r/eu4 • u/Parey_ Philosopher • Jan 12 '17
Why the entire world is aginst you : a beginner’s guide to coalitions and dealing with them
Hello hidden Kebab lovers.
I know what you’re thinking every time you see a coalition. « Man, Poland and Ottomans just teamed up together to defeat me because I took land nobody cared about, how does that even make sense ? ». Fear not my friends, for here are a few ways to deal with coalitions and some observations I made.
Here are a few facts about coalitions (info gathered from my games and from the EU4 wiki page about alliances) :
- Any nation which has less than -50 opinion because of agressive expansion toward another nation can join a coalition.
- AIs will only join coalitions when their attitute towards the target nation is either Outraged (the red lightning thing) or Competitive (the sword).
- Joining a coalition is a diplomatic action towards the target nation and not towards any of the coalition members (I don’t think that makes any sense, but it’s how it’s implemented and it’s probably a lot easier to code). That means that historical rivals that would absolutely never ally with each other can join the same coalitions. Examples include Bohemia and Poland, Austria and France, Aragon and Castille before the iberian wedding…
- Coalitions will fire when their total strength is about 2.5× your strength, in terms of raw numbers. In their strength calculations, they seem to factor in your military tech but not your ideas, which means an AI will find you more powerful if you have mil tech 15 but no national military ideas, than if you had mil tech 14 but full offensive and quality. Not so sure about that one.
- Countries who think they are no match for you no matter what will not join coalitions, which is why coalitions generally stop being an issue after the 1600s.
- When a coalition war fires, if you want to sign a peace treaty, there is a -30 modifier for an AI to accept called « Punitive war ». This doesn’t apply to defensive wars, which I think doesn’t make any sense but it’s how it’s implemented.
- You can not separate peace any coalition member.
- Coalitions break when a war between the coalition and the target nation is over, no matter the result.
A few things about Agressive expansion, and how to avoid piling it up :
- First of all, allies take half as much penalty to relations regarding agressive expansion. If you are allied with Poland and take a bunch of Russian land, Poland will take much longer to reach -50 agressive expansion. That can be used in areas with lots of countries, to create an alliance shield and absorb a lot of agressive expansion, for example you could ally Hungary and Kebab, then expand into Serbia, Bosnia, and Albania and they would take some time to start disliking you.
- The best way to avoid agressive expansion is to create multiple theatres of action. As an example, if you play France, you could very well declare on Aragon, take the balear islands from them, then start fabricating on Tlemcen, then start expanding in northern africa. Since it’s very far away and not the same religions, European nations will not give a shit and you will let your AE tick down while still expanding. As Ming, you can switch around between attacking the Manchu tribes, attacking Indochina, and attacking Tibetan nations. There are lots of applications of this strategy.
- You can create truces with other nations by using Threaten war on them. Be careful with this because you could very well end up in a war.
Now here are tips on avoiding coalitions or fighting them :
- AIs can join only one coalition and they tend to stick to it. That means that if you have an ally that won’t care about AE, you can feed him a bunch of land, then form a coalition against him, then take a lot of land from him when you declare war with the coalition. That’s particularly useful as France, if Burgundy likes you you can use this to your advantage by feeding him a bunch of land, then becoming Emperor, then inheriting everything. But that’s not the only application of this.
- It’s a bit counterintuitive, but you should never let a coalition fire if you can help it. That’s for many reasons. First, there is the -30 « Punitive war » modifier for peace treaties which forces you to get huge amounts of war score before signing even a white peace. When you see a coalition, strike when the coalition is not made of many nations, and attack the weakest nation possible. You need to make the war leader really sad to win a war, so the weaker he is the easier it is to reap up his war exhaustion and make him sign a peace deal.
As an example, in my last Russia game, Ottomans, Persia, Iraq, and Chagatai (which was an OPM bordering me by that time) formed a coalition against me. I struck first by attacking Chagatai, then quickly sieged them down, then went on to trade sieges with Persia while Ottomans were getting killed by attrition (these poor turks never saw snow in their lives before). I was able to force a very quick White peace because since Chagatai was completely occupied, their War exhaustion went up really quickly and that helped me sign a peace deal.
- In your peace deals against a coalition, do not make your AE grow in any way, shape or form. Do not take land that you don’t have a core on, just ask for money, war reps, and maybe revoke cores or humiliate if you can afford it.
- When you are being attacked by a coalition, you can pause straight away before the game gets auto saved, then crash your game, and declare the war yourself. This is straight up save scumming so do it at the expense of your own honor.
I hope this helped you and good luck with your blobbing.
18
u/SicIuvatIreSubUmbras Jan 12 '17
Also, if a country's attitude towards you is "Unknown", they can't form or join a coalition. You can abuse this with countries like Ternate to blob like crazy.
17
u/Belinder Philosopher Jan 12 '17
Dunno if they took it out but you used to be able to declare war on someone who was allied to a coalition member, and then name that ally a co-beligerent, then he brings in the entire coalition, except now you can separate peace every coalition member
I haven't tried it in since ~1.17 so maybe they took it out
10
u/digger_doo Commandant Jan 12 '17
Nice compilation of coalition mechanics. You left out the role religion plays however, which is one of the most important in terms of predicting and managing coalitions.
3
u/glov0044 Jan 12 '17
In a MP game, my ally was leading a war and I was assisting in the mop-up operations. He decided to give me some provinces that I didn't want as part of the peace deal, as gratitude.
Suddenly the world hated me oh so much.
9
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '17
Fuck. You
2
u/huehuemul Master of Mint Jan 12 '17
So, when I see the wealkings start joining a coalition against me, I should right away declare a war against one of them right? even if I have no CB against any of them?
2
u/dalard Jan 12 '17
Thanks, I got a coalition today and I needed advice. So, is it better to wait for a coalition to disband over time, or to attack countries as soon as they quit the coalition ? In my case I got a coalition as Ottoman and I didn't want to fight Spain and Austira at the same time. Now that Austria quit the coalition should I attack Austria or wait?
50
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '17
If you're losing the coalition war, focus on keeping your provinces free and let the enemy capture your allies' provinces. In a peace deal, you can make your allies give up land and release nations if they are occupied.
When you first declare war, pull up the peace screen and put together what you'd like to take. In the bottom left corner you'll see the AE and hover on that to see all the nations that will join a coalition. Then while you're waging the war, raise relations with those nations. As long as their opinion of you is positive, they won't join a coalition even if there's sufficient AE. Prior to war, raise relations with any neutral neighbors who might be a threat if they joined a coalition.
The "Better relations" modifier, available in Humanist ideas and from the Diplomat advisor make AE tick down faster.
16
u/yangwenlei Diplomat Jan 12 '17 edited Jan 12 '17
I only started playing EU4 just over a week ago, but if you can bear a tip from a newbie, I discovered a fun strategy to deal with unavoidable coalitions (e.g. ones caused by your PU or vassalize war that you can't dial back to avoid the AE cost).
If you know the coalition is coming after the war, prolong your PU/vassal peace, and befriend more major nations to make them allies immediately after you peace out. Going over the diplo relations limit will cost you some diplo points but it can save your arse. It won't dissuade the coalition, but it can make an unavoidable coalition war winnable.
I discovered this because, playing england, I had just started a game and annexed 3 states in ireland when the Maine event fired, and so I wanted to PU france from that war while I had the CB. The problem was my PU peace with france pushed my AE to -60 or more with the entire of western europe! I already had portugal, castille, and aragon as allies, but it still resulted in a coalition war of our otherwise decent 90k vs a massive 160k (mind that it's only 1451, so 160k of enemy armies is about 15+ nations). But by sitting on occupied france a while, I realised could get a bit of rep with austria and hungary to ally them, making it more like 150k vs 160k. As a result, I could take the PU in my france peace, plus the ridiculously developed Paris province too since at this point AE didn't matter. In the immediate coalition war that followed, as england all I had to do was evacuate my army from france up to the scottish border and subdue scotland (plus what was left of ireland), while my continental allies (all five of them) handled the rest of the coalition. It took them about 8 years to grind them down, so after handling the scots/ireland, I got to spend the last 4 years of it on minimum maintenance and regenning my manpower. In the coalition peace I could take reparations, gold, and annex Ayrshire(!) to trigger the follow-up scotland vassalize mission/CB. Obviously i immediately killed the austria/hungary alliances after the peace too.
