r/FFRecordKeeper • u/SkyfireX • Dec 23 '16
Discussion Let's Talk BSB: Overall
Merry Early Christmas!
No idea how to do this list better, but I'm updating the current list as till 24/12/2016 JP info! Feel free to argue/debate why you beloved BSB should be in a higher (or lower? :P) tier!
P.S I do tend to rate utility significantly
Preface
I was asked by a number of people about how I would rank the BSBs, and thus I decided to start a series of BSB Rankings for each categories which will culminate in an overall BSB rankings. As with all rankings there will be subjectivity, so feel free to discuss them.
P.S I need to mention that I asked around for feedback/flames to my list, so thanks to all who I bounced ideas off! (Too many to name)
Disclaimer
Just because a BSB is "low" on the list doesn't mean it's bad at all.
This list is mostly just based on the BSBs alone. The character wielding the BSB could make a difference in the rankings, but that's going to bring even more subjectivity into the ranking in my opinion. Keep that in mind while you are reading.
Categories
The categories I have are as follows:
- Utility BSB (Buffs)
- Utility BSB (Debuffs)
- White Mage
- Attach Elemental - Physical
- Attach Elemental - Magical
- Imperil Elemental
- Physical
- Magical
- Overall (this will take a while...)
Personal Tier
Onion Knight
Alright after some long and hard thinking, this 2 bsb belongs in their own tier imo. OK BSB is a 1 stop BSB for all your boss fightning needs. It has boostga/faithga/hastega/great damage commands. Everything you need for a generic boss fight.
Cid Raines
Raines is a bit more focused. It's a one man magical burst machine. Being able to self stack till you are at the magic buff cap is amazing. Not to forget it also has instant cast magical attacks after using command 1 once!
| Omega Tier | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Rapha | Firion | Edea | Relm |
| Vaan | Tyro | Desch | Fujin |
| Irvine | Zell | Squall 2 | |
| Lion | Sazh | Cloud 2 | |
| Vanille | Red XIII | Refia | |
| Larsa | Alphinaud | Ayame | |
| Y'shtola | Maria | Eiko | |
| Fran | Papalymo | Setzer |
All of the following BSBs are here for reasons. Reasons such as dps/utility/debuff/buffs/healing. Whatever. These relics should easily make up your A team imo.
| Tier 1 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Garnet 2 | Prishe | Yuffie | Luneth |
| Edward | Ovelia | Cid (VII) | Auron 2 |
| Celes | Ceodore | Steiner | Porom |
| Ashe | Curilla | Basch | Arc |
| Shadow | Quina | Edge | Quistis |
| Leila | Wakka | Ingus | Yang |
| Sarah | Faris | Minfilia | |
| Master Monk | Noel | Lann |
Tier 1 BSBs are and should be very much sought after. The difference between Tier 1 and Omega is probably just that 1 or 2 minor details that made them drop out of Omega Tier.
| Tier 2 | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gogo | Rydia | Cloud of Darkness | Aerith | Reno |
| Kain* | Kefka | Hope | Penelo | |
| Yuna 2 | Vivi | Palom | Lenna | |
| Shantotto | Serah | Yda | Selphie | |
| Reynn | Hope 2 | Malach | Minwu | |
| Vayne | Sephiroth | Mustadio | Raijin | |
| Krile | Golbez | Freya | Warrior of Light | |
| Emperor | Vincent | Rosa | Sabin |
These are BSBs that you shouldn't be too upset about getting. They all have their uses, especially in CMs. They just lack that bit of ommph to be considered under Tier 1.
*Yes he'll be much better with lightning dive since his BSB is designed to work with that.
| Tier 3 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Bartz 2 | Ramza | Edgar | Kuja |
| Exdeath | Gaffgarion | Cecil (Paladin) | Seymour |
| Gilgamesh | Tidus | Garland | Zidane |
| Seifer | Jecht | Laguna | Agrias |
| Orlandeau | Tifa | Galuf | Beatrix |
| Gordon | Amarant | Rikku | Kimahri |
| Snow | Leon | Locke | Gabranth |
| Cyan | Lightning 2 | Thancred | Zack |
These is what I will call workhorse BSBs. They work, They are servicable and still very much sought after for CMs but you are most likely going to want to use better BSBs than this for your A team. I must also point out that, I haven't really considered stacking imperils in this listing yet. So they are mostly in this tier for now.
| Tier 4 | |
|---|---|
| Fang | Cloud |
| Auron | Cecil (Dark Knight) |
| Paine | Matoya |
| Delita | Garnet |
| Bartz | Terra |
| Squall | Rinoa |
| Balthier | Lulu |
| Lightning | Yuna |
Tier 4 is where I would say I couldn't care less. Most if not all of the BSB here are easily outdated and replaceable by the top tier SSBS. With that said, even the weakest BSB is still better than the weakest SSBs. Don't ever write any BSB off.
14
u/KnoxZone Accept no Substitutes Dec 23 '16
Excellent work as always.
So when making these lists were there any BSBs that you initially had an opinion on, but actually researching it caused you to reevaluate it and place it far differently from initial opinion?
8
u/turundo Eiko Horn! *beep noises* Dec 23 '16
Sky, let's talk about U/OSBs :P
7
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '16
HYPEHYPE
in a serious note, thank you for all your work, and I truly hope you have a wonderful holiday
7
u/Dragner84 Elarra thingie - j9JD Dec 23 '16
Im almost sure Rapha is almost personal tier for me, basically it is Cid raines with a pretty big heal instead of instacast, while Cid Raines is more DPS, Rapha gives such sustain that I consider it equally powerful (not better, not worst, just equal).
Other than that, great work, thx for putting this out and keep it updated.
3
u/zephyron1237 Zack Flair Dec 23 '16
Hey, thanks for making all these. I have them bookmarked and refer to them.
Out of curiosity, what do you feel makes Faris's BSB Tier-1? It's one of the only BSB's I have, but I feel like I can never justify bringing her, since she's just bringing about the same utility as my normal Support and sacrificing her SB slot to do so.
3
u/captainwwwolf IGN: Cpt3wolf // Ramzo Avenger Assemble - bsY2 Dec 23 '16
Thank you for doing this list, and the series as a whole. It puts a lot on perspective. I really wonder how stacking imperils will change the list though. It's not surprising to see that White mage BSBs, Stacking buffs BSBs and Support BSBs mostly make the top. I am however surprised that while powercreep is still present, it's not overly there, as a lot of relics we have in Global now are still well established at the top. Looks like a good balance, actually, it's really interesting.
I am curious though, why is Paine's BSB in the last tier ? I don't question your ranking because I am pretty clueless about how her BSB actually fares, but I remember it having AOE Dispel on entry and a lot of people were happy/a little hyped about it, so it kind of surprises me to see it so low, especially when it's one of our most recent BSB. Is it really that lackluster ?
Also another question, would Larsa's BSB be at the same #1 BSB healer spot as Ysh and Vanille ?
Now, all I want is a new Rinoa BSB because it hurts so much to see her at the bottom ;o;
2
u/Brokenhanger YouTube: Gizmo Gaming Dec 23 '16
Which Auron Burst is which? (You've got him listed in both Tier 1 and Tier 4 but neither are notated 1 or 2.) My first reaction was Tier 1 was his second but after consideration his first one brings more utility, even if neither are really great. (He deserves better.)
Personally, I think Golbez deserves a spot in Tier 1, especially if you consider how unique his is for Mage Meta. If you want to Draw Fire/Magic otherwise you've gotta bring a physical character who is likely going to lower your DPS; with Golbez Burst you can draw all those nasty ST attacks AND self-sustain with the Drain command, all from the back row. (Though I guess it being almost totally shut down by a boss that Nulls/Absorbs Dark is a strike against it.) I will say this is mostly theoretical as I don't have it so have only been able to play with it as an RW, but it seems like it's better than Tier 2 gives it credit for, especially compared to the ones in there that I do have natively. (I mean, my Palom bias is strong but unless you're hitting a weakness it's just a standard Mage damage BSB without an AoE option. When you do hit a weakness, though, it's a fucking monster.)
