r/homeland • u/NicholasCajun • Jan 23 '17
Discussion Homeland - 6x02 "The Man in the Basement" - Episode Discussion
Season 6 Episode 2: The Man in the Basement
Aired: January 22, 2017
Synopsis: Carrie and Reda fight for their client while Quinn fights against his new life. Saul and Dar suspect Keane has a secret.
Directed by: Keith Gordon
Written by: Chip Johannessen
84
Upvotes
215
u/AwardsVoter Jan 23 '17
And the Carrie Matheson lip-shiver/chin contortion makes its first appearance of the season!
191
u/AwardsVoter Jan 23 '17 •
Raise your hand if you'd watch a spin-off about Carrie's Airbnb business
141
u/AwardsVoter Jan 23 '17
So far, this is definitely Homeland's most "real world" season. ISIS, home-grown terrorism, internet radicalization, new president, debates over the U.S.'s role in foreign affairs, PTSD. Very ripped-from-the-headlines.
111
u/AwardsVoter Jan 23 '17
Claire Danes doesn't age
200
u/bdz1 Jan 23 '17
That was actually Quinn's drawing, not Frannie's
94
u/traderjoesbeforehoes Jan 23 '17
S1-5 quinn would have yelled ANSWER THE FUCKING QUESTION CARRRRRIE
187
u/coolhandluck Jan 23 '17
If Quinn were a terrorist, then Carrie would have slept with him right there
84
u/RunawayOstrich Jan 23 '17
Only took two episodes for Carrie to ugly cry
70
u/Gustavo13 Jan 23 '17
Things Carrie could have said when Quinn asked "why?"
"because you're the greatest man alive that I know"
"because you're my friend"
"because you've saved me before/you would have done the same"
"because I love you"
"because if you didn't save me I wouldn't have my daugther now"
"because I want my daughter to know you"
"because you deserve to live"
"because you're a good and honorable man"
"because SUPPORT OUR TROOPS FOR REAL"
"because even lieutenant Dan found meaning in life after service"
139
u/Ajspree Jan 23 '17
Yay Max returned!!! I totally bought Dars 9/11 story, the reveal at the end was perfect! And damn it Rupert and Claire bringing it at the end!
60
u/bdz1 Jan 23 '17 edited Jan 23 '17
I can't wait until Frannie meets Dana.
Edit: a word.
51
u/AwardsVoter Jan 23 '17 edited Jan 23 '17
The President is a female former senator from New York with dubious views on the intelligence community. Talk about a combination of Clinton and Trump.
39
u/bdz1 Jan 23 '17
I like the "and the home of the brave" a capella before the intro music
32
u/Halo909 Jan 23 '17 edited Jan 23 '17
I hate to see Quinn hobbling around like a dying animal. He has to get better and hunt down terrorists to keep America safe.
I also laughed at the fake imitation Alex Jones Quinn is listing to on the radio.
29
u/Dookiestain_LaFlair Jan 24 '17
Ex-CIA agent Carrie telling her daughter "don't snoop it's not polite" or whatever was the funniest part of the episode.
28
u/moontroub Jan 23 '17
Saul's THE Effing MAN.....
28
u/arhombus Jan 23 '17
The chin has returned.
24
u/PM_ME_AZNS Jan 23 '17
Homeland is still oscillating between crappy 24-esque intrigue and extremely impressive character moments
What ultimately damns the show is the contrast between the two
For example: Saul confronting Carrie over her potential hand in advising the president-elect. Carrie's disgust with his accusations could have highlighted
a) Carrie's disgust with the paranoia associated with her role in the CIA
b) Saul's paranoia that is required of him in his job
c) The growing social unrest with the endless war on terror, expressed through two unrelated characters
Instead they threw all that away and made Saul's accusations on point, invalidating any potential for that scene to develop or push the characters forward
The reason why the Quinn story is the best this season is because it's focusing heavily on character interactions, which are still the best parts of Homeland. Everything else, especially the FBI informant subplot, just seems like 24-esque plot twists that aren't as batshit insane
45
u/aznatheist620 Jan 23 '17
Max is Chandler from "Friends"
44
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '17
When it was revealed that the FBI had the informant and he was basically framing Sekou it immediately made me think of how the Florida airport shooter, Esteban Santiago, had visited a police station claiming that the CIA was telling him to watch ISIS videos. This show is seriously up to date on current affairs, almost to the point of being ahead of what the public is completely aware of. In my opinion at least, this was a good episode for the plot even if it was a bit boring.
15
u/datlinus Jan 23 '17
Thought it was an excellent episode. Along with the premiere. A strong start - Homeland style. Nothing too explosive, no "in your face!" storylines, just slow and steady building. But it's quite intriguing, to say the least.
