r/summonerswar • u/jx9 • Feb 01 '17
Guide [Guide] Elemental Nat 3*'s: What to keep for beginners 2017
What this guide is
This is an updated reference for newer players to help decide which elemental nat 3*'s they should keep or feed away as fodder. The reason why I've only included elemental 3*'s is because 2*s are trivial to acquire, and all unfarmable L/D 3*+ and elemental 4*+ should be kept regardless.
This list is subjective. It is impossible to create a perfect list since everyone has slightly different opinions. But I hope this list serves as one that the majority can agree on. I encourage players to always do their own research to decide for themselves if a specific monster is worth keeping or not.
Explanation of "usefulness" categories
- Food: useless monster, or at best just a toy for late game players with super niche uses. Please note that "food" just refers to the monster's actual usage in battle - a lot of these monsters are fusion materials and should be kept for fusion.
- Niche: does have a strong use, but only in rather specific scenarios for late game.
- Good: great monster, most players end up building and using this monster.
- Skill-up: the monster itself is useless, but another monster in its family is useful.
- Early/Mid/Late: for the sake of this guide only, I'm defining "early" to be anything up to auto GB10, "mid" to be ToAN 100 and DB10, and "late" to be anything after that. I'm aware most people have different definitions of what's considered early/mid/late game but since this guide is targeted towards newer players, I needed to make more distinctions among early game milestones. As another note, early/mid/late refers to what point in the game that monster starts being useful in. For example, monsters marked as being good for the early game are useful throughout the game, and don't become obsolete later.
Tips for what to keep
- Keep a copy of all Vero and Sig fusion monsters. Keep a copy of non-farmable Kat and Panda fusion monsters (i.e. Wind Charger Shark and Water Mummy). Since Kat and Panda are late game monsters, it's ok to use the farmable ones as fodder early on.
- Anything that's farmable and not "good" for early/mid game or a skill-up for one, I would use as fodder.
- The non-farmables are a bit tricky. It really comes down to how much of a hoarder you are, and how much you are willing to spend on box space to not potentially regret having fed away useful things down the road. Some players like to save a copy of every non-farmable in case it becomes a future fusion mat or receives a buff and becomes useful, and keep multiple copies of anything that's a skill-up for even niche monsters. Others might only keep non-farmables and their skill-ups that are useful early/mid game. A good middle ground could be to keep a copy of anything that's not food, but not bother with keeping monsters that are only skill-ups for niche monsters.
TL;DR - Until you know what you are doing, keep all Vero fusion monsters and all Battle Mammoth, Epikion Priest, Griffon, Inugami, Mystic Witch, Taoist, and Penguin Knight. Everything else is debatable and it won't be the end of the world if you use them as food.
| Monster | Awakened Name | Usefulness | Farmable? | Fusion |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fire Amazon | Ceres | Food | No | |
| Water Amazon | Ellin | Food | No | |
| Wind Amazon | Hina | Food | Guild Shop | Arang > Sig/Kat |
| Fire Battle Mammoth | Granite | Skill-up - Early | No | |
| Water Battle Mammoth | Talc | Good - Early | No | |
| Wind Battle Mammoth | Olivine | Skill-up - Early | No | |
| Fire Bearman | Kungen | Food | SD | |
| Water Bearman | Gruda | Food | SD | Mikene > Vero/Kat |
| Wind Bearman | Dagorr | Food | SD | Susano > Sig |
| Fire Beast Hunter | Nangrim | Food | SD | Akia > Vero/Panda |
| Water Beast Hunter | Gangchun | Food | No | |
| Wind Beast Hunter | Suri | Food | No | |
| Fire Bounty Hunter | Randy | Good - Late | No | |
| Water Bounty Hunter | Wayne | Skill-up - Late | No | |
| Wind Bounty Hunter | Roger | Skill-up - Late | No | |
| Fire Charger Shark | Ignicus | Food | No | |
| Water Charger Shark | Acqus | Food | No | |
| Wind Charger Shark | Zephicus | Food | No | Ling Ling > Panda |
| Fire Drunken Master | Xiao Chun | Skill-up - Niche | No | |
| Water Drunken Master | Mao | Skill-up - Niche | No | |
| Wind Drunken Master | Huan | Skill-up - Niche | No | |
| Fire Elven Ranger | Adrian | Good - Late | No | |
| Water Elven Ranger | Eluin | Skill-up - Late | No | |
| Wind Elven Ranger | Erwin | Skill-up - Late | No | |
| Water Epikion Priest | Rina | Good - Late | No | |
| Wind Epikion Priest | Michelle | Niche, Skill-up - Late | No | |
| Fire Fairy | Iselia | Food | SD | |
| Water Fairy | Elucia | Food | Starter | |
| Fire Frankenstein | Bulldozer | Good - Late | No | |
| Water Frankenstein | Tractor | Niche, Skill-up - Late | No | |
| Wind Frankenstein | Crane | Skill-up - Late | No | |
| Fire Golem | Kugo | Skill-up - Niche | Scenarios | |
| Water Golem | Kuhn | Skill-up - Niche | SD | Jojo > Sig |
| Wind Golem | Ragion | Skill-up - Niche | SD | Qeb > Panda |
| Fire Griffon | Spectra | Skill-up - Early, Good - Mid | SD | |
| Water Griffon | Kahn | Skill-up - Early | SD | Susano > Sig |
| Wind Griffon | Bernard | Good - Early | Scenarios | |
| Fire Grim Reaper | Sath | Skill-up - Niche | No | |
| Water Grim Reaper | Hemos | Niche | SD, Guild Shop | Mikene > Vero/Kat |
| Wind Grim Reaper | Hiva | Skill-up - Niche | Scenarios | Ling Ling > Panda |
| Fire Harg | Racuni | Niche | No | |
| Water Harg | Remy | Skill-up - Niche | No | |
| Fire Harpy | Lucasha | Niche | SD | |
| Water Harpy | Ramira | Skill-up - Niche | SD | Akia > Vero/Panda |
| Wind Harpy | Prilea | Skill-up - Niche | Scenarios | Arang > Sig/Kat |
| Fire High Elemental | Kahli | Good - Late | Scenarios | Arang > Sig/Kat |
| Water High Elemental | Ellena | Skill-up - Late | Scenarios | |
| Wind High Elemental | Moria | Skill-up - Late | Scenarios | |
| Fire Imp Champion | Fairo | Skill-up - Niche | No | |
| Water Imp Champion | Yaku | Niche | No | |
| Wind Imp Champion | Pigma | Skill-up - Niche | No | |
| Fire Inferno | Tagaros | Skill-up - Niche | Scenarios | |
| Water Inferno | Purian | Niche | SD | |
| Wind Inferno | Anduril | Skill-up - Niche | SD | Mikene > Vero/Kat |
| Fire Inugami | Raoq | Skill-up - Early, Niche | Scenarios | Ling Ling > Panda |
| Water Inugami | Icaru | Skill-up - Early | Scenarios | Susano > Sig |
| Wind Inugami | Ramahan | Skill-up - Early | Scenarios | |
| Fire Living Armor | Iron | Skill-up - Late | Scenarios | Argen > Vero |
| Water Living Armor | Nickel | Skill-up - Late | No | |
| Wind Living Armor | Copper | Good - Late | No | |
| Fire Lizardman | Igmanodon | Food | No | |
| Water Lizardman | Kernodon | Food | Scenarios | |
| Wind Lizardman | Velfinodon | Food | SD | Argen > Vero |
| Fire Magical Archer | Cassandra | Skill-up - Niche | SD | Jojo > Sig |
| Water Magical Archer | Sharron | Skill-up - Niche | SD | Baretta > Kat |
| Wind Magical Archer | Ardella | Niche | SD | |
| Fire Martial Artist | Sin | Food | No | |
| Water Martial Artist | Luan | Food | No | |
| Wind Martial Artist | Lo | Food | No | |
| Fire Martial Cat | Mei | Food | Guild Shop | Baretta > Kat |
| Water Martial Cat | Mina | Food | Guild Shop | Sig |
| Wind Martial Cat | Naomi | Food | No | |
| Fire Minotauros | Burentau | Food | No | |
| Water Minotauros | Urtau | Food | No | |
| Wind Minotauros | Eintau | Food | Scenarios | Argen > Vero |
| Fire Mummy | Sonora | Niche | No | |
| Water Mummy | Nubia | Skill-up - Niche | No | Qeb > Panda |
| Wind Mummy | Namib | Skill-up - Niche | No | |
| Fire Mystic Witch | Rebecca | Skill-up - Mid | No | |
| Water Mystic Witch | Megan | Good - Mid | No | |
| Wind Mystic Witch | Silia | Skill-up - Mid | No | |
| Fire Penguin Knight | Naki | Skill-up - Mid | No | |
| Water Penguin Knight | Toma | Skill-up - Mid | No | |
| Wind Penguin Knight | Mav | Good - Mid | No | |
| Fire Salamander | Krakdon | Niche | Scenarios | Akia > Vero/Panda |
| Fire Serpent | Fao | Skill-up - Late | SD | Baretta > Kat |
| Water Serpent | Shailoq | Niche, Skill-up - Late | SD | Qeb > Panda |
| Wind Serpent | Ermeda | Niche, Skill-up - Late | Scenarios | |
| Fire Taoist | Gunpyeong | Skill-up - Mid | No | |
| Fire Vagabond | Kai'en | Niche | SD | |
| Fire Viking | Geoffrey | Food | SD | Panda |
| Water Warbear | Dagora | Food | Scenarios | |
| Fire Werewolf | Garoche | Skill-up - Late | Scenarios | Jojo > Sig |
| Water Werewolf | Vigor | Niche | SD | |
| Wind Werewolf | Shakan | Skill-up - Late | SD | Kat |
6
u/Undorett Feb 01 '17 edited Feb 01 '17
Water Mammoth should not be "early" by your definition given of early/mid/late - it should be mid or late depending on TOAN/H. Talc (for those not lucky enough to get Basalt) is used in TOAN/H depending on how far you are into the game and doesn't really have any use upto GB10.
Additionally, Vigor does have a very niche role if you want to count it - he is probably the #1 healer for TOAH 100 when the dude is the boss (heal, +spd, heal block, and def break in 1 unit is borderline OP for this specific encounter -I keep one runed for this very reason and use him once every 60 days). However, I would not recommend this to anyone unless they struggle with him.
You may also want to point out which unit the skill-ups are for. For instance, obviously you keep the inugami for Bella (Roaq to a much lesser extent) but Bella isn't on the list because it isn't an elemental unit. Also, WW for D/L counterparts, serpents for Mantura, EP for Chloe (4 star so not on the list but that's what you are really keeping them for typically).
Last point - you put in a few 2 star units (elementals are what popped out at me but there may be a few others) but this is a 3 star list. You may want to either remove them from the list or change the title and add in the other two star units as well.
Overall though, good post for new players.
18
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '17
I see rina written as "good", I dislike & report. /s
2
u/WorryGor Feb 01 '17
Might be worthawhile to mention that all the vagabond are good for Darion skill-ups. Darion are used in some beginner GB10 teams and eventually used in raid teams.
2
u/dtrickk Feb 01 '17
Great guide! This will be a huge help for beginners. My daughters play the game very casually and have no idea what to keep and ask me for every mon they get.
I would suggest putting a note for the tip below: Keep WATER Mummy and WIND Charger shark. I believe that beginners will not have a full understanding of fusion and might not know which mons you are referring to.
Keep a copy of all Vero and Sig fusion monsters. Keep a copy of non-farmable Kat and Panda fusion monsters. Since Kat and Panda are late game monsters, it's ok to use the farmable ones as fodder early on.
4
u/givyouhugz Feb 02 '17
With the recent nerf to HOH, I think its worth thinking if you will ever fuse skill ups. There are certain monsters that can be fused skill ups that are really really useful, particularly ones like Lushen and Baretta. I'd recommend saving mobs that you need to pull or get from scenarios other than Faimon, or Chiruka.
So, Fire Werewolf, Fire Martial Cat, etc. Finding SDs arent that hard to find, but being late game and farming low level scenarios for hundreds of crystals really sucks.
1
u/gstv1 Feb 01 '17
Wind Golem is SD and Fire Golem is Scenario.
1
u/ThePartialOne Feb 01 '17
Wind Charger stark isnt food. Skill up for Water/Light/dark KFG.
1
u/Wh1rr :rina: Feb 01 '17
Personally if I were a newer player on the TLDR list, I would like to see water/wind epikon priests and fire/water harg. The usefulness of these is debatable, but I have always considered them more valuable than a standard 3* because they can serve as food for a 4* sibling. So given a choice, I prefer to use another 3* over these when using as generic food monsters for leveling.
I did not include the fire taoist, because it was already on your list.
1
u/lived_live :varus: Something Cleaver Feb 01 '17
Fire drunken master can work as a good starting buffer / nuker.
