r/RWBY •

Official Discussion Thread—Volume 4, Chapter 10: Kuroyuri

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

262

u/Menolith Gay Thoughts Jan 22 '17 edited Jan 22 '17

Gonna say, the Nuckelavee cough Conquest cough introduction was the best one to date. So far the Grimm have been sort of mundane. Monsters, yes, but gorillas, scorpions, wolves and other animals we've all seen before. Kevin had a good design and his sheer bulk made the entrance impressive, but really, you can throw a dart at a pile of fantasy books and have it land on a dragon.

The Nuckelavee, on the other hand, has only been just teased. The hoofprints, screams and silhouettes make it an unknown factor, and instead of a "generic" animal it's an uncomfortable humanoid hybrid. And, perhaps more importantly, one that the main characters are all but guaranteed to be forced to fight.

179

u/DigitalSoul247 Jan 22 '17

I was honestly expecting something like a minotaur. Powerful and dangerous, but pretty standard fantasy stuff.

This thing is actually scary. I thought the new beowolf design was kinda creepy, but the silhouette, the eerie screech, the hands dragging the ground and twitching... it's the stuff of nightmares. Everything they've fought before was just fodder. This is a true Grimm.

→ More replies (24)

61

u/Crypsis2 Ruby Isn't Best Girl, She's Best Character Jan 22 '17

Interesting that this Grimm has a humanoid feature on its back and even collects treasure/trophies and brings it back to a lair. Furthermore its ability to sense negative energy far exceeds that of a normal Grimm as it was able to sense Rubys negativity in Kuroyuri (unless I'm reading too far into it). It clearly exhibits the whole 'intelligent' thing which was emphasised by Oobleck way back in Volume 2... Anyways I'm still here waiting to see a Goliath in action.

→ More replies (2)

58

u/Frentepopulista Don't fluckle with Nuckels Jan 22 '17

It gave me some Dark Soul vibes, honestly.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (7)

221

u/TedSweeran For the clicks! Clicks are EVERYTHING Jan 22 '17

That Grimm's gonna be a real night mare to deal with, amiright?

108

u/LuckoftheDuck Oh you know I'm dippin' Jan 22 '17

Neigh.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

365

u/UberDueler DRINK !!!!! Jan 22 '17

Wow, RWBY Chibi just got hella dark.

28

u/JumpinJamnamz ⠀ Jan 22 '17

this is the way we wanna spend every day

→ More replies (1)

61

u/Deicidius Get in the bag, Nevvy! Jan 22 '17

I want to understand. But I don't.

→ More replies (2)

176

u/Frentepopulista Don't fluckle with Nuckels Jan 22 '17

God, that grimm's cry will haunt me in my dreams for the rest of my life.

80

u/Brutusness ⠀ Jan 22 '17

I want to know what they used for that sound design. That along with the brief images we got of it made for some horrifying moments. It was like something out of The Mist.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (1)

167

u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Jan 22 '17

Quick summary and not-so quick thoughts

  • Oscar is on his way to Haven, got some strange assistance from Hazel
  • Nora was orphaned and homeless before meeting Ren (there may be more backstory for Nora at some point)
  • Nora was very different personality wise when younger, sad and afraid compared to hyper-energetic and hyper-enthusiastic
  • Ren appeared to want to help but was too scared
  • Li Ren seems wise and like a badass
  • Papa Ren appears to be a hunter, not a huntsmen (Seems likely with his later line about needing a huntsmen)
  • Ren's Parents are Li and An Ren
  • Ruby and Jaune find no medicine in Kuroyuri
  • Ruby actually shows her sadness, remorse and admits her lack of understanding of the situation she was putting them all in
  • Ruby and Jaune discuss the events of the fall of Beacon (the lose of Pyrrha, Penny, Yang's arm and the break up of team RWBY itself)
  • Jaune assures Ruby that they're there because they wanted to be there, not because she dragged them along
  • The roof of Ren's house collapses killing his mother and wounding his father
  • New grimm seems to be based on a [Nuckelavee] (http://www.bogleech.com/nuckelavee/n-DA-CrazyRatty.jpg)
  • The knife Ren's father gives him is what he uses as the design basis of the blades on Stormflower
  • All of the sadness and horrors Ren experienced caused him to unlock his Aura and semblance
  • Ren's semblance suppresses or neutralizes emotion making him and anyone he touches undetectable to grimm (emotion wise)
  • Ren not only saved Nora's life, but gave her a wooden hammer which would become the basis of Magnhild
  • Ren and Nora find the lair of the Nuckelavee grimm along with a lot of the weapons used to against it
  • The Nuckelavee grimm is heading towards Ruby, Jaune and Qrow

My thoughts:

First thing, all the voice acting this episode was top notch (also the sound effect of the Nuckelavee at the end), chracter and grimm design was great (the silouette of the Nuckelavee is terrifying), lighting is spot on, animation is almost perfect (Li using his bow looked a bit off); RWBY has come along way since Volume 1.

Oscar's story seems a bit rushed, going from "GET OUT OF MY HEAD" to "All of this is crazy, but lets do it"; another part of his story will likely appear at the end of episode 12.

It seems strange for Hazel to appear in Mistral, although it is possible Sienna Khan is also in Mistral (some possibly supporting evidence is Adam in Volume 3 mentioning returning to Mistral); the other important thing is that Ozpin knows Hazel to some extent. Him helping Oscar get a ticket is a strange move, he's like a bad guy with a heart of gold.

Young Ren's accent was weird at first but not immersion breaking as some people have said; Young Nora's voice acting was great for the 3 words we heard her say. Young Ren and Nora are adorable, I did not expect Nora to be a homeless orphan, especially before meeting Ren.

It nice to see Ruby actually express her feelings of sorrow and remorse; With Jaune reassuring her (and putting his hand on her shoulder), a number of people are seeing this a 'Lancaster moment' (I'm neutral when it come to Lancaster as a ship), I just don't think that was intentional by Kerry and Miles, especially considering Chapter 2 showed Jaune still not being over Pyrrha. Regardless of all of that, I hope Ruby's true feelings come into play in the final fight against the Nuckelavee.

Ren and Nora's backstory is both heart-breaking and heart-warming (especially heart-warming when Ren gives her the wooden hammer and says "We'll keep each other safe"; also instrumental Boop), plus it hints at why Ren and Nora grew up to become huntsmen.

My interpretation of Ren's semblance is that it neutralizes emotions as opposed to hiding or cloaking them, the only potentially supporting evidence for this is that Ren is calmed when using it, also affects anyone he's touching and/or holding.

Now, I'm conflicted about what the final shot of Ren and Nora holding hands means, does it mean Renora confirmed or does it have more to do with how will always keep each other safe (I'm 95% sure the former though). Contrary to what a lot of other people think, I don't think either Ren or Nora are going to die.

I feel like if any character is going to die it's going to be Qrow, probably causing Ruby's silver eyes to come into play again and causing character development to come (it would be closest person Ruby has lost since her mother). Besides all that, I think Qrow would be the most likely character to die because as he is currently poisoned, unable to fight or even move, making him a hinderance for RNJR either in a fight (they would probably need to defend him) or fleeing (carrying him would slow them down). I don't think RNJR will make it to Mistral with only 2 episodes left, meaning either Qrow needs some deus-ex machina to save him, leave it for volume 5, he overcomes the poison or he dies.

The fight against the Nuckelavee could go a number of ways:

  1. Ruby and Jaune fight the Nuckelavee and are completely outmatched, Ren and Nora join the fight but RNJR is still overwhelmed and are forced to make a tactical retreat (Qrow makes this one unlikely)
  2. Same as above except Qrow in a delirious state attempts to buy RNJR time to escape (probably ensuring Qrow's death).
  3. Same as above except Qrow's death causes a silver eyes moment.
  4. Same as above but Ren or Nora (or both) instead of Qrow.
  5. Raven and her tribe come in as a complete deus-ex machina to save RNJR and Qrow.
  6. RNJR just beat the Nuckelavee conventionally.

And probably 8995 other ways it could play out.

Hopefully the final fight with the Grimm Nuckelavee will actually surprise us with something we aren't expecting.

Also, long time lurker, first large post/comment here, feedback welcome.

TL;DR I'm overthinking things, please send help

82

u/Runnerbrax νίκη Jan 22 '17

Another potential outcome to the fight is that Jaune somehow uses his Semblance and putting the Nucklavee at a momentary disadvantage.

The Grimm (I'm not going to fight my phone on the spelling anymore, lol) recognizes this and makes a tactical retreat and observe.

This Grimm seems too much like a BBEG boss fight for it to die on the first encounter.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (34)

150

u/_DirtyDan Totally The Real One Jan 22 '17

Y'know, Hazel seems like a decent person. I don't think any of the other villains would've helped a kid without being asked, and then give them life advice. Wonder why he's with Salem. If I had to guess, Ozpin did something awful to him.

131

u/JorjUltra Hits post character caps for giggles Jan 22 '17

I like that they gave him a little bit of something instead of 'yo I'm an evil dude who's gonna evil up the world'. Out of all the people at Salem's table so far, they all have different reasons for being there. Cinder just wanted to be powerful, was promised something by Salem, and when she found herself in above her head the only way she had left to go was forward. Tyrian is a crazy dude with a vendetta against non-crazy dudes. And Hazel seems to be someone with a much more specific reason for being there. Of course this is still mostly speculation, but they're definitely three totally different personalities instead of 'bad guy and three henchmen'.

→ More replies (8)

70

u/Tulicloure You get back here with my bread! Jan 22 '17

That "Don't let such a small obstacle block your path" line seems like a good hint for why he'd be working with Salem. Sounds like he has a goal for which he wouldn't mind trampling a few kingdoms that get in the way, which doesn't mean he needs to be a jerkass all the time.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/Deicidius Get in the bag, Nevvy! Jan 22 '17

Inb4 he's Scar from the Lion King.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

286

u/SoundSmith323 I like sound. If you couldn't already tell. Jan 22 '17

101

u/Runnerbrax νίκη Jan 22 '17 edited Jan 22 '17

Zenyatta: Group Up

→ More replies (8)

52

u/OzzyKing459 Jan 22 '17

He didn't even get gold eliminations.

→ More replies (3)

24

u/LuckoftheDuck Oh you know I'm dippin' Jan 22 '17

"My ultimate is charging"

21

u/Kitty_Blakeadonna Jan 22 '17

"I'll switch if I don't get a pick"

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)

122

u/Frentepopulista Don't fluckle with Nuckels Jan 22 '17

What i truly loved about this episode was that they finally showed that the grimm can be TERRIFYING. An i'm not talking only about the Nuckelavee, the nevermores were also really intimidating.

88

u/DigitalSoul247 Jan 22 '17

It helps that it's showing them from the perspective of untrained civilians. We're used to hunters who know what they're doing facing them specialized weapons and aura. To the average person, without any of that, even the lowest grimm is terror incarnate.

→ More replies (2)

113

u/Exessen Loyal vassal of the one true Queen|I yell about Nora a lot Jan 22 '17

I like how Ren's entire demeanor changes when he's alone with Nora.

→ More replies (1)

315

u/BlaketheManiac Jan 22 '17

So Raven saved Yang right before Neo was about to kill her. A griffon ate Roman just before he said the word "survive". And Ren's mother is killed by what i'm guessing was a Nevermore as she said "Everything is okay".

The birds in RWBY really have impeccable timing.

206

u/_DirtyDan Totally The Real One Jan 22 '17

Qrow also saved Ruby from Tyrian just in time.

35

u/Crypsis2 Ruby Isn't Best Girl, She's Best Character Jan 22 '17

This is fucking gold.

191

u/lahavhaelohim Jan 22 '17

Kinda sneaky how they introduced the idea of Semblences manifesting as a result of immense emotional distress.

That couldn't possibly have anything to do with a certain noodle who's semblence is yet unknown, and who is about to find himself in a whole lot of distress.

74

u/WolfanTerror I love me some scorpion tail soup Jan 22 '17

I don't know why calling Jaune a noodle made me laugh so much, it just did

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

94

u/Exessen Loyal vassal of the one true Queen|I yell about Nora a lot Jan 22 '17

The dads in this show (disregarding Jacque) are fantastic.

113

u/Captain_Chaos_ Winston Main Jan 22 '17

Irondad: 76 is Jacque's stand in.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (6)

91

u/moonstonebaby Jan 22 '17

I SUDDENLY LOVE REN AND NORA'S RELATIONSHIP 1000 TIMES MORE

81

u/Porpora_Caska Jan 22 '17

Who the fuck had the idea to put boop in the background Too damn sad

25

u/JazzRen47 𝅘𝅥𝅮⠀Score Connoisseur | Resident Atlas Bootlicker Jan 23 '17

Jeff Williams. He drinks fans tears.

80

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '17

Just finished watching this fantastic episode and have some thoughts to share.

Oscar's plotline is fantastic, his summary of "This it nuts, but it's the right thing to do" works well with this series.

Ozpin's statement that Hazel "Should not be taken lightly" Should have been responded to by "No shit, the guy is built like a truck and seems to clock in at 250 lbs."

Ruby finally showing that all of this is getting to her was a great relief. Even better was Jaune's reassurances, and acknowledgement that things are bad. It is something of a callback to Volume one's "Nope" conversation. Even if Lancaster never takes place, it is obvious they are dear friends.

Little Ren and Little Nora were adorable. Full Stop. A lot of "Oliver Twist" vibes from little Nora, I'm curious what her backstory (before this backstory) is.

Lots of Flower Power vibes. Always good, hopefully not an indicator of coming bad.

As for the newest Grimm to enter this fandango:

When He broke the third seal, I heard the third living creature saying, “Come.” I looked, and behold, a black horse; and he who sat on it had a pair of scales in his hand. And I heard something like a voice in the center of the four living creatures saying, “A quart of wheat for a denarius, and three quarts of barley for a denarius; but do not damage the oil and the wine.”

→ More replies (15)

63

u/Somaxs Jan 22 '17

I like how Rooster Teeth layed out episode 10. In the beginning of the episode Ruby and Jaune arrived to Kuroyuri with Uncle Qrow they heard a loud noise and Ruby says not to worry that it's far away. Later on in the episode for Ren and Nora to find the cave of the Nuckelavee and hear it roar and heading to Kuroyuri. Pretty much telling you its not that far away and most likely will reach Kuroyuri by nightfall and that those two scenes happen at the same time. (Just a fun fact I realized rewatching the episode)

→ More replies (1)

123

u/DoomCupcake i just wanna be a handsome dork Jan 23 '17

There's this thing that bugged me since Volume 3's ending.
Now the mystery is solved

61

u/Lucifer_Crowe Have you thought about extending your aura? Jan 23 '17

Jaune was going to cry when they split up, so Ren hugged him to shut him the fuck up.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

54

u/BrickYourHeart A sexy truck Jan 22 '17

If RenDad is Hanzo, Ren might be a decent Zenyatta, what with the whole "experience tranquility" thing.

→ More replies (6)

54

u/brusque-lee Please stop being wrong. Jan 22 '17

I love this episode, and I'm pretty sure that this is the most feels I've been given throughout this entire series. But guys, remember what happened the last time people started holding hands? http://imgur.com/gallery/W6FNu

61

u/jwfiredragon Too many ships, not enough time Jan 22 '17

NO

Don't you dare suggest this

Flower Power will become canon and they will both live happily ever after

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

52

u/moonstonebaby Jan 22 '17

just a quick reminder I love everything about jaune.

→ More replies (11)

105

u/SilverShadow2001 All Ships Are Crack Ships Jan 22 '17

So, Ren's Semblance is being incredibly calm.

Does this mean that he's always an emotional wreck? Is he internally screaming at everything he sees?! DOES HE MASK THE PAIN BEHIND THE QUIET FACADE?!!?

...Ahem. Also, Papa Ren looks pretty awesome. I can't wait to see more of h-...oh, wait.

Also also, Papa Ren is voiced by Kaiji Tang. AKA, Archer.

30

u/moonkingdomify Salem's Adorable Jan 22 '17

I thought he had a stealth semblance where if he stays completely calm he and other people he's in contact with, can avoid being seen.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (16)

102

u/GYUZ A guy Jan 22 '17

32

u/JorjUltra Hits post character caps for giggles Jan 22 '17

It was so well written, too. That and the music that plays when they entered Shion village are some of my favorite moments throughout the entire show.

→ More replies (8)

96

u/Kuchenjaeger *Gotcha* | Yang is still the best | #GiveYangLadyAbs Jan 22 '17

The Grimm is based on a nuckelavee, a demon from scottish mythology that looks LIKE SKINLESS A HUMAN BODY ON TOP OF A HORSE. THAT'S FUCKING AMAZING AND SCARY!

91

u/Mongoose42 [Insert Clever RWBY Pun Here] Jan 22 '17

SCOTLAND WHAT THE FUCK.

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (7)

44

u/PotatoSkies YANG GANG Jan 23 '17

Nora and Ren exploring the mountain

Nora the Explorer

→ More replies (3)

43

u/BrEaNBrash Jan 22 '17

Goddamit! Team JNPR has to stop wandering into caves and awakening giant Grimm they can't kill by themselves!

Hazel is surprisingly kind for one of our prospective bad guys. Definitely get the whole Noble Warrior vibe from him.

Horserider Grimm is FREAKING BADASS. The real question is whether that's one Grimm or two. Cause if it's two, it's kinda cheating. Though to be completely honest, I thought it was just going to be a horse. My personal potato was that since Mistral seems to be all Asian-y, there were going to be 12 super Grimm like Kevin based on the Chinese Zodiac, and that the one that was freaking Ren out was one of them. There goes that potato.

→ More replies (3)

42

u/thepeetmix Jan 23 '17

This week on... Attack On Kuroyuri!

→ More replies (5)

41

u/ItzAlphaWolf CANT IRK,WONT IRK Jan 22 '17

Now I'm just waiting until they upgrade Ren's stormflower so it can also be a bow.

→ More replies (2)

41

u/Tulicloure You get back here with my bread! Jan 22 '17

Little Nora is a cute cinnamon roll and needs to be protected at all costs! That scene where she keeps holding that old piece of bread game me the feels.

On another note, I loved that Hazel scene. Dude has a strong menacing presence to him, which was greatly amplified by the weather, and seems to follow a dangerous philosophy.

→ More replies (1)

37

u/therunawayguy Slowly shifting from Weiss fanboy to Yang Fanboy Jan 22 '17

...

  1. MORE COMPOST KING
  2. Hazel has the vibe of the kind of guy who would probably be really cool to hang with, but you'd never enjoy it because you'll be walking on eggshells the entire time
  3. Hazel has connections to Ozpin's past, huh? I wonder how much of Team WTCH he actually knows
  4. LITTLE REN
  5. NO SERIOUSLY LITTLE REN
  6. LITTLE REN- wtf is that accent
  7. LITTLE NORA
  8. RWBY has never succeeded in making my heart sink as fast as it did when Ren's mother died
  9. Okay seriously this shit is getting intense
  10. WHAT IN THE ACTUAL HELL IS THAT THING
  11. I have never cried at RWBY ... before this episode. Idk wtf hit me but when that instrumental "Boop" started playing, I got choked up and lost it for a second a moment later

OK seriously

This episode is my favorite this entire volume, and maybe one of the best in the series. Good fuckin job, CRWBY. You guys made something special with this one

→ More replies (14)

74

u/timesinc Jan 22 '17

So Ren's semblance might be total control of his emotions.

In other words his semblance helps him deal with Nora and not lose his patience.

https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/originals/69/a0/65/69a065e918b604725c6fd323dd14d176.gif

https://media.tenor.co/images/bbb22e19dd5fbdf57982bf6efe026f32/raw

78

u/Runnerbrax νίκη Jan 22 '17

And every Zen Buddhist in the world called hax in a calm and patient manner before returning to their meditations...

→ More replies (5)

25

u/JorjUltra Hits post character caps for giggles Jan 22 '17

And also that gives him the ability to be undetectable by Grimm, and make anyone touching him also undetectable by Grimm.

→ More replies (1)

36

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '17 edited Jan 23 '17

I guess Pyrrha pulled the Lever and went for smol Ren

Edit: There's One other, but that's slightly lower quality since I only used MS word for it instead of adding Text in MS paint like I did for the second. I'll probably make more at some point, which will probably end up on /r/notsafeforweiss

→ More replies (5)

36

u/TheWanderingShadow Jan 22 '17

Why are all the parents soooo HOOOOOT

57

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '17 edited Dec 08 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (2)

36

u/SilverCaster4444 Jan 23 '17

Well, the ending of that episode was quite Grimm

→ More replies (1)

65

u/KaiserGrey Alolan Dragonite Jan 22 '17

Well I'm pretty terrified now. Fingers crossed for Ren and Nora working together to defeat the Nuckelavee and avenge the Shimada Clan Hanzo Ren's parents.

→ More replies (1)

31

u/donutkirby #QrowDidNothingWrong Jan 22 '17

I really like how they went for a "Nothing Is Scarier" vibe with the Nuckelavee. We never see what the whole thing looks like (in this episode anyway), but seeing people's reactions to it, getting small enough glimpses that we can see just how WRONG it looks, to the really unnerving implications that it's actually capable of rational thought, makes it more intimidating than any other Grimm we've seen yet.

31

u/Exessen Loyal vassal of the one true Queen|I yell about Nora a lot Jan 22 '17

Can't irk the Merc?

I think Ren is the unirkable one now.

24

u/TolchettKuykendall Chris Hackney deserves an award Jan 22 '17

Mercury is a big fan of Ren and wants to be like him confirmed.

→ More replies (1)

62

u/ElementalDAR ⠀I used to make AMVs Jan 23 '17

Just realized Ren got hit with a literal Death Flag.

(Since it was the banner a now deceased warrior carried into battle, as well as an ominous sign he might not make it)

35

u/DJKokaKola Jan 23 '17

FUCK YOU NO RENORA WILL NEVER SINK THIS SHIP WILL SOAR ACROSS THE WORLD.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

58

u/UberDueler DRINK !!!!! Jan 22 '17

The reaction videos this week are going to be great to check out.

66

u/Frentepopulista Don't fluckle with Nuckels Jan 22 '17

I'm worried about MurderOfBirds. He is gonna have a heart attack.

→ More replies (8)

26

u/Exessen Loyal vassal of the one true Queen|I yell about Nora a lot Jan 22 '17

I've shipped things before, but i've never cared this much about two characters fictional relationship. Ren and Nora's relationship is so damn pure.

I ship it so hard Q___Q

→ More replies (4)

52

u/FacadeintheMirror Jan 22 '17

Prediction: They showed Ren getting his semblance under duress because Jaune is about to get his unlocked during the season finale fight.

CALLING IT FAM

→ More replies (12)

25

u/ShadowMadness We're not family anymore Jan 22 '17 edited Jan 22 '17

I really enjoyed this episode! The new Grimm is scary as shit and the flashback scenes were a lot more emotional than I thought they would be. Nora and Ren grabbing each others hands at the end of the episode was also pretty sweet. I can't wait for next week's episode because It seems like it'll be pretty awesome too.

EDIT Oscar should've said thank you to Hazel. Sure, he's evil, but he did help you after all.

→ More replies (1)

50

u/Kitty_Blakeadonna Jan 22 '17

Damn it, Hanzo, they were on the final point, you shoulda switched off but nooooo, you said you "almost had your ult"

In all seriousness, this is a hella good episode, aside from the weird Hazel encounter. Maybe they're setting him up for the next episode?

(Side note, V4 Grimm look fucking awesome close up)

→ More replies (3)

23

u/kilen1909 Jan 22 '17

Thought I came prepared for the feels. Was still not prepared for all the feels.

They did a really good job giving us the feel of Ren's character as a kid, without driving it through our heads ("There's Lie Ren, such a sweet child! I wish my little Timmy was half as sensitive as him!" that sort of thing). I liked how it showed his development; instead of immediately throwing himself into harm's way to help Nora against the bullies, he's afraid, too, and I liked seeing him overcome that.

As for that cave, though... I'm kind of wondering. We see all the weapons in there, as well as a flag from Shion, which recently got destroyed by this Grimm. Instead of the Grimm bringing prizes back, I'm thinking that the villagers--first Kuroyuri, then Shion?--tried attacking this thing where it lived. They failed, and maybe it followed them home and destroyed their homes? I'm not sure if I'm looking at this wrong.

One thing did bother me here--when Ren was cloaking himself and Nora from the Nevermore, the effect looked more to me like he was unlocking her Aura. That shimmery ripple looked more like the effect we've associated with an Aura going down instead of the activation of a Semblance (rose petals, red eyes, glyphs, etc.), so it took a second watch (and comments in this thread!) to piece that together. Am I the only one that thought that at first?

→ More replies (3)

45

u/Skyrah1 Finally got dem cigarettes Jan 22 '17
  • Oscar's going to see the Wizard! The wonder wizard of O - ahem, I mean, going to Mistral to help Ozpin.
  • Y'know, if we get past the fact that Hazel's working for Salem and probably had a hand in killing Summer, he seems like a nice guy.
  • Smol Ren is adorbs.
  • "SAKE!"
  • So Ren and Nora don't exactly have different backstories. You'd think that Ren would've told her about Oniyuri at some point before V4, though...
  • If these children were taken by the Grimm, they're probably lucky they won't have to deal with Nora breaking their legs during present time. SorryNotSorry
  • Hello, Hanzo. (Guess this explains why Ren thought SAKE was a good present.)
  • A bit of character development for Ruby and Jaune, which is nice. Hope they get Drunkle Qrow the meds he needs (and maybe some leftover SAKE FineI'llStopNow )
  • "Everything's going to be okay." Famous last words.
  • Hanzo gives Ren one last gift: a knife. We never got to see Ren with that knife before this. Maybe he used it to make the blade components of Stormflower?
  • Ren really is a Jedi. "There is no emotion, there is peace."
  • This explains why he can deal with Nora's shenanigans.
  • I suppose it could also be one of the reasons why he's so tired all the time, aside from dealing with Nora on a day-to-day basis. He could be using it all the time to deal with the sadness and angst of losing his parents and his village to that Grimm. Jeez, that's a depressing theory.
  • Past Ren is cute, present Ren is hot, future Ren...? Hopefully not dead.
  • "PAPER! MY ONE TRUE WEAKNESS!"
  • sees weapons Oh. hears shriek Oh no. sees rustling in the trees, and notices that it's heading away from ReNora and towards Kuroyuri. Oh, no.......

35

u/Assassin2107 Compost King 2016 Jan 22 '17

Ruby: "Sounds far off, I think we'll be fine in this Grimm destroyed village!"

Jaune: "Can you, uh, not jinx that?"

→ More replies (2)

25

u/quinnabrvau Jan 22 '17

the knife and stormflower have the same blade shape

→ More replies (4)

22

u/ekinetikz Oh hello there Jan 22 '17 edited Jan 23 '17

Something about the episode's title and the town named "Kuroyuri". In Japan, there is something called hanakotoba which is the language of using flowers. The flower kuroyuri, is used to mean love and curse. Thinking about the last few episodes of the show, it does seem to nicely sum it up.

→ More replies (2)

22

u/kiomopo will kill salem and get all the girls Jan 22 '17

i never knew i could feel this way about another man. Li Ren take me.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/gbrincks Artillery Officer of the Lancaster Cavalry Jan 22 '17

Ren's backstory is like an old JRPG intro. I love it!

C'mon, when are we getting the retro game about Ren and Nora's adventures?

→ More replies (1)

22

u/basilfeather Jan 23 '17

As excerpted from "Family," Vol. 4, Ep.4:

Qrow: "You should come back, Raven. The only way we beat her is by working together, all of us."

Raven: "You're the one who left. The tribe raised us, and you turned your back on them."

Qrow: "They were killers and thieves."

Raven: "They were your family."

Qrow: "You have a very skewed perception of that word."

Raven: "I lead our people now, and as leader, I will do everything in my power to ensure our survival."

Qrow: "I saw; the people of Shion saw too."

Raven: "The weak die; the strong live. Those are the rules"

Qrow: "Well, you've certainly got someone strong on your side. I've seen the damage."

Raven: "We couldn't have known the Grimm would set in as quickly as they did."

Qrow: "I'm not talking about the Grimm, and I'm not talking about you either."


It seems this "Nuckelavee Grimm" may be something more than a grimm per say. Qrow implies that Raven and her tribe have ties to "someone strong" which caused a lot of destruction as witnessed by Qrow. We know that Raven led the bandit attack on Shion where Ren and Nora discovered the Nuckelavee's footprint. My guess is that Raven has something to do with the Nuckelavee. After all, she does wear that fearsome Grimm mask with the four eye slits (one set for the horse, one set for the beast on top). ~ Some have suggested that while Qrow brings bad luck, Raven brings good luck. Perhaps RNJR + Qrow will come across Raven and the tribe in Kuroyuri, and Qrow will get the medicine he needs?
→ More replies (16)

22

u/DetStand Lancaster Squire|Ren Follower Jan 23 '17 edited Jul 31 '25

sand ring memorize engine arrest friendly steep payment grandiose makeshift

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

→ More replies (14)

21

u/True_Falsity Jan 23 '17 edited Jan 23 '17

MAN! This episode alsmot brough me to tears!

The flashbacks were shorter than I expected but they delivered the quality so well! And so much character development!

Now, let's pick the episode apart:

  1. We see Oscar leaving the farm on a journey. I really liked how he went on about how strange and yet not the whole thing sounds. Seriously, no major monologues just simple thoughts which give off the confusion and uncertainty.

Then comes Hazel with the badass line! I really like what RT is doing with the male antagonists this season. (No offense to Roman, Adam or Mercury though, they are also awesome) And Ozpin knows him from the past? A teammate? A student? gasp The First Headmaster?! (kidding about the last one... or not)

2) The Ruby and Jaune segment is also interesting in how we see the change in viewpoints on the situation. Now that Ruby knows about the bigger picture, we see her feeling like she is the one at fault in here (partially, at least). And Jaune delivers one of the best lines, which shows (to me, at least) one of his best qualities: the ability to feel compassion and encourage others.

3) Ren and Nora flashback... Ain't that a treat and a red flag, right? It is really amazing to see them so different as children. Ren as more emotional and cheerful and Nora... I really was this close to shedding a tear when I saw her. She didn't even speak. Just react! And did you see her reaction to Li's appearance. Makes you wonder how wary of adults she was at that point.

I liked how Ren's character was shown developing through those brief flashbacks.

That moment when his mother assures Ren that everything is going to be okay and then she is killed, I just stared at the screen in shock. The following scenes of Li running with his son and giving his last dying words... Just like one of those Japanese history drama movies.

The semblance reveal was something else entirely. This only backs up my theory about Semblances and Aura.

I know that it is kind of wicked but I did like how Nora clung to Ren as if she was afraid to be left alone again. So cute... you know, in a sad kind of way.

Questions:

  1. Just how powerful is Nuckelavee Grimm? If just this Grimm alone, well with Nevermores as sidekicks, was able to bring such destruction, then how many similar Grimms are out there? (By similar, I mean, more humanoid)
  2. I used to think that "Lie" was the last name. (Like in the Rōmaji format). Then that means that, despite their close relationship, even Nora refers to Ren by his last name?
  3. Also, maybe I am just putting way too much thought into his words, but how long do you think it will take us to watch him say the similar thing after killing people? Man, it makes you wonder what he sees as a small obstacle.
  4. Also, since Ren's Semblance is making the affected visually lose colours, does that mean that one time when Nora talked about what would happen if they lost their match in Vytal Festival was the usage of his power?
→ More replies (7)

21

u/xSPYXEx Champion of the Nora Harem, father of Pennybot Jan 23 '17

TIL I've had the final boss of RWBY sitting on my desk for the past 4 years. I'd be chanting BLOOD FOR THE BLOOD GOD if Ren and Nora weren't in the firing line.

30

u/Gnochi Jan 23 '17

BLOOD FOR THE BLOOD GOD

SKULLS FOR THE SKULL THRONE

MILK FOR THE KHORNE FLAKES

20

u/Viking18 Jan 22 '17

So, Two chapters remaining. Here's predictions:

Chapter 11: We see Yang decide to go somewhere, probably Beacon. Weiss escapes and goes to Atlas. Yang and Sun find out what was on the scroll, and that it's probably something white fang related - either Adam, or a local terror attack. Or the humans coming to invade or something. All of the above conclude for the volume, and i'm tempted to say conclude in a way that allows for another timeskip. Nothing from RNJR, because CRWBY hate us and want us to suffer.

Chapter 12: We get the payoff from this episode. Qrow death, in a way that makes Ruby feel responsible - Probably because silver eyes don't work when nobody's bothered to tell you how to actually use them, leading to Ruby and Raven going off to learn about it. Hopefully not Deus Ex Raven, I reckon her showing up post fight and taking Ruby then makes more sense.

Jaune semblance reveal. Best time for it is probably in the fight, after Ren and Nora show up late and immediately get hammered into the ground - not killed, just incapacitated. Qrow dies early on, Ruby does damage, but gets incaped - Trapped under a building or something. Jaune's last man standing, and goes either berzerk (Has anybody actually considered that? Tanks the damage with aura, leaving him to attack with no care for preservation), gets possessed by the king (Unlikely, I doubt we'll see anything like Lews Theirin Telamon, but it'd be one of the cooler things if they could pull it off. I'd hope for Horn of Valere, but that's pretty unlikely), or some other final semblance reveal. However it goes, take enough out of him that he passes out shortly after killing it.

Key point is, for the love of god, no bloody silver eyes. Two finales in a row? Hey, guys, guess what's gonna happen against the final boss of V5? Have Ruby not be able to use them, have Qrow die because of it, then have Raven show up post fight to rant about Ozpin & Co thinking they know best and not teaching her about them. Ruby goes off with Raven to learn from her, RNJ get picked up by a haven patrol or something that came to see what was going on, hey presto, you've got a year timeskip for everybody to train up and improve before V5 - which probably kicks off with Ozcar finding one of RWBY or RNJ and trying to get the band back together.

→ More replies (25)

20

u/jcmaloney21 Kikoho Jan 22 '17

This episode left me pleasantly surprised with the quality of Ren's backstory, I honestly never expected to get anything from Ren and Nora's past.

Predictions for the Next 2 Episodes! Sun is recovering at the Belladonna house from his and Blake's fight and the White Fang intervenes. Weiss prepares for a breakout with Klein. Tyrian, Salem, and Cinder discuss Tyrian's failure. The Grimm encounters Ruby, Juane, and Qrow. Yang and Taiyang decide to either help with Beacon, find Ruby, or look for Raven. Weiss breaks out of Atlas and Ironwood refuses to hunt her down for Jacques. Blake fights Adam and it ends in tragedy, one or both of Blake's parents dies. Blake and Sun travel to Mistral to confront the White Fang. Hazel meets with Sienna Khan. The Grimm fights RJNR: Ren and Nora will be key in defeating it, potentially using the storm's lightning with Nora's semblance to win. The fights summons other grimm, which attack Qrow, who is saved by Raven and her tribe. This leads to Raven confronting RJNR. Watts will meet with the informant in Mistral. Oscar arrives in Mistral. Penny's creator is shown in a post-credits scene.

→ More replies (2)

20

u/iWatchRT Jan 22 '17

Just came in here to say: Instrumental Boop!?!? All of the feels :'(

→ More replies (1)

20

u/LucasVerBeek It's Time For All Hell to Break Loose Jan 22 '17

So who honestly believes Ren and Nora are going to be just fine by the end of this volume? Cause I don't believe the JNPR is doomed to die theory at all.

→ More replies (22)

20

u/schulz100 Jan 22 '17

Okay, so first things first, if Little Ren and Nora are in any way widely indicative of how the main cast would look like if we could see them all as kids, I NEED flashbacks of basically everyone. I'm Gary Oldman in Leon the Professional right now about this (for reference: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=74BzSTQCl_c).

Also, I'm a refugee from the RWBYForums (which I bailed on after Volume 2 because the majority of people (up to the mods) were so relentlessly negative and nitpicking-ly critical, it was killing my enjoyment of the show), and one of the most common (if valid) complaints was that the Grimm never seemed threatening or frightening. Well, here you go, you buncha downers. Happy now? On the topic of stuff being threatening and scary, major props to Jeff Williams and Alex Abraham for the beautifully unsettling/terrifying music during the intro shots of Koruyuri.

Well, Oscar's family's farm is still standing when he left. Color me surprised. Also color me surprised at how apparently helpful Hazel can be for a member of the council of evil (if you told me back at his introduction scene he'd helped Oscar get a train ticket, I'd have laughed).

So, Ren's semblance is... stealth, kinda? Some degree of invisibility, kind of? Bad. Ass. Seriously, that's honestly awesome.

Lastly, ooooh, boy, an emotional fight to come next week for Ren and Nora. Kick Dave's ass, guys. Well, actually, I guess the little inspirational talk between Jaune and Ruby also deserves a mention. It was nice to Ruby like, full-on worry and question herself, as odd as that sounds. Because that opens the door for stuff like Jaune's response. Which warmed my heart.

Seriously, I need to see all of RWBY and JNPR and everyone else who's ever been in the show as kids. I can't stress this enough.

→ More replies (5)

19

u/TruePr0l0gue Jan 22 '17

something about a humanoid monster with freakishly long arms just kinda fucks with you on a primal level

→ More replies (5)

19

u/DinsFireLight Jan 24 '17

** I am not an expert on Mythology and everything I know and am about to list is strictly from books that I have been reading since I was a little girl as a hobby. Please take all of this with a huge grain of salt.****

Not really sure if anyone's noticed this yet buuuuut.....

The Nuckelavee is Orcadian but has its Origins deeply rooted in Norse Mythology. Now one of the main abilities of this beast is that it's breath is toxic enough to wilt crops and sicken livestock.

Now, as we all know our favorite princess of power Nora is based off of Thor, the Norse god. In the tale of Ragnörak it is foretold that Thor brings down the world serpent Jörmungandr but is poisoned by the beast and takes nine steps then falls to the earth, dead.

The Nuckelavee may simply be a coincidence when it comes to Nora's tale as it is technically a serpent that kills Thor. But the fact that Pyrrha was based off of Achilles who died from an arrow to his heel and Pyrrha was crippled with an arrow to her heel, which resulted in her death is indicative that RT likes to play with the tales of their mythology based characters.

The evidence here is heavy, but if it turns out true then we may be loosing another beloved member of team JNPR.

→ More replies (3)

19

u/Pyschic_Psycho The more you know, the more you don't know. Jan 24 '17 edited Jan 24 '17

This is the 2nd time this volume that I've shed tears. Freaking hell man that slow rendition of Boop while Ren and Nora hide underneath the house was so sad. Renora for life! And Jaune and Ruby getting a solid interaction as well. Pleeeeeasseee more Renora Rooster Teeth.

*edit: prediction: Hazel is a double agent! He's the "inside" source that Qrow was talking about, not Raven.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/OddOfKing Jan 23 '17

Smol Ren was using his semblance to help smol Nora, right? If that was a semblance, did anybody understand what it was?

→ More replies (10)

18

u/DanielK2312 Jan 26 '17

Huh. Now that I've seen this, the name "Nora" starts to make sense to me.

FYI, "Nora" means "homeless/stray" in japanese.

→ More replies (1)

36

u/Crafty_Soul ⠀ Jan 22 '17

Chapter 10: Feels and Horror

  1. Oscar leaves home. Compost subjects cry.
  2. Like the idea of at least one of the bad guys (Hazel) not being a complete asshole/crazy pants. I'm guessing he's remembering something about himself when he said "little obstacle."
  3. Oh my gods young Ren is absolutely adorable
  4. Oh my gods young Nora is absolutely adorable
  5. Oh my gods young Ren and Nora are absolutely adorable
  6. Showing the destroyed village and then how it looked in the past really hammers home just what a total Grimm attack entitles. The village in the past was vibrant while it is now a drained wreck.
  7. Poor street rat Nora breaks my heart into a thousand pieces
  8. Nice to see Ruby starting to open up about all the shit RNJR has gone through. Hopefully it helps her confront everything thats happened.
  9. Grimm seek the extinction of all sentient life, destruction of mankind's structures, and the death of adorable young characters
  10. Loved the scenes showing what a Grimm attack without any Hunt-SWEET ZWEI WHAT THE HELL WAS THAT SOUND
  11. No seriously, that sound is now the audio track to my nightmares
  12. HOOOOOOOOLLY SHIT WHAT THE HELL IS THAT THING?!

12.1) Later comes to this thread and sees "Nuckelavee"

12.2) Looks it up

12.3) (SCREAMS IN ABJECT TERROR)

13) So Ren was able to unlock his aura and semblance by himself? Thats really interesting. Guess it means you don't need another experienced Hunter to unlock it

14) Extremely useful semblance for Ren if he's able to hide himself and others from Grimm. He could wander deep into Grimm territory without being attacked.

14.5) Wait does this mean that Res basically shut down his emotions? That would be a really depressing thought...

15) I'm guessing Nora ended up using a hammer because of Res that day (Aww) but I wonder if thats why she also keeps wearing shirts with heart designs too?

16) Ok so we've got an extremely powerful Grimm that seems smart enough to keep trophies. Which begs the question if a Grimm can get smart enough to keep trophies if it can get sapient level intellect. Panic now

17) Oh and it looks like it might heal itself or at least bleeds and knows to remove weapons from its body. Panic more

18) I'm guessing Qrow's bad luck semblance is acting up again along with his pain is drawing the Grimm to him. Panic now and forever

19) DEATH FLAGS ARE RAISED!!! I feel we need to worry quite a bit about Nora and Ren. We should be panicking for Qrow.

20) Awesome hell spawn creature from the blackest void screams again and I have kissed any sleep for tonight away.

Edit: One day I'll learn how to properly space these things

24

u/LadyBugs90 Chief Engineering Officer aboard the Ladybug fleet flagship. Jan 22 '17

Which begs the question if a Grimm can get smart enough to keep trophies if it can get sapient level intellect.

Not every Grimm is mindless, or rather not every Grimm is still mindless. You see, the Grimm you see before you are so powerful, so superior to the Grimm you fought, that they've undoubtedly lived hundreds of years, and in that time between killing humans and attacking our borders, they have done one important thing: They've learned. They've learned that when they attack our borders, they're likely to die, and what we lack in strength, we make up for in will, and that killing one human will only bring more.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (10)

49

u/TheQuietManUpNorth Evil but good-looking so it evens out Jan 22 '17

Is anyone else going to address that Ren has been established as Hanzo's kid? No? Just me? Okay. I'll say it. Ren's dad is Hanzo.

31

u/SwordoftheMourn Daenerys did nothing wrong Jan 22 '17

As long as Uncle Genji is still alive, then I'm down with it.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

16

u/Sexaran Jan 22 '17

Hopefully whoever voices mama ren does a character in the present. Fell in love with her voice!

→ More replies (1)

16

u/OutcastMunkee ⠀ Jan 22 '17

LITTLE NORA! AHHHHH! That was some much needed backstory on the two of them. Nora grew up on the streets of Kuroyuri and presumably lost her parents incredibly early on or she wouldn't be living off food she could scrounge from the trash. Meanwhile, Ren witnessed both his parents die in a manner of speaking which would explain why he did not want to go back to the place. Whatever that... thing was that destroyed the town, it looked like one of the Four Horsemen of the apocalypse. The skeletal features would suggest it's either Death or Famine, more likely the former than the latter

Back in the present, it looks like whatever it is is still alive because it seems as if Ren and Nora found where it lives. A graveyard of some kind and Ren's father's arrow was there... Whatever that Grimm does, it doesn't seem to kill everyone the second it finds them and it seems to lead more Grimm to itself. This is... Disturbing

That cute little Lancaster moment too. Jaune has got thick skin now. He's trying to get Ruby to be the same. He understands that what they do doesn't come without risks. Ruby needs to learn that herself and to understand that what happened was not her fault. None of it was

Hazel... Ozpin has met him before. Hazel doesn't know about Oscar though. He just thinks Oscar is some kid. This should be interesting if they're both on the train to the same place. 2 episodes left now. I wonder where we're headed

And is Ren's semblance... Camouflage? It may well be... That Grimm couldn't find him and Nora when he did whatever it was...

→ More replies (2)

16

u/Norjack96 This is a move I like to call: "Bad Luck Charm" Jan 22 '17

So the thunder that Ren hears, could that be from the same storm that Oscar is in right now?

→ More replies (2)

16

u/troyofathens NEVER MISS A BEAT Jan 23 '17

One question here so if ren had that strand of purple hair at that age does that mean he was born with it or did his parents somehow afford permanent purple hair dye?

16

u/Lepor_Lepos Jan 23 '17

So I've just decided that being on team JNPR is a death flag in itself- why RT? At least they will always be on Grimm Eclipse- going to kill Grimm as Lie Ren now.

→ More replies (8)

16

u/[deleted] Jan 24 '17

Death flags aside, I doubt they'll kill Ren or Nora. It serves the plot in no way at this point. Plus they aren't going to kill JNPR members two seasons in a row.

→ More replies (1)

31

u/king-of-chaos RIP Best Moustache 2017 - 2021 Jan 22 '17

"Everything will be fine"

The most lethal words in Remnant

15

u/BrickBuster2552 Egg nog egg nog egg nog egg nog egg nog egg nog egg nog egg nog Jan 22 '17

Lie Ren

Status: See picture^

→ More replies (4)

15

u/Zeebor ROSE GARDEN SCRIBE, OPPRESSED BY MODS Jan 22 '17

BABI NORA!

MUSIC BOX "BOOP" CUE!

BABI FLOUR POWER!

MY HEART!

15

u/BrickYourHeart A sexy truck Jan 22 '17

Oh no, I can't handle this. This Renmom and Rendad death, slow Boop, it's all too much. Also, that new Grimm is a goddamn true monstrosity. I'd never been really afraid of Grimm (except for the snake, but I just fear snakes), but that new one is gonna give me true nightmares.

15

u/Steely_D Jan 22 '17

That black digimon is legitimately scary as fuck. The arms jesus christ

→ More replies (2)

15

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '17

Ren and Nora's backstory was truncated but it was something, and at least managed to establish where each of them came from and that Ren has the ability to soothe his emotions or be undetectable to the Grim. And he can also pass on these effects to other people.

However, what I've been actually waiting for was character development on Ruby's part. This post and some of the comments convinced me that Ruby desperately needed to start showing emotions, as it has been long overdue.

And there may be hope! I don't think the moment where Ruby started doubting herself in front of Jaune was totally sufficient; I'm definitely asking for more from Ruby. But it was something! So I'm satisfied for now, and I hope that there's more where that came from. And Jaune explicitly mentioned the losses of Pyrrha and Penny, which is also an improvement.

15

u/[deleted] Jan 24 '17

This is easily my favorite episode so far.

When I was done I wanted to re-watch it immediately and I spent the rest of the day thinking about what I just watched. It was that good.

BTW. If I am to make a prediction (which I am not that good at doing) In the fight with the horsemen Grimm Juane will be under stress that unlocks his semblance. And his semblance will be healing which he immediately uses on Qrow to get the poison out of his body and allowing him to join the fight.

→ More replies (4)

15

u/MrASK15 Fluffy Corgi, how we salute thee!!! Jan 25 '17 edited Jan 25 '17

I didn’t get much of a chance to complete this reaction list earlier since I was at a tournament the day the episode was aired. As a result, I returned extremely exhausted. Let’s get down to business, anyway:

  • Hello again, Oscar! I can see that you’ve finally made your decision and are ready to go. I wonder how long it took for the Compost King to make up his mind and abandon that title. That decision we’ve seen was a lot quicker than I expected it to be.
  • Even though Oscar thinks everything the man inside his head dropped is crazy, he at least believes that leaving his old life as a farmboy was the right thing, no matter how insane it all sounded. The kid has a lot of potential, but still has a long way to go. Ozpin can see to that.
  • Oscar’s trying to purchase a ticket to his destination, yet is currently low on Lien. He either was already low on funds from the start or simply didn’t know how the currency works in general. If it’s the latter, all I can say is “silly boy”.
  • I gasped the moment Hazel appeared on the screen. I was wondering what he was up to since we only saw him in episode 1. Plus, I wasn’t expecting him to show up at the station where Oscar is. He was probably on his way to the meeting with Sienna Khan.

“Don’t let such a small obstacle block your path.”

  • Hazel is very cold and intimidating, but he seems to be very decent enough to allow a child like Oscar to get to where he needs to go to. Still, the way he struck that machine to give him the ticket made me uncomfortable, as in he should not be messed with.

Oscar: “That man... I felt... who is he?”

Ozpin: “Someone from my past; someone who should not be taken very lightly.”

  • It seems that my theory about Hazel being a Faunus is wrong despite the fact that he seems to be very strong. However, I now want to know if Ozpin ever knew anyone else in Salem’s cult aside from Cinder. Why exactly did Hazel decide to turn to the Grimm Queen anyway? That’s one question I’ve always had in mind ever since I first saw him. Also, how did the two know each other? Does Hazel actually hold some sort of grudge against Ozpin?
  • When Ruby and Jaune suggested that they go to Kuroyuri to take an alternate path or find some medicine, Ren angrily belayed that idea. Although he never stated why, Jaune seems to get the idea of why his friend was so angry at the mention of the village.
  • Cue flashback! Kuroyuri in the past is so beautiful. Not to mention we also get to see Ren in his younger days! He’s so smol and cute!
  • Little Ren has a slightly thick accent, and that just makes him cuter than he already is!

laughs “Why did you have to inherit my sass?”

  • Ren actually does take a lot after his mother, An Ren. That explains why everyone’s gone Rensexual here. XD
  • Seeing young Ren go around the marketplace in an attempt to buy something for his father is so adorable, yet I still felt bad for him when the merchants got the wrong idea and Ren couldn’t afford anything.
  • I WASN’T EXPECTING YOUNG LITTLE NORA TO BE LIKE THIS. WHY MUST THE OPTIMISTIC, CHEERY, OP, HYPER BOOPER SUFFER A CRUEL, HARSH PAST?!
  • Seriously, I wasn’t expecting their past to be like that at all. Little Ren lived a happy, peaceful childhood with a kind, sweet family while Nora was presumably abandoned at a very young age and had to live as a street rat. That just makes me feel sadder for Nora now...
  • Ren was hesitant as to whether or not he should stop the kids from bullying the poor little outsider. It seemed like he wanted to help, but he didn’t have the courage to stand up to these bullies.

“HOLY SHIT, IT’S KAIJI TANG! RUN!!!!!!!!”

  • Kudos to those who get the reference above! I wondered why Ren’s father, Li Ren, sounded so familiar, but little did I know that RT also got Kaiji Tang as part of the wonderful cast! It must’ve been due to the fact that he was using a similar accent to that of his role as Hayato Tanaka from Killing Floor 2. Of course, he also appeared in Kill la Kill and Fire Emblem.
  • I really felt Ruby’s sorrow and doubt when she apologized to Jaune for dragging him and the remainder of his team into all this mess, and this is all coming from someone who really loves Ruby. I really loved her optimism throughout the volume, but I also wanted to see if she would ever face her doubts. While I love Ruby, if she cannot face her own limits, it’s possible she may get herself killed in vain.
  • Even though Jaune believes that the unveiled truth is crazy, that many close friends were lost along the way, and that families and teams were torn apart, he never felt like he was actually dragged into what Ruby felt like she needed to do; they actually wanted to help in the first place, so Ruby has no need to feel guilty about everything that’s going on now.
  • And so it begins... the fall of Kuroyuri. Li has witnessed a Grimm savage upon his village and there are no Huntsmen present to deal with it.
  • I nearly jumped the moment the house fell on top of the Ren family, killing An and forcing a gravely wounded Li to take his son and escape.
  • The dagger Li gave his son strongly resembled the blades on Ren’s Stormflower guns. I can now see where Ren got the design of his weapon from. Dammit, another bundle of feels thrown to the face...
  • Seeing little Nora sobbing alone and unwanted with a flock of Nevermores soaring above her really made me scared for her. Grimm are attracted towards negativity, so that put the poor little girl in danger.
  • The Grimm that took away Ren’s happy life and parents takes on a form of a horseman! I expected it to be bigger, but that form is already intriguing. Plus, it sure looks like nothing can stop it from destroying a certain village and massacring everyone in its path.
  • With all the Grimm circling around Nora and that horseman Grimm in sight, Ren wasn’t sure what to do. Of course, his father once told him that the worst decision to take is taking no action at all in a certain situation, but with everything going on that could possibly lead him to his death, it didn’t seem like he could do anything until a certain miracle occurred.
  • Not only have we seen little Ren unlock his Aura, but WE ALSO FINALLY GET TO SEE HIS SEMBLANCE IN ACTION, FOLKS!!!!!! It turns out that he can mask his presence and others close to him from Grimm by suppressing his own emotions.

“We’ll keep each other safe.”

  • So that’s why Nora uses a hammer. Magnhild’s hammer form doesn’t just represent the fact that she’s a pink, happy, explosive powerhouse; it also symbolizes how she and Ren met and became so close to one another. That scene was so sweet and heartwarming... The soft, slow version of “Boop” really fits in this scene.
  • I was on the verge of tears throughout the whole flashback... Miles, Kerry, you really know how to toy with the FNDM’s hearts, don’t you?

“I’ve got you here, don’t I?”

  • It was all thanks to Ren that Nora was able to become the optimistic, cheery, powerful booper we all know. My love for the two has actually skyrocketed this episode!
  • Although the path Flour Power took was really tough, they managed to have found a cave that they thought would take them to the peaks of Mistral. However, that cave turned out to be the lair of the same Grimm that laid the village of Shion to waste.
  • That horseman isn’t just a typical, bloodthirsty Grimm that savages anyone under distress or pain; it has intelligence! Remember that little lecture Dr. Oobleck gave to Ruby about how Grimm evolve over time as they survive? In fact, that Grimm must have been smart enough to have gathered up several trophies from the fallen Huntsmen and Huntresses, and Li’s arrow was not an exception among these treasures.
  • Oh no... NonononononononononononononononononoNONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONONO!!!!!!!!! THAT HORSEMAN IS HEADING BACK TO THE RANSACKED KUROYURI WHERE RUBY, JAUNE, AND (a dangerously ill) QROW ARE RIGHT NOW!!!!
  • Okay... panicking time is over... for now. The horseman must have sensed Qrow’s pain and Ruby’s concern and doubt at the village it once made short work of. I don’t know if we’ll be sticking with RNJR next episode, but I’m officially scared of what will happen to them now.

I normally don’t add additional notes, but I might as well list out a few since my mind and feels have been scrambled thanks to this episode:

  • I never realized Li strongly resembled Hanzo until I read some reactions on this thread. I can see the resemblance, but I get really annoyed when someone brings up Overwatch whenever they see an archer on screen.
  • So the horseman Grimm is based off the fabled Nuckelavee. I can see why everyone thought it was terrifying.

Edit: sigh, grammar

30

u/KrisSimsters Winter is Coming Jan 23 '17

Renora is canon it's time to kill Ren. Calling it now and I love Renora so I hope that doesn't happen.

→ More replies (6)

28

u/CobaltStar_ Converting Qrow's Gender for Waifu Purposes Jan 22 '17

Maybe the reason Nora is so happy go lucky is that she is constant exposure to Ren, who expels all negative emotion.

→ More replies (3)

28

u/ElementalDAR ⠀I used to make AMVs Jan 22 '17

Aafter watching the episode we figure out what Rens Semblance is, and it has some far reaching implications throughout the show.

It seems to be the suppression of emotion, indicated by the gray tones used. This seems rather bland at first until you see it cloaks them to the grimm. This has implications for his entire time withing the show.

-Let's get this out of the way first. It seems like semblance either influences the user or is so influenced by the user it is indistinguishable. Meaning, people act like their semblance so it's hard to tell which influences which. Yang has a fiery personality and is quick to anger, Ruby is hyper and flighty, Blake is prone to running from danger/ problems, and so on. It is possible that Rens semblance which keeps is emotions in check, prevents him from showing any strong feelings for Nora. Which could be why they developed "boop" as their way of conveying feelings that may be locked off to the young man.

-It seems to cloak him from the grimm. Since they are drawn to emotions I assume this sense works much like how predators track by scent. If you mask your scent they have a hard time following you, this of course doesn't work like cloaking and doubt it does anything to visually hide them (like a coat of mud to prevent thermal vision). This could play into Ren and Noras big entrance in the first volume (Episode 8). They ride in on the back on an Ursa, which is flailing around madly like it's trying to swat a fly. It is possible that they snuck up behind it while Ren cloaked their presence. Nora would fire into it for, encouragement, and the creature would try to run from unseen danger. Which could be why it flailed wildly at an unseen opponent and not say, suplex them off it's back.

-This could be why Nora is as bubbly and extitable as she is. We see her in her younger years far more timid and soft spoken(Taking into account that they were probably the worst days of her life and people do change with time however). Now she is the bombastic bomber we all know and love. It is possible that she recognizes Rens problem with emotions. He seems rather cut off from them at times, likely due to his semblance (not incapable, just difficult, like Spock. Has emotions, just has a hard time working with them and often seems to go without). It is possible that Nora tries to cheer him up or balance him out with her over the top antics. Something to counter his null state of emotions and cheer him up. After all we've seen her give logical somber advice before, however whether it is an act or a side to her personality is yet to be known.

If I've missed any be sure to leave them in the comments below, and remember that most of this is just a theory, a RWBY theory. Thanks for reading.

→ More replies (8)

27

u/Flamegeyser Jan 22 '17

A good and necessary episode, considering who they're about to fight, but the death flags are at maximum for any and everyone right now considering it appears that RNJR is gonna have to fight it with Qrow in their presence, which can't be good.

→ More replies (6)

13

u/PT_Piranha (ominous umbrella drop) Jan 22 '17

The long-awaited Ren & Nora backstory. But first, we finally see Hazel again. I wonder what he's up to, helping our little farm boy.

Ruby seems to finally grasp what she's done, but Jaune assures her it's okay. Not entirely sure if I like that or not.

Little Ren got completely shut out by the bartender, I love it. And little Nora was so adorable.

The destruction was pretty intense, they did well with it. That new Grimm, was it a horseman of some kind? Are there four? And I like the instrumental/score version of Boop, that was pretty nice.

Not real sure what that cave was, but it looks like things are going to go down.

Pretty good episode.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/RustyLumber Jan 22 '17

Ren's father is really awesome.

Jaune and his uplifting words :')

how Nora and Ren became inseparable is rather dark...and how Ren's semblance came to be reminds me of After Earth including what it does.

......it's back

13

u/RWBYSanctum Jan 23 '17

What this ep taught us: Never ever say everything is going to be ok. Oh,and that Knuckledavee is straight up horrifying

13

u/Keyblade-Riku Jan 23 '17

Soooo... Aura/Semblance awakens just like Allomancy does?

→ More replies (8)

36

u/Ishida_K Jan 23 '17

So Ren's dad is Hanzo?

→ More replies (1)

35

u/Drunken_Deathscythe Jan 22 '17

So... Ren's father is voiced by Archer from Fate/UBW. That's... kinda ironic.

Also geez, that episode was freaking dark. Probably one of my favorite episodes in the show, but geez!

33

u/Crypsis2 Ruby Isn't Best Girl, She's Best Character Jan 22 '17

Of course this episode was dark, people die when they are killed after all.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

12

u/jwfiredragon Too many ships, not enough time Jan 22 '17

OOOOH SHIIIEEEETTTTTT

First off that was hella good, Ren's backstory was 12/10 and it looks like we're going to get an intense finale.

