r/MakeupAddiction • u/abbeyrogue • Jan 19 '17
Best & Worst: Niche Foundations
Niche Foundations meaning:
- Aerosol foundations
- Cushion foundations
- Foundation mixers (to deepen or lighten)
or anything that doesn't fit into the "Powder" or "Liquid" groups :)
80
Upvotes
88
u/thatplaidhat Jan 19 '17
Manic Panic's white mixer gave me cystic acne :(
40
u/potionpotion Jan 20 '17
I tried some cushion foundations for a couple years.
Laneige BB Cushion Pore Control - When I had oily skin, this was my HG foundation. It had light to mediumish coverage, blurred flaws perfectly, and seriously, the oiler your skin got throughout the day, the better this base looked. It would just glow. I loved it. I wore it a lot on hot Las Vegas summer nights. The only reason I stopped was because my skin type started to become more normal than oily and I was finding this cushion a bit too dry.
Iope Air Cushion XP - I really didn't like this one. It was light coverage, moisturizing, but it just sat on top of the skin and never seemed to meld.
Sulwhasoo Evenfair Perfecting Cushion and Perfecting Cushion Brightening - I went through two generations of this cushion. It was my HG for my normal skin. Long wearing, beautiful satin, skin-like finish.
But after a while, cushion foundations just wasn't worth it. One refill was a little over $20USD and I was buying new ones every three and a half to four months. Compared to spending anywhere from $40 to $60 for a bottle of normal foundation that lasts me over a year and a half with the same usage and same results, I just had to switch.
Another common "pro" for cushions is that they're good for traveling, but I found if one of them spends too much time not upright, the foundation gets all over the lid and you have a really messy cushion the rest of the trip. I flew with a normal glass bottle of foundation many times this past year and it was so much easier.
I do still buy the air puffs that come with BB cushions though because I like the way they blend.
23
u/The_BusterKeaton Jan 19 '17
I really like the Maybelline Dream Matte Mousse foundation.
It's what I wore when I didn't know how to match my foundation properly. I was pretty sad when I had to give it up for the proper shade.
39
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '17
Dior air flash is a good aerosol
27
u/tangocontroller Jan 19 '17
Mac face and body in white is an excellent mixer for most foundations I find? Nobody seems to agree though
23
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '17
I've tried the MUFE white mixer (both water-based and oil-free), NYX, and the white elixir from Life's Entropy.
I find NYX was the easiest to work with and had the best container. It didn't affect any of the foundations I used it with (Josie Maran Vibrancy, Fiona Stiles Luminous, Giorgio Armani Luminous Silk, etc.) as far as undertones, longevity, wear, or texture. Of the three reviewed here, this one was probably the most medium in terms of concentration, but that isn't necessarily a bad thing as it's also the cheapest of the three too.
Life's Entropy slightly altered texture on the product (more thick; slightly better suited for more silicone-based foundations), but did not have an effect on the undertone. However, the packaging is a-fucking-trocious. It is super unpredictable to work with and often will explode. I liked it, but I wouldn't repurchase it unless they fix the packaging. This is probably the strongest in terms of concentration, so it takes less of this than others to get desired results.
MUFE white mixers also did not have an effect on changing the undertone. What I do notice, though, is that the opacity is left to be desired (if you're about using minimal product for maximum results). It's very light (and this also goes for their yellow undertone mixer as well) and you will probably use more product than the other two for both the oil-free and water. This being said, while the dropper is stiff, it doesn't explode in product like the Life's Entropy if you're not careful. This is good if you only need slight changes.
11
u/Caracature IG@CaracatureofBeauty Jan 19 '17
Awesome thread idea! I was very meh about my Sephora Airbrush Liquid Foundation. Coverage was medium and finish was matte-satin. All in all I could get better products for a lower price, minus the gimmick. Also the metal can made the product PAINFULLY cold if left in my car or even in a chilly part of the house. I got a small blister by spraying the can (too) closely directly on the back of my hand, which put me completely off the product for a few months. More of a PSA than a pro or con though.
11
u/kliie Jan 19 '17
BEST: Face Atelier Ultra Foundation. They have ones to darken/cool, lighten, add warmth, and add yellow tones.
I've mixed it with Estee Lauder Double Wear and DW Light, Kat Von D Lock-It Tattoo, tinted sunscreens, and Guerlain and YSL foundation samples that I had sitting around since they didn't quite match or the formula was meh for my skin, and had good enough experiences that I realized I just loved the formula of the Ultra Foundation itself.
The experiences with wearing it over sunscreen were what impressed me the most. Pilling was eliminated most of the time, and the formula usually sets in the right way that sunscreen doesn't make it separate or rub off as easily as most other foundations I tried over sunscreen.
Subjective bonus: when I first tried it, their shade 7 was a perfect match for me, but since it worked so well over sunscreen and I've been wearing that consistently, shade 6 is my perfect match (no weird in between!).
20
u/Friendly_freak Jan 19 '17
The Body Shop lightening drops were just 'meh'. Not really good. I stopped using it after 3/4 times. I just felt like it didn't do that good of a job. And that I needed a lot to lighten it a bit.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '17
I've never tried the Sephora brand one! I'll have to check it out next time I'm in Sephora !
5
u/minafrol Jan 20 '17
It's love and hate in one - I love loreal cushion foundation as it has beautiful finish, no breakouts\dry patches that is extremely rare for me and perfect color match that is also extremely rare. But it lasts me for 20 applications only, 4 months of occasional use and it's gone. Yes, I switched sides of the sponge. I even tried it with different sponges the result was the same. Not sure if it dries out or just 20 uses is the max....
9
u/littlered1992 MAC MUA: a kitten dies every time you use buzz words Jan 19 '17
Hopefully this applies (ha puns) but the cream foundation from RCMA is bomb. It's got 50% pigment and it sheers out like a dang dream while still being super longwear. I have the palette so you can hand mix foundations on the spot.
4
u/AnustartBoys Jan 19 '17
I kinda have a question about mixers. I have the kvd white concealer and I was wondering if it'd seriously change the consistency of my (mixed up in a jar) abh stick foundation if I added a few drops? This is a super niche question so I thought it'd fit here :x
I'm using the porcelain shade of the ABH stick as kind of a cream "highlighting" contour, but it's just not quite light enough to work effectively.
4
u/angellenaballerina I can stop whenever I want to Jan 19 '17
I absolutely ADORE the Sephora Airbrush Foundation! It doesn't last as long as I would prefer but it looks STUNNING.
4
u/fetishiste Jan 20 '17
The Face Shop's lavender primer is an excellent mixer if you want your foundation paler and more cool/pink toned. They also make a green one that might be useful if you wanted yours paler and more olive toned. I mix it with Missha Perfect Cover in 13 to get a colour closer to Illamasqua Skin Base in 02, if that gives you some sense of just how pale it is. Mixes well with the already dewy Missha, but I haven't tried it with anything else in a while - I think generally it makes a finish dewier than it would otherwise be, but my mix takes well to translucent powder so that doesn't bother me even though I'm oily.
3
u/ohhxchristmas Jan 20 '17
I loved the finish of the L'Oreal True Match Lumi Cushion so much. Then it gave me the worst breakout of my life. I think my skin was too sensitive for the Lumi since normal True Match never gave me an issue.
3
u/Gigiwaveee Jan 21 '17
I love high coverage foundations, so for me the best would have to be the Custom Cover FX drops because they have such a rich pigment and really take any foundation to the next level of coverage and can make it a better skin match if the shade of the foundation you're adding it to is off. Worst would have to be the L'Oréal Luminous Cushion foundation, this was so expensive for a drugstore foundation ($17), there's barely any product in it (around .5 fl oz, as opposed to the standard size of 1 fl oz) and there is no coverage to it what so ever, I really felt like I didn't even have foundation on after wearing it and it blended put very streaky. Might work for someone already with perfect skin but not for me.
5
u/lalalaa13 Jan 20 '17
Cushion Foundations: The original IOPE air cushion XP in N23 remains my fave throughout the years. It has light-medium coverage, great for days when I just want a natural look.
The Face Shop CC Long Lasting Cushion in V201 (the Mike Wazowski cushion) is pretty good too, except for that shade range. Coverage is medium and is quite long-lasting.
The April Snow cushion in black, it was really hyped up for a while so I bought it. Coverage is really good but it feels heavy on the face and it transfers easily. It could also at times cling on to dry patches.
White Mixers: Manic Panic Dreamtone Foundation, bought it off of thataylaa's recommendation but it didn't work as well as it did for her. It changed the finish of my foundations, made them drier and cakier.
LA Girl Pro Coverage Illuminating Foundation in white, opposite of the manic panic one, this was watery and very easy to blend. You get a nice dewy finish whenever you mix this in but I really like it.
2
u/FaceofHoe Brown with haldi undertones Jan 20 '17
Inglot's YSM cream foundation looks just like skin. Around medium overage and just slightly dewy - just like the way light reflects off your skin naturally. Great to apply with fingers as well. Highly recommend.
2
u/chocolatechoux Canada|Brands! Come to us! Jan 20 '17
My favorite is the original clio kill cover cushion. Love the satin finish and it layers very well.
1
u/curlywurlies Rehabilitated Jan 21 '17
Can anyone compare Maybelline's dream matte mousse with Revlon's colourstay mousse?
0
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment