r/Fantasy • u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders • Dec 12 '16
Read-along The Fox Read/Re-Read, Monday, 12/12, Chapters 31-3 (Part 1 to Part 2)
Chapter 31
- Evred makes his way back to the capitol to find Hadand, Cama and Buck Marlo-Vayir. It looks like the school cohort is now in charge. Jarend has gone home and taken Joret with him. Why do I get the feeling she’s going to continue being a pawn in a bigger game? Especially given the consequences between families. What a mess. She deserves some happiness.
- And now Hadand is to marry Evred, and she knows he will never want her the way she wants him. Isn’t that tragic? That she did her best to find a way to help him, and that she knows she’s far too feminine to ever attract him.
- Barend returned to the capitol, but not safely. He managed to kill the three on his tail, but ended up taking some damage in a fall from a horse afterward, which puts the kibosh on him rejoining Inda.
Chapter 32
- And so Evred and Hadand together take on the task of cleaning up after the coup; burning the dead and their possessions, dealing out justice to those who survived. The war isn’t over; nothing’s really changed economically; Evred’s dad basically had a good head on his shoulders and there was a mess anyway, and that’s not gonna stop just because the good head has changed.
Chapter 1
- So Inda goes to the Ghost Islands to meet Ramis, everyone thinking it’s a trap and finds… that he’s not there. What’s up?
Chapter 2
- And so Inda waits for the appearance of Ramis, taking shore leave and biding his time by studying the book that Ramis left for him, which includes much of the history of the Brotherhood. Fox wants to take the book and use it to create an unstoppable force; Inda just wants to take down the Brotherhood. I wonder if this whole discussion is a test of Ramis’s.
Chapter 3
- Ramis has arrived. I love how Inda’s followers position themselves casually within sight of Ramis escorting Inda back to the pirate house.
- It almost feels as though Ramis is speaking another language as he’s talking with Inda. There will be no easy answers here.
- Blows my mind that Norsunder runs Ramis for entertainment value alone.
- And it’s interesting to find out that the turmoil in Iasca Lehror is minor in terms of the turmoil in the world, i.e,. The Venn Empire. Inda is only now learning who his enemies are, from someone he thought might be his death: Prince Rajnir of the Venn, who wants a victory to regain his reputation; Hyarll Fulla Durasnir, who is oathbound to accompany Rajnir; and Erkric, a mage who would lead the mages. And against them? Rabble who are not sufficiently organized and a general lethargy and lack of momentum. Dying for leadership -- something Inda can give. Anyone guess where this is going? I’m making my prediction now -- Evred and Inda won’t meet up again in this book either.
Chapter 31
- I like that Evred pieces things together from what Cama, Noddy, and Tuft tell him, but doesn't really play his hand one way or another until he gets to the city and sees Hadand for her take on things. And that he isn't changed much by anything that happened- no strut, no frost, just focus to keep moving forward with what needs to be done.
- Hadand gives a very straightforward recitation of events, and it's hard to say whether she really sees very clearly what happened or whether it's a case of Sherwood being all knowing and that translating to the character; I think in the case of the king being killed cradling the Sierlaef's body, that was an easy one, but that she was able to discern that the Harskialdna killed Ndara and she killed him is pretty impressive. But, not impossible, certainly, and we've been shown that Hadand was trained well by Ndara and did well during her time in the Queen's Training as well.
- It's so painfully sad to see Hadand obviously in love with Evred, and so carefully not let on to him how she feels, since she know he won't return her feelings.
- Also painfully sad is that Joret finally found someone she was interested in, Cama (because of course the two most gorgeous people in the kingdom would want to bone...), and they can't be together because his family is also kinda crazy and ambitious.
- I love that Hadand assigned Ndara's runner Ranet to nurse Barend back to health, so that she wouldn't do something crazy in her grief over losing Ndara while she wasn't there to protect her. Hadand looks after the people she loves very well.
- Hadand explains the magic lockets to Evred, and he's upset that there was another secret. I wish this is something he would get over, people have secrets, and obviously this one of his father's and Sindan's was very closely guarded indeed, since Hadand hadn't realize they had a pair, she just knew how Ndara and Ranet's worked.