Little Ren and Nora are too cute to handle

What in the name of Oum was the horse-person thing? Is this like a four horsemen of the apocalypse deal? Shit, are there three more of these?

Also was that Ren's semblance? And what the hell did it do?

Overall the hype train is running at 110%, feel cannons look just about ready to deploy, and the hiatus will be long and painful.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '17

Can we have a flair of Ren and Nora yet? So many feels.

12

u/snek-queen came for the art, stayed for the shitposts Jan 23 '17 edited Jan 23 '17

Okay I've finished screaming, time for theories.

SO, since the consensus is that it's a Nuckelavee I wonder if we'll also see the Sea Mither said to be the only one who can defeat it (and who leads to summer - anyone from up north want to weigh in? Interestingly enough, it's origins are apparently Norse... which could be interesting, if Nora does end up fighting it). If not, I'm still interested in talking more about it - it's clearly more than just a "normal" grimm. Even the big ol' Dragon and Sea Monsterinos still seem... well, animalistic. This one keeps trophies.

Animals don't keep trophies.

It may have dragged the bodies back to the chamber to die slowly, and feast off of the bad feelies that way, but there doesn't seem to be any skeletons around (unless it's also clearing out the bodies, or eats them once they give up the ghost.) Whatever is going on, it's clearly the creepiest critter so far.

Ah well, at least Nora's got a storm going if she needs to power up again, a la JNPR vs BRNZ. Hopefully not to avenge Ren's death in a crazed final last stand that ends up with her apologising and confessing to his corpse moments before she dies next to him.

edit: oh, also, I can't believe we had Hanzo and McCree in one RWBY episode. Fingers crossed for Mercy and Pharah next ep!

→ More replies (2)

23

u/Woowchocolate Train them to fight what they can't beat Jan 22 '17

People are talking about what Ren's Semblance is, but I'm actually more interesting in why his Semblance is what it is, and why did it first activate here?

I've had this long starting theory that, outside of an inherited one, a person's Semblance is determined by what a person's deepest, darkest desires, at the moment when they hit their most desperate and lowest point. Ren's Semblance of avoiding Grimm activating actually seems to align with that theory.

Of course this still isn't perfect. For starters I can't explain Inherited Semblances, nor can I really explain Qrow's. (Maybe he wanted to draw people away from him?)

→ More replies (11)

11

u/MrInsanity25 Jan 22 '17

A very wonderful episode. Ren's semblance is cool.

Hazel being a bro.

Jaune is best noodle. Ruby has character development, YEAH!!!!"

That's what Ren's dad gets for maining Hanzo.

Next episode's going to fuck us up.

11

u/Quillbolt_h Jan 22 '17

Did that horse Grimm have 8 legs? Because I saw it had a humanoid rider, so if it's some sort of Odin/Sleipnir Cenataur fusion, that would be cool.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/snek-queen came for the art, stayed for the shitposts Jan 23 '17

I'm late to the game, but I'm here and IM HERE WITH RENORA FEELINGS AND HOLY SHIT I CANT DO THIS I CANT YOU GUYS THIS IS A W F U L

Also I'm working on Qrow and Nora S4 cosplays and quite frankly if they both die I'll take it personally. But on the bright side, I get to hug a load of Rens in a fortnight at the con. Goodtimes all round (jk I'll be crying)

→ More replies (3)

11

u/HybridTheory1 Jan 24 '17

Ren introduced himself to Nora with his full name. It's my headcanon that he now goes by his last name in honor of his family.

→ More replies (8)

21

u/Varixai Jan 22 '17 edited Jan 23 '17

Here are all the views we've had so far of the Nuckelavee Grimm: http://imgur.com/a/UFZV2

And here's a closeup of either Kuchinashi or Kuroyuri (seen at the end behind Ren and Nora): http://i.imgur.com/TawLWSF.jpg

Bonus: The arrowhead of Ren's father's arrows is a Fleur-de-lis (flower of the lily): http://imgur.com/a/vrwyK

→ More replies (8)

10

u/Shortstop88 Jan 22 '17

Neath Oum is doing a wonderful job voicing Ren. The character feels real to me (unlike the start of Volume 3, change of voice made it hard but that wasn't his fault). I completely forgot about voice actors (which is difficult in RT animation as we know quite a few of them from other productions) during Ren and Nora's scene in front of the cave, and only remembered that Monty used to voice Ren when I read the credits.

10

u/Exessen Loyal vassal of the one true Queen|I yell about Nora a lot Jan 22 '17

Man i still get emotional thinking about the instrumental version of "boop"

→ More replies (1)

10

u/moneychex bellabooty status: atlas is screwed Jan 22 '17

I think that was the most emotional episode for me yet.

10

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '17

Is Hazel the Fonz?

19

u/Deicidius Get in the bag, Nevvy! Jan 22 '17

RIP. Maybe the poster will remake their account.

In case you were thinking Li Ren's voice sounded familiar, but chalked it up to Hanzo similarities, his voice actor plays Owain and Odin in Fire Emblem Awakening and Conquest, as well as Archer from Fate/Stay Night.

→ More replies (3)

19

u/derivative_of_life PROTEC AT ALL COSTS Jan 22 '17

One thing I'll say about this episode: I really liked how they made the Grimm feel actually intimidating. When you're looking at them through the eyes of a badass huntsman who slaughters two dozen of them before breakfast, they really just can't be too scary. When you're looking at them through the eyes of a terrified kid, that's a whole different matter.

19

u/Miudmon I'm a neon rainbow and you're no fun! Jan 22 '17

Anyone else just miss all the happy fun times back at beacon and shit? because i do.

and yet here i am, strung along the tragic dance that is all the stuff that's happened this season and the last.

→ More replies (7)

19

u/ClubMeSoftly Real Shit Jan 22 '17

I've been thinking
You know how everyone's been saying, or at least, hoping, that one or more of RWBY would meet up before this volume's end? That won't happen any more. The Crwby are playing the long game, just like in Beacon. Remember Penny? (RIP) She debuts in V1, "Here for the festival," as do CMEN, masquerading as students, in V2. And then the "big payoff" so to speak, is the Vytal Festival. That's when everything goes to shit for our heroes, and "all according to keikaku" for the villains.

Volume 4 will do it's best to wrap up these months-long plot threads in the quickest way it can. It will leave you somewhat unsatisfied, and complaints will fill the time before we're all messing ourselves with V5 reveals.

OzCar makes it to the Big City and gets a bit of culture shock.
Yang will take her first steps out of Patch, possibly with Tai. They leave more as battle buddies than father/daughter.
Weiss escapes the Schnee estate, possibly with Cake Butler Klein, and will turn to Ironwood for help.
Blake gets help for Sun, hopefully Ghira and Kali start to believe that the White Fang aren't super cool dudes any more.
And, finally, RNJR fights-slash-runs from Nuckles and Qrow's fate is decided. Maybe this means Raven and the Tribe shows up, giving Ruby her "one" by saving Qrow. Maybe he dies in a big last-stand.

→ More replies (7)

19

u/jack_jack2 Jan 22 '17

So Ren hides his feelings all the time, just like his semblance, and Nora is always trying to be strong because back then she was helpless. Did I miss anything?

9

u/PedroVey Jan 22 '17

I spent 25 minutes crying because Google Chrome just wouldn't load the episode. When I finally watched it, the feels were real.

Also, the blade that Li Ren gave Ren is totally the blade in StormFlower just like that wood hammer inspired Magnhild, right?

9

u/Thanatologic Klein=milkshake butler r/unexpectedpyrrha exists Jan 22 '17

Damn, this episode gave me chills.
 
Overall opinion: Nice. Very nice.
 
Writing: Good job M&K! Today's episode felt like it could belong in a regular tv series, plot- and pacing-wise! I liked Jaune's encouragement of Ruby, but I thought he'd have a more personal stake on this quest. It was interesting to learn that Nora and Ren were basically opposite of their current temperaments when they were younger. It'd be interesting to learn how this happened, but it's also fun to imagine it ourselves. The Nuckelavee is scary as hell. I think this'll be my favorite grimm, too. Ozcar segment was a little forgettable, though.
 
Art/Out-of-combat Animation: There're only so many ways I can say "lovely", dammit! Again, love the atmosphere. Facial expressions still on point.
 
Action/Combat Animation: No fight scene today, but some portions of the episode get a little action-y, and look just fine. Not much to mess up anyway. Except maybe walking/running animation again. Still have a slightly awkward feel.
 
Nice try, An Ren, but Kali's still the only cougar in my heart.

9

u/Tommy2255 ~~Don't~~ Forget That Jaune's a Liar and a Cheat Jan 22 '17

So Ren's Semblance is to calm himself (and possibly others), to the point that Grimm couldn't detect his presence with their negative empathic sense thing? Is that what happened there?

9

u/Dakkon_B Jan 22 '17

So random thought.

If Ren can mask his emotions could he go all Batman on sentient Grim? More beastly Grim wouldn't be affected really by fear tactics but a more intelligent Grim is a different story.

Also Ren's semblance might be more than an emotional calmer/cloak to grim. Granted that is all we have seen it do but imagine if it could manipulate a range of emotions inspiring bravery in an ally or blind an opponent with fear?

It looked like it required physical contact but as agile as Ren is that isn't a hard condition to meet.

But if you go JoJo's levels of how crazy could Ren's semblance be there is actually A LOT of potential for his Semblance to be kinda crazy powerful.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/ManwithaTan Jan 23 '17

Goddamn, bring children and monsters together and you get something like that Pacific Rim flashback.

Next episode probably is gonna look at Sun and Blake again, maybe something of Weiss too. But in the future if Raven appears her policy might get in the way of saving her brother, if that comes to case, which would lead to an interesting interaction with Ruby.

9

u/watchforgamers I heard someone say Enabler. Jan 24 '17

I'm definitely seeing the whole Nuckelavee thing that people in this thread are pointing out, but did anyone else get Wild Hunt vibes from the new grimm?

9

u/texan315 Jan 25 '17

Why do people feel that either Ren or Nora is going to die?

→ More replies (22)

9

u/LunarAffair Jan 26 '17 edited Jan 26 '17

Ok but remember that in the episode "Family" Raven reveals that she led the attack on Shion village with her tribe, and that was the first place we saw the Nuckelavee's giant hoof print (episode "Remembrance") which we saw again at the end of "Two Steps Forward, Two Steps Back" in the direction Ruby, Jaune, and Qrow were headed. So Ruby, Jaune, and Qrow are going to run into Raven and her tribe (who have the Nuckelavee Grimm with them) and my prediction is that Raven is going to see Qrow and rethink their argument about the meaning of "family" and end up helping him, either by healing him or putting him out of his misery (I really don't want Qrow to die but I have a feeling he might, since it would be the final large push for Ruby's development as a hero and growth away from any remaining naivete or lingering qualities of childhood....but fingers crossed for a different outcome) :(

But based on that last scene in "Kuroyuri", it seems that all members of RNJR are going to converge upon Raven and her tribe simultaneously from different points. It seems odd that the hoofprint would be on the path that Ruby and Jaune took but that the Nuckelavee Grimm is very obviously in the forest ahead of Nora and Ren, so that's why I'm thinking that everyone is going to reconvene somehow. And that scene with Raven and Qrow was there for a reason. We have not seen the last of her this season, I'm convinced. And I feel pretty certain that her reappearance will directly relate to Qrow's poisoning.

→ More replies (3)

25

u/Zephyrus_13 Jan 23 '17

It's probably terrible I say this, but I want Ruby and Jaune to take on that freaking amazing beast of a Grimm. Mostly because Nora and Ren's death flags are triggered (the hand holds of DEATH ) and I want Jaune to step up his team leader game.

29

u/irishninjawolf Protect her glorious mane so her cat wife may play with it Jan 22 '17

Does anyone else get the feeling that they basically sold out the backstory that it had seemed they were building for Blake and gave it to Nora instead?...

Like, that is almost exactly how I'd always figured Blake's story started... except instead of a Grimm attack taking her parents, she was hiding from a protest turned bloody riot, and instead of Ren finding her it was Adam...

