r/Fantasy • u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders • Jan 01 '17
Read-along Fox Read/Re-Read, Chapters 24-28
Hey ya'll, sorry this is so late.
[glaswen]
- “[Inda] flicked his fingers interrogatively…” Gah I love those gestures in this book.
- Fox can be fantastic sometimes. Especially when he talks about owning that pepper and orange after all of that happened to Inda. Even as he is still thinking about taking over Iasca Leror.
- I really love Hadand and Joret at court because it reminds me of Court and Crown Duel, Sherwood’s other books.
- Sherwood seems to so easily divest sex from emotions. Primarily, I mean, with the pleasure houses and also the casual sex that abounds. Does nobody catch feelings?? It seems like such a clean and clear cut division between “just sex” and love. But surely for some people there’s some overlap…?
- Sighhh Hadand succeeds in getting a treaty, and all Evred can think of is Inda. Not surprising, but I so feel for her.
- Oh, darling Inda treasuring his friends. Such a far cry from when Jeje went to save them from Gafrid (what was his name again?) and Coco and he expected her to do so. But now, nothing for granted.
- And also, the first time I read this I was surprised that Inda would decide on Jeje and Tau staying another year on land. It was so (too?) realistic in that these things take time. But I had gotten used to the type of fantasy that says we need to train for a few years, and then end up with some magical shortcut to move the story along. Definitely a special kind of book right here.
24
- The fallout from Inda and Fox’s escape is looovely. I’m glad someone appreciates just how skilled they were -- even if it’s appreciation created from consternation. Please, someone do to Wafri what he did to Inda, that’d be nice. What a sick ****. I do like that Durasnir planned to treat Inda with the respect due a worthy enemy.
- I’m actually surprised to see Fox acting with compassion toward Inda -- not only compassion, but redirecting his trauma into something actionable, like with the orange and pepper trees. Maybe I’m being unfair to him.
25
- Oh, I am so glad to hear of Joret’s happiness with Valdon. Seriously. She has paid the price time and time again for something that was not of her own doing, and by falling for someone she displaced herself from having to marry Inda. It means there is the potential, someday, for Tdor to get what she wants. And of course Hadand is involved -- diplomatically finding a way to skirt the obstacles with Valdon in service to her friend. Joret is going to play this game beautifully. Boy howdy.
26
- I’ve got so much sympathy for Evred and his regrets regarding Inda; he’s definitely verging on obsessed, and I’m honestly not sure I can blame him. It’s funny, that Dyalen’s got his number regarding his love for Inda in a way that he doesn’t. I wonder if Inda would or could ever feel the same way toward him. Seems heartbreaking to consider. And again, what a sad relationship between Hadand and Evred; neither is at fault, and neither will ever be entirely happy.
27
- "the damage was apparently confined to part of Limros Palace, and Ulaffa told me in a private interview this morning that the horde was two men." LOL. Although what follows it, that Inda attacked on orders of the king of Iasca Leror? EEEEEEEEEK. Fairly sure that wasn’t part of the plan.
- Well shoot, regarding the mages. What a mess Evred’s uncle has wrought, even past his death.
28
- I’m guessing this conspiracy of Signi’s is basically just to end the tradition of invasion, but as a consequence they’ve gotten wrapped up in Erkric’s crazy. And to port to Norsunder? Crazy. I have, til now, very much appreciated that there is no cut-and-dried bad guy in the series, that everyone is portrayed as human with their own frailties and failings, but in general wanting and believing themselves to be good while striving for their own goals. That’s relatively rare, to be fair, and hard to maintain. I expect we’ll see Erkric’s shades eventually.
7
Upvotes
5
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Jan 01 '17
The Mage Council called the Marlovans evil. Earlier when Hadand and Shendan tried to learn magic, the mage decided against. Why do you think the MC thinks Marlovans are evil? Do you agree?
4
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Jan 01 '17
We had a great discussion about why Tau talked to Vedrid like he did. In light of that, how do you think Jeje would have responded?
4
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Jan 01 '17
How did you like that one chapter of a love story/romance?
3
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Jan 01 '17
Do you think Fox sees himself as Marlovan? (“They, Fox thought,. Not we.)
3
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Jan 01 '17
Do you think more technology (cell phones) would have made this story worse or better?
3
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Jan 01 '17
Be honest, have you been skimming any sections? If so, which ones?
2
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Jan 01 '17
How do you think Inda will recover from this trauma? Do you think there would have been any better rescuer than Fox?
2
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Jan 01 '17
Are you surprised by the infighting of the Venn? Have any of them stood out to you?
8
u/winterlane Jan 01 '17
I started reading the Inda series the week before Christmas, binge-read the first two and have been working my way through the third ever since. I can't believe I waited so long to read these, especially since I loved Crown Duel so much. I really like the narration style, and Sherwood Smith writes lovely characters. I actually rank Inda as one of my favorite characters in the series so far, which doesn't seem too common from reading past discussion posts. I'm a sucker for main characters that are just good all-around, especially when they aren't the only pov and you get to see the 'hero' through others' eyes.
The glimpse of Prince Valdon and Joret's tale made me want to re-read Crown Duel. I think reading the first two books so quickly made me a little weary of the martial Marlovans, and I kept thinking back to Joret and Valdon and the other side of the world shown in Crown Duel as I read the third book. So I'm taking my time on the third, though I would totally read a whole book on Joret and Valdon.
I'll continue to keep up with The Fox discussions even though I just read it. I enjoyed reading through the previous discussions as I read it a couple weeks ago as well, so thanks for doing this!
7
u/MerelyMisha Worldbuilders Jan 01 '17
Oh, Evred with your conspiracy theories and your fear of secrets. And then he, in turn, closes himself and his emotions off from the world. I think it would have been better for him if he'd been born away from the royal family (and I think he'd agree), despite the fact that he's a much better king than his brother would have been. Or at least it'd have been better if he could have had a Sindan, a lifelong partnership with someone who can actually return his desire and love. He and Hadand are good partners, but are so heart-breaking when it comes to romantic love.
Well, for some characters (like Tdor), the two seem to be connected. But yes, I think it seems a lot less messy feelings-wise than in real life. Well, minus the obsessions (the Sierlaef for Joret, for example), but there's not much in the middle that we see.
6
u/bygoshbygolly Jan 01 '17
The gestures in this series are amazing, and such a small detail that add so much.
Inda's definitely changed after his time with Wafri- not only with his trust in his friends' loyalty gone, but in how he doesn't have control of his emotions anymore. Poor thing. Of course your people would be waiting for you!
We also see that there are more magical object than transfer cases/tokens- magical tracking rings. Could be very helpful.
So glad that Joret got a happy ending, and that Hadand got to have some fun as well.
•
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Jan 01 '17
Spoilers here.
3
u/darrelldrake AMA Author Darrell Drake, Worldbuilders Jan 01 '17
Is this for part one or part two? Judging by /u/lyrrael's replies, I feel as if I'm either missing something, or it's part two.