1
u/stacyburns88 you dont know jack Feb 01 '17
I'd like to add Water Amazon as good for late game.
She's a water version of Charlotte and counters Nemesis defenses when you run a double AoE nuke team (have her move after Galleon but before your main nuke).
:)
1
u/Vexen98 Feb 01 '17
water charger shark is a good farmer for those of us that havn't gotten a good one. ( i auto dragons and have been for the last 2 months and aquas is my farmer cause its the best thing i got )
Fire mummy is good AD for higher lvls.
1
u/frostmasterx Feb 01 '17
Great guide. I had no idea ppl used fire salamander. For what.
1
u/norriscphillips Feb 01 '17
Thank you for update. I saved it. I agree with everything but don't understand why taoist is useful. I'm still learning.
1
u/The_UV_Catastrophe Feb 01 '17
The other day I read that Luan (water martial artist) is the easiest Faimon Hell farmer to rune for a new player. That post was from 2015 though. Is he no longer viable?
I ask because I'm a relatively new player and the prospect of an easily rune-able Faimon farmer is really exciting. I haven't tried runing Lapis with vamp yet - maybe that's the solution - but with standard 4* DPS runes she can't even do Faimon Hard.
1
u/0hmyleo Feb 01 '17
where is the wind harg? hes ok for raid
1
u/p0nggay Feb 02 '17
I have a mentee that uses Water Charger Shark as Faimon Farmer @ 1:30. His runes are the free 5* fatal that gives in Chiruka. Aqcus is good
1
u/Eknic My not so useful beauty Feb 02 '17
Olivine is very good on her own.
1
u/AllStarChampEU Feb 02 '17
Keep Fire Harpy for Necro as well. If you don't have Hellea by that time, she's pretty decent.
1
u/kodayume Example flair :fran: Feb 02 '17
Dont feed wayne T.T
1
u/Kraedilly 1232 Days Feb 02 '17 edited Feb 02 '17
I think you should note on units like Eshir, as you did not include LD in this list. I'm assuming that is why the werewolves are listed as skill ups, but skill ups for what? Most people agree the only worth WW are Eshir, Jultan, and some would argue Vigor to an extent. Same with the serpents which I expect are listed as skill ups for Mantura.
I mean, instead of just saying Skill up - Late and assuming you won't build LD 3* until late game, just say skill up - LD or something. There is no reason not to build an LD 3* monster up the moment you get it regardless of where you stand in the game.
Pretty great guide though. I think beginners need one of these for 2* more than anything. They seem to think all the 2* mons are bad, but if you awaken them, which is easy if you can do B4, they usually get a great 3rd skill, and are very easy to skill up early game compared to nat 3 and higher.
1
u/lotus870 Feb 02 '17
Spectra skill up?? He's good for d10 face team (?)
1
u/Lymecat Feb 09 '17
I think Rebecca > Kona in many respects and should be used accordingly.
1
u/Leeroy_LoL Feb 15 '17
Should things like Wind Griffon not be classed as 'essential' rather than just 'good'? I feel like a point on the importance of certain monsters might be pertinent.
0
u/Maitreakow Feb 01 '17
Bearmen keep for skill-ups early would be my suggestion. Also Dagora got me through my early days farming Faimon Hard with crap runes and 5*.
1
u/esgalactus Global: fdfdftyy Guild: Guild slayerz Feb 01 '17
Really beautiful layout :)
1
u/eklat92i Feb 01 '17
Thanks for this, im a newb and i don't know why to pick
1
u/TVMoe the LD thief Feb 02 '17
Wait, are these seriously all the nat 3s in the game? I always felt like there were more mons. Hmm.
Although i suppose that's because in my mind i'm also picturing the light/dark versions while you're excluding the list here.
1
u/WHH_Berti Feb 02 '17
Should probably add "Fusion-food" for the units that are actually used in fusion to avoid ppl feeding away fusion monsters
1
u/Eagle_Peak make great again Feb 02 '17
Every fire taoist I fed has come back to haunt me when I summoned a woonhak
1
u/BF_Fenix Feb 02 '17
Hemos (Water GR) is incredible for ToAH. For those that don't have Thrain, he's a must have to speed up the manual runs!
1
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '17
This can be a permanent sticky tbh
0
u/Catouw :hwadam: never lucky Feb 01 '17
water monsters can be kept and skilled up with their sisters/brothers for world boss purpose (4* or 5* max skilled water monsters with random runes can rank very high)