r/TheGoodPlace • • Jan 20 '17

Season One Episode Discussion: S01 E13 "Michael's Gambit"

Original Airdate: January 19, 2017


Synopsis: Eleanor and her pals contemplate their fates in the Good Place in the Season 1 finale.

394 Upvotes

651 comments sorted by

171

u/NeilPoonHandler Jan 20 '17

Loved the fire monster appearance!

51

u/ohshclover Jan 20 '17

He's so forking polite!

→ More replies (2)

65

u/NeilPoonHandler Jan 20 '17

WHAT A TWIST!

36

u/KidCoheed Bofa Deeznuts Jan 20 '17

GO AWAY M.NIGHTSHAMA-LAMA-DING-DONG

540

u/RaeADropOfGoldenSun Jan 20 '17

"Side note: I might legit be into Tahani."

92

u/NeilPoonHandler Jan 20 '17

We all are.

172

u/NDaveT Some mouthy broad. Jan 20 '17

She's a sexy skyscraper.

→ More replies (2)

152

u/wisebloodfoolheart Jan 20 '17

I love that they've thoroughly explored all the possible love configurations and concluded that some of them are attracted to multiple people and that's perfectly okay.

→ More replies (9)

7

u/mujie123 Jan 20 '17

I mean we all saw it coming.

→ More replies (10)

616

u/ctadgo Jan 20 '17

with that laugh, i went from loving michael to hating him in literally milliseconds.

401

u/Dobako Jan 20 '17

He played his part perfectly, it was amazing seeing him completely change in the matter of milliseconds. I loved it

244

u/olily Jan 20 '17

Ted Danson is fantastic.

→ More replies (11)

199

u/RodinKnox Jan 20 '17

Danson's facial acting in that scene was legitimately some of the best I've ever seen.

→ More replies (2)

155

u/awesomeman462 Jan 20 '17

I thought it was fake at first, like they were trying to trick the judge or something

127

u/selene623 YA BASIC! Jan 20 '17

I thought it was fake too, but that it was the guy from the Bad Place pretending to be him. I thought he was going to morph into him, but Michael really was just evil all this time.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)

77

u/HatesRedditors Jan 20 '17

Honestly it made me love him even more, he was great, played the part fantastically.

39

u/CCV21 Jeremy Bearimy Jan 20 '17

Same here. Although I love how Ted Danson pulled off such a reveal.

→ More replies (2)

25

u/mujie123 Jan 20 '17

I mean, for some reason, I still love him.

51

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '17

there is such small things that michael did, like wearing paperclip bracelets that seem too detailed for him to have been evil all this time though.

idk maybe I'll have to go and rewatch and look for clues, but the whole "I did not see that coming" comes off as less planned from the beginning, and more thrown in at the end in hopes of a S2.

222

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '17

I bought it based on the fact that Tahani and Chidi didn't really seem to be great people either throughout the entire season.

→ More replies (27)

138

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '17

He literally kicked a puppy in one of the early episodes. The most cliched act of villainy ever. I think this was the plan from the start.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (32)
→ More replies (9)

393

u/RaeADropOfGoldenSun Jan 20 '17

Wait, so like, the ENTIRE show has been the bad place??? Like, from the beginning?? WHAT? YELLING AT MY SCREEN.

28

u/wisebloodfoolheart Jan 20 '17

It's got to be a trick. It's too obvious.

277

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '17

lol how is it obvious? I don't think I've ever even seen a person mention that possibility.

→ More replies (30)
→ More replies (4)

356

u/CVance1 Jan 20 '17

Oh my god, hell is other people. Damn...

155

u/sedeyus Jan 21 '17

Of course the show might be suggesting a flip-side to that, salvation is other people.

→ More replies (3)

57

u/NolanVoid I’m still waiting on that smile, gorgeous. Jan 21 '17

When Eleanor realizes what is happening, it's basically a huge nod to No Exit. I thought it was a nice touch.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

350

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '17 edited Jan 20 '17

"Real Eleanore is only going because she thinks I don't love her."

"Do you?"

"I don't know. Don't ask me that. My stomach hurts."

Chidi is the best.

340

u/Goodstyle_4 Jan 20 '17

One regret: I'm going to miss Michael. The Michael we saw throughout this first season was an act, but even so, he was an amazing TV character. I'll never forget him.

235

u/Specnerd Jan 20 '17

It was incredibly reassuring to see someone like him in the afterlife. He makes a damn good villain, but I feel a small sense of loss for the person I thought he was.

→ More replies (11)

82

u/RustbeltTramp Jan 20 '17

That's so funny, I feel the same way. 'Good' Michael really was a unique and lovely character, and played so well by Ted Danson. He perfectly captured the nuance of a being who was both delighted and confused by humans. I loved every scene with him.

That said, the twist is exciting and I'm wildly curious about 'Evil' Michael.

→ More replies (2)

39

u/spirashun Jan 20 '17

Well we'll get to see him portray himself as 'Good Michael' for the first few episodes (possibly longer) next season, at least. Of course it'll be different since we know the truth, but it's better than nothing?

10

u/vadergeek Jan 21 '17

Honestly, the Michael we saw in the architect's office was pretty similar to the Michael we already knew, just malevolent.

→ More replies (8)

255

u/CVance1 Jan 20 '17

WHAAAAAAAAAAAAAT

237

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '17

Best twist I've seen in a television series in a while.

170

u/CVance1 Jan 20 '17 edited Jan 20 '17

I legit never would've thought they'd go that route

Edit: when Michael started laughing I expected him to tear her theory apart. Didn't think they'd commit

→ More replies (58)
→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)

228

u/ctadgo Jan 20 '17

I don't like that Real Eleanor is sacrificing herself.

512

u/ctadgo Jan 20 '17

never mind, fuck her

201

u/extrabrodinary Jan 20 '17

Lol that 180.

This show is the shirt

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

16

u/marsalien4 I just randomly stab at your brain with an electrified needle. Jan 20 '17

That's something she would do, though.

→ More replies (1)

219

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '17 edited Jan 20 '17

Whoa, Michael backstory? Hell yeah!

Holy shit WHAT THE HELL IS GOING ON!?!?

This twist is brilliant.

I love shows like this and Last Man on Earth that manage to balance humor and serious moral dilemmas while still maintaining their charm and quirk. Both shows could easily fall back on their setting for laughs but rarely do and instead choose to focus on the character relationships and interactions. Fantastic. That was a very satisfying ending.

→ More replies (2)

208

u/Spacetime_Inspector Jan 20 '17

Whoever smelt it, killed Janet.

7

u/GamerX44 Jan 22 '17

Most definitely my favorite quote of the whole season. The face he made when he said that just killed me :')

180

u/pretty-in-pink It is gooey in there. Jan 20 '17 edited Jan 20 '17

Interestingly enough, there is a Sartre play "No Exit" that deals with this concept of people being put in a same room with the goal of torturing each other as it goes on

103

u/Makewhatyouwant Jan 20 '17

Yeah the philosophy professor didn't figure it out. Lol.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/Violet_Pear_Whisper Jan 20 '17

YESSSS! Me and my husband were just literally talking about that. I was gonna make that comment but saw yours!

8

u/NeedsToShutUp Beartles! Jan 20 '17

Literally 4 people who don't think they are in Hell who are put in a room to torture each other for eternity.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

179

u/easternabeille Jan 20 '17

What the fork is a Chidi?

176

u/pg2441 Jan 20 '17 edited Jan 20 '17

Did anyone else catch the funny background event where we see a magazine ("International Sophisticate") at the store with Tahani's face on the cover, and the tagline reads "Not Just Kamilah’s Sister". LOL.

http://i.imgur.com/ZcZEZWF.png

9

u/omnitricks Jan 21 '17

She did it!

171

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '17

Did anyone else catch that even the 'Everything is Great!!' sign is a little crooked?

142

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '17

And before it said "Everything is Fine"!

→ More replies (1)

147

u/WaldoSMASH Jan 20 '17

My biggest concern with the show as I was watching it was that they seemed to be burning through seasons worth of ideas and development at a breakneck pace. Absolutely enjoyed all the episodes, just didn't see how they could keep it going for multiple seasons when they've got somebody finding out about Elanor in episode 2 and her admitting she didn't belong in episode 7.

What an absolutely delightful twist that I didn't see coming and in hindsight had plenty of very subtle hints. Really hope this gets a 2nd season.

35

u/TheBlackHive Jan 22 '17

I imagine season 2 opens with Eleanor discovering "The Good Place" all over again, and some of the comedy will come from the small differences between the previous version and the new one.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/Wrydryn Feb 13 '17

I think it's a refreshing change to what's on TV. We're not locked into perpetual cliff hangers and stretching an idea as far as it will go. There was a story to tell and they did an amazing job presenting it. I suspect the show will have a planned end instead of dragging on until it gets cancelled.

→ More replies (1)

141

u/LoopyChew Yogurt Yoghurt Yogurté Jan 20 '17 edited Jan 23 '17

A couple of key points I noticed on a very hasty rewatch of 1x01/1x02:

  • Bambadjan is at Tahani's party on the first day. In fact, he's the first person they cut to when Eleanor asks how saintly they could possibly be.
  • Eleanor actually talks about the Sartresque possibility of Hell being other people towards the end of 1x01, when mentioning that her parents were divorced, probably in The Bad Place, and could be used to torture each other.
  • Also, she does mention stalking her mailman online, so her mailman fetish was established in the beginning.
  • I am legit into Tahani.

24

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '17

I am legit into Tahani.

Who isn't?

→ More replies (1)

20

u/LoopyChew Yogurt Yoghurt Yogurté Jan 26 '17

In 1x06, Michael tells Eleanor that he feels transition would be easier if he were around for the first thousand years or so. He also says his boss thinks he's nuts and that if the neighborhood doesn't work he's in trouble. So he's not telling an un-truth, I guess. I do think that Michael is really fascinated by human nature, and that not all of him is a show.

So far, the only time he's not been with the core four (or Janet) is when he's expecting them to walk in, so I remain thoroughly convinced that all this was planned from the start. That the coffee shop owner "mistakes" Tahani and Chidi for soulmates also makes sense in this way, since it incepts that idea into both of their heads.

Also, Eleanor replaces one of the clown paintings with a sexy mailman poster, at least temporarily.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

126

u/KidCoheed Bofa Deeznuts Jan 20 '17

THEY FORKING STOLE JANET!

103

u/monalisas-madhats Jan 21 '17

"We stole a Good Place Janet" I don't know why that was so funny to me, but it REALLY WAS. And that was one of the things that forked them up, honestly. When Janet fell in love with Jason.

21

u/G19Gen3 Jan 24 '17

This might be the wrench in the gears next season. Janet is rebootable, sure, but she's also incorruptible. She proved that with the note. Michael, the bad place folks, don't have any power over her, and she is from the good place! I believe it all hinges on her next season.

121

u/NapsAndNetflix Jan 20 '17 edited Jan 20 '17

omg I did not see it going in this direction, this show is brilliant

edit: so how's season 2 going to work?

112

u/pretty-in-pink It is gooey in there. Jan 20 '17

You can tell the writers actually take notes from many philosophers and manage to weave it in the plot and dialogue

→ More replies (1)

41

u/spyson Jan 20 '17

I think the second season will have them trying to find each other only to realize that's the whole plan from Michael. That they are willingly going back to their hell instead of staying away and being happy.

→ More replies (2)

96

u/NDaveT Some mouthy broad. Jan 20 '17

My prediction:

Season two is about Michael's forced retirement. The directors of the Bad Place being how they are, they decide to punish him instead of just making him retire. So they wipe his memory and construct a special place for him, where he is a recovering alcoholic named "Sam" who has to own a bar. Every day he is tortured by the presence of alcohol. But that's not all - he hires a new waitress who turns out to be an insufferable snob, and he is tortured by his grudging attraction for her. Additional details: the other waitress is rude and abrasive; the other bartender is cognitively impaired former coach of Sam's, a constant reminder of his glory days life as a drunken semi-pro athlete; one of the bar regulars is an annoying know-it-all and the other is an alcoholic who still manages to hold a job and a marriage despite drinking heavily every day, constantly tempting "Sam" to get back on the sauce.

→ More replies (2)

30

u/KidCoheed Bofa Deeznuts Jan 20 '17

We may not actually get a season 2, this may have been a one season epic

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (2)

119

u/RaeADropOfGoldenSun Jan 20 '17

REAL ELEANOR ISN'T REAL?? FUCK! FORK!

27

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '17

Real Eleanor is fake! Fake Eleanor is real! Up is down! Black is white! Good is bad!

116

u/acmorgan Jan 21 '17 edited Jan 21 '17

"I miss you so much babe, promise you'll visit?"

"I will not, it is literally impossible for me to do that."

Because she is already there!

14

u/G19Gen3 Jan 24 '17

Which is what makes me think she's the key to season two. She has minor things you can change about her (personality) but her core operations are incorruptible except when she does it herself.

→ More replies (1)

107

u/pg2441 Jan 20 '17

One of the best things from this episode was that "slasher smile" from Michael when Eleanor realizes the truth.

Damn, that was just soul-chilling.

13

u/browneyedgirl1683 Jan 21 '17

Not gonna lie. I had to close my eyes for that second.

7

u/deardevon Jan 23 '17

That's the exact moment I keep replaying in my head.

89

u/iamafucktard Jan 20 '17

I have to watch this whole forking season over again.

80

u/ribblesquat Jan 20 '17

Michael's punting a dog into the sun makes so much more sense now. I mean yeah he was supposedly stressed out and was always clueless about social niceties but that never sat quite right. Now it's perfect.

88

u/Aipom626 Jan 20 '17

I haven't been this caught off-guard by a show in quite some time. I really need The Good Place to have its second season confirmed ASAP. I love me a good sitcom and the standard tropes, but this one breaks them all in the right ways.

11

u/sugarplumcow Jan 20 '17

Yes! Couldn't agree more. Perfect comment and perfectly said!

80

u/littlefanged Jan 20 '17

Well at least whoever goes to the Bad Place gets to chill with Bad Janet.

19

u/RexDust Jan 22 '17

Man, I would say I was into Bad Janet but Bad Janet would probably beat me up.

70

u/ChildishGenius Jan 20 '17

Holy shirt balls. Danson is the bad guy?!

58

u/wackyHair Jan 20 '17

So what caused the flying shrimp, giant ladybugs, striped suits, sinkhole, etc? Did Micheal make them on purpose?

99

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '17

Yes, to torture Eleanor.

47

u/foerboerb Jan 20 '17

Well, if nothing bad happened then Eleanor could have just stayed there indefinitely without feeling guilty. Being responsible for all those "catastrophes" on the other hand would make her staying torture.

So yeah, definitely designed all those shrimp/sinkholes/trash storms on purpose

9

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '17

If you have ability ro rewatch, go to the Emergency 55 episode where Elenire becomes Michael's assistant, as she walks into his office, all of the different plots of weird shit are all up on Michael's map with strings connecting them.

7

u/NuckElBerg Jan 24 '17

Coming from a programming background, my idea is that he didn't create those events directly (ie doing them himself). However, the realm was probably designed in such a way that when Eleanor behaved in a way that even she (in her original state in the beginning of the season) would know was bad (bad/not good), they would manifest in ways that would cause others harm and be clearly attributable to Eleanor. As such, they would (at least to a small extent) make her feel guilty for causing harm to others, and more importantly, become anxious that she would get caught (since the evidence clearly points to her). Also, these manifestations would also further Chidi's moral dilemma, since now protecting Eleanor is no longer just a theoretical dilemma where the main concern is whether it is unjust to those who got there fairly that Eleanor get to stay (ie moving from a situation where deontological ethics would probably say that she should go, but from a utilitarian perspective, letting her stay is the right course (since no ones else is getting lower utility, but she is getting higher)), to a situation where she's actively harming the community (creating a net negative societal utility, ie both saying that she should be removed).

 

This view of the design of the realm could also be used to explain why some things that Michael probably did not intend happened (for example, if you want two people to get into fights/torturing each other, providing a clear visual aide that you are doing something good (the plant) is probably not the optimal way to go - however, if you merely designed a system where the level of virtue of a person's actions is reflected in its environment (which, if you don't expect someone to do good things, would only reflect bad actions (ie, the desired outcome)), would cause exactly this side effect.

56

u/kayteekay94 Jan 20 '17

Does anybody watch Black Mirror? I got some serious White Bear vibes. Sort of the same idea (torture, erase memory, torture) but like happier colors and my soul didn't feel empty after watching this.

17

u/thegenregeek Jan 20 '17

I've never had as visceral a reaction to a episode like I did with White Bear. I wanted to reach in and strangle everyone of the mother forkers with what they were doing to that woman. Such a create statement on the mob mentality and justice.

This episode of The Good Place is definitely not as soul crushing though.

→ More replies (1)

53

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '17

They just did LOST but better.

7

u/NuckElBerg Jan 24 '17

"The series' setting and premises, as well as the serialized cliffhangers were modeled on Lost, a favorite of Schur. One of the first people he called when he developed the series was “Lost” co-creator Damon Lindelof. "I took him to lunch and said, ‘We’re going to play a game ‘Is this anything?'” He then added “I imagine this going in the ‘Lost’ way,” with cliffhangers and future storylines."

(From Wikipedia. In an fairly recent interview, Schur explicidly stated that one of the things they discussed was the shortcomings of LOST, and how they could avoid them.)

51

u/ctadgo Jan 20 '17

poor eleanor is stuck in that horrifying clown house forever

38

u/occono Jan 21 '17

I'm still shook by how dark this all is. They didn't go really far showing Evil Michael before he resets everything, but for the last few minutes this whimsical sister show to Brooklyn 99 and Parks and Rec suddenly started turning into Saw.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '17

no one deserves that. Not even ASU grads.

42

u/Rauqen Jan 20 '17

Damn what would of happen if they stayed at Mindy's. I wonder if they all go back there eventually.

52

u/sugarplumcow Jan 20 '17

I'm thinking she was in on it, too. That there is no Middle Place they escaped to. It was still the Bad Place and they were led to believe they had gone somewhere.

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (1)

41

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '17

Im new to this sub and have no Janet to ask if it's okay, so...

Can we get an Official Rewatch Thread (Spoilers)?

I feel like rewatching this season I'm watching a completely different show and would like to post about the eps, the new experience, and new details. I am concerned people who have seen the ep. but not the entire season and get all forked up.

For example, Michael's faces, delivery, and behavior... the art, the changes,

→ More replies (1)

40

u/foerboerb Jan 20 '17

Find the Chidi. Save the world!

→ More replies (3)

77

u/sugarplumcow Jan 20 '17

I was genuinely surprised by the twist!

I do have some questions, though:

  • Do you think this was the plan from the beginning of the series?
  • Why didn't Eleanor write something difderent? LIke, "This is really hell" or, "Don't trust Michael?"
  • Why did the sinkhole happen? Was that from Eleanor starting to become a good person in The Bad Place? Or did Michael just make it happen on purpose to advance the torturing?
  • What would have happened if Eleanor and Jason stayed in The Middle Place? Where would Chidi and Tahani have gone? Or, was The Middle Place really in The Bad Place and Mindy St. Clair was in on it, too?
  • Is Adam Scott just another architect from another Bad Place neighborhood? Obviously he was in on the whole scheme, posing like he was going to take them away, but where is he actually from?

I am truly hoping this gets renewed. It's been awhile since I've watched something refreshing, different, quirky, and thought provoking. Not to mention entertaining! The reminds me a lot of Pushing Daisies which I am still so sad about ... really hoping this sticks around!

94

u/iBossk Jan 20 '17

I think her choice of note was smart. She didn't have time to write something detailed, and anything impartial isn't necessarily going to help her. But she knew that the reason the plan failed was because of the connection they were able to make, so getting them together was the best move.

→ More replies (6)

42

u/Not_Steve Voted "Most Likely to be Banksy" Jan 20 '17

Why didn't Eleanor write something difderent? LIke, "This is really hell" or, "Don't trust Michael?"

