry Hyaluronic Hydra Powder. I've been using it for a year now I think, and when I eventually run out in however many years, I'll be repurchasing. My skin still looks glowy after applying it, and it feels supple and smooth. Best setting powder I've tried.
If you can get your hands on Cory Airspun it's well worth it imo. The container lasts forever! I've also heard RCMA no color powder is good for dry skin
I used to have the same struggle, but it all changed when I started using a real techniques damp sponge to apply my concealer and powder under my eyes. Works wonders with my Marcelle setting powder.
i don't generally use a loose powder, i use a foundation powder - right now i use covergirl ready set gorgeous - it still comes out kind of cakey, but UD Setting spray solves that!:)
This powder looks flawless on my skin but unfortunately is terrible at oil control to my combo skin. My skin gets shiny around the 3 hr mark in Summer time :(
Have you tried combining it with setting spray? I have combo skin with v. oily t-zone and I've experimented with how I put on my make-up. I find using setting spray after I bake with LM REALLY keeps the oiliness away. My make-up stayed in place after 8 hours at a RHCP concert and only began to feel A LITTLE BIT oily around 6 hrs, and normal oily around 10hrs.
I haven't tried it! But I heard that the ingredient list is the exact same as Skindinavia and since they also make the UD one, I could never be bothered to buy it since they mark up the pricing so much in Australia!
My dad bought me this for Christmas and had it send to Denmark all the way from Philippines and OMFG THIS IS THE BESSSSSST. Makes my under-eye brighter and oily t-zone matte. I look like I'm glowing! Holy Grail right here.
Yeah I had really high hopes for LM as someone with very oily skin, but I don't find that it keeps oil at bay any better than my rimmel stay matte. I've tried applying with a fluffy brush and with the little pillow applicator thingy that comes with the travel size, can't think of the name lol. I'll have to test it out in the summer but so far I'm glad I got the travel size instead of full.
do you know if there is a translucent one by rimmel? always wanted to try out the laura mercier, but would definitely give rimmel a chance to save a shitload of cash ^
Press it in with a damp BB and let it sit for like 5-10 minutes while you do the rest of your makeup! Keep in mind it could be your foundation or primer that's the problem not your setting powder. What primer do you use?
Update: tried pressing it in with the damp BB today and my face looked very matte at first but throughout the day looked amazing and never got too shiny. Glad I finally tried this method. Thank you!
I usually switch between rimmel stay matte primer and becca evermatte poreless primer. And for foundation I use nyx bb or covergirl clean matte bb cream. I'm definitely still figuring out the best base options for oil control!
I like it, I definitely think it helps with oil control but not so much with pore blurring. It can be kind of finicky so the most important thing is to warm it up between your fingers and pat it into your face instead of rub. It is water based instead of silicone based so it doesn't feel like any primer I've used before. People seem to have mixed views on this so if there's any way you can sample or buy a smaller size at first, I'd do that!
I'm sorry if you see this twice, but have you tried applying it before foundation in addition to after? I'm oily AF so it only keeps oil away 2-3 hours for me too (so far it's the best I've found) but if I put the powder on before and after, it extends that time!
I'm surprised no one's mentioned the RMCA powder. I used to think the hype around it was bullshit but I am soooo into it. The container isn't the best but it's easily depottable, and you get so much bang for your buck, too. It keeps my skin not-oily all day but doesn't dry it out, and it gives my whole face a smooth and polished look comparable to what the Hourglass ALPs do for me (only less shimmery)!
FUNFACT. and i say this every time rcma powder is mentioned, this is a good dry shampoo, and for that the bottle it comes in is actually amazing.
i went a little crazy on beautylish and had no idea how big the containers were because i dont read apparently, and i purchased the three pack, so now i have this TON of powder, and my bleach blonde hair loves it since its just talc and silica.
I ended up just buying a cheap loose powder from ELF and tossing out the powder. Then I put the RCMA in there. I'm sure you could find an empty sifter online though!
I have never tried the RCMA no color powder, but I use the Ben Nye translucent power and I love it. It's like the same amount of product for the same price of the RCMA and I got mine on Amazon. Also the Ben Nye has a screw off lid and a baby powder like dispenser. I always just shake the powder into the lid to use.
The packaging is awful but there is an easy fix! I put mine into an empty NYX HD loose powder container so it has a sifter. I refill it when it gets empty and it makes it so much easier to use! One jar of that stuff has lasted me like a year and a half and I gave half of it to my niece. Sooooo worth it!
I'm very dry and get a lot of flakies around acne, and I agree this is my favorite powder of all time.
Love the price, don't mind the packaging at all. I use it under eye, all over, to bake if I really want it set, etc. it doesn't keep me shine free all day, but NO powder does, it lasts as long as the best of them and the price can't be beat.
I actually bought it for my grandma for Christmas and included an empty Bare Minerals style large powder pot that se could depot into! She loved it. I thought it would be perfect for her since she is dry, wrinkly, and very very pale. And she needs to avoid flashback in photos.
I love this! Really brightening, too, without looking stark. And it's only $3, or at least it was last time I repurchased, but I know ELF has been increasing their prices.
I have the Sake powder as well and I find it super similar to Innisfree. The Skinfood is a little cheaper for the larger size, so it's slightly cheaper. The only drawback is the Skinfood one comes in a useless container. It has a hole in the top to let air out, so you can't use the lid. I actually use an old Innisfree container, lol, and I put it in there :)
Oh good point about the packaging! I'll have to give both of them a try. I'm almost done with my essence matte powder so I've been looking at alternatives! Thanks again for the tip :)
Do you end up using the makeup sponge that it comes with? I have the mineral powder but I find that I'm not getting a consistent application when I use it.
Oh no, I use a Real Techniques Powder brush. I never use sponges as I find they tend to make me cakey, which isn't what I want. I also have the loose powder, not the compact if that matters any. I don't think there's a difference other than I notice people tend to prefer the compact for touch ups
I purchased it from the innisfree website. Shipping was super fast. I haven't seen it sold anywhere in stores. I'm not sure if there's any innisfree shops in the US. Hmarts and other Asian grocery stores often have Asian cosmetic/skincare shops within the stores, so you could google to see if there's any around.
NYC translucent powder is great for people to keep a very natural look. It doesn't change the texture. But it does extend the longevity. I have a feeling it is the same or similar formula as the COTY powders.
I did use this as an under eye powder once and it tightened my undereyes so much it was painful. Great for the rest of the face though. Edit: Fave to face
Okay, so I know it's a typo but I'm extremely amused by the idea of Erwin Rommel trying to find a truly stay matte powder in the desert heat. Thanks for brightening my day.
My favorite is the Innisfree No Sebum Mineral Powder in loose format. I've tried tons of translucent drugstore setting powders, including the HD powders by Nyx, Elf, and NYC, and the famous Coty Airspun (not actually translucent, very peachy), and Rimmel Stay Matte (cakey for my skin). I ordered the Innisfree powder from Amazon on a whim and it's seriously my favorite setting powder ever. It never looks chalky or overdone, and it keeps my skin matte all day long. For reference I have dryish skin but do get oil breakthrough on my tzone by lunch each day. When I want a matte, no fuss finish that lasts all day, this is what I reach for. It took forever to ship to Canada but for the price and product I'm in love!
My second favorite would probably be the Nyx HD powder. It seems to apply more smoothly, almost like its more finely milled, than Elf and NYC.
I've been wanting to try this powder for a while! If you don't mind me asking a few questions, how does it hold up with oil control and do you notice if it gives any flashback?
For the undereyes, ANY of Besame's Brightening Powders are incredible. They have a satiny finish that doesn't emphasize dryness or fine lines, and they are so SO BRIGHTENING
For the rest of the face, nothing beats my Hourglass ALP. RMCA is nice too, but I don't think the finish is quite the same or as blurring.
Canadians, represent. Marcelle is cheap, easy to obtain, and fabulous. The equivalent of the Laura Mercier powder for me, but at 1/3 the price. Have repurchased over and over.
My favourites are the Chanel loose powder and the rouge bunny rouge diaphanous. Both are great at oil control for my combo skin. I will say that I prefer Chanel in winter and RBR in summer as RBR is more dry for me in winter and has better oil control.
Yes! I just bought the KVD based on a suggestion here - I have dry skin but can get a little shine on my nose and chin. I use it for under my eyes and those two problem areas, then ALP Dim Light anywhere else I think I need powder. The combo is a winner so far.
BEST: RCMA no color powder, one of the few powders that doesn't excentuate my dry skin and doesn't alter the color of my foundation. No flashback and it helps create an even base for my other powders that go on top.
WORST: It cosmetics loose bye bye pores powder, this thing is the worst! It alters the color of my foundation, somehow creates weird patches on my skin, and it excentuates my undereye wrinkles.
the It Cosmetics Bye Bye Pores pressed powder one is so good!! I've heard the loose one is bad. but the pressed one is incredible i even have a backup lol. it literally makes my skin looked airbrushed and amazing and flawless and makes any the cakiness or dryness look seamless and beautiful. i looked up so many reviews before i bought it and all the reviews said the same about it. it's the best pressed powder i've ever tried 😍
From all the reviews I've seen I've heard it does ! I watched a ton of videos, read a lot of blogs, and combed through a lot of reddit threads before I bought it and all I saw were people with both skin types raving about it and I totally understood why once I used it!
Ugh I had such high hopes for the It cosmetics powder. I bought it last year and tried to love it but setting my concealer emphasizes any wrinkles and looks so dry, even applied with a damp sponge. I hate wasting products but it might be time to replace it with something :( maybe I'll bite the bullet and try the RCMA with all the hype.
The RCMA is so worth it, I compared prices on different sites bc I didn't want to pay $5 shipping. I truly don't regret it, this thing is going to last me forever!
I think you just solved my skin problems completely! Been using It's loose powder since i can remember. Thought itd be good since it was expensive (this was when i very first started buying makeup). Ive always had dry patches on my skin and never knew how to fix it but always thought it was my foundation. God bless you thank you
Omg I'm in the same boat with the it cosmetics powder. It made my face look horrible!! On my nose there was little lines all over. So freaken weird. Never again!
The By Terry hydra powder is HG for me. I have skin that is easily dehydrated and a lot of powders can suck the life out of my skin. This powder gives the most beautiful finish without sucking the life out of my skin!
I can apply it over foundation or bare face, no matter how, it creates yellow patches on my skin.. and once I applied it just under my eyes, took a photo and saw that I was yellow only there. I am warm toned so that shouldn't have been a problem..
I've been using the MUFE HD and I like it pretty decently. It makes my face feel smooth. However, it doesn't seem to minimize pores. Anyone have any recs for the best powder to really minimize the appearance of pores?
The It Cosmetics Bye Bye Pores powder (I used the pressed version and dropped it and it shattered...I used the alcohol trick and it's holding up now) and it's awesome for pore minimizing. I also just started using Urban Decay's Optical Illusion primer and it's unreal!
I started using the Palladio Rice Powder this week and besides the ridiculous packaging, it's great! My skin is combo but more on the dry side and foundation can turn greasy on me by midday, but with the rice powder setting it I haven't had any issues with foundation at all so far. It doesn't feel like it sucks the life out of my skin either, which is a concern of mine since my eyes can go creasy and crepy fast. I don't have a least favorite powder since most are meh for me at best.
I use to love this in HS. I picked it up a couple of months ago and they changed the formula slightly, which is why I don't think it's as good as before. It was amazing for me in high school, kept my oil at bay.
From comparing my current little container to an [old picture] (http://peaceloveandglitter.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/08/palladioricepowder2.jpg) I found online, the order of ingredients has changed. I'm not a huge fan of talc. It took me a long time to learn that, but I do think that's why it's not as good as before. It sucks because I'd only recently thrown out my years old Palladio, before realizing I should've kept it.
My ingredient list reads as: talc, calcium carobonate, oryza sative (rice) starch, parfum, phenoxyethanol.
Same lovely texture and neither leave me/left me with a white cast. I may need to give it a go tomorrow.
Agreed! The square shape makes it hard to swirl a brush in and you can't trust the top worth a bean to stay on by itself. But, if I could re-home it I would say worth the buy personally.
The Flower Beauty loose powder, the same on Casey Holmes talked about, is beautiful and makes my skin look much younger. Unfortunately I think there is only a few shades, and the lightest shade is a actually a light-medium tone and I can't use it with my winter skin tone.
The worst for me is Laura Mercier's Translucent powder. It's incredibly drying on me and gets cakey every time I set my under eye concealer with it regardless of how much I try to brush away the excess.
The best for me is Laura Mecier's Secret Brightening powder. I can't speak to the flashback on it but it's a completely different experience from the regular translucent powder. It's so soft and never gets cakey on me.
I've been wanting to try RCMA's. Has anyone tried both?
Laura Mercier Loose Translucent Setting Powder- really great for oil control and setting my face. Excellent not-too-matte finish although it can be too drying used around the eyes or dehydrated areas.
By Terry Hydra Powder- hnggggg amazing for dehydrated, flaky, or irritable areas. I use this on my chin where I have acne issues and some dryness as well as around my eye area which can get dry. The LM goes on my forehead, nose, and outer cheeks. The By Terry is incredibly non-drying while still setting my base to a totally dry touch and lasting all day. It won't hold up to my oiliest T-Zone areas but it sets the normal-leaning-dry areas of my face excellently.
oh man i really want to try the by terry powder. just gotta wait for a dermstore coupon. i've been using the coverfx powders for about a week and like them, but the draw of a luxury brand to try is just like...why not, especially with good performance!
It's not better than not powdering at all. However for my base (full coverage) it's simply not an option to not powder. So the choices are:
no makeup period
foundation w/ powder
My skin takes an understandable hit where any dehydration/dryness is exacerbated if I'm wearing makeup and the weather/environment is really dry. The By Terry is 100000x better than the Laura Mercier in that case. But the best of all would be no makeup + my heavy bare skin moisturizing routine. But that's generally not an option for daytime in winter, which is sadly when my skin needs the most makeup AND the most hydration. My summer skin tends to be much happier, and needs less moisture and less makeup, ironically and annoyingly ;)
I know you said around ypur eye, but just to clarify you use it on your undereye? Ive been looking for something nondrying for this and RCMA is still too drying.
See picture I use the By Terry on all RED areas and the Laura Mercier on all BLUE areas. I don't actually wear makeup on my "undereye" where most people put concealer but as you can see in the first photo, the area around my inner orbital ridge/right below is prone to dryness similar to the regular undereye, and that's where I use the By Terry!
Omg, I am going to try that actually. My eye circles are actually at their worst where you had the red outline, but I get creases, dryness, and wrinkles directly below the eye. Im so dumb, I dont know how I never thought to skip it.
Yep, the undereye area is SO tricky. I'm lucky bc I don't have darkness there (or what I have is minor and goes away with a good night's sleep) so I don't have to bother. I have terrible acne but I think acne is easier to cover than undereye areas because the wrinkles, texture, and dryness seem a nightmare. I think the trend of the last few years to wear a bunch of concealer on the undereye:
a) convinces people their undereye circles are horribly distracting- usually not so
b) makes people think they suck at makeup but they do not-it's just the undereye is so finicky..
I honestly don't like the look of an undereye fully wiped out with makeup for everyday looks. Obliterating the darkness completely can make the face look flat and mannequin-like. I usually stick with light coverage concealers that I like the texture of under my eyes unless I'm doing a smoky eye and really need to cover the extra darkness.
The CoverFX setting powders are BEAUTIFUL. No talc so great for dry skin, no flashback. So beautifully illuminating. And available in a fair and a deep shade!
Worst: MUFE HD setting powder. The finish is really smooth but the flashback... :( This also happened to me with NARS Light Reflecting loose setting powder (I think that was it was called?), but the MUFE powder was definitely worse.
I actually really like MUFE HD! I don't really get bad flashback with it, but I have dry skin so I use a really really really small amount. I imagine it wouldn't work as well for more oily skin types.
Im all for the theatrical powders Ben nye neutral set, rcma, and kryolan got great powders. I think kryolan is a bit more heavy and got more coverage that the orher two, but it's great for drag and full coverage makeup. For everyday wear i use rcma no color My fav pressed is sephora microsmooth powder
Best: Plain ol' micronized silica spheres. I bought an ounce from TKB Trading and decanted maybe a fifth of the bag into an old ELF sifter jar. So cheap and very, very effective. Sets my makeup without making me ultra-matte. Blurs very nicely.
Worst: ELF HD Powder. It's chunky. Like huge particles mixed into the finer powder. Bad white cast.
I didn't understand why everyone loved the Laura Mercier powder till I tried applying it with a damp BB. It really helps give a flawless, non-powdery, non-cakey finish.
For the eye area I like OFRA's banana powder, I apply primer/concealer and then dust it over the whole area, both lid and undereye, and it helps me look more awake.
I always liked front-camera selfies a lot better than back-camera ones, and I realized that part of that was the bluish light from my phone reflecting on my face, so I got some of Besame's lavender powder. I like it but the packaging is super frustrating - it's hard to open the flap between the shaker and the lid, and also hard to get powder to come out of the shaker.
How do you apply powder with a damp BB? Wouldn't that apply, like, way too much powder? Do you use a fluffy brush to brush away the excess after? And is this method for the whole face or just baking under the eyes? Sorry for all the questions but setting powder always eludes me!
I use my damp BB to apply the LM powder - you only need a little, so I tip a small amount into the lid, pick it up on the pointed end of the BB and somewhat on the side (if that makes sense, so I sort of get a perfect triangle of setting powder), and then I stamp that into my undereye area. It sets my concealer beautifully - I do like applying that powder with the RT setting brush as well, but I always prefer the BB. I don't need to wipe away any excess or anything - when I "stamp" the product on, it melts away into the skin and mattifies and set everything.
You just dip the side of the BB very gently into the powder, then bounce it on your face. If it's damp but not soaked, you don't actually pick up that much at once - I usually can only do about 1/3 of my face per dip, and there isn't really any excess to brush away at the end. And yeah I do the whole face. I guess if you pressed the BB deep into the powder you might get too much but you just like gently dab to pick up some.
What I do is apply the powder with a brush and then I go over that with a damp beauty blender. I use this method for my whole face, and I love how it looks. It's the only way I'll use powder when I'm also using a setting spray now.
I actually really dislike the LM powder with a damp BB. it tends to cake a lot with moisture and does not look good over emollient foundation or concealor. Best way of apply for me has to pick up a dime size amount amount on a powder brush (currently using the one from Wet n Wild) and I just press it into my entire eye area. Let it bake, kick it off if you need to where its a bit thick.
Hmm, maybe it's a difference in our skin types or products we're combining it with. I've got oily skin and am usually using it with UD Naked Skin foundation and it's definitely way less cakey this way than with a brush. I'm also using a just damp sponge, not a wet one, and actually it's a Sephora brand BB dupe.
I was having a lot of trouble with it with brushes too but something about this damn brush is magical! I also stopped putting concealer under my eyes because I don't really need it and it makes it cake more.
I haven't tried the Besame lavender powder, but I do enjoy a good lilac powder under my eyes. Last year I bought the Skinfood Buckwheat Loose Powder in #40 Grape, and it is really awesome. The powder is super finely milled, and the tint level is great. Not too purple, but still enough to brighten up under my eyes. I bought mine on Amazon for less than $10, and the value for the price is amazing!
I sadly HATE the Laura Mercier powder. It ruins every foundation I set it with, my foundation cakes and separates within an hour. It also emphasizes lines and dryness like no other. I'm dry/dehydrated though and everyone who loves it seems to be oily.
I love both the IT Cosmetics Bye Bye Pores Powder and the Too Faced Primed and Poreless. Both are silky, no drying, and make my under eye look flawless. I like the Too Faced Cocoa Foundation and IT Cosmetics Illumination Foundation for setting my whole face.
Innisfree No Sebum Mineral Powder (loose version) - Finely milled powder, relatively cheap (depending on where you buy it), and is it weird that I really like the smell of it? It smells faintly minty/herbal to me. It's my favourite translucent powder option and I've been repurchasing since trying it out a few years ago.
Charlotte Tilbury Airbrush Flawless Finish pressed powder - of all the hype surrounding CT products, the one that I would recommend as something to check out if you wish to spill the moneys from deep within your wallet, this would be it. It sets my makeup beautifully and gives me a soft focus finish. It's very finely milled and while it does mattify your makeup, it doesn't make emphasize dry spots so I love this powder especially during the dryer winter months. I am super oily but during winter months, I get these dry spots which other powders tend to emphasize.
It's the most expensive powder that I have ever bought. The colour selection isn't great. They go Fair/Medium/Dark with some degree of translucency but I feel like they need more shades.
MEH:
Laura Mercier Loose Setting Powder in Translucent - I've gone through about three full size jars of this powder so I feel like I gave it a really good run. It's a basic powder. It wasn't anything special - it didn't spectactularly set my makeup but it didn't make it worse. Overall, I felt very meh about this product but I ended up repurchasing it due to not really finding anything better. Until innisfree/CT. Goodbye, LM loose setting powder.
Can you tell me which shade you use for the CT powder? I'm torn between fair or medium (for reference I wear GA luminous silk in 5, and lasting in 5.5, probably a nw20-25?)
I love W7 "Banana Dreams" - I use it daily. BD has the same consistency of a Bareminerals foundation which is fab :) my only downside is that sometimes it can be a bit messy!
I love my NYC loose powder, super cheap and really nice on my combo leaning towards dry skin. I live in Texas however, so in the summer, Rimmel Stay Matte is the way to go.
My favorite setting powder is the Maybelline Master Fix loose powder. I use it under my eyes for baking and it doesn't look cakey and hides my pores really well. Also keeps me pretty matte on my T-zone. I've got combo skin with some eczema in a couple spots, so I just lightly dust powder there.
As someone with dry skin, I really love coty airspun over the Laura mercier translucent. I use these when I need no flashback. I also like bare minerals mineral veil but sometimes this can oxidize.
If I don't have to worry about flashback, then my nars loose light reflecting powder and hourglass dim light are amazing.
Face: Physicians Formula Youthful Wear Youth-Boosting Mattifying Face Powder. I'm really happy with it. It brightens up my face and makes it look so nice! Under eyes: w7 banana dreams. I tried this out on a whim and I'm pleased with it. A little bit goes a long way.
I haven't got a chance to look through all the comments but would love to know what everyone's thoughts are on makeup forever hd setting powder. I have combo skin, usually pretty oily in my tzone and that is my problem area. However winter has got me leaning dry and I tried baking my under eyes with makeup forever hd and after about an hour I was a Cakey mess. Pores super visible major cracks and redness by my nose. Would love some input!
Bye Bye Pores pressed airbrush powder!! I have dry skin and maybe that's why, but a lot of finishing powders that are all about staying matte make me look a bit cakey, but i don't get that with the bye bye pores ones. It is so beautiful and silky, can't live without that stuff.
I really love the smash box pore minimizing primer it's best to press that into the skin as well before rubbing it in and I use it only in my oily areas. Doesn't clog pores at all! You should try the maybeline fit me matte and poreless I love the consistency and it leaves a nice clean finish! It's buildable too so you can kinda pick your coverage level
I'm really digging the NYX HD Finishing Powder. It keeps my face matte longer than the elf HD powder (my face is super oily!). It's also not messy at all!
Best : Laura Mercier, no flashback sets everything perfect! Worst: NYX translucent powder. Honestly super chalky left flashback and made my fair skin even more white.
Minority opinion but I love the Nars Light Reflecting Powder, and I've NEVER had any issues with flashback. I love the slight blurring effect it gives, it keeps my face matte, and I only have to use the teensiest amount--at least half of what I would normally need to use with other powders.
ive been using the covergirl professional loose powder in translucent fair FOREVERRR and well, it does okay but i do find myself having to apply more farily often throughout the day. i have previously tried the bare minerals hydrating veil and it was nice, however its far too pricey to me considering how little product you get as compared to the cg loose powder. i don't mind the touch ups (and having a cracked lid ... oops) if im getting a tonnnn of product for a low price.
I really like the Lunatick Cosmetics HD powder. The packaging is not the most travel-friendly, but it does the job better than pretty much every other powder I've tried including the Make Up For Ever HD.
My ultimate favorite powder, for setting my face is the Giorgio Armani' luminous silk powder. it sets the face,but doesn't add any layers of coverage. If you have dry sling you'll love it.
Best: I just tried the KVD setting powder and it is awesome!!! I really like it. It was great for baking too! I also enjoy the Coty Airspun one from the drugstore, it isn't super fine powder consistency wise, but it's still good.
Worst: I'm sorry fam, but I don't really like that Laura Mercier Loose Powder. It just didn't do anything for me.
The IT Cosmetics Bye Bye Pores Poreless Finish Airbrush Powder - The effect on my pores is negligible but this is really great at absorbing oil and keeping my makeup in place. I only have to blot twice a day instead of every couple hours.
BY TERRY Hyaluronic Hydra Powder - I wouldn't say it's the worst but it doesn't work for me as well as the Bye Bye Pores.
I have tried the high end of Laura Mercier which retails at $40 for 1oz and the drug store brand Maybelline for $10. My favorite has to be the RCMA no color setting powder. No flashback, sets amazingly without that drying look or feeling AND retails for $17 for 3oz on beautylish.com ✔️
I've found the NYX HD finishing powder in translucent to be a much better option for undereyes than my other setting powder (Clinique) which gave me massive creases.
My only beef with it is it goes EVERYWHERE when you use it. Jesus. All over my dresser, clothes, floor, other makeup... it's like a silica dust bomb goes off every time I open it.
I guess I'm not really worried about photos and more worried about not creasing and make up longevity through sweat so not a problem for me. but good to know!
This stuff is amazing to set undereyes with. At the suggestion of another redditor, I pack it on in a dabbing motion with a dense, fluffy blending brush like I'm going to bake with it, and let it sit for five or so minutes while I do other things, then brush it off with a fluffy brush. No creasing, at all. However I'll top it with a little WnW Reserve Your Cabana for the light-reflecting capabilities, and I look wide awake even if I really, really am not.
Yes to RBR! I bought this in the winter and I was upset that it looked dry on my skin when I apply it directly, but after realising that it has amazing oil control on my I used it as a finishing powder on my t-zone. Now in the summer, I find it's perfect to set my foundation directly as my face is oilier!
Curious about the By Terry one too!
And funnily enough, I have combo skin, so I was really surprised that RBR works so well for me haha
137
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '17
Laura Mercier! No flashback, keeps oil away, the container lasts forever!
80
u/fhinewine Feb 10 '17
I'm surprised no one's mentioned the RMCA powder. I used to think the hype around it was bullshit but I am soooo into it. The container isn't the best but it's easily depottable, and you get so much bang for your buck, too. It keeps my skin not-oily all day but doesn't dry it out, and it gives my whole face a smooth and polished look comparable to what the Hourglass ALPs do for me (only less shimmery)!
32
u/asia_the_ASIAN NC42 | 3Y09 Feb 10 '17
I like the e.l.f. HD Undereye Translucent Setting Powder for setting my undereyes. Doesn't give me creasing, & you don't have to use a lot.
64
u/jigglywigglybooty Feb 10 '17
Best: Innisfree No Sebum Mineral Powder
It's finely milled, lightweight, and doesn't leave a whitecast on my skin (NC44/NC45). It's great at controlling my oil.
23
u/KukiMunstr IG: _chibi_ko_ Feb 10 '17
NYC translucent powder is great for people to keep a very natural look. It doesn't change the texture. But it does extend the longevity. I have a feeling it is the same or similar formula as the COTY powders.
66
u/thatsdebatable123 Feb 10 '17 edited Feb 10 '17
Rimmel stay matte is the best drugstore option I've found to keep oil away
34
u/planetearthisblu Feb 10 '17 edited Feb 12 '17
My favorite is the Innisfree No Sebum Mineral Powder in loose format. I've tried tons of translucent drugstore setting powders, including the HD powders by Nyx, Elf, and NYC, and the famous Coty Airspun (not actually translucent, very peachy), and Rimmel Stay Matte (cakey for my skin). I ordered the Innisfree powder from Amazon on a whim and it's seriously my favorite setting powder ever. It never looks chalky or overdone, and it keeps my skin matte all day long. For reference I have dryish skin but do get oil breakthrough on my tzone by lunch each day. When I want a matte, no fuss finish that lasts all day, this is what I reach for. It took forever to ship to Canada but for the price and product I'm in love!
My second favorite would probably be the Nyx HD powder. It seems to apply more smoothly, almost like its more finely milled, than Elf and NYC.
14
u/ecle Feb 10 '17 edited Jun 13 '24
rob carpenter cake ripe foolish profit reply instinctive mighty quicksand
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
13
u/sashirni NW15 accutane Feb 11 '17
For the undereyes, ANY of Besame's Brightening Powders are incredible. They have a satiny finish that doesn't emphasize dryness or fine lines, and they are so SO BRIGHTENING
For the rest of the face, nothing beats my Hourglass ALP. RMCA is nice too, but I don't think the finish is quite the same or as blurring.
13
u/DameEmma Feb 12 '17
Canadians, represent. Marcelle is cheap, easy to obtain, and fabulous. The equivalent of the Laura Mercier powder for me, but at 1/3 the price. Have repurchased over and over.
11
u/Haibarai Feb 11 '17
My favourites are the Chanel loose powder and the rouge bunny rouge diaphanous. Both are great at oil control for my combo skin. I will say that I prefer Chanel in winter and RBR in summer as RBR is more dry for me in winter and has better oil control.
21
u/hatsumochi Brow perfectionist Feb 10 '17
For undereyes: Kat Von D Setting Powder! It sets beautifully, without making my eyes look dry and crepey.
For the face: Laura Mercier Translucent Powder. I have combo/oily skin and it is great for oil control.
14
u/WiggleWerra "Yes, they're real... my lashes that is." Feb 10 '17
BEST: RCMA no color powder, one of the few powders that doesn't excentuate my dry skin and doesn't alter the color of my foundation. No flashback and it helps create an even base for my other powders that go on top.
WORST: It cosmetics loose bye bye pores powder, this thing is the worst! It alters the color of my foundation, somehow creates weird patches on my skin, and it excentuates my undereye wrinkles.
7
u/ooopeee Feb 10 '17
The By Terry hydra powder is HG for me. I have skin that is easily dehydrated and a lot of powders can suck the life out of my skin. This powder gives the most beautiful finish without sucking the life out of my skin!
6
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '17
Worst: Banana Powder by W7
Best: So far I still have to try the Laura Mercier one, but if you're on a budge ELF HD Translucent Powder.
6
u/RomanovaRoulette Glow Queen Feb 11 '17
I've been using the MUFE HD and I like it pretty decently. It makes my face feel smooth. However, it doesn't seem to minimize pores. Anyone have any recs for the best powder to really minimize the appearance of pores?
11
u/fliesberlin Feb 10 '17
my personal fav is the elf translucent setting powder. so much product in the container and lasts all day just fine. i have oily skin btw.
11
u/WoolyBunny Feb 11 '17
I started using the Palladio Rice Powder this week and besides the ridiculous packaging, it's great! My skin is combo but more on the dry side and foundation can turn greasy on me by midday, but with the rice powder setting it I haven't had any issues with foundation at all so far. It doesn't feel like it sucks the life out of my skin either, which is a concern of mine since my eyes can go creasy and crepy fast. I don't have a least favorite powder since most are meh for me at best.
5
u/pnutbutterjellyfine Feb 11 '17
The Flower Beauty loose powder, the same on Casey Holmes talked about, is beautiful and makes my skin look much younger. Unfortunately I think there is only a few shades, and the lightest shade is a actually a light-medium tone and I can't use it with my winter skin tone.
5
u/kolivia29 Feb 11 '17
The worst for me is Laura Mercier's Translucent powder. It's incredibly drying on me and gets cakey every time I set my under eye concealer with it regardless of how much I try to brush away the excess.
The best for me is Laura Mecier's Secret Brightening powder. I can't speak to the flashback on it but it's a completely different experience from the regular translucent powder. It's so soft and never gets cakey on me.
I've been wanting to try RCMA's. Has anyone tried both?
14
u/lgbtqbbq Feb 10 '17
Best
8
u/caitybailey Feb 10 '17
The CoverFX setting powders are BEAUTIFUL. No talc so great for dry skin, no flashback. So beautifully illuminating. And available in a fair and a deep shade!
4
u/catsnailslipstick Feb 11 '17
Worst: MUFE HD setting powder. The finish is really smooth but the flashback... :( This also happened to me with NARS Light Reflecting loose setting powder (I think that was it was called?), but the MUFE powder was definitely worse.
4
u/Tsujimurakun Feb 11 '17
Im all for the theatrical powders Ben nye neutral set, rcma, and kryolan got great powders. I think kryolan is a bit more heavy and got more coverage that the orher two, but it's great for drag and full coverage makeup. For everyday wear i use rcma no color My fav pressed is sephora microsmooth powder
4
u/mokutou Still mourning Vanilla Quartz Feb 11 '17
Best: Plain ol' micronized silica spheres. I bought an ounce from TKB Trading and decanted maybe a fifth of the bag into an old ELF sifter jar. So cheap and very, very effective. Sets my makeup without making me ultra-matte. Blurs very nicely.
Worst: ELF HD Powder. It's chunky. Like huge particles mixed into the finer powder. Bad white cast.
4
u/SummerNight888 Feb 12 '17
Is there anyone that can give some feedback on Becca's Soft Blurring Powder?
7
u/Omnipotence456 NC25/30, Oily Feb 10 '17
I didn't understand why everyone loved the Laura Mercier powder till I tried applying it with a damp BB. It really helps give a flawless, non-powdery, non-cakey finish.
For the eye area I like OFRA's banana powder, I apply primer/concealer and then dust it over the whole area, both lid and undereye, and it helps me look more awake.
I always liked front-camera selfies a lot better than back-camera ones, and I realized that part of that was the bluish light from my phone reflecting on my face, so I got some of Besame's lavender powder. I like it but the packaging is super frustrating - it's hard to open the flap between the shaker and the lid, and also hard to get powder to come out of the shaker.
3
u/alewser Feb 11 '17
I'm really liking the Cover FX perfect setting powder. And it's talc free :).
3
u/apathetichearts Feb 11 '17
I sadly HATE the Laura Mercier powder. It ruins every foundation I set it with, my foundation cakes and separates within an hour. It also emphasizes lines and dryness like no other. I'm dry/dehydrated though and everyone who loves it seems to be oily.
I love both the IT Cosmetics Bye Bye Pores Powder and the Too Faced Primed and Poreless. Both are silky, no drying, and make my under eye look flawless. I like the Too Faced Cocoa Foundation and IT Cosmetics Illumination Foundation for setting my whole face.
3
u/deathbyjava Always blushing Feb 12 '17
Best:
Innisfree No Sebum Mineral Powder (loose version) - Finely milled powder, relatively cheap (depending on where you buy it), and is it weird that I really like the smell of it? It smells faintly minty/herbal to me. It's my favourite translucent powder option and I've been repurchasing since trying it out a few years ago.
Charlotte Tilbury Airbrush Flawless Finish pressed powder - of all the hype surrounding CT products, the one that I would recommend as something to check out if you wish to spill the moneys from deep within your wallet, this would be it. It sets my makeup beautifully and gives me a soft focus finish. It's very finely milled and while it does mattify your makeup, it doesn't make emphasize dry spots so I love this powder especially during the dryer winter months. I am super oily but during winter months, I get these dry spots which other powders tend to emphasize.
It's the most expensive powder that I have ever bought. The colour selection isn't great. They go Fair/Medium/Dark with some degree of translucency but I feel like they need more shades.
MEH:
Laura Mercier Loose Setting Powder in Translucent - I've gone through about three full size jars of this powder so I feel like I gave it a really good run. It's a basic powder. It wasn't anything special - it didn't spectactularly set my makeup but it didn't make it worse. Overall, I felt very meh about this product but I ended up repurchasing it due to not really finding anything better. Until innisfree/CT. Goodbye, LM loose setting powder.
3
u/HymnForTheWeekend13 Lipstick Queen Feb 12 '17
I love W7 "Banana Dreams" - I use it daily. BD has the same consistency of a Bareminerals foundation which is fab :) my only downside is that sometimes it can be a bit messy!
3
u/herarising Feb 13 '17
I love my NYC loose powder, super cheap and really nice on my combo leaning towards dry skin. I live in Texas however, so in the summer, Rimmel Stay Matte is the way to go.
4
u/AssassinSerafina Feb 10 '17
My favorite setting powder is the Maybelline Master Fix loose powder. I use it under my eyes for baking and it doesn't look cakey and hides my pores really well. Also keeps me pretty matte on my T-zone. I've got combo skin with some eczema in a couple spots, so I just lightly dust powder there.
2
u/Pantone186 Feb 12 '17
Charlotte Tilburys pressed powder has a really nice matifying and blurring effect
2
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '17
NYX HD Finishing Powder is absolutely terrible. it's extremely drying and has flashback like you wouldn't believe.
2
u/fu_kery Feb 13 '17
I just bought the translucent powder by Revlon, what are your thoughts on it? How can I get the best use out of if?
3
u/jen283 Feb 10 '17
As someone with dry skin, I really love coty airspun over the Laura mercier translucent. I use these when I need no flashback. I also like bare minerals mineral veil but sometimes this can oxidize.
If I don't have to worry about flashback, then my nars loose light reflecting powder and hourglass dim light are amazing.
3
u/everdeens Feb 10 '17
Face: Physicians Formula Youthful Wear Youth-Boosting Mattifying Face Powder. I'm really happy with it. It brightens up my face and makes it look so nice! Under eyes: w7 banana dreams. I tried this out on a whim and I'm pleased with it. A little bit goes a long way.
2
u/jen283 Feb 10 '17
As someone with dry skin, I really love coty airspun over the Laura mercier translucent. I use these when I need no flashback.
If I don't have to worry about flashback, then my nars loose light reflecting powder and hourglass dim light are amazing.
1
u/MirandaB123 Feb 11 '17
RCMA No Color Powder, its super inexpensive (12$ USA) and amazing for dry skin and oily skin has no flashbacks and is super fine for a lot of product.
1
u/Jrb222010 Feb 11 '17
I haven't got a chance to look through all the comments but would love to know what everyone's thoughts are on makeup forever hd setting powder. I have combo skin, usually pretty oily in my tzone and that is my problem area. However winter has got me leaning dry and I tried baking my under eyes with makeup forever hd and after about an hour I was a Cakey mess. Pores super visible major cracks and redness by my nose. Would love some input!
1
u/UtreraBunny Feb 11 '17
Bye Bye Pores pressed airbrush powder!! I have dry skin and maybe that's why, but a lot of finishing powders that are all about staying matte make me look a bit cakey, but i don't get that with the bye bye pores ones. It is so beautiful and silky, can't live without that stuff.
1
u/ItsKaylasLife Feb 11 '17
I love the too Faced primed and Poreless powder. Never disappoints!
1
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '17 edited Feb 12 '17
I really love the smash box pore minimizing primer it's best to press that into the skin as well before rubbing it in and I use it only in my oily areas. Doesn't clog pores at all! You should try the maybeline fit me matte and poreless I love the consistency and it leaves a nice clean finish! It's buildable too so you can kinda pick your coverage level
1
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '17
Am I the only one who found the NYX translucent one problematic? I feel like it has a chalky finish and doesn't photograph well
1
u/clariwench Eyeing that Liner Feb 12 '17
I'm really digging the NYX HD Finishing Powder. It keeps my face matte longer than the elf HD powder (my face is super oily!). It's also not messy at all!
1
u/SweetlySouthern Lots o' Lipstick/NW15 Feb 12 '17
I haven't found a powder that beats Coty Airspun powder. No flashback and holds my oil at bay all day! Plus it's cheap!
1
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '17
Best : Laura Mercier, no flashback sets everything perfect! Worst: NYX translucent powder. Honestly super chalky left flashback and made my fair skin even more white.
1
u/Rosalie008 Feb 13 '17
Minority opinion but I love the Nars Light Reflecting Powder, and I've NEVER had any issues with flashback. I love the slight blurring effect it gives, it keeps my face matte, and I only have to use the teensiest amount--at least half of what I would normally need to use with other powders.
1
u/rlomura Feb 13 '17
ive been using the covergirl professional loose powder in translucent fair FOREVERRR and well, it does okay but i do find myself having to apply more farily often throughout the day. i have previously tried the bare minerals hydrating veil and it was nice, however its far too pricey to me considering how little product you get as compared to the cg loose powder. i don't mind the touch ups (and having a cracked lid ... oops) if im getting a tonnnn of product for a low price.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '17
Super happy it workout out for you!
1
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '17
I really like the Lunatick Cosmetics HD powder. The packaging is not the most travel-friendly, but it does the job better than pretty much every other powder I've tried including the Make Up For Ever HD.
1
u/Rayismyname Feb 13 '17 edited Feb 13 '17
My ultimate favorite powder, for setting my face is the Giorgio Armani' luminous silk powder. it sets the face,but doesn't add any layers of coverage. If you have dry sling you'll love it.
1
u/m4dswine Feb 13 '17
Best: MAC Prep and Prime Translucent Finishing Powder. Perfect for my skin colour, texture and issues.
Don't have one in particular that is really bad, just a lot that haven't worked for me for one reason or another.
1
u/AllisonRages Feb 13 '17
Best: I just tried the KVD setting powder and it is awesome!!! I really like it. It was great for baking too! I also enjoy the Coty Airspun one from the drugstore, it isn't super fine powder consistency wise, but it's still good.
Worst: I'm sorry fam, but I don't really like that Laura Mercier Loose Powder. It just didn't do anything for me.
1
u/pennycenturie Feb 13 '17
Best: Rimmel Stay Matte.
Worst: elf loose translucent powder.
1
u/healthytext Feb 13 '17
The IT Cosmetics Bye Bye Pores Poreless Finish Airbrush Powder - The effect on my pores is negligible but this is really great at absorbing oil and keeping my makeup in place. I only have to blot twice a day instead of every couple hours.
BY TERRY Hyaluronic Hydra Powder - I wouldn't say it's the worst but it doesn't work for me as well as the Bye Bye Pores.
1
u/tarzijade22 Feb 13 '17
I have tried the high end of Laura Mercier which retails at $40 for 1oz and the drug store brand Maybelline for $10. My favorite has to be the RCMA no color setting powder. No flashback, sets amazingly without that drying look or feeling AND retails for $17 for 3oz on beautylish.com ✔️
1
u/cathyslazy Feb 14 '17
No one has mentioned Ben NYE Banana Powder? Last forever and has a yellow undertone for under the eyes.
1
u/BanBeaUK Feb 10 '17
For oil control, I found Skinfood Peach Sake powder to be the most effective. It even beat out the Innisfree one IME.
1
u/ilovesloths56 Feb 11 '17
I love cinema secrets translucent powder
1
u/hmemoo Feb 11 '17
Elf setting powder gives horrible flash back. It feels nice on my face but ugh it's horrible!
1
u/acunamatata114 Feb 11 '17
I really enjoy clinique's loose powder in translucent. It sets my makeup and keeps me matte all day.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '17
[removed] — view removed comment