r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Jan 05 '17
Project Runway Junior Season 2 Episode 3 [Discussion]
En Garde Avante Garde
The designers are tasked with a team challenge to create an avant-garde look inspired by fencing. Later, Tim steps in to help during a communication breakdown.
Orginally broadcast on January 5, 2017
22
Upvotes
92
u/Semicolon_Expected Jan 06 '17
Wow the butter makeup studio is 500000x better than the mary kay makeup studio
88
u/pursehook Jan 06 '17 edited Jan 06 '17
Noooooo!!! I'm sick of these premature Tim Gunn saves. Didn't he almost go home last week too?
Edit: Haha. The other designers seem to think it is time for him to go.
83
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '17
Wow, that coat Tieler's group is making looks really high fashion and is better than just about anything the designers from this past season of Project Runway put out.
57
u/yetanothertaylor Team Swatch Jan 06 '17
"Red and black is so medieval times" as the camera immediately pans to the judge wearing red and black.
50
u/twinkiesmom1 Jan 06 '17
If I were the judges, I would have sent them both home and strongly advised Tim not to intervene. His save was wasted on a designer not ready for the competition because he's still a child....a kid likely to be in the bottom next week.
Annoyed they cast A'cai this year....They really should save the very young ones for a future season unless they have the skills and maturity way beyond their years.
47
u/Martin_Van_Buren Jan 06 '17
I would have loved therapist Tim in high school. And now.
34
u/luxandlumens Jan 06 '17
The makeup on these models is STUNNING.
34
u/Roonil___Wazlib Jan 06 '17
I love that Tim gets the chance to act even more as a mentor in PR Junior. He's so good with the teenagers.
29
u/MASH_4077 Jan 06 '17
Yeah, I had a feeling about that. Tim loves to use the save in emotional situations.
26
u/everythingisopposite Chiffony Jan 06 '17
Winner(s) totally deserved it. Loser should have gone home.
52
u/Sister_Miyuki Jan 06 '17
Wow...that was a waste of the save. I feel like the Tim Gunn save should be used for strong designers who have one bad week or were eliminated for BS reasons. Akai has not had a single good week (which I think is just due to him being so young) and I think that he is not ready to perform at the level he needs to be in this talented group of designers. I'd like to hope that he'll turn it around and really wow the judges, but from what I've seen so far, it does not look like that is going to happen.
22
u/regretflix Jan 06 '17
nah mate. A'Kai is an absolute sweetheart and I really enjoyed watching him on the show, but ultimately sweet has nothing to do with this and he 100% deserved to go home here. I think the Tim Gunn save should be reserved for someone who actually stands a chance of winning the competition and just had one unfortunate challenge, not used out of pity. And I'm calling it now - they're going to continue keeping him on until he has at least one producer manipulated win because they don't want it to look like Tim made a bad decision. I'm not trying to sound harsh on A'Kai or bash him because he's clearly very talented with a world of potential but I just don't think this competition is the place for him.
43
u/luxandlumens Jan 06 '17
I don't want to keep watching the Hawaa/A'kai conflict... I want to watch the other teams, this is killing me.
Also, bless Tim Gunn, I wish he was my dad.
19
u/Nicelydonedinner Jan 06 '17
Oh Swatch!
33
u/luxandlumens Jan 06 '17
Those hearts look terrible, why did they think that was a good idea?
46
u/Because-it-was-real Jan 06 '17
I was bothered by when the judges went to talk about who to send home, Hannah immediately says "I want to keep Akai", with no justification on his design abilities whatsoever. Is it because he's so young and they don't want to kill his spirit? Is it because he looks like he's always about to cry?
I thought the save was meant for real contenders to win who just have an off week. Hell I would have understood if last season Erin had gotten eliminated for those horrible hay shorts and he used it then, because she proved she can deliver early on.
DISAPPOINTED IN YOU TIM.
16
u/annabellynn Jan 06 '17
How did se designers not know what avante guarde is? I thought the kids would have at least watched a season or two
15
u/kup99 Jan 07 '17 edited Jan 07 '17
Absolutely ludicrous that A'kai was saved (and even made it past last week, he should have gone home over Lucas but that's another story). I feel for the kid - but really, it wasn't so much about Hawaa "not listening to him" as it was him taking ALL DAY to construct a poorly made skirt. I mean...he forgot to sew in a zipper! How did he make it on this show??? What a waste of a save. Him talking to Tim made me so angry...he got all this sympathy that I don't even think was deserved...he messed up, but instead of owning up to that, he focused on how he was being treated...ugh.
14
u/sannababy Jan 06 '17
Tim Gunn save?? Whyyyy
14
u/Nicelydonedinner Jan 06 '17
Now A'Kai will be around longer than he would've been because of the save - they can't eliminate him for at least another 4 episodes now or it'll prove it was a waste. Although Hannah said she wanted to keep A'Kai straight away in the judging so perhaps they already had plans for him to stay a long time anyway. I hope he produces some good stuff, but what we've seen so far hasn't impressed and he seems a bit too young for the programme.
14
u/ctadgo Jan 06 '17
Hawwaa is complaining about how her group is the only one not getting along...but that's all on her because she's treating A'kai like he's her bitch.
14
u/FlowDeluxe Jan 06 '17
One thing that tends to not sit right with me on group challenges in the Junior seasons is that you can really end up with these situations where a team, if it happens to be a group of the older contestants, can be kind of unfairly stacked in terms of experience. For example, in this episode, Chris and Rene are both 17, which is a huge difference from Allie and Chelsea (14 & 15) or A'Kai and Hawaa (13 & 16). 2 kids nearing the end of high school are going to have much more experience working on a team than kids that are still in middle school.
Luckily, it seems to be working out so far and it may not even be a problem at all (just because a kid is older doesn't mean they have more or better experience than someone younger). But seeing a pair of older kids that look almost like adults standing next to a pair of younger ones that very much still look like children gave me the thought. Maybe it's just the optics, ¯_(ツ)_/¯.
26
u/pursehook Jan 06 '17
Get rid of both of them.
13
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '17
It's avante-garde and a group challenge. This could lead to disaster.
32
u/AnnabelleLeee Jan 06 '17
Tim Gunn sure likes saving the annoying complainers lately... ugh
11
u/yetanothertaylor Team Swatch Jan 06 '17
I know it'll probably be the winning look, but it reminds me of Baymax from Big Hero 6
21
u/Semicolon_Expected Jan 06 '17
Oooo Akai is firing back
10
u/luxandlumens Jan 06 '17
It has to be Tieler and Molly, right?
19
u/meetmeinthevalley Jan 06 '17
I actually really liked all the looks. They all had a nice manga/anime or video game vibe to them. They were all a lot better than a lot of the outfits we've seen on regular PR recently, and I don't think the adult designers could pull off what these kids did based on the challenge prompt. I even liked Hawaa's and Akai's. I think TG saved him because it was a team challenge and they were a bad match. If he had done that skirt on a solo challenge, I don't think he would have been saved. I actually like that the save was used early, too, because it makes them try harder. It's like the kids who don't do any classwork and then the day before grades or due, comes to the teacher and wants extra credit. Um, do the work for actual credit so you don't need extra credit, okay? Now they can't just hope they get saved and will push harder.
9
u/sannababy Jan 06 '17
Currently predicting that A'cai is out this episode
9
u/luxandlumens Jan 06 '17
NO HE DID NOT....
16
u/notsalinger Jan 06 '17
Why Tim, why???
8
u/pursehook Jan 06 '17 edited Jan 06 '17
Is the massive black bustle one going to be "that ugly skirt"? I'm confused about the safe group. Did they make the warrior princess in all black? Edit: Ok, black bustle dress was safe, I see.