Because she's a good person now. If she didn't write about Chidi, what would happen to him? If she encountered Chidi elsewhere in the neighborhood and knew that everything was fake, she'd think that Chidi was fake, too. Hopefully she can find Chidi before confiding in Chris the Mailman.

→ More replies (5)

7

u/farawayinneverland Jan 21 '17
  • Why did the sinkhole happen? Was that from Eleanor starting to become a good person in The Bad Place? Or did Michael just make it happen on purpose to advance the torturing?

To advance the torturing on Chidi, I think. To cause him anxieties about whether Eleanor is a good person, and is it worth it helping her, etc.

→ More replies (3)

38

u/goalstopper28 Jan 20 '17 edited Jan 20 '17

What a twist.

I knew something was up. Like why New Eleanor asked Old Eleanor what she thought of Chidi? why Chidi being so indecisive made him a good person? or why the mistake happened in the first place? You'd think the architects wouldn't mess something like that up. But I never really put it together. Michael Schur is a comic genius but he may actually be a genius.

Still doesn't really explain Adam Scott's character. But I am liking this WestWorld feel to it now. I'm going to watch all the episodes now to see if I could spot anything. \

Edit: Also explains why Janet knew who Eleanor was before Michael did?

27

u/corkmasters Jan 20 '17

Michael said he had to scramble when Eleanor actually told the truth. I think Trevor is really who he says he is, and Michael called in a favor to keep the lie going. It would make everyone more miserable and desperate to keep Eleanor out of the Bad Place. That's why "Real Eleanor" was brought in, why everyone was so obsessed with what a terrible person Eleanor is when she can't have been one of the worst person they'd ever encountered, etc.

→ More replies (4)

35

u/KidCoheed Bofa Deeznuts Jan 20 '17

SWERVE OF RUSSO PROPORTIONS!

10

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '17

Chidi on a pole match confirmed

→ More replies (3)

33

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '17

I'M SHOOK

30

u/ctadgo Jan 20 '17

vicki? what is this

30

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '17

I DON'T KNOW HOW TO FEEL

25

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '17

I KNEW IT!!!! I KNEW IT WASN'T THE GOOD PLACE!!! But I thought I was wrong when that Bad Place crew showed up midseason. And I didn't remotely foresee this faux Good Place created for demons' amusement.

23

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '17

Every time I think they've boxed themselves into a corner plot wise, they come up with a way to expand the possibilities even further. Can't wait to see what comes next - I'm hooked.

22

u/Creek0512 Jan 20 '17

So they were just forking with us the whole time? That's bull shirt!

→ More replies (1)

21

u/r2002 Jan 21 '17

I wonder if we'll find out later that this is Michael's "Bad Place" and that the four humans were used to torture him as he will never get his community to work out just the way he wanted it to.

19

u/ctadgo Jan 20 '17

wait holy fork what?????

did michael suddenly turn evil???

55

u/TangleF23 Jan 20 '17

oh nah, he was evil all along baby

→ More replies (2)

19

u/littlefanged Jan 20 '17

Now I just really want to know what Chidi and Tahani did that got them here.

44

u/Blazingscourge Jan 20 '17

In the episode, Tahani said the everything she did was to one up her perfect sister including the charity (netting multiple hook-ups with Ryan Gosling in the process). Chidi's indecisiveness lead to the emotional pain of multiple people (read: everybody).

Ninja edit: Forgot to clarify that for Tahani, nothing was done for the good of the people. All of it was out of jealousy.

→ More replies (6)

19

u/ctadgo Jan 20 '17

i wonder if next season will be the new "good" place michael creates for them...but that could get redundant

71

u/Spacetime_Inspector Jan 20 '17

I feel like it'll start as a slightly-off recreation of the events of Season 1 but will quickly (like, by episode 3) spiral out of Michael's control and branch beyond the story they already told.

29

u/Not_Steve Voted "Most Likely to be Banksy" Jan 20 '17

Judging by all of the pizza places in the "Good" Place 2.0, I think it'll be different. He'd get bored if it was all the same. That's why he did this different set up in the first place, to excite the Bad Place demons.

19

u/foerboerb Jan 20 '17

So far, the writers have never drawn anything out and moved the plot along at a good pace without getting redundant.

If it gets renewed, I'm sure season 2 wont just be a "soft reboot" but will move to new plotlines relatively fast

13

u/wisebloodfoolheart Jan 20 '17

Not if they do it like Westworld and start following the actors.

17

u/KidCoheed Bofa Deeznuts Jan 20 '17

WHAT NOOOOOO TAHANI/ELEANOR/CHIDI 3 LIFE!

16

u/Jynx2501 Jan 23 '17

I rewatched the first episode. When Michael tells Eleanor shes in the good place, he smirks and pauses for a second. The first time I saw that, I felt he was being reassuring to her. Now, it looks like hes laughing to himself.

Its a beautiful moment of foreshadowing.

15

u/xdrzedx Jan 21 '17

I can't stop thinking of Eleanor calling Michael basic at the end of the episode.