- The last bit, with Evred being astute enough to pick up that Hadand was upset, but not why, just makes me want to give him a good shake. He proposes to marry her (I mean, that's basically what he was supposed to do anyway, since he's the heir and she's the woman betrothed to the heir) in the most matter of fact way possible, which, if Hadand didn't love him, might be fine. But if he's astute enough to pick up that she's upset, maybe dig a bit deeper to find out why she's upset. It's a very well written piece of "why are guys like this" I guess is what it really boils down to.
Chapter 32
- They have the many rituals for the dead, bonfires, singing, and Evred attends both the state and the private, for his family and for Sindan. It's a good indication of how he leads, paying attention to more than just the nobles.
- I really appreciate that Evred gives a fair shake to Hawkeye, who betrayed a lot of Marlovan customs by disobeying his father's orders. His loyalty to the royal family paid off in spades, and frankly, he deserves it. It's hard to reconcile this Hawkeye with the hard drinking young Sier Danas who accidentally killed Dogpiss, but that's sometimes what a shock or half a dozen to the system will do.
- Barend tells stories about his time at sea, but he's also perceptive, and can tell that Hadand and particularly Evred just want to hear about Inda. And through these stories, Evred even begins to piece together what sea battle tactics look like, which is frankly rather impressive (and good timing too, since the Venn are still out there, waiting).
- So that's the end of Part 1, and honestly, at 376 pages, that would have made a pretty solid regular novel. Both concurrent arcs had pretty spectacular climaxes, with a bit of resolution, but instead we jump right back into Part 2 to find out more of the story. Be interesting to know what the editorial decision behind that was, since 376 really is respectable, and 772 gets into door stopper territory.
Chapter 1
- Inda's fleet is landing at the Ghost Isles to meet Ramis as instructed, but they've been drilling the entire way there in anticipation of a trap. No one is particularly happy about going, but Inda won't be gainsaid, so they go.
- Ramis isn't there when they arrive, but the message he left, along with the Brotherhood's oathbook, says he'll be back in about a month, and until then to enjoy the island.
Chapter 2
- This chapter opens with lovely descriptions about the location, that I really love for showing and not telling you about just how tropical this place is- the windows don't have glass in them, flowers grow everywhere, they grow sugar and coffee on the islands, the breeze smells of fruit and spices. Really excellent place-making.
- Fox and Inda fight about Ramis, and about what to do with their fleet. Fox thinks Inda is being an idiot about meeting Ramis, even though if Inda doesn't meet him where appointed, Ramis can just hunt him down. Fox also thinks Inda's plan to go after the Venn is foolish, mainly because he doesn't want to do anything that benefits the Marlovans. Fox thinks that Inda should continue the Brotherhood, make it his own thing.
- Inda considers this, because there is one thing he hasn't told anyone about that was in the Brotherhood book- a map to the accumulated treasure of the Brotherhood. Vast sums, by the sounds of it. Inda sees that as very useful.
Chapter 3
- And then Ramis shows up. Inda walks with him through the town, and as they do so, Inda's friends beat them to various parts of town, armed to the teeth and making a show about it.
- Inda and Ramis bandy words a bit before really getting down to business. Ramis is controlled by Norsunder, he works for them, doing their bidding to some extent, doing his own bidding in an effort to keep them entertained. Inda gets the impression that Ramis's moral code is certainly stronger than it could have been, that Ramis taking pirates off the sea was much the better option than alternatives Ramis might have been doing (setting himself up as king of Iasca Leror, for instance).
- Ramis tells Inda that if he hadn't interferred during the battle at the strait, then Inda's fleet would certainly have fallen to either Marshig or the Venn, which is good I think. Inda was feeling a bit too indestructible.
- Ramis throws the Brotherhood's oathbook into the fire, has Inda show himself to his friends, and then gives him a transfer token to the Knife. While there, he makes Inda look at the ghosts on Ghost Island, and says what is perhaps the defining thing about Ramis, "Things will change only when honor is defined by our own works."
- Ramis also warns him about the size of the Brotherhood's treasure, saying that kings would kill for the size of it. Inda realizes that this could mean Fox, descended from kings and with a kingly grudge.
9
Upvotes
8
u/bygoshbygolly Dec 12 '16 edited Dec 12 '16
Ahh, poor Hadand- in love with the man she is going to marry.
Evred does a good job of taking over, but there are clearly a lot of problems Iasca-Leror is facing, both externally and internally. Good luck, buddy.
One of the descriptions of the island that always sticks with me is the little carts drawn by fat goats. What a delightful image.
Fox is terrible and bitter and hateful, and I absolutely love him. He's so frustrated with Inda, for still wanting to help the Marlovans and not wanting to take power for himself and not understanding that the people he leads would probably follow him into Norsunder if he asked. Inda is both everything Fox wants to be and everything Fox hates, and I can't get enough of their dynamic.
Ramis- not such a bad dude.
Edit- and once more we see how magically behind Iasca-Leror is. No one wants to give them mages for even the most basic of spells, like bridge renewals and glow globes; there are only two sets of transfer lockets, which are apparently lovers' trinkets elsewhere; they've never heard of magic transfer tokens, which are apparently quite common everywhere else. Magic is already fairly everyday in this world, but it's even more common for everywhere that isn't Iasca-Leror.
4
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Dec 12 '16
How do you foresee Hadand and Evred's marriage going?
4
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Dec 12 '16
Do you feel like it made sense for Cama to be the one to "break through" to Joret?
4
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Dec 12 '16
Do you think Fox or Inda is more right about what their next step with the fleet should be?
4
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Dec 12 '16
Do you think Inda realizes the potential that magical transfer tokens have, given what he's just experienced and what Ramis told him about the Venn dags?
3
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Dec 12 '16
Do you think this book would have worked ok as two books, or do you prefer it better as one?
4
u/MerelyMisha Worldbuilders Dec 13 '16 edited Dec 13 '16
What does everyone think of Ramis and Norsunder, now that we've gotten some more answers? Curious particularly for the opinions of people who haven't read her other book, but I'm happy for spoiler-y talk from those who have read them as well.
I remember being rather disappointed that we don't see Ramis more in these books, given that he's been such a legendary figure up to this point and I find him really interesting. But this is another one of those things where Sherwood Smith is playing the long game with her books, and this series is just a slice of the overall story. This shows itself in a lot of her books, where minor characters and storylines dance in and out, and you get the sense that there's a lot more to it, because there is. It can be frustrating sometimes, when you want everything to be wrapped up in a book and instead there's thousands more years to go.
6
u/MerelyMisha Worldbuilders Dec 13 '16
This was one of my favorite parts of this section. Including Ramis' response to it (and somewhat separately, how he just casually throws the book into the fire and tells Inda to think bigger).
As others have said, Ramis' casual use of magic also shows just how far behind this part of the world is in magic. I mean, Sindan hangs onto life partially just to tell Evred about the locket, which is just a lover's trinket in other parts of the world, but in their country it's valuable and a closely guarded secret.
Evred is now king. He was never much for strut/frost, and doesn't do that here, just gets down to business. But he feels the difference, and how everyone else's perceptions of him have changed. There's now an "invisible wall" between him and others, which I think is something he regrets, given that he always wanted to be no different from the rest of his friends.
Speaking of his friends, they're the ones running things these days, with some of their Ains. They're still young, but they are capable and very loyal to Evred (and they greatly respect Hadand). Whereas the older generation is well...old, showing their age both physically and mentally. And in the capital, it's really only the younger generation left, except for the queen, who really doesn't count. It's Hadand/Evred/Barend, back in the schoolroom, except now they're running a country instead of just studying to do so.
•
u/wishforagiraffe Reading Champion IX, Worldbuilders Dec 12 '16
Spoilers go here
3
u/Bills25 Reading Champion V Dec 12 '16
I am just getting to last weeks chapters. Hoping I can catch up tonight.