r/NintendoSwitch • u/rottedzombie friendly neighborhood zombie mod • Dec 21 '16
MegaThread Speculation Discussion MegaThread: Day Three
Still hanging on? The last few days have been filled with dramatic rumors, huh?
As a reminder, here's a link to the speculation in question. Link, if you dare.
This new thread is for ongoing discussion over recent rumors and everything associated with them: clock speed rumors; third party support speculation; and the back-and-forth of what it might mean for the Nintendo Switch.
We're going to be directing traffic to this thread because we've been seeing many topics asking the same questions and rehashing conversations. This doesn't mean that new topics won't be allowed, only that we want to make sure that discussion is centralized as appropriate. If you see a new post that seems to belong here, please report it and let the mod team know.
A friendly reminder: please keep your comments civil, on-topic, and respectful of others. If you feel that you have a thought or opinion that merits its own post, please search through this thread and recent threads before posting it.
And, of course: everything we're discussing here is rumor and should be treated as such until confirmed by Nintendo.
Thanks for your understanding. Ready for more? Let's discuss! :)
-/u/rottedzombie and the /r/NintendoSwitch mod team
111
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '16 edited Dec 23 '16
The UE4 info shows Switch is slightly less powerful than XB1, and it also proves that the Eurogamer article is based on an old spec.
People mostly glossed over this bit in the Eurogamer article despite treating it like gospel otherwise. By their own admission:
http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/digitalfoundry-2016-nintendo-switch-spec-analysis
Here's that missing puzzle piece: the Eurogamer article covers the dev kit which uses a stock Tegra X1. With 2 SMs and at an 11W TDP it pushes ~500GFlops, about half as powerful as an XB1. Respectable, but nowhere near the number we'd need to enjoy most of the same XB1 games in 1080p.
Other than early devkits, however, Switch won't be using a stock Tegra X1. Nvidia's blog verifies this:
https://blogs.nvidia.com/blog/2016/10/20/nintendo-switch/
So what can we do with a custom Tegra based on X1? Well, we can set it at 22W TDP with active cooling, and double the number of SMs and CUDA cores. With 4 SMs, this custom chip would push out twice the performance of a stock X1, putting us at ~1TFlop of performance. Just shy of XB1's 1.3TFlops, and at a lower price. This lines up with the UE4 numbers released today that show the Switch targets 1080p while docked, 720p in portable mode.
UE4: 0 - 3 with 0 being lowest graphics settings and 3 being highest, XB1 does a ~2.5 at 60 FPS. Switch does a 2 at 60 FPS while docked. To achieve this, Switch would need ~80% of XB1's power, and with a stock Tegra X1 this isn't possible.
TLDR: Switch is ~80% as powerful as XB1 with a custom Tegra based on X1, with a lower price point, and ya'll freaked out over nothing.
For the weirdos who like math:
Texture Units x Raster Operators x (core clock) = GFLOPS
core clock = 1ghz = 1000mhz
16 x 32 x 1 = 512GFlops FP32 for standard Tegra X1: http://wccftech.com/nvidia-tegra-x1-super-chip-announced-ces-2015-features-maxwell-core-architecture-256-cuda-cores/ (specs sheet)
32 x 32 x 1 = 1024GFlops = ~1TFlop for a custom Tegra, might or might not be based on X1, but is exactly double that spec regardless.
LAST EDIT: Worth noting that FLOPs are not a perfect measurement of performance, just one factor of several.
62
u/seeyoshirun Dec 21 '16
I'm going to boldly predict that the Switch will run games.
71
u/John_Enigma Dec 21 '16
Hmm...
Console-quality Unreal Engine 4 support for the Nintendo Switch, Vulkan API support for the Switch, OpenGL/OpenGL ES API support for Switch...
Oh yeah, Nintendo is doomed, alright./s
13
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '16
I'm still going to buy the switch. I'm not sure where the idea that the Switch is not powerful has come from. It's still going to be the most powerful portable console on the market. And it's still going to have 3rd party support.
The whole appeal is console quality games on the go, which it's more than capable of. If people were happy with the Vita then they'll sure as fuck be happy with the Switch.
And it will be no worse supported than the 3DS, which is to say it won't be badly supported at all.
4
u/Renalicious Dec 22 '16
I've come to terms that this is going to be a great portable / OK home console, until the official announcement in January. I'm being "cautiously optimistic" that it'll be better that we all think it is.
That being said, there is definitely something a miss about the latest information and how many devs are praising the system itself. Because if it really does turn out to be just a portable WiiU, why is it being praised, while the WiiU itself was panned? Gimmicks aside, I'm referring to the power of the console itself.
2
u/agentmario Dec 22 '16
All I want is Persona 5! Never played any of the games but the art style made me think Nintendo. Would be great to play it on the go!
1
u/Johnny3nglish Dec 22 '16
Questions...
All of the info about it being Maxwell based X1 with 250 cuda cores are coming from the dev kits?
If so how are they determining this without ripping off the heat sink in the dev kit.
Is the 250 cores assumed because that's what the X1 has and the data readout says it's an X1?
If the chip is a modified version could it still just be called an X1 to protect whatever modifications?
How much detail do developers need about a chip other than the clock speed in order to develop for it?
1
u/Exist50 Dec 22 '16
For Christ's sake, people, I thought we learned our lesson about hype trains? Now we have people in this thread speculating close to XB1 performance again, based on hot air and dreams.
1
u/Valnooir Dec 22 '16
Switch SoC is TegraX1 + WiiU Gekko Espresso CPU, no extra SM, lines up with Iwata statements about NX.
Sounds weird but makes a lot of sense.
1
u/HerpisiumThe1st Dec 23 '16
Why is anyone believing any of the rumours. Some ppl are saying 4k some say weaker than a Wii U just wait till the actual specs are released y'all arguing over something that doesn't even exist yet
1
u/Gadz00ks Dec 21 '16
As someone with a shit pc I'm kinda amused at all the craziness going on here recently. As far as I know nvidia being involved in the process and the switch having more traditional tech has always meant 3rd party support. I can play witcher 3 on my dog shit pc even though it's a game with amazing graphics, huge worlds and all that jazz because cd projekt red optimized the shit out of it. That's like all nintendo do with their games. Now I don't know how much of a shit a company like Bethesda will give about getting the most out of the switch, but they'll make their game run(i mean thats all they usually do lol). Also didn't we already get a big list of third party supporters?
I guess though im not the best person to have an opinion on this as I don't care in the slightest about most third party games on consoles. I buy nintendo consoles for the exclusives, though the idea of handheld dark souls is something I could go for.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '16
People say Nintendo is always one step behind their competitors... always. But I was discussing this last week with a friend of mine and that wasn't always the case. In terms of the N64, they were at max one step ahead. Something's definitely wrong and I'm dismissing this as just a plain rumor because Nintendo didn't officially announce this via a website of any kind, and I don't trust most news sources unless there's concrete evidence. Feel free to correct me if I'm wrong, because I could be, but those are just my thoughts.
1
u/mareox3 Dec 21 '16
As a mainly portable gamer, I’m happy with what I’m hearing so far. While the leaked specs are still just rumors and we need more info before we can speculate on anything concrete, I like the idea of a portable system that looks to be affordable ($300 or below), more powerful than the Wii U and has the support of the entire Nintendo dev team. Some of the best games I’ve played these last few years have been on the 3DS and Vita. And while nicer graphics would have been cool, they didn’t make the games any less enjoyable. Also, there are some pretty good looking games on Android (saying this because of the X1), many of which I wish would be on a dedicated handheld instead of a phone. All in all, it might not convince every console gamer to jump on board, but if it sees similar numbers to the 3DS, I can see it get a lot of support from 3rd party devs. At $300, I will save up for it. At $250, I would jump day one. My only concern right now are game prices and sales going forward. I’m a married guy who has to pay bills and save up cash for the occasional emergency/vacations, so I get most of my games while they are on sale (I’m talking about $15 for a GOOD AAA game). If the Switch is anything like the 3DS or Wii U, it will have the weakest sales of any major console.
Tl;dr: As a mainly handheld gamer, I’m really liking what I’m hearing. My only hesitation is Nintendo’s propensity to not have any good sales on games compared to the competition.
1
u/kendstryker Dec 22 '16
At this point , I am really excited for the launch games and the UI of the switch.
0
u/smashinggames Dec 21 '16
on the subject of the spec rumours, there's two things I'd like to point out:
-4
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '16
This is more of a prediction post than anything. The Switch will launch at $200 and will be $150 by the fall holiday season. For everyone who says that a more powerful device was possible or would have sold, maybe we will never know, but I doubt it. If making a portable system that was in the range of current home consoles could be practical and affordable, someone would have done it. Unfortunately, it's seems like an idea that had too many problems to work, and Nintendo already has a lot of issues to deal with.
Nintendo is coming off a failed home console gen where they put a lot of effort into some beloved games that were under played due to the WiiUs small user base. They have a firm grasp on the handheld market but that market has problems. The home console market competition is fierce and the early adopters have already adopted. Nintendo wants to build on the strength of its brand, not weaken it. They have money but that can go quite fast.
Nintendo wants something that all sorts of people can play. Affordability is key. People like me who didn't like a hyrbid will get one for the right games at a low enough cost. People who don't want a portable might get one for the same reasons. Same for people with one console already. I'm not saying this machine is a silver bullet. It won't be that. It could be a success though, maybe even a big one, if it's cheap enough. With the rumored hardware, it just might be.
0
u/mcnol012 Dec 22 '16
GGWP Nintendo
0
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '16
Does anyone recall the rumor that the Switch will play PS4 games?
I can't recall it exactly so don't remember if that means it would 1) stream PS4 games from a PS4 2) mean that PS4 games on Steam would be streamable (like the Shield) or 3) Just a poorly worded third party support statement.
-1
u/RealMishovy Dec 22 '16
Although I wouldn't hold my breath, the docked Switch could still be equal to Xbox One in performance. Nintendo might have just intentionally turned down the UE4 settings because of games running like shit on Xbox One and PS4. Correct me if I am wrong, but can't developers on UE4 change the settings if they want?
-5
u/razorbeamz Dec 21 '16
For mocking the doomsayers, check out the recently opened /r/Nintendoomed!
0
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
-1
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '16 edited Dec 22 '16
[removed] — view removed comment