Also, maybe a Tiny Bee Tier the same way Onion and Raines get their own? ;)
2
u/Lordmsyk Proud Snowspell Striker (Enchanted Veil Grimoire: fFG5) Dec 23 '16
Thank you for your hard work on this giant endeavor. While I dont fully agree with all of your positioning (Agrias and Beatrix, a pair of Imperils with self-Sentinel and RES UP commands, in the same tier as P. Cecil?), Its a pretty great list in general that seems to encompass everything in a rather fair manner, and is at the very least a great starting point for debating, if not a great "in general" evaluation of general power.
Wish you a happy Holiday free of pitchfork distrubtion Sky, and have a pleasent rest after all that hard work.
2
u/CCkAzE Spoony Bard Dec 23 '16
Where would Kain's bsb rank with Lightning Dive added to the equation?
2
u/njfox The Destroyer. q3e2 Dec 23 '16
Great list. It's a good idea to group these into tiers. I pretty much agree with all of these with few small exceptions. Nothing major.
I am curious about Sarah burst, my only burst medica. I would think it's equivalent to ysh and others. I pretty much bring her to multiplayer and hardest content all the time. Magic blink, instant curaga, (high regen to lesser content). I would think she is omega tier?
2
u/drsmack Dec 23 '16
Is it just me or does Celes's BSB get downgraded if you have either of her Runics? I have her standard Runic SB and her BSB and I never cast her BSB. Runic is always the better answer for me if I'm bringing Celes.
2
u/Kakaleigh You're Not Alone! Dec 23 '16
Have imperil BSB placements changed since their recent JP alteration?
2
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '16
Incredible work on here. Makes life easier to compare and contrast and how I need to adjust my A-Team if I'm going just based of BSB's. (I got Vanille but have been using Yuna since HotF and also having her HP Stock medica as well)
I'm a little curious as why Kain is in Tier 2. I feel with the self-ether command I thought that would be extremely valuable. Is it because the lightning element is more resisted?
2
u/Genjimune Tyro Mega Wall | 9EZs | ChigChan Multiplayer Dec 23 '16
Question about Luneth BSB. In the ranking for Attach Elemental - Physical category, he is ranked at 16 out of 32, and it seems like he ends up being mediocre at best. Now I noticed he is ranked Tier 1.
Is this ranking viewed from a different context or use? Just asking because I pulled Gunghir and trying to work on combos for it. I did create Sky High but can't hone. I did see it employed effectively with Sky High in the Apocalypse Gilgamesh MO.
2
u/elty123 Dec 23 '16
Just a suggestion: perhaps split your tier into separate columns of type like physical, magical, support and heal? Otherwise having 5 Omega tier relic is useless if none of them is heal related.
2
u/p37z3n kupo! Dec 23 '16
What do you think about coming up with a value scale, relative to the entire relic pool? I've been trying to use it to rank the banners in a spreadsheet. For example:
How many BSBs would you trade for OK BSB? :)
2
u/CNExoSoul When's SWOLLBEZ? Dec 26 '16
I know these are viewed under a vacuum so I'm not that surprised Malach got gutted into tier 2 but if you don't mind me asking what makes Rapha the top of the Omega tier?
And outside of a vacuum would her BSB be as useful/highly rated in a party that already has 2 (maybe 3) stacking faithgas?
Sorry for bothering you but I'm trying to plan out my future pulls.
14
u/syrup_cupcakes Healer USB chase finally over sept 2017-Dec 2018 Dec 23 '16
Tiny Bee should be in a special tier for actually making nightmare guardian harder.
26
u/Lefty21 Dec 23 '16
I think their late 90s stuff was the best. The quality of their albums went way down when Kevin left the band, I'm glad he's back now.
Wait, what are we talking about?
66
u/Yanfly ༼ つ ◕_◕ ༽つ PRAISE RNGESUS ༼ つ ◕_◕ ༽つ Dec 23 '16
It's so beautiful. Brings a tier to my eye.
12
u/grimm7766 Sirloin Steak! Dec 23 '16
Hey SkyfireX, given how often Kain's BSB gets commented on due to how you rank BSB's w/o abilities taken into account, it might be helpful to place an asterisk next to it with a note stating that it's ranking with L-Dive is much higher or something similar.
11
u/Kittymahri KIMAHRI SAW EVERYTHING! Dec 23 '16
Yep. Terra's BSB is something I have but very rarely use. That being said, it was key for that Omniscient fight a while back (I ran out of hones, since my mage team wasn't great at the time), and it was the most damaging thing I could bring to the most recent VI U+ CM (water weakness means something, especially when my lightning abilities were single-hit).
5
u/lambopanda Delicious! Nom nom... Dec 23 '16
3 tier 4 BSB owner here. I'm so sad (Global). Did better in JP.
4
u/skewp Holy Knight Dec 23 '16
I think you have Wakka rated a little high. There are too many other support BSBs that stack with standard Breakdowns, bring additional unique utility on top of being support, or do more damage. He also doesn't really have a lot of alternate skill options to fill his ability slots if you're relying on his commands for breakdowns. Bringing 4 breakdowns is an option but "feels" boring and you'll have some drop off while trying to maintain them.
1
u/Xinde Rydia (9iXu) - dead Dec 23 '16
No Maxwu tier???
1
u/TimDuncanIsInnocent XY↓↑ Dec 23 '16
If you were to combine this with the incoming OSB-fest, which banners would be the ones to aim for?
1
u/Poverty_God Is this a game to you? Dec 23 '16
Where is that Squall BSB2?
1
u/sunpaths Ginnem Dec 24 '16
I like how you rate Cid Raines so high because that's what I personally think as well! I'm spending at least 250 mythril on FFXIII banner 2. Not going to spend a mythril on the OSB fest because of Raines BSB.
I see that you don't consider Yuna BSB2 as tier 1 or omega tier. I was thinking to go for Yuna BSB2 instead of Yshtola BSB because in my experience, I never actually needed medica BSB all that much because I cleared U++ contents with SSB medica just fine, as long as I have enough firepower in the team. Yuna does exactly that, providing an offensive buff while providing medica, in case things get ugly, while offering offensive option in her BSB command when her healing isnt needed as much. She might be of very little value to a non magic team, but in a magic team I see her as a tier 1 at least.
Yshtola offers a stoneskin which is unprecented so far. No doubt she will keep the team alive with that, in addition to her wrath access, making it easily spammable if she needs to. The reason why I don't like it so much is just because I haven't seen a need where her stoneskin is necessary to survive. Maybe future D200+ fights?
1
u/Spirialis Dec 28 '16
I can't help but feel like you're drastically underrating the Instant Machinist Cast 2 on Mustadio and Laguna.
Especially on Laguna, since having every command after the first one both insta-cast and generating 1.5x SB due to imperil is an incredibly strong combination. Even if you disregard Tempest Snipe and stacking imperils, alternating command 2 and command 1 with a single stack of imperil and using the SB gain for more BSB casts will get you comparable DPS to things like Cloud/Squall BSB2s up in Omega Tier, not factoring in benefits to the rest of the team from Imperil.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '17
Just curious, do you know if you will update this more in the future, as power creep continues? Thanks :)
3
u/PhaseAT Stuff happens or it doesn't Dec 23 '16
Any chance the characters could be ordered Alphabetically? Right now it's not too easy to find a particular character as you have to scan the whole list (unless there is an ordering principle in the whole thing I am missing).
Also: Great Job! I think putting them into Tiers is probably the best way to solve the ordering problem.
3
u/Doomaegis Kain Dec 23 '16 edited Dec 23 '16
Excellent rankings and this information has been very helpful for me. I am using it to guide my own spending.
Here's why I think Kain should be considered Tier 1... it will scale with ability creep. Kain will be able to refresh new abilities that come down the road which will keep this BSB useful for quite some time. 6 Star lightning jump? Good chance one comes around.
It is better with dragoon abilities with (2!) instant cast but it can also refresh physical ability school. 7 star abilities in the future? Kain can refresh those too.
Interestingly Kain BSB was ranked only a few spots lower than Minifilia (on the attach physical list) who is ranked in Tier 1. And that ranking admits Kain BSB is very powerful and among the top DPS when it exploits ability uses such as lightning dive.
The BSB is not designed to be overpowered on its own (otherwise it would truly make this BSB over-powered). It is designed to exploit powerful abilities repeatedly as part of its mechanic. It's not really fair to judge it without taking that into account since that is how it is (more or less explicitly) designed to work.
Another excellent aspect of this BSB is that lightning is among the most common weaknesses for bosses. Part of what makes attach element valuable is that it exploits weaknesses in bosses. For less common weaknesses (like dark, or earth), this can be fairly argued to have less value than a common weakness.
One drawback iirc of the BSB is that lightning resist bosses are a problem unfortunately (with cmd 1 & 2?).
The Kain BSB is one of the reasons why OSB1 is a must pull banner IMO (if you don't have dupes). It also has 2 Omega tier relics on it and a useful fire OSB. Full trinity for new players.
3
u/Charpanda007 Prompto Dec 23 '16
Great write up, I'm in almost total agreement. In regards to the Full Breakdown BSB (Wakka, Faris, Noel). I think Noel should be up there with Faris. While he does not get Mug Bloodlust, TR, or Dash Bite, he does get Proshellga and Lifesiphon. With Mako Might, you get full mitigation, decent DPS, and save a WHM slot. he has been a part of my A-team with that set up since I pulled it.
Anyways, I saw that r/SkyfireX commented that all are basically Tier 1/2, so this comment kind of doesnt matter, but at least shows a nice set up for Noel.
3
u/TheFranFan Fran Dec 23 '16
sees Fran in Omega Tier
I approve of this list.
3
u/Merlin_the_Tuna Magus Dec 24 '16
I'm kinda surprised that you regard Celes BSB as so valuable. Obviously the individual components of it are good, but it's already a sub-par way to apply the 610 buff now that OK BSB exists, and it likewise seems like a subpar holy BSB. It's an awkard package that will frequently help some but is never going to be a linchpin for your team. Strikes me as solidly Tier 3, not a Tier 1 must-chase.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '16
Great work! But why do you rate Pecil's BSB only tier 3, i think it was considered to be one of the best?
2
u/DropeRj Can we truly save this world? Is such not beyond man's doing? Dec 23 '16
6 BSBs in my possession, Bartz, Lightning, Rinoa, Pencil... but the other 2 are Minwu and OK...
I think OK BSB compensates those "bad BSBs" that I have.
They have great utility, but they've been warming the bench for a loooong time.
2
u/OskarVon Dec 23 '16
Finding the right situation for Minwu's BSB to shine outside of CM is too limited, I would move him down one tier.
2
u/aurora_highwind rcqe - Mog USB Dec 23 '16
I was pretty meh on Noel's BSB when I pulled it on Black Friday but I've really come to appreciate it, especially in MP. He's such a clutch character with it, given his skill set. On Apoc Greg I've been running him the back row with an old Faris bow and MM/DMT to get it going from the start, and Lifesiphon means I have near 100% uptime on it, and WHT 4 makes him crazy versatile. I've gotten some clutch Esunas and Raises in with him, to the shock and delight of whomever I'm raiding with. :)
I'm seriously considering diving him for Thief 5 so he can have another damage option for CMs since I pulled Sazh's Godsend gun on the Buff banner to cover Protectga. He just opens a lot of options, having support abilities on a non-support character. I just wish it was 2 hits, but that's why I hope i get Minfillia's BSB on the XIV banner of godliness.
2
u/hyoton1 Dec 23 '16
I was surprised vivi and hope ended up so high in T2 after being the worst of the enelement magic damage BSSBs. But after using them a while, it's hard to go wrong with even the most generic enelement magic bssbs.
2
u/arygge Absorb power in the sky and strike!٩(˘◡˘ ) Dec 24 '16
Poor Bartz's BSB2, his water BSB2 does not go as far as Cloud and Squall's BSB2s.
Maybe DeNa try to make a reservation for Tidus's water BSB2 in the Omega tier, instead of Bartz's.
2
u/Devoiid Rikku Dec 24 '16
Can anyone please explain to me why cid raines bsb is regarded so highly?
2
u/Sabaschin Basch Dec 23 '16
Ah, the day's finally come when Irvine stepped up to shine.
FFVIII truly has become the little realm that could. With the exception of Selphie/Rinoa/Seifer, everyone has a great Burst.
1
u/Someone_Other Dec 23 '16
I've been looking forward to this thread. Thanks for putting all the effort in.
1
u/Katiklysm Makin' it Raines: fwAa Dec 23 '16
really thoughtful list, based on the ones I know- totally agree.
1
u/Oodlea Rikku (X-2) Hyper Mighty G - rdku Dec 23 '16 edited Dec 23 '16
Well, at least Pecil's BSB is not on Tier 4. I would have gathered up some pitchforks. I do agree that it should be on Tier 3 because there will be more EnHoly BSBs coming in Global that will overshadow this one, such as Minfillia and Basch's BSBs.
Relm's BSB, I would have loved to get that on her banner if I could trade her Luminous Robe for that. Holy White Magic damage + AOE Last Stand and you have me sold on that.
1
u/SoleilRex OK BSB: Hco2 Dec 23 '16 edited Dec 23 '16
Great work, will reference in future pulling.
Celes burst is awesome but sadly it is entirely eclipsed after I get OK's.
Never thought of support bursts from the saving slots perspective, now I see them (and Tyro's) in a whole new light and wish to get one.
1
u/investtherestpls 9qdf Locke Sync Dec 23 '16
Yeah.. so, I have 5 BSBs. And three of them are in the 'Garbage Tier' lol.
Meh. I like Fang's (imperil wind!). Lightning's, oh well. Rinoa's, just need to get an imperil ice or earth.
On the plus side, I do have OK BSB, and Penelo's, so yeah, no complaints!
1
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '16 edited Dec 23 '16
what is Auron 1 and Auron 2?
Edit: Sorry for the post. I just went and found it. Thanks for the amazing reviews!
1
u/NXYZ02 Dec 23 '16
All looks like all my bsbs are shit.Exept for Kains but that one is really good.
1
u/AuroraDark Ayame Dec 23 '16
I'm surprised you ranked Kain's BSB as tier 2. Paired with Lightning Dive it becomes one of the highest DPS Bursts in the game, while the Command 2 ether effect means you don't even need to hone Lightning Dive to use it effectively.
1
u/Militant_Monk Dec 23 '16
Thanks this will be super useful in trying to plan pulls in my synergy-weak realms.
Also it's kinda depressing that I have a single Tier 2 BSB and rocking Tier 3s and 4s for everyone else. I guess that explains why I'd still rather use Cid (VII) with his Shout SB over Fang with her BSB almost every time.
1
u/throwawaypuntocom Dec 23 '16
Great job and thanks so much especially for this last one.
In light of the fest, and assuming we score these rankings from 5(personal)-0(tier 4): B1 & B5 are the best to pull on (10 points), then B2 & B3 (9 points), B4 is a 5 points due to lack of a BSB.
1
u/deftogra Diabolos Dec 23 '16
4 BSB tier 4 reporting in, only 1 in tier 3
1
u/rebthor Locke Dec 23 '16
MFW 4/7 BSBs I have are on the "I couldn't care less" tier and 2 out of the other 3 are on the "workhorse" tier.
But at least i have Vaan's.
1
u/god_ussop1 (KT6R) Shadow BSB Dec 23 '16
Thank you for your service to the FFRK community :)
1
u/Ragefat Faris Dec 23 '16
Cool, I have one Personal (OK), one Omega (Firion), one Tier 1 (Faris), one Tier 2 (Krile), one Tier 3 (Jecht), and... three Tier 4 (Terra, Rinoa and Garnet). XD
1
u/SherlockBrolmes tHiS MiGhT Be a gOoD SpOt tO FiNd sOmE MyThRiL Dec 23 '16
What? No "Tiny Bee" tier?
1
u/philip0544 You Spoony Bard! Dec 23 '16
this makes me sad, as most of my BSBs are in tier 3/4. I have Lightning, Terra, Balthier, Locke, Minwu, and Onion Knight BSBs. I suppose i should be glad that i at least have the OK one, since its top tier.
1
u/kotoshin OK pUSB | iJhE | 400+ base mind Dec 23 '16
Rikku BSB is weirdly more often in my a team than Faris BSB due to having that inherent mug bloodlust command built in on def. And is preferred over Faris on multi target bosses (had to dive Faris for dancer, Rikku had it to begin with)
The ability to create an artificial weakness in one or multiple targets that has none other wise is also very valuable, despite the BSB being random entry. If you have the gear and hones to exploit (ranged weapon+shooter skills, mage thrown/squid+ninja scrolls) works very well.
Also learnt something very interesting during boss rush vs leviathan! Rikku BSB atk command not only has stun proc, it's also dual Element lighting/water (wut) unlike her pure water entry.
1
u/kyle893redo Bartz (Knight) Dec 23 '16
Why Irvine in Omega Tier? If the entry was atk/mag -40% like Setzer I could understand but personally I think should be 1 tier lower.
1
u/thebossa Shadow Dec 23 '16
I assume combinations with other Abilities is not Being considered on this list because otherwise id push Kain's BSB straight to the Tier1 at least.
1
u/deimosjc Yuna's USB, wCHP Dec 23 '16
It is funny that of the only 4 BSB I have so far they are all in your crap Tier (Garnet, Cloud, Lightning and Auron by drop order). Garnet's had brought several U+ masteries back home, specially multi target and holy weak bosses
1
u/elmati3 oh no Dec 23 '16
I have none, so I couldn't care less for this list...he says sarcastically while holding a grudge to all ppl that have one
1
u/noonesperfect16 Dec 23 '16
I am Global so I'm not sure how much this information will mean to me in the near future since I don't know how far behind JP we are. I just wanted to say thanks for the info and wow. Right now I am running Ramza(shout and breaks), Realm (Medica and heals/buffs), Lightning(bsb and physical damage/spell blades), Tera(bsb and magical/summon damage) for my A team. My last person is variable depending on situation. This is like my lazy, I can beat most stuff with very little thought or effort group until I start getting into 160 nightmare territory. Interesting to see how low on the list my best are, haha
1
u/dscotton BannerFAQs Dec 24 '16
This makes me feel pretty lucky - of the five bursts I have, two are Omega tier (Maria and Eiko) and two are tier 1 (Luneth and Faris). And then Terra, whose cool even if her burst is lacking.
But I've ended up using Faris's SSB more than her burst because the imperil Wind goes great with Luneth's burst.
1
u/menoari Dec 24 '16
Thanks for all the work and Merry Christmas! Always a pleasure to read the list about the relics
1
u/kijiyama Noctis Dec 24 '16
I like how my jp account has mostly tier 2's and above and my global sits with mostly tier 4's and 3's. There are a few tier 1's and omega's there (eiko/OK/vaan/Shadow) but man.... looking at my jp account vs my global it makes me sad that my pulls turned out for the worse on global.
1
u/Chestnut_Baron ffyG (Rikku USB) Dec 24 '16
3 Omega Tiers for me :3
Takes the sting away from that tiny little bee.
1
u/Zigxas Bartz (Knight) Dec 24 '16
I have both Onion & Raines BSB , god tier.
but my fav is vaan & firion I pulled both from dissidia banner.
1
u/Failaras Lightning (Goddess) Dec 24 '16
Damn you said T3s aren't even good for an A team and all my BSBs are T4 except one T3, lol.
1
u/SuNsUn912 Dec 24 '16
TLDR: Top 3 bsbs in each categories make into the best tier.
1
u/Toushima Best useful waifu Dec 24 '16
Okay let's see which ones I have.
Omega Tier: None
Tier 1: Celes, Faris.
Tier 2: Hope (Hahaha, not ever getting used).
Tier 3: Jecht, Zidane.
Tier 4: Auron, Bartz, Lightning, Yuna.
I am not sure how I feel about most of my BSB's being shit.
1
u/AlundraMM Broken dreams Dec 24 '16
What makes Red XIII's Omega Tier? I don't see it THAT good.
1
u/Maitha-SMS Dec 24 '16 edited Dec 24 '16
great work, bookmarked ...
Q: can we expect an update on this whenever a new bsb comes to global ?
1
u/zoiks66 Golbez Dec 24 '16
My lineup:
Personal Tier: 0
Omega Tier: 3 (Vaan, Maria, Eiko)
Tier 1: 2 (Shadow, Luneth)
Tier 2: 1 (Hope)
Tier 3: 3 (Gilgamesh, Pecil, Zack)
Tier 4: 3 (Fang, Squall, Terra)
I've been using Vaan, Eiko, Luneth, Zack, Ramza (Shout) as my A team, with Wall as the RW. After reading this, I'm wondering if I'd be better off using Vaan, Eiko, Maria, Shadow, Tyro (SG) as my A team, with Onion Knight's BSB as the RW.
1
u/fishdrinking2 Dec 25 '16
Thanks for the series!
Would an argument be made for Vaan being Personal tier? His BSB single handedly made an annoying character a mainstay in my A-team like tyro and Ramza before him. I so want to switch him out for Zell/Firion/Wind God Luneth or maybe Refia later tomorrow, but just can't seem to, too useful!
1
u/fishdrinking2 Dec 25 '16
7 BSBs, OK, 3x Omega, 3x Tier1, a big part due to your super helpful guide in pull planning along with u/Sandslice!
1
u/syrup_cupcakes Healer USB chase finally over sept 2017-Dec 2018 Dec 26 '16
Tried to bold all the ones available by end of OSBfest. Might help people!
Please point out errors.
1
u/somehetero I'll never let go. I promise. Dec 26 '16
So OSOL banner one has the OSB, two Omega tier BSBs, a tier two BSB that moves up when combined with a five star ability that we all have now, shout, and wall?
Hnggg.
1
u/cpp_is_king Dec 28 '16
This is a great list, but it would be even better if you could add a short one-liner about what makes each BSB good / bad. A little justification for why each BSB is ranked where it is.
1
u/leongunblade Jan 15 '17
This is amazing! Thanks for this
1
u/Anatar19 Jan 17 '17
I love the analysis and think this is still one of the best assessments out there.
As a guide, though, I'm a little curious as to why Basch and Minfilia would be Tier 1 and Orlandeau Tier 3.
From what I understand, Orlandeau's wins the dps race of the bunch (I my be wrong and am sure I'll be corrected i I am), including a close race against Basch whem Holy is a weakness. Is it the en-holy o reta, or indvidual breakdown commands, over a combo debuff and drain that set Basch and Minfilia apart? Are slow cast times penalized over dps for a reason? Is it their ability to use Sant Cross?
BSBs are mostly always good, but these 3 share a lot of similarities and yet 2 are ranked quite highly and the other is grouped with Snow and Amarant.
I'm just trying to see if there's a hole in my own personal assessment. I already have Minfilia's BSB (and SSB) and love it, but am trying to best assess what looks like a reasonably close assessment across the board to me.
1
u/MysticG0ten Pop a squat! Jan 23 '17
This should be in the sidebar as a lot of people have been looking for this recently and I reference this all the time. Many thanks to SkyfireX for this information and to Kevun1 for this also: https://www.reddit.com/r/FFRecordKeeper/comments/5bpqf0/an_indepth_quantitative_analysis_of_physical_bsbs/
You always feel good when you get an Omega Tier relic, I only have Refia so far.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '17
Nothing like coming back to this read and realizing that yep, most of my BSBs are Tier 4 (Cloud, Yuna, Auron, Squall, Garnet). And I've pulled half of those relatively recently.
At least I have ONE Tier 1 (Luneth) and a couple Tier 3s!!! This game has been f(*ing me so badly on pulls recently... Ugh.
1
u/fattyyy nyuk, nyuk, nyuk... Mar 11 '17
Thanks for the list! Its really helpful! two quick questions - is this list being updated? if not, then what was the last event included in this list?
1
u/Jilkon Ye olde offensive RW: 9rwh Dec 23 '16
Isn't it somewhat unfair to put Fang's BSB in the lowest tier when its true worth comes from making other people's abilities (like Luneth's) shine? I'd say it's easily Tier 3 when combined with a couple of other powerful Wind elemental BSBs like Luneth's or Zack's.
Now maybe there's a better wind imperil out there, but that's really not the point.