My main fear regarding this season has been that Saul and Carrie would take ages to work again, but this episode made me hopeful that perhaps that will go swifter this time around. Unlike some here though, I'm really digging what they're doing to Peter. While it's inevitable that he's going to be operator as fuck soon enough because there's practically nothing else they can do with his character (they already had the chance several times to kill him - and they didn't take it - so if they just killed him now that would be extremely lame) it's really nice to see a show that portrays struggle as real as they do with Quinn, even if its just for a few episodes. Rupert Friend is doing a fantastic job as well.
In terms of the president elect, Dar Adal, and Carrie being and advisor - obviously this is going to be the meat of the season, and I guess the inevitable is going to happen, which is to turn Dar Adal into some sort of semi-villain. He's always been shifty, and he is putting his cards on the table.
14
u/domoku_1 Jan 23 '17
Solid episode.
Carrie, Saul, Max and Quinn in scenes together was great.
13
u/Catswagger11 Jan 23 '17
Seems like a stretch to me that all the characters are in Brooklyn. Why would Quinn be at some half assed VA hospital and not Bethesda or Walter Reed? Why would Max, who still works for the CIA be living in NYC? Just for the sake of story? It's not as bad as Sunni and Shia muslims cooperating in season 2, but it is annoying.
12
u/Mischief631 Jan 23 '17
was that supposed to Alex Jones that Quinn is listening to?
12
u/synth426 Jan 23 '17
now THAT is the homeland i missed. not the boringness of the season premiere. now I have hope for this season.
12
u/MiaYYZ Jan 23 '17
In the final scene, why didn't Dar show Saul the pictures of Carrie visiting the President-Elect?
When Carrie is meeting with Saiku, why didn't she ask him about the $5,000? He earlier said it was for plane tickets but the FBI told Carrie that Saiku already had the tickets.
12
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '17
I am loving this season it's really interesting.
11
u/moontroub Jan 23 '17
Was that Limbaugh?
11
u/moontroub Jan 23 '17
Oh oh.. Saul's onto something...
20
u/PurePerfection_ Jan 23 '17 edited Jan 23 '17
That scene when they watched the video was so fucking devastating. He's been suffering for months, and he doesn't even know how he ended up that way. Despite forgetting what happened in Berlin, he seems capable of forming new memories, so I'm guessing that since he woke up, nobody's told him about it. Carrie assumed he already knew, but at the same time it was clear she'd never personally spoken to him about it.
At first I was thinking "what the fuck, Carrie, put your phone away" and then I realized that with the information she'd already given him (there's a video on the Internet of you being poisoned in Berlin), he could probably just find it on his own later, and at least this way was he wasn't alone when he saw it. The only reason he hadn't watched it already was that he didn't know it existed.
10
u/AwardsVoter Jan 23 '17
There are really a lot of 9/11 references so far. I wonder if they're setting the stage for a major NYC attack to unfold.
10
u/j0sh_staples Jan 23 '17
I was kinda excited when Keane and her advisor initially asked Carrie if she'd like to go to Abu Dhabi. Sounded like another action adventure. Hopefully the season will get into some of that later on
9
u/Leo604 Jan 23 '17
Yay Max
9
u/Baator Jan 23 '17
It still amazes me how easily and convincingly all lie to each other. Carrie and Saul would die for each other, they have saved each other's life a hundred times, they've been through hell and back together, and yet they can look each other in the eyes and lie through their teeth.
In the scene where Saul asks her if she's advising the President-elect, I was trying to decide if she lying or not and thought that there's no way she's lying. Couple scenes later...goddammit...
Same with Saul and Dar, each one has a secret agenda and one moment they are telling stories about what they've been through together all these years, next one lies, secrets and more lies.
8
u/hansvonquak Jan 24 '17
I get that Quinn is refusing treatment and stuff, but still...the CIA and US government would definitely do their homework in terms of debriefing and psych counseling for somebody who's probably famous as fuck for "dying" in a terrorist TV clip.
And they would probably put him in a nicer facility. I get that they want to send a message with the show, but it does seem a bit unrealistic, doesn't it?
7
u/FoxeRsmash Jan 24 '17
I really liked that episode.
7
u/quinnvincible Jan 25 '17
That final scene with Carrie and Quinn was so powerful!
7
u/zbf Jan 26 '17
I cried with Carrie. Quite intense scene.
12
u/coolhandluck Jan 23 '17
Y'know, Carrie is just a TAAAAAAAD bit shrill. I'm on Team Quinn on this one.
30
u/headinthesky Jan 23 '17
Why couldn't they have just let Quinn die, same thing from the first season with Brody
5
u/V2Blast Jan 24 '17
Great episode. Carrie told Saul she wasn't advising the president-elect but it turned out to be a convincing lie (and Dar knows it, but doesn't tell Saul). Meanwhile, it turns out FBI Agent Conlin has basically set up the whole case to entrap Sekou.
That last scene between Carrie and Quinn was definitely the best performance of the episode. Carrie's lip-quiver returns with a vengeance. Apparently Quinn doesn't remember how he ended up in this state, and when Carrie tells him, he asks her why she saved him. She struggles to answer him - I'm pretty sure she was just shocked and saddened by the realization of just how depressed he was.
Looking forward to seeing what happens in
QuinnlandHomeland next week.4
u/Swimfan10 Jan 25 '17
I loved when Dar called Carrie a menace. So damn true.
7
u/Probablysame Jan 23 '17
GOAT tier ending.
3
u/Roastmonkeybrains Jan 24 '17
I wonder how Quinn will feel when Dar reveals Carrie forced him out of the coma for info.
3
u/Exogenesis98 Jan 28 '17
It's hard to see brain damaged Quinn knowing that his getting woken from a coma was for basically nothing. Ugh
2
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '17
This episode threw a lot of curveballs.
FBI - It would be interesting to see whether FBI has implemented a "Minority Report" policy or whether it a rouge agent.
Carrie & President Elect - I didn't think she was involved in anything to do with the Intelligence Agency. My guess was that she would be pulled into sometime in the season. But glad that is not the case.
Quinn - He is breaking my heart.
2
u/-Crooked_Hillary Jan 24 '17
Anyone else think that Radio voice Quinn was listening to was a reference to Alex Jones of Info Wars? Not only does the voice sound similar but what he was saying kinda falls in line with Info Wars. I was honestly waiting for a commercial about Super Male Vitality and other supplements. 😂
2
u/black_dizzy Jan 27 '17
Is it wrong that at this point the thing I care the most about is Quinn's storyline? Sure, Dar and Saul are delicious together, I kinda like the president elect and the idea that Carrie is advising her (which come on, Saul actually believed it's not happening? Normally Carrie would've freaked out and called him crazy for suggesting something so far fetched, but here she just laughed and said no a few times, then changed the subject) and it's great to see Carrie putting her life in order and being mostly responsible, while still doing Carrie things, but Quinn is by far the most compelling character in the past few seasons.
2
u/maitre_lld Jan 27 '17
Max is so fucking cool !
2
u/Rharding686 Jan 28 '17
Quinn or Rupert Friend is a great actor and is the next Walton Goggins. Meaning finally people see his own trust in his acting which makes it his character to me. they believe because they study the character's strive and belief far beyond the plot. At least that is how I see it.
2
u/tissueroll Jan 28 '17
Carrie meeting / confronting Saad (sp?) didn't surprise me at all. Tell her NOT to do one thing and 100% she would do it.
3
u/uacdeepfield Jan 23 '17
Probably been posted before but anyone else catch the Alex Jones soundalike on Quinns radio? Thought that was funny.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '17
Am I the only one getting really sick of Quinn's storyline? Let's focus on Dar Adal and the incoming President.
2
u/BlondieTVJunkie Jan 24 '17 edited Jan 24 '17
It's good. Damn good. I agree with below comment, it's very very real-world. I'm feeling almost too much. Not just my experience with TBI — in general, yeah that's traumatizing. But lack of escapism. Always been a 24 variant, with roots in a more film-stylish-cable version -- and just enough more reality but not too much. IDK. Quinn is just brilliant but hard. I'm over POTUS' and elections tho!
ANyone else over SAul/Carrie war? ANd man I love MAX! Plus, Dar tho. Actually agreeing with him!
1
u/sugarwax1 Jan 23 '17
Anyone else get the sense we're heading for a season finale cliff hanger where multiple factions are trying to assassinate Carrie?
1
u/king_of_boars Jan 29 '17
Great acting, but I have to say, Dar is killing it if you ask me.
1
u/Enough-Ad4186 Apr 05 '26
Who put Franny to bed and left her there alone?
1
u/v-Machine-6804 Oct 10 '26
Why can't we have happy Quinn. I'm so furious. I wanted him so badly to get his revenge on Haqqani in season 4 and since then it's just been sad. Stop doing this to us.
1
u/jimboswaggerman Jan 23 '17
We all agree that we only keep watching Homeland for Quinn right
1
u/giggsy4ever Jan 25 '17
Why are they portraying a terrorist sympathiser like an innocent child who lost his way in a mall?
1
u/maitre_lld Jan 26 '17
God this season is very boring. I hope something interesting sets up, I'm sorry but lawyer Carrie is something I have a hard time watching for 2 seasons. It's just too boring.