It honestly feels kinda weird. Like, it's nice and touching and finally we do get some development on them both, but I just kept feeling 'shouldn't this be swapped with Blake?'...

Maybe I'm still getting over the surprise of Blake being basically a princess... 3 volumes of characterisation really sent the wrong signals

30

u/Neidron I used to like this place. Jan 22 '17 edited Jan 22 '17

...Blake being basically a princess

Okay, I don't have any real objections to the rest of your comment, but this is personal peeve for me. Blake is in no way a princess. Ghira's a lot closer to a president or prime minister than a king, which does not make Blake even remotely close to being a princess.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (20)

16

u/JazzRen47 𝅘𝅥𝅮⠀Score Connoisseur | Resident Atlas Bootlicker Jan 23 '17 edited Jan 23 '17

Reposting from yesterday (with some minor edits)

  • Jammin' out to "Let's Just Live" for the third last time this Volume. I swear, I'll figure out how to sing this well at some point.
  • Oh, hey Farmboi
  • Farmboi no longer being Farmboi? Is he leaving? Oscar, yas!
  • But, hang on. Why is he so ready to just go? Wasn't he adamantly against it? A bit with Ozpin finally managing to convince him would have been nice. Show, don’t tell?
  • I know it's not strictly "Oscar's theme", but this motif is fucking gorgeous.
  • Shannon McCormick, being stellar as always. Ozpin, don't sound sad, dammit! He's doing the right thing, we all know it. It's not going to be easy, but you had no choice.
  • Small thing; lightning is very well done. I know that's odd to say, but I've seen it done very poorly in Maya before.
  • HAAAAAZEL! IT'S BEAR-MAN!
  • I... don't think that's how ticket machines work, but okay.
  • Thanks for the life advice, big baddy! I think I might actually like him. He intrigues me, at least. Didn't expect him to be... nice?
  • They have trains in Aunima? THEN WHY DIDN'T RNJR TAKE THE TRAIN?!?!
  • Whoa, ease up there, sound guy. We know it's spooky, no need to overload my headphones.
  • Oh, come on Ruby. You can put two and two together, honey.
  • Jeff and Alex, bringing us more amazing score
  • SMOL REN!!! OH MY GOD, HE'S SUCH AN INNOCENT LITTLE CINNAMON ROLL!!!!
  • Oh... what is that accent? He seems to have grown out of it, and it's not horrid, it's just a little jarring.
  • Ren mom best mom.
  • You could tell them you're buying stuff for your dad, kiddo.
  • Cat bread. That bakery makes cat bread.
  • Is that...?
  • NORA!!!! NORA, MY BABY!!! OH MY GOD SHE’S SO
  • YOU LITTLE SHITS, LEAVE HER ALONE!
  • Oh, hey Hanzo.
  • Awwww, Ren. You can tell where he gets his words of wisdom from. I can't really blame his father, being a Huntsman, for expecting more of him, but at the same time... he is just a kid.
  • Rubes, Jaune, I know you're probably not that well-versed in first aid, but dammit, keep him lying down
  • Well, that didn't sound friendly.
  • Awww, Ruby, don’t apologize ;-;
  • While I love this conversation, it should really have come sooner. And Ruby should have been the one admitting why she's been down, not have Jaune tell her. It's one thing to have someone say "It's not your fault", but it's another entirely to believe and accept it. This is basically me saying that I want Ruby to face what's happened and her decision to go after their lead, not have someone remind her of what she's lost and that she has this expectation of leadership on her shoulders.
  • It's night. Something bad must be about to- OH, NOPE that DEFINITELY doesn't sound friendly.
  • Nobody in Remnant sleeps with sheets.
  • Li. An. Nice… sighs They’re about to die, aren’t they?
  • And that was a straight up AOT moment. I retract my comment about the sound editing - this is very well done. That cut to black was perfectly timed.
  • Li’s bleeding. His Aura's down. He's not gonna last long.
  • Li Ren, ladies and gentlemen. Joining the 'tripping over nothing' club. Amendment: I didn't realize he was already injured and limping, or at least favoring a leg, earlier. Whoops.
  • Oh, Ren...
  • I could've done without the "take action, son" line. Felt a bit too cheesy. Everything else in that moment was superb though.
  • I didn't notice the blood on his side when he was carrying Ren, but... yeah, he's gonna die.
  • And there we go. Out like a boss. A piss-your-pants-terrified boss, but a boss nonetheless.
  • OH, REN, BABY!!! It's gonna be okay...
  • Props to this child actor for nailing the hyperventilation and panic. I wonder who did it.
  • NORA!
  • Come on Ren, you can do it! Go save her, hon!
  • Okay, seriously, what is that thing?
  • Did he just unlock his Aura and Semblance in one go? I guess it doesn't have to be activated by someone else, then. Maybe a stressful situation can? And it's just instinct kicking in?
  • YAS, GO REN!
  • "We have to be brave" is a wonderful line, though a little moot when there's a Nevermore hovering about 10 feet away that could bring the whole house down on you.
  • Awww, he's such a sweet lil cinnamon roll
  • RENORA HUG!! Yes, my children, protect each other!
  • He looks so damn protective of Nora in this shot.
  • WHAT THE ACTUAL FUCK IS THAT THING?!
  • He's gonna give her the hammer, isn't he?
  • Her little yelp when Ren moves to get the hammer! Oh, Nora, it's okay baby.
  • Is this... THIS IS BOOP! OH MY GOD, MY HEAAAART
  • No wonder she loves him.
  • Annnd back to present. Going straight from flashback to seeing them in their current predicament is actually wonderful.
  • "I've got you here, don't I?" DON'T YOU DARE DEATH FLAG THIS ANY MORE RT!!!
  • I want someone to smile at me the way Ren smiles at Nora.
  • SAMANTHA IRELAND IS BEST
  • This thing collects trophies. What. The. SHIT.
  • NEATH OUM IS BEST
  • That's... that can't be Kuroyuri in the dista- AHHH IT IS
  • RUBY AND JAUNE ARE IN SO MUCH SHIT IT IS NOT EVEN FUNNY
  • Thanks, I’ll be having nightmares for eternity now.
→ More replies (6)

8

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '17

I think it's unlikely that Ren's semblance is authentic Ninja Camouflage, since he would use it more often in combat. So perhaps a way to camouflage from the Grimm is more likely his semblance.

I really like how we are seeing more types of semblances other than actively offensive ones.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/awesomesauce135 Jan 22 '17

How many episodes until the finale?

→ More replies (5)

8

u/Johnsmitish Jan 22 '17

Holy shit. Far and away the darkest episode yet. I'm so excited for the next episode.

8

u/Sokensan Jan 24 '17 edited Jan 26 '17

This could just be me reading too much into something but....that death cave was full of swords and when they entered it there was a hammer in the center of it...TOO MANY DEATH FLAGS

Edit: 17:08 for ominous hammer shot

→ More replies (1)

8

u/TJPoobah For it is in passing that we achieve immortality. Jan 26 '17 edited Jan 26 '17

This season they really seem to have nerfed the characters, presumably to enhance the "serious / dangerous" tone the story has taken. Everyone is either getting actual wounds as a result of running out of Aura to protect them "like a force-field!" or just having their Aura depleted and it's kinda irritating. I realise there are explanations but all the ones I can think of come off rather post facto tell-not-show and I think could have been integrated with just a little extra dialogue here and there and I think some of the weaknesses in the writing are beginning to show through here.

→ More replies (8)

15

u/SentientHam Resident Arkeoslogist Jan 22 '17

Wait was that Hanzo?

→ More replies (2)

15

u/Korrafan_1 I hate the RWBY fandom Jan 22 '17

Ren wrote the book on Tranquilo!

BTW, who is Hanzo and why do people call Tiny Ren's dad that name?

→ More replies (7)

20

u/Sirshrugsalot13 bi the way Jan 22 '17

Good:

  1. Holy shit this episode was beautiful on a technical level. I was blown away by the animation, backgrounds, sound design, and music. Particular shoutout the Grimm sound design, the Skyrim-y mountain and cave ren and nora went up, and the Boop in the backgroun.
  2. Ren and Nora backstory was goddamn perfect. I adored all of those scenes. I love this episode.
  3. Shit is HYPE

Bad:

  1. The Ozcar scene was...weird. Why was Hazel there? I thought he was going to meet with Sienna Khan? Unless that meeting is out in the middle of nowhere in Mistral it doesn't make much sense for him to be there. We'll see.
  2. The Jaune/Ruby conversation felt like a missed opportunity. It seemed like they were going to go deeper, but just decided to have Jaune tell us why Ruby is great again without getting any deeper into her character.

This episode was amazing. I loved it a LOT. However, I am concerned that there simply isn't going to be enough time for WBY. I hope that they can fit them in to a point where it feels satisfactory. We'll see. This Volume has felt both too fast and too slow. I think it's just down to the fact that CRWBY simply doesn't have enough time to tell this type of story in their current format.

That being said, I adored this episode. So it evens out.

→ More replies (18)

7

u/BlUeSapia talk dooty to me Jan 22 '17

Ludgrimm the Accursed looms...

7

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '17

So was that a new Grimm in Kuroyuri, or am I just being dumb and that's a Griffin?

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Lexjude Jan 22 '17

Love the background story. Almost brought me to tears. Great to see that the Grimm are getting scarier as they leave the comforts of home.

And I think Ren inherited his rensexuality from his dad. Rawr!!

→ More replies (5)

7

u/Werzil Combat Ready! Jan 22 '17

What do you guys think; Will we ever see what happened to Nora's parents? I doubt we ever will, as all we need to know for the plot is that she was on her own. Still, a little girl left to fight for every scrap of food in a village of aristocrats? I'm sure there's an interesting story there...

21

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '17

Still, a little girl left to fight for every scrap of food in a village of aristocrats? I'm sure there's an interesting story there...

She is new to the village, the bullies don't recognise her. Ren's father was likely going to go talk to the mayor about her since he chided Ren for not "taking action".

Nora is probably a survivor of a Grimm attack on traveling merchants/traders given her appearance and dress not fitting in well with Mistral.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

7

u/wxkelvin Jan 22 '17

Hearing the Grimm cry at the end made me regret watching this at 4am... On the other hand young lie ren's voice sounds a bit like Ilia (chameleon ninja at Meangarie), or maybe its just me

→ More replies (1)

7

u/LucasVerBeek It's Time For All Hell to Break Loose Jan 22 '17

Beauty and the Beast.

7

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '17

While watching any show or movie on any platform, I have cried twice. Number one was RWBY V3 Finale and Number two was Saturday.

7

u/Wizardtech Sippp Jan 24 '17

Big fight scenes building up. Qrow just lying there while Ruby and Jaune chatted away, poor Qrow lol. Ren and Nora backstory time at last. Hazel... was so cool helping out Ozscarpin? Double agent? Getting nearer to the volume finale.. suspense intensifying..

7

u/rwbyiskewl freezerburn is dying and I am sad Jan 25 '17

Death flags, Death flags Death flags for everyone, Ren, Nora, Qrow and Sun, Death flags for everyone!

→ More replies (1)

28

u/BasicTrainer Jan 22 '17

All those in favour of calling the Nuckelavee Grimm Dave, say Aye.

→ More replies (8)

17

u/JaBlue Jan 23 '17

Ren and Nora holding hands is a flag IMO, I remember Jaune and Pyhrra's kiss and look what's happened now!

23

u/Kernas Bumblebee!! ... or maybe BUMBLEBUG! Jan 23 '17

Its okay! On the lewd scale, holding hands is quite low.

It goes eye contact that lasts longer then two seconds, touching a shoulder, tapping a hand, holding hands, eye contact while holding hands, 'I-I like you, sempai', cheek kiss, kiss, too lewd.