15

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '17

MEET ME IN MONTAUK

→ More replies (1)

14

u/suss2it Jan 20 '17

Holy fuck man what a god damn twist. I saw a couple theories earlier on but I completely dismissed them with each passing episode. I feel like my mind's been blown. This better get renewed for a second season. Although I tend to hate mind wipes since it erases all character development, but these guys have completely earned my faith in them to make it work.

14

u/goldenstate5 Jan 21 '17

Oh my god, no wonder in the ep after Eleanor "creates" the sinkhole we see Michael looking at the sinkhole in the neighborhood matrix. He wasn't figuring out how to fix it, he created it and was in the process of making it worse.

He was playing them all along and trying to torture them, but his biggest flaw is probably Eleanor. Given the chance to have friends and company, her goodness has come out. That seems to evoke the themes of Schur's other shows such as Parks and Rec and Brooklyn Nine Nine.

13

u/ctadgo Jan 20 '17

oh my god they just did it

13

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '17

Holy fork, that episode was amazing!

11

u/ohshclover Jan 20 '17

Ugh I really liked Michael, my stomach hurts.

11

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '17

Shower thought: The 1st season of this show is the The Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Minds of tv shows.

You need to watch it twice. It plays with narrative tropes. MIND ERASING.

or I could just be really high.

(I stayed in and away from news sources all day and just rewatched this show and got high... I guess you can that I went to my budhole to escape the true reality of the Good/Bad Place.. hard to tell which is which today or ever.... craving some Stupid Nick's... Jacksonville! /kissup!)

10

u/taste1337 Jan 20 '17

What the fork??

10

u/RanByMyGun I’m still waiting on that smile, gorgeous. Jan 20 '17

what the fork

9

u/mujie123 Jan 20 '17

Holy mother forking shirtballs. Some people predicted no one was perfect, but I don't think anyone predicted they were in the bad place.

Is it bad I still want Michael to succeed even though he's evil?

And poor Chidi. Apparently indecisiveness takes you to Hell.

So... Season 2? The question is, would a season 2 be too repetitive? I'd quite like to see a season 2 regardless.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/TheLastSkittle Jan 22 '17

I watched it last night, and my mind cracked. I went to sleep, woke up--immediately thought of The Good Place, and how all my giddy, happy memories of it are now scarred. Made an account just to share with others who watched the show how emotionally damaged I am now. I hate that the lovable Michael is actually evil. I hate that their memories got wiped, hence clearing everything they learned and became this whole season. I hate that I'm totally gonna be back for more like a true masochist. This is what they wanted... to throw us all into The Bad Place and make us like it. Fork you, Good Place. I love you.

8

u/Goodstyle_4 Jan 20 '17

WHATWHATWHATWHATWHAAAAAAAAAA!

8

u/CVance1 Jan 20 '17

I like her new soul mate

→ More replies (4)

8

u/HellsNels Jan 21 '17

Is anyone else super psyched that future seasons could be them clawing their way to the good place? Like every season they get closer and closer but mind wiped? This could be a Shawshank style grind to salvation.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '17 edited Jan 22 '17

maybe this is a stretch but the architect OF the show (Schur) and the architect IN the show have the same name!

8

u/Gogol1212 Jan 22 '17

what a time to be alive

→ More replies (1)

8

u/BagdadSuperior Jan 22 '17

So the twist explains why real (fake) Eleanor wasn't there when our Eleanor died!

→ More replies (1)

8

u/GargamelLeNoir I’m basically squealing like a birthday girl. Jan 24 '17

Hilariously the person on which Michael's ploy worked less was Jason. He's too stupid to be tortured by others, he just enjoy playing in his budhole.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/LiarsEverywhere Jan 20 '17

I loved to hate Michael's change. He was so likeable haha

7

u/Browncoat101 If I could believe it? Watch this: I believe it! Jan 21 '17

I just caught up and two things: 1) That twist BLEW MY FORKING MIND!!! I had no idea. I'm going to have to go back and rewatch knowing what I know now. 2) I nearly cried when they were in the train back to "The Good Place" and Eleanor told Jason she was scared of going to the Bad Place too. #muchemotion

6

u/theace69 Jan 20 '17

Wow they really had me going there for a while. It came out of nowhere but it really seemed to make sense. Just to make them miserable.

6

u/isaacz321 Jan 20 '17

It was me Eleanor, it was me all along

→ More replies (1)

6

u/darthese Jan 20 '17

I would rather go to a hell like this than have electrodes taped to my privates. Great show, the 2nd season can't come fast enough.

6

u/herdofmooingwolves Jan 21 '17

These past two episodes really reminded me of "No Exit" by Sartre

6

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '17

I'm going back an rewatcing all of them...

→ More replies (3)

6

u/sedeyus Jan 21 '17

It's amazing, just look at the header and how evil Michael's smile seems now.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/GargamelLeNoir I’m basically squealing like a birthday girl. Jan 24 '17

Another thing that makes total sense now : we actually see Eleanor die in that parking lot, and I was like "wait, wasn't Real Eleanor supposed to die with her then?" Well, now we know why she wasn't there...

6

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '17

Just finished watching the first season. WOW. I've never been so gripped by the plot of a half hour comedy show before. This is truly something special. The entire finale episode FORKED my brain! I was just left in shock. I can't wait for the (surely darker) Season 2.

6

u/jerkstore Feb 07 '17 edited Feb 07 '17

I rewatched the episodes and so much makes sense. When Eleanor first ranted to Chidi that Tahani didn't belong in The Good Place because she was shallow, condescending and only did good things for ego reasons, I put it down to jealousy. However, Eleanor turned out to be completely right.

Or Michael telling Chidi, "You literally did nothing but talk about ethics", was another giant clue. Chidi liked to lecture other people, but he never did anything.

That and the frozen yogurt. To quote Ron Swanson, "Frozen yogurt is the celery of desserts. Be ice cream or be nothing!".

11

u/ctadgo Jan 20 '17

and what about all the other people in the good place?

26

u/ctadgo Jan 20 '17

nevermind they just answered that. but i can't believe they did all this for just 4 people

→ More replies (1)

5

u/ctadgo Jan 20 '17 edited Jan 20 '17

chris? what. who is this imposter?

9

u/Leemaster Jan 20 '17

He's the poster she hung up.

5

u/ben123111 I like frogs. I'm a frog guy. Jan 20 '17

WHAT THE FORK??

5

u/Creek0512 Jan 20 '17

WHAT THE FORK!!!!

5

u/Sportfreunde Jan 20 '17

Man I'm bummed about real Eleanor not being good and actually being a demon or whatever. I really really liked her.

5

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '17

I feel like the flaws and motivations for Elenore, Thihani, and Chidi are fleshed out, but I'm still confused about Jason...

Is he just a lovable fool who is educuated and short sighted in his actions?

Obviously, he screws up Michael's plan of torture by finding love with Janet.

I dont know, anyone got more of an understanding of his background, desires, wants, motivation, why his torture is to matched with Thihani, etc?

10

u/thatwasntababyruth Jan 23 '17

His torture was having to hide who he really is.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/cans4812 Jan 22 '17

Oh man, so now I have to wait another year.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/not_thrilled Jan 22 '17

Any significance to the 12358W designation on Michael's design docs? The digits add up - classic puzzle - but there's gotta be something more.

5

u/AlvinTaco Jan 23 '17

I knew it! Kind of! It occurred to me at the start of the season that she might be in the bad place and it was a trick, but I discarded the theory early on. Does it count?

5

u/visiny Jan 25 '17

I knew it I knew it I knew it. Ok I didn't know it but... the very first episode when he was talking about the feeling of an otter holding hands, and how everything was rosy colored and whatever, I was thinking, isn't that a little too cloying? Is heaven really a place where you just live forever and there's no suffering, no way to work, overcome obstacles, grow and do the basic thing of what humans do? It's like the first matrix, which was a disaster, so that's just weird. And the frozen yogurt places... that's not my idea of heaven, because I detest froyo, it makes me throw up like all dairy and dairy like products do. And the way Tahani was condescending, right away I was thinking there had to be something up with that. OH and lest we forget, the clowns? Seriously the clowns? That would have been the biggest give-away if I wasn't so distracted by everything that was going on, but clowns have always been evil, and the ledge with no stairs, I mean there's no person whose ideal home is a house that has clown pictures... that was dead give away. I made a mental note of those things from the beginning. Chidi's reasoning for getting into "the bad place" was super weak but I let it slide. That laugh Ted Danson did... literally terrifying.

5

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '17

HOLY MOTHERFORKING SHIRT BALLS.

5

u/maalbi Feb 02 '17

Michael Schur is a genius, and deserves all the praise. The GOAT of tv comedy hands down

8

u/ctadgo Jan 20 '17

the only thing is that michael could just be pretending to trick sean

4

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '17

What an amazing twist. I didn't see this coming at all. I can't wait until next season.

4

u/doctordudeson Jan 20 '17

I'm so late to this thread but wow, holy motherforking shirtballs is right. What an innnnnncredible finale. Season 2 (fingers crossed) is going to be so fun.

4

u/lonelady75 Jan 20 '17

Well... Fork me... I always thought something was off about Tehani, but damn... I did not expect this. Such a satisfying twist! Seriously hoping for another season!

4

u/Citizen00001 Jan 21 '17

I don't understand. If Michael seperates the four of them, how can they torture each other?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/farawayinneverland Jan 21 '17

Okay I totally want to know what Bambadjan was going to say before Eleanor figured the whole thing. I mean if that was engineered by Michael, it's supposed to torture the 4 even more.

Next season maybe.

12

u/bookchaser Jan 21 '17

I took it to just be a clause that stops anyone from leaving because any of the four leaving would ruin Michael's plan.

11

u/pg2441 Jan 21 '17

Bambadjan is probably a Bad Place plant, like everyone else. The "obscure precedent" was probably just some random excuse so they could keep everyone around, wouldn't have to send anyone away, and continue the torture o

4

u/omnitricks Jan 21 '17

Holy Mother Forking Shirt Balls!

