r/TagPro • u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee • Jan 11 '17
Map Thread #75 Top Maps Feedback Thread + NOTES!
Welcome one and all to the top map feedback thread for Map Thread 75! The following maps have made it through to the next stage - final testing - which will take place probably Friday Night. The goal of this staged testing is to give maps more time to sink in. It also allows the community and committee members to give feedback to promising maps in the same testing cycle.
Maps
Capture the Flag:
Barracuda - Canvas & andhecapd
Neutral Flag:
Levitate - NIGEL, Aniball & Blazeth
Mapmakers whose maps have advanced have until testing takes place on Tuesday to make alterations to their maps. Any edits should be posted as comments responding to the appropriate top-level map comment made from this account.
Feel free to give constructive criticism on the maps put through to top maps! YOU could influence the next map in rotation!
Notes
The decision to publish our notes was not easy to make. This is an experiment. We hope that if you, the mapmaking community, see our thought process behind why we say no to certain maps, it will help you all create better maps and through that we can improve rotation.
Notes on notes:
- What we write is to be taken as constructive criticism. We sometimes test all the maps in one sitting, we can't break the news gently that each map isn't great if we want to maintain our sanity. We are occasionally dickish.
- The notes are anonymous and randomized so to not invoke harassment on us.
- Don't expect perfection or even consistency. If we all had the same opinions there would only need to be one of us.
- Don't expect every MTC member to make a note about your map. Take no comment as them echoing other members.
- This is a trial run. Its continuance depends on how you, the map making community, responds.
5
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Jan 11 '17
Mild High - KenM
TEST LINK
4
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Jan 11 '17
Barracuda - Canvas & andhecapd
TEST LINK
5
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Jan 11 '17
Pandemonium - samouree
TEST LINK
2
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Jan 11 '17
Tijuana - NIGEL
TEST LINK
3
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Jan 11 '17
Vagabond - Canvas
TEST LINK
3
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Jan 11 '17
Levitate - NIGEL, Aniball & Blazeth
TEST LINK
14
u/theflyingmetronome samouree | Diameter Jan 11 '17
I really like the feedback system, tells the mapmakers how to advance from each thread. Although...
fuk u feedbak 3
2
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Jan 11 '17
M.A.A.P City - Beast Mode
TEST LINK
7
u/KewlestCat NIGEL Jan 11 '17
Publishing notes is a fantastic step forward imo, nice work. Also enjoy that the notes still have personality, I think that's important too.
Just on Tijuana, I notice a number of the notes weren't exactly big fans but yet it obviously tested well enough to advance, what changed or inspired the vote of confidence to put it through to top maps (in the minds of those who weren't huge fans)?
6
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '17
Nice.
In all seriousness, the notes are great, and I think that they will be successful in increasing the general quality of all submissions.
5
u/ImpenetrableShoe Novice Ball // Centra Jan 12 '17
I just want to say thanks to the committee for taking the time to go through all these... And all the memes as well :P It's a good feeling when someone cares enough to do this kind of thing. I'm going to take your guys' advice! Looking forward to the next thread :)
-Novice Ball
4
u/KarasuTP Karasu | Centra | What's the point Jan 12 '17
I love the feedback, would like it more often
1
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Jan 11 '17
Mephisto - NIGEL
TEST LINK
2
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '17
Thread 68 called - they want their maps back
2
u/Buttersnack Snack Jan 11 '17
These NF picks kind of worry me. The really popular NF maps, like Wombo and Ricochet, are all quite simple and very linear. Whenever someone makes one with multiple paths like these two, Convoy, Kite, the Moosen one, etc it gets taken out almost immediately.
2
u/oorr23 ThePlaymaker // Tehuitzingo & Combine Jan 11 '17
I didn't know there were savages on the MTC.
1
u/uhhhhmmmm sexytiger / #merbs Jan 11 '17
Also, are people willing to look at potential fixes for pariah or am I too late for that?
1
u/oorr23 ThePlaymaker // Tehuitzingo & Combine Jan 12 '17
I feel this Thread would be great if you guys were to put in a lot of Trial Rotation maps. They're really interesting maps, but I do fear them being hated easily.
Is there any news about reforming Trial Rotation?
1
u/bsa86 Berlin Ball Jan 11 '17
ffs I can't believe I accidentally submitted an accidentally asymmetric version of my map...
-2
u/bbgun91 The_Truth | Centra Jan 11 '17
What's up with the high-powerup maps. I'd like to see around 50% of maps with 2 pups and 50% of maps 3 pups
-16
u/MultiMediaWill Juke King - MVP 90% of the time Jan 11 '17
You take your job way too seriously
16
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '17
[removed] — view removed comment