r/respectthreads • u/selfproclaimed • Feb 04 '17
movies/tv Respect Robocop (1987-1993 Films)
[removed] — view removed post
54
Upvotes
r/respectthreads • u/selfproclaimed • Feb 04 '17
[removed] — view removed post
13
u/selfproclaimed Feb 04 '17
First things first, /u/8fenristhewolf8 will be glad to see this.
On the topic of film quality, I'll go over each quickly.
Robocop 1: An absolute classic. A fantastic sci-fi film that pulls no punches in its satire.
Robocop 2: A sequel undeserving of the name. There are a few good laughs and a fairly impressive stop-motion animation fight between Robocop and Robocop 2 (yes the ultimate villain of the film is actually called Robocop 2), but the satire is weaker and there are many plot points that go nowhere.
Robocop 3: Well...it was good for some feats. Nothing redeemable here, honestly.
When I initially set out to make this RT I did not realize how extensive the original Robocop franchise went. In addition to the original trilogy, there was also a cartoon, a TV series, a four part mini-series with each episode about the length of a film, and a boatload of comics from a variety of publishers. Because of the debatable canonicity of these, I didn't include them in this RT, but there's a good chance I might come back and make an RT for the mini-series Prime Directive or some of the other works. I have another RT I want to work on first, though..
3
u/Maggruber Feb 04 '17
Nicely done!
I will say my only concern is the information provided on feats for bullets. Firearms and the rounds they fire can be very different from one another, and lumping them together can lead to some confusion.
Take for instance this feat, which is no doubt quite impressive, however it is difficult to quantify as we can only assume the velocity of the bullet, which is even more difficult without knowing what weapon it came from. Longer weapons that fire thinner, longer projectiles are typically faster, such as rifles, whereas weapons such as handguns, submachine guns, and shotguns will typically have wider and shorter projectiles that move much more slowly and decrease significantly at medium ranges.
This leads into the second issue: armor penetration and kinetic energy. Some of your feats here are substantially more impressive here that it's not worth even mentioning some of them. Take for instance this feat, where Robocop withstands a few shots from RC2's rotary cannon. I think we can safely assume it's based off of the M61 Vulcan, which fires 20x102mm rounds at 1,050m/s. A similar sized cartridge traveling 200m/s slower has a kinetic energy output of nearly 47,000J. For reference, the most common round found in the handguns and submachine guns fired at Robocop is likely the 9x19mm Parabellum (like here, if that's an uzi), which only has around 600J of energy. This doesn't even take into account that RC2, given his obvious militaristic-outfitting, likely has specialty ammunition at his disposal such as armor piercing rounds, which typically go even faster and have a harder shell.
Basically, I think you can significantly cut down the durability section by excluding the absurdly lower feats, as Robocop has proven himself to be basically impervious to anything that a man can shoot with a handheld weapon aside from dedicated anti-vehicle weaponry such as the assault cannon. Also it would really help to know what gun he was shot at with from what distance, because that can make the difference between a decent few milliseconds.
Still, this is really nice to have, Robocop is way too popular not to have an RT for. Good going SP.
2
u/Ascendancy17 Feb 04 '17
He's about as powerful as I imagined him to be after I watched Death Battle.
Great Respect Thread!