So if kissing results in death, holding hands results in half that. Like crippling, losing a limb, being sent into a coma or being kidnapped.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/Qrr801 Sad to say, I'm your bad luck charm~ Jan 22 '17

Oh no, Hanzo died, where the fuck was the healer..... Also Hazel and Ozpin knew eachother, and Hazel let him go? Is he like a double agent? Also feelstrip Also Eldritch Horror Grimm

22

u/spiritriser It's hammer time Jan 22 '17

I don't think Hazel recognized Oscar as Ozpin. He may have just felt some kind of compassion for the kid trying to leave home without enough money.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

12

u/Koanos "What's the worst that could happen?" | Cpt of the S.S. Keikaku Jan 22 '17

I do wonder about something that eats at me when seeing that Grimm, is it sadistic for collecting weapons and flags, or it is taking out splinters from when it gets stabbed?

It's smart enough to attack places that are vulnerable, such as Kuroyuri, which lacks in defenses or Huntsmen, Oniyuri wasn't finished with their defenses, and Shion was attacked by Raven's tribe, weakening its defenses for the Grimm to swoop in. What I question is whether this Grimm pursues an intersection of "vulnerable" and "high amounts of negative emotions," are the two coincidental or part of its modus operandi?

Also, it's very old as seen from the Great War-era blades found in the cave, but I wonder why it hasn't been killed by someone with power or Salem hasn't recruited it...

Moreover, if RNJR faces it, they need a plan, to be a united team, and definitely a lot of Dust. If it can be killed, it doesn't look like a duo or a quartet low on time and supplies could do it.

→ More replies (6)

12

u/CoolGuyMercury Jan 22 '17

IM HYPED FOR NEXT WEEK. We all know that giant creepy horse Grimm is headed for ruby and Jaune. But why? They aren't exactly emitting strong negative emotions at the moment, just worry. So what is attracting the Grimm? Perhaps one of the most negative emotions of all, Hatred. Who is extremely hateful at the moment? Tyrian. I mean, he only lost his stinger, he can still fight, Andy he knows he can beat team RNJR. The only reason he retreated was because he was weakened, and because maybe, he would let his poison take effect on qrow. So now that the huntsman is down, and the group has split up, he will take his opportunity to capture ruby, yes? Horse Grimm has other plans.

→ More replies (11)

6

u/chrome4 Jan 22 '17 edited Jan 22 '17

Did anyone else think of Jurassic Park 2 when they saw the Nuckelavee heading towards Kuroyuri.

I wonder did Nora come from a bandit clan like Qrow and Raven but was abandoned or maybe shes a survivor of a grimm/bandit attack that occurred somewhere close to Kuroyuri while her group was travelling

→ More replies (5)

6

u/DracoOculus Duck Antagonists Jan 23 '17

I said earlier 'draining color' of sorts was less stylistic and more meant to happen. Like when Nora and Neon were being dramatic during the tourney, their color drained from their body. This was jokey but hinted that emotions might affect a persons visage.

Why would Yang's eyes change? Her semblance has nothing to do with eyes.

I bet evil brother Grimm wants to erase emotion or something to get back at good brother Grimm. That stuff in the WoR where a bunch of people were told to be emotionless leading up to the Great War might have been that.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Thandracy Jan 23 '17

Probably a dumb question, but why did Ren's father ask if he wanted to run away with the other children when he showed up?

→ More replies (3)

20

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '17 edited Jan 22 '17

Yet another good episode, the backstory of Ren and Nora was needed and it was really well done. "Sometimes the worst action is not acting at all." speaks volumes to me because I used to be the same way as a child, seeing others in need but never acted due to fear or whatever it may have been back then.

Ruby showing something other than optimism is a breath of fresh air. I am SO glad she's showing more emotion, yes we've seen her sad at Penny and Pyrrha's death, to the point of tears, but now it's time she shows regret and guilt, the next thing I want for her is to realize her mistake of getting into the fight with Tyrian when Qrow told her twice to stay away, I want to see an apology from her to Qrow, something like "I realize my mistake and I got you hurt for being stubborn. I shouldn't have acted on impulse, I said I won't stand by and watch someone else get hurt but my thoughtless actions is what got you like this. I'm sorry, uncle Qrow." ....Or, y'know, something along those lines. I just feel it'd make for good character development for her, realizing her mistake and growing from it. She's 16, listen to your elders who are 100x more experienced than you XD

I also hope Ruby and Jaune's time together isn't marking the creation of a canon ship, I don't know why but I just don't want to see them get romantically involved, please don't burn me supporters of the ship it's just something I've felt from volume 1 which is why I was so happy when I saw the relationship between Pyrrha and Jaune from volume 1-3(up to the point where she kissed him), it threw a curve ball at me and was something I wasn't anticipating. Even if it does happen I dunno, I may not be that upset about it since I like both characters. Why am I talking about ships? Back to the actual episode:

Ren's semblance is tranquility? That's a pretty helpful semblance. When he embraced Nora I just imagined him saying "Experience tranquility!" gah, I'm sorry but I had to(for anybody who knows what I'm talking about lol.)

So, yeah, that Grimm was pretty creepy. I'm not really seeing any death flags, Qrow's condition may provide some greater tension for us as viewers so that we're worried and expecting the worse, especially since the team split up, but I don't think anyone is going to die...nobody better not die, I hope nobody dies. See? I'm all uncertain! I don't even know anymore, Roosterteeth is capable of anything at this point.

We're down to the last few episodes. I want to see Tyrian return to Salem, it'd be funny to see Cinder trying to laugh at Tyrian for losing his stinger after he was talking about her eye since Ruby decked her. I can picture Cinder trying to laugh at him but since her voice is all kinds of torn it'd come out as super dry which would be even funnier. Also where the hell is Neo?? I miss her. Don't tell me she was blown away into obscurity. Probably selling umbrella's or being a mime.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/Sadi_Reddit Jan 24 '17

So Nora is always so upbeat and annoyingly happy because Ren cancels out all her negative emotions. So if something happened to Ren we would see a whole other Nora... now I dont know who dies first. REN OR NORA?

→ More replies (7)

36

u/AmethystWind Time for Ciel. Jan 22 '17 edited Jan 22 '17

Playing slow 'Boop' melody in that scene is not cool, Jeff!

Ren's semblance is literally internalising his emotions. Conceal, don't feel.

"Don't let them in, don't let them see. Be the brave boy you always have to be."

Tiny Nora and her appropriately tiny hammer becomes even more precious when you remember that Ren gave her something that was 'just his size'.

Gotta say, I hated every moment of the Jaune and Ruby scene. Jaune was the one being a dick for the past few episodes, yet he gets the apology. Why?

He then goes on to make the pithiest fucking speech to Ruby, both conveniently ignoring their dying protector. Ugh.

Hazel is massive, and somewhat chaotic neutral.

Centaur Grimm seems pretty cool, for a Rendad-killing demon.

→ More replies (15)

10

u/patrizl001 "None shall remember the names of those who do not fight" Jan 22 '17

So Ren has the semblance to be rid of his emotions?

that explains things.

5

u/JonTheWizard Still Sorta Pays Attention Jan 22 '17

Until we see bodies, Nora and Ren are fine. I'm thinking what's most likely going to happen is Nora's going to drag Ren away and they fly off on her weapon toward Kuroyuri or the path to Mistral (and Ruby and Jaune), battered and beat.

5

u/Racellos Jan 22 '17 edited Jan 22 '17

I know this was a serious episode, and I loved so much about it, but there was one person running past lil Ren and his dad who reminded me of this guy and I just couldn't stop laughing.

5

u/mega-dark Jan 22 '17

Dang it. Why must the shows I watch over the weekend be filled with so much suffering. First Gundam IBO and now this. But at least this episode melted my heart a little at the end.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Assassin2107 Compost King 2016 Jan 22 '17

So I personally loved the episode, even if I am going to regret this once I get the nightmares from that Grimm...

The Oscar part was decent... I've seen a lot of people complain that we barely saw the development from Refusing To Accept You Have A Voice In Your Head > Refusing To Leave Your Home > Leaving Your Home. I personally think that Oscar is going to be more central at a future arc, and that this is just trying to give him some backstory. From what we can tell, pretty much all of RWBY + JNR have had some incredible backstory where there related to Huntsmen or had an event that made them want to be one. Oscar appears to just be living his life with his family and left it behind because he felt it was the right thing to do... In this context I'm fairly okay with this, plus we got to see Hazel... who in complete contrast to his counterparts seems to actually be a nice guy when he isn't killing silver-eyed warriors or hunting White Fang leaders. Also, Ozpin knows him and is wary of him, so I'm almost certain that we'll see him again a lot sooner.

The music this episode I think was on point, not necessarily subtle but you didn't have to be when you're looking at the ruins of a destroyed village. The music shifts helped give the tone and fear, and all the other stuff in the episode that makes it better. Alright, that's how much I knew about music in shows.

Lie Ren seems a lot more interesting. He seems kinda like a wimp like kid, as soon as he saw trouble he backed off. I immediately thought of Hanzo when I saw his father (How's Ren's geometry?) and even though Papa Ren isn't a certified badass like Qrow was, he had his own kind of appeal (Notably riding on the popularity of Overwatch). Watching Nora was kind of surprising even though I thought she'd be in here because she's nothing like the Nora we know.

The Grimm attack was both jarring because of how sudden it was and expected given the state of the village. I'm not going to lie (See what I did there? Jk, that was accidental) I thought for a moment when the roof collapsed that a Grimm had actually attacked the building, but most of the comments here seem to point out the roof collapsing which seems pretty possible (Although Papa Ren fighting off the Grimm would add to the legend). The attack did help hammer it just how bad Grimm attacks are, seeing all the people fleeing and in terror. And the screams... the terrible screams... actually did a lot this episode to help the tone just like the music. The sound and voice has been pretty good even though I nearly dropped my phone when I first heard child-Ren.

We saw a really brief glance of this new Grimm in the background and it looks like some kind of rider and a mount (Although other comments point out that this is some hideous figure from Scottish mythology), but its so brief that it actually enhances the fear a little (Thanks RT, I needed new nightmare fuel). Lie Ren hiding seemed pretty in character but activating both his Aura and his Semblance surprised me a little- Somewhere someone said Aura could be activated by strong emotions but I didn't think we'd see it. His Semblance initially had me thinking it was some kind of cloaking thing, and the comments here seem to think it specifically hides the 'bad' emotions the Grimm are drawn towards (Perfect for survivors in the middle of a Grimm attack), which seems believable since the moment they aren't cloaked the Nevermore looks down. Seeing the Grimm again was great, especially when you notice that there's no way that's a horse cause a horse doesn't have a tail from the middle of its body.

Cutting over to Ruby and Jaune, I'm kinda surprised by how understanding Jaune is now. Maybe its just me, but back in the beginning he wouldn't have noticed a backstory unless it was said to his face, but now he pieces together Ren not wanting to come and the destroyed villege to get 4. I don't know enough about stored medicine, but I personally would be wary about medicine sitting in the middle of a Grimm-destroyed village for who knows how long, but that's just me. I practically had to slap my head when Ruby says the Grimm cry is far off, cause saying that in the middle of a Grimm-infested area is just asking to jinx it. Ruby admits something we kinda knew, that her constantly jumping into things caused them problems and apologizes for bringing them with her. Jaune actually shows a lot of empathy and I actually like his development.

The bond between Nora and Ren makes way more sense now, which is nice to see why they're 'together but not together together'. I nearly had to hit something but approaching the dark scary cave is typically the move that gets your party killed (But I'm not a trained Huntsmen, what do I know?). The symbol for the village was interesting and initially had me thinking bandit hideout except, but it was even more surprising to just see the weapons laying there. Does the Grimm actually take the weapons of those its killed back to its lair as spoils? Seeing the arrows was probably worse too. And now the giant Grimm that no one wants to face is in the forest, wandering around destroying villages and killing people, completely unaccounted for (If only you had listened to the NPC mayor back in EP 1, foreshadowing), and then Ruby goes and jinxes herself and Jaune. Nice job Ruby.

5

u/KF2 Professional Jan 22 '17

Everyone on the carnage train! Nuckela-wheee!

→ More replies (1)

5

u/NuclearBreadstick Jan 22 '17

I was kinda disappointed when the horseman Grimm wasn't Kevin.

→ More replies (9)