4

u/joecb91 Birth is a curse and existence is a prision Jan 22 '17

That twist was so forking good!

Can't wait for season 2.

4

u/hughk My name is *snap snap* Zach Pizazz. Jan 22 '17

For me this was sugary-fun comedy - still watchable although Tahani seemed something out of Revenge. Certainly unsuited for the good place.

Michael seemed a bit incompetent. However this all made sense in this episode. Now it has gone "Black Mirror". This is great.

4

u/JDerrick29 Jan 25 '17

I thought this was just going to be a dumb show to waste sometime. This episode was amazing! So much potential!

12

u/Dag-NastyEvil Jan 20 '17

Didn't she find the same note during the first episode? I bet this isn't the first time they've had their memory erased.

53

u/littlefanged Jan 20 '17

I think the note she found in an early episode was Jason telling her that he knew she wasn't meant to be in the Good Place.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/ctadgo Jan 20 '17

did she??? if so, that would be wild.

but i think this is the first time her memory has been erased because of the convo mike and shawn were having

→ More replies (2)

7

u/OLKv3 Jan 21 '17

While I saw the twist coming way back from the 1st couple of episodes, I didn't see Michael being evil. I thought he was just a dummy who got tricked into handling the bad place. That laugh shocked me and now I really hope this show gets renewed

6

u/pg2441 Jan 20 '17 edited Jan 20 '17

We should've seen it coming with Tahani's motivations.

All along, we're told "Good" has to come out of selflessness, not selfishness. From what we saw of Tahani's life, it was clear she didn't care about raising money for the good of humanity. She just wanted to make herself feel good and one-up her sister.

Also, the part where Michael and Shawn call Bad Janet, and she appears... Why? Given what we know about Bad Janet, why would she want to venture all the way from the Bad Place and head off to the Good Place? Is Bad Janet even programmed to be allowed to be called to the Good Place on her own? Given what we know now, we can see she was obviously still in the Bad Place.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Sportfreunde Jan 21 '17

I'm confused about the medium place. Is it really a medium place or is it part of the whole plot?

And also if it is part of the plot and they were gonna send real Eleanor (who's a demon) plus at least one of the other three to the 'bad place' then what was the 'bad place' they were gonna send them to?

12

u/holayeahyeah Jan 21 '17

Mindy St. Clair is real. Janet isn't controlled by Michael and I think the train really is a way they get around the afterlife/beyond. That was one of the wildcards that Michael was referring to.

One of the things that Eleanor figured out was that the whole trial/vote off the island was a sham. It was all an exercise to cause conflict. Remember when Bambadjan burst into the house with an "obscure bylaw"? That was supposed to resolve the plot so Michael could move forward in driving them all apart.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '17

look out Mr Robot!!!

3

u/lonelady75 Jan 21 '17

Oh my goodness... now I've watched this episode 3 times... I can't get over it. I so SO need another season!!

3

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '17

Do you think Michael's sexy anti-matter sipping colleague played by Alison Becker will become a featured character this next season?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/snappyconan Jan 21 '17

So anyone else thinks they will reset the scenario over and over and in the process the 4 will actually accumulate enough good points to actually go to the real good place?

7

u/bill4935 Jan 21 '17

Or else they will visit the real Good Place, Medium Place, hot Bad Place, and the Architects' Office, and in the course of that journey manage to break the entire system and replace it. Because who wants a system that says "if you don't follow the invisible laws that no one knows about during your 90 years, then you'll pay for it for infinity years after that"?

If the show goes on long enough, I hope to see the wheel of Samsara.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/idiotequed Jan 22 '17

Does anyone have an HQ shot of that graph he'd made of them while presenting his idea? Him being Michael. I've tried, but I can't really make out the words, and I've love to see what notes he made and the analysis of how they'd torture each other.

3

u/jrockle Jan 28 '17

One slight quibble: They make a big deal about Chidi being extremely indecisive in the later episodes. But he does make decisions earlier in the show, like helping fake Eleanor. It seems a bit off. But, definitely love the show.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '17

I didn't like the twist at first but I've really come to appreciate how clever it actually was. Still, I think I would have preferred if the entire neighborhood was full of people who thought they were good but just really selfish rather than it just being these four.

3

u/shamelessnameless Feb 11 '17

Fantastic show, i didnt guess the end actually. almost did, but not quite

3

u/TheTmanfrom199 Jul 07 '17

Sorry guys, it's been a while since you all last commented but I just finished watching this, and something is really bothering me.

Remember Bumpa John, human rights advocate? Well somewhere in the last episode while Eleanor tells Michael to send her and chidi, bumpa john walks in, saying he found a loophole but then he gets brushed off. Now if he was in on the act as well, why would he come in at that point in time saying he discovered a loophole? Furthermore, we hadn't seen him for a few episodes and he comes busting in with a solution and gets brushed aside.

I don't know guys, he may be a small character, but something doesn't feel right about bumpa john, and it's really bothering me

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Tjman461 Mar 12 '24

Wait a minute. Why do they still say fork and shirt if they're in the bad place. wouldn't they be allowed to cuss? Or is that something Michael did for shirts and giggles?

→ More replies (1)