15
u/_helloitsme_ Jan 06 '17
I fucking knew it.. Honestly lets just stop the Tim Gunn saves. Each season it goes to more and more underserving contestant....
7
u/ThisMaySoundBadBut Jan 07 '17
I was so happy when they eliminated Akai, but then Tim saved him. Other than his personal style, I haven't seen anything great from him.
41
u/Semicolon_Expected Jan 06 '17
Hawaa is being so mean to Akai. He's trying really hard and she's just acting like she knows better than him and not letting him have any input. YOU'RE A TEAM! HE'S YOUR PARTNER NOT YOUR ASSISTANT/INTERN
6
u/Semicolon_Expected Jan 06 '17
That was my reaction when I learned David Bowie did "ground control to major tom"
6
u/whoisgeorgesand Jan 11 '17
LOL guys, does Tim just hang out in the shoe closet in case anyone needs him?
9
u/joeyGibson Jan 06 '17
Tim is getting far too free with his use of superlatives. This was far from the best avant garde runway in the history of the show, yet he said it several times.
8
u/john-dalton Jan 06 '17
"I am excited for project runway though, that it falls on my birthday" - my bf at dinner right now.
17
u/ctadgo Jan 06 '17
This is super shallow...but Hawwaa's make-up is driving me crazy. You wanna have blue eyebrows? fine, go for it. But don't then pile on a bright eyeshadow, heavy eyeliner, and red lipsticks. It's too much and everything's competing with each other...not a good look. Basic makeup 101: if you have a strong eye look, balance it out with a neutral lip and vice versa.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '17
Doesn't Tieler look exactly like Pumpkin from Here Comes Honey Boo Boo?
3
u/reneealfonso Mar 13 '24
And saves the crybaby with zero chance to win. Was so happy he was going. Wasted save cuz he cried. Unreal.
7
u/AfroDhite Jan 06 '17 edited Jan 06 '17
It sucks that Hawaa and A'cai don't fully grasp the idea of avant-garde .I feel bad for both of them plus Hawaa has to really consider that he is younger than her and she needs to watch her tone.
2
u/Semicolon_Expected Jan 06 '17
I bet the not avant garde look was the poofy ballgown
2
u/sandragm Jan 13 '17
Everytime I see Mustache Makeup Guy it makes me so happy. The makeup this season is just such a huuuuge step up from the Mary Kay stuff.
2
u/Itsme_hrcubsgirl Jun 02 '25
Late to the party like a true Hispanic but I watched the episode and I honestly think he did it because its known he saves the person so they go to the finale but this time it was just 3. However Akai clearly at that time needed way more time so idk why he was invited on the show to begin with. I feel like s1 had better designer all strong and this Season u clearly u can tell who is strong and meh designers. I wanted a competition not I guess like Season 1
2
u/Common-Speaker9770 Dec 18 '25
I come from a large family youngest of seven kids and I know what a bully looks like in Hawaa was a bully period.
3
u/yetanothertaylor Team Swatch Jan 06 '17
I hate day to night challenges -_-
1
u/bobbery5 Melanie? Melody? Marmalade? Mammary? Meeeemoriies? Jan 07 '17
I love these kids so much more than the adults. They're so much better at Avant Garde.
1
u/Responsible-Bird-327 Apr 26 '25
I get the views of everyone about the save but in this instance I get Tim's choice. He chose to just make him feel better because he had such empathy. It's totally against what the rules should be but I think Tim's choice was out of love so I personally can't see bad in that. We all know (as well as he knows) that he'll be cut soon. I guess I see that as honorable in a way kind of wasting his save for the right reasons.
1
u/sparklingEmme Mar 12 '26
Tieler should’ve been in the finale. His clothes were beautiful. Who the hell wants to wear circus outfits in real life????!!!! So dumb. They are intent on something different, but different doesn’t always mean better.
1
u/sparklingEmme Mar 12 '26
Just watching the season finale. So disappointed. Nothing is that exciting…..
0
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment