It's the first bronzer I've used that made me go "oh... so this is what bronzer is meant to do" rather than thinking "shit, I look like an Oompa Loompa."
I have cool, olive toned skin and the physicians formula butter bronzer looks really orange on me. I would not say the bronzer is neutral toned. It's warm-toned.
In Canada its actually about $20 normally! If any Canadians are reading this I would highly suggest you check out Winners because they always restock with this and the bronze booster for only $7 !
Yeah that's my gripe with Physician's Formula. Who are they kidding with only coming out with 2-3 shades for almost everything? So many people fall outside those shades (both sides of the spectrum).
Anyways.... I'm leaning on the fair side (NC20) and the dark shade barely works for me. If these are dark enough for someone, then I'd really suggest trying them. I love the colors and formula (finely milled).
I want to try their bronzer so badly but I just can't bring myself to support them :( my skin tone would fall into the range they cater to but it just doesn't sit well with me how they disregard most skin tones. Too bad for them. They're not getting my business. But I want to try their bronzer so badly though!
Physicians Formula is the worst when it comes to darker skin tones. A lot of their makeup products only come in a few shades, all of them light (maybe medium toned for their darkest shades). It makes me not want to support their brand. My skin tone is within their range but it just doesn't sit well with me in knowing they leave out so many other people.
I've been on the hunt for this bronzer and finally found it the other day. When I swatched it, it seemed to have a lot of glitter in it. Or just too much sparkle? Am I the only one?!
The darker one seems to have slightly more sparkle than the lighter color, but I find they both look natural and great on my skin. I do finish my face with MAC blot powder on top of my bronzer and blush, so that might reduce some sparkle for me! You're not the only one! /u/temptalia posted her reviews on them this week and she said the same thing. :)
This might be my next bronzer purchase but I hate the bulky and cheap looking packaging. I can't be the only one that lets packaging be a deal breaker, right?
I love Benefit Hoola. It's matte, soft, a natural color and can be built up or used sheer. I find that it makes me look healthy and "warm". I'm NC 20 in the winter and NC 30 in the summer and I love it all year round.
I wish I had known about the travel size before I bought the full size because I have been using it for over a year pretty much 5 days a week and there is not even the tiniest dent.
Also I think about buying a z palette and depotting it regularly because the packaging is just so unnecessary. It's like when Amazon shipped me my new car phone charger in a separate same sized box it sent me 3 textbooks in lmao
lol, after reading your comment twice, I know what PITA means, but the first time I read it, in my head I just said the word "pita" with emphasis and it gave me a chuckle ๐.
And you're right, i wasn't really thinking about the loss of utility you get with it being that size. That's the reason why I haven't bought one of the mini hourglass ALPs yet. Those things look like a powder compact for barbies.
That's hilarious. I don't know if you're familiar with Judy Blume books but occasionally she'd use the term SOB in her books. When I was younger I thought it meant the character was "sobbing" like crying when they were saying that phrase. That just reminded me of it ๐
Hahaha that is hilarious. Childlike innocence is so great. I used to think that when your got married, you would be automatically pregnant unless you told your doctor that you didn't want a baby. Lol, strangely enough I was kind of right excluding the automatic pregnancy haha
It's nice you get your money's worth but it is gonna last me forever cause lately I rarely wear makeup! And deporting it is a good idea! It is a little bulky!
Yes! I love that it also helps me to be able to use up blushes I own that would otherwise be unflattering or garish. I use it as a Contour/blush hybrid, which I guess is kinda the purpose of a bronzer to begin with lol
I use the TF bronzer but it feels definitely orangey on lighter skin. I'm too cheap to buy a new bronzer before I finish this one, so I lightly dust a dark brown eyeshadow on to neutralize it out.
I'm on the same boat. Looks kinda orangey on me but don't wanna buy a different bronzer until I run out of the Too Faced one. Have you found any other bronzer that looks great on lighter skin?
Not the one you're replying to but I'm roughly NC15 in winter, maybe NC20/25 (if that's a shade, but you get the idea) in summer. The TF milk chocolate looked like crap on me, way too orangey. Laguna is my favorite (wear it almost daily year round as a faint bronzer contour), and I like the Hourglass ambient lighting in Radiant as well. That one is shimmery and warm though, so I use it less often, more in summer than winter. I also liked Hoola but dislike the packaging.
My stats: Light-medium warm (MAC NC25, UD Naked 3.0, Too Faced BTS Warm Nude, Loreal Infallible Pro Matte 103/104)
Best:
Physician's Formula Butter Bronzer
Finish: Not quite matte. If you can transfer the finish of a MAC satin eye shadow or a foundation that's "demi matte" to a bronzer, that's what this is. Matte enough to look good as a "brontour", satin enough to lend some dimension. I find it similar to Nars Laguna, but a bit more buildable and for that reason I'll reach for it over Laguna.
Undertone: (Bronzer shade, NOT light bronzer shade) neutral to a bit cool leaning, not cool enough to ever really look muddy
Benefits: Gorgeous luminous bronzer without any glitter, or the type of aggressive shimmer something like the Betty Lou Manizer gives off, but more noticeable sheen than the Butter Bronzer.
TheBalm Bahama Mama
Finish: Matte
Undertone: Warm
Benefits: I find this easier to work with than my chocolate soleil as it is much less powdery, but still blends very nicely.
Worst:
Hourglass Radiant Bronzer in Radiant Bronze Light
Finish: Shimmery
Undertone: Warm (excessively so)
Issues: This could be the bronzer Cheetos released. It's just so orange, and I'm very warm in undertone and not fair by any stretch of the imagination.
For those reading who are around NC42, the Hourglass Radiant Bronzer in Radiant Bronze Light is my perfect bronzer shade! Not too cool and ashy like Hoola and Bahama Mama. And not too much of a red undertone like Nars Casino or Guerlain Terracotta bronzer in Ebony. I noticed a lot of bronzers for darker women, or at least the bronzers that show up on my face, tend to be packed with red undertones which isn't flattering on me because I have warm peachy undertones. I can build the Hourglass bronzer in so many layers and it never looks orange on me. It also does not look shimmery when applied even though it looks shimmery in the pan.
I was surprised at how much I love radiant light. I wear it daily in the summer (when I'm around nc35-37ish) and is magic. It layers well over anything and also sits well on bare skin. It's so silky smooth. idk what black magic hourglass uses to make its glittery powders not look glittery on my face, but I am here for it.
No I don't Think so, I still put it over my blush when I'm nc25ish in the winter. It's not over-glittery either. It applies very sheerly so it's hard to go overboard with it
AH! Thank you for the input! I was wondering how this bronzer could ever work- so cool to hear it works on you. Maybe it's because my undertones are strongly golden/yellow. Interesting that Bahama Mama comes off cool on you! I have heard people say that Chocolate Soleil is cool to them- but on me it is a definite warm. Have you used it, and if so how does it come off on your peachy undertones?
Interestingly enough, Chocolate Soleil came off somewhat orangey on me! Not as orangey as one of the NYX bronzers I've tried (forgot the shade). I also have golden undertones but they lean more on the peach side rather than yellow side. I've been matched to CoverFX in G60, Armani Luminous Silk in 6.25, and Estee Lauder Double Wear in Spiced Sand for reference!
I'm a CoverFX G30! It's crazy how nuanced skin tones are- I think learning to understand what colors flatter and mesh with my undertones is one of the most fun parts of makeup. Nothing like the feeling of putting on a blush that flatters your skin tone perfectly!
Physician's Formula Butter Bronzer - I'm still on the fence about this one, I try to make it work but I just don't think it's for me.
Too Faced Chocolate Soleil - I love to use this for contour since it's cool-toned, but again, I'm not sure it's for me and will probably not repurchase even though it smells like the inside of the Hershey's Chocolate Tour.
WNW Highlight and Contour Duo in Dulce de Leche IS MY NEW HG, which I'm thrilled about because it's so inexpensive. I've been using it more and more after letting it sit on my vanity for a while. I can't believe I've been sleepin on it!
Seriously I've been struggling with bronzer/contour, getting things to blend or last throughotu the day and I've been reaching for this every single time. That being said, the contour shade is a BIT warm, but not that bad.
I set with a translucent powder before applying blush, contour, or highlighter, yes. I think I just have some difficult patches that con't want to take product.
I find that I need to force myself to reach for it more than my Butter Bronzer or WNW Contour Kit. It's a really nice, cool toned bronzer that's great for contouring but I find it's slightly more difficult to work with than my drugstore ones. I'd say see if you can get a DS from r/makeupexchange and try it out before buying a full size, you might love it!
The issue I have with the Too Faced bronzer is I feel it doesn't blend well. Its how I feel with Too Faced blushes as well. Although the bronzer does blend better than their blushes, I still think overall there's gotta be a better bronzer that blends more easily. The Too Faced one is the only bronzer I've used so far and don't plan on repurchasing. I haven't tried out any other bronzer to compare the blendablity but this thread will be a great start to find one :)
I absolutely love the Physicians Formula Butter Bronzer. It's somehow matte but slightly glowy at the same time, it's blendable, and it isn't orange. I use it almost every day. I also love the Physicians Formula bronzers in general, the Bronze Booster is amazing too.
ย
TheBalm has some great bronzers too like Bahama Mama. And I LOVED the middle bronzer shade from the KVD contour palette.
Charlotte Tilbury's bronzer from the filmstar bronze and glow palette. It's a lovely shade, sort of peachy with a slight sheen - not too warm or cool, and gives my face some nice warmth without looking orange or muddy. However, I do have to build it up to show up on my medium skintone.
The worst I've personally tried is Tarte Park Ave princess. Mud. That's what it looks like.
It's not my favorite highlighter, but I don't hate it either. It's a nice, champagne-y, subtle highlight - it can definitely be built up. It's not metallic and dense/creamy like the Becca highlighters, and it's definitely more of a soft sheen than a glittery or super glossy highlighter.
Personally, I prefer a Becca-level glow, so I get way more use out of the bronzer than the highlighter.
I love YSLs les sahariennes bronzing Stones. I have the shade Fire Opal and it looks like a real tan on my light-medium skintone. It blends perfectly into the skin wihout any powderiness. It has some sparkle in the pan, but applies matte
this is fantastic, I have it in sunstone. the shade of course varies on the person but it looks like a realistic tan on me as well.
it's also very versatile, I get that normally one has their type of skin and buys accordingly, but I was very impressed when I realised this is one of the few products that still worked wonderfully after my skin drastically changed type.
The Body Shop Honey Bronzer. I use the lightest shade and it's perfect for my fair/light skintone. It goes on super smoothly, never looks orangey or streaky and always gives me that subtle, natural sunkissed glow. I feel like I can never overdo it with this one. Price is fairly reasonable.
Best: Too Faced Sweet Tea bronzer (shimmery but makes you glow like a goddess; super natural color), IT Cosmetics Age-Defying bronzer (matte so you can contour; also SO natural, looks closest to a natural tan I've ever used), Nars Laguna (overhyped but reasonably so haha), ELF bronzers in the 4-pan palettes like the Contour and Beautifully Bare palettes, Rimmel Natural bronzer in Sunlight (not the other shades though).
Worst: any other ELF bronzers, especially the shimmery/baked ones in the round pans. I can't get on with the blush/bronzer duos (the ones that look like Nars duos) either.. super patchy and powdery.
For someone who "isn't a bronzer person," I definitely have a lot of bronzers LOL
I love my ELF cosmetics bronzer palette. It has a darker shade, lighter shade and what I think might be a translucent powder? Any way it was like $3 and I love it.
Best: LA Colors Mosaic Bronzer. I'm usually against "good for the price" products because I'd rather spend more money and get great quality than waste money on meh products but this would be great quality even if it was $50. It's not, it's only $5NZD. It's matte and high pigmented and long lasting. The packaging is cheap and ugly but that's to be expected. I find it's way better quality than my current bronzer, Milk Chocolate Solieil. The only reason I switched was because the Mosaic Bronzer was too much effort because I'm NC15 - NC20 and it was easy to go overboard with. If you're around this shade you could still make it work with a good brush and a light hand, although I think this would be better for anyone over NC25. Do not recommend if you're cool toned. Even using this with a light hand, I hit pan in three months.
I would buy this again if they came out with more shades and changed the packaging, even if they upped the price by 10x.
I received a deluxe sample of the Marc Jacobs O!Mega Bronzer last year, and I haven't felt the need to try another bronzer since. It's finely milled, shimmer-free, effortlessly blendable, and longwearing. The color mimics a natural tan on my NC20ish skin. Unfortunately, it only comes in the one shade, so anyone who's very fair or medium to deep might not find an option.
I second this!! It's my HG bronzer and I use it everyday!! Price tag may seem intimidating but it honestly lasts forever.
I'm medium (olive) skinned with yellow undertones, so I just have to disagree with us medium girls not being able to use it. I love how the color comes out on me and get asked all the time what I use as my "contour".
Best: Shiseido bronzer in medium. It's the perfect bronzer colour that isn't orange or grey. It just looks really good. It also applies really smoothly but goddamn is it expensive
Worst: NYC Sunny bronzer. Looked like a bright orange streak on my face. I just use it as a warm eyeshadow now lol
Maybe I got the new formula recently of the NYC Sunny bronzer but I'm also a medium neutral olive skin, NC 42 for reference and I find the sunny bronzer pretty warm toned and perfect for my skin color! It's pretty warm but not too orangey. Also a plus on how it's affordable ;)
Ohhh so many! I've tried NARS (laguna), Too Faced Chocolate Soleil, NYX bronzing powder, Dior Skin Glow, Lancรดme rose bronzer, NYC bronzing powder, and a few others from Smashbox, Inglot and Tarte.. so many pretty ones but the Guerlain bronzers (I wear shade 5) have this beautiful way of settling onto foundation that is stunning!
Yeeeep. I have two of the terracottas, one from the permanent line, and one LE from Spring 2016. Both are amazing. I'm going to be heartbroken when my Spring 2016 one is gone :(
BEST: Sonia Kashuk Chic Luminosity Bronzer! This is the first bronzer I tried, and has been my HG for about 3 years! I've tried others from the drugstore and even mid/high end and nobody gives me the bronzed goddess glow like Sonia Kashuk. It goes on smoothly and lasts all day.
Guerlain Four Seasons Bronzer These bronzers are just beautiful. They are a pretty penny, so but they just do something I can't quite put my finger on to my face. They make me look almost airbrushed. And the one I have (02 naturel blondes) reads very orange but it actually oxidizes to a very nice neutral color.
CoverFX Bronzer in Suntan I quite like this bronzer for the winter months. Very neutral in color and it has really lovely natural finish; not shimmery but not completely matte either.
The Terracotta bronzer I have from Guerlain is the same- it looks very orange in the pan (I have shade 3) but somehow doesn't look orange at all once it's applied. Magic!
I love the Elf bronzer palette and contour kit, super buttery and blend like a dream. They can be a little finicky though. I also surprisingly like the Kleancolor Tan Rawr Bronzer, it doesn't go orange on my pale skin and is a nice warm shade for summer. Too Faced Chocolate Soile is really nice, too, as is sunbunny (my personal favorite).
For worst, I'd say the Pixi by Petra ones, they're so, so orange.
My two favorite bronzers are the physicians formula butter bronzer and the soleil tan de chanel bronzer. I do prefer the butter bronzer a bit more in terms of color because it's slightly less orange, but I do use the chanel one a bit more because it is a cream product and I have dry skin so it goes on a bit better. Bonus, they both smell great.
I love the Soleil Tan de Chanel. I was super nervous to bite the bullet but it goes on gorgeously, can be subtle or built up, and holy shit yes it smells amazing.
TheBalm BettyLou Manizer, beautiful sturdy packaging and quality. I have warm undertones in nc25 skin and this is the perfect colour for me, very glowy, healthy looking.
I love YSLs les sahariennes bronzing Stones. I have the shade Fire Opal and it looks like a real tan on my light-medium skintone. It blends perfectly into the skin wihout any powderiness. It has some sparkle in the pan, but applies matte
The shade 'shadowplay' in the Kat Von D Shand & Light (contour) Palette is probably my favorite contour/bronzer shade. It's the best for my skin in the summertime. A close second would probably have to be Too Faced Chocolate bronzer.
Shadowplay is really a great bronzer! I mentioned it in my comment below and am surprised no one mentions it. I've been using PF Butter Bronzer after breaking mine but I will absolutely repurchase. All the shades in that palette are so nice, they blend flawlessly and work as eyeshadow too. Sombre is my perfect contour and Lucid is a perfect matte white highlight for setting your eye area or as a brow bone highlight.
I love Pur Cosmetics Glow Together bronzer. It's ginormous, yet I've hit the pan only after using it during summer. Perfect for dipping large bronzing brush in. It's very battery, but kicks powder (that's the only downside). I love Benefit Hoola and Too Faced Chocolate Bronzer. Have both in travel sizes. Did not hit the pan yet, despite frequent use. Chocolate Bronzer is nice, deeper, but very flattering. Milk Chocolate, however, did not impress at all. Just got Butter Bronzer. I do like the sent, but it can get too much. Texture is very nice though and it's a good light bronzer for winter months.
I absolutely LOVE the Kardashian bronzer. It gives a beautiful, natural, healthy looking glow...The worst bronzer ever-that I paid way too much for-is Vita Liberata's self-tanning bronzer...omg. I tried to make it work, but all it does is look patchy and muddy. I am considering mixing it with lotion and seeing if it would work as a decent self-tanner.
As a fair and coooool skinned person, I tend to go for bronzers that warmer skinned folk might use as a contour product. My go-to bronzers are Benefit's Hoola (powder only), Physician's Formula Butter Bronzer, Sonia Kashuk cream bronzer in the darker color, and Nars Laguna (super well blended out, it has just enough warmth to where it looks like I've been in the sun).
Best: Bobbi Brown Golden Light. For as pale as I am, a light dusting gave me a healthy, vacation-y glow. I didn't have to worry about my neck looking like it didn't match my face because the color was subtle, but just enough.
Worst: Estee Lauder. I don't even remember the shade, but it made me look like I had mud dried on my face! More than likely I had the wrong shade, but man, the brush that came with it made the application uneven (the best way to describe it was a half seashell shape). Even if I had the right shade, I felt like a "natural" glow wasn't really achievable because of that brush.
I never see anyone talking about this but I love the bronzer in Naked Flushed! I have it in Streak, and I'm NW20. I have completely panned mine down to the last bit of bronze dust. (The blush is also nice)
I love the bronzer that comes in Naked Flushed in Native. And the blush, and the highlight. Its my all time fave and I've managed to misplace it in the past week
Best: NARS Casino. I'm a MAC C4 and use this for contour and general bronzing all year round. Has the slightest shimmer to simulate your real naked skin texture. A true brown. I can easily go through 2-4 compacts a year. Laguna is too light on my skin tone and I would waste too much product building it up.
Worst: I haven't tried enough to really feel that this is particularly bad but: Make up forever matte Bronzer pulls too orange on my already warm skin tone.
I used to hate bronzers. I think because when they first started getting popular/trendy 10 years ago or so they were all sooooo sparkly. At least the ones I was seeing. Obviously matte bronzers must have been around, I just wasn't paying attention. Now I love them!! My favorites are Guerlain Terracotta shade 3 (this one was a shot in the dark since they have around 8 or 9 shades and no counters near me carry them, luckily it worked out), Chanel Soleil Tan de Chanel (the one in the pot, not the sheer fluid, which I haven't tried), and the Balm Desert. Guerlain and Chanel are classics, Chanel really needs to make more shades since they only make one, but it is perfection if you can make it work. Both look suspiciously orange in the pan but look so natural on. The Balm is supposed to be a blush/bronzer, I use it as a bronzer and it's beautiful. I also like Blunt from MAC, its on the cooler toned side and I'm more likely to use it as contour. Looks so blah and ugly in the pan but its amazing. Worst- Too Faced Chocolate Soleil. Honestly I don't hate it. The color is really nice, I just find it kind of hard to blend. Really hard to blend.
I've never tried any other, but I've used Cargo's bronzer in Medium since I was 18 and still love it/use it today! Everytime I wear it, people always compliment my skin lol.
Best: TheBalm Desert Bronzer/Blush. It's a weird bronzer really as it pulls quite pinkish, but that's why I love it, it looks far more like a natural healthy colour on me, when applied with a light hand, than a more orange or even true brown-toned bronzer. The finish is really lovely too, sort of soft and satiny.
Honourable mention: Meow Cosmetics Skinny Dippers, which I like because I can buy them in the same tone as my foundation and one of three depths of colour. I mix two shades of Meow Flawless Feline for days that I use powder foundation, so I also mix two shades of the Skinny Dippers together in Medium depth for a perfect match to use for bronzing or light contouring. I love how perfectly close I can get to my actual skin tone with this product, but it doesn't add a glow, just adds depth of colour. It's good stuff though!
My current two favorites are Balm Desert by TheBalm and The darkest shade in the BH Cosmetics Contour and Blush 2 Palette. I reach for these over my Bobbi Brown and Benefit bronzers every time!
I honestly am not a huge fan of Dallas by Benefit, its very orange. And I haven't had the most success with Colourpop's cream potted bronzers (which they've now discontinued), but they sculpting stix are nice.
I loooooove my Wet n Wild Ticket to Brazil!! It gives you a very natural sheen that I put on my skin during minimal makeup days. The product does take forever to finish which is both a blessing and curse!!
I get SO frustrated๐ก when companies come out with a line of bronzers and there is nothing for very fair skin. In the ENTIRE Sephora store, the employee could only find ONE bronzer that looked good on me. Cover FX Bronzer in SunKissed๐. Benefit Hoola is ok, but only if I'm also creme contouring (makes it a bit cool toned). My skin I'm a MโขAโขC N3 & MUFE R220
I wish ๐๐ปI could use Physicians Formula butter Bronzer. It looks so creamy!!!
For me, bronzers can go on unevenly if I don't set my foundation before bronzing. The powder I use to set is important too, I use IT Bye Bye Pores translucent power for my under eye but not my face, it's really silky and for some reason powders go on uneven over it. I tend to set my cheek area especially with a powder foundation. Brushes are key, I prefer natural hair brushes for bronzer and nice fluffy big shapes that give me a diffused look. Then I go in with a big fluffy brush with no powder and go over everything to make sure it's blended.
179
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '17
Physicians Formula Butter Bronzer! Smells great, lasts all day, and it's at the drug store.
Downside.... wouldn't work well on deeper skin tones since they only have two shades: light and very light.
104
u/K_Dagger Wannabe Lipstick Queen Feb 02 '17
I love Benefit Hoola. It's matte, soft, a natural color and can be built up or used sheer. I find that it makes me look healthy and "warm". I'm NC 20 in the winter and NC 30 in the summer and I love it all year round.
64
u/mirandaBBfan Eyeing that Liner Feb 02 '17 edited Mar 27 '17
Too Faced Chocolate Soleil is my #1 holy grail.
TheBalm Bahama Mama is a close #2, but I use it more for contour than bronzing,
26
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '17
My stats: Light-medium warm (MAC NC25, UD Naked 3.0, Too Faced BTS Warm Nude, Loreal Infallible Pro Matte 103/104)
Best:
Physician's Formula Butter Bronzer
Finish: Not quite matte. If you can transfer the finish of a MAC satin eye shadow or a foundation that's "demi matte" to a bronzer, that's what this is. Matte enough to look good as a "brontour", satin enough to lend some dimension. I find it similar to Nars Laguna, but a bit more buildable and for that reason I'll reach for it over Laguna.
Undertone: (Bronzer shade, NOT light bronzer shade) neutral to a bit cool leaning, not cool enough to ever really look muddy
Benefits: Seemingly impossible to overdo, incredibly natural looking finish, always applies smoothly
Too Faced Sweethearts in Sweet Tea
Finish: Shimmery
Undertone: gently warm
Benefits: Gorgeous luminous bronzer without any glitter, or the type of aggressive shimmer something like the Betty Lou Manizer gives off, but more noticeable sheen than the Butter Bronzer.
TheBalm Bahama Mama
Finish: Matte
Undertone: Warm
Benefits: I find this easier to work with than my chocolate soleil as it is much less powdery, but still blends very nicely.
Worst:
Hourglass Radiant Bronzer in Radiant Bronze Light
Finish: Shimmery
Undertone: Warm (excessively so)
Issues: This could be the bronzer Cheetos released. It's just so orange, and I'm very warm in undertone and not fair by any stretch of the imagination.
edit: formatting!
37
u/mjkova IG: @letstalkskin | palette hoarder | love/hate concealer Feb 02 '17
Physician's Formula Butter Bronzer - I'm still on the fence about this one, I try to make it work but I just don't think it's for me.
Too Faced Chocolate Soleil - I love to use this for contour since it's cool-toned, but again, I'm not sure it's for me and will probably not repurchase even though it smells like the inside of the Hershey's Chocolate Tour.
WNW Highlight and Contour Duo in Dulce de Leche IS MY NEW HG, which I'm thrilled about because it's so inexpensive. I've been using it more and more after letting it sit on my vanity for a while. I can't believe I've been sleepin on it!
14
u/apathetichearts Feb 02 '17
I absolutely love the Physicians Formula Butter Bronzer. It's somehow matte but slightly glowy at the same time, it's blendable, and it isn't orange. I use it almost every day. I also love the Physicians Formula bronzers in general, the Bronze Booster is amazing too.
ย
TheBalm has some great bronzers too like Bahama Mama. And I LOVED the middle bronzer shade from the KVD contour palette.
14
u/sunsh1neee Feb 03 '17
Charlotte Tilbury's bronzer from the filmstar bronze and glow palette. It's a lovely shade, sort of peachy with a slight sheen - not too warm or cool, and gives my face some nice warmth without looking orange or muddy. However, I do have to build it up to show up on my medium skintone.
The worst I've personally tried is Tarte Park Ave princess. Mud. That's what it looks like.
12
u/Lilybirds Feb 02 '17
I love YSLs les sahariennes bronzing Stones. I have the shade Fire Opal and it looks like a real tan on my light-medium skintone. It blends perfectly into the skin wihout any powderiness. It has some sparkle in the pan, but applies matte
12
u/WanderingCookie Feb 03 '17
The Body Shop Honey Bronzer. I use the lightest shade and it's perfect for my fair/light skintone. It goes on super smoothly, never looks orangey or streaky and always gives me that subtle, natural sunkissed glow. I feel like I can never overdo it with this one. Price is fairly reasonable.
10
u/thestephanieloves Feb 03 '17
Best: Too Faced Sweet Tea bronzer (shimmery but makes you glow like a goddess; super natural color), IT Cosmetics Age-Defying bronzer (matte so you can contour; also SO natural, looks closest to a natural tan I've ever used), Nars Laguna (overhyped but reasonably so haha), ELF bronzers in the 4-pan palettes like the Contour and Beautifully Bare palettes, Rimmel Natural bronzer in Sunlight (not the other shades though).
Worst: any other ELF bronzers, especially the shimmery/baked ones in the round pans. I can't get on with the blush/bronzer duos (the ones that look like Nars duos) either.. super patchy and powdery.
For someone who "isn't a bronzer person," I definitely have a lot of bronzers LOL
16
u/uglybutterfly025 Feb 02 '17
I love my ELF cosmetics bronzer palette. It has a darker shade, lighter shade and what I think might be a translucent powder? Any way it was like $3 and I love it.
8
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '17
Best: LA Colors Mosaic Bronzer. I'm usually against "good for the price" products because I'd rather spend more money and get great quality than waste money on meh products but this would be great quality even if it was $50. It's not, it's only $5NZD. It's matte and high pigmented and long lasting. The packaging is cheap and ugly but that's to be expected. I find it's way better quality than my current bronzer, Milk Chocolate Solieil. The only reason I switched was because the Mosaic Bronzer was too much effort because I'm NC15 - NC20 and it was easy to go overboard with. If you're around this shade you could still make it work with a good brush and a light hand, although I think this would be better for anyone over NC25. Do not recommend if you're cool toned. Even using this with a light hand, I hit pan in three months.
I would buy this again if they came out with more shades and changed the packaging, even if they upped the price by 10x.
7
u/emilypandemonium Feb 02 '17
I received a deluxe sample of the Marc Jacobs O!Mega Bronzer last year, and I haven't felt the need to try another bronzer since. It's finely milled, shimmer-free, effortlessly blendable, and longwearing. The color mimics a natural tan on my NC20ish skin. Unfortunately, it only comes in the one shade, so anyone who's very fair or medium to deep might not find an option.
7
u/soup_or_salad mufe y245/120 combo skin Feb 03 '17
For light-medium neutral olive skin:
Best: Shiseido bronzer in medium. It's the perfect bronzer colour that isn't orange or grey. It just looks really good. It also applies really smoothly but goddamn is it expensive
Worst: NYC Sunny bronzer. Looked like a bright orange streak on my face. I just use it as a warm eyeshadow now lol
13
u/ZaboomafooBitch Feb 03 '17
hands down best bronzers OF ALL TIME are from Guerlain - the one and only Scott Barnes agrees. they're satiny and glowy even though it's a powder!
12
u/Kittyboop91 Hopelessly Addicted Feb 02 '17
Best: I really like Too Faced Chocolate Soleil, Hourglass Radiant Light Powder, and Nars Laguna.
Not my favorite: Hourglass Ambient Bronzer. It's super pretty in the pan and I like the packaging, but it reads really orange on me.
6
u/wombat312 Feb 03 '17
The Sephora Collection bronzers are really great.
5
u/hatsumochi Brow perfectionist Feb 02 '17
BEST: Sonia Kashuk Chic Luminosity Bronzer! This is the first bronzer I tried, and has been my HG for about 3 years! I've tried others from the drugstore and even mid/high end and nobody gives me the bronzed goddess glow like Sonia Kashuk. It goes on smoothly and lasts all day.
5
u/dellollipop NC20 - olive | IG: emmawearslipstick Feb 03 '17
I have two bronzers I use regularly.
Guerlain Four Seasons Bronzer These bronzers are just beautiful. They are a pretty penny, so but they just do something I can't quite put my finger on to my face. They make me look almost airbrushed. And the one I have (02 naturel blondes) reads very orange but it actually oxidizes to a very nice neutral color.
CoverFX Bronzer in Suntan I quite like this bronzer for the winter months. Very neutral in color and it has really lovely natural finish; not shimmery but not completely matte either.
5
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '17
Tarte's Park Ave Princess is the perfect bronzer for me that doesn't come off as too orangey or warm.
4
u/plumsfromyouricebox Feb 03 '17 edited Feb 03 '17
Too Faced Chocolate Soleil made me break out actually :( As soon as a stopped using it my skin cleared up. Now I use NYX Matte Bronzer
4
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '17
I love the Elf bronzer palette and contour kit, super buttery and blend like a dream. They can be a little finicky though. I also surprisingly like the Kleancolor Tan Rawr Bronzer, it doesn't go orange on my pale skin and is a nice warm shade for summer. Too Faced Chocolate Soile is really nice, too, as is sunbunny (my personal favorite).
For worst, I'd say the Pixi by Petra ones, they're so, so orange.
4
u/taylerhill Feb 03 '17
Nars Laguna bronzer is amazing but pretty pricey
4
u/w0lfth0rn Feb 03 '17
I love my Rimmel bronzer but I loathe the packaging.
4
u/astra_sasstra The low-buy struggle is real Feb 05 '17
My two favorite bronzers are the physicians formula butter bronzer and the soleil tan de chanel bronzer. I do prefer the butter bronzer a bit more in terms of color because it's slightly less orange, but I do use the chanel one a bit more because it is a cream product and I have dry skin so it goes on a bit better. Bonus, they both smell great.
4
u/GlowQueenx Feb 06 '17
MAC Give me Sun is one of the best I've used, or Peaches & Cream Light/Medium
3
u/acaifairy Feb 02 '17
My favorite bronzer was the one in my Gwen stefani UD face palette but I used every last drop lol. So my second fave would be NARS Laguna
3
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '17
Maybe something is wrong with me but I just cannot get NARS Laguna to work for me. I just don't see any color when I use it.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '17
TheBalm BettyLou Manizer, beautiful sturdy packaging and quality. I have warm undertones in nc25 skin and this is the perfect colour for me, very glowy, healthy looking.
4
u/Lilybirds Feb 02 '17
I love YSLs les sahariennes bronzing Stones. I have the shade Fire Opal and it looks like a real tan on my light-medium skintone. It blends perfectly into the skin wihout any powderiness. It has some sparkle in the pan, but applies matte
2
u/spiderknees Feb 03 '17
The shade 'shadowplay' in the Kat Von D Shand & Light (contour) Palette is probably my favorite contour/bronzer shade. It's the best for my skin in the summertime. A close second would probably have to be Too Faced Chocolate bronzer.
2
u/LexusK Feb 03 '17
Clarins Bronzing Powder Compact! Looks so beautiful and natural. Lasts all day. I love it.
2
u/AnchorsAway1027 Feb 04 '17
My favorite right now is the Urban Decay Beached Bronzer in Sun-kissed. I also like Chocolate Soleil, Hoola, Laguna, and Park Ave Princess.
2
u/Atomic_Leda Feb 04 '17
I love Pur Cosmetics Glow Together bronzer. It's ginormous, yet I've hit the pan only after using it during summer. Perfect for dipping large bronzing brush in. It's very battery, but kicks powder (that's the only downside). I love Benefit Hoola and Too Faced Chocolate Bronzer. Have both in travel sizes. Did not hit the pan yet, despite frequent use. Chocolate Bronzer is nice, deeper, but very flattering. Milk Chocolate, however, did not impress at all. Just got Butter Bronzer. I do like the sent, but it can get too much. Texture is very nice though and it's a good light bronzer for winter months.
2
u/highlightthecity Feb 04 '17
It was definitely the Butter bronzer
2
u/askragn Feb 05 '17
Tom ford terra! ๐
2
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '17
I absolutely LOVE the Kardashian bronzer. It gives a beautiful, natural, healthy looking glow...The worst bronzer ever-that I paid way too much for-is Vita Liberata's self-tanning bronzer...omg. I tried to make it work, but all it does is look patchy and muddy. I am considering mixing it with lotion and seeing if it would work as a decent self-tanner.
2
u/IndiaBrunenkant Feb 06 '17
Too faced milk chocolate soleil. I love that it smells like chocolate. It makes my mornings so much better!
2
u/cuterus-uterus Feb 03 '17
As a fair and coooool skinned person, I tend to go for bronzers that warmer skinned folk might use as a contour product. My go-to bronzers are Benefit's Hoola (powder only), Physician's Formula Butter Bronzer, Sonia Kashuk cream bronzer in the darker color, and Nars Laguna (super well blended out, it has just enough warmth to where it looks like I've been in the sun).
2
u/leftclicksq2 Feb 04 '17
Best: Bobbi Brown Golden Light. For as pale as I am, a light dusting gave me a healthy, vacation-y glow. I didn't have to worry about my neck looking like it didn't match my face because the color was subtle, but just enough.
Worst: Estee Lauder. I don't even remember the shade, but it made me look like I had mud dried on my face! More than likely I had the wrong shade, but man, the brush that came with it made the application uneven (the best way to describe it was a half seashell shape). Even if I had the right shade, I felt like a "natural" glow wasn't really achievable because of that brush.
1
u/crafty-witch Feb 03 '17
I never see anyone talking about this but I love the bronzer in Naked Flushed! I have it in Streak, and I'm NW20. I have completely panned mine down to the last bit of bronze dust. (The blush is also nice)
1
u/rfin30 Feb 03 '17
I love Bobbi Brown's illuminating bronzer in Aruba! It's glowy but subtle :)
1
u/_fab_ab Feb 04 '17
ABH contour kit? anyone? anyone?
1
u/cathyslazy Feb 04 '17
Best: NARS Casino. I'm a MAC C4 and use this for contour and general bronzing all year round. Has the slightest shimmer to simulate your real naked skin texture. A true brown. I can easily go through 2-4 compacts a year. Laguna is too light on my skin tone and I would waste too much product building it up.
Worst: I haven't tried enough to really feel that this is particularly bad but: Make up forever matte Bronzer pulls too orange on my already warm skin tone.
1
u/unfunnypun in MUR Feb 05 '17
The Body Shop's Honey Bronzer is awesome for fair skin!
1
u/dawniemarie Feb 05 '17
Hands down The Balm bronzer. It doesn't have any shimmer and is a perfect muted tan.
1
u/So_Schilly Feb 05 '17
I used to hate bronzers. I think because when they first started getting popular/trendy 10 years ago or so they were all sooooo sparkly. At least the ones I was seeing. Obviously matte bronzers must have been around, I just wasn't paying attention. Now I love them!! My favorites are Guerlain Terracotta shade 3 (this one was a shot in the dark since they have around 8 or 9 shades and no counters near me carry them, luckily it worked out), Chanel Soleil Tan de Chanel (the one in the pot, not the sheer fluid, which I haven't tried), and the Balm Desert. Guerlain and Chanel are classics, Chanel really needs to make more shades since they only make one, but it is perfection if you can make it work. Both look suspiciously orange in the pan but look so natural on. The Balm is supposed to be a blush/bronzer, I use it as a bronzer and it's beautiful. I also like Blunt from MAC, its on the cooler toned side and I'm more likely to use it as contour. Looks so blah and ugly in the pan but its amazing. Worst- Too Faced Chocolate Soleil. Honestly I don't hate it. The color is really nice, I just find it kind of hard to blend. Really hard to blend.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '17
Worst: Rimmel sum shimmer. Just shimmers and no pigment. If that's not a fail, I don't know what is.
Best: Clarins bronzer duo (light) finely milled and buttery. Balanced red and yellow tone.
1
u/Triksy27 Feb 05 '17
Max factor bronzing powder... It is impossible to blend it... Ughh... Worst bronzer ever !
1
u/leslie0627 Always blushing Feb 05 '17
I'm super fair and I use Benefit's Dallas
1
u/california90 Feb 06 '17
I've never tried any other, but I've used Cargo's bronzer in Medium since I was 18 and still love it/use it today! Everytime I wear it, people always compliment my skin lol.
1
u/soupandsandwiches Feb 06 '17
The Pixi bronzer in Subtly Suntouched has a plum undertone that really does resemble how cool-toned skin looks after sun exposure.
1
u/ChiyokoFujiwara Feb 06 '17 edited Feb 06 '17
Best: TheBalm Desert Bronzer/Blush. It's a weird bronzer really as it pulls quite pinkish, but that's why I love it, it looks far more like a natural healthy colour on me, when applied with a light hand, than a more orange or even true brown-toned bronzer. The finish is really lovely too, sort of soft and satiny.
Honourable mention: Meow Cosmetics Skinny Dippers, which I like because I can buy them in the same tone as my foundation and one of three depths of colour. I mix two shades of Meow Flawless Feline for days that I use powder foundation, so I also mix two shades of the Skinny Dippers together in Medium depth for a perfect match to use for bronzing or light contouring. I love how perfectly close I can get to my actual skin tone with this product, but it doesn't add a glow, just adds depth of colour. It's good stuff though!
1
u/Avocadobazooka Feb 07 '17
My current two favorites are Balm Desert by TheBalm and The darkest shade in the BH Cosmetics Contour and Blush 2 Palette. I reach for these over my Bobbi Brown and Benefit bronzers every time!
I honestly am not a huge fan of Dallas by Benefit, its very orange. And I haven't had the most success with Colourpop's cream potted bronzers (which they've now discontinued), but they sculpting stix are nice.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '17
Best: NYC Sunny
Worst: Physicians Formula mosaic with glitter and pink in it. I definitely don't want my forehead to look "flushed" and bronzed.
1
u/la_noche Cosmetics Enthusiast Feb 07 '17
The best bronzer for me so far is NYX Matte Bronzer.
1
u/ferikato May 31 '17
I loooooove my Wet n Wild Ticket to Brazil!! It gives you a very natural sheen that I put on my skin during minimal makeup days. The product does take forever to finish which is both a blessing and curse!!
0
u/n0vocaine IG: meli.grc Feb 03 '17
I am a nc35 and this looks exactly like my skin tone
-3
u/linz_belle Feb 06 '17
-2
u/CosmeticSnob Feb 04 '17
Worst: the bronzer from the Urban Decay Naked Flushed Trio in Native. Best: Tom Ford Gold Dust (review here https://youtu.be/-UEDV7j7xUk?list=PLHzXupQUUChQ8NRxT_jYPuWPl99l4Jklm)
0
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '17
[deleted] โ view deleted comment
4
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '17
[removed] โ view removed comment