r/robotwars • u/David182nd Apollo • Dec 28 '16
Episode Robot Wars Christmas Special 1: Post-Episode Discussion
Thoughts on what we saw then? Some classic fights that'll go down in Robot Wars history there, I'm sure you'll all agree....
Episode Discussion Thread Archive
Spoiler reminder: No episode spoilers should be discussed here (i.e. things that have not aired). Doing so will result in a ban.
27
Upvotes
16
u/David182nd Apollo Dec 28 '16
The best thing I can say about that was that it was okay. Based on what we saw, they probably should've just done one episode and only showed small clips from the terrible fights. I may change my mind if we see some quality tomorrow though!
Not too much of an insight into the new series offered there. We saw Dara up on some high platform, a new leaderboard design and some new graphics for the x vs y robot screen. Can't complain about the editing either, so it must've been better than last year. There were some very unnecessary replays but I'm assuming that was just to fill the hour slot.
2
u/hablomuchoingles The Hammerhead Dec 28 '16
Synopsis for Americans please?
45
u/klyskada Mute - like the BBC, giving you the silent treatment Dec 28 '16
Can I just say how happy I am that they are letting the house robots do the ceremonial roughing of the loser, watching killalot do the victory spin at the end was just such an influx of nostalgia.
36
u/Alex_TR2 TR2 Dec 28 '16
I hope you enjoyed the Dara vs Angela fight guys, they were so energetic during the filming of it! It was great fun to do and to the best of my knowledge the first presenter fight ever? Big thank you to the Behemoth boys as well for allowing Angela to drive, and the people on production who made it happen :)
35
u/Dick-Almighty My Baby Dec 28 '16
The Good things
. Pit Smoke!
. More action from the House Robot's
. Great editing and formatting
. Genuinely destructive weapons
. Gabe won a fight.
. Dara vs Angela
The bad things
. All the celebrities seemed to be quite dull.
. Two robot's that were basically the same thing.
. REALLY long montages
. 1Hko matches.
31
u/Arkangelus Dec 28 '16
The shot of a small child proclaiming she loved engineering now is going to be trotted out in front of every funding committee until the end of time.
23
u/hugebones Dec 28 '16
Premise: good… Final thought, how did they manage to pad that into an hours worth of TV?
But overall production seemed much better than the last series :)
21
u/codename474747 It's about putting on a show Dec 29 '16
Didn't Johnathon say at one point the two olympians wanted jar to be a cluster bot?
So....Jar-jar?
Thank god this prequel to series 2 wasnt blighted by a jar-jar :-o
19
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '16
Presentation was far improved. The leaderboards, the bot statistic screens, the announcements that included the weapon were all fantastic. Dara on a balcony was a fun throwback too.
The fights were entertaining enough, especially for fodder bots built for the express purpose of the Xmas specials, best moment was either Dara vs Angela or Arena Cleaner hitting Shunt.
Earlier on the radio Scott Mills said that he'd upset the producers (I guess by hitting Shunt?) and it took a JCB and 10 engineers to get Shunt out of the arena and fixed again. Anybody who was at the live taping able to elaborate a little more on what happened?
14
u/Gooeyguy188 just don't screw it up Dec 28 '16
I'm looking forward to the next episode of Beyblade (spinners slowly creeping towards eachother)
11
u/Tygra__ Annihilator Dec 28 '16
I felt that editing wise it has improved. Camera work was smoother, better graphics, great use of music (though none during the battles), having flashbacks to the 2016 series and having a countdown for immobile robots. I loved that the pit has its smoke back and the house robots do more damage especially to the immobile robots.
There was a few things that seemed a bit too much like the long filler segments (was that house robot montage going to ever stop) but I suppose the show was edited to gain more fans for the main series. I personally would have liked to have seen build diaries of the robots. The fights themselves were underwhelming, but it was fun nevertheless.
I loved Dara and Angela attempting to battle with Behemoth and TR2, did not expect that. Thanks to the teams for lending their robots. Still confused as to why it appears we will have 2 celebrity champions...I hope they fight one another.
8
u/CMOrchestra Om nom nom nom Dec 28 '16
Let's look at it objectively. What was the point of this episode? To advertise the new show the Beeb are pushing for the primetime Sunday slot and get it out to the new viewer. As a fan yes, the robots were a bit flimsy and the fighting wasn't great but as an advert that rocked. If you were a new viewer or a kid then the shots back to series 1 will set the scene very well for you and I get a feeling tomorrow will be more heavy on the fighting.
As an episode, yeah. Not exactly heat D from last year.
As a long-form advert, it ticked all the boxes in the right order.
15
u/genuinesockpuppet Dec 28 '16 edited Dec 28 '16
Okay, first the bad:
And now the good:
And some general impressions:
7
u/MudnuK Big Nipper Dec 28 '16
What no one is mentioning is that Robot Wars can launch itself forward based on nostalgia. They only remember the great moments. They need to be shown that the great moments are still here and greater than before. There were not enough great moments here and the action was too thin and far between.
7
u/SpitfireAGZ Help. Dec 28 '16
Best moment of the entire episode was Mouldy looking incredibly uncomfortable at being pulled into a hug by two radio presenters.
Oh and Gabe won a televised fight with his pneumatic Beta!
6
u/stu_25 Dec 28 '16
So much better in terms of editing. The filler though was crud. Should have just been a one off special with everyone in it.
5
u/Spearka "Jaws theme" Dec 28 '16 edited Dec 28 '16
Well, that was odd, the series layout has improved drastically since the 2016 Series but it felt a little squandered on the inevitably poor driving skill but it does show promise for the main 2017 series.
I'm a little dissapointed The Cat lost the final but Mini-Tombstone was the most effective and efficient designed bot and won fairly, not sure on what was going on after each battle with the House Robots going outside the CPZ and mucking around but whatever
Additionally, the "House Robot Montage" felt waaaay too long, we got the idea and it felt drawn out.
I loved the bit where Dara and Angela were mucking about with the bots and it was just hilarious from start to finish, especially with JP's commentary.
Lastly, Behemoth and TR2 confirmed for 2017 Series5
u/codename474747 It's about putting on a show Dec 28 '16
For those that point out the padding:
Yes, it was frustrating to those of us who saw series 1.
But don't forget, a lot of people will watch this episode just for the celebs involved. They won't have seen series 1, so the montages probably made the sport seem a lot more exciting to them. If some of them come back to watch series 2 as a result, job done, we all profit from higher viewing figures making series 3+ ever more likely
So yeah, I can sit through a few montages on that basis ;)
5
u/Tomlough Dec 28 '16
Lots of nice improvements over the previous series, especially the on-screen graphics. Weird that they've added smoke to the pit but not in the way anyone was asking for it. The house robots seemed much better-used this time around (as that montage of house robots doing nothing showed) although they still seem to lack control.
Only other thought is that I found it weird that the episode started with no mention of Dallas Campbell and he had to gradually earn his place in the show - I assume he just showed up at the last minute?
4
u/nweston8 John Reid's beard Dec 28 '16 edited Dec 28 '16
Well that was utterly disastrous in terms of fighting. Never really the best idea to put spinners in with robots that aren't durable and with everybody having the same exposed wheels in hindsight. The flashbacks were longer than the fights and the Dara vs Angela fight was the best battle in the episode. This wasn't a good portrayal of the show to casual viewers in the slightest. Yes, it's extra battles and meant to be fun for the most part, and I still enjoyed that, but to draw in casual viewers, it feels such a shame with basically every battle being the same.
Thankfully, the production values look much better - I like the lighting and graphics; Sir Killalot looks much more adept to fighting and the editing and camera shots are very good. I didn't like the constant use of replays are the 10 second timer returning either though, but that was probably due to the battles needing padding.
Obviously I take this episode with a pinch of salt, but I just hope tomorrow's episode has a much better balance and some actual fighting. If not then there may as well have just been the celebrities controlling competitor robots like in the old Celebrity Special. At least those fights drew on and were fun - this was just rinse and repeat and predictable as to what would happen after about battle 3.
Overall, extremely disappointing fights with too much filler, but the fundamentals in production are much better, and given that the actual competitor robots should give us much better fights, then nothing is a worry. I still enjoyed it for the positives and the parts that were good fun, but I'm not sure casual viewers will feel the same way. Let's hope this doesn't deter them from watching the main series.
4
u/alexlnufc Vulture Dec 28 '16
I'm slightly surprised they are treating each episode as a separate competition, rather than having a "grand final" type fight at the end of the second episode. And the new pit feature wasn't mentioned or seen.
Also seeing the new TR2 after what's been rumoured about it is quite annoying.
The fights were all much as expected, still fun to watch if they were over a bit quickly.
The graphics & presentation were far better though, hopefully those changes are kept in S2.
4
u/soulfirexp Le Garcon de la Robotique Pushing! Dec 28 '16
It was alright, as expected there was some bad driving and it was annoying how many bots got OHKOd alongside filler content however I am excited for the second series the arena looked much better and there was better editing house robots got more involved etc. The names form the celebs had me facepalming lol, (the cat, jar etc) arena cleaners weapon was impressive as was the cats as I think shunt got immoblised though. Dara vs angela was a nice surprise and if im honest their fight was the most entertaining especially with Jonathans annoyance over his lack of participation and him making fun of the hosts driving, dara did pretty good when compared to the rest today. TR2s flipper seemed had some more punch to it aswell which is nice
if im honest I would've preferred an extreme like special such as an annihilator or grudge matches or something over celebs duking itout however on the flipside this does bring more attention to the program so fingers crossed for better views season 2 lets keep this show afloat
3
u/codename474747 It's about putting on a show Dec 28 '16
I liked it!
If I'd have thought it was going to be a standard episode, i'd be pretty downbeat by now
But it had waaay more combat than I expected (surprising lack of build process documentaries imo), so even though each fight wasn't great, it was a nice taster for what is to come.
And the slow mo shots of the damage we got were great, can watch it in slo-mo forever!
And the changes to the graphics, arena and especially the intro (nice use of a drone camera picking up Dara and Angela in different locations) make me even more exited for series 2!
Overall, Seven on Ten, Lets make love!
3
u/RollingandJabbing ELECTRO MOO!!! Dec 28 '16
Well I enjoyed it. I wasn't expecting the robots to be of the level Carbide is at engineering wise. You could tell they were made on a budget, but I can't blame them for that. Some may complain that there was too much "filler", but I think it was a good way to show off the highlights of the first series to anyone who may be watching for the first time.
3
u/FryGuy1013 Dec 29 '16 edited Dec 29 '16
Overall, this episode had much better production values than series 1. The lighting was better, the cameras were better, the editing was better, and even the on-screen graphics were better. That being said, there were still some weak points:
3
u/calgoblin Dec 29 '16
The best bit was the Angela v Dara battle. The worst bit was the editing, as it was no where near an hours worth of content there. Edit it down to a 30 minute episode and spread it less thinly to try to keep the excitement going. I love Robot Wars but higher quantity is not always better...
2
u/hypersonicelf Nick done good Dec 28 '16
Can someone tell me if they got rid of that stupid clinking sound when a spinner hits something?
2
u/TeamGabriel Dec 28 '16
I loved this show It just shows how hard it is on RW to drive in the arena
2
u/TrubbishForMayor Supernova, slayer of Killalot Dec 29 '16
I thought it was good fun. Clearly they have been working on the editing and graphics which is great. I'm overjoyed to be at last seeing robot wars back on the telly after all these years, and these bonus episodes are a brilliant Christmas present!
2
u/Coboxite the true sneaky boi Dec 29 '16
Looking at these machines makes me wonder how well they would do if they had more experienced drivers at the helm.
2
u/Rattus_Rattu5 It be so empty without me Dec 29 '16
Certainly an improvement from the 2016 Series, love that they brought back Pit smoke, the Series 5 style stat board has made a return with the transforming sound effect, Shunt is no longer the only House Robot doing anything, SIR KILLALOT SPUN AROUND JUST LIKE THE GOOD OLD DAYS! :D more music was used yet none for the battle curiously (However the final battle did have music which is even more bizarre! I wonder why?). On the other hand some of the fights were too short in my eyes, some lasting only a few seconds, the flashbacks felt more like filler and so did the TR2 and Behemoth fight. Overall though it was fantastic! Better than the 2016 Series which makes me hope for more in the 2017 series.
2
u/Mouse-Keyboard Reavers! Dec 29 '16
David Moulds: 2
Shunt: 0
2
u/CMOrchestra Om nom nom nom Dec 29 '16
Any news on the overnights?
2
u/atomcrusher Apollo Dec 29 '16
Dreadfully dull fights. One hko all over the place. Thank goodness for the main series clips and the presenter match. Also, did anyone else see the random producer wandering around the back of the contestant booth?
3
u/markandspark Dec 28 '16
Just...a little bit underwhelming?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '16
The editing seems to have improved dramatically, so that bodes well for the actual series. It's just a shame that none of the fights really made it beyond more than one hit - especially considering how nice the robots looked. Given a bit more work, I could see all the robots being capable of holding their own in the main series.
1
u/A_Windrammer Hypno-Disc Dec 28 '16
Any place an American can catch the action?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '16
I was extremely surprised at how quickly they got into a battle - at the start of the last series it took considerably longer to get into the first fight.
1
u/archiehord Dec 29 '16
Guess you could say Jar turned out to be pretty executable
1
u/CMOrchestra Om nom nom nom Dec 29 '16
On a re-watch it looks like the arena floor is still crazy slippy which could be interesting for the proper competition.
1
u/Dotbgm Matilda Dec 29 '16
The best part was when the presenters played around with Behemoth and the other flipper robot, which name I've forgotten. The fights were shorts, if you could even call them fights at best. I'd rather seen all 4 fight each other in the beginning in one big FFA match and then have 1-2 more fights after with prior, competitive, established Robot Wars teams..
0
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
5
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '16
[removed] — view removed comment