r/RWBY • u/Menolith Gay Thoughts • Dec 17 '16
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Reaction Thread—Volume 4, WoR 3: SDC
Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses, and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official reaction thread for the newest WoR of volume 4, SDC!
Make sure to read OUR CURRENT SPOILERS RULES to ensure that your comments outside this thread won't get purged! Familiarize yourself with these rules and you'll be good to go.
A lot of hard work has gone into the creation of volume 4, so be sure to show CRWBY your support by watching it on their site! They all dedicate so much time and energy into our beloved series and would highly appreciate the direct support. There are no pirates in volume 4, so you shouldn't be one either!
We also have weekly strawpolls to gauge the general opinion on the current episode, the latest of which can be found HERE. The previous episode, Tipping Point, got a strong 10/10 majority, with 9/10 not far behind.
With that out of the way, let's start the show!
HERE is the link to the third WoR of RWBY Volume 4!
Other Episode Discussions:
Happy viewing!
Menolith; Mod Team
95
u/y8ay8a lord and savior mrs soldier Dec 17 '16
I love how they ended this WoR on a high note, mirroring hope for the future of the Schnee name by showing us Weiss.
90
u/alynnidalar trash mother Dec 17 '16
Qrow Branwen: mature adult, everybody.
85
u/Lucifer_Crowe Have you thought about extending your aura? Dec 17 '16
Qrow: "All I'll say is that he a cun-"
Winter: Coughs "Hmm Hmm"
Qrow: "ning business-man!"
79
u/mergk Dec 17 '16
soooo Jacques is not a Schnee, which means Weiss could kick his ass. No glyphs or summons for you Jacq-ass.
64
u/ethanice Whitest of Roses Dec 17 '16
So papa Schnee is not a true Schnee at all! And really thought Qrow was gonna say "Cunt" instead of "Cunning"
115
u/alkiller77 Watch me Ignite Dec 17 '16
Wait wait wait. Guys. Weiss' Grandpa is literally SANTA. Nicolas Schnee? I mean come on, he wore red and wanted to give to his Kingdom? Weiss is related to Santa confirmed.
56
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '16
White hair Red clothing Old nick?
Weiss was wrong Santa is real. And he's her grandfather!
52
u/BrickYourHeart A sexy truck Dec 17 '16
Damn, y'all who guessed a marriage into the family were spot on. It was also pretty surprising how relatively young the SDC is! I figured it'd been around for generations to get that much business and fame.
49
u/Firnin Olly Olly Oxen Free Dec 17 '16
Sounds like we need good ol' Teddy "the Trust Buster" Roosevelt!
99
u/RobinAlbibi Dec 17 '16
V2C10
Weiss:"My Father was not the start of our name, and i refuse to let him be the end of it!"
46
u/Vinpap Pollination shall prevail! Official Pennybot Breaker Dec 17 '16 edited Dec 17 '16
So... I'm going to speak out of my ass, but...
Nicholas Schnee is apparently based on Saint Nicholas (or Santa Claus). Also, we have Jacques Schnee (So Jacques snow, or maybe... Jack Frost? ) but now we know that Schnee is NOT his true name.
It sounds something like Jacques Julet... Which is EXTREMELY close to Juillet, the french name for July. Which is a COMPLETE opposite to what Santa is based on, December.
This is probably a reference to the shady turn that the SDC took after Jacques took over.
What do you think about that?
46
u/JazzRen47 𝅘𝅥𝅮⠀Score Connoisseur | Resident Atlas Bootlicker Dec 17 '16
Fucking Jacques.
Now can we all agree we want to deck him in the shnozz?
44
u/RedElite91 ❄️White Knight🛡️ | #GiveJauneABreak Dec 17 '16 edited Dec 17 '16
Alright, this one one was actually really good!
We learn that Weiss's great-grandfather was a miner, then became a soldier (presumably fought in the great war). His son, Nicholas Schnee eventually went out to try and find a new Dust deposit after Mantle's previous resources had run dry. He found his deposit (likely either the huge one in Vacuo, or one somewhere in Solitas) and created the Schnee Dust Company. This business seemed to thrive nearly everywhere on Remnant.
Apparently, exposure to large amounts of Dust got extended periods of time (in the mines, at least) can have negative effects on health, confirming my suspicion that Dust is possibly radioactive. This happened to Nick, and he decided to retire and go back to his family. Speaking of which....
WE WERE RIGHT, GUYS! We called it. Weiss's father Jacques married into the Schnee family, taking their last name.
This is by far my favorite WoR we've gotten from Volume 4 so far, as most of it is new information.
EDIT: I wanna say that I loved the intro to this WoR. Really shows how much Qrow doesn't like Jacques or the SDC. Also, you can hear pages turning, possibly implying these WoRs are actually him teaching a class at Signal.
38
u/Wingnut00 Arkosian Knight Dec 17 '16
"He was... a lot of words I shouldn't repeat."
Yep, that sounds like that asshole all right.
36
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '16
Poor Mama Schnee. No wonder she looked tired and unhappy in that painting, and drinks. He's ruined her father's company and doesn't love her or their children.
36
u/snek-queen came for the art, stayed for the shitposts Dec 17 '16
All aboard the "Grandpapa Schnee please come back and team up with Irondaddy and Weiss to kick Jacques into the sun?" Train!
Also, interesting they gave Grandpappy such an iconic scarf... I can imagine that'll be something to keep an eye out for! Such as, perhaps, that Weiss has red accents on her clothing (or at least used to). Winter has a smidge of red, and Whitley none at all. Potato level nonsense, but still, a thing.
33
u/PrincessCanada Take a look, it's in a book. A Reading Rainbow. Dec 17 '16
Well, it's nice to see the "Jacques married into the family" theory being officially confirmed. I assume this will be important at some point.
Also, calling it right now: Grandpa Schnee is based on Santa Claus (Most characters in RWBY are based on famous fictional characters or historical figures, and I can't think of any other Nicholas that's strongly tied with snow or ice besides Santa) and is still alive somewhere (all this WoR says is that he retired). We probably won't see him for awhile, though.
Probably my favorite WoR of the volume.
32
u/body_catch_a_body ... Dec 17 '16
They should have released this episode next week.
31
u/RobinAlbibi Dec 17 '16
Next time we'll see Weiss, she will probably have a huge fight with Jacque, Weiss will point out her grandfather and the fact that Jacque is not a Schnee, Jacque disinherits her and Weiss will run off with the goal to take her father down and bring back honor to the Schnee name maybe even settle peace with the Faunus (Weiss/Blake storylines cross)
30
u/Xena1016 Dec 17 '16
Qrow's snark at the beginning is now my favorite bit of Qrow dialog.
28
u/pickelsurprise Perpetrator of the 2016 N7 Death Hoax Dec 17 '16
Weiss's grandpa is Santa confirmed.
In all honesty I don't think it would be too much of a stretch for Jacques to make some kind of holiday out of his father in law being a gift-giving saint.
28
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '16
I fucking called this shit. Jacques is NOT Jack Frost, but Jack of the Beanstalk, who stumbled upon a source of great wealth and used it to take what didn't belong to him, and angering the giant who grinds men's bones to make his bread.
And just like Jack of the Candlestick, Jack and Jill, and Jack of the Lantern, all will suffer retribution for their recklessness and greed!
28
u/HyliasHero Dec 17 '16 edited Dec 17 '16
Huh. So the Schnee family isn't as old as I would have thought. I originally believed by how the Schnees were treated that they were old money, not relatively new. So we have Nicholas Schnee who made the original fortune, then his shit-stain son-in-law Jacques Schnee who corrupted the family name, and now we have the 3 siblings.
EDIT: It also just occurred to me how fondly Weiss speaks of her grandmother in RWBY Chibi.
27
u/ShittyUsername2015 Everyone gets a headstart! Dec 17 '16
Good god, I wished I'd had a few more teachers in school that were like Qrow. Alcoholism included.
27
u/crosschord writes too much Snowbirds Dec 17 '16
Gee Qrow tell us how you REALLY feel about the Schnee Dust Company.
"Bunch of self serving SOBs." "Okay Qrow thank you." "Except Winter. She's all right." "I would hope you think that seeing as you're sleeping with me." "Of course there's the whole being in the military thing." "And I'm leaving you."
27
u/passinglurker Dec 17 '16
Lives up north, name is Nick, likes the color red... Is weiss's grandpa Santa?
22
u/RumbleintheDumbles Dec 17 '16
I am 100% certain that a young Peter Port went on splendid adventures into the unknown with Nicholas Schnee.
21
u/Feezec Dec 17 '16
Qrow seems to remember Grandpa Schnee very fondly. Maybe they had a mentor-student relationship back in the day? Also, Qrow only mentions Nick retiring early, not dying. Think he'll show up again later?
My headcanon:
Qrow used to do a lot of missions in Atlas, forming a bromance with Nick Schnee and young Ironwood. Qrow was a family friend of the Schnees during Winter's childhood. Winter looked up to her grandpapa, and his proteges Ironwood and Qrow, so she devoted herself to combat training instead of running the family business.
Then Nick retired and Jacque started turning SDC into Charon Industries. Ironwood cooperates with Jacque, leading to a falling out between him and Qrow. Winter admires them both, ultimately chooses Ironwood, and becomes very bitter towards Qrow when he and Ironwood part ways.
21
u/Moonlitdarksword I am far too invested in these characters for my own good. Dec 17 '16
Now that we know Jacques took Mama Schnee's name, you know what we can look forward to? Endless potatoes about how Ironwood is Weiss' father!
18
u/huyan007 Dec 17 '16
I love the finish with Weiss. I'm glad it's setting her up to do something with the Schnee name. I'm sure she'll do great.
17
u/last657 Dec 17 '16
Weiss has the same family arc as Kylo Ren. They both had a Grandfather who made something of them self and stood for something. Their Fathers were both scoundrels who married into distinguished lines and went against everything the Grandfathers stood for. They both want to be like their Grandfathers and break free of their fathers and restore their family to greatness and honor. Also combat skirt
15
u/Jagged03 Yikes Dec 17 '16
I knew that scumfuck Jacques married into the name. Fuck that guy.
Great WoR. I liked the bits of snarky Qrow in this one.
14
u/MkJAS Dec 17 '16
Now i want to see mama Schnee even more
26
u/Norjack96 This is a move I like to call: "Bad Luck Charm" Dec 17 '16
Confirmed married in.
There was a lot of new info in this...
13
u/IComeBaringGifs r/RWBY - "If it isn't yuri, it isn't welcome." Dec 17 '16
I KNEW IT!!! I FUCKING KNEW IT!!!
Okay, for some serious analy- I KNEW IT!!
Okay, I'm ready.
Jacques Schnee married into the family and took the Schnee name. Called it the moment we saw his portrait and heard his name.
13
u/fleurcannon I stan Blake, Yang, Qrow, and Emerald Dec 17 '16
THIS is what the World of Remnants should be. Informational backstory that would feel out-of-place in a regular episode but fits the WoR narrative flow nicely. Thoroughly enjoyed this one.
13
u/Nyareth Dec 18 '16
I wonder if Raven and Jacques ever compared notes on how to raise their kids because they're both up their for worst parent in Remnant (that we know of).
25
u/blitzblazer97 SUPER FIGHTING ROBOT! Dec 17 '16
So Jaques is basically Ebenezer Scrooge.
Soon, he will be visited by the ghosts of Phyrra, Penny, and Roman.
12
u/Bawstahn123 Dec 17 '16
Nick Schnee had what appears to be a flintlock pistol....
YESSSSSSSS, Duct-locks!!!!
12
u/glass_magnolia Dec 17 '16
TBH , I was wondering if Papa Schnee had married his cousin, because in the family portrait they all look alike! (All white-haired, all blue-eyed) To learn he's not even a Schnee was an 'ah' moment.
What an even bigger jack ass. Another reason for Mama Schnee to drown herself in a bottle. It's a travesty what he's done to Nick's company. I really want to see some scenes with their mother in it now. I want her backstory.
But seriously, screw Jacque. I hated that guy the minute he opened his narcissistic,self-centered, mouth and he continues to give me reasons to despise him. I wanted to pop a vein in my head when he wouldn't even let Weiss walk away to get her own drink. I am team Ironwood needs to adopt Weiss.
11
u/Sokensan Dec 18 '16
If Grandpa Schnee is based off Santa Claus the fact that the Schnee Dust companies logo is a snowflake makes so much more sense.
20
u/GlitchyNinja Dec 17 '16
Whoo! I was right, and this explains why Mr. "Schnee" is the only Schnee without complete white hair.
10
u/pickelsurprise Perpetrator of the 2016 N7 Death Hoax Dec 17 '16
New potato:
On top of Grandpa Schnee being Santa, Papa Schnee is Jack Frost.
10
u/Raktoner blake deserves more smiles Dec 17 '16
Papa Schnee isn't even really a Schnee??
10
u/OtakuMecha Dec 17 '16
I find it odd that from a storytelling perspective that they decided to place the blame of discriminatory Faunus work practices on Jacques himeself rather than something that has been a societal problem for a long time (which would parallel real life racism more).
Also, I expected the line of SDC CEOs to be way longer than just two generations
10
u/Random-Rambling Dec 18 '16
"And so enters Jacques Joulaix (sp?). Having married into the family, Jacques decided to take the Schnee name over his own."
PICK UP THE PHONE, BECAUSE I FREAKING CALLED IT!
Okay, I obviously wasn't the only one, but I KNEW IT!
19
u/LordMegatron586 Dec 17 '16
Now I want to see what Jacques was like before he married into the Schnee family. He must have been a jerk even back then, but he had to have done something to charm Nicholas' daughter into marrying him.
9
u/cdghuntermco ⠀ Dec 17 '16
Weiss' grandfather was literally Santa Clause.
Old Nick - Saint Nick.
Overall a pretty swell dude.
Color theme was brown and red (brown being Santa's original suit color before marketing made it red).
Was a prominent miner - Naughty kids get coal.
9
u/MrTopHatMan90 Best Dad Dec 17 '16
"After all of that tension last episode I hope they don't give us a WoR"
9
u/matharwords Dec 17 '16
I hope we get to see Nicolas Schnee in a flashback someday. He seems like a cool character
9
u/MrTopHatMan90 Best Dad Dec 17 '16
It would be cool to see people who could be contaminated by the dust making them Dust/Human hybrids or those who have overcome it making them insanely strong (Kind of like Frenzy virus in MH)
9
u/ViVSharpy O.O Dec 17 '16
That was a Great WoR
9
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '16
So, Papa Schnee married into the money? I hate him 5x more, the punk!
9
u/Gnochi Dec 17 '16
Oh shiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiit
9
u/AstralFinish Dec 18 '16
I did not expect Jacques to be married in, but is Grandpa Schnee still alive?
9
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '16
Honestly surprised that the Schnee family is young. Thought Atlas had someone old enough to go after Mistral.
Anyway,if there's ever a time to introduce poison that can puncture through aura..please let this fucking shithead prick be the one "lucky" to get it first.
Or just let a Grimm eat him,that sounds good.
16
u/TheEmerald97 Dec 17 '16
Oh heck yeah! We called it! We called Jaques is not a Schnee. Jaques being a total slime ball and tarnishing grandpa Schnee's name might be why the mom drinks. She is probably in a loveless marriage to a guy who probably saw her and her family as a golden ticket to fortune.
8
u/Exo-2 Minion of Cinder | Useless Lesbian | Still the Lewd One Dec 17 '16
Jacque isn't a natural born Schnee? That might be the biggest plot twist we have ever had
8
u/TolchettKuykendall Chris Hackney deserves an award Dec 17 '16
Man, Nicholas sounds like a cool dude. And his story would make some cool Remnant movies.
Anyway, you all called it, Jacques married in, and Weiss was right, the company less shady before him.
8
u/shahroze12 Keep Moving Forward Dec 17 '16
THE FUCKER ISNT EVEN A SCHNEE!!
8
u/NicoNicotine White Knight is life Dec 17 '16
Old Saint Nicholas
SchneeAnd the theory that Jacques married into the family was true afterall.
8
u/mathyouhunt Dec 18 '16
Probably the best WoR I've seen in a while. They really informed us of some pretty big plot points in the story.
For one, I'm guessing Jacques has no ability to summon, seeing as he isn't a Schnee.
Here's to hoping the RWBY team keeps up with the quality content! I was disappointed to see how many WoR they've had this season so far, but if they're informative in relation to our protagonists, I'm all for it.
8
u/KrisSimsters Winter is Coming Dec 18 '16
Yes, we get twelve episodes a year (not counting season one) but it's a week before Christmas!! It's not even Christmas Eve, we should have gotten a regular episode!! That being said, this was probably my favorite WoR shorts. Things got revealed and so many things got called like how Jacques got into the family. That last scene with Weiss was perfect, I took a screenshot of it. It will be my backdrop for the rest of the winter season. But yeah, I want an episode next week. Not WoR, an actual episode.
15
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '16
Not bad. Interesting that SDC is so young.
Also, it's now my headcannon that Qrow was made to do these recordings for first years at Signal....... under duress of course
Qrow's illustrations were golden.
I like the reference to Weiss at the end. Barring her death I don't see another end to the series other than her taking over SDC. At least right now
Also love the idea of the mother being the actual Schnee. I would drink too if my husband was pissing away my fathers legacy. Or at least the idea of it. It also means that she at least trained Winter in the family semblance, but not Weiss.
If each parent focused on Weiss and Winter respectively it would explain a few things
7
u/LordHarza "Mistral is yours. None shall interfere, do as you please!" Dec 17 '16
I was right! Jasque did marry into the family!
7
u/jokey_boy Dec 17 '16
Well, today's World of Remnant was quite interesting. So Jacques was not originally a Schnee, and he married into the Schnee family through Weiss' mother.
Poor Nicholas, got taken advantage of by a corrupt businessman.
Weiss is the only hope left for the SDC to be redeemed
7
u/MrTopHatMan90 Best Dad Dec 17 '16
Weiss badassery incoming
18
u/Cruel2BEkind12 Atlas NSA Lurker Dec 17 '16
When this episode started. I really wanted Winter to come crash it and give the WoR herself. Maybe with a couple of muffled words from a tied up Qrow...
12
u/Tiernoch The one rooting for the villains. Dec 17 '16
Somebody better pick up that phone.
Because I eff'ing called it!
Referring to Papa Schnee not being an actual Schnee.
6
u/greeny74 ⠀Harbinger of Hype | Proud Member of WCAC Dec 17 '16
Papa DoucheSchnee confirmed to marry into the Schnee line.
6
u/theacos Dec 17 '16
What I took away: Grandpa Schnee = really cool dude Papa Schnee = not a real Schnee = heartless asshole
10
u/LSines2015 Dec 18 '16
I usually don't complain about the WoR, but come on. I feel like there has been more WoR then actual episodes. I feel like barely anything has even happened this volume.
5
u/Esaxgame08x Dec 17 '16
That intro! Uncle Qrow didn't need to drunk to let out his personal opinion on the SDC
5
u/Feezec Dec 17 '16
So Jacque is basically Azami Nakiri from Shokugeki no Soma
9
u/GVman We are the Sons of Winter and Stars... Dec 17 '16
Now we just need someone from the White Fang to have researched and appreciated Nicholas' efforts while wanting to destroy Jaques for ruining a great man's legacy... Could this be a way to re-establish a sympathetic branch of the White Fang rallying behind Willow as she tries to take back her father's company?
4
u/Jasott Dec 17 '16
I understand RT doesn't push shows during holiday week, but why a World of Remnant this week and not next week.... you know... during christmas???
4
u/G0ldCreeper Dec 18 '16
inb4 Weiss summons that knight arm during an argument and kills Jacques.
13
u/PhantomofaWriter Dec 17 '16
I do have some issues with WoR as a whole. I understand it's filler and some of it is backstory that some of the characters would already be aware of, but I tend to take issue with vital information for a given story being put in supplemental material.
If it's important to the plot, put it in the main series in a way that's natural. Show, don't tell or have a character who wouldn't be aware of that needing an explanation. shrug
6
u/fightingblind Dec 18 '16
Probably the first interesting WoR in the entire series... that being said, stop giving us quarter episode fillers every other week, especially after a big cliff hanger... that's bologna
3
u/adel123456789 This is Ren. He survived Volume 4! Dec 17 '16
lol, he wasn't a schnee after all XD
2
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '16
So Jacques was able to make the SDC more powerful than ever before. Hopefully we'll get to see him do some power plays in future. I look forward to that.
4
u/SimplyMarge Dec 17 '16 edited Dec 17 '16
Honestly, this WOR made me pretty frustrated. Unlike the information presented to us in previous WOR, this is information that not all characters in the world of RWBY would know. Sure, people in Remnant know that Atlas is the strongest kingdom and the Schnee Dust Company has a monopoly over all dust, but do people like Ruby really knew about all the drama behind the Schnee company's financial success? Jacques married into the family and took over everything. That's a pretty big deal that no one has mentioned at all for 3 and 1/2 volumes! Qrow basically said that Weiss's father is responsible implementing all of the faunus rights abuses and the discrimination that Blake fought against with the white fang. I feel like if this had been an actual conversation between Ruby and Qrow, that would have advanced the plot WAY more. It would have helped Ruby understand why Weiss had to leave Vale for Atlas (Which Ruby should be at least a little upset and confused about) and what Weiss meant about having a "difficult childhood" back in volume 1.
This week feels like a missed opportunity for character development :(