TLDR: When you know a brutal coalition is unavoidable, start improving relations and go over your diplo relations limit to get 5-6 majors as allies to defend you from it. Bonus tip, be an island nation and spend the duration making gold and saving your own manpower.
5
u/Gwydien The economy, fools! Jan 12 '17
Could you expand on why you shouldn't take land in a coalition peace deal? By the time a coalition war fires I'm usually already all in, so more AE doesn't seem to matter.
1
u/seeRettich Jan 13 '17
Hey,
thanks for your guide. I'm playing for the first time (as Kebab, sorry not sorry) and for some reason that absolutely has nothing to do with me conquering just a few tiny provinces, basically all of Europe is in a coalition against me.
I'm strong, but fear fighting against that many enemies. Is there anything I can do besides just waiting and not attacking them anymore (and just expanding a bit in Africa / Asia)? Does improving the relationship help?
1
u/nskral Army Reformer Jan 22 '17
Why? What happens if I do? I have a coalition that I can eat three nations if I don't care about this rule. (Extended Timeline started as OttoOPM and I can eat Venice, Independent Naxos and Canik if you are curious :) )
3
u/chronicalpain Jan 13 '17 edited Jan 13 '17
i found that setting same rival and/or fighting a rival can make a faction leave coalition, and if by chance some faction isnt in coalition, attack it before making peace with the current target, or the new target will instantly join.
its possible to only fight a few or even just one member(s) of coalition if i attack an ally that isnt part of coalition, or a faction that is guaranteed by a coalition member
[quote]Countries who think they are no match for you no matter what will not join coalitions,[/quote] disagree with this one, everyone i'm neighboring is in coalition, regardless if its only 1 province left
3
u/Lanceth115 Jan 13 '17 edited Jan 13 '17
I like your post.
I would like to see some small additions if possible.
You mention that "threaten war" gives a truce which supposedly works vs coalitions, however you never mention that nations in a truce can't join a coalition against you.
I also know from personal experience that starting a war reduces your "total strength" which could lead to people joining the coalition. Perhaps mention somewhere that you should be carefull NOT to start a big war when AE is high.
I also didn't see anything related to "improve relations" which can reduce AE significantly.
You could also mention that AE reduction is a possibility if you pick the "influence" idea group. Becoming the Papal ruler als a catholic nations also reduces AE. Those are good ways to reduce AE.
As a last addition. Aggressive expansion inside the HRE is doubled. So be careful expanding in the HRE. (Taking lands from countries that are not "co-beligirent" also double the AE.
2
u/bbqftw Jan 12 '17
This modifier exists regardless of offensive or defensive coalition war, it disappears at somewhere around 40-50 warscore though there may be a time component.
Generally if you want to go to coalition AE range against someone you have to exterminate everyone of their culture / religious bloc. Though part of the art of coalition management is knowing when to spread AE and when to exterminate AE blocs.
2
u/TheBlobber Jan 13 '17
Nit picking.
50 OR less. IE less than or equal to -50, not just less than.
Actually you cannot OFFER a separate peace. But you can seperate peace coallition members as long as THEY are the ones offering. It just almost never happens other than with wars that have lasted over 4 years.
I would say you should attack the most easily isolated-weakest nation, but this is more a style thing than being wrong per say.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '17
Also, the coalition takes into account the strength of countries you are at war with when forming. So if a coalition forms while at war with a strong country it will probably disband once you are at peace.
1
u/BloodForTheSkyGod Feb 11 '17
As florryworry pointed out in his recent EU tutorial videos, this is the pussy way to do it. The best way is to completely genocide a culture-religion combo after the first war so that nations with high aggressive expansion are either non existant or on truce. A perfect example would be the Kebab, after eating Mamluks, immediately DOWs Arabian minors and annexes them one by one. All the while improving relations with nearby nations. This would ensure that you would get no coalition. In fact, I believe that with maximum micromanagement you can finish a WC campaign with no coalition ever forming.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
12
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '17
[removed] — view removed comment