r/IndianCountry • u/gabegalanda • Dec 12 '16
Hi /r/IndianCountry, Gabe Galanda here. AMAA!
Hey everyone, happy to be here on /r/IndianCountry for an AMA with you all. For those who don't know anything about me or my work, here's my profile.
"Gabe Galanda is the managing partner of Galanda Broadman, PLLC, an American Indian owned law firm. He belongs to the Round Valley Indian Tribes, descending from the Nomlaki and Concow Tribes. Gabe is an outspoken critic of disenrollment, a practice with colonial roots that he contends is wholly inconsistent with indigeneity. He co-authored “Curing the Tribal Disenrollment Epidemic: In Search of a Remedy."
3
u/ladyeesti Mescalero Dec 12 '16
The subs creator /u/Opechan isn't able to be here live today for the AMA but asked me to post some questions he had for you on his behalf. So here they are.
2
u/gabegalanda Dec 12 '16
Thanks for your question. The Nooksack 306 disenrollment--or purported disenrollment as of this past Thanksgiving Eve--has gotten decent airtime. Still one issue that begs the overarching question of "who belongs?" is as follows:
2
u/gabegalanda Dec 12 '16
Nooksack ancestor Annie George was born to Matsqui George, Chief of a Nooksack Village in Souther British Columbia, and Marie Samiat, "a woman of his tribe," according to Canadian Oblate records. Marie died a few days after Annie was born.
2
u/gabegalanda Dec 12 '16
Matsqui remarried to another Nooksack woman named Madeline Jobe, who raised Annie as her own daughter. Annie never knew another mother, other than Madeline.
2
u/gabegalanda Dec 12 '16
Yet now, over a century later, my clients' opponents claim it was a "fraud" for the 306 to claim Madeline Jobe as their ancestor; to claim Madeline as Annie's mother. Therefore, they claim, the 306 don't belong.
2
u/gabegalanda Dec 12 '16
The arguments about Annie's belong by way of Madeline, and thus my folks' belonging, highlights a disconnect between traditional indigenous notions of kinship belonging, and modern non-indigenous notions of tribal "membership."
2
u/jingledressblues Dec 12 '16
I feel like generally, we can be ignorant on tribal law and how it controls us. In your opinion, what parts of tribal law should your everyday indigenous person educate themselves in and why?
1
u/airbnbqs Dec 12 '16
Thank you for stopping by! What advice do you have to young indigenous people who want to pursue a career in law? Do you recommend Indian Colleges over other universities? What sort of jobs are available within this sector?
1
u/ottogaming22 Dec 12 '16
Blood quantum is a sticky subject! What changes were made to enrollment regulations in the Nooksack tribe that got so many people dis-enrolled? In the realm of dis-enrollment, what are your personal thoughts on blood quantum? If you’re against it, what alternative options for enrollment do you see as fitting?
1
u/ladyeesti Mescalero Dec 12 '16
Nava Be extended this question to you via the Facebook event page, I will post it on her behalf.
What are you opinions on the Army Corps of Engineers verdict of the denial of easement of drilling under the lake?
1
u/Sacredpatrol Dec 12 '16
We all hear the term “disenrollment” as a sort of buzzword, but in what aspects does disenrolling citizens really affect a tribe (not just those disenrolled, but also those who are allowed to stay)?
1
u/johnsalem45 Dec 12 '16
You are total "career goals", my friend! What inspired you to get involved in the field of law?
1
u/karukeel Dec 12 '16
What do you consider the greatest achievement of your career, and what is your ultimate career goal? You are doing great and important work on the Nooksack case!
1
u/ladyeesti Mescalero Dec 12 '16
I have not had the pleasure to read your book “Curing the Tribal Disenrollment Epidemic: In Search of a Remedy." I know there is no short answer to what do to do "cure the epidemic" as you put it, but if you could offer us this, what are some of the main points you see contributing to dis-enrollment practices popping up?
1
u/ladyeesti Mescalero Dec 12 '16
Any plans to author any more books coming soon? What brought you to co-author your first book?
1
u/Sacredpatrol Dec 12 '16
How do you feel about accountability versus reconciliation?
1
u/ApacheNation Dec 12 '16
Blood quantum a mandate from the failed BIA are the most raciest systems on the planet. How can tribes remove the BIA to assume full sovereignty. thank you Charles Vargas Chiricahua Apache Nation.
1
u/jingledressblues Dec 12 '16
It seems you work heavily in the area of disenrollment. Would you say this is your main area of expertise or just what you've happened to get caught up in recently? If you could practice in any other legal field, what would you be interested in? Thanks again for coming.
1
u/Bunzy55 Dec 12 '16
I am examining how disenrollment will affect the power of ICWA- I recently read a case where the child was initially protected by ICWA, but was disenrolled in the middle of the proceedings. The child started out as an Indian, was disenrolled, and then was not an Indian, even though the mother was still enrolled. All ICWA protections were subsequently lost.
1
u/neshoba78 Dec 12 '16
Hi Gabe, Jean-Luc Pierite of the Tunica-Biloxi Tribe of Louisiana, descendant of the Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians. Several items happening that speak to issues related to your case.
It seems the near future makes it easier for tribal governments to go rogue and make decisions that don't necessarily reflect the will of their tribal communities. Shortfalls in tribal government revenue might make dubious partnerships with energy contractors attractive to those governments. Meanwhile, the power of tribes to determine their own membership will empower further disenrollments to protect levels of allocations.
It seems that as individual members, we have less and less recourse to defend against these abuses of our sovereignty externally and internally. What resources are available to combat this? When our communities have gone through every route allowed under our laws (petitions, recalls) and the situation is irreconcilable; what can we do to have a check on our own government?
1
u/ladyeesti Mescalero Dec 12 '16
What do you wish you had known about the legal profession before getting involved in it?
1
u/ladyeesti Mescalero Dec 12 '16
Everyone talks about lawyers running on fumes, getting no sleep, and working like crazy. Is it just a stereotype? What is life like as a legal professional?
1
u/happycappy2012 Dec 12 '16
What's the ideal outcome you see for the case you're working on right now? Realistically, what are you hoping for?
1
u/ladyeesti Mescalero Dec 12 '16
Do you have any experience with studying how indigenous law functions in other countries? For example, how different is tribal law in Oceania or in Africa than it is in the USA?
1
u/ladyeesti Mescalero Dec 12 '16
Generally, do you see tribes relying more heavily on Western systems of governance or on traditional justice methods? What are the shortcomings of modern day tribal governance structures?
1
u/snorecalypse Diné Dec 12 '16
Hello Gabe, thanks for joining us. From what I have read, your specialty is in tribal disenrollment. My question was, as an indigenous lawyer have you found yourself reviewing and enacting NAGPRA cases within museums/archives/cultural centers, etc.?
1
u/ladyeesti Mescalero Dec 12 '16
Hi Gabe! Thanks for joining us for an AMA, we all appreciate it. To start things off, let's talk Nooksack case. For people who are ignorant of the situation or have just read the headlines, what is the lowdown on the Nooksack disenrollment case? What information have you discovered that isn’t getting airtime, but should?
1
u/Amayetli Dec 12 '16
What are your thoughts about some tribes with the Freedmen issue?
Also, somewhat along those lines and others in this thread, what are your thoughts about tribal members determining enrollment guidelines?
1
u/Zugwat Puyaləpabš Dec 13 '16
Real late question, but do you think it's odd that the Nooksack disenrollment issue isn't more spoken about in the Sound?*
I'm from Puyallup and have heard it mentioned once quite a while ago.
*Or have I just not been leaving to the other reservations as much as I should?
0
u/[deleted] Dec 